wherever you got the fact that the cannon maintains the 5-point piece value is incorrect. the cannon relies on pieces as screens, so it can attack. as the game progresses, more and more screens or pieces disappear, weakening the cannon. the horse is the exact vice versa, and this contrast, in my opinion is the most interesting think in xiangqi.
Interesting comment! Could you tell us the story about the people who died for calling the piece a king? Maybe it would have been better to have called it a general, but I used king just to make the instructions easier for western chess players. I called "xiang" elephant for both red and green, but red xiang might better be translated as advisor. Anyway, I think the important first step is to learn how to play. The minutiae can come later. What do you think?
@ElephantChess basically, they used to used to use emperors (kings), but a chinese emperor found out and executed them. thus the "king piece" became general.
that is a wierd board, i got mine back in vietnam and it is black and white pieces with some sort of chinese letters, and it doesnt says river on it, it is made out of rock and me and my dad still playing with it :) chinese chess is actually fun
@tatomuck18 actually GO is the best ,because it's the most complicate game ever,NO COMPUTERs can play it well. you can check on WIKI,and there also GO videos on youtube,
@Techno2790 What's your point ? I'm a 5k go player, and yet I wouldn't say it's best, nor worse : they're simply very different games. Players should try go (weiqi for the Chinese), xiangqi, western chess and even shogi. Having a taste of each one, decide which one you find is the most fun and simply go with it.
The values are not 'arbitrary'. They are relative values based on assigned a soldier that has not crossed the river a value of 1. A car/rook has a value of 9, not 10 (you must have a bad board). Horses/knights gain value from about 4 to 5 as pieces are removed from play because there are fewer obstructions for them. Cannons start at 5 and lose value to 4 as pieces are removed because there are fewer platforms to jump over. This is why people do not trade cannon for horse at the very first move.
I was not aware there was a points-system to evaluate the relative strength of the pieces, so that's interesting to me. In my experience, a cannon is powerful in the beginning but weaker towards the end (because there are less pieces to jump over.)
Thanks for your input. I got the values from Lau's book, which is considered one of the important, and few, xiangqi books in English. I know that the Korean version is different from the Chinese version of xiangqi. How about the Vietnamese version? Is it the same as the Chinese version? What do you think - would you trade two knights for a cannon? I feel that a knight is about equal to a cannon, but the values change over the course of the game. Anyway, thanks for your input!
THe vietnamese version is the same and chinese. After all we were dominated by them for thousands of years - Hopefully. But trading 2 knights for 1 canon is not worth it to my idea. It just Depends on what type of pairs you use to cast checkmate i guess. ie Chariot + Chariot | Chariot + Canon etc etc
But once lost a canon the opponent will be greatly weaker to be able to cast check
I'm talking about the Korean version of xiangqi. I included the rules in the instruction manual, but I've never played the game and it's been a while since I looked at the manual.
A traditional XiangQi set would have the words "Chu He, Han Jie" written along the River, Translated as Chu River, Han Boundary, in reference to the Chu Han War that finally resulted in Liu Bang establishing the Han Dynasty around 200 AD. Pawns never move backwards, cannot move diagonal.
There are some similarities between XiangQi and Int'l Chess. Both have Rooks (called Chariot in XiangQi) and Knights (horsemen in XiangQi). 5 Pawns each side in Xiang Qi instead of 8. No queen in XiangQi. Elephants move and attack like Bishops, but they cannot cross the River, thus are only for defence. The King & 2 Guards are confined to the "Palace". Kings move/attack orthogonally, Guards move/attack diagonally. The Cannon piece is unique to XiangQi. It moves like a rook, but "Jumps" to atk.
@ElephantChess can u please tell me where u got your board? a website perhaps? id like to get one with the univeral symbols on the pieces but without the word "river" in english just in chinese:)
You can buy the set from my website or some other retailers that I supply. Set #202 has a plastic board and wooden pieces. If you want a wooden board without English you can buy one online at any other business that sells traditional Chinese chess sets.
