Palestine, Israel and Self-Edward Said Life and Philosophy

[starcatcher2222]

Edward, You were born and reared in Cairo not "Palestine" may you burn in Hell with the other Cairo Born and reared "Palestinian" Arafat.

[rachelgolem]

Israel is just like South Africa, except we don't have an 18% HIV infection rate.

[vivascargill]

O Edward what a terrible essay on Jane Austen! Oh Edward how I miss you! God bless you!

[meshzzizk]

Great upload, thanks so much. Too bad the sound quality isn't better.

[theromashka1]

Edward Said spotted throwing rocks at Israeli soldiers and that if you ask me is a terrorism! Palestinian nation doesn't exist, it's political fabrication and it exists to justify the occupation of jewish and christian land!

[SiNaoia]

Wow! that was really nice and interesting...:-))

[joe80dman]

Interesting how the American controlled media doesn't reveal that 50% of the Lebanese are Christian, and a good many Palestinians as well. They'd rather have us believe that ALL nations surrounding Israel are militant Islamic-fascists.

[bigcree]

@joe80dman the need to perpetuate the Lie, the Myth of "All Arabs and Muslims are evil". A really sorry excuse born of deluded minds full of hate. ZioNAZI Bullshit.

[bigcree]

Homeless little Troll from ZioHell (Below) still following me around like the stuck pig 'It' is. Pathetic.

[bigcree]

@bigcree Anybody starting to smell Roast ZioPig in here?? Whew! Stinks.

[LittlPussi]

@bigcree Not only does "It" have racist problems against Arabs, it also seems to have racist problems against people from Africa and people who live in ghettos in general (jews?). Notice too, how often the Zionazis call dissenters gay or faggot or queer or pussy. Homophobe macho neurosis born out of insecurity about their own gender-identity, no doubt. Peace brother.

[bigcree]

@LittlPussi Good summary. Just one more person like yourself to see 'IT' for the Neurotic and severely stunted Individual 'IT' is. Terribly self centered, self hating at the same time, with delusional self images. Sick and tormented.

[LittlPussi]

@bigcree Since I don't have a degree in psychiatry, I feel unqualified to counsel patients like this. I will therefore continue to block and ignore in the hope they will find professional help eventually.

[bigcree]

@LittlPussi All we can do is hope! This one appears to be without such lofty aspirations.

[vionorino]

You can learn from that man!!! all the respect Edward the Zionist didn't leave u alone and made ur life unbearable..... they feared ur intellectuals and loyalty to ur Palestinian cause !

[palestinemoncoeur]

@vionorino

merci pr le partage

un bon exemple pour nous tous

[hamsawiy51]

@bigcree What's to know about the Arab that call themselves palestinian? There's never been any such race, nor any such country. I doubt there ever will be. Cage those Arab monkeys up and throw away the key, all they ever do is fight and kill women and children. Fuck Gaza and fuck the heap big fake-ass indian bigMonkCree, lol

[joe80dman]

@hamsawiy51 : The claim that there never was a Palestine is one of the more recent falsities spewed by Zionist propagandists. I have maps dating back to the 1920's that clearly show a nation called Palestine. The only women and children being killed are Palestinians living in Gaza, and the IDF is responsible for their deaths. Fascinating how you can reverse the guilty party as being the victim somehow.

[bigcree]

@joe80dman You`re talking to the holder of 100`s of FAKE Channels. An Imbecile and Whore of the lowest Order. 'BobbyCroc`o SHIT' aka 'Coco' the Gorilla Alcoholic little Shit that dwells on youtube for 'IT`s' boss RavDov the ADL Jackass.

[bigcree]

@joe80dman I don`t talk to Imbeciles like that one. 'IT' is beneath me, and not worty of breathing the same air. Lower than dog shit. And I have said as much to 'IT' before.

IT' knows that too.

[bigcree]

@bigcree Typo on "Not worthy"..

[bigcree]

@vionorino Thanks again my Brother for the share! Great History lesson here.

[cisfx]

multiple identities? als judenhasser doch stets erkennbar.

[roosoo2]

palestinians are the best ppl

[arabicgelato]

god bless

[ocinkwaman]

I dunno if stereotyping is all the time true?

[iamthepalastenian]

its so sad....its our life ,thanks to the western Orientaisim l,we are suffering from this until this day

[triplecheck4]

HAMAS NO MAS! Destroy the bile of Edward Said, a professor of hate, lies and terror.

Hell

Angels

Murderers

Arab

Sociopaths!

