Added: 4 years ago
From: ThreatVision
Views: 68,338
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (355)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 2k5 definately

    

  • 2k5? I didn't even realize this was still considered a game. Madden 98 is better than 2k5. And who sells more games..Madden or 2k5? Thats what I thought...

  • ur goingto sell more games if ur the only game seller dumbass

  • 2k5 was way too easy probably half the people say madden sucks play the game on rookie and still cant win

  • i prefer madden as im loyal to it as it porvides me entertainment and fun. i dont care about the stuff wrong with it because quite frankly it really doesnt happen to me..madden as proven to me thats its best........mabey its just to advanced for some gamers

  • @Predemtion madden advanced lol it's the same game over and over every year

  • i just ordered 2k5 i hope it was worth the 4$ it cost

  • I LOVE YOUR VIDS

  • wow that raider lineman sux lol he couldve had a sack

  • damn I forgot how dope 2k5 was...I would sit and play tha game for hours on xbox live and not get tired of it....I gotta go 2K all day...they delivery was seamless...highlights wit Chris Berman...you had ya crib you could stylize...gameplay was mothafuckin genius...it sux that Madden has exclusivity wit the NFL, cause like on the basketball side, 2K would run EA...

  • lol gson70 becuase there arent many!!

  • They stopped making NFL 2k because madden bought the rights I have a ps3 and 360 and madden still has yet to surpass the NFL 2k5 bench mark for a football video game just like 2k owns the basketball world madden knew that they got scared cause they knew the couldn't compete with 2k madden isn't even worth 60 dollars it's bad a five year old game still out does madden even today

  • one problem i found with this game and that was that the qb had a crazy break tackle ability

  • @Rukupo07 lol, yeah but thats in real life too. Look at Ben Rothlisberger haha. The key is to arm tackle instead of dive. hold the tackle button instead of tap, yes it makes a difference!

  • nice catch dude although i'm a Cowboys fan

  • madden has so many haters cuz its the greatest football franchise in video game history. 2k games are for people who are to poor to afford 360's or Ps3's. they stopped making those games for a reason.

  • @philaeagle38  lol wow dude

  • @philaeagle38 You are one of the most ignorant people on here lol. Have you ever even played 2k5? I'm just going to assume you haven't just like you have assumed that Madden is the greatest football franchise.

  • 2K all the way, it's sad but true (metallica tribute =)

  • that was the marvin harrison catch

  • I like how in 2k5 u can acually Lob the ball for a sick pass

  • Gates is better by half a hair, but what happen to NFL 2K.

  • OH MY GOD THE RAIDERS HELMETS ARE SILVER ON A S2 GAME hallujea!!

  • why can 2K make great football and basketball games but not hockey and baseball

  • @cincyreds2446 2K was originaly Not 2k the first 2k game was in '06 and espn was the game maker before '06 and hockey & Baseball espn 2k games r better than the just 2k games

  • So sad 2k5 still owns madden and its extinct

    pass the torch to backbreaker

  • how do you guys get the star

  • 2k> gay madden

  • everyone likes to point out the bad things in madden. i want to see a video of the bad stuff in 2k.

  • @gson70 make one.... oh yeah the game is nearly perfect lol

  • there was bad stuff in every football game

  • @gson70 there probably are some things... but heres the thing...2k5 is being compared to madden 10...not madden 05. and yet it still holds a good fight. the monopoly EA is pulling is not cool.

  • @gson70 theer are way more than madden this game sucks lol

  • @gson70 because there barely are bad things in nfl 2k5 duh

  • @gson70 problem... there isnt!

  • @gson70 srry there aint much for a game made in 04 and considerin how long madden has had to beat it they still havent so OWNED!

  • @gson70 well when 2k can have or share the liscence you will

  • @gson70 plus madden has had about 5 years now to prove itself

  • @gson70 well that wouldnt be fair cuz this game is 5 years old and madden has had alot of time to fix the stuff. i have never even played this but my favourite madden game was 08

  • @gson70

    I could make a video of bad stuff in 2k really easily.

  • @gson70 That is theoretically impossible my friend

  • how do u know

  • I like both games, I wish they could like Merge to make the ultimate football game. That would be awesome to see, like the only thing that would need to be added is more hall of fame players.

  • thats were madden 10 comes in it has at least 100 hall of famers

  • By far the greatest football every created. NFL 2k5. I am no joking currently playing it as we speak and have spent much time beasting up my crib. Pussy ass EA Sports knew their Madden Game got owned in 2005 therefore decided to buy out the rights to being the only football game. Forever this game will be far better than any madden ever made and will be made! :D woot woot!

  • whats your source ?

  • madden is the same stuff every year. they cried cause 2k5 was waaaaaaaaay better then anything they will or ever made so they made a deal to get the NFL players to only appear in there games 2k all day

  • So what this video means by generic player is "made up?"

  • No....generic as in a computer generated rookie from the draft in franchise mode....

  • nfl 2k all the way hay ******** yeah

  • the pa in 2k5 actually sound like they know what there talkinabout other than madden 09

  • 2k5 is a great game but the madden 1 handed catch was much better just my opinion.

  • wow NFL 2k5 has great animations. damn

  • Just look at the drop back of the QB, it was like a real QB in real life madden cant match that drop back and its now 2009.

  • heck yeah man

  • 2k5's animation was beastly but it was rare which made it special when it happened in a game. it's the kind of animation that when it happens you're "like goddamn that was great catch". Not that the madden animation was bad because it wasn't but you would see this animation attempted like five or six time in one game so it wasn't that special when your receiver actually caught one

  • Omfg, i nearly jumped out my seat, i wasn't expecting that depth of realism from a football game. ive gotten so used to madden. seeing

  • 2k5

  • I loved 2k5

  • u guys have no life watching this vid u probly sit on the pc all day doing nothin

  • your watching it aren't you?

  • thats gates!

    not that impresive:(

  • 2k5, best football game ever! My rosters are fully updated too, i dont even play madden 10 unless i wanna play online

  • how you update???

  • I've doing it myself since i had the game every year

  • you create every single player?

  • 2k had wayyyy more physics involved then any madden game on the 360.... they work on the graphics too much and not making it more realistic....

  • 2k5

  • too bad 2k cant make actual nfl games anymore!! 2k5 was awesome!! and cheap

  • Its amazing that Madden still has some work to do to catch the 2k series in some aspects. The presentation still isn't close, and even in this vid, the 2k5 catch looked more realistic then Madden.

  • cause thats what i look for in a great football game not a acrcade version of football

  • tell me ppl wat would u rather perfer 2k5 in high graphic and clear animation with updated roster and a way better feel on everything in the game up to madden 10 now wat one would u pick becuase mine would be 2k5 becuase madden10 has got nothen on the realistic play in a football game

  • really only reason i got madden10 is for new players and rosters.. i mean we got pro tak in 2k stuff cuz its in football its just there

  • well to bad madden 10 is way better

  • Well In madden 08 they have a 1 handed interception. But 2k5 is better

  • slyider1 - 2k5 also has one, i saw it myself

  • FUKING SEXY ass catch damnn!! u dont get dat in madden !! u see how dat nigga reached out der to get dat damnn! ha i feel like playin 2k5 again haha damn i wish 2k could still make football shit dey already have da best basketball nd baseball game on da map

  • beauty

  • ea is all about tryin to look pretty and if its in the game its probly not in the video game unless you play 2k5

  • people have overhyped 2k5 by miles and miles. the game plays good and all but, it resembles madden for ps2 and xbox. the only real thing i like more about 2k5 is the presentation like sportscenter and good halftime/post game shows. and all u guys are saying 2k should make another game, they did, all pro 2k8 and we all know that game wasnt that great. just look at the reviews, madfden 08 averaged 1 or 2 number higher reviews.

    2k5 is overated!

  • Yes it's been overrated, but not overhyped as much as you think. You think madden is better thats why you think 2k8 is so overrated. But MADDEN is also overrated, and it's been lots and lots of times. Both have been

  • yes,yes both have.for $1 this is a ghood game.but 2k8 is the red headed step child of madden 08.

  • red headed step-child with freckles. fucking gingers dude. there scary

  • Did you see how the play action develops in 2K5...Thats flat out beautiful for a game thats 5 YEARS OLD!!! Madden has all the money in the world but is 2 lazy to make a game this great, they half ass it knowing that fan boys will buy it because their is also no other game to buy

  • 2K5 is beter

  • I still play 2K5 on PS2 to this day.

    I still have some hope, seeing as Ian Cummings still listens to the folks at OS, but I can't sit down and play even 09 for long before I get fed up with its arcadey gameplay. I then turn to 2K5.

  • Maybe its not even Ian Cummings fault the game has been bad, notice how the game is finally making improvements when he beceme lead developer. If he can fix the jokes in the running and blocking game then I will respect him.

    If not well, they really don't care about us.

  • I actually played a build of Madden 10. I'm impressed with the one year turnaround. It's still not perfectly sim, but Ian's helping get it there.

  • star icon?

  • What combination of players in this game make the best team?

  • 2k5 is the best football game ever

  • i agree

  • me too

  • @sammi325266543262 no the best game would have the physics of backbreaker the look of madden and flow of 2k5. am i right?

  • the move of O-line is unrealistic in madden.

  • Look at the way the quarterback sells the fake to the RB. It looks so smooth.

    I'm done with all the new Maddens but I remember really enjoying Madden 05, the one with Ray on the cover.

    Not sure whether to get this or Madden 05. May as well get both, ha!

  • this madden is the same as the older games, nothing has really changed in the madden series.

  • nothing changes in any sports game to be honest

  • well the animation from madden 08 never happens

  • im not tryingt to give you crap but honestly you shouldve gotten hit when you threw that ball in 2k dude was right in your face...a sack or a bad throw either way wouldve been fine...but nice video all the same

  • i agree, if this was about the play that would've sucked but its about the catch.

  • Agreed. The guy was in the QB's face but then turned for some reason.

    Nice Vid!

  • He tried to jump in the QBs face & bat the ball. . .

  • we do all have to admit the main complaint I have with all pro(2ks)is use basically have to tell your men everything(take control)way to much.

    BUT I WILL GLADLY DO THIS INSTEAD OF PLAYIN A MADDEN GAME ON MY OWN WILL

  • nfl 2k5 looks better on than madden 09 on the 360 and nfl 2k5 is on the ps2

  • actually in madden there are 2 animations of 1 handed catches

  • holy crap, the start of the video for NFL 2k5 i thought it was real life.

  • ea is sorta like an arcade game company..

    2k is more realistic... nd i think the ppl who work for ea thinks more kids play games than adults

    so therefore kids will like arcade play rather than realistic..2k

  • 2k5 is the only resone i own a 360 and original. I keep the original just to play 2k5

  • its backwards compatable and a lot better to play with on the 360 controller, stiff arming is a lot easier

  • what last time i tryed to play it on my 360 it said it wouldnt work

  • dude my xbox 1 is broken believe me

  • Not to mention it sold for $20

    Instead of a ridiculous $60 for a far inferior product

  • I miss 2k5

    they were everything madden isnt

    They had excellent presentation, excellent player control, incredible franchise control (my personal favorite, draft and pre-draft sportscenter)

    honestly, everytime I play madden im a little dissatisfied

    It seems like they keep leaving out so much that could make the game great every year for more sales

    I can only dream of the day when ESPN/2K get their hands on the licensing again

    Everything Madden keeps claiming they add on every year, 2k already had

  • sport center was the shit..

    wit chris berman nd tha highlights...

    man i miss 2k

  • Whats funny is, look at how in 2k5 the WR's head follows the ball all the way into his hand.......EA is making a big deal about how they are finally putting this in for Madden 10, LOL!!! Also see how the QB ran around then set up, madden doesn't do that either!!! EA IS TRASH!!! Until they work out a deal with 2k the game play will never match up to the PS2 version that is gaoing on 5 years now, and thats sad. Imagine, Maddens old deep franchise mode and graphics 2k's animations and presentation!

  • this is dumb i allways get 1 handed catches

  • i never understood what all the 2k5 hype was about till now... if 2K5 gameplay was this good, why is Madden 09 gameplay so crappy? i dont understand... its really pathetic

  • becuz they have no direct competition

  • madden is way better

    espn has the same tackle every time

    and its too easy to score on espn

    i had like almost 2000 rushing yards in one game

    so unreal

  • ugh not on legend mode

  • wat tha hell r u talking about. 2k has way tha hell more animations than madden!!! 2k is way better and madden doesn't even compare!! the numbers in madden r completely retarted and theres no pass defense.

    MADDEN SUCKS ASS!!!!

  • ur right about the pass defense!! it's RIDICULOUS lol go 2k5!

  • test

  • I think both Madden and 2k5 one-handed catches look great, but Madden for me; it has a more aesthetically pleasing look to it. Just IMO.

