HQ: NDTV Talk Show Analysis 2010 - Dr. Zakir Naik 2/25 - [Shahrukh Khan - Barkha Dutt]

[dpsghuman]

zakir naik in one video states that he supports the existing death penalty to non muslims preaching their faith in saudi arabia as he is sure that only islam is the true religion and all other religions are farce...do u support such vitriolic statement of a vibrant learned islamic scholar....same be upon him....

[95SilentNINJA]

@dpsghuman Zakir Naik never claimed he was a scholar, He blatantly said, he is a student of comparative religion. By the way if you are confused and confused about misconception, go to the IRF foundation in India or go to a Peace conference organised by the IRF and ask the speaker your queries. You will be convinced and re-assured by their answers. Please don't be so ignorant. You can watch many videos on Islam hosted by Shaik Ahmed Deedat or Dr Zakir Naik etc. who will enlighten you. :)

[sajidicma]

@dpsghuman Mumbai riots, Gujrat riots, Golden temple riots, independence movements all are going in India not in Muslim countries. What do you think? You said there are basic faults in Muslim teachings. I have already told you that fault may be in Muslims but not in Islamic teachings.

[dpsghuman]

@sajidicma ...Don't compare india with muslim nations where even basic security of life is under threat....it is a secular democracy of 64 years where every person is free to profess, practice or preach his religion ....there are no draconian blasphemy rules to target minorities....muslims have risen to the highest positions in every sphere and mostly live cordially with hindus and sikhs ...it is a superpower of asia and the whole world sees it with respect ..now copare it with ur IRP...

[sajidicma]

@dpsghuman Why should not I compare India with Muslim states. In Pakistan minorities have rights to practice their religion. The security risks in Pakistan and other Islamic states are due to involvement of agencies and international powers not due to religious riots. Every non Muslim can practice his religion in this country. And again for your kind information India is not the super power of Asia. Its China man!!!

[dpsghuman]

@sajidicma ...everybody knows the case of asiyan bibi, a christian sentenced to death for blasphemy and the killing of punjab governer salman taseer for voicing support for her and open support of his killer by muslim organisations ..of the killing of minorities minister mr. bhatti recently...both spoke of humanity and were silenced in pakistan....and ur minority population is negligible compared to india ...china dumped u in 1971 and again will..and it is not representative of chinese people

[sajidicma]

@dpsghuman Dear, we are discussing religion here, not politics. The space is not enough to discuss these matters in detail. But if one person does something wrong you cannot blame the whole community. What do you think about Bal Thakure? Should we think that all Indians have same thoughts? If this is the case than Indians are biggest extremists in the world.

[dpsghuman]

@sajidicma ...man your politics is inseparable from religion....they mutually coexist....the creation of ur nation itself was on religious parochial mindedness and the name islamic republic of pakistan is a testimonial to it...and bal thackrey is virtually admired as a villian in indian politics....and for every 100 muslim extremist one hindu extremist is there and it is a nature's rule...he was born &bred in hate like ur muslim scholars are breeding ur upcoming novice young generation..

[dpsghuman]

their are some basic faults in islamic teachings or the tutors and preachers and unless muslims admit this things are not going to change....just think why maximum violence is taking place in muslim nations globally ....there is some need of introspection??...if someone says this is wrong in my religion(sikhism) though i am not a hardine religious person i am more than happy to admit it and rectify it...no shame in accepting your weaknesses if u intend to move forward....

[sajidicma]

@dpsghuman My dear, India is the country with greatest number of yearly riots and I think its not a Muslim country. What do you think? Actually a Muslim can be wrong but Islam can't be wrong. There is not a single principle of Islam which is against humanity. The problem is that non Muslims have misconceptions about Islam. Due do improper knowledge and insufficient research they take Islam as a brutal religion. Brother please watch lecture of Dr. Naik on 'Misconceptions about Islam".

[dpsghuman]

@sajidicma ..what r u talking dear...maximum riots in india every year..hold on...it was way back in 2002 in gujrat and modi was thoroughly criticised by media and all sections of indian society...1450 people die in ethnic clashes in karachi streets in 2 months....have a look on shia- sunni clashes in islamic nations...afghanistan was ruled by terror before 2001..same with iraq, libya, muslims are killing muslims in syria, somalia...in 99% terror attacks a muslim is involved..just think...