[brucelee8l]

Wow your clearly screwed up and uneducated. I bet you haven't read any of his writings or actually listened to what he has to say. Not all Middle Eastern are terrorist just like not all whites are racist. By the way there have been a plethora of terrorist attacks in America done by American which had nothing to do with the Middle East such as The shooting at Colimbine High school, Lynching of blacks, the Una bomber ext.... So grow the F*ck up seriously.

[brucelee8l]

Also R.I.P Edward Said your one of the most esteemed intellectuals of our time you will be missed :)

[triplecheck4]

If I didn't meet him personally, I could have agreed with you, but he was a vicious, pompous, and worse a liar of the first kind! An 'intellectual terrorists! There was never and there is really not such a people-hood called Palestinians. The Jews used to be called Palestinians prior to 1948 and the Arabs use to despise this word saying it is a Zionist invention. Do your homework. Said was discredited. Read a book by Ibn Warraq called: Defending the West, a critic of Edward Said.

[SweetDissident]

@triplecheck4, you should take advice from your username.

[moodini99]

When it comes to racism, white people don't rule the roost. Just look at Africa, look at India, racism is much more common there. I don't know about the U.S, but racism is very rare here in the U.S. People often confuse race with culture or religion.

The vast majority of terrorist attacks are from the middle East and Pakistan. I'm not implying that Middle Easterners are all a bunch of terrorists, they're not, but most terrorists are from that area. That's a fact.

[Ramble1212]

ooooh so your a internet hardass are yah? well let me be blunt you fucking fagget if i ever saw you in real life you

would be one dead bitch!! I bet your pissing to panties just thinking about it, lol pussy

[Ramble1212]

lol your fucking dead fag I'm in manchester with my family we going to take a alittle tripp this weekend are the midlands too filthy fucker!!!

[moodini99]

Yeah, sure you are. Why would a Muslim have a profile picture depicting Mohamed as a pig? You're no Muslim.

What I don't understand is why you're parading around as a Muslim. Are you a member of the BNP, trying to gain Islamic hatred? maybe you're Israeli or a Christian. According to your profile, you aren't illiterate, so I'm guessing that you're not an immigrant.

A nice persona, but what are you really?

[Ramble1212]

i thought you said whites aren't racist so whats wrong with your bnp? plus yes i am muslim look at the profile you white loser

[moodini99]

You're not a Muslim. Why would a Muslim have a picture of a pig in a turban as their profile pic? It's the most offensive thing to any Muslim. Woody Allan is more of a Muslim than you, lol.

I didn't say white people aren't racist. I said that racism was a lot more prominent in countries that aren't white majority. I live in the U.K and racism is rare here - in most parts of the country.

I don't know what you mean 'my BNP'. They're nothing to do with me, I vote UKIP.

Dumb, kafir.

[Ramble1212]

ok racists are mostly whites and the most racist countries are angloid so the uk is THE most racist play in the world name ONE ! one non white country thats racist and i'll explain to you why your wrong. my friends are in the uk right now and the amount of racist remarks your kind screams out is insane i don't blame the poor children of non white parents turnming terrorists maybe it was good what happened to thoughs buses. plus i'm shiite muslim we are more tolerant then the sunni muslims.

[moodini99]

you don't know what racism is. You can't differentiate between race and religion. I doubt you've been to India. If you had, you would know that the northern Indians can be very racist toward southern Indians

You're a Shi'ite? That is interesting. I have always wanted to speak to a Shi'ite Muslim. Everyone I speak to seems to be sunni.

look, kid, I'm not racist in any way. I don't care about skin colour. I don't care that there are immigrants in the U.K. I just want to protect our culture, okay?

[moodini99]

Let's cut the arguing shit, it is fun, but it's getting tedious. Plus, I would actually like to learn a few things about Shia Islam. Hopefully, you are a true Muslim and don't just call yourself one like so many British Muslims do. I know about 6 or 7 from where I live, they are nice people, but they all drink(bar one) and some don't practice Halal, however, they all call themselves Muslim.

Are there any differences in the practices of daily life that differ between Shia and Sunni?

[Ramble1212]

ok listen up i'm suck of explaining this to you fat western pigs my faith and path to islam dosen't forbide me from have pictures of my god and drink wine! but like so many of you white racists you make up shit and then paint us all with the same bullshit brush islam is the most tolerant religion ever and christiens are the most racist just look at what you said about those muslims in your own country.

[moodini99]

Yeah sure, a Muslim depicting Mohamed as a pig. Bullshit. You're not fooling anyone, mate. If you're a Muslim, then Ayatollah Khomeini was a Jew, lol.

You don't know the first thing about Islam. You don't even know what racist means, you dumb cunt. I don't even know what race you are, it's your piece of shit religion I hate. Religion and race are two entirely separate things.

Oh, and if you'd bothered to read the Quran, yes, it does forbid you to drink wine. A real Muslim would no that. Kafir!

[Ramble1212]

you christians have no sense of humor WE muslim can laugh at ourself unlike your racist ass you calling me kaffir is like calling a me a nigger so your a racist pig!

[moodini99]

We Christians? you think I'm Christian? I hate Christianity even more than I hate Islam. Come on, the son on God, that shit is ridiculous.

You are a stupid cunt. You literally don't know what the word 'racist' means. You're the racist. You're a racist and a pedophile. And you are a kafir. 'Kafir' is a religious term, it has NOTHING to do with race. A religion is a set of beliefs and traditions, NOTHING TO DO WITH RACE. You're the racist.

A real Muslim would not depict Mohamed as a pig! Kafir!

[moodini99]

You are the racist. Assuming that I am a Christian because I am white. That is a racist as it gets. And you can't spell - 'you're and your are not the same thing. To sum it up; you're a racist, illiterate kafir that pretends to be a Muslim. That's rich.

I am calling you a kafir because that's what you are. You are a disgrace to Islam and Mohamed. Islam is a set of beliefs, it is practised by many races, including white Caucasians. The following words are racist and wrong - "nigger, kike, spik".

[Ramble1212]

oh i see so because english isn't my first language i'm stupid? hmmm sounds like your a racist bigot to me . by the way you can't be racist to anglos or white people in genrel lol that doesn't make any sense LOL! plus your scum for saying the n word racist fuck!

[moodini99]

it was you who used that word, you stupid, racist cunt. Feel free to browse the previous comments. Regardless of your race, you're still a cunt, a real piece of shit. Not even a proper Muslim, just a confused little kafir. You don't know what racism is, you don't know what religion is. You're nothing, you're opinion is meaningless because you have no understanding of what actual words mean.

Get a dictionary, you pedophile cunt!

[Ramble1212]

ok so because i'm muslim and black i must have sex with little kids? my god you white people are truly the most racist bigotted bunch of shits in the world i'm glad your race will be nothing in europe and america in the years to come its about time the world stomped out the last embers of your racist hate! and we can all live in peace with out you whitey!

[hamsawiy51]

@Ramble1212 are you some dumb Muslim ghetto monkey? Racist piece of shit, go back to Africa.

[bobyloopo]

this man has shown his support for peace a nice educated man who has passed away i wish one day you can come to half of his intellegence

[triplecheck4]

Boycott the terrorist, Arabs/Palistinians/Hamas, No Mas Hamas!

Edward Said, professor of hate lies and terror, google it.

[fuascailt32]

actually i'd rather boycott apartheid isreal.and other racists

[triplecheck4]

Said is the crudest I ever met. He is hateful and bitter. His books are based on falsehood! He was caught on many lies. He is unreliable, simply put, a Jerk!

[awazahome]

You are disgusting for berating one of the only true advocates for Palestenian rights. He is not bitter, he is an advocate for justice and you are a racist, anti palestenian, clearly.

[Africanmistress29]

I love his pictures.

[jack9255]

edward said will remain an icon and an inspiration to us all

god bless you, and rest in peace

[moamed2006]

To JeruBoy7, U R typical Zionist liar, He said He is Palestinian, BORN in Palestine, of A Palestinain, Family, and got the photos 2 prove it, & made A documantry on channel 4, in UK, U can't sea Palestine cos the Zionist Terrorists like the romanian Shamir, and the Polish Perez+offeski, Begin, Jabotenski, the Moroccan, Amer Peretz,David levy, the Egyptian Shaol Mantia,& Iranian, Mofaz, and Katsab, & the Russian Ben Guion (Gorien),Sharon, Barak, Sharanski, Ivagador Lieberman, All these Terrorists

[moamed2006]

All these Terrorists Have wiped Palestine off the map, the British Army (the real God founder & creator of Multinatianal mafia Israel) on the so called independent day 14/15 May 1948,& Handed the Archieve (of the Palestinain population names where U will find who's who, & no Sharon, Shamir, Rabin, Dayan, Perez, Mofaz, Peretz, Mier-fski, Hertozog), Handed to the zionist Polish find his name in David Gillmoore book the dispossesed, Or read The Jewish Truth telling Pro N.G. Finkelstein,

[moamed2006]

Pro N.G. Finkelstein, Houlocaust Industry, or his ch-2, in E. Said book, Plaming the Victims, and ch4, by Peretz. Kidron, Truth whereby nation(not mafia) live. AND On the Jews expeled from Muslim lands i.e the ARAB WORLD, read the book written by the Iraqi Jews in Ocuppied Palestine, on who the Zionists bomped them in Iraq, Egypt, and recently in Franc, so that they can flee 4 the Mafia State to survive, as Sharon Asked them 2 leave France.

[moamed2006]

And Finaly 4 JUST solution Let us Let every body GO Back Home, Irqi 2 Iraq, Polish (Like prisedent! Shimon Perez+Offeski), and Theodor Hertzl 2 Austria, And Sharon & Ben Gorien 2 Rusian, and let Mahmoud Abass Go 2 Tabaria, and Yasser Arafat & E.Said 2 Jursalem (Al-Quds), last rem in Jewish Tradition when Prophet Solomon, want to know the real mother out of 2 disputing women, He said let us,

[moamed2006]

He said let us cut the child into 2 halfs, the true mother cried No No division, & U know who said No division 2 Palestine, the owners the Palestinians, who got the land deads and the Keys of Churches, Mosques, the demoletioned Homes, who nos what the land can Grow.

[tincoffin]

He had a good English education . An education which prepares you for prison.

[aburebecca]

Excellent video... better quality please!! would it hurt?? we greatly appreciate it

[Jimmypagerainsong]

This guy is a legend, i enjoy reading his stuff very much

[JeruBoy7]

I believe this guy. His family where imigrants to Palestine. They where Lebanese & Egyptians etc. This is very typical.

I am sorry for him.  Curious what he thinks about the 850,000 or so Jews who where expelled from Muslim lands around 1948 ?! That's about twice the # of Palis displaced (many fled of their own accord).

[n8glenn]

"palis", that's nice. Yes, they fled of their own accord, to avoid being slaughtered.  So let them go back to their homes of their own accord, as the UN decreed in December, 1948.

[JeruBoy7]

Actually N8, plenty did leave of their own accord. Plenty stayed back & wheren't slaughtered (20% of Israel is Arab). I'm surprised that you don't comment on the million or so Jews expelled from Arab countries without compensation during this same period. Why is that ? I chalk it up to ignorance

[n8glenn]

Really? Let me ask you this, would you leave your own house, your farm, your family's land, of your own accord, and never return? Think about it. Were Jews expelled from arab countries? I don't know of such a thing happening, but it's certainly possible. I do know that certain zionists were caught bombing synagogues in arab countries to terrorize the jewish population there and convince them to move to israel. Am I ignorant? Of course, we're all ignorant to some degree.

[JeruBoy7]

Actually many Arabs did leave the war zone with the promise of the invading Arab armies that upon the anihilation of the newly born Jewish state, they could return. I am curious if you have knowledge of how the Jewish community of Palestine was treated under Muslem rule. Quick example. 1929 the Jewish community of Hebron was massacred by Arabs & their land taken. & yes, more Jews where expelled from Arab countries than Arabs who fled Israel.

[n8glenn]

You are citing popular myths. Please find me some documentary evidence of what you are saying. No one so far has been able to find any proof, whatsoever, that arab armies ever contacted the palestinians, and even if they did, it makes no difference, the UN has recognized their right to return to their homes since december, 1948. Also, arabs have always been very tolerant toward jews in general, and even if they weren't, it makes no difference, two wrongs don't make a right.

[JeruBoy7]

I am actually citing facts. As for Arabs being tolerant of Jews, ROFL. You are focusing solely on some good periods and perhaps comparing them to Christian Europe's horendous treatment of Jews. Under Ottoman rule Rabbis where held ransom, Jews where unequal before courts, synagogues destroyed. As for the UN, it is the most corrupt legislative body on the planet. 55 Muslem member nations !! You think Israel gets a fair shake ? What you are advocating is Israel actually commiting suicide.

[n8glenn]

I repeat, and will continue to repeat, find documentary evidence of these false claims. Claims of injustice against jews which you evidently are trying to use to justify injustice toward palestinians. Also, I repeat, two wrongs do not make a right. Adhering to un resolutions and international law is not suicide, the suicidal path is violence, racism and revenge.

[bigcree]

@n8glenn Well said Glenn. Many would agree on that comment. Just once it would be nice to see Israel Apologize to the Palestinian People for what it has done to them. And then make proper Amends by getting back to IT`s Pre 1967 Borders and giving them FULL RIGHT,OF RETURN. And then maybe there can be some form of "Two State Solution".

[GorterPoss]

@bigcree A full right of return would surely be just, but it is terribly unpracticable. Even the most flexible Israelis willing to make great concessions have a very difficult time defending such a proposal. Monetary compensation would be more workable. In any case, I think that a two state solution depends more than anything else on the Palestinians conceding the permanence of the state of Israel. As long as many of them believe Israel will be undone I don't see any kind of solution. Do u?

[KennBurch]

The expulsions of the Mizrahi Jewish communities from North Africa, loathesome and stupid as these were, occurred AFTER the expulsion of 800,000 Palestinians in 1948. If those people hadn't been forced out of their homes by Plan Dalet, who knows if anything would have been done to the Mizarahim at all?

The weird part is, prior to their expulsion, almost no Mizrahim had been supporters of Zionism.

[Monkeyspank101]

There still lives a poulation of jews in tehran. They are mostly left alone.

[DasWesen29]

This is interesting, especially his thought on the origin of his own identity. One thing that bothers me is the charge that he is a liar. It seems to be unfair here since he is talking about his recollection of his childhood, the formation of his identity, and the emergence of his own race-consciousness. I am disturbed by all the Liar charges. If these are meant as critiques, the academic conference or journal wpould be more appropriate.

[alanjohn2006]

im sorry this is Edward Said speaking,its not dubbed his voice was distinctive. He did not lie.

[Angel4eva]

Edward Said was awesome.

I aint againt israel or Palestine(but i hate hamas and suicide bombers).

but Said was one of the few Palestinian activist i had a genuine admiration and respect for he wasnt violent or hateful he made sense he genuinely wanted peace.

R.I.P Edward.

[jy768]

What a liar!

[sayle79]

fUCKPAL! MEANS FUCK pal-estinians ISN'T IT? AND YOU WROTE THAT YOU ARE FROM IRAQ ON YOUR PAGE ! YES! IT IS OBVIOUS WHO IS LIAR ...YOU ARE THE LIAR ..BE RESPECTFUL YOU RACIST MORON ABOUT EDWARD SAID WHO WAS (IS) THE ONE OF THE MOST PROMINENT SCHOLARS IN THE WORLD...

[meenxo]

Rest In Peace Said

[jimmyjoemeeker]

Said was a liar. He was born in Egypt, although he lied and claimed he was born in Jerusalem. Justus Reid Weidner exposed his lies.

[fuckpal]

what was he palestinian, lebenese, egyption, american well he was frud we know that for sure. when he was confronted with facts he said all the bullshit of which you hear in the clip he never was in jerusalem. during one of his visits to israel he couldent name one village in westbank. a total luni frud

[bitchaches]

israeli denial as usual

[fuckpal]

this is the truth and is confirmed, he was an arab british as you can see with british accent and grew up in england. He was in university of wisconsin and i was in the hall and an israeli student presented him with copy of his birth certificate in egypt and question him about it he left the lecture hall and demanded the student to be removed.

[pz29]

this is an overdub, he is not speaking English. please watch carefully.

[fuckpal]

he was a houx all his life and could never prove his theories, he was palced several times on academic suspension for publishing invalid and unsubstiated academic work.

[xmarifulx]

Can you provide more information on his academic suspension?

[fuascailt32]

its nice to know

someone like shmluksaw this

by edward said.i sent the

little nazizionist

prik it.

ps.said aint muslim.

free palestine.

longlive justice.

[triplecheck4]

Boycott the terrorist, Arabs/Palistinians/Hamas, No Mas Hamas!

Edward Said, professor of hate lies and terror, google it.

God bless Israel and the free world!

[mpersia]

RIP! Dr. Said

[alphautubeone]

++SLAUGHTER-ING pALESTINIANS AT A RATIO OF "8 to 1" YEAR AFTER YEAR AND THEN CLAIMINm YOU ARE THE VICTIm OF TERRORISM^ AND ANTISEMITISM IS SIMPLY LAUGHABLE BY ANY RATiONAL, LOGIc, RELIGiON OR CREeD. NO EXCUSe IS CREDiBLE FOR THESE LEVELS OF TERRORISM. NOT EVEN THE JEWISH HOLY TORAH ALLOWS KILLING BEYOND AN EYE FOR AN EYE!

PLEASE MEMORIZE & HELP POST THIS COMMENT ON MANY OTHER ISRAEL RELATED VIDEOS

BOYCOTT ISRAEL!

[triplecheck4]

Boycott the terrorist, Arabs/Palistinians/Hamas, No Mas Hamas!

Edward Said, professor of hate lies and terror, google it.

[bookss4ya]

get out of here Zionist..long live Palestine..and resistance in Ghaza