And... I honestly have no idea how everyone in the comments are still attributing Johnny Depp to singing this song when the artist (Nine Inch Nails) is clearly credited in both the title and description. How can you click on this video with the title right there and still think Johnny Depp had anything to do with it...?
Well, what can you say, this song. Fuck. Some songs are for dancing, some are for singing along, this is for sitting in a cold dark room, on the verge of suicide, too exhausted to even move, your thoughts crawling along with the monotone strum of the guitar.
Thank god this video doesnt have that background static in it that all the other ones do. Like, i know its part of the song and all but its frigging annoying..
actually I'm pretty sure Johnny plays guitar....which would make him a musician plus, there are a few pics of him rocking some concerts for charities or something with other actors/musicians/artists. When you sign up for acting, you may as well enroll yourself in music and dance as well. The entertainment biz is a 3 in 1 package pretty much today. Not everyone functions under these, but the majority have more than one/two skills.
I hurt myself today To see if I still feel I focus on the pain The only thing that's real The needle tears a hole The old familiar sting I try to kill it all away But I remember everything What have I become My sweetest friend? Everyone I know Goes away in the end You could have it all My empire of dirt I will let you down I will make you hurt I cannot repair Beneath the stains of time The feelings disappear You are someone else... I am still right here
I personally prefer the live version; Trent's voice is incredible, but when the whole crowd sings with him, it just sends shivers up my spine. LOVE THIS SONG
Ive have watched about a hundred diff videos of this song (both NIN and Cash) and they all have the same damn arguement going on in the comments lol. Music is art, not competition. Just enjoy it
This song fits the movie perfectly! amazing job on this... Im tired of people say cashes version is better Its great but so is NIN. They are different. I think people believe that johnny cash wrote this song:)
Yeah great,,,, but really i just wanted to listen to this song and not all the other shit you've put on that comes on afterwards that wont leave until i shut my pc down you f'kin bellend !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Nice job... I just wished it focused on Sweeney's relationship with his wife and child. The song makes more sense in that aspect than it would with Ms. Lovett because Sweeney doesn't love her. He loves Johanna and his wife. Nice job though.
@RevoSociety The song's not about one person or event. It's about the problems you make in life and the pain you feel, and, in turn, the people you hurt.
Very nice work indeed. Decided to search for the NIN version of Hurt since I've truly yet to listen to it and wanted to give the creators their due rather than just liking Johnny Cash's cover of it.
you do realise its not "Trents interpretation" its his song, Cash just covered it... dont believe me? then feel free to Wiki it, JC's version was OK but this one has more meaning in my opinion
Trent gives this (his?) song alot of emotions, but in a way i like Johnny Cash's better. He sings it wit so many emotions you could cry...He recorded this song just after his wife died, and he lets the world know he's "hurt"
When Johnny Cash heard this he must have felt what we felt when we heard it. He remade it, in his own way. He didn't want recognition for it, he died shortly after. I think he just realized that someone had already wrote the words he needed to sing. It wasn't a competition, or whos was better. It was a goodbye...sang deeply and beautifully no matter who sang it. Johnny Cash just felt hurt for different reasons, thats all.
Your a goddamn poet!I prefer cash's version over trents but your absolutely correct!Even though I prefer one over another they both have my respect equally.If trent never wrote it Johnny could'nt of made it a master piece.
Hey Echo~I like what you did.Forgive my ignorance {I don't get out much} but is THIS YOUR work?Cuz I liked ST put to NIN, especially the ending movements.If the vid IS your work, good job!Keep posting for the sick phuks like me that like to watch :)tongue out
@EchoStarlite Yah Echo, I am really impressed with the quality work that you did with this song. It fits really well with the story line and has NIN is able to draw you into the picture almost as if the lyrics were written for the picture.
cash's version in my opinion isnt better, i like this one cause its the original version, Nine Inch Nails wrote it, and i like how its more quiet, it gives it a sad feeling
I understand Ur feelings on this.Cash's version,2me,is JUST as sad,it's just that it's a different "sad",2me.Somehow w/Cash,I could FEEL his pain..it was palpable...after a lifetime w/his other half, 2 have her gone from his life MUST have hurt...in a way I have yet 2experience.With Rez, 4some reason, I was never convinced of that,tho I LOVE what he did!But I like what U said about "it's more quiet"..I agree! I'd like to know how U feel about others...keep posting,my friend, you have a good ear!