[dpsghuman]

@sajidicma .dear while jesus was nailed to the cross , the persons who were nailing him were laughing and cracking jokes on jesus to which he said-- o god forgive them for they don't know what r they doing..that is why maximum christians are peace loving and forgiving..on the contrary while quran was being written by prophet muhaamad he was constantly engaged in warfare with musfiqs of mecca and so the violence on field transferred from battlefield to his book to islamic scholars to muslims

[sajidicma]

@dpsghuman My friend, do you know that Mecca was conquered without any single assassination. Prophet Muhammad PBUH forgave all his enemies who were thirsty of his blood. Now come to terrorism. Islam has no connection with terrorists who kill innocent people in the name of religion. If they are calling themselves Muslims... ask them, not me. International agencies and powers who are us are involved in worldwide disturbances who are using the name of Islam. Independent analysts would tell you.

[dpsghuman]

@sajidicma ...DON'T TALK CHILDISHLY blinded by religion...no war is conquered without assasinations....then why did prophet mohammad said wherever you find a kafir(non believer) kill him..why "kill" word came out of knowlege bestowed by the almighty...doesn't it promotes violence..where is the compassion reflected by jeasus christ towards his captors while he was nailed to cross in Islam..i know targeting a religion is not good but your islamic scholars like zakir have shown bad face of islam

[sajidicma]

@dpsghuman Now would you please tell me about any major Shia Sunni riot. I am living in Pakistan where both Shias and Sunnis are living and during my lifetime I never heard of any major Shia Sunni riot. Please stop this unsubstantiated propaganda.

[dpsghuman]

@sajidicma ...not long ago shia sunni clashes were a common news in reliable print and electronic media mostly affecting iraq, iran though lesser incidents were reported in pakistan..no major riots but skirmishes and simmering differences showing destructive power of religion and religious intolerance ..and i don't do propaganda as i am not associated with any religious group or organisation..

[sajidicma]

@dpsghuman Now you said Prophet Muhammad wrote Quran. For your kind information its a historical fact that Prophet was illiterate and could not read or write. Quran was a 'wahi' from God Almighty and the knowledge was bestowed on Prophet by the God almighty. This fact is sufficient to prove that Quran was not written by himself but it is the word of God. Listen to Dr. Naik's debate with Dr. William Campbell and with Shri Ravi Shankar.

[dpsghuman]

@sajidicma ..why are u only targeting barkha dutt..all the other guests on the talk show differed in their opinions on islamic life with those put up by zakir naik and all these guests were not picked from streets..they were muslims who had made a mark in the society and are socially more approved than him..and u fear allah..u call allah ho akbar while stoning young girls to death and while butchering or lynching someone in cold blood.....never have i heard or seen so much violence in god's name

[dpsghuman]

@sajidicma ..why are u only targeting barkha dutt..all the other guests on the talk show differed in their opinions on islamic life with those put up by zakir naik and all these guests were not picked from streets..they were muslims who had made a mark in the society and are socially more approved than him..and u fear allah..u call allah ho akbar while stoning young girls to death and while butchering or lynching someone in cold blood.....never have i heard or seen so much violence in god's name

[sajidicma]

@dpsghuman I am targeting Burkha because she was hosting the program and she gave lesser time to Dr. Naik as compared to others.

[sajidicma]

@dpsghuman Other guests, so called Muslims, were not religious scholars except Mufti saab. If you want to solve a mathematical equation, you should go to a mathematician and not to a doctor. So when you are talking about religion Shahrukh or others are not proper persons. They can present their own views. But Islam is not their homemade religion. We have to follow what is provided in Quran, Sunnah and those Hadiths which are agreed to be authenticated by most of the scholars. Hope u now undstnd

[dpsghuman]

@sajidicma ..even the killer of salman taseer of pakistan says he is serving islam and following it strictly..actually religion makes u blind and deaf to the feelings and sanctity of other religions and this is what dr. zakir naik is..i have listened to his innumerous videos on you tube..at first i thought he was a revolutionary muslim trying to break the shackles of fundamentalism and parochial mindedness but soon i realised that he was the same old thing with a different wrap....a hate monger

[sajidicma]

The audience of Peace Tv and Dr. Zakir Naik is much more than that of NDTV. Burkha Dutt is no match of Dr. Zakir Naik. I knew Dr. Naik for many years but I have seen Burkha a few days ago only because Dr. Naik participated in her programme. She is child before him.

[dpsghuman]

hahaha.....it is not easy to digest defeat and this especially for zakir who has a reputation of snubbing others on peace tv confrences....he was pounded by barkha and other members of his faith who have made great marks in the society and are examplary personalities ......abb gand main mircha lagg rahi hai.....sorry for using this language but this suits such a person.....YOUTH FOR RELIGIOUS EQUALITY...

[sajidicma]

@dpsghuman Very funny...Yes it is not easy to digest defeat. That's why Burkha had no courage to let Zakir Naik speak. She was afraid from such a great scholar. If she let him talk, Burkha and all others would have no answer. You morons have no logic but only abusive language to defend yourselves.

[dpsghuman]

@sajidicma ......she is a vibrant and confident professional journalist and was never afraid of zakir naik....fear is instilled in weak minds like yours that don't do this as allah will punish you....do this and allah will uplift you...it was hard to hear his nonsense babbles and not only burkha even others were cutting him short...if she was so fearful of him she would rather had avoided from hosting him...it was actually zakir naik who was feeling nervous and blown away...dont hide facts plz.

[dpsghuman]

@MrKolo070 ....no dear zakir naik was not silent rather he was silenced by not only the host but other guests on the show as well.....and for the mark twain comment it is a really great comment but you have applied it in the opposite direction....it applied to arguing with persons like zakir naik , bal thackrey, andy chaudary....

[liturkesh]

Why clarification of NDTV talk show is needed in first place?

[midenarifit]

@liturkesh y u came here to answer and y ndtv did that program?

[sajidicma]

@liturkesh Because he had no chance to speak and present his point of view. The audience of Peace tv is much greater than that of NDTV. If Burkha has all rights to conduct her pointless programme, then why Dr. Naik has no right to present his views.

[ragala3]

One can pick a chit - I agree

But one can also pre arrange the questioners(with a readymade question and interview to make it exceiting)

[shamimuhammed]

ZAKIR SAAB,WE ARE WITH YOU.YOU ARE ON A NOBLE CAUSE.WE PRAY FOR YOUR SUCCESS.

[dolytruth7]

Please watch youtube.com/watch?v=GXQBSAWSn_­g&feature=related

[gillani07511]

zakir naik must be killed by all muslims.he is a fitna

[TheCutebarbieslover]

@gillani07511 so you are the son of hindu

[gillani07511]

@TheCutebarbieslover no im hindu killer.

[TheCutebarbieslover]

@gillani07511 you are jealous retaded person if you didn,t have any knowlege then why blaming a good person a fitna , mind your language and , give a single proof that zakir is doing fitna, before opening your ass make some research. if i call your father a dijal or anti Christ without any reason that what you are talking about.

[gillani07511]

@TheCutebarbieslover he is a fitna against islam know nothing about quran or hadith but just know art of debate.but this doesnt make anyone in position to speak wrongfully against the hadith of prophet muhammad saw and what he said about Hazrat Imam Hussain RA and yazeed was just his own agreement.so whoever speaks for the sake of batil is a fitna for me and i will call him fitna inshallah.unless someone prove whtever he said was according to hadith of prophet SAW

[TheCutebarbieslover]

@gillani07511 ya may be that was his mistake but it dosen,t mean that you can blame him for every thing.

[gillani07511]

@TheCutebarbieslover im not blaming him for everything but what he did there was potrayed evil as a virtue.though i was a big fan of this guy because of his debating skills with non muslims.but whenever he says anything say it with justification but that day he didnt quote any hadith with reference.which was sufficient for me to disturb his image in mind.now i cant help it bro.that is why i said whatever u red earlier

[TheCutebarbieslover]

@TheCutebarbieslover his Urdu is weak thats why he said you think that he is favoring yazeed , impossible its not possible that you can agree with him on every point but thats the big word for him.

