Is it just me or does Roger come over more arrogant and less proffesional than Dave.Maybe that was and is the problem as to why the band don't tour together anymore.Dave still sings well here though Roger is weak.
Thank you Micky Meat. I have your four videos set up as my favorite playlist. Did you notice they didn't show Richard Wright until the end? I think it was just ignorance on the part of the director, unaware that that wonderfully talented keyboardist was part of the band.
this is one of the best Pink Floyd performances not only for the amazing song they choosed (the best of all) but for the meaning of this little reunion.
HOWEVER the PULSE version of Comfortably Numb is the BEST INTERPRETATION EVER even above the original version. Who knows what possessed Gilmour that time because that IS the best solo of all time.
I agree but somethings must've possessed sir Gilmour again because Remember that Night was amazing probably even better than Pulse, and i mean both of his renditions of it (w/ bowie, and with Wright).
One of the greatest moments in rock and roll and it just happened a couple of years ago! This is a most breathtaking performance. David Gilmore is marvelous.
it took the 4 of them, or at least waters and gilmour to make the songs great, pink floyd didnt do as well w/o waters, but look at the crap he's writen ever since
Aside from the tesnion that seems to still exist with Waters and Gilmour, you can definately tell that Gilmour loved doing this song again, you can see it in his playing and in his face. I dont care what people think or say about it all, When you are up there on stage and playing those songs, tension and disputes leave you, and just for a few moments even if they were the last moments, Pink floyd with 4 of them again sounded acted and felt like what they once were. They ARE the Best, ever.
Absolutle stunning. I saw Waters live in Vancouver and he was equall if not even better than this. Without Waters, these guys are nothing. Great song.
Love the way after completely tearing that solo to kingdom come David Gilmour says, 'Thanks very much good night' as if he'd just finished his last pint at the pub before going home!
Gilmour, Wright, and Mason for life!! they sound just as good without waters, sometimes even better without him. hahahaha he is just too full of himself
If roger waters wasnt around then there would not be a pink floyd, and they would not play theese 4 great songs. Pink Floyd isnt the same without the true hero Roger Waters, but they are great that's for sure.
he's full of himself becuase he wrote everything. if waters wasn't in the band then you coudl say goodbye to the entire wall album. you'd basically have the division bell.
I love this band and I loved this performance the only thing that annoyed me a little butfrom a bass players perspective is roger waters playing or in sencond verse lack of playing at times, mibbee being caught up in the monent but it flattened the verse a little, made up for it in the final solo though
Lol... gotta love the faces on the crowd. I bet truckloads of them were there waiting to see Mariah Carey or Robbie Williams, and when they saw this they suddenly felt they might have just been mistaken for their entire lives... lol. Learn the truth folks. This is music.
It was a Great Idea to put all members of PINK FLOYD sing and play together after so many years ot separation and bitter feelings. David is wonderful as allways!!!
Why must people sing along..Shut up and watch the band. Especially since this particular lineup hasent played together in years. Save the singing for your cars people!!!I would expect more out of europeans.
While this was a very emotional moment for all Floyd fans yonger and older, I can't imagine what it was like for them. After what they have all been through, seeing them together, let alone sharing a stage playing some of thier best tunes, is amazing.
We build up walls for ourselves through our lives...only to break them down...and come up behind us again...
m22frogger 2 months ago
7:34. No words needed.
cdorresteijn 10 months ago
It looks like the video team never knew the Floyd was a 4-piece band, not a 3. Lousy video, but thanks for the post.
LashBridges 1 year ago
The best guitar solo of all time.
firekip69 1 year ago
Roger is so into it during the second solo, actually they all are... They are just gods
dylantoniazzi 1 year ago
in years to come this will be classical music rated along side mozart et al
treacles2 1 year ago
Is it just me or does Roger come over more arrogant and less proffesional than Dave.Maybe that was and is the problem as to why the band don't tour together anymore.Dave still sings well here though Roger is weak.
KGMDMusic 1 year ago
la mejor, simplemente brillante, magia pura!!!!
floyd (L)
ViciousS23 2 years ago
dios!
marugong 2 years ago
This Song Makes Me Cry
Remember When... They Were Pink Floyd
Yesterday2294 2 years ago
They were simply well ahead of their time.
You just cant put a time frame, or era on their music.
They did pioneer a new and deep frontier.
Theyre the Beethoven of Pink Floydenian music.
I not only love them, but I equally and deeply respect and admire them.