ok just to clear up this johny cash nine inch nails fued...... i love johny cashes version its really good and i love to listen to it but the nine inch nails version is way more darker and just makes you have so much feeling, i think it depends on wat kind of person u r on how well u lke tis song nd by the way nice job on the vid liv tat movie nd really went wit the theme of the song
The argument about who's version is better here doesn't make sense to me. Johnny's version is about something different, but i think that's actually the mark of a good song. It can be interpreted by different people to mean different things. Now whether you think cash's version or NIN's version is better, i think credit has to be given to trent for WRITING the song. He wrote a good song which was covered by many people and if you prefer another version that's your opinion. No point arguing
Both versions are good. I don't really know nine inch nails, but johnny cash's version really sums up his life, all of his past, drugs, jail, death of loved ones, etc... so to say that he didn't understand the song is not true. And sounding tortured doesn't mean you have to sound like you have lost your vocal cords. They are both good in their own respects.
@what55ify Actually, no... Johnny Cash COVERED this song. It was originally written and performed by Trent Reznor (Nine Inch Nails). While I'll admit that the Johnny Cash video and the supposed reason he covered the song (the recent loss of his wife) made an emotional impact...his version does not come close to Trents'. Johnny Cash is an amazing musician, however in this specific case, I cringed everytime I heard him sing Trents' song.
@eeyoreannie I totally agree. I don't think the song was suited for the death of his wife. I don't feel like all of his emotion was put into the song, infact, since he sang it for his wife, I feel like he didn't even understand it enought to cover it. He's a great musician but he really didn't sound that great coving this song. With Trent you really feel it, his voice sounds so tortured.
@JLT1994 It all depends on what you like. I love both because they both sounded true. Trent came from the truth of addiction hurting the ones you love and the will to quit not always feeling like enough. Johnny's was his wife and the feeling of loss of the one he loved. As long as the words are true for the performer, most any great song isn't hurt by their performance. Trent's was beautiful for it's ambiance and Johnny for his simplistic interpretation. Bottom line... great song.
oh yea and he kills the judge befor that happens joanna runs away with a hot young lad name anthony after geting thrown in a mental ward because the judge is evil and wanted to keep her locked away form him then a young boy named toby who mrs lovette devolped mother son bond with earlleir kill sweeny for throwing ma ma in the oven and the end
for a while until sweeny finds out his wife didn't kill her self and mrs lovette lied to him and he accidently mistook her for a nosey beggar woman and hacked her neck sweeny furious throws mrs lovette in the oven
agaisnt judge turpin and to want to get his daughter out of judge turpins costody because he starts to have nasty pervo feelings for her aswell Mrs lovette devolpes a creepy stalker crush on sweeny todd and they hatch a schem to kill not just the judge but alot of innocent people and then cook them as meat pies makeing a lovely little profit off of um shaveing people sliceing their throat choping them up cooking and selling them as meat pies the plan seems fool proof
he got sent to prison for a crime he didn't comite and the same corupt judge rapes his wife while he's gone she poisions her self with arsenic leaving their darling daughter joanna with pervo judge he comes back when joanna is like 16 and his he finds his wife and child gone the pie shop owner mrs. lovette tell him all about it and that he can said in the upstairs room above her shop for a small fee and he can run his baber bussness there it doesn't take long for sweeny todd to crave revenge
i disagree, i would have to say both have some serious pain to it, between the dying johnny cash and the pain-filled Reznor version both could bring a person down easily
sweeney todd is a good movie by its self and now adding hurt to like a video of some sweeney todd parts awsome
SuperTurtlemandude1 3 months ago
NIN rocks... so glad I've found another awesome band (or, one man band) to listen to!
But one question: Did Sweeney Todd kill Professor Snape at 4:12 ?!
TheMasterNewAccount 5 months ago
brilliant the video goes sooo wel nine inch nails are class mr depp is hot xxx like cash too his version is cool x
tonifox123 5 months ago 2
<3
AliceofChains 6 months ago
Finally this song with good quality
SS2Jasper 6 months ago 3
this song....perfect for my life right now and perfect for what i've made him feel....
tHe2PrEtTy2ReCkLeSs 7 months ago
Am I alone in thinking that Beetleguese was Sweeny Todd when he was alive?
breacat 8 months ago
bestsong+bestmovie=<3 o:
musthavetacos 9 months ago 2
everyone i know, goes away in the end....