[shamimuhammed]

@gillani07511 if u have disagreement with Dr.zakir's view,u better ask him/ IRF for clarification of your doubts.they may be able to clarify.its too low to put down such a warior of Dawah.may allah help us do Dawa in the best way

[kwashie1000]

and what are u doing to ur zelf n for self ,

[shreesoft33]

This person whoever he is funny , see how he is foolling people by talking about I agree and do not agree, hahaha! I saw his NDTV show where he was backing up people who killed thousands of people all over the world and killed many in india He even said tht i am not sure whether OBLaden is a offendor or not ....mere muslim bhaiyion dont follow him!!

[zairt]

@shreesoft33 blah blah blah/////////////////

[hahahaha5794]

indianbadguy1980 seems to be a son of a slut bcoz such children don,t know who their father is similarly he does not know who has created him. he thinks he has come out of shit. hey man try to understand that there is someone who we need to report to at the judgement day.don't u understand a simple logic that behind any creation there is a creator,thus this world has been created by ALLAH since anything can't be created automatically.i request u to have faith in ALLAH.

[indianbadguy1980]

@hahahaha5794, your sick language reflects the teachings of your parents. Calling me son of a "slut" shows you are a friggen Qadiyani. You really enjoy sucking the dicks of Qadiyanis like Ghulam Mirza Ahmed etc. We do not need people like you or Zakir Naik who enjoys spreading terrorism in name of islam. So fuck you, I enjoy fucking your sisters each night.

[ariyent]

jazzak allah brother Zakir

[indianbadguy1980]

@zareenazam1, Zakir Naik is the biggest kafir and a fool as well. InshaAllah he will be banned from all over the world.

[kssson]

1 master and 1million lambs....

[shbs11]

@indianbadguy1980 muhammad is last prophet dont make people fool

[indianbadguy1980]

@shbs11 zakir naik claims he is better than muhummad so hence zakir naik is the final prophet of islam

[Saifhaider65]

@indianbadguy1980

PLZ DON'T USE THIS KNDA WORDS

[Saifhaider65]

@indianbadguy1980

PLZ DON'T USE THIS KNDA WORDS

HAVE U EVER TRIED TO LISTEN HIM OR TO EVEN TRIED THAT WAT IS RIT WOT Z WRONG

[indianbadguy1980]

@Saifhaider65, yes, Zakir Naik is wrong, and banning him from UK n Canada is right

[oink714]

Masha Allah the two brothers are doing an execellent job. and the relationship between them Subahan Allah, is amazing. i would be proud to have children like them. Insha Allah one day.

[iluvparixit]

so quaran matters only 7% and rest 93% depends on mr naik!!! LOL

[deena0syed]

for all those who say zakir naik shud not have defended himself ... this program is not 4 u ... it is for all those non believers & those who dont him well enough ...not every1 knows his opinions & havnt heard his complete lectures & the way he was portrayed in tht interview was very misleading ....

[erajkkhan]

i am not going to see the third part after these two...it is unbearable....Dr. Zakir was the last person, i expected this from....and like every mature person, i realized that the NDTV show was quite skewed and prejuidiced but why go out of the way to defend this argument....that is NOT mature

[erajkkhan]

i am quite surprised at this analysis...i mean i always respected Dr. Zakir for his good work but over here, he's just being defensive and nothing more...i mean, it wasn't the end of the world for him, he could have continued his work...but instead he decided to choose the sheer wastage of time and energy just to provide his argument...he seriously lost all his respect in my eyes after answering these pre-meditated questions, asked by Dr. Mohammad Naik...its so staged....

[Saifhaider65]

@erajkkhan

HE Z DA GR8EST SCHOLOR SO WE MUST RESPECT HIM OK !

THEIR Z RESION BEHIND IT

BUT I THINK U HAVENT GOT IT

IN NDTV SHOW THEIR Z MUCH MORE TO BE UNDERSTOOD

[indianbadguy1980]

@Saifhaider65, zakir naik is a kaffir and a Qadiyani, everything he learnt about other religions was a from a Qadiyani source, so hence zakir is the biggest fraud. Visit w w w . a g n i v e e r . c o m to know more about this fraud

[hahahaha5794]

@indianbadguy1980 i suspect u being muslim. b'coz in islam it is prohibited to call some kafir, be it hindu or christian or of any other riligion. plz do research about islam before saying something.may allah show u the right way.