I just thank them for their contributions to music.
nononsensegeorge 2 years ago
@nononsensegeorge well said
txfirehawk 1 year ago
The best fucking song of all time!
MrBluesboy21 2 years ago 10
Thank you Micky Meat. I have your four videos set up as my favorite playlist. Did you notice they didn't show Richard Wright until the end? I think it was just ignorance on the part of the director, unaware that that wonderfully talented keyboardist was part of the band.
oliverpolland 2 years ago
Excelente, simplemente Excelente!
Moanku 3 years ago
the second solo makes my cry is so feeling
aggguy666 3 years ago
The magic here is the presence of the genius - Roger Waters.
rockaires 3 years ago
RIP Richard Wright
shparker 3 years ago 8
i live an a pink floyd fan dies a pink floyd fan
Falenas 3 years ago
They rock as much as they did in the 60s-80s. Pink Floyd will never die and will be in the hearts of us all.
branflakes442 3 years ago 3
omg i looked for this before but i couldnt
find it and its been here for two years!!
And i was also told that roger wasnt there!!
Man the bull ppl spread!!
This was amazing!! Does anyone know if the
whole concert is on here in parts??
paulusmagirl 3 years ago
Do a search for Pink Floyd Live 8. The Pink Floyd set was:
Breathe
Wish You Were Here
Money
Comfortably Numb
nikoldg 3 years ago
WOW since a last time back together with a perfect song.. awesome
ZUMWAN 3 years ago
the cause dwarfs their petty differences.
okrabay 3 years ago
one of the best moments in history of live music
kubaosina 3 years ago 4
love this track ive got good memories listning to this one
nelltoot 3 years ago
Rogers doesn't look at Gilmour once; instead he tries to draw as much attention to himself onstage as possible. God, what an asshole.
diem4nn 4 years ago
Nah man - it was a big experience for him - you must've seen him at the beginning of WYWH - he was just enjoying playing with the others again.
beanolabub 3 years ago 2
this is one of the best Pink Floyd performances not only for the amazing song they choosed (the best of all) but for the meaning of this little reunion.
HOWEVER the PULSE version of Comfortably Numb is the BEST INTERPRETATION EVER even above the original version. Who knows what possessed Gilmour that time because that IS the best solo of all time.
espaunfromgel 4 years ago
I agree but somethings must've possessed sir Gilmour again because Remember that Night was amazing probably even better than Pulse, and i mean both of his renditions of it (w/ bowie, and with Wright).
I7arkSideofTheMoon 4 years ago
rogers lost his voice but tis still the best performance
PinkFLoydrulzs 4 years ago
I hope i've been named by thís David! Most beautiful song ever heard in the best performance ever seen!
DoItAgainDave 4 years ago
2nd that,
That solo brang a tear to my eye.
One of the best solos i have EVER heard,
def top 5.
Im going straight to the learning pad!!!
kalim2007 4 years ago
considered the 2nd best guitar solo ever
kboydude 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Shit sux.
darksagerk 4 years ago
ur fuckign gay...dont post that if u dotn likei t
PinkFLoydrulzs 4 years ago
immortale
koanflyer 4 years ago
I am just amazed at how well David Gilmour's voice has held up. He is amazing! Meanwhile, it's almost as if Rick wasn't even there!
sistermorphine17 4 years ago
Yeah, I noticed that... they rarely ever cut to a shot of Rick.
cushlinkes 4 years ago
yea that was bullshit every member dezerves reconition he probably felt like shit when he watched that idk i jus feel bad for him
TheDoorsRule4Ever 3 years ago
One of the greatest moments in rock and roll and it just happened a couple of years ago! This is a most breathtaking performance. David Gilmore is marvelous.
sparkler007 4 years ago
David Gilmour is Pink Floyd.
Fibostop 4 years ago
no my friend...
David Gilmour, Roger Waters, Syd Barrett, Rick Wright & Nick Mason is The Pink Floyd Sound
natoblokesur 4 years ago 4
Did Gilmour wrote the lyrics of all PF songs between 1972-1983, Fibostop? And most of the music? Read a little before giving an opinion.
rockaires 3 years ago
it took the 4 of them, or at least waters and gilmour to make the songs great, pink floyd didnt do as well w/o waters, but look at the crap he's writen ever since
Robrambler 3 years ago
I love this tune so much sends the shivers going lyrics are out of this world not much else to say about it really but immense
angelbj 4 years ago
Aside from the tesnion that seems to still exist with Waters and Gilmour, you can definately tell that Gilmour loved doing this song again, you can see it in his playing and in his face. I dont care what people think or say about it all, When you are up there on stage and playing those songs, tension and disputes leave you, and just for a few moments even if they were the last moments, Pink floyd with 4 of them again sounded acted and felt like what they once were. They ARE the Best, ever.
PaiLung 4 years ago 3
Absolutle stunning. I saw Waters live in Vancouver and he was equall if not even better than this. Without Waters, these guys are nothing. Great song.
danriksedin 4 years ago
jajajajajajajajajaja equall or better ? jajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajaja
pleynax 4 years ago
Who will create that solo? Can the Water's guest musicians create it? Only imitate it.
Without Gilmour this song wouldn't have any sense.
jorkanmx 3 years ago
Obviously one of the best songs ever from one of the greatest bands ever.
chazzwozer 4 years ago
Love the way after completely tearing that solo to kingdom come David Gilmour says, 'Thanks very much good night' as if he'd just finished his last pint at the pub before going home!
fbgd 4 years ago
gilmore is quite clearly the greatest guitarist ever
noelwannabe 4 years ago
yer i was at earls court on friday the show was wicked wasent it! did you see the flying spaceman
koolclara 4 years ago
glad to see them all together again!
Gilmour, Wright, and Mason for life!! they sound just as good without waters, sometimes even better without him. hahahaha he is just too full of himself
spazman622 4 years ago
What the fuck are you talking about???
If roger waters wasnt around then there would not be a pink floyd, and they would not play theese 4 great songs. Pink Floyd isnt the same without the true hero Roger Waters, but they are great that's for sure.
LeifJohan 4 years ago
he's full of himself becuase he wrote everything. if waters wasn't in the band then you coudl say goodbye to the entire wall album. you'd basically have the division bell.
benerack 4 years ago
What exactly is said division bell
dimebagonbass 4 years ago
i wish theyd just tour already!
profjohnfrinks 5 years ago
he is the legend...great!!!
swaroopmc 5 years ago
good stuff
nocondition 5 years ago
I love this band and I loved this performance the only thing that annoyed me a little butfrom a bass players perspective is roger waters playing or in sencond verse lack of playing at times, mibbee being caught up in the monent but it flattened the verse a little, made up for it in the final solo though
airdrieboy1984 5 years ago
Lol... gotta love the faces on the crowd. I bet truckloads of them were there waiting to see Mariah Carey or Robbie Williams, and when they saw this they suddenly felt they might have just been mistaken for their entire lives... lol. Learn the truth folks. This is music.
G4br1ch 5 years ago 4
Amen to that!
flymogram 5 years ago
fuck that solo gives me the chills every time... well pretty much every Gilmour solo gives me the chill haha
glamrockchick92 5 years ago
Yeah but nothing ever beats the solo on Comfortably Numb. It's just something else.
G4br1ch 5 years ago
It was a Great Idea to put all members of PINK FLOYD sing and play together after so many years ot separation and bitter feelings. David is wonderful as allways!!!
nadini2001 5 years ago
er, syd?
Spooksie 4 years ago
Syd's gone. That's too bad, but that's the way it is. May he rest soundly.
CTOConnor 4 years ago
I've heard Roger Waters essentially blew his voice out doing all the screaming in The Wall. Still, it's a wonderful concert.
Bigstan2000 5 years ago
Why must people sing along..Shut up and watch the band. Especially since this particular lineup hasent played together in years. Save the singing for your cars people!!!I would expect more out of europeans.
ehronaragon 5 years ago
It's called enjoying the concert. Save the mindless idiocy for yourself. Would expect more from North Americans...
jamiethelanky 5 years ago
awesome
barman1176 5 years ago
demasiado arrecho, provoca demasiados sentimientos, uno no sabe si llorar o reir, tremendo video, y muy bien escogido para la causa del Live 8
jleonardo 5 years ago
While this was a very emotional moment for all Floyd fans yonger and older, I can't imagine what it was like for them. After what they have all been through, seeing them together, let alone sharing a stage playing some of thier best tunes, is amazing.
Bane2100 5 years ago
THEY WERE GREAT!!! I HOPE TO GOD THAT THEY START A TOUR TOGETHER!
trickye999 5 years ago
Nice of everyone else to warm up for the Pink Floyd reunion gig!!!
fbgd 5 years ago
yyyyyyyeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaaah, at last, the best!!
astrape 5 years ago
simply amazing
TheLatnSensation 5 years ago
I love this song so much.
CVargas 5 years ago