Added: 5 years ago
From: podflower
Views: 50,558
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (70)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • For me I find this unmistakably better than Katharine.

    But then I see so many people prefer her so I guess it shows how people's opinions differ.. Also again they're just opinions so bare in mind what you see as 'better' might not be what other people see as. So don't attack them for it. ;D

  • I agree! Leona's performance of this was MUCH better then Catherine. Leona is also a much better overall singer that Katharine. This is evidenced by the fruit of each performer after the got off the show. Leona has a much better career and is internationally more renowed than Katharine. Don't get me wrong Katherine is a very good singer, though. I don't want to subtract from her greatness. But I feel Leona was better.

  • Ditto X 100  :)

  • @AsuScholar I can't evenm hear her to know if it is better or worse

  • imho, katharine's version is better than leona's. from the song's arrangement to katharine's vocals were just superb. not to mention katharine's over all performance, she connected with the audience and felt the song.

  • katherines song!!

  • you cant compare katherine and leona cause they have diferent version of the songs, and they have different voice types, so they r both great. we all have different opinions sooo leave them alone

  • Definitely superior to McPhee's. But slightly inferior to Tamira Gray's. Leona's version is borrowed from Gray, even the key of the song. Simon Cowell gave Gray a standing ovation for this.

  • Far superior than McPhee's. The voice quality and purity of the voice is on a whole different plateau.

  • Além de cantar bem é linda demais!!!

  • good, but Eva Cassidy's version is SO much better. i recommend everyone check it out.

  • wooo!

  • leona is a lot beeter bitches

  • Leona you sing very good, and you sell a lot... you're a promise on the future... But Katharine MCPHEE's version SO much better... sorry is the truth

  • 100% agree with you dieguito178

  • unreal fantastic

  • i love leona, stop criticizing her you

    no-voice-at-all!!!

  • I really don't usually like Leona but she does a great redition of this song although no-one can beat Eva Cassiday at this song.

  • You make a new version of this song in one week noh

  • You're entitled to your opinion; but, Leona is also entitled to interpret the song however she pleases...and you have to admit, she has some voice.....

  • i have seen and heard eva cassidy's version of 'over the rainbow' and for me, leona sang better this song...

  • i have seen and heard eva cassidy's version of 'over the rainbow' and for me, leona sang better this song...

  • Excuse me? She's not 'ripping it off', she's singing it as she wants in a way that suits her voice more, which is better than trying to turn into a clone of the previous artist. She hasn't even released this or even SAID that it was her own version.

  • TOO TRUE!

  • leona is the best xx mwah

  • i thought she did a lovely version

  • SHANE WARD!!!!!!!!!!!WHO???????

  • I dont know why everyone is marking it as spam....its his oppinion. He can say what he wants to about it

  • Thumbs up to you! :)

  • OMG shayne ward is an absolute justin wannaba HAHAHA i cant belive you said his version is better, that is pathetic, you are probably his mam anyway!!

  • totally agree!!! whoever thinks shayne ward is better than leona must have their head stuck up their arse!!! i don't know who in the hell they've been listening to!

  • you do realise that the whole song is a lot longer?! or are you just that stupid?!

  • This is the best version of this song sung by lovely leona lewis, knocks spots off the rest :*}

  • That woz amazin! I just wish she would bring ut an album. wonder wen she will!

  • She now has! :]

    YAY! haha x

  • Somewhere over the rainbow Way up high And the land that I heard of Once, once in a lullaby Well some day I'll wish upon a star And wake up where the clouds are far behind me Where troubles they melt like lemon drops Away upon the chimney tops That's where you'll find me Somewhere over the rainbow Skies are blue And the dreams that you dare to dream They really do come true If happy little bluebirds fly Beyond the rainbow Why, oh why can't I?
  • i abosutly love this song and this is the best cover version i have ever heard.

  • She's actually great... (although I prefer Katharine more ^_^;)But this is just too long and make it boring... but tat's me... I don't say she's not good, she great! But well, um...

  • personally i prefer shayne ward's version (the year before's winner of X-factor)

  • amazinggggggg!!!!!

  • this is a beautiful song that leona nails and looks incredible in, if u dont like her why look at her video's. cant wait for the album

  • shes overrated, this is boring

  • shut up ernest leona rules

  • I can see where ernest is coming from she is very over rated cos she isnt the best singer ever although she is fantastically talented i just guess its not everyones taste, i wish shed use her voice more often cos she is phenominal

  • whats amazes me about leona is her control over her vibrato...she goes faster when necessary, but like here, as the song began it was really slow- that one sign of a remarkable voice

  • Eva sang it with faster much softer and colourful vibrato in the original. the slow vibrato at the beginning adds NOTHING to the song for me. in fact i think its rubbish. and if that was "the best performance he's ever seen" (quote from cowell) that says it all about the crap he usually see's!

  • i know ye, how dus she do that lol

  • i love that dress

  • yeah, vocal range is great...but a little too long. just get to the point. katharines is amazing though.

  • Well, other than the great 'Somewhere Over the Rainbow' part, this was a little long... and dull.

    I like Katharine's better.

    But that's just me. What do I know.

  • I agree, I usualy wait for this video to load and fast forward it to that part.

  • this is soo freaking boringgg.

  • BEUTIFUL!!! shes such a brilliant singer! THE best to have come out of xfactor AND american idol

  • Man i wish i could sing like her! So glad she won the X factor...there would be no justice in the world if she hadn't.

  • this is my favourite of her songs i think!!

  • zzzzzzzzzz...

  • I'm so confused lol ! I thought this was amazing. xD It's so wierd how everyone is so different.

    Also how she did it for her cousin, I reckon she'll release a big album for her cousin.

    I'm a MASSIVE fan of Leona.

  • now THATS wat im talkin bout

  • leona is amazing she shud definitly win the x factor she has star qualoty and definitly the X FACTOR!

  • Just listened to the Eva Cassidy version and it remains the best but Leona is fantastic - she isnt EVA Mariah or Whitney she is herself and thank goodness for this show it is frightening to think she may never have been discovered she will be huge whatever she sings and I think she will prove she can sing anything - go girl

  • Great voice! but she bores me! yet another ballad!

  • she's done two up-tempo I also advise you to do some reasearch on her...when she was making her demo's her style was up-temo rnb/pop

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more