Xiang Qi is Chinese, Viets play this game too. Shoqi I think, is the Japanese version of this, very similar, maybe with different rules, I'm not sure. Koreans also have a version of Xiang Qi.
Korean janggi is almost identical to chinese chess, except that they don't have river, the elephant moves by 2x3 rectangle, Cannons don't move like rook, they jump even without capturing, pawns can move sideway without crossing the river. However SHOGI is totally different. Check out HIDECHI's video on that.
There are 2 board games that I don't really comprehend nor played b4: 'GO' & 'Shogi'. Hope I can play after watching ur videos! Cheers! ^ ^ Oh is there any recommended online sites that can play these games? Thanks.
you can try downloading a free verison of shogi around, search in the google using "shogivar". xiangqi also has a freeware system, search for qianghong xiangqi.
i play shogi, western chess, and xiangqi and i like all 3 games for different reasons. i've been playing chess longer so i'm better at it. i like shogi becuase it seems like you can use paratroops. i like chess because it has more long range units and i like xiangqi, the board effects the game play such as the palace and the rivier. i want to learn how to play go. i think xiangqi is the most played game in the world but chess is more known throughout the world and shogi is more popular in japan
Your video was so helpful!! I have bought the game for my son (he's learning chess now, too). I look forward to more videos about strategy techniques! Do you have a website?
Hey man im personally a go player I started playing it just about a month ago and the board I got for go actually has a Chinese chess board on the back so I went threw to look at some videos and found your great videos on it. The game seems to complected for me personally for now at least but I can see my self playing it latter on in my life. And also your shoji video was also very good as well. Any ways great videos very informative and easy to understand make some more when you can.
Your comments mean a lot to me. It makes me very happy to know more people are getting into these games. I am sure that you will enjoy playing xiangqi and shogi in the future.
Do you play both games? I would be interested in reading your impressions as to how the two games compare to each other. I hope more chess players will give xiangqi and shogi a try.
You may be right. I think chess may be better known throughout the world. I just think that xiangqi is actually played more than any game. I've read that xiangqi is the most popular game, and I think the article refers to actual play. However, with the growing popularity of computer games, this may be changing.
but chinese chess is played in china that has over 3,000,000,000 citizens. not all may play but that's where it came form so it probably has a lot more players for the same player:population ratio. so it's probably close.
I have received requests for strategy instruction. Unfortunately, I am not a great player, but I am in the process of making a larger magnetic xiangqi board and I hope to put some more videos up soon. If you have some strategies you could share, please contact me with algebraic notation and comment, and I will try to post your game or moves.
It isnt the worlds most popular board game I thought. Most players can play backgammon (one way to count popular), and chess is the game played the most on competive level.
Interesting comment. As you point out, there are many ways to consider popularity. Of the dozens of articles about world board games I've read, most mention xiangqi as the most played. An estimated 500 million people play actively, and personally, I've never met any Chinese adult or youth who didn't know how to play the game. I don't know how to rate competitiveness, but I believe the Asian Xiangqi Federation is the organization which sponsors the most universally recognized competition.
I invite viewers to submit statistics or sites that have more information about popularity of board games, their competitions, and other such information. Thank you for the though-provoking comment!
eh cause its chinese chess...thats why...but eh tis 3 videos can still help people learn how to play cc....so good job overall...u should make more...
Western chess disliked this 5 times. thanks for teaching me how to play xianqi!
Halokid998 5 months ago
this is the only board game i dont get hehehe... tanx for the help dude :)
CeeEmmz 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Thumps up if you are Chinese.
spore637 8 months ago
i'm chinese and i freaking like you, because you introduce chinese culture to people
fangchengchen 8 months ago
@fangchengchen
Thanks - that means a lot to me!
ElephantChess 8 months ago
@ElephantChess No, thank you :)
fangchengchen 8 months ago
wtf where u get those pieces lol double sided? lmao
RYANMOW 9 months ago
wherever you got the fact that the cannon maintains the 5-point piece value is incorrect. the cannon relies on pieces as screens, so it can attack. as the game progresses, more and more screens or pieces disappear, weakening the cannon. the horse is the exact vice versa, and this contrast, in my opinion is the most interesting think in xiangqi.
spicytuna64 11 months ago
general! two people died for calling it king
Scythemeup 1 year ago
@Scythemeup
Interesting comment! Could you tell us the story about the people who died for calling the piece a king? Maybe it would have been better to have called it a general, but I used king just to make the instructions easier for western chess players. I called "xiang" elephant for both red and green, but red xiang might better be translated as advisor. Anyway, I think the important first step is to learn how to play. The minutiae can come later. What do you think?
ElephantChess 1 year ago
@ElephantChess basically, they used to used to use emperors (kings), but a chinese emperor found out and executed them. thus the "king piece" became general.
Scythemeup 1 year ago
Interesting!
purespirit9 1 year ago
xiang qi, shoqi, and chess are really similair!
noobsdumb 1 year ago
I like how you can see him reading the manual to explain the movements lol! But good video anyways!
Siryphas 1 year ago
that is a wierd board, i got mine back in vietnam and it is black and white pieces with some sort of chinese letters, and it doesnt says river on it, it is made out of rock and me and my dad still playing with it :) chinese chess is actually fun
hydro0228 1 year ago
Which game is better? Chinese Chess or regular Chess?
tatomuck18 1 year ago
@tatomuck18 actually GO is the best ,because it's the most complicate game ever,NO COMPUTERs can play it well. you can check on WIKI,and there also GO videos on youtube,
Techno2790 1 year ago
@Techno2790 What's your point ? I'm a 5k go player, and yet I wouldn't say it's best, nor worse : they're simply very different games. Players should try go (weiqi for the Chinese), xiangqi, western chess and even shogi. Having a taste of each one, decide which one you find is the most fun and simply go with it.
WarBaboon 1 year ago
@WarBaboon I‘m Chinese,and I do play all these games,my point is for different people have different fun,But Go is the most complicate of all
Techno2790 1 year ago
The values are not 'arbitrary'. They are relative values based on assigned a soldier that has not crossed the river a value of 1. A car/rook has a value of 9, not 10 (you must have a bad board). Horses/knights gain value from about 4 to 5 as pieces are removed from play because there are fewer obstructions for them. Cannons start at 5 and lose value to 4 as pieces are removed because there are fewer platforms to jump over. This is why people do not trade cannon for horse at the very first move.
ihateuutube 2 years ago
Thank you for the clarification and excellent explanation. Poor word choice on my part.
ElephantChess 2 years ago
I was not aware there was a points-system to evaluate the relative strength of the pieces, so that's interesting to me. In my experience, a cannon is powerful in the beginning but weaker towards the end (because there are less pieces to jump over.)
wnsk 2 years ago
cool, I'd like to try this, I think you would like the 2-player boardgame "Relapse"
jakrueg2pbg 2 years ago
Are there any xiangqi clubs out there? I would like to hear from you. Please contact me by email.
ElephantChess 2 years ago
umm ur values u say...are very different to ones i have learnt...the ones i learrnt were umm
Rook 10 | Cannon 7 | Knight 3
(this is viet btw xD)
The saying i learnt in vietnamese was
xe 10 pháo 7 ngưa 3 ...you can ask a vietnamese and they will tell you that probs :S
lilmonkeymagic666 2 years ago
Ngựa***
lilmonkeymagic666 2 years ago
Hey-
Thanks for your input. I got the values from Lau's book, which is considered one of the important, and few, xiangqi books in English. I know that the Korean version is different from the Chinese version of xiangqi. How about the Vietnamese version? Is it the same as the Chinese version? What do you think - would you trade two knights for a cannon? I feel that a knight is about equal to a cannon, but the values change over the course of the game. Anyway, thanks for your input!
ElephantChess 2 years ago
THe vietnamese version is the same and chinese. After all we were dominated by them for thousands of years - Hopefully. But trading 2 knights for 1 canon is not worth it to my idea. It just Depends on what type of pairs you use to cast checkmate i guess. ie Chariot + Chariot | Chariot + Canon etc etc
But once lost a canon the opponent will be greatly weaker to be able to cast check
lilmonkeymagic666 2 years ago
Edit: Han Dynasty around 200 BC
danpt2000 2 years ago
Also, if memory serves, I think cannons and rooks can move diagonally within the fortress, is that right?
ElephantChess 2 years ago
huh... Not sure which game you're refering to. but those moves are not in Chinese Xiang Qi.
danpt2000 2 years ago
I'm talking about the Korean version of xiangqi. I included the rules in the instruction manual, but I've never played the game and it's been a while since I looked at the manual.
ElephantChess 2 years ago
A traditional XiangQi set would have the words "Chu He, Han Jie" written along the River, Translated as Chu River, Han Boundary, in reference to the Chu Han War that finally resulted in Liu Bang establishing the Han Dynasty around 200 AD. Pawns never move backwards, cannot move diagonal.
danpt2000 2 years ago
There are some similarities between XiangQi and Int'l Chess. Both have Rooks (called Chariot in XiangQi) and Knights (horsemen in XiangQi). 5 Pawns each side in Xiang Qi instead of 8. No queen in XiangQi. Elephants move and attack like Bishops, but they cannot cross the River, thus are only for defence. The King & 2 Guards are confined to the "Palace". Kings move/attack orthogonally, Guards move/attack diagonally. The Cannon piece is unique to XiangQi. It moves like a rook, but "Jumps" to atk.
danpt2000 2 years ago
In the tournaments which kind of pieces are used?.
davidnalba 2 years ago
Thanks , only good tutorial on Youtube... I bought a xianqi set at a local store.
CUB3FR34K 2 years ago
Thank you.
ElephantChess 2 years ago
@ElephantChess can u please tell me where u got your board? a website perhaps? id like to get one with the univeral symbols on the pieces but without the word "river" in english just in chinese:)
64miguel 1 year ago
You can buy the set from my website or some other retailers that I supply. Set #202 has a plastic board and wooden pieces. If you want a wooden board without English you can buy one online at any other business that sells traditional Chinese chess sets.
ElephantChess 1 year ago
i didnt know western peolpe plays chinese chess
xiaocurrypuff 2 years ago 2
Xiang Qi is Chinese, Viets play this game too. Shoqi I think, is the Japanese version of this, very similar, maybe with different rules, I'm not sure. Koreans also have a version of Xiang Qi.
danpt2000 2 years ago
shogi is quite different but its shares the smae basic idea and origin..
KOGR11 2 years ago
Korean janggi is almost identical to chinese chess, except that they don't have river, the elephant moves by 2x3 rectangle, Cannons don't move like rook, they jump even without capturing, pawns can move sideway without crossing the river. However SHOGI is totally different. Check out HIDECHI's video on that.
naldchow 2 years ago
There are 2 board games that I don't really comprehend nor played b4: 'GO' & 'Shogi'. Hope I can play after watching ur videos! Cheers! ^ ^ Oh is there any recommended online sites that can play these games? Thanks.
comicaluv 2 years ago
you can try downloading a free verison of shogi around, search in the google using "shogivar". xiangqi also has a freeware system, search for qianghong xiangqi.
KOGR11 2 years ago
well i play Xiang qi everyday at school during recess cuz ther eis a board game corner..
well i'm a average player and i always lose to my family members except my grandmother
Takumi0justifaiz 2 years ago
Thank Heavens for grandmothers!
;-)
ElephantChess 2 years ago
i play shogi, western chess, and xiangqi and i like all 3 games for different reasons. i've been playing chess longer so i'm better at it. i like shogi becuase it seems like you can use paratroops. i like chess because it has more long range units and i like xiangqi, the board effects the game play such as the palace and the rivier. i want to learn how to play go. i think xiangqi is the most played game in the world but chess is more known throughout the world and shogi is more popular in japan
oakenguitar3 2 years ago
Thank you!!
Your video was so helpful!! I have bought the game for my son (he's learning chess now, too). I look forward to more videos about strategy techniques! Do you have a website?
Excellent stuff!!!
Slingtownpics 3 years ago
Hey man im personally a go player I started playing it just about a month ago and the board I got for go actually has a Chinese chess board on the back so I went threw to look at some videos and found your great videos on it. The game seems to complected for me personally for now at least but I can see my self playing it latter on in my life. And also your shoji video was also very good as well. Any ways great videos very informative and easy to understand make some more when you can.
Blaze
Pepper500 3 years ago
Hi Blaze,
Your comments mean a lot to me. It makes me very happy to know more people are getting into these games. I am sure that you will enjoy playing xiangqi and shogi in the future.
Best wishes for the New Year of the Ox.
Mike
ElephantChess 3 years ago
I know many people who are very good at chinese chess who switch to chess.
TheJokerRiq 3 years ago
Hi TheJokerRiq,
Do you play both games? I would be interested in reading your impressions as to how the two games compare to each other. I hope more chess players will give xiangqi and shogi a try.
Thank you for your comment.
Mike
ElephantChess 3 years ago
Xiangqi is defiitely not the most famous board game. Chess is definitely much more famous.
TheJokerRiq 3 years ago
Hi JokerRiq,
You may be right. I think chess may be better known throughout the world. I just think that xiangqi is actually played more than any game. I've read that xiangqi is the most popular game, and I think the article refers to actual play. However, with the growing popularity of computer games, this may be changing.
ElephantChess 3 years ago
but chinese chess is played in china that has over 3,000,000,000 citizens. not all may play but that's where it came form so it probably has a lot more players for the same player:population ratio. so it's probably close.
castq3 2 years ago
I have received requests for strategy instruction. Unfortunately, I am not a great player, but I am in the process of making a larger magnetic xiangqi board and I hope to put some more videos up soon. If you have some strategies you could share, please contact me with algebraic notation and comment, and I will try to post your game or moves.
Thank you!
ElephantChess 3 years ago
do you know of a good over-the-internet XiangQi program?
nproject 3 years ago
search for something in flash
PoliomanGamer 3 years ago
Check out the Xie Xie website for a free download.
ElephantChess 3 years ago
well done!~
htxiang 3 years ago
It isnt the worlds most popular board game I thought. Most players can play backgammon (one way to count popular), and chess is the game played the most on competive level.
furrer08 3 years ago 2
Interesting comment. As you point out, there are many ways to consider popularity. Of the dozens of articles about world board games I've read, most mention xiangqi as the most played. An estimated 500 million people play actively, and personally, I've never met any Chinese adult or youth who didn't know how to play the game. I don't know how to rate competitiveness, but I believe the Asian Xiangqi Federation is the organization which sponsors the most universally recognized competition.
ElephantChess 3 years ago
I invite viewers to submit statistics or sites that have more information about popularity of board games, their competitions, and other such information. Thank you for the though-provoking comment!
ElephantChess 3 years ago
I have a chinese chess set but none of friends know how to play chinese chess.
doromamire 3 years ago
Check out the internationalized version of xiangqi on my website. It is much easier to learn using symbols.
ElephantChess 3 years ago
Thank you for your reply.
My xiangqi set is in traditional chinese version.
doromamire 3 years ago
eh cause its chinese chess...thats why...but eh tis 3 videos can still help people learn how to play cc....so good job overall...u should make more...
marcel4a4 3 years ago
I will try to put up a few more videos this summer. Thanks for the positive feedback.
Mike
ElephantChess 3 years ago
eh why do u put the pieces in the international side instead of the chinese words....thats weird....
marcel4a4 3 years ago
Why do you think it's weird?
ElephantChess 3 years ago
most popular board game in the world? no kidding?
nguyen0169010 3 years ago
DUDE!! 1.48 i saw u holding a piece of paper...
are u new to chinese chess?
Santazclausz 3 years ago
Hi Santaclausz,
Thank you for your comment. Actually, I was holding the manual I wrote ~10 years ago. I wanted to get the relative values of the pieces correct.
Thank you for your comment.
Mike
ElephantChess 3 years ago