Added: 4 years ago
From: seekfortruth
Views: 4,523
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (288)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • islam is pure evil, the muslim is the follower of islam. Satan is allah, this is so obvious. mulsims follow satan. Hate the sin, not the sinner, pray that the sinner be delivered from this great evil.

  • @GTCism As you can see, I have already replied to all of those who had commnets similar to yours, and I assure you that your claims are nothing but falsehood. I invite you to learn about Islam from its sources, not from false propaganda. How can Islam be from satan and its holy book the Quran says: "God commands justice, the doing of good, and liberality to kith and kin, and he forbids all shameful deeds, and injustice and rebellion: he instructs you, that you may receive admonition." [16:90]

  • Islam is evil ideology, you should leave Islam and save your humanity!

  • @rikkyb84 I assure you that you're under the influence of false propaganda against Islam and I invite you to discuss those claims of yours so you may see, based on objective and rational evidences, that such claims are nothing but falsehood, you're welcome for an open discussion, anytime. God says in the Qur'an: "We sent you not, but as a Mercy for all creatures." (Surah 21, verse 107)

  • Islam is just another evil in this world. As bad as catholicism.

  • @ActsChurchFire Hi, I truly believe that you and all of those who may agree with you are influenced by the distorted image that is depicted by some tv channels, movies, and actions of some Muslims who don't really represent Islam. I would like to have a dialog with you in which we may discuss all the misconceptions that you have about Islam, and I will answer you based on evidence from both the scriptures and historical facts. Waiting for your reply so we may have a civilized dialog. Take care.

  • @MrChickybee1 Quit launching your false claims and try to learn the truth about Islam with an open mind. I'm ready for dialog, only when you are!

  • this guy is a disgrace to humanity, everyone wants democracy.......everyone wants "rule for the people by the people". no one wants to be ruled by old fashioned desert stories (islam, or any religion for that matter). speak for yourself scum, not for all muslims. I was born muslim and don't feel this way about the world. if you don't like the west, you should not come to this democratic nation. GO HOME!!!

  • @ahmad18ny I am the guy in that video, Sary Farah. Democracy and self rule are only illusions that modern governments use to control the masses! Even when people rule themselves, they don't necessarily make the right choices, and there are many examples about that... You said that you're an ex-Muslim, I bet that you know almost nothing about Islam, or you only know the distorted image that is depicted by Muslim haters, or please prove me wrong. If you really knew Islam, you'll agree with me...

  • @seekfortruth greetings to you.  You, like most muslims, are not a bad person. I would put it differently, your a brainwashed person. When I was muslim I read a lot of Quran, hadith (not only bokhari/muslim but tirmidhi and many others). An in depth review of any religion will show you poorly constructed logic and flaws left and right. the only way you will enlighten yourself is by stepping aside from all this islamic dogma, and really honestly studying science...specifically the evolution.

  • @ahmad18ny Some progress... from "a disgrace to humanity" to "not a bad person". That's a good start! It is such a silly claim when you say that someone is brainwashed! How does brainwash occur? What is the process? I'm an educated person, a teacher of psychology and a school counselor. I studied in a university in Beirut that teaches the American curriculum. I was raised in a secular environment, studied at a catholic school, during my teenage years I was into leftist movements... tbc

  • @ahmad18ny ... then while studying philosophy I was inetersted in religion, so I read and investigated until I was convinced that Islam is the true religion of God. The evidences that Islam puts forth are rational and objective ones, there's no room for blind faith. I'm ready to try answering your reasons behind leaving Islam one by one, and I hope that you watched my lecture: What is the evidence for Islam?

    Take care

  • @ahmad18ny And by the way, this was in a studio in Beirut, where the CNN where doing a special program called "Eye on the Middle East", it wasn't shot in the US or Europe!

    If you claim that Islam is "outdated" because it is revealed in the 7th century, then democracy is far more outdated: from the 3rd century B.C. in Greece!!!

    It's not the time that matters, what matters is that Islam is revealed by God to manking, and since God is transcendent and omniscient, then it is suitable for all ages!

  • Qur'an 9:29 Fight those who believe not in God nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which has been forbidden by God and His Apostle, nor acknowledge the religion of truth, [even if they are] of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizyah with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued.

  • @giosia03 Let me clarify this verse for you:

    Fighting is against the fighters only:

    Fight in the cause of God those who fight you, but do not transgress limits; for God loveth not transgressors. Quran 2: 190

    Muslims are asked to have the best relations with peaceful non-Muslims:

    God forbids you not, with regard to those who fight you not for (your) Faith nor drive you out of your homes, from dealing kindly and justly with them: for God loveth those who are just. Quran 60: 8

  • @giosia03 And as for Jizyah, it is a tax paid for protection, and Muslims pay more as Zakat every year, so it is not non-Muslims only paying, and Non-Muslims in return will be exempted from military service and only capable men pay it while women, children and elderly and poor people as well don't pay it.

  • HMMM Iran also thought islam was a solution to its problems, now women are stoned, gays hung, and other cultures called decadent and told they will be destroyed, nope we don't need islam, I'm happy enough the way I am.

  • @thecelticwarlord Iran isn't genuinely implementing Islam since it is a nationalistic and denominational state and more like a dictatorship, and Islam encourages the accountability of rulers. Is that all you know about Islam? Its capital punishment? That's not fair, you should know Islam better before judging it based on hearsay or some of its rules! Hope we can resume this discussion in a civilized manner.

    Take care

  • @seekfortruth Yes indeed but the people in the crowds attending stonings, they are not in the monority mate now are they? they are in the dozens, even hundreds. ?Strange to see that wherever islam goes corrupt tinpot tyrants just happen to pop up. But though I know less about Iran, it is Sudan that shocks me, I come from a military background with friends in the army, returning from peacekeeping in Chad where millions are fleeing to because of muslim government in Khartoum causing genocide.

  • @thecelticwarlord My dear friend, the problem is you're not (and not only you but many people as well) distinguishing Islam from Muslims, simply because you don't know much about Islam. Sudan is not ruled by what could be referred to as a genuine Islamic law. Islam was falsely associated with tyranny and dictatorship, while in reality Islamic teachings condemn such acts: prophet Muhammad said: "The best jihad is a word of haqq (truth) to an unjust ruler.."

  • @thecelticwarlord In another hadith: "The master of the martyrs is Hamzah ibn Abdil Muttalib and a man who stood up to an unjust ruler, commanded him (to do the good and refrain from evil) and so he (the ruler) killed him.“

    This is the most profound form of expression: urging the endurance of harm to the point of death, in accounting the rulers and struggling against the tyrant rulers.