[shazmatica]

lol he got owned in 'we the people' so he had to resort to such desperate measure for some damage control so as to not lose his fan base!

[dinoraul119]

@shazmatica

oh yeah

have u seen that show??...giving karan johar more oppurtunity to speak than zakir naik is a thing enough to show the biased nature of that useless journalist barkha dutt

[dinoraul119]

@cardian5

fuck u

[cardian5]

@dinoraul119

Same to you cut piece

[86mimz]

@cardian5 and u r one of them :D !!! hahahaha...if u hate him this much why did u bother to watch it ...jerk....!!! grow up !

[cardian5]

@86mimz :D i dont hate him.. i find him extremely entertaining.... like a JOKER :)

[86mimz]

@cardian5 and you r on of them :D hahahaha ...if u hate him this much why did u bother to click it...!!! jerk...get a life grow up...!!! nobody is interested abt what u think or say..!!!

[sohailsem]

@cardian5

sajay dut has done something wrong with your family thats y u r missing khal naik

[cardian5]

@sohailsem why you are getting so angry?? :) is this Joker your father? looks like he is.... you have a good sense of humor.. i must say...keep it up

[sajidicma]

@cardian5 No he is your father and father of all your Gurus and pandits. Check your family tree and you will find him. You nonsense people can only make fun of great scholars because you morons have no knowlege of your own religion even.

[cardian5]

@sajidicma I like your sense of humor, LOL, but atleast now I know why I wonder you sound so much like this joker with your comments.... He can only be a scholar for a low-life like you.. for majority of the world I am sure he is not, and he can not be...ever, with the way he talks about other religions. Religion is manmade, and there is only one GOD/CREATOR, all human beings are equal, we should respect life in general, not religious fanatics. I will pray for you and joker's wellbeing!

[sajidicma]

@cardian5 For you kind information Dr. Naik is a scholar for millions of people worldwide. You don't know viewer ship of peace tv. You are calling me a low-mind person. Let me tell you I am a qualified Cost and Management Accountant and a highly educated person. Your comment shows your low mentality. Some stupid has told you that religion is man made. My dear, religion is from God almighty. It cannot be man made. Religious scriptures are the source of religion and not personal views.

[sajidicma]

@cardian5 I agree that there is one creator and human beings are equal in respect of humanity but rest of the comment shows your low mentality, not mine.

[usrytube]

Zakir Naik always shows humility and respect while clarifying opposing views of any kind of audience. May Allah swt bless him and his family and reward him for all his sincere efforts towards the cause of islam.

[nafsar100]

@PhantomSoldier9999

perhaps you would like to enlighten us about few of dr naik's 'illogical' arguments.

you will not find any because whenever makes a point he makes sure that he backs it up with appropriate evidence .

peace

[PhantomSoldier9999]

Yes, Barkha Dutt ain't a good host, but Dr. Zakir Naik delivers a load of baloney! He's a propagandist with highly illogical arguments and theories which his fanatical audience blindly accept.

[aysha003]

@PhantomSoldier9999 i don't believe that he always backs his answers up with hadith quotes and sections from the qur'an he makes sure he always does..i never seen a talk which he gave with out backing his words up with out hadith quotes and qur'anic quotes

[Destroyticus]

@PhantomSoldier9999 Like such as? Describe for me please, for I am such a fool that I blindly follow even tho it is clearly status in my religion that evidence comes before fate^^ All you can do is to insult, say bad things, or just plain being negative, without really knowing what the heck you're babbling about^^ Why would anyone even care to read what you're typing? Come with evidence please, haha that came from me, as you know I only follow blindly hahaha^^

[sgtsbre]

@PhantomSoldier9999 The first mistake you made was use the word baloney. Nobody will even stand to consider what you have to say when you use such elementary grammar. The the second do you have any evidence of this? I and a am sure all these other people here would be delighted to witness your such called "baloney." ;P

[yasir0ahmed]

thanks for these videos jazakallah khair

[tareeqmadikeri]

Salam Brothers/sisters,

I am eagerly waiting to see the video of Dr. Naiks programme which was held in Dubai in 2010. Can anybody clarify if the video was done or not! Thanks...