Added: 4 years ago
From: siamlin
Views: 363,411
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (300)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • one way to get rid of your girl friend just bole her down the ice

  • It was a hit to the head. Could be bad

  • did i read that this ended their career???

  • What happened???

  • I agree with Hawaii. You don't know what happened. If I fell to judge I would just been bruised a bit. It's not that bad. It's your instinct to go and HELP someone just in case their not ok.

    But she must have been ok cause that really couldn't do much damage if he really meant to throw her on the floor. Just falling from that height she is just mostly bruised.

  • I'm kind of confused, she doesn't appear to have hit her head, but she is very  motionless.

  • He is like " go away from me girl" !! lol !!

  • I can't believe that so many people are calling it fake when this accident ended their career

  • Not meaning to sound rude or anything, but it must have been worst then what it looks like, she didn't hit her head and her hand somewhat broke her fall. Hope she's okay

  • I thought it looked like her chin hit the ice, maybe snapping her head. Could've knocked her out? And if she broke her ribs? -a little hard to just get up with broken ribs. She was at a competition; I bet she'd of gotten up if she could. He was spinning her around, to go from that speed, unprepared onto the ice-I doubt anyone here would've just 'walked it off'.' Leave her alone-pain is pain, and everyone has a different tolerance. Besides, that looked bad!

  • WTF is that ruskie saying?

  • but even that was so bad you can not exaggerate and lie motionless, so please

  • @soso97100 if you fall like that you cant just get back up! its actually dangerous to! you HAVE to just lay there and not move.

  • wow that was so hurtful , omgggggggg

  • So sry fo her:(

  • faker

  • @megatallica999 she broke her ribs, or so i heard.

  • he's just like "fuck you bitch" and drops her on her face. lol

  • The man at 1:39 on the right looks like Mr. Bingley from Pride&Prejudice :D

  • Is there blood everywhere or wat is that red stuff????

  • um does any one have this video in ENGLISH???? :P

  • I understand how this could have hurt. But I was doing a double axel in my program one time and i landed flat on my stomach and my hand wasn't even out like Melissa's was here. i got up and finished the program and it wasn't even competition! Sure it hurt, but it was important to me to keep going and it should've have been important to Melissa, too, especially since this was at a competition. Though I don't doubt for a second that it hurt her, I think she overreacted.

  • @ilikepie62 I think she may have had all of the air knocked out of her. And if you've been skating awhile you probably know what that's like. You can't breathe and it's just too much to even move. And I herd that she may have broken a rib or two..

  • did she break her neck?

  • oooooh,i tell you,it is not realy funny to see this!Me,myself,i have also broken my right ankle while having ice skating lessons!!!This sport is not to be messed around with.To be honest,this sport,being dangerous as it is,athletes should be allowed to use protections.But,unfortunately,­this is not the case...What a nasty fall it was!

  • Talk about an Ice Burn! damn!

  • I think people are thinking this doesn't look so bad because in my opinion the clip shown is in very slow motion.....perhaps shown in normal speed can make a difference to show the speed and impact of the throw....I have no doubt the woman is in a lot of pain.

  • probably broken ribs and lots of severe bruising inside her stomach. If it weren't serious...PARAMEDICS wouldn't be out there!

  • @Raquelamithra: yes they would be. Better safe than sorry. And secondly, while I don't doubt that there may have been some serious injuries sustained here it may just as easily have been minor. I have played dangerous and intense sports, like others, and I have and have seen players walk away from much worse.

  • Trust me im 12 and someone tryied hockey stopping in front of me and he missed his timing and slammed into i fell hit the ice on my cheek and flew into the boards and i got up and skated away thats nothing!

  • @jgsstl Were you in the air in that position when you fell??? Obviously not, the centrifugal force was really strong and she flew up in the air and fell. How could you even compare your fall to hers???

  • Okay she hit the ice but she went sliding across the ice not straight down into it. I know ice is hard dipshit try being AM for skateboarding, yes the ground is hard and falling hurts but I've seen toddlers eat harder shit than that and they get right back up. She's being dramatic and weak that's what theyre good for, acting

  • I have fallen many times and this is not bad at all. Must of heart, sure, but no more than any other fall, and its nothing compared to what happens when one goes mountain-biking :)

  • Crimson vibrato they barely fell hard at all. All the force of her fall sent her across the ice not impacting it. Weak

  • @aw4991 Yes, they did. Are you blind, lol? How can you say they didn't impact the ice? What they fell on air? You make no sense.