  • @thecelticwarlord The prophet Muhammad also said: “Any man whom Allah has given the authority of ruling some people and he does not look after them in an honest manner, will never feel even the smell of Paradise.” and "If any ruler having the authority to rule Muslim subjects dies while he is deceiving them, Allah will forbid Paradise for him.” You see our problem as Muslims is those evil Muslims who do bad stuff and then their evildoings are labelled "Islamic".

    Take care

  • @seekfortruth Thing is, I must also give praise to those who fight the Iranian government and protest at its huge mass of public executions, if more muslims concentrated on making their own countries better places instead of spreading their religion everywhere around the world by any means, then it would not be ridiculed by cartoons etc peace on earth could be achieved, if only muslims adopted a more tolerant approach, people will tolerate you if you do likewise to them.

    Peace.

  • @thecelticwarlord We must do both: internal reform and spreading religion peacefully through dialog and civilized invitation as God told us: " Invite (all) to the way of thy Lord with wisdom and beautiful preaching; and argue with them in ways that are best and most gracious: for thy Lord knoweth best, who have strayed from his path, and who receive guidance." Qur'an 16: 125

    Most of us Muslim reformers are practicing Muslims and pious people but we are persecuted and imprisonned by governments.

  • @thecelticwarlord As for tolerance: Islam promotes tolerance and coexistence, as the Islamic civilization introduced tolerance during Middle Ages when the Catholic Church was persecuting even other Christians who follow diffirent denominations. This is not an empty claim, it is what many Western historians had testified: For example Edward Gibbon stated that non-Muslims, especially the Jews and Christians were entitled to the freedom of conscience and religious worship...

  • @seekfortruth yes we did our share of bloodshed in the middle ages, its very true, but do you see the catholic church encouraging us to hang muslims or burn them at the stake in modern times, no. the past is the past, and we have learned from it.

  • I would like to have this explained. What would make one not want democracy? what would be the Islamic alternative? BTW - Thank you for your open mindedness and the ability to talk to one like me who does not share the faith. I'm a student of life and the majority of the time you can't get any info from the people who fallow a belief system... just rash claims toward an alternative view (mine).

  • If you watch my other video under "video responses" to this video you will understand more what I said on CNN. In biref, what I wanted to say is that I don't believe in the imported US democracy especially because of the corrupted US foreign policy which is driven by greed and imperialism. I believe in an Islamic system which can provide justice prosperity and a decent life for all: Muslims and non-Muslims alike. The way I'm talking to you I learned it from Islam: the civilized way of life. tbc

  • I believe in civilized dialogs without prejudice, without shouting and hatred and bashing. This is how we can get to live together in one world when we understand one another and this is only possible through civilized dialogs. I would never force you to believe in anything against your will, you are free, I can only invite you and answer your questions. I always work on promoting such dialogs wherever I go, because this is the true way to peace in our world. We'll talk later, take care.

  • That's another problem I have with religions. Why are we so ashamed of our own desires? Why, if God, so perfect in every way, create a perfect universe, perfect physics, perfect just about EVERYTHING, created us are we are so imperfect. Why do we have to reject our feelings and wants. I can't say all of our feelings need to be acted upon, but why would you want them not to be a part of who you are?

  • A good point that I will answer before I leave: there are two extreme viewpoints: repressing human desires and freely satiating those desires. Islam is moderate concerning this issue: it doesn't teach to deny human desires, instead it teaches how to regulate those desires and how to satisfy them in a way that won't cause harm to one's self or the society. Our imperfection is the main element of our test and is related to our free will. We can choose between good and bad yet we're responsible...

  • ... And our accountability is based on our choices that we made in our lives. For example: If one was a president he can be just or unjust, he could abuse his authority or use it to help people. We can resume our discussion later through private youtube account messages if you like.

    Take care and best wishes

  • I don't disregard it because it's ancient. Like I said, I have access to ALL of their information AND hundreds and hundreds of years more. as far as revelation from God... well, that's a matter of faith and (1) I don't share your faith and (2) I do not think you have to be special for god to speak to you (if god would/can/exists). Why would he create so many beings and only talk to a few? It's false. This, like I said, turns you into a follower believing you r not good enough/special.

  • Even if you have access to all of the information of the past, this doesn't make you superior to them!

    1) Blind faith is no faith: true religion is based upon reason and that is what Islam teaches. I am ready to discuss with you the rational and objective evidences of Islam.

    2) About the existence of God that requires another discussion, and that is easy to explain.

    If God has willed He would've directly revealed to each individual, but God wants people to choose faith and not to force them

  • All you need is to be a truthseeker, to investigade on God and religion before taking a certain direction and making a certain opinion. Why do you need to do so? Simply because it's worth it, ask yourself: what if its true that this is the purpose of life? What if there is an afterlife? What if I am accountable for all that I said and did in this life? What if this life ain't absurd it has a meaning and that the one who created it has revealed that meaning to us? Just think and we'll talk later.

  • to answer you question. I don't need some person from a long time ago telling me what life means or how to live. I have access to more information in one day than most could attain in a decent stretch of years back then. This means, I am more able to draw my own conclusions than one could so may years ago. I'll lead my own way not follow someone else.

  • Ancient ideas are not necessarily outdated. If you disconnect yourself from the past your future will be far from prosperous. Rejecting a certain set of principles just because they were said long ago is quite superficial. Engineers are still using principles set by ancient Greek and Arab mathematicians. The same applies to many fields of knowledge. Even if you are living in "modernity" you can never by yourself know what the prophets knew because they received revelation from God...

  • ... Instead of simply rejecting faith because of its "ancient" source, you need to study it and examine it, in order to see whether or not it provides evidences for its veracity. I hope that one day you will come to realize the truth that will set you free from the chains of your own desires, by providing you with a reasonable and practical worldview that comes from God the Creator, the Most Merciful. All the best and will try my best to explain, no hard feelings, just a civilized conversation.

  • All religions claiming to be the one true way of a make believe god need to be forgotten. That will solve the worlds problems.