  • ps2 games do work on ps3

  • yes it does

  • do ps2 gms work on ps3/???

  • only 80 gb and up

  • to top it off this was a 20 dollar game brand new when first released

  • I FORGOT ABOUT THAT! Is sure was! That makes all this even crazier!

  • it makes it all even more pathetic. fuck john madden i just bought 2k5 off ebay and threw that game in the trash. i dont want another fool to buy it used like i did.

  • I know madden bought 2k, but can they keep the same people who made 2k but just change the name to madden?

  • Why would EA do that when they can keep selling that same crap. . .I mean people keep buying it, so they keep giving them the same thing they keep buying. They have no motivation to improve that crap, & they have no SHAME.

  • no they didn't they were trying to. cuz 2k is alot better then EA plus they wanted to have the rights to GTA

  • wait. rights to gta? 2k has sum ownwership over 2k? so dat means rockstar is a 2k branch?

  • the parent company is Take-Two Interactive, 2K Sports and Rockstar are branches of Take-Two.

  • madden better

  • even though 2k5 is almost 5 years old it still owns

  • 2k5 rules

  • i hope that when EA Madden is done with the exclusive rights to the NFL i would love to see Sega go back into making football games i loved the 2K series better thewn i liked Madden. i don't think it is fair that EA can do what they want and not let a another company make football to.

  • but it won't happen because the NFL is money hungry. It's a 17 year exclusive deal. They'll just renew it.

  • the deal is up to 2011.but there are a couple of rumors that there may be a NFL 2K game coming out soon. it seem john madden will not be apart of EA any more. i dont know why but if EA dose not have the madden name on there NFL game then the deal with the NFL is broken

  • The original license was up this year, but in Feb 08 the deal was extended to end after the 2012 year which will actually be in early 2013.

    Madden will still suck just as bad in 2012 as it does now. I miss 2K football.......

  • 1:22 Our Chicago Sound...

    And ya don't stop.

    PEACE,

    RRKS

  • look at blocking animations look at any animations u want the quality in 2k is way better and its a tougher game because its so much more realistic oh any by the way the ai in 2k way surpasses madden 0any thing!

  • WOW this always happens.... one handed catches with no coverage is easy

  • NFL 2K5 catch was better because it wasnt in practice

  • 2k5 wins by far

    MADDEN SUCKS

  • I wish 2k sports made 2k9, it would have pwned madden. The only reason I didn't buy 2k5 was because the rosters were not up to date by about 5 years from now...so i got madden 09 on ps2.

    SUCKS. it's basically madden 08 put into a different cover. i never played 07 or 06, but i doubt they could have been worse than 09.

  • 2k5 is way better than madden 09

  • Dude have you even played nfl 2k5? madden sucks now because they know there's no competition against them. NFL 2K5 is arguably the best football game there is. You can even see Chris Berman doing commentary and they'll even have Sportscenter. Madden doesn't have sportscenter but yet they have an espn license.

  • 2k5 came out 5 yrs ago and it was considered the best football game. madden is still making games and they r no where close to making a game like the 2k version. u can campare it to which ever one u want but none of them will be better then 2k5. the reason EA bought the NFL license was because they were afraid they might lose their buisness. by taking away the license it would only allow them to make the game and people will buy it because there is no other football game left.

  • No, what would be fair is if we could compare ESPN NFL 2K9 & Madden 2009. . .

  • QB shulda been sacked

  • Wow, who gives a fuck you dirty asshole eating cunt?

  • GAY

  • this has to be the worst vid i have ever seen in my whole life i just wasted a chunk of my life for horrible vid your a menie

  • lol it looks funny how in 2k5 when he caches the ball the ball just gets fixed in his hand

  • the only reason to catch one handed is if the ball is too high to reach so the madden 09 catch is a valid and quite realistic catch. A receiver in the nfl will only catch with one hand if he cannot get his other hand up in time, and also there is a higher fumble and possible strip risk in catching one handed.

  • 2k is wayy better i never bought any 2k football games until i seen this vid now im gonna

  • 2k5 is only 3 dollars best football game eva

  • madden 09

  • the ones in 09 suck the better get better ones

    and better hits and make it so helmet come off and refs are on the field

  • 2K way better, why is the player icon a star insted of a circle

  • I completed all of the milestones. . .