    Ice is hard. You fall, it HURTS. Just simply falling on your butt hurts, falling like THAT? Come on, use your noodles. :P

  • It may not have looked that "serious" but put it in perspective. Doesn't just simply slipping on ice generally hurt? Imagine falling like THAT, it had to be painful for the both of them. Ice is hard people, and these people don't have paddings or anything. That is exactly why I respect these types of sports: skating, gymnastics...etc. They are sports that generally people who don't know anything about them seem to blow off as "easier" sports if you know what I mean. :P

  • I get the smacking part of her stomach and chest but why is she playing dead?

    She seemed to lay her head pretty smoothly on the ice after the fall.

    I don't get it...

  • I think it is interesting that while this obviously occurred during the warm-up, and she is laying on the ice, and all the other skaters are just like totally ignoring her.

  • Didn't really look like that hard of a hit...but obviously it was. O_o

  • 0:39 she looks like an ice princess.

  • For me, the *really* terrifying part was that I can't even see what went wrong. It looked perfectly fine, and then Petukhov just plain lost the handle.

    The edge of control. And unlike auto racing, it's not just hitting the wall that's the danger.

    And while it MIGHT not have been that serious, I have no interest in ever learning firsthand, thank you very much.

  • @hawaiidkw Well, the worst of injuries are the invisable ones. The internal that we can't see without x ray. So it was probably worse than what they could figure out. But only the doctors at hospital could say what was wrong.

  • Not only did she smack her forehead on the ice, but falling with that much force on your chest & abdomen can fracture the spine, cervical to thoracic. OUCH! :(

  • Lol...nobody was taking care of him. People just walking by. Poor guy.

  • They *have* to avoid him if he may be injured, because any movement risks worsening the injury. Leave that to the professionals, always. If he's okay (and thank goodness he was), politely ask if he wants help. Someone did come by to see if he was all right, and thankfully he was.

    This may seem like a cold sport at times (in every sense of the word), but nobody ever wishes harm on these athletes.

  • i think when she fell on her stomach it looked like here forehead bounced on the ice, which is a hard surface people!

  • wow, whenever i go ice skating it hurts to even fall lightly when i'm barely skating. i could only imagine how it feels to fall like that.

  • Wow what a baby that's nothing compared to the skater totmianina

  • Faker?? She fell on her abdomen. Of course it hurts!

  • I know she didnit even hurt her slef that bad

  • Walk it off , walk it off

  • wait, she didn't even hit her head

  • oh come on ive seen mutch worse check out the video of totmianina and marinin fall which is mutch worse than this faker

  • Thats nothing! They truly are bad!

  • Seriously??! This girl is making it look worser than it is! That was absolutely nothing! The worse injury from that is a bruise. I've seen videos of figure skating girls fall up in the air when their partner tripped. Some even got up after that and skated away.

  • She was probably too embarassed to get up

  • She could have gotten up quickly and it wouldn't seem so bad. Instead she lays there motionless as if she broke her neck or got shot by a shotgun. She should quit being a figure skater and become an actress. Thats an oscar winning performance right there!

  • She probably didnt know what to do next, i guess she figured if she just stay down, others will take on the next roles for her. I don't know. its like when i get embarassed, i want someone to intervene to take the attention off me, lol. but who knows, maybe she was really hurt.

  • I'd never skate with that guy again!

  • I guess she was just in shock of what COULD have happened.

  • Obviously the fall would hurt but seriously shes acting like shes dead.... she didn't hit her head and she landed mainly on her stomach and thigh not even knee..... and one person went over to the guy who actually had more possibility of being hurt.

  • How would you know? You weren't the one who fell... Just because you didn't fall on your head doesn't you mean you can't break your ribs... or something else breakable.

  • @Bromer321

    Keep in mind that was in slow motion - who knows how fast they were moving when that happened. She could've broken a rib, or smacked her face so fast nobody noticed.

  • @SandyRose240 heh no doubt in my mind she is in pain or she would of got up.. however even after reviewing a video in slow mo events don't change or go missing.. ie hitting her head so fast its not on slow-mo.. lol. Its all good tho

  • @Bromer321 I know. I would have helped him. He whacked his head on the wall

  • did u watch jessica dube get sliced in the face by her skating partner?? oh, and ya, totmianina and marinin's fall was pretty hard too....she fell right on her head, OUCH!!

  • @Bromer321 it might not look painful but it probably hurts more than it looks

  • @Bromer321 I think you're wrong. it's slow motion so the speed of the fall isn't visible. And the people would've noticed if she was just acting being unconsious..

  • @Bromer321 She broke her ribs and he hurt is knee and neck

  • she didnt even hit her head, nor did she fall that far before hitting the ice. she just wanted to avoid embarrassment and pretended to be out cold. i play ice hockey, i know how hard ice is (even without padding)

  • el patinaje es hermoso pero muy peligros y es verdad la caida en el hielo duele peor que si fuera concreto

  • It may be look like it's no big deal, but it hurts pretty much. I also slipped in my scratch spin one and even before I could place my hands on the ice,my head hit it and I had to say it was very painful. I laid there for like a half minute and than got ice on my cheek. I had a small concussion.

  • Just don't understand how some people think it's funny...

  • Comment removed

  • easy slip, its obvious

  • hammer throw much? drop iceskating, get into the track and field

  • Euh..elle doit pas avoir eu grand chose!jai déja vu pire sérieux..

  • that guy isnt getting eny pussy that night

  • i'v seen snowboarders bail off 60 foot jumps, get up and keep on riding despite getting a concussion

  • @notyetpro1 There is a major diffrence between snow and ice.

  • agreed. in case notyetpro1 isnt aware, snow is pretty soft and powdery while ice is, ya know, rock solid. it hurts, dude. while im not dismissing the dangers of snowboarding, it's just not the same.

  • falling into deep snow snow is like falling into a foam pit, while falling on ice hurts about as much as falling on concrete.( or worse). but snowboard jumps and half pipes are made out of ice, not soft fluffy snow, look up Shaun whites fall during practice at the x games, he hit his head so hard his helmet fell off his head, and he still got up and won the whole competition the next day

  • there you go. HELMETS. figure skaters dont wear helmets. that helmet is what kept him from cracking his skull wide open, but figure skaters just fall, like melissa did, and have no real way of protecting themselves. plus, snowboarders have all that padding as well. figure skaters have just those skin tight costumes.

  • padding? the only padding that snowboarders wear is a helmet, which did nothing to protect Shaun white because he hit the half-pipe with his chin, he got extremely lucky, he should have a broken jaw right now. any way, snowboarders are usually too stoned to feel any Payne, besides, we cant relay compare the two sports, but if you wanna see a really lucky skateboarder, look up Jake browns mega ramp fall at the x games.

  • they are "icey" but they aren't ice.

  • what does the speaker say? I dont understand him...whats happen to them??

  • It looked like they both just were like "ah fuck I'm taking a nap"

  • lmfao. it really does

  • she landed on her chest and her hip

  • nice throw!

  • hahahhah!

  • It definitely looked as though she winded herself. I fell on my head in 2005 while skating and managed to get back up to skate off. An hour later I was given 20 minutes to live due to a brain haemorrage. Funny thing was I never had that much fussing around me!!

  • I don't get what was bad about this...just looked dramatic.

  • she hurt herself pretty bad

  • The momentum you have from rotating in a lift like that is huge. To be taken from your center of gravity abruptly like that is bad enough, let alone landing on your chest.

  • pues yo creo k se pego mas feo el shavo k ella, pero pues kien sabe jijij

  • i saw Kathy Casey back there!

  • Comment removed

  • unless something realy medically strange happened to her neck or back....otherwise it looked like a clean fall sry to all you Denise and Melissa fans but she seems to be faking.....dunno why but she is.

  • I don't think she was faking, she probably had the wind knocked out of her from landing on her chest, but the personnel have to treat any fall where the skater doesn't get right back up as a potential paralysis so they have to put her on the backboard and immobilize her just in case.

  • yeah it looked like she fell on her arm to me

  • The first time I went ice skating I took a bad fall towards the end of the session and jammed both wrists and my knee

  • Ironic lyrics playing in the background..."every time I see you falling, I get down on my knees and pray."

  • what's scarry is taht she's not that high above the ice.

  • Can someone lay out the fall whitout slow motion

  • OMG is she OK?

  • For all of those idiots who think this was faked or that it didn't hurt, go jump off of a table and land straight on your stomach. Then see if you would say the same thing.

  • This ice is harder than concrete. Much harder actually. Ice is like glass it doesent bend it brakes and so much less of the energy from the inpact is transferred to the ground. It is all taken out on the softer object that hits it. Basic science. You dont want to fall on ice.

  • I don't really think that it's so much the harder than concrete part that makes it so painful, I know through my experience the colder it is the more pain I feel.

  • i felt like her skiing some years ago and it was really horrible!!!!!!!!

  • Do you mean roll off a 1 ft tall table? Stop being so dramatic. This is super weak.

  • @veinsofmercury13 i have and it didnt hurt me superior genetics.

  • LEARN TO WRITE, STUPID!

  • stupid ,, well it was my comment,

  • How did she get so badly hurt. The fall didn´t look so bad. Did he slam his head?

  • I know, at 0:10, her hand touches the ground (which might have lessened the shock) before her entire body hits the ice. ...

    anyway,I do feel sorry for her and i hope she is okay...

  • well that was a slow-mo :) ... when u fall on your chest like that u might damage ur ribs and usually it will be hard to breathe caus of the impact on the lungs (from personal experience lol) and it does send u in a shock...

  • was she ok?....like was there any injuries?...

  • The poor guy must have felt horrible.

  • Not so bad. Just had the wind knocked out of here, and she almost fainted. understandable. But the safty rules require certain actions to be taken. That's why so much attention. Don't want to get sued.

  • she might have broken her hip. sometimes when you fall awkwardly things break. so for all those people that are calling her a pussy please stop.

  • DUDE Her cheek was already opened enough to get operated on! It's crazy for her to go on, she would of got blood all over the arena! I fell a few days ago and I got a huge bruise on my hip and knee, and now EVERYTHING hurts.

  • that's not the same girl

  • Anybody who says that dose not hurt at all is crazy.Those kind of falls even hurt in hockey.I got triped by my goaly and fell right on my chest.I tryed to keep going but after a min. i had to get off the ice i was in so much pain. Now imagien that without pads, going faster and falling from a higher leavel.I only had a burised rib!!!

  • I don't understand, what happened to hurt her? it looked like she fell properly to me. . .

  • ever landed on your face on ice?

  • No, she didn't do a face-plant, but I did write the wrong message on the wrong page, sorry.

    It probably hurt more because she took the crash to the ribs, if you watch her head only touches the ground after she is sliding, and it is her head, not her face.

  • I meant to type here, that I was sorry to hear about your fall, and I agree that falling on anything so solid is very painful.

    Good luck next season!

  • how did she get hurt???

  • I do triple jumps all the time and I had worst falls, and you cant just lay and sit on the floor to cry. she shoulded continue, like the chinese pairs at the olympics, THAT was a truly hard fall, and they WON silver! Thats courage!!

  • Comment removed

  • it looked bad, but ive seen worse and they got up. but, dont listen to me cos it proberly was bad. but she wasnt knocked out..

  • its not that bad?

  • for all of you who are saying shes faking it shutup. im guessing half of you havent even be skating before. they were going at a very fast spead-faster then it looked. and if she was faking it, wouldn't the paramedics have know?? your a bunch of idiots.

  • The video didn't show how fast they were moving. If you're rotating at a high speed and your partner loses his center, it's VERY PAINFUL.

    Don't assume that just because it 'looked' like a minor fall, that it was. It was enough to take them out of the competition, which is the last thing any elite athlete wants.

  • She was probably in shock...it wasn't a horrible fall...there have been worse...but it's still a scary thing, esp with all the accidents lately

  • Why would anyone ever want to PRETEND to get knocked out when you get this far in a competition?

  • Her fingers move, she aint knocked out, guesing catching her breath again

  • To all that thinks the fall was faked: Oh shut up, why don't you take a fall from three feet above the ground and land on your shoulder and see how much that hurts you??!!

  • u have obviously never fallen on the ice becuz if u had u would have known it can hurt pretty bad. so dont be judging her like that, its rude.

  • how could that knock her OUT?? she just fell flat on her stomach and not form a very high point FOR CHRIST's SAKE..

    I think she's being a diva and faking it!

  • hey.. what the hell are you thinkin'... can't you see? it was an accident.. does she want it to happen to her//... and look, why should she fake it asshole? they have been practicing for months and even years for that competition and suddenly she will just make a drama out of that accident.. oh come 'on.. try hurting yourself in that situation, on that position, on that speed, on that exact place..

  • What happened...

  • That's not real.

  • strange that nobody came over.

  • poor Melissa and Denis... I hope they're completely recovered already.

  • it looks like she was faking

  • i agree. she's most probably embarrassed about that fall.

  • It probley knocked her out. tats wat happens to me

  • You people are idiots. People fall all the time. She wouldn't fake that.

  • I have seen worst falls, mmmm, maybe she was tires and she did not want to be in he competition

  • if you didn't wanna compete, would you take a part in the competition? -no!

  • but maybe there happened more than we saw..

  • Then they'd just drop out nimrod. Why would you hurt yourself to get out of a competition?

  • Well trhown

  • ouch! she landed o her boobs, doesnt that hurt? i wouldnt know.

  • hahah yes, it does.

  • And then nothing was said about them during any skating broadcast on ESPN or ABC for the rest of the season. You would have thought that someone (DICK BUTTON, TERRY GANNON, PETER CARUTHERS) could have updated us at somepoint during, I don't know, the GRand Prix finals, The US Nationals, or The Worlds.

  • i've seen worse than that... and they just keep on skating...

    welll it must have hurt alot

  • mucho ouch! wow lol tho