@crackpot148 I could be cruel and say the quality of your comment matches your user name! Comparing Worcester Male Voice Choir with Trorchy isn't really comparing like with like, similar to comparing a keen, well organised local church choir with the choir of King's College Chapel, Cambridge. We are a group of keen amateurs who work hard and improve as we go and as well as that, we enjoy our singing. What a pity more people don't sing themselves. Do you sing with the Treorchy?
Of course you're right, why wouldn't you think so? I'll concede that the recording isn't great so I'd probably be far more impressed with your performance if I heard it live.
I'm not very good at contrition but let's just say, those who can do, those who can't just listen. I'm a listener.
Since you see my comment as pejorative and of low quality, I withdraw it.
I am so proud of my Welsh Heritage although ( I am half English). The Welsh are a small nation who never conquered anyone nor lorded it over other nations but kept their language over the massive attempts of the English to destroy yr hen iaith (th old language). I love music and poetry and I am sure that my Welshness has helped in that too.
I enjoyed it very much. I love the sound of a male voice choir and I thought your choir sang it beautifully. There was a great range between the soft and lyrical, and the gutsy! It was also an arrangement that I wasn't familiar with, and that I liked very much.
I want someone's opinion. My mother's father was pure welsh. Somewhere along the line... it... dwindled... so I'm 1/4 welsh. Am I still "Welsh Enough" if you will?
@Musicfan121495 5 of my 8 great grandparents were 100%, and there are traces in the other 3 as well... and the rest is a bit American mongrel, but i know i am still Welsh enough because i do not need to ask and would be happy to get in a punch-up or thump someone with a marrow bone for doubting:-D. does that help you at all?
@Musicfan121495 ppl misunderstand the welsh SOOO bad....having ancersotrs is good for story telling.....but anyone can become welsh culturally and half of being welsh or indeed 'celtic' is but a state of mind
@MrsBloomsburyBarton We do not all have usernames which incorporate our own names. However, if you look through your octogenarian singers you will find my father.
It's in your genes....you can't help it. You feel the hair on your arms stand up when the choirs sing and your voice rises to join in.
Hailstone47 6 months ago
Na mae chwarter Cymraeg ddim yn digon, dim yn ddigon o bell fordd i fod yn onest 'da chdi, ond galle't breddwydio.
lewisgale100 1 year ago
A bit less than a quarter by my reckoning. See our Ar Hyd y Nos!
MrsBloomsburyBarton 1 year ago
Comment removed
crabart73 1 year ago
Comment removed
crabart73 1 year ago
Comment removed
crabart73 1 year ago
Great attempt. Nice to see the english trying to keep up with us!
You sound great boys, best of luck!
killerwelshman 1 year ago
This lot pale into insignificance besides Y Côr Meibion Treorci. That's Treorchy Male Voice Choir to you.
crackpot148 1 year ago
@crackpot148 I could be cruel and say the quality of your comment matches your user name! Comparing Worcester Male Voice Choir with Trorchy isn't really comparing like with like, similar to comparing a keen, well organised local church choir with the choir of King's College Chapel, Cambridge. We are a group of keen amateurs who work hard and improve as we go and as well as that, we enjoy our singing. What a pity more people don't sing themselves. Do you sing with the Treorchy?
MrsBloomsburyBarton 1 year ago 4
@MrsBloomsburyBarton
Of course you're right, why wouldn't you think so? I'll concede that the recording isn't great so I'd probably be far more impressed with your performance if I heard it live.
I'm not very good at contrition but let's just say, those who can do, those who can't just listen. I'm a listener.
Since you see my comment as pejorative and of low quality, I withdraw it.
crackpot148 1 year ago
I am so proud of my Welsh Heritage although ( I am half English). The Welsh are a small nation who never conquered anyone nor lorded it over other nations but kept their language over the massive attempts of the English to destroy yr hen iaith (th old language). I love music and poetry and I am sure that my Welshness has helped in that too.
Aled
ifuliki 2 years ago
Lovely sound.
Am 1/2 Welsh with my father being from Cardiff... Truely the Land of My Father -:o)
Pj.
PaulJeffreys1974 2 years ago
I enjoyed it very much. I love the sound of a male voice choir and I thought your choir sang it beautifully. There was a great range between the soft and lyrical, and the gutsy! It was also an arrangement that I wasn't familiar with, and that I liked very much.
kkkathykk 2 years ago
Welsh and Proud.
johnnee51 3 years ago 3
I want someone's opinion. My mother's father was pure welsh. Somewhere along the line... it... dwindled... so I'm 1/4 welsh. Am I still "Welsh Enough" if you will?
Musicfan121495 3 years ago 8
and i love wales and i'm learning welsh. actually, i'm quite obsessed with wales. i luv it. Cymru am Byth!
Musicfan121495 3 years ago 3
being welsh is all about believing in what you love and hold dear to your heart.
"to be born welsh, isn't to be born with a silver spoon in your mouth - but to have music in your heart, and poetry in your soul"
Dagvalda 2 years ago 2
I am 1/4 Welsh myself, but whenever I hear Welsh singing, I feel my heritage swelling up inside me and while that happenst I feel pure Welsh.
Chernolapkin 2 years ago
@Musicfan121495 5 of my 8 great grandparents were 100%, and there are traces in the other 3 as well... and the rest is a bit American mongrel, but i know i am still Welsh enough because i do not need to ask and would be happy to get in a punch-up or thump someone with a marrow bone for doubting:-D. does that help you at all?
revpgesq 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Na diom yn ddigon i fod yn wir onest 'da chdi, ond gallet breddwydio.
lewisgale100 1 year ago
@Musicfan121495 ppl misunderstand the welsh SOOO bad....having ancersotrs is good for story telling.....but anyone can become welsh culturally and half of being welsh or indeed 'celtic' is but a state of mind
3tangle3 10 months ago
@Musicfan121495 ancestry is nice to have for memories..........culture is more important, all humans invited to enjoy :)
3tangle3 7 months ago
Sorry boys you don't have what we Welsh have and that is hwyl.
easyTaff 3 years ago 2
Lovely!
erinmaxerina 3 years ago
God Bless Wales!
JohnnyNW 3 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
nice tunes boys can we have it in english now...:)
24greenlands 3 years ago
hahaha top(Y)
mcfcliahm 3 years ago
Competent enough . . . for an English choir. But the basses are lacking in tone. No richness. Leave it to us, will you?
fredlark 3 years ago
But half of them ARE Welsh! Who is us?
MrsBloomsburyBarton 3 years ago 3
@MrsBloomsburyBarton I agree. My father sings with the Worcester male voice choir, and he comes from Treorchy!
Galericulus 11 months ago
@Galericulus There's nobody in WMVC called "Galericulus :-)
MrsBloomsburyBarton 11 months ago
@MrsBloomsburyBarton We do not all have usernames which incorporate our own names. However, if you look through your octogenarian singers you will find my father.
Galericulus 11 months ago
@Galericulus Mine doesn't incorporate my own name, I wouldn't want to be saddled with that, even if I were female!
MrsBloomsburyBarton 11 months ago
Na dio'm yn ddigon i fod yn wir onest 'da chdi, ond gallet bredwydio.
lewisgale100 1 year ago
Great video. Just like the one I've got on my laptop. Guys, check out 'Anglesey Slideshow' this music plays
Whybird 4 years ago
would that be egg chasing? :-)
MrsBloomsburyBarton 4 years ago
I did, actually. But one chorus of "O am aros yn ei gariad ddyddiau f'oes" is not the same as hearing the whole thing in Welsh.
Seinegydd 4 years ago
Oh well. We do sing some other songs in Welsh:-)
MrsBloomsburyBarton 4 years ago
Excellent. But why can't we have this in Welsh? (Arwain, Arglwydd, drwy'r anialwch...)
Seinegydd 4 years ago
You haven't listened right to the end;-)
MrsBloomsburyBarton 4 years ago