SelfAware1 10 months ago 7
The entire time I was watching this, I couldn't help but think:
"I love his hair."
Promzo14 10 months ago 20
@Promzo14 oh ya
rd6659 10 months ago
And... I honestly have no idea how everyone in the comments are still attributing Johnny Depp to singing this song when the artist (Nine Inch Nails) is clearly credited in both the title and description. How can you click on this video with the title right there and still think Johnny Depp had anything to do with it...?
xxBeautifulxDeathxx 11 months ago 9
what he sad
kraptis1989 1 year ago
Well, what can you say, this song. Fuck. Some songs are for dancing, some are for singing along, this is for sitting in a cold dark room, on the verge of suicide, too exhausted to even move, your thoughts crawling along with the monotone strum of the guitar.
DylanBobMr 1 year ago 155
@DylanBobMr You sir, should be a writer.
Vinodnj1978 1 year ago
@DylanBobMr I feel like that alot....
brinkadink93 10 months ago
@DylanBobMr Sooooooo true, that comment has just gone straight into my english essay. :)
24sped21 10 months ago
@DylanBobMr Agreed. brother (Y)
batmankills293 6 months ago
Thank god this video doesnt have that background static in it that all the other ones do. Like, i know its part of the song and all but its frigging annoying..
Hoorahify 1 year ago 7
@MarisaRosa7
I saw it, the music's good but the story kind of doesn't go anywhere.... It's an okay movie to me :)
WeBelongInTheSea 1 year ago
@WeBelongInTheSea
thanks
MarisaRosa7 1 year ago
Comment removed
janstohler 1 year ago
Tim Burton's Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street (2007)
LepaTena 1 year ago
Awesome
RAAAWRimapenguin 1 year ago
@kmk247420 Where did you here that rumor? :o
LethalRabbit 1 year ago
actually I'm pretty sure Johnny plays guitar....which would make him a musician plus, there are a few pics of him rocking some concerts for charities or something with other actors/musicians/artists. When you sign up for acting, you may as well enroll yourself in music and dance as well. The entertainment biz is a 3 in 1 package pretty much today. Not everyone functions under these, but the majority have more than one/two skills.
ThatPunkGirl 1 year ago
As far as I know Johnny Depp NEVER sang in a band. All I know is that Trent Reznor still sings with Nine Inch Nails to this day.
doctorshifty83 1 year ago
@doctorshifty83 I thought Reznor died?
kmk247420 1 year ago
@emmymae09 this song is amazing, and Cash knew it. They both sang the hell out of it. Both versions, are equal. Therefore, no one is better.
snipinblackkid 1 year ago
This song gives me chills especially the Johnny Cash cover. Thats pretty much why I like it.
MermaidAntihero1988 1 year ago
99622917 1 year ago
love NIN
niecy118 1 year ago
creepy but good. love the song.
moviemaestro001 1 year ago
I love this.<3
MaddieAwbrii 1 year ago
@Wymorej Its Cash's remake. this is the original.
gekori 1 year ago
51 people are blind and deaf idiots -_-
seko0408888 1 year ago
i loooove this song </3
jasontxmexdat972 1 year ago
This is the best video :)
Raybeecham2009 1 year ago
NIN IS KING
DamienTheDarkLight 1 year ago
it was a great music video..
breakageaqeaol 1 year ago
omg the song sounds so much better on here. like it doesnt sound all bad in the beggining. I hope you guys know what im talking about.lol
001jhl 1 year ago
I LOVE THIS SO MUCH!!!!!
101KatieMusic 1 year ago
I personally prefer the live version; Trent's voice is incredible, but when the whole crowd sings with him, it just sends shivers up my spine. LOVE THIS SONG
XxListen2metalxX 1 year ago
Loved it! Great song/movie combo...well done!
IAmTheEvilMonkey 1 year ago
@cbritton1876 When i say he does sing, I meant to say he does sing in Sweeney Todd. Just to clarify.
cbritton1876 1 year ago
I still think Johnny cash did it better. His voice just gives me chills. But i love this song.
zombiestew1 1 year ago
Perfect song for these characters. Unbelievable song choice.
PhantoMPhreeK92 1 year ago
@NicoTeen7
Seriously. Dude needs to grow a brain.
MacLotr 1 year ago
Ive have watched about a hundred diff videos of this song (both NIN and Cash) and they all have the same damn arguement going on in the comments lol. Music is art, not competition. Just enjoy it
chsxredford 1 year ago
Like it. But Johnny Cash is better ;)
LeneStinkt 1 year ago
johnny cash did this song better... not even johnny's song but its still better
systemofaserj 1 year ago
loved it
slager4ever 1 year ago
This song fits the movie perfectly! amazing job on this... Im tired of people say cashes version is better Its great but so is NIN. They are different. I think people believe that johnny cash wrote this song:)
lissajane79 1 year ago
the original had a touch more grit and soul. Depp does Cash justice nonetheless.
izaakbenjamin 1 year ago
this is great. best song ever and i adore the movie. so yeah i love it.
yourmom3433 1 year ago
mmmmm........ yes yes johnny deep and Trent.
Thanks for this.
wdy73 1 year ago
were to download a clean version of this song? cuz all I can find are live shows or terrible sound...
CreativeDoom 1 year ago
Beneath the stains of time
The feelings disappear
You are someone else
I am still right here
supERIKAshirley 1 year ago
Fucking love this song. It does go great with the video. Good job... Trent and I have these thoughts in common...
Notyoursbiatch04 1 year ago
Wow...such a good video! The song suits the movie and the video is just...wonderful...:)
Excellent job!
bluefoundation26 1 year ago
this is so good! :D brings out his loving side :3
ChazJayHeaton 1 year ago
awesome song awesome band awesome movie
XxJOKERxXish 1 year ago
Nice editing!
BrightMidnight 1 year ago
Thank you for making this! I love it. the song is perfect for the film. =)
FriFroJones 1 year ago
you put together this video really well with this song good job, i give 10 stars out of 5.
mypocketsoncreatine 1 year ago
Yeah great,,,, but really i just wanted to listen to this song and not all the other shit you've put on that comes on afterwards that wont leave until i shut my pc down you f'kin bellend !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
stephenmerton 1 year ago
I dont care I love both NIN and John Cash
RoflCopterClan 1 year ago
good song
SpaQueenRocks 1 year ago
Nice job... I just wished it focused on Sweeney's relationship with his wife and child. The song makes more sense in that aspect than it would with Ms. Lovett because Sweeney doesn't love her. He loves Johanna and his wife. Nice job though.
Chompobar 1 year ago
johnny''s version is better in my opinion
HermanHermes 1 year ago
both the movie and song go together perfectly
roflcopter908 1 year ago
this song makes me cry pretty much everytime i hear it.
PlanetKooi 1 year ago
As I recall, Trent loved Johnny Cash's cover.
TheUnNerved 1 year ago 71
@TheUnNerved actually, he didnt love it. Trent thought the cover was nothing special. But when he saw the music video, he loved it.
SoiledtheBand 1 year ago
Greatest Movie ever made
OverWarProject 1 year ago
@OverWarProject DAMN STRAIGHT!
residentevlidead 1 year ago
dude, it should have ended with him throwin her into that oven. haha. but seriously badass vid bro.
kurdtdouglas1023 1 year ago 2
I want pie!!!!
ZunigaZorola 1 year ago
This is just what i heard from a friend of mine but was this song written For Kurt Corbain? I know for a fact that they were friends and all.
RevoSociety 1 year ago
@RevoSociety The song's not about one person or event. It's about the problems you make in life and the pain you feel, and, in turn, the people you hurt.
GetsuakaKato 1 year ago
Very nice work indeed. Decided to search for the NIN version of Hurt since I've truly yet to listen to it and wanted to give the creators their due rather than just liking Johnny Cash's cover of it.
Keep up the great work. *thumbs up*
NeroRadec707 1 year ago
like the song though the movie scares me :S
TheEasternPrince 1 year ago
Wow i really like this song i just found it .
AvrilLavingeBigFan 1 year ago
the scences in sweeney todd reminds me of alice in wonderland
mosidian 1 year ago 2
do you live on the moon or something ? its sweeney todd the demon barber of fleet st
ultramagnus73 1 year ago
It's this song that motivates me to wanna say fuck it all , and just go where ever the wind takes me , Fuck laws, friends, love, Family, etc.
jasonkingj69 1 year ago 13
what is movie called?
tattmanrocko 1 year ago
Sweeny Todd
livingmylifeatmach2 1 year ago
@tattmanrocko sweeney todd: the demon barber of fleet street lol
22rawrrawr 1 year ago
i found myself in a dark trance staring at the screen very moving
22rawrrawr 1 year ago 2
helena bonham carter is hot! This is a good song and movie, one of teh best movies I have ever seen
residentevlidead 1 year ago
This is an ORIGINAL Nine Inch Nails song. Trent Reznor WROTE IT. Johnny Cash just remade it.
Smeegasaurusrex 1 year ago 3
you do realise its not "Trents interpretation" its his song, Cash just covered it... dont believe me? then feel free to Wiki it, JC's version was OK but this one has more meaning in my opinion
coolbutcashless 1 year ago
the song goes so well with the video i love this versio of the song
ilovejohnny13 1 year ago
I really love Trent's interpretation of this song... It's more "evil" than Cash version...
EvilMoFu 1 year ago
darker
Trevrz1 1 year ago
Trent gives this (his?) song alot of emotions, but in a way i like Johnny Cash's better. He sings it wit so many emotions you could cry...He recorded this song just after his wife died, and he lets the world know he's "hurt"
cavaro18 1 year ago
I love that movie
residentevlidead 1 year ago
When I heard NIN sing this song, it's creepy, Johnny Cash made it haunting.
marinesgirl349 1 year ago 3
When Johnny Cash heard this he must have felt what we felt when we heard it. He remade it, in his own way. He didn't want recognition for it, he died shortly after. I think he just realized that someone had already wrote the words he needed to sing. It wasn't a competition, or whos was better. It was a goodbye...sang deeply and beautifully no matter who sang it. Johnny Cash just felt hurt for different reasons, thats all.
AutumnRain333 1 year ago 89
Well said.
I personally like Johnny's version the most, he really made it his own and put his heart into it.
I have respect for those artists who can acknowledge other artists work, and translate it in their own way.
AnotherDaneMetalhead 1 year ago 3
@AutumnRain333
100% right!
Zoltkaa 1 year ago
@AutumnRain333 Johnny Cash mentioned that this song best describes the drug problems he had, and that's why he chose to cover it.
justbourlier 1 year ago
Your a goddamn poet!I prefer cash's version over trents but your absolutely correct!Even though I prefer one over another they both have my respect equally.If trent never wrote it Johnny could'nt of made it a master piece.
karlvon12 1 year ago
Hey Echo~I like what you did.Forgive my ignorance {I don't get out much} but is THIS YOUR work?Cuz I liked ST put to NIN, especially the ending movements.If the vid IS your work, good job!Keep posting for the sick phuks like me that like to watch :)tongue out
cravingart 1 year ago 6
Yeah, I made this a while ago, actually, and thanks for the compliment!
EchoStarlite 1 year ago
@EchoStarlite Yah Echo, I am really impressed with the quality work that you did with this song. It fits really well with the story line and has NIN is able to draw you into the picture almost as if the lyrics were written for the picture.
rjpruess 1 year ago
cash's version in my opinion isnt better, i like this one cause its the original version, Nine Inch Nails wrote it, and i like how its more quiet, it gives it a sad feeling
MGRaiden64 1 year ago 2
I understand Ur feelings on this.Cash's version,2me,is JUST as sad,it's just that it's a different "sad",2me.Somehow w/Cash,I could FEEL his pain..it was palpable...after a lifetime w/his other half, 2 have her gone from his life MUST have hurt...in a way I have yet 2experience.With Rez, 4some reason, I was never convinced of that,tho I LOVE what he did!But I like what U said about "it's more quiet"..I agree! I'd like to know how U feel about others...keep posting,my friend, you have a good ear!
cravingart 1 year ago
I think cash's version is better because it means something but still a good song none the less
WSGTTV 1 year ago
ok just to clear up this johny cash nine inch nails fued...... i love johny cashes version its really good and i love to listen to it but the nine inch nails version is way more darker and just makes you have so much feeling, i think it depends on wat kind of person u r on how well u lke tis song nd by the way nice job on the vid liv tat movie nd really went wit the theme of the song
rotateshair 1 year ago 3
... go back to school kid... learn to spell...
NinjaMan1997 1 year ago
awesome compilation! check out my cover on my page =)
CyanideStudios 1 year ago
seeing johnny depp with that white stripe in his hair, makes me think of marc bolan.
IWhentOut 1 year ago
heehee..good eye...I can see that!
cravingart 1 year ago
such a beautiful song. i love nin
allxxapologies 1 year ago
The argument about who's version is better here doesn't make sense to me. Johnny's version is about something different, but i think that's actually the mark of a good song. It can be interpreted by different people to mean different things. Now whether you think cash's version or NIN's version is better, i think credit has to be given to trent for WRITING the song. He wrote a good song which was covered by many people and if you prefer another version that's your opinion. No point arguing
nekolux 2 years ago
I think they do the song better anyways. It sounds darker.
nightmareutopia 2 years ago
would have looked cool if u have left out all the parts with their lips moving, just my opinion
GothenburgMetalhead 2 years ago 2
this vid goes great with the song :P
RiddickLookALike 2 years ago
I love Johnny Depp in this role. This song is perfect for his character and his lust for revenge & evil. Thank you for all of your hard work.
Jill499 2 years ago
Both versions are good. I don't really know nine inch nails, but johnny cash's version really sums up his life, all of his past, drugs, jail, death of loved ones, etc... so to say that he didn't understand the song is not true. And sounding tortured doesn't mean you have to sound like you have lost your vocal cords. They are both good in their own respects.
trucanuck14 2 years ago 2
Fuck you.
TheDivineVessel 2 years ago 2
that is trent reznor dumb ass!!!
winninpoo 2 years ago 3
Very cool. I never would've thought of combining this song with Sweeney Todd. Interesting.
alleclipsed 2 years ago
I love. this version and johnny cash's.
missesmellow 2 years ago
goooooooooood job
vanessahdepp 2 years ago
Johnny Cash didn't sing it first. He covered it. :x
EmoraChan13 2 years ago
this was an awesome vid and song choice i loveddd it keep up the good work!
DeathsIncarnate 2 years ago
there's somethin crazy sexy about helena botham carter
callmegod6x3 2 years ago 4
are their different versions or mixes of this song ? my Nin hurt sounds slightly different to this
Deathcab47 2 years ago
Johnny Cash sang it first, if that helps. His sounds really similar to this.
what55ify 2 years ago
@what55ify
this was a tribute to johnny cash.
tlin69 2 years ago
Nine Inch Nails wrote this song first dude
Themooksterman 2 years ago 4
@what55ify
nah nin did it 1st (released in 1994)
Cash released his version in 2002
Kalt13 2 years ago
Oh! Now I feel like an idiot...
what55ify 2 years ago
@what55ify Actually, no... Johnny Cash COVERED this song. It was originally written and performed by Trent Reznor (Nine Inch Nails). While I'll admit that the Johnny Cash video and the supposed reason he covered the song (the recent loss of his wife) made an emotional impact...his version does not come close to Trents'. Johnny Cash is an amazing musician, however in this specific case, I cringed everytime I heard him sing Trents' song.
eeyoreannie 2 years ago
I know. Look up to see if I've already been told... which I have.
what55ify 2 years ago
@eeyoreannie I totally agree. I don't think the song was suited for the death of his wife. I don't feel like all of his emotion was put into the song, infact, since he sang it for his wife, I feel like he didn't even understand it enought to cover it. He's a great musician but he really didn't sound that great coving this song. With Trent you really feel it, his voice sounds so tortured.
ChemicalConundrum 2 years ago
@what55ify No, Johnny Cash covered it. Trent Reznor sang it first.
augustrunsred 2 years ago
@Deathcab47 Yeah, NIN did different versions of this song. There were "Quiet" and "Album" versions, censored/uncensored versions.
0u70fSync 2 years ago
This song is sogreat i love two versions
And the film .. unwords
NareNix 2 years ago
@toliveistodie1983 in that case your right
hoi477 2 years ago
sweet movie.
DreadSMC 2 years ago
@ jonathonpvaldez17
yeah but when Johnny sang it, it looks like the song is written for the man in black
hoi477 2 years ago 2
he changed it trents is about heroin and cash is about his wife they both are good though
toliveistodie1983 2 years ago
yea trents is a million times better though..being an ex heroine addict the song really hits home ya know..
