She's not flat. I'm sitting here with the score in front of me with an electronic keyboard (which cannot go flat or sharp) and she is right on pitch. I think her voice is lovely. I don't know anything about her support from watching this--it may be that her characterization--as Charlotte is a reserved woman and trying to hold in all these feelings--gives that impression. The role is more dramatic but is sung by both lyric and dramatics in the U.S. And any mezzo can sing this aria.
She is flat...her high notes are pressed and come under the pitch. Her support is too high...she's working too hard. Listen to Berganza or Von Stade. This opera is for a lyric mezzo anyway, a young woman.
But she's not Berganza, now is she? She's not flat either. Further, what is a "pressed" high note? How do you know she's working too hard? Did she channel you for this performance? Ugh!
Hey, there's a voice there no, question. I'm just arguing technique. Bigger voices can hide a lot. Sorry, but her production is too much "work". It would take me hours to elaborate on the technique so I'm just posting MY opinion and MY opinion is different than yours.
bella voce, grande mezzosoprano...
TheGennaro2011 5 months ago
che bella voce!
TheGennaro2011 5 months ago
She's not flat. I'm sitting here with the score in front of me with an electronic keyboard (which cannot go flat or sharp) and she is right on pitch. I think her voice is lovely. I don't know anything about her support from watching this--it may be that her characterization--as Charlotte is a reserved woman and trying to hold in all these feelings--gives that impression. The role is more dramatic but is sung by both lyric and dramatics in the U.S. And any mezzo can sing this aria.
luceroblanco 8 months ago
mmmm
aneloBannA 1 year ago
i dont like it so much..i will post my sis how she is singing this aria.i like it better how my sis its singing
veressemoke1990 1 year ago
I don't like the conduct...
FabyEDDMAC 2 years ago
I wish i could know wut she is saying! or understand!
AimeeY123 4 years ago
ceck your hear then..
francocerri74 4 years ago
So flat...
francocerri74 4 years ago
flat? didn't hear it.
davidSBG 4 years ago 2
She's not flat.
urgrad03 4 years ago
She is flat...her high notes are pressed and come under the pitch. Her support is too high...she's working too hard. Listen to Berganza or Von Stade. This opera is for a lyric mezzo anyway, a young woman.
mezzoola 3 years ago
But she's not Berganza, now is she? She's not flat either. Further, what is a "pressed" high note? How do you know she's working too hard? Did she channel you for this performance? Ugh!
urgrad03 3 years ago
@mezzoola Pretty sure this is for a dramatic mezzo...
chiarocontralto 1 year ago
Hey, there's a voice there no, question. I'm just arguing technique. Bigger voices can hide a lot. Sorry, but her production is too much "work". It would take me hours to elaborate on the technique so I'm just posting MY opinion and MY opinion is different than yours.
mezzoola 3 years ago
I agree with you. She's flat.
Weillfanatic 3 years ago