@MsGera1994 Yeah, thats true, I guess. But still, we are Europeans. Almost the same race. Dont you think? :) Anyway, it would be wonderful if we were together, thats my opinion. Because I like every country in Europe. People, nature, and the cities. Just beautiful! And food for fuck sake!!! :D
@panosmel97 Seriously! Don't be racist! Hated will destroy yourself! I'm sorry for u! I see you have national problems, you're also racist! Racism will turn your life into Hell! Judge people by it's PERSONAL characters, if someone kills a man, another man of his nationality is Saving a life!
Remmember, there are lots of innocent Children in every race, nation whom u hurt saying that..
@MsGera1994 lolololol i was just kidding.i dont want to kill anyone (Not a nation at least just some ppl i know :P) anyways i was kidding. btw i was not referring to tatarsw but to the nation called turkey,there were many wars bewteen us and we were under occupation for nearly 350 years.then when we got our freedom not even half of the totall greeks were there,they were in ottoman occupied lands.so we went in the 1st war which we lost.then 1912 bulgary,serbia,montenergo and greece went in war
@MsGera1994 2) with the ottoman empire whic greece won.later during the end of ww1 greece joined the allies and attacked ottoman empire again occupying smyrna (izmir) the world war ended but turks didnt stop it.they lost the war but didnt want to give up so they performed a genocide killing MILLIONS of armenians and greeks, burning down smyrna.i bet you gonna say 'thats in the past bro' in 1974 they attacked cyprus forcing greeks of the northen part to go the south one or die.
@MsGera1994 well i dont say i hate all turk-ish but forgetting history is not easy.everyone from mother's side has roots in asia minor (where the genocide took place) but i cant say im gonna kill turk-ish people.by the way i thought you were called tattars.and ways if you ever hear a greek talking about turks he is talking about turkey most likely.also we dont even refer to turk-ish people as tattars or turks,we say they came from mongolian lands (central asia) is this where tattars were?
@MsGera1994 thanks.you see greeks or 'hellenes' as we call ourshelfes are not a mix we are descendants of the anicent hellinic tribes (dorian,ionian,achaians) and some other hellinized groups.the magor 3 i mentiones forwars built state-cities (athens sparta) are the most famous.and thats all.so i get confused with multi cultural nations...
@MsGera1994 still weird.like whats different bewteen russia and ukraine?or why isnt austria a part of germany or how can italy be a nation when the northen ones are mostly francs and german like while south ones are greek and 'real' italians
You dumbass Europeans fight with each other instead of making an united empire to protect from ISLAMISTS attacing from everywhