Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (105)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • It's against American law to be involved in torture, which is why the US gov. outsources the dirty work to private and/or foreign entities who report only to the top echelons of the pentagon. Think about all the top secret files kept in high tech vaults. The pentagon is the most secure and heavily guarded facility in America outside of Area 51 for example. Think about all the intel that might have been destroyed at the pentagon on 911.

  • @Fleshy91 Good point. What the US state is prohibited from doing at home, it may carry out abroad. Did you know that the US was using Libya to render people ("terror suspects") to Guantanamo?

    Now apparently the US govt doesnt approve of Gaddafi and thinks it should invade and bomb the country. Sounds like what they did to Yugoslavia with NATO.

    Re: secret files - what about Bradley Manning - now in solitary confinement for releasing details of US war crimes? Its hypocrisy

    Thanks for watching.

  • it is haram to mistreat your prisoners in islam.  Muhammed ordered his men to untie them, and give them water.

  • @Vausgorn its a shame Binyams torturers were not good Muslims, Christians, Jews or atheists.

    They were infact insane soldiers, with no morals, brainwashed by the US government to commit acts of terror and torture against humanity. Your typical imperialist army really...

  • son of a bitch bush

  • OBAMA!!! BIAtch

  • @lifeinthenfl Obama still hasnt closed down Guantanamo. His name is no use here.

  • George W Bush should be put through the courts along with dick "head" cheeney, rumsfield and the rest of his nazi grouping!! they think they own the world. It is about time they had to face the consequences of living beyond the rule of law and human rights!! I would hope for the death penalty just as bush has fought for in his redneck texas!

  • this is so sad..this should never of happened..open your eyes people...we need to stop this!

  • Thanks for posting. It was interesting to watch the juxtaposition of Rice, Bush and Blair. Now that we know all three were lying it is interesting to watch their body language as they lie.

  • Honestly. Listening to GW is like listening to some drunkard talking into a spitoon. What a loafing piece of work. I actually do pity the miserable creature.

  • ...why would a muslim refugee who has supposedly fled from tyrani to the uk to be safe and free from danger, then fly to another danger zone in pakistan, and, in2001...then fly back to the uk on a false passport ...if he hadnt have been caught...what would he have gone on to do next i wonder.....i guess him and his human rights lawers will make a bundle from this..(and especially out of us...the poor old british tax payer !)..

  • My friend. Binyam was not charged for 3 years whilst being tortured for information. Then he was charged but faced no trial for 4 years of torture and imprisonment. That is what this video is about.

    Do some reading around the subject and you might understand it better

    best

    a

  • i do understand what u r saying n in some way u r right of course but its more to all stories on the BBC we r rich we pay no tax 1 man Green something paid himself n family £1.2 BILLION not Million in 1 year n paid No tax at all cause his wife owns all the shares n she lives in Monaco it was many others too the rich robbing the poor City of London is a state within but their alligence does Not belong to the host country n they pay No tax tp their host country like tha vatican n washington DC

  • It is really sad when people absorb the information they are given and do not seek the truth. Does anyone ever wonder why no american or white terrorists are locked up in gitmo? I guess ur minds they do not exist. This country puts hate into u and those of us that are smart enough to notice it reject it. If anything this torture makes our country less safe because it gives people even more of a reason to hate america. come on people, take ur head off bush's lap and read a book.

  • David Hicks

  • Lovely people these American and British politicians aren't they. They lie to the world and their people with a smile on their face!

  • y was e usin a fake passport?

  • What happened to American values?

  • Europeans landed on Native American shores...that's what happened.

  • what happened to his passport?!?

  • The Law is flawed, deeply. Time after time we see low sentences for disgusting crimes, we see the hard work of police ruined because of insane guidelines, we see injustice everyday, everywhere. A story recently, a man highly suspected of being a pedophile, abused 3 kids, the kids wouldn't testify, he ended up with a suspended sentence, in which time, he raped and kill a child. WHERE ARE THE RIGHTS OF THE INNOCENT? THE GOOD? Why are blatant bad peoples rights of such importance?

  • Fuck you liberty groups, fuck you human rights groups. What about the rights of the victims in the world? Bad people get locked up for a reason, if we know a man is a paedophile or a rapist, must we have to wait for him to abuse a child or rape a girl before we can lock him up? I am all for Bush, and what he did. Human rights in this world too often, squabble about the size of the rapists cell being too small, or them not being allowed to watch tv, what about his victims? You absolute filth.

  • you kind of missed the point mate- Binyam has NEVER BEEN TRIALLED OR SENTENCED FOR ANY CRIME

    just illegally tortured and confessions extracted during torture

    have a good day

    -chips

  • if we know it, then

    no courts

    are necessary"

  • This is a bit rich. Mohamed was held for almost 7 years without trial. Regardless of allegations of torture, that is wrong. It is against the basic rule of law, not just us soppy liberals' sensibilities

    Oh, and I think the comparison you make here (while A: very Daily Mail and b: completely unrelated) is useless. Nobody watches TV in Gitmo

  • your all for bush? you do relise that he suffers from mental psycosis right?

  • Fuck the Morocco government for allowing this.

  • bush is a freakin lair

    the biggest lair ever

  • poor man

  • To realize the dream of NWO,alias the first global empire,America must not rely on force of arms alone. History teaches us that to rule a mighty empire,there needs a consensus. And trust is central to it. The early Romans demonstrated to the conquered that Roman laws were fairer than their own autocratic laws. The empire offered security for their surrender of freedom. The new Roman Empire or NWO needs to offer similar to persuade widespread complicity n NWO citizenship like Roman citizenship

  • Gitmo = no habeas corpus & many died during torture

    New book by Former Gitmo Sec Off writes that our torturing at Gitmo is not only a heinous & useless abomination; it is in fact the direct cause of the deaths of over 3000 US Soldiers!

    Why is there torture by Americans?

    Likely these abominations of war & torture are merely an extension of the typical Americans brutal mind; a mind corrupted by a pathological disassociation of compassion that is inherent to the corporate working stiff

  • The danger is that innocent people can be wrongfully arrested,tortured,abused and killed to cover up the error.

    What happened to American values?

  • They died with our forefathers. America is a super-power... nothing with this much power has ever stood uncorrupted by it in the history of man, and America is no different.

  • what values ......do u c our horible history.....compare us to germany if u wish....(no offense to any germans)

  • Thanks alphaone for the video. Very sad indeed. May God release dear Innocent Binyaman from the capitivity of the evil ones who have been exposed. And Grant Binyamin peace tranquility and happiness again.

  • Hang Bush for war crimes

  • kk kkkkkkkkk bush

  • My country has become the most evil country in History. Led by a moron that's making us less safe. Damn you Bush and damn all your idiot followers that think he is making us safer.

  • why does everyone feel sorry for a fucking terrorist?? now maybe we should feel sorry for people who don't deserve to be locked up and tortured. basically this makes me want to throw up all over my desktop.

  • Binyam has not been trialled. This means that it has not been proven that he is a terrorist. Maybe we should go round to your house and kidnap you to an underground prison in Morocco and then take you to an illegal torture camp in Cuba and cut you with a razor to make you talk?

    Im sure your family would love that?

    But then again you dont see Binyam as human since he is a Muslim thus determining that he is a terrorist.

    Your foul logic and understanding is inexcusable. You should be ashamed.

  • But, he's not a terrorist.

  • Please write to Binyam....if you care.

  • Very sad,very sad, I dont know what to do I trust my brother , He dont lie on this kind of issue. I know my brothers Ethiopians , We Ethiopians lived togerther with out dividing us by religion for thausand years. We dont have extrimist in Ethiopia. We leave our Country in case of poletics problem , no other mission. I hate America nowa days in case of theire wrong the worst poletics.

  • "Sorry I meant we leave our country in case of econemy" it could happen too poletical case but for sure not this much nowa days.

  • If he is still in prison then how did you get his diary?

  • his diary was released ... not him

  • Also read "Bad men" by Clive Stafford Smith. Good book.

  • clive stafford smith is a genius!

  • Its fine to kill hundreds of thousands of innocent people in Iraq for oil, but when they kill 3000ish innocent people they are apparently worst?

    Whats worst, hundres of thousands or thousands... :|

  • by the standards the US is the terrorist :D

  • Hello alphaone;

    This movie is playing tonight on TVO in Ontario, Canada.

    Your video gave me a heads up and I will watch the movie toight.

    Thanks, Fred

  • white males are so emasculated and threatened by other men that they must torture and war monger to assuage their feelings of inadequacy. now that they can no longer string black men from trees they have set their sights on Arab men. must be why so many white women turn to pedophilia.

  • interesting perspective, but i dont think this case is entirely about racial supremacy.

    the film makers do not insinuate white people are bad or the root of this problem is ethnicity.

    its more about bad government and abusing the word 'democracy' to the limits. we call for freedom of the guantanamo bay prisoners and an end to the torture.

    peace bro

    a

  • Nomorelebs: I have to ask you a question. You say that if 100 people are detained and tortured and ONE of them is guilty, it is still worth it. Now, would this still apply if your brother, your father or yourself were one of the 100?

  • Its really tragic that only 4,428 people saw this...

    It just goes to say...

  • true, we agree! I think people are sick of hearing about guantanamo but do not realise its still going on and the illegal occupation still exists!

    thanks for your comment

    a

  • extraction, to show to the supporters and creators of these cruel acts, how misgudied are they, and to show them the truth of their ways. they would have no excuse to use these methods if another is found. i shudder at the thought of the fanatic soldiers in the camp, i pray that they will never accepted back into society for the acts they commited even under orders.

  • Just for the record, the filmmakers have nothing against US citizens but this film is an open remark towards the US Administration.

    thanks for your comment, I agree you have a point that many people 'hate americans' not realizing they are insulting many open minded and great people who do not support the government

    alpha

  • i think we should stop insulting USA on the whole. it is too broad, can u accuse American Citizens of the actions of their government? Yes, you should accuse American administration, hate them, but hating the citizens who i believe will be subjected to this torture if they are accused of being a terrorist. and even while hating, we shouldn't just protest, that yes it is illegal, stop the abuse, i feel that knowing these event is happening, we should think of another more humane method of

  • Hello everyone. I'd just like to make my stand here. Thank you to the person who posted this video, it was an eye-opener. I've got absolutely no experience in any field regarding this, and I'm not out to offend anyone. In my opinion, I feel that for the sake and safety of the masses, we have to sometimes take extreme measures to counter terrorism. However, I thik its is important, that in doing so, we do not become terrorists ourselves and hurt innocent people. Yep, that's all I have to say.

  • respect to you brother... good point

    alpha

  • But dont understand that innocent guy from the land of promised and the land of Christian and Muslim lives together of thausand years , Which law allows torture. This is only un human !!!!

  • thanks for your comment brother. dont worry one day we will be free and this behaviour wont happen again

    peace + love

    a

  • HAHA stupid americans. No wonder every one hates you. You torture innocents and justify it in the name of protecting yourself from terrorism. God, I hope the worste for you

  • If we arrest 100 people... 99 of them innocent.. just having that one guilty terrorist in prison is going to save a hell of alot more than 99 lives. Worth it. All you lefties who want to be arm chair experts from the safety of your computer room.. stop taking your freedoms for granted. You are defending the very people who want to take it away from you.

  • nomorelebs; I don`t take my freedom for granted. That is why I am outraged that torture is sanctioned by The American , and by its failure to take a stand , the British governments. This is my freedom to expect the rule of law , and a the hard won right to a fair trial to be applied, being taken away by the people who are supposed to represent us

    This is a despicable evil and the good names of our countries is in tatters as a result.

  • Ask the Sudanese and the Nigerians what they think of the secret police. Do you want that here or do you think we could be better?

  • Khalid Sheikh Mohamed who sawed off the Head of Daniel Pearl and mastermind of 9/11. If you knew he (ahead of time)planned to kill 3K innocent people, would you want him water boarded? Well, he was water boarded and saved lives after he killed 3K people. This movie bombed because it was about how America has caused Islamist extremeist. I bet this movie didn't bomb in the middle east. Did I say bomb...sorry poor choice of words. Repeat after me. I'm a lefty and I hate the USA. Peace

  • watch extraordinary rendition trailer

  • thanks for your poetry Gaprielll

  • couse we do best when we liye and pary for our enemis or the terrrist to diye, but we never show them

    how hard we cry,

    as if we do

    we gonna lose to the enemis side

    it's all liye.

    why shoud we kill and hate

    if we all coud have peace and lorne from oneanothers mistakes.

  • Havenly father pleas forgiv us

    for what we did

    the past cant never chenge,

    the pine can never end.

    no one will believ on that,

    i hate to say that my struggel was my brothers lost

    and even the death is a natural part

    we will never com to think what if we

    diye tonight.

  • is there any soulution we can allstart by stoping the mony coruption I pary to god every day, to realis the paine from this man, and let him to enjoy the life, if he can, couse after what he saw, It gonna take a real men, whith strong wil to say, that I belive that toomorrow is gona be a realy good day " Gevorg Bagdasarian (gaprielll!)
  • I don't think that Bush is a vere of that, not cause his stupid in wich he is, but cause he is not that imporant to know about it, and it's in a secret, the real big people with power are invisible, so when somthing happend, the whol world will judge and point to someone how has no idea what is going on, thats it. Yes i am gonna say that i am agenst bush, but i am even more agenst the people that are truely top of this political game.

  • Look every one, I am just gonna say my opinion. I don'think that bush has a power at all, thats the plan, that way hi is president, there is Higer and more much more powerfull people,and it's them how's controling and cmanding every thing, even Bush

  • Seems to me this video is sympathetic to people that want to hurt this country. a good sign of this is the british accent of the narrator. freakin brits make me sick, they think they are better than us, but thats ok, there was a reason people left the uk and founded america.

  • Well, I'm awfully sorry but this documentary was made in the UK- hence the British accent! Bingo!

    What do you think the Americans did to the Afghanistani and Iraqi people? Bombed them? Used chemical warfare? Invaded their country in order to wipe out the government in search for WMDs that they never found? Invade peoples homes and murdered their families?

    Please try to open your mind and learn about what is happening in our modern world. Educate yourself and get free.

    -Anthony

  • murdered thier people??? yeah ok, mabye we should have left the iraqi people to the devices of saddam. the more i think about it, the more i wish we did. why pour billions of dollars into something the people of iraq and others dont appreciate. wow, i guess i could use the same comment on ww1 and 2, because the british obviously dont appreciate what america did for your country. britain is very arrogant in their feelings against america considering you have a british accent and not a german one.

  • Please understand that Sadam had dealings with the US government since the Bush Snr days. Realise that the reason the US invaded Iraq was to gain access to install a new government in order to run pipes to new oil.

    The US Gov't use the "terrorism" issue to scaremonger, justify illegal invasion and kidnap to support their cause.

    a

  • your arrogance is really out there. when we first invaded iraq a lot of people like yourself said, "we're going because of oil, we're going because of oil", so i kept an open mind about it and do you know what i realized since then? we havent taken one drop of oil from them, NADA! we are actually letting the iraqis use thier oil revenues to build thier country back. so youll have to do better than that.

  • Are you that stupid that you thing the US soldiers would just start barreling up Iraqi oil and shipping it out?!?! They have invaded to replace the gov't with a US appointed one which does straight business with the US.

    So maybe you have to be less blind and see how this business runs deep and discreetly so.

  • I add- British people do not agree with war and do not appreciate the invasion of another country in order to save them from some certain evil. We are not ignorant people and do not buy the US terrorism propaganda.

    Once again- do some reading over than your national press.

    a

  • yeah i am aware of eu's policy, and i also see thier country is full of muslim people. you might want to get ready, because i see a very dangerous future for them. madrid, spain was just the start of it. not to mention a burning vehicle in one of your airports. wake up, terrorist are attacking my country and yours and you still fail to address the situation.

  • i have many muslim friends who are normal citizens just like you and I. So I know from personal experience that these muslim 'terrorists' or extreamists we are dealing with are just as bad as GW Bush is a right wing Christian.

    Im not afraid of muslim terrorists as I know they hardly exist and are mostly media hype.

    a

  • Right and I suppose the mass genocide in Suddan, Nigeria and the constant suicide bombings in the middle east are carried out by a small team of disgruntled McDonalds employees. The attackings of Danish embassies world wide after the Prophet Mohammed cartoon was carried out by Donald Duck with Goofy providing the covering fire.

    The French ISLAMIC riots were not actually carried out by Muslims.. it was actually Frenchmen who were pissed off because the country was running out of frogslegs.

  • nomorelebs, let's imagine your son was arrested for something then TORTURED in a secret prison away from US soil, where no one could hear his screams- Guess that would be OK? And if formal charges were not pressed and he was released 6 years later traumatically and physically wounded- you would feel that is JUST?

    Unfortunately, Guantanamo bay is not a lefty air chair nightmare- but an ILLEGAL torture prison. WAKE UP.

    Thanks for watching.

  • What you just wrote was absolute scaremongerism.. to suggest it could be 'anyone, anytime, anywhere' who is sent to one of these facilities is completely false. And If we have to use non lethal methods of torture to extract information from suspected terrorists in order to use that information to save civilian lives then I am completely in support of it.

    Stop trying to tie the hands of the Western Governments and then asking them to throw a punch or two when necessary to protect you.

  • Im afraid that you are wrong in that I dont require the 'Western Government' to protect me and I did not ask for them to respond to 9/11 by starting war in Afganistan or Iraq. In fact, who did ask for it? You will find that the people did not ask for it and Guantanamo bay the result of the US's scaremongering war campaign- not mine. I support peace not war and fair trail, not torture prisons.

    My point about 'what if it was your son' in that position was to appeal to your humanity and justice.

  • just to let you know that if you want to talk to me about this send me a PM, i dont think everyone wants to hear us argue are differences.

    in response to your comment about tying the hands of western gov'ts- we are not trying to. We are trying to expose an illegal occupation of Cuba and its use as a torture camp, exposing the US's violation of human rights.

    alpha

  • 1. There is no illegal occupation of Cuba. Guantanamo is on permanent lease to the US.

    2. Stop sympathizing with muslim terrorist scum.

    3. Have a nice day.

  • 1. for your info the current Cuban government considers the U.S. presence in Guantanamo to be an illegal occupation of the area. How do I know? I have spoke to some government officials from Cuba about the issue.

    2. i dont sympathise with any terrorist but i do protest again torture and its my right to hold that opinion.

    so first go check your facts before speaking and secondly dont think your opinion is anything more than that.

    PEACE

    PS: viva la victoria siempre!

  • Of course Castro "considers" it illegal. The deal was made before him, and he's pissed he can't do anything about it, that's all. Let's not forget that Cuba is a COMMUNIST country; their word is shit. The deal was made; the US has a legitimate claim to Guantanamo. Look it up for yourself; if your not too busy with you America bashing.

  • erratum: "you're"

  • It does not matter whether the guilty or the innocent are caught in a situation like this. This is ethically wrong, it is a severe human rights violation. This is torture of the worst.

  • What gets on my nerves is that you badmouth the american government for "supposed" torture, but you say nothing of the fact that these terrorist at the beginning of the war caught some of our soldiers and cuts thier heads and limbs off. you want to talk about torture, then tell the truth.

  • Nobody deserves torture!!! Not the US soldiers and neither the followers of Al Quaida. And I don't bad mouth anyone. I am for the government. I am against the Bush administration.

  • well things are not going to get any better for you if you dont like the bushies, cause the two dem front runners, hillary and obama, dont have a chance in the general election. one is corrupt and the other doesnt have enough experience. i cant believe thats all the dem party has to offer. another conservative, hopefully not gulliani, will be the next pres.

  • Hillary Clinton is going to win the 2008 election.

  • lol, oh man thats so funny nicolatwo

  • No, this is not too funny how many people believe this hate propaganda against Hillary Clinton.

  • Here's the thing: you are voting for hillary for one of two reasons. Either you are ignorant of her corruption or you dont care how corrupt she is. ive read the book "dosier of hillary clinton" and let me tell you, she is the most corrupt politician in history. mabye you should read up on a few things or mabye the fact that shes a democrat is all that matters to you.

  • This is my last comment on this subject. The slander books about Hillary are written by the corporate agenda. All slander material broadcasted is designed by the right wing agenda which are scared of her because she will stop the corruption. Why don't YOU read some books and internet information on this subject?

  • Well I'd hate to live in your country if that were to happen, because, as it's been said many times before, the US cannot afford another republican leader.