  • I think that your comment stems from thinking that religion is the main cause behind world conflicts. There are many wars and struggles which have happened without any religious influence. Religious conflicts happen IN THE NAME of religion and not BECAUSE of religion. Islam doesn't just claim to be the true religion, nor does it deny the origins of other faiths, all the prophets (Abraham, Moses, Jesus..) are respected in Islam. Islam provides ample evidences for its veracity. We can discuss this

  • Islam is the sollution ? More lik the cause of the problems

  • Well that's what you and many people think, but that is not true. If you study Islam, you will know what I mean. I am ready to discuss this with you and show you that Islam is not what some bad Muslims do, it is a great religion revealed by God, and this can be proven. You will also realize that Islam provides practical solution for our problems and that Muslims and non-Muslims alike can prosper under Islamic rule, if applied correctly. Waiting for your reply.

  • How do non-muslims prosper under Muslim rule. Christians get killed for no reason all the time in muslim lands. you can build any non muslim church, temple under shariah. You can only pray in private. You have to pay a special tax. As an atheist i would be killed.

    There is no universal solution to everything.

  • Hi there, I can clearly see that you are misinformed. Islamic law guarantees protection for all non-Muslim citizens who may choose to coexist, and there is a lot of evidence for that. The Islamic history gives a lot of evidence for that, especially when Islam was rightly practiced and applied. Many non-Muslim thinkers and historians confirm what I just mentioned (Sir Thomas Arnold, Gustave Lebon, Gibbon and Oakley, George Bernard Shaw, Will Durant...) Islam guarantees Freedom of religion for all

  • ... Non-Muslims can have their own places of worship (Churches...) and their lives are protected: Prophet Muhammad said: Those who commit an act of oppression against a member of the non-Muslims, who usurp his rights, who make any demand upon him which is beyond his capacity to fulfill, or who forcibly obtain anything from him against his will, I will be his (the oppressed) advocate on the Day of Judgment

    Under Islamic law Muslims as well as non-Muslims paye taxes like any other country.

  • Here are some quotes by Western historians on Islamic tolerance: 'The tolerance of Muhammad towards the Jews and Christians was truly grand; the founders of other religions that appeared before him, Judaism and Christianity in particular, did not prescribe such goodwill. His caliphs followed the same policy, and his tolerance has been acknowledged by skeptics and believers alike when they study the history of the Arabs in depth.'

    [Gustave Lebon, Arab Civilization, p. 128]

  • 'We never heard of a report of any planned attempt to compel non-Muslim minorities to accept Islam, or any organized persecution aimed at uprooting the Christian religion. If any of the caliphs had chosen any of these policies, they would have overwhelmed Christianity with the same ease with which Ferdinand and Isabella exiled Islam from Spain, or with which Louis XIV made following Protestantism a punishable crime in France, or with which the Jews were exiled from England for 350 years... tbc

  • ... At that time Eastern churches were completely isolated from the rest of the Christian world. They had no supporters in the world as they were considered heretical sects of Christianity. Their very existence to this day is the strongest evidence of the policy of Islamic government's tolerance towards them.'

    [Sir Thomas Arnold, Invitation To Islam, p. 79 80] Last but not least, It would be quite pessimistic to say that there is no universal solution to everything, we'll chat later. Peace

  • Eastern churches were never completely isolated from the west. It was the eastern churches who called the west to engage in what would be later known as the crusades!

  • Again it seems that you are misinformed my friend. When crusaders arrived, the killed Christians and Jews who lived along with the Muslims, and not only Muslims. Read this fact from the encyclopedia: "The Crusades were fought mainly against Muslims, although campaigns were also waged against pagan Slavs, pagan Balts, Jews, Russian and Greek Orthodox Christians, Mongols, Cathars, Hussites, Waldensians, Old Prussians, and political enemies of the popes." Muslims and Christians peacefully coexisted

  • Will Durrant says in his The Story of Civilisation: "the Muslims offered a degree of toleration hardly equated in contemporary Christian lands. They were allowed the free practice of their faiths, and the retention of their churches... and received the protection of the government... they were allowed self-government under their own leaders, judges and laws. Christian heretics persecuted by the patriarchs of Constantinople, Jerusalem, Alexandria, or Antioch were now free and safe"Vol.4 p.218-219

  • Gustave Lebon said: From the verses of the Qur'an we can see that Muhammad's tolerance towards Jews and Christians was truly very great. None of the founders of the religions which appeared before his time, especially Judaism and Christianity, has spoken or acted in this manner. Then we saw how his caliphs followed his traditions. This tolerance has been recognized by some European scholars who have deeply contemplated Arab history. (Gustave Lebon, Arab Civilisation, p. 128)

  • Robertson says in his book The History of Charles V that Muslims are the only people who possess a zeal for their faith as well as a spirit of tolerance toward the followers of other religions... they leave those who do not know their religion (Islam) free to adhere to their own religious teachings.

  • Patriarch Ghaytho wrote: The Arabs, to whom the Lord has given control over the world, treat us as you know; they are not the enemies of Christians. Indeed, they praise our community, and treat our priests and saints with dignity, and offer aid to churches and monasteries. (Arthur Stanley Tritton, The People Of The Covenant In Islam, p. 158) You see my friend, you presented only claims I replied to you with facts and evidences to show you that even Western Historians witnessed Islamic tolerance

  • Religion is designed to lock people's brain inside a box, thus creating a follower and destroying a free spirit and thinker. If you put faith in one book, you can't test your own belief system and in most cases are not allowed to by the very nature of what it teaches. Secondly, It's just false that one could know what happens after death and think that there is punishment for seeing things differently. Religion = bondage. you just can't see the chains your in. you call them truths.

  • That is your perspective on religion and it may be true as a description for false religions. But let me ask you some questions: what if a religion gives you proofs and evidences for its veracity? What if a religion would tell you that you are not to follow blindly any one and that there are no clergy men and religious people are not infallible. How would you know about the purpose of life? The meaning of existence? And what is going to happen to you after death? Just think about it and reply

  • On being a free thinker: In order to think you need to feed your mind with information and you certainly need information about things that are beyond human minds to answer. Such information is provided by religion, and I personally was anti-religious because I had ideas like yours and I misunderstood religion. After deep studies I found out that Islam is a reasonable faith which respects the human mind and explains the wisdom behind its teachings. Islam provide seat belts for safety, not chains

  • [Q 3:59] In fact, the example of the birth of Isa ( Jesus) in the sight of Allah is like the example of Adam who had no father and mother, whom He created out of dust, then said to him: Be and he was. (dust in the original Arabic text: Turab which is more accurately the soil of the earth, as it is also in Judaism and Christianity, Check the Bible)

    [Q 19:67] Does not man remember that We created him before out of nothing? (meaning that man did not exist before God created him)

  • I'm quoting a Christian website:

    They alleged that the creation of Adam is an anti-scientific nonsense, and God did not create Adam from a handful of dust, like the Bible says. Their allegation and their pre-conceived idea are not written in the Bible. Nowhere in the Bible can you find a verse that Adam was created by God from a handful of dust. What is written is recorded in Genesis 2:7, which says:And the LORD God formed man of the dust of the ground..." Source: Scribd

  • Yet another contradiction in the quran:

    What was man created from?

    Blood Clot [Q 96:1-2]

    Water [Q 21:30]

    Dust [Q 3:59]

    Nothing [Q 19:67]

    quran is not from God

  • Your last stinky comment was marked as spam (not by me) but I will reply anyways You don't seem to be well informed: detergents were not available at that time even the Christians and Jews used to clean themselves similarly and by the way Europe was contaminated with plague during the Dark Ages until we Muslims taught them how to clean themselves go and read a history book instead of launching corny claims at Islam. I recommend that you visit 1001inventions website (just google it)

  • well done for the islamic world they were good...but u cant go claiming credit for everything and calling your self seekfortruth and then follow slavishly a man made book which has absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with spirituality...spirituality is the opposite of religeon and a primitive obstacle to enlightenment...peace and love to you brother x

  • First and foremost the Qur'an can be proven to be God's word. Go to my page, and then go to the Islamic44 link then to my link there (Sary Farah) then download the power point and audio entitled The Evidence for Islam (Is the Qur'an God's word) and then we can discuss it. Among the people who were convinced with it Dr Ian Webber from England search his name on youtube so you can see how he accepted Islam. Unlike Christianity, Islam caused enlightenment and removed all obstacles to human progress

  • Moslems of today are still wiping their assholes with their bare hands. They are spreading diseases because they contaminate everyhing they touch with germs from their hands. Examples: doors, doorknobs, shaking hands, water fawcets, food, etc.

  • Your comments reflect your standards of ethics and intellectual level. Anyways, you are completely wrong my friend, we Muslims are the most hygenic people on this planet, and your claims are based on conjectures. We wash ourselves 5 times a day, our face, hands, and feet, so my foot is cleaner than your mouth which is full of dirty words that you keep posting on my page. I repeat again: we taught the world about cleanliness so don't open your mouth again with insignificant false claims.

  • hello EICid4321, you should of known the answer to ur question? man was created from mud. now what is mud? ok when u answer that then u can drop one from the choices.. ok now what about the blood clot was it created from mud? when u answer that then go head and drop another one. God created everything when there was nothing.. sir, read the bible and the quran and dont argue too much...see what your mind and heart tell you...when you decide on something go to the next step to find out more

  • Another contradiction in the quran:

    Who Was the First Muslim?

    Muhammad [6:14, 163]

    Moses [7:143]

    Some Egyptians [26:49-51]

    Abraham [3:67]

    Adam [2:37]

    The quran is false.

    Islam is a false religion.

  • Another weak and false claim by you man, the term (first of the Muslims) does not mean the chronological order, it means the first Muslim of a certain nation: So Abraham was the first Muslim of his own nation at his time and age, and so it applies to each and every prophet that you mentioned. As for some Egyptians, it doesn't say "first Muslims" it says the first to believe, as those magicians truly were the first to believe in the message of Moses after they witnessed his miracle.

  • Just an explanation for you: A Muslim means anyone who truly submits to the one and only true God in love and obedience. And again first in those verses does not imply chronological order, it is that some of those you mentioned were the first to submit among their people in their time and age. {And say: truth has (now) arrived, and falsehood perished: for falsehood is (by its nature) bound to perish.} [Q 17: 81]

  • The quran does not say that these were the first muslims of their own nation. The quran says that they were all the first muslims period, This is impossible since all of these people lived during different periods of time. Therefore the quran is false.

  • An elaborated reply will be posted soon, I'm currently traveling. In the meanwhile, I recommend that you read the verses before making your false claims.

  • The Qur'an is not false, the problem is in your false understanding of the verses, and your false understanding of the term Muslim which means he who submits himself/herself to God. It is very clear from the context of those verses that what was meant is that they were the first to submit among their people in their own times, like the magicians of the Pharaoh after seeing the miracles of Moses, they were the first to submit. I hope that answered you well. Keep your mind open.

  • Yet another contradiction in the quran:

    What was man created from?

    Blood Clot [Q 96:1-2]

    Water [Q 21:30]

    Dust [Q 3:59]

    Nothing [Q 19:67]

    quran is not from God

  • Man your claim is so superficial: If I say that a cake is made out of flour, or that it is made out of water, or sugar, etc... would there be a contradiction?

    Moreover, Adam the first man was created from clay (dust + water). The verse referring to the blood clot is talking about the human embryo at one of its stages, the verse in 21: 30 is saying that every living being is made out of water which is true since it is the main constituent of the bodies of living creatures...

  • ... and I already mentioned that clay is dust + water. Nothing in 19: 67 means that man was created and he didn't exist before Allah created him, so please next time use better arguments instead of those weak ones you just used, and thank you for your comment, it shows how lame are the accusations against Islam.

  • The quran says that a man is made of a blood clot. A blood clot is just dead blood. You need more than water to make a man. A man is 90% carbon. A man is not made of dust. A man is not made out of nothing,

  • Correct your medical information: In medicine, body water is all of the water content of the human body. A significant fraction of the human body is water. Lean muscle tissue contains about 75% water by weight. Blood contains 95% water, body fat contains 14% water and bone has 22% water.The human body is about 60% water in adult males and 55% in adult females.

  • Allah almighty says in the Qur'an: {God forbids you not, with regard to those who fight you not for (your) Faith nor drive you out of your homes, from dealing kindly and justly with them: for God loves those who are just} 60: 8 How could someone claim that Islam allows killing anyone from other faiths? Qur'an 2: 190 states clearly that fighting is only against who fight against Muslims and transgression is strictly prohibited. Islam as the verse shows teaches kindness and equity with non-Muslims

  • In addition to scriptures, history also witnesses for the coexistence under Islamic rule where people escaped persecution by the Catholic church in Europe to live with the Muslims. Non-Muslims had the freedom to live, trade and worship, no one forced them to convert, otherwise there will be no Christians in Muslim countries, so stop your false claims and your audacious lies, truth prevails, and falsehood disappears.

  • Praise be to God, you witnessed how, when strong arguments are put forth, people with false allegations like mended 2004 suddenly become speechless. This is simply because they have no truth in their claims, they only speak falsehood, and they take a few texts out of context and use it to demonstrate their weak arguments. May God help us and guide us all.

    Seek for Truth

  • compare their mercy to ur religion

  • Now allow me to give you something to think about: First, AN IMPORTANT NOTE:

    As Muslims, we do not embrace the pedophilia, rape, terrorism and all of the other forms of evil that exist in the Bible, nor do we believe that the Prophets of Allah Almighty, peace and blessings be upon all of them, ever committed such cruel acts that are falsely attributed to them.

    We're only exposing the corrupted bible and the evil that exists in it.

  • "They fought against Midian, as the LORD commanded Moses, and killed every man... Now kill all the boys [innocent kids]. And kill every woman who has slept with a man, but save for yourselves every girl who has never slept with a man. (The Bible, Numbers 31:7,17-18)"

  • Kill everything that "breathes" from humans and animals!

    "However, in the cities of the nations the Lord your God is giving you as an inheritance, do not leave alive anything that breathes." [Deuteronomy 20:16]

    It is certainly the Bible's principle and foundation to kill all humans and animals from the enemy's side. If one wouldn't call that terrorism, war crimes and mass-murdering, then what else should they call it?

  • Suckling infants were executed by the tens of thousands:

    The Bible: 1 Samuel 15:2-4

    2 Thus saith the LORD of hosts, I remember that which Amalek did to Israel, how he laid wait for him in the way, when he came up from Egypt. 3 Now go and smite Amalek, and utterly destroy all that they have, and spare them not; but slay both man and woman, infant and suckling, ox and sheep, camel and ass. 4 And Saul gathered the people together, and numbered them in Telaim, two hundred thousand footmen...

  • A praise for dashing little children against rocks as a form of revenge:

    Psalm 137:8-9

    8 O daughter of Babylon, O destroyed one, O the happiness of him who repayeth to thee thy deed, That thou hast done to us.

    9 O the happiness of him who doth seize, And hath dashed thy sucklings on the rock!

    HOW CRUEL! HOW DISGUSTING!

    I challenge anyone to produce ONE, JUST ONE Noble Verse from the Noble Quran that condones killing of innocent children, women or even hostile enemy men who surrender.

  • The pedophilic Biblical verses are Numbers 31:17-18 and Numbers 31:35-40. Below, you will see DETAILED HISTORY on these SPECIFIC verses from the Jewish Talmud explaining the pedophilia that took place against the 3-year old slave girls under the direct command of Moses.

    "....The Tannaïtic Midrash Sifre to Numbers in §157 comments on the above quoted commandment of MOSES to kill the Midianite women as well as the male children...."

    (see next comment)

  • "...According to the Tannaïte Rabbis, MOSES therefore had ordered the Israelites to kill all women older than 3 years and a day, because they were "suitable for having sexual relations."

    "Said Rabbi Joseph, "Come and take note: A girl 3 years and one day old is betrothed by intercourse..."

    "A girl 3 years and one day old is betrothed by intercourse. "A girl three years old may be betrothed through an act of sexual intercourse," the words of R. Meir. And sages say, "3 years and one day old."

  • In the Torah (the Book of Numbers in the Bible) after the conquest of Midian and Moab, and the great venereal plague, Moses (pbuh) [alleged] ordered that all the women "who have known a man" be killed but that "all the young girls who have not known a man by lying with him" be kept alive for the Israelites.

    Since the only females left fit for marriage and wholesome relations were prepubescent virgins a Jewish law concerning child marriage was enacted. That law is found in the Babylonian Talmud:

  • AND... what about X-RATED PORNOGRAPHY in the Bible!

    Women's vaginas taste like "wine" (Song of Songs 7:1-4, 8-9)

    Song of Songs 8:1-3 "If only you were to me like a brother, who was nursed at my mother's breasts! Then, if I found you outside, I would kiss you, and no one would despise me. I would lead you and bring you to my mother's house-- she who has taught me. I would give you spiced wine to drink [i.e., her vagina's semen!], the nectar of my pomegranates..."

  • EXTREME PORNOGRAPHY!

    Read Ezekiel 23 in your Bible, I won't dare pasting it here... You'll know when you read about the "Two Adulterous Sisters: Oholah and Oholibah".

  • Song of Songs 5:4 "Listen! My lover is knocking: 'Open to me, my sister, my darling, my dove, my flawless one. My head is drenched with dew, my hair with the dampness of the night.' I have taken off my robe, must I put it on again? I have washed my feet, must I soil them again? My lover thrust his hand through the latch-opening; my heart began to pound for him." What a disgusting way for someone to talk so pervertly about his sister and/or about her brother like that!!

  • Although this garbage is in The Bible, it can never be thought of as the word of God; it is a mere fabrication by the devious ones who changed the true Bible:

    "Then woe to those who write the Book with their own hands, and then say: "This is from God," to traffic with it for miserable price!- Woe to them for what their hands do write, and for the gain they make thereby. (The Noble Quran, 2:79)"

  • Mr.Teacher of devil, sorry for late reply as like what i told u i have life to live not like u a teacher who just like to spread the devils roomers , i told u before not to mix up thing and answer one by one ,, and not running away like your previous sheyikhs of devils by spreading lies about our holey ppl to defend their fake prophet and the satanic book Quran ,,, i advise you to go read the bible and the translation of each story or letters that mentioned there from the correct resources!!!

  • if you want me to use ur cheap islamic way of mixing up things to confuse the reader i will do so by opening 100 issues about ur fake prophet of satan mohammed and prove it from your book and support it by hadeth sa7ee7 one without following your cheap way of cutting pieces without understanding the contents !!

    I really want to understand ur satanic islam but it is confusing so try to teach me without lies like what you did before,,,

  • Still you didnt answer my question with all your justification of why the satan prophet Mohammed rapped the 9 years old child

    Still we are in the subject about ur fake prophet of satan Muhammad as Rapist

    Once we finish from this we will move to the other issues about ur prophet of satan

    -Errors in the Qur'an

    -Scientific Errors of the Qur'an

    -Women in Islam

    -Terrorism and Islamic Expansionism

    - Human Rights Abuses in Islam

  • And many more and dont be socked or sad of wasting your life till now with this lies and satanic way of living

    You have asked me to meet with you many times,, do you think is it possible to meet with islamic teacher who his satan prophet asked him to kill anybody who try to say the truth !!!!! man wake up from ur dream and read ur satanic book ,, if for a small cartoon about ur fake prophet all the blinded follower of ur islam became angry and want to kill everybody and destroy everything!!

  • Prophet Muhammad raped no one, it seems that you didn't read what I wrote and you insist on your lies. I sent you private messages read them well. A 9 year old girl in thailand recently gave birth to a baby, noone condemned her! I can answer to all your claims by using concrete scriptual and historical evidences. I repeat my invitation to you for a meeting, I'm interested in showing you the truth bring your Bible and your arguments, and I'll certainly answer you. I'll send you my link as message

  • I didn't use a single lie or falsehood in my arguments I challenge you to sort out any, I refuted your claim about the Prophet's marriage to Ayesha and gave evidences that it is a agreeable in many societies since the girl will be physically and mentally mature. My counter rebuttle aimed at showing that horrible things do exist in your Bible that was manipulated by devious people. You can check your Bible again for the concrete facts that I presented, no lies at all. Open your mind and be honest

  • Well wlcome back, nice to hear from you again, hope you're ok. You insist on calling me bad names, fine, this shows how distant you are from the true teachings of Jesus (pbuh). I hope that you read my comments showing the deviations of the corrupted Bible, check your own Bible and you'll find exactly what wrote. I know the Qur'an and the Bible very well, but you keep own launching your false claims in your speech, well, I won't use your false style, but I will only use facts in my arguments.

  • Comment removed

  • yeah

    in battle of badr the prisoners of war were alloewed to give their own ransom ex: teaching 10 muslims to read and write would set them free

  • you must pay money (jeziah) if you want to remain non muslim else either Mohammed will kill you or you shall forced to be Muslim)

    thats why all the poor living ppl where the cancer islam still living and rich ppl still not muslim )

    please read your book my friend and know what writen dont follow blindly fake prophet again i can help you

  • The only one who needs to read is you, I am reading everyday. The Jiziah is a tax as any other tax payed in any country. People all over the world pay taxes to their governments. Muslims also have to pay Zakat, which does in many instances exceed the amount of money payed as jizyah by some non-Muslims. Since The Islamic state is based upon religion, it wont compel non-Muslims to fight for its cause. Non-Muslims have to pay a certain tax for protection, since they do not fight in the army.

  • Not all non-Muslims are required to pay the jizyahh tax. There are conditions which may exempt non-Muslims from paying the jizyahh tax, which could be summarized as follows:

    Women and children are excused absolutely

    Handicapped, blind, old men, even if they are rich

    Needy

    mad-men

    Day laborers, servants or wageworkers

    A chronically ill-man even if he is rich

    Religious people who keep themselves free for praying and worshipping, i.e. men of churches, cloisters, monasteries, and oratories

  • If a non-Muslim voluntarily participates in military service for protecting the country.

    If the Islamic state becomes unable to protect non-Muslims, then they are legally exonerated from paying the tax.

    [See Ibnul Qayyim, Ahkam Ahlul Dhimma, Volume1, pp.8, 15 and al-Shafi', al-Umm¸ pp. 172-1]

  • The treaty of protection made by Khalid ibn Al-Walid with the Christians of Al-Hira in Iraq states:

    Any aged non-Muslim who is unable to earn his livelihood, or is struck by disaster, or who becomes destitute and is helped by the charity of his fellow men will be exempted from the capitation tax and will be supplied with sustenance by the bait al-mal (the government treasury).

    [Imam Abu Yusuf, Al-Kharaj, p. 144]

  • it is called tax for translation not just simply money

    half the world pays tax

  • but nobody get killed for not paying tax or converted to Muslim read your satanic books !!!!!!

    please read b4 you comment or you will get defeated like your satan teacher of lies!!!

  • The only one defeated here is your ignorance. I have exposed the falsehood of your claims but still you are living in your fancy world of illusions. Don't you ever misquote the Qur'an again. No one shall be killed if he refuses to accept Islam. People of different faith enjoyed peace and prosperity under the rule of Islam for over 10 centuries, and even Western scholars mention this fact in their book. Read for Montgomery Watt, Simon Okley, Gustave Lebon, Thomas Arnold, Toynbee, and many others.

  • Just to answer your funny claim that forced conversion was condemned by islam in the Quran 2: 256

    this Surah was when Mohammed was weak and unabel to fight and whe he become strong he use to force ppl (i have lots of surah from your satanic book , it was as follow :

    Aslim Taslam ( become muslem to be safe)

  • Your ignorance is exposed over here: this verse 2: 256 was revealed when the Muslims have established their state in Madinah, and not when they were weak and oppressed in Makkah. (Spelling correction: unable not unabel). Prophet Muhammad as well as his followers never forced anyone to embrace Islam even western historians such as Sir Thomas Arnold witnessed in his book: Islam: a history of peaceful preaching. Show me the surahs as you claim so I may explain how wrong you are.

  • to correct you Mr.teacher In Mecca, where Mohammed started his new religion in the year 610 A.D, he was not

    yet strong (WEAK). To be accepted by all people, he presented a peaceful and loving picture of Islam, avoiding any mention of violence, and here are some quotations from the Quran about that first stage:

    Mohammed was told not to impose Islam by force in Surah Al baqarah (2: 256)

    Let there be no compulsion in religion

  • then when he became stronge :

    This verse is abrogated (its authority has been abolished) by the following verse:

    AT-TAWBA 5

    So when the sacred months have passed away, then slay the idolaters wherever you find them, and take them captives and besiege them and lie in wait for them in every ambush, then if they repent and keep up prayer and pay the poor-rate, leave their way free to them; surely Allah is Forgiving, Merciful.

    so please correct your info Mr.Teacher of Satan

  • This is what Christianity taught you? to call people bad names? Fine, I won't go down to your low level of morality, I will simply tell you that verse 190 in Surah 2 (Al Baqarah) explains it by saying that this applies to the battlefield "fight those who fight you and do not transgress" By the way why didn't you read the verse that follows At-Tawbah: 6 "If one amongst the Pagans ask you for asylum grant it to him so that he may hear the word of God; and then escort him to where he can be secure.

  • lol

    he is our teacher

    u calling us satan??

    pls show some respect and stop silly name calling

    this is one of the biggest things we learnt from our Prophet (SAW)

  • i bet half the matter u r typing is from anti-islam sites or books

    tht is why thdey r wrong as proven by seekfortruth

  • How many times do I have to correct you: Surah Al Baqarah was revealed in Madinah when Muslims had their own states and were strong. Read any commentary and it will explain it. Your explanation is unacceptable since the Qur'an only allows fighting those who fight us and forbids killing innocents even if they be followers of other faiths. Coexistence is one of the values taught in Islam and practiced for centuries, while Christian Catholics and Protestants used to massacre one another.

  • Another mistake you have committed, which shows your ignorance and exposes your lies again, is that there is no verse in the Qur'an which says: slim Taslam ( become muslem to be safe)

    The true meaning is embrace Islam for your salvation, it never meant that if one refuses to accept Islam he shall be unsafe or even killed. Non-Muslims have coexisted with Muslims for centuries, a big evidence against your false allegations. Read Qur'an surah 60 verse 8 to see God commanded us to be good to them

  • I have a lot to shock you but the main problem is that who teach you Islam Is teaching you the only bright part of it (taken from the holey Bible by Mohammed) without putting any single light of the satanic big part of it!!!

    Please read your book and come back and if you want I can help you to know the truth

  • Ok come on and shock me, but the only who will be shocked is you. I've studied comparative religion for years and I have debated many Christian pastors and holders of Phd in theology and they were clueless. It is impossible that Muhammad took from the Bible since the first Arabic Bible came out 3 centuries after his death. Besides, all his people witnessed his upbringing and they knew that no one taught him and he was unlettered. The truth there is no god but Allah and Muhammad is His messanger

  • My friend i have lots of friends who converted to Christianity after knowing the truth of your fake liar prophet

    Another one small question for you (do you know how your fake prophet knew that he is prophet from god??)

  • I have tens of friends who accepted Islam as well, search the name of Dr Ian Webber on Youtube and you shall see why he accepted Islam, it is I who was with him in that video. In case you don't know Arabic, wait and listen to him speaking in English towards the middle of that clip. Those who became Christians are obviously misguided. Prophet Muhammad received revelation from God as Jesus foretold in John 16: 12-14, and as prophecized in Deuteronomy 18: 18-19

  • u have many friends

    the whole world knows the mslim population is rising

  • This is only on your dreams my friend

  • My dear friend, this is not a correct argument, the number of Muslims and its increase or deacrease is not an indicator of the veracisty of Islam.

  • your satanic Quran teach you about sex and sleeping with Childs and for your info your Mohammed was allowed to fuck any women he wish to no matter what if ( i can prove it from your book) !!!!! And also give you the page number from your satanic books

  • It is a physiological fact that puberty varies from one climate region to another. a 9 year old in the equator is more mature than a 9 year old in northern Europe. Early marriages are not unique to this case, throughout human history many cultures allowed marriages around that age even the Christian Byzantine empire. Ayesha was both physically and mentally ready for marriage. She lived for decades after the Prophet Muhammad and she never complained about her early marriage, on the contrary

  • She was happily married to the Prophet peace be upon him, and thousands of hadiths were narrated on her behalf. Had it been as you are portraying: a traumitizing experience of a child forced to marriage at a young age, she would have revolted afterwards, like after the prophet's death, but it wasn't the case. And you are threatening to prove your false allegations from the Qur'an, ok bring it on so I can correct your understanding and teach you not to misquote again. You are obviously wrong.

  • Mohammed ultimate achievement of what??!!! Dont believe on this big lie (GIVE me one thing new that your fake prophet bring to the humanity other than his satanic lessons!!!!

    Dude, in islam you can marry 1 years old girls (can also prove it from your satanic book!!

  • Prophet Muhammad's great achievements: He had put an end to idolatry, elevated the status of women, helped moving Arabs from the darkness of ignorance and superstition to the light of knowledge and scientific endeavour, established universal brotherhood among the believers and established a society of peaceful coexistence among people of different faiths. Islam doesn't allow the marriage of a girl that is not mentally and physically ready for marriage and there's no evidence for your false claim

  • Islam is the solution for what ???!!!

    are you crazy ,,,, man stop dreaming !

    tel me your story and i will defeat you from your quran book ,, did you read tje Quran and Hadeth before you post this big lie ???!!! Jesus out lord for ever and he still alive not like your fake prophit Mohammed !

  • Again I still think that you are mislead by your false concepts on Islam, you need to learn and read. I am a teacher of Islamic studies and I am well versed in knowledge, and it is obvious that you are not. All you know is some verses taken out of their context and some hearsay uttered by some haters without any evidence. I can easily prove you wrong based on concrete evidences and show you how fallacious your claims really are. By the way, you spelled prophet wrong.

  • Hi Seekfortruth, you are absolutely right in one thing only that Im normal Christian who believe in one god and who like to read, learn and try my best to remove your Muslims false claims and false concepts

  • and lies even from a normal person like me I can defeat you the Islamic teacher because anybody who read can defeat any teacher who teach lies. Please excuse my English and some of my previous spelling mistakes and I will do my best to avoid this as am a normal guy not like you Mr. Teacher of lies.

  • Comment removed

  • Allow me to answer you one by one and from your books without claiming anything from outside and I will be awaiting your response one by one too for the readers benefits and it is up to you to accept it or not but it is not your right Mr. teacher of lies to spread lies via your wrong video post and misleads the watchers and the innocent people exactly the same as your fake prophet!

  • (again I might take some time to reply as I am normal guy who have his life and many things to do other than teaching lies so please you and the readers bear with me) +++

  • I will start by praying that the Lord will use me (the normal Christian guy) to enlighten you and the watchers to come to the Lord Jesus Christ who is the only savior. Jesus said,

    "I am the way, the truth, and the life. No man comes to the Father, but by me."

  • Has it not occurred to you Muslims that your trying to conquer the world is part of Bible prophecy? One that has already been foretold the YOU will be the losers?

  • Well which prophecy? Danial's or the one inthe apocalypse by John (Ne Testament)? They both could have many interpretations. As we Muslims view it, the Jews (Zionists) and their allies (Americans) are the ones who seek to conquer the world, this is very obvious especially during the last few years the struggle for oil domination and the US corporations controlling the world. We Muslims want our independent & freedom, those groups that kill innocent civilians don't represent us. we'll talk later.

  • To answer mended2004's claims: Prophet Muhammad married Ayesha after she reached puberty, females reach puberty earlier in warmer areas than in colder areas (biological facts) and this was and still approved in many parts of the world, even non-Muslim societies (Africa, latin America, etc...) As for forced conversion, it is condemned in the Quran 2: 256, and it was never done by the Prophet Muhammad. Please read a book. Thank you. (view below the quotes from non-Muslim orientalists)

  • Lets start with your fake prophet Mohammed wives and the 9 years old Aiysha satanic marriage and your false claim defending!!!