DanGarwood2406 2 years ago
cash's version is more about how he's dying and misses his younger days
B4413 2 years ago
i focussed on the pain *evil grin at razor blades*
xD
DrunkPassedOutHobo 2 years ago 3
thats really good i was never able to see the movie so that was a nice glimpse of what i missed
fma113 2 years ago 2
@fma113
its a hell of a movie. would love to watch it again
brambeclaw 2 years ago
hollow life by KoRn would go good with this too. I listened to it now after watching this movie and imagined Johnny Depp singing for some reason xD
twirlingchair 2 years ago
johnny cash's version sounds better
JLT1994 2 years ago
Johnnys version is good, but without NIN Johnny never would have been able to do it.
jonathonpvaldez17 2 years ago 3
fair call, but johnny has more sorrow to his voice wich works better for this song
chainerd 2 years ago
doesnt get the emotions accross as good as Nine Inch Nails do
66SmUrF66 2 years ago
@JLT1994 It all depends on what you like. I love both because they both sounded true. Trent came from the truth of addiction hurting the ones you love and the will to quit not always feeling like enough. Johnny's was his wife and the feeling of loss of the one he loved. As long as the words are true for the performer, most any great song isn't hurt by their performance. Trent's was beautiful for it's ambiance and Johnny for his simplistic interpretation. Bottom line... great song.
gthoma2a 2 years ago 13
@gthoma2a johnny's version wasn't because of his wife,she was still alive when he recorded it.
melas169226 1 year ago
*finds a happy place
ObzidianKnife 2 years ago
so to answer your question its alot of dark crazy things
spiderlily21 2 years ago
oh yea and he kills the judge befor that happens joanna runs away with a hot young lad name anthony after geting thrown in a mental ward because the judge is evil and wanted to keep her locked away form him then a young boy named toby who mrs lovette devolped mother son bond with earlleir kill sweeny for throwing ma ma in the oven and the end
spiderlily21 2 years ago 2
for a while until sweeny finds out his wife didn't kill her self and mrs lovette lied to him and he accidently mistook her for a nosey beggar woman and hacked her neck sweeny furious throws mrs lovette in the oven
spiderlily21 2 years ago 2
agaisnt judge turpin and to want to get his daughter out of judge turpins costody because he starts to have nasty pervo feelings for her aswell Mrs lovette devolpes a creepy stalker crush on sweeny todd and they hatch a schem to kill not just the judge but alot of innocent people and then cook them as meat pies makeing a lovely little profit off of um shaveing people sliceing their throat choping them up cooking and selling them as meat pies the plan seems fool proof
spiderlily21 2 years ago
he got sent to prison for a crime he didn't comite and the same corupt judge rapes his wife while he's gone she poisions her self with arsenic leaving their darling daughter joanna with pervo judge he comes back when joanna is like 16 and his he finds his wife and child gone the pie shop owner mrs. lovette tell him all about it and that he can said in the upstairs room above her shop for a small fee and he can run his baber bussness there it doesn't take long for sweeny todd to crave revenge
spiderlily21 2 years ago 3
never saw this film. why did he get demented?
Warlord1500 2 years ago
what a great song. perfect movie for it.
BijouSSJ4 2 years ago
this fits perfect!
HeATHaBAbY95 2 years ago
woohoo i luvs this song
oldsmelly911 2 years ago
muy buena la cancion
johanjh666 2 years ago
great song!
mcisner3 2 years ago
yeah but there are no goths in fable lol
DIELAWN123 2 years ago
Sweeney should have sang this song in the movie! awesome movie! awesome song!
jokerluvsLP 2 years ago
in which part of Fable II?
dogster129 2 years ago
everyone i know goes away in the end
that describes my life perfectly
hitechtonicleader 2 years ago
and one else think that this movie and the atmosphere of Fable II are rather similar? just sayin XD
twsty123456 2 years ago
yeah it does have the same dark feeling
smellacaster1 2 years ago
cashs version is good too theyre just in different views
this one is more like actual pain and johnny cashs is more like the fact that hes getting older
ewyou10 2 years ago 4
i disagree, i would have to say both have some serious pain to it, between the dying johnny cash and the pain-filled Reznor version both could bring a person down easily
B4413 2 years ago
@B4413 exactly what you just said
ewyou10 2 years ago
@B4413 i agree with what you just said
ewyou10 2 years ago