  • Let me tell you something: If Al Gore was elected, we would have been attracked several times since 911. Republican leaders like bush have the balls and the intelligence to stop terrorism. Liberls are pussies and would act weak in a time of terror. Freakin libs make me sick.

  • Well that's wonderful and it's so great that fucking Bush was elected TWICE because HE did such an awesome job... and now we have everyone scared shitless- in turn giving the terrorists what they wanted. All this to the point of where people like yourself can justify the torture of innocent people

  • Torturing of innocent people???

    The only torture I see is 3000 people that were killed in the towers. Sometimes I wonder why young people hate their country so much. I think its because they have no sense of history, and they need to rail against something just to say they are a part of something. Todays young generation will be the death of this country and when they have all of their freedoms stripped away from them, they will wish they had their freedom back, but then it will be too late.

  • stop the terrorism?? bush provoked the terrorism!! it's unbelievable that Iraqi people were called terrorists! if USA was invaded for the fake reason and you would defend your country, would you like to be called a terrorist?

  • Wait a minute did you just say that Bush was intelligent? Don't make me laugh. If you think that he has done anything good for the US or the world then you're sorely mistaken, he has caused nothing but fighting and death. He blindly started a war with no grounds for it. 9/11 was a day that tore the world apart and since then Bush has run his country with fear, telling the public that if they don't do what he says then the terrorists will win, just so he can do whatever he wants. It's fucked up.

  • God bless your humanity! Im so glad to hear someone one youtube speak some sense on this issue and im sick of pro-bush war mongers too!

    peace

    x

  • Absolutely, peace to you too. Thank God there are people out there with a little common sense. When i got the email about this comment i was worried it would be another ignorant individual who, thorugh a lack of information on their part, knows nothing and cares little about the facts of the war. Thanks for your support.

    x

  • the illegal torture interrogation camp which the Bush administration have set up in Cuba (Guantanamo Bay) is a prime example of how the US constantly breaks international law and commits serious cases against human rights.

    Educate yourself user Andrew197553

  • the people at gitmo were caught on the battlefield fighting against american soldiers, including myself. if i had my way with them i would cut thier balls off and make them eat it. they have more rights than they should if you ask me. they hate america and wish us dead and you expect me to have sympathy, please. the democrats in america want to give them legal rights to our courts, which is why they will NEVER win in a general election again.

  • "Hating America" is no reason to make an illegal prison where torture is carried out. Torture is never an acceptable form of extracting information from a suspect under INTERNATIONAL LAW.

    Does the US follow international law? No it doesn't and this is why we made this documentary to point that out.

  • Sharing it now *****

  • i don't care what a person has done, torture does not equal justice.

    why haven't we risen up against this yet?? How can government officials be so heartless?

    these people should not be in power; you cannot lie to your people without consequence. it is wrong and its time we get the entire truth.

  • I guess everybody's just waiting for martial law.

  • thanks for your comments. you can go and join groups against this type of illegal activity. dont stay quiet if you feel bad- write, protest, make art... show that you think its wrong. peace. A

  • I joined my local militia yesterday, and I correspond with my elected officials every chance I get, but I don't feel like it's enough.

  • sureeeeeeeeeeee thing

  • I pray there is a Hell for you Bush.

  • yeah peace out! Wouldn't pity for Bush be more inline with "peaceful loving bitch"?

  • he used a false passport. hello???

  • hello

  • agreed, why wasn't this investigated to a more thorough degree? Probably b/c it doesn't serve the agenda of the makers. Surely a muslim man travelling in Pakistan at or around the time of the Twin Towers would raise a suspicion

  • "Surely a muslim man travelling in Pakistan at or around the time of the Twin Towers would raise a suspicion."

    Oh dear, just imagine... a muslim man travelling in Pakistan on the 11th September... who would do that?! SURELY only a TERRORIST. I mean It couldn't just be a muslim man from Pakistan could it?

  • a false passport isn't reason enough to have cuts on your penis or torture interrogation. For all we know, those are the claims from the authorities that withhold that "passport" as evidence, which the defense attorney has no access to nor any legal agent.

  • a well-made short doc that exposes some awful truths - watch it now.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more