    Here you go my friend and god bless you:

  • After the death of Khadija, his wife of almost twenty years, and after proclaiming himself the Messenger of Allah, Muhammad unleashed his sexual desires and in a span of ten years he married fourteen wives in addition to his many concubines. Not one of them was mentioned in the Quran by name, for Islam has no regard for women. They were, however, mentioned in Muhammad's biography written by Ibn Hesham.

  • Before we mention the wives of Muhammad, we have to remember the words of the Quran concerning Muhammad.

    And surely thou hast sublime morals (Surat Al-Qalam 68:4).

    Ye have indeed in the Messenger of Allah an

    excellent exemplar (Surat Al-Ahzab 33:21).

  • So, if Muhammad married all these wives without any sense of guilt, a good Muslim can marry four women without any sense of quilt. Muhammad is his excellent example.

    A Washington Post Parade Magazine reporter printed a column entitled "Sex in Saudi Arabia." Here is that column.

  • This reporter rang up Dr. Seymour Gray in Brookline, Massachusetts, recently and asked the former Harvard Medical School professor if he really believed that the late King Ibn Saud, founder of modern-day Saudi Arabia, had married 300 women in his lifetime. Dr. Gray, 72, worked from 1975 to 1978 as physician in charge of the medical department at the King Faisal Specialist Hospital in Riyadh. He is the author of Beyond the Veil - The

  • Adventures of an American Doctor in Saudi Arabia, a fascinating book published earlier in the year. "I don't know if Ibn Saud was married to precisely 300 women, " Gray replied, "but that approximate number, give or take a dozen or two, seems to be correct."

    We then asked if it is true that Moslems by law and tradition are permitted to have only four wives - admittedly a far cry from 300.

  • "Under Islamic law," Gray explained, "a man can have no more than four wives at any one time.  What some royal Saudis do is to divorce their oldest wives when they reach 35 or 40 and take younger ones. Divorce in Saudi Arabia is quick and simple. All the husband has to do is to announce three times, 'I divorce you,' and that's it."

  • Gray contends that many Saudi men are obsessed with sex because Islamic law segregates the sexes so strictly. Saudi women must wear veils and avoid the society of men. Adultery is punishable by death. Premarital sex is so taboo that later, after a man marries, he often has a compulsion to engage in sexual relations as frequently as he can manage. Gray writes in his book that

  • many male Saudis consider themselves impotent if cannot indulge in sexual intercourse more than two or three times a day.!!!!!!!!

  • One of Gray's must illustrious patients was Prince Ibrahim Mugrin el-Kabir, who had fought alongside Ibn Saud early in the century. The prince complained of "decreasing sexual prowess" and explained that he had fathered no offspring for five years. He demanded improvement of his waning potency, but-at 90-age was against him.

  • He soon died, leaving an estate valued at $32 billion, which was divided among his four wives, 23 sons and 11 daughters (Washington Post Parade Magazine, November 13, 1983, page 9).

    ((These people and many more are just following Muhammad's excellent example))

    There is a story related to every wife of Muhammad but space only allows us to mention the most interesting one. as follow ::::>

  • Aisha, daughter of Abu-Bakr was a beautiful little girl. Muhammad married her when he was fifty three years old and she was only six years old. He had intercourse with her when she was nine years old. This is a gross case of child abuse by the prophet of Islam.

    When Muhammad married Aisha, he set an example for the Muslims. To this day older Muslim men marry much younger girls, following Muhammad's example.

  • The Egyptian weekly magazine Almussawar printed a letter sent to Ameenah Al-Saaeed, one of its editors, from a woman who was a teacher of languages in Egypt. The letter appeared in the September 6, 1991 issue. Here is a part of that letter:

    Dear mother Ameenah Al-Saaeed:

    My problem is. . . my husband came home with a friend who is about his age. He requested that our daughter "Marwa" who is nine years old bring

  • tea to his friend. At night he told me with great joy that his friend agreed to marry "Marwa." His friend is fifty years old, "Marwa" is nine years old. When I objected, he told me that he is following the prophet Muhammad's example when he engaged Aisha when she was six years old and had sex with her when she was nine years old as is written in Sahih Al-Bukhary.

  • Muhammad Sobhi Alantabli, a high ranking police officer, sent a letter to the same editor, which was printed in Almussawar magazine in the December 20, 1991 issue. Here is a part of that letter:

    The chief of a tribe invited me to attend his wedding. He was eight four years old and his bride was fourteen years old.

  • "Why do you marry a girl who is much much younger than you?" I asked. "Because my other three wives became old, and when the woman gets old she will be like a rusty car. I mean a car covered by rust," he answered. The young bride's father was very happy because of that marriage.

    !!!!! Muhammad Married His Daughter-In-Law - to be cont. after finishing from the child marrige response!!!!!!

  • Muhammad followed an Arab custom in marrying a child who had her first menstrual cycle. This action must be questioned, regardless of it being a cultural norm, because Muhammad's action and teachings on marriage established an Islamic precedent: a girl is judged an adult following her first menses, and is eligible for marriage and sexual relations.

  • Thus Muslim men are allowed to marry and have intercourse with young girls who have happened to have an early first menstrual cycle. As will be shown, this leads to physical and psychological damage to the child.

  • At the age of 49 Mohammed was betrothed to Aisha, age six. Aisha was his closest friend's, Abu Bakr's, daughter. At that time, she had already been betrothed to another man but by mutual consent the betrothal was dissolved. Three years later, following her first menstrual cycle, he then formally married and sexually consummated his marriage with her.

  • Most Western people know it is not in a 9 year old girl's best interest to engage in marriage and sexual relations with a 52 year old man, regardless of the cultural setting. We know that,

  • in our culture today, a person doing such a thing could possible be sent to prison for sex with a minor, statutory rape, or other related laws. Most of us find it questionable for Muhammad, a self proclaimed prophet of God, to do such a thing.  We expect a real prophet to know better, or at least hear from God on the matter.

  • What is more critical than Muhammad's single action with Aisha is that he taught that a girl is considered an adult following her first menstrual cycle. He also taught that his followers were to follow his "sunnah" or lifestyle. Thus today, throughout much of the Mideast, girls as young as nine are often married by men old enough to be their grandfather!!! huh real prophet!!!