Because they are so biased and ill informed. What is the name of the first commentator going bazurke ? That is never ever going to be a penalty try as there was no way Smith was definately going to get to the ball first, yet he shouts 'hes been taking without the ball, that is a clear cut penalty try' - well sorry mate no it isn't. You'd never get the likes of it on the English Sky or South African SuperSports, so why Sky NZ? Need to sort themselves out.
@cs19ish And you would know this how? do you do the same job as them , or as a referee , i guess not. So get some more information to back your story up. Thank you.
penalty try or not it should have for the very least been a 5m scrum to the Hurricanes having been taken in goal off a sharks player. That is not a legitmate way to finish a game of rugby....any fool who knows anything about rugby should know this
btw hmmm098 = turd burger...gee you must hate it when you see the rankings year in year out...RWC is one tourney over 4 weeks every 4 years...ABs are on top for all the rest so get over yourself
@EvKrusty that's not right - if it's not a PT - it's game over, simple as that; - the ball was made dead - you can't end on a penalty or fk - but if the reset is a scrum/lineout/restart kikc (i.e. 22) then the game ends.
But Marks bottled it and should have consulted the AR (and arguably the TMO as it was in the act of scoring...though given the early tackle was inches in the field of play it'd probably have been a breach of protocol).
@dafyddg1984 fair enough, I stand corrected I didn't think the ball was dead when it has been taken back by the defending team...but turns out I was wrong. all the same what a shite way to finish a game!
@hmmm098 yeah there was a sharks player on the different angle - he tipped the ball and Smith would have had a simple catch and score but he was taken out. You moron
@hmmm098 then you wouldn't have heard much from us in 2010 when we kicked your bitch ass in the Tri-Nations then got the only Grand Slam against weak Northern Hemisphere teams that both Austrialia and SA failed to do. Listen to that. Over, and over again.
@hmmm098 ahh yeah you cocksucker. So Smith was grabbed SLIGHTLY outside the ingoal area, but then dragged down thru the first 5m of it, during which he obviously WOULD have grabbed the ball and scored a try as he was then the front runner for the ball. Oh, maybe you are South African and can;t see the truth and overlook the cheating of SA players. Burger never gouged anyone's eyes right?
I've often been tackled (chasing a kick) without the ball right infront of the try line ALOT of times, the refs are always cunts and just have a scrum.
Its a matter of whether or not Smith would have got to the ball or not. If he had, then it IS a penalty try and the ref is a nonce. If he wouldn't have, then fine. It all goes down to the referee's perception.
I think he would have got there tbh, the only question for me is if he would have grounded it in time before it went dead, which I dont think he would have. The rules state that its awarded if the try would have been scored. I dont think he would have got there.
Wait, how can you argue Smith wouldn't have grounded it before it went dead? Waldrom got to it before it went dead and he was about 5 steps behind Smith?
i'm not a Hurricanes fan,being South African, i support the bulls, but i like the sharks too when they aren't playing the bulls XD, but that was clearly a penalty try.
the Ref later apologized after watching the replay and admit he mad a mistake. If Hurricanes were given this win they would of had a home semi's which would of changed everything as if they won their semifinal at home they would of played the bulls in NZ.
bananaz piss off the made it to the final last year didnt they? and should ahve won it too. careless mistakes at the end. i agree with the commentators it cleary was illegal but try not to be a prick
One wonders whether the Ref and the linesman for that matter which i think might have been Kelvin Deaker had a few bucks on a Draw at Full Time with the TAB.
THATS FUCKIN GAY
nellsskate 3 months ago
Because they are so biased and ill informed. What is the name of the first commentator going bazurke ? That is never ever going to be a penalty try as there was no way Smith was definately going to get to the ball first, yet he shouts 'hes been taking without the ball, that is a clear cut penalty try' - well sorry mate no it isn't. You'd never get the likes of it on the English Sky or South African SuperSports, so why Sky NZ? Need to sort themselves out.
cs19ish 5 months ago
@cs19ish Not necessarily a penalty try, but definitely a penalty/5m scrum.
AlexChanNZ 4 months ago
@cs19ish And you would know this how? do you do the same job as them , or as a referee , i guess not. So get some more information to back your story up. Thank you.
h3artl33ss 2 months ago
fuck that number 12 in black
Drspeedstackingguy 7 months ago
it was knocked on at the end of it but ya that should have been a penalty
GxDStatus 9 months ago
the kiwi commentators are an embarrasment to their country.
cs19ish 10 months ago
@cs19ish why's that exactly?
87Kiwiboi 6 months ago
@cs19ish your an embarrassment to your mum
brownpooz 4 months ago
@cs19ish You are an embarrasment to yourself. No country has to be involved.
h3artl33ss 2 months ago
Paul Marks is a typical Aussie brain surgeon
Mad111Axe 11 months ago
shit what the f*ck!, should have won that!
NFORSA 11 months ago
What a bunch of chokers!
timflan1234 11 months ago
penalty try or not it should have for the very least been a 5m scrum to the Hurricanes having been taken in goal off a sharks player. That is not a legitmate way to finish a game of rugby....any fool who knows anything about rugby should know this
btw hmmm098 = turd burger...gee you must hate it when you see the rankings year in year out...RWC is one tourney over 4 weeks every 4 years...ABs are on top for all the rest so get over yourself
EvKrusty 1 year ago
@EvKrusty that's not right - if it's not a PT - it's game over, simple as that; - the ball was made dead - you can't end on a penalty or fk - but if the reset is a scrum/lineout/restart kikc (i.e. 22) then the game ends.
But Marks bottled it and should have consulted the AR (and arguably the TMO as it was in the act of scoring...though given the early tackle was inches in the field of play it'd probably have been a breach of protocol).
dafyddg1984 11 months ago
@dafyddg1984 Conrad Smith was clearly taken out without the ball = penalty = can not end game
Hurricanes can't take a line out because time is up, but they can kick for goal, set a scrum 5m out or tap and go.
its history now but nonetheless the Hurricanes were robbed of the opportunity to win the game
EvKrusty 11 months ago
@dafyddg1984 fair enough, I stand corrected I didn't think the ball was dead when it has been taken back by the defending team...but turns out I was wrong. all the same what a shite way to finish a game!
EvKrusty 10 months ago
@hmmm098 yeah there was a sharks player on the different angle - he tipped the ball and Smith would have had a simple catch and score but he was taken out. You moron
acehighnz 1 year ago
1:17 lol
87Kiwiboi 1 year ago
its jst becoz the reef is s.african
bskwattt 1 year ago
@hmmm098 thats why the kiwis are ranked number one isnt it?
Phillyated20 1 year ago
@Phillyated20 correct.
87Kiwiboi 1 year ago
@hmmm098 then you wouldn't have heard much from us in 2010 when we kicked your bitch ass in the Tri-Nations then got the only Grand Slam against weak Northern Hemisphere teams that both Austrialia and SA failed to do. Listen to that. Over, and over again.
CicusMan 1 year ago
@hmmm098 ahh yeah you cocksucker. So Smith was grabbed SLIGHTLY outside the ingoal area, but then dragged down thru the first 5m of it, during which he obviously WOULD have grabbed the ball and scored a try as he was then the front runner for the ball. Oh, maybe you are South African and can;t see the truth and overlook the cheating of SA players. Burger never gouged anyone's eyes right?
CicusMan 1 year ago
@TheXoLogical, LOL hahah, that happens to me 2 bro :P
MultiSaucy 1 year ago
issac luke
h7p10 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
That was a penalty at the very least
smartalec65 1 year ago
Should have at least been a penalty.
extremenumanuma 1 year ago
I was at that game, and that happened right in front of me. The Hurricanes got robbed of a victory, but that's sport.
Tehui1974 1 year ago
Come on people chant
ALL WE WANT IS A DECENT REFEREE, A DECENT REFEREE, A DECENT REFEREE haha
FlawlessJah 1 year ago
I've often been tackled (chasing a kick) without the ball right infront of the try line ALOT of times, the refs are always cunts and just have a scrum.
TheXoLogical 1 year ago
fucknut ref.
kingbollix 1 year ago
WHAT THD FUCK IS THAT
MatthewHolt11 1 year ago
Paul Marks is such a stupid fucking idiot.
He ripped the Cannes off, and now in 2010 hes ripped the sharks off. Thats just (Australian)
otpylacopA 2 years ago
if there ever was a clear penalty try: that's the one
LubluxDxUSAxDxNZ 2 years ago
nonu is a champ
metru2222 2 years ago
If it's not a penalty try it is a try. Waldrom grounded the ball. He missed a try and a penalty try, that's what we are pissed off about.
halgong 2 years ago
@halgong waldrom knocked it
karazn 2 years ago
home oh ref
SS5SanVegeto 2 years ago
@hmmm098 but he diddnt knock it on?
warofthemonsters1 2 years ago
Its a matter of whether or not Smith would have got to the ball or not. If he had, then it IS a penalty try and the ref is a nonce. If he wouldn't have, then fine. It all goes down to the referee's perception.
I think he would have got there tbh, the only question for me is if he would have grounded it in time before it went dead, which I dont think he would have. The rules state that its awarded if the try would have been scored. I dont think he would have got there.
I can't decide tbh.
mjhansford 2 years ago
Wait, how can you argue Smith wouldn't have grounded it before it went dead? Waldrom got to it before it went dead and he was about 5 steps behind Smith?
jcgggg 2 years ago
well i dont have googles on =P i think thats a penalty try lol...
Taken out without the ball...
Thats a penalty try! hehe
runstr8 2 years ago
clearly a penalty try!!!
GuRuGeorge03 2 years ago
i'm not a Hurricanes fan,being South African, i support the bulls, but i like the sharks too when they aren't playing the bulls XD, but that was clearly a penalty try.
PiWizard1 2 years ago
fucking bullshiit
tGarEpReP 2 years ago
the Ref later apologized after watching the replay and admit he mad a mistake. If Hurricanes were given this win they would of had a home semi's which would of changed everything as if they won their semifinal at home they would of played the bulls in NZ.
MrRugbyFan 2 years ago
did you see this game? the referee was terrible.
Smith was taken off the ball, should of been a penalty try. Anyway the kiwis werent losing-its a draw.
berniebreak123 2 years ago
Penilty try he didnt even touch the ball....
i still think he sould wath the other guy to see iv he has grounded the ball or not...
Frozenamp 2 years ago
there was enough evidence to say he could of and that my friend is a penalty try!
MrVaepOr 2 years ago
hahaha they will do anything to win a game but when they are winning u will never here about the other team
RatedRAussie 2 years ago
your obviously blind and only on youtube 4 the sound
dot2dot67 2 years ago
that fat ass ref
Dan12396 2 years ago
damn you takler!!!
MultiAmanda23 2 years ago
Using the precedemt set in the Sharks v Saders game - that wasn't a penalty cos it happened when it was over the try line!
mjribes 2 years ago
Comment removed
NZMaorihaka 2 years ago
that ref was probably distracted by 30 men wearing shorts al around him and forget that he was mean to keep his on his whistle not in his pants
pufftan 3 years ago
Conrad shouldve smashed dat fag dat shouldered him...and the other guy dat tackled him without the ball...stupid fag.lol
Lavulo187 3 years ago
if you think about it, that is probably the biggest ref miss ever.. how the hell does he and the touch judge miss that?
springbokk4life 3 years ago
Thats because thats the only way they can make it to the final, with a dodge ref
bananaz8 3 years ago
bananaz piss off the made it to the final last year didnt they? and should ahve won it too. careless mistakes at the end. i agree with the commentators it cleary was illegal but try not to be a prick
springbokk4life 3 years ago
Yeah i'm just kidding... they are a good team, i mean, they were already drawing with them
bananaz8 3 years ago
It could have been given but it wasnt get over it
edthebumblingfool 3 years ago
He should not ref another game this season, bloody fag!!
welly9753 3 years ago
Ouch. I was going for the Sharks but yeah that should've been a penalty try
Juventino01 3 years ago
thats fucking gay shit conrad was tackled it should have been a penalty try. that fucking homo ref gave the sharks a penalty try lolz how gay shit
tiarnapaige 3 years ago
One wonders whether the Ref and the linesman for that matter which i think might have been Kelvin Deaker had a few bucks on a Draw at Full Time with the TAB.
nazztube 3 years ago
deaker was on the other touch. think the one on this side was another australian
r8dkid 3 years ago
"that is an early tackle he has prevented a try being score" = good work Barritt
anonymous1urker 3 years ago
bullshit!
steelpotato 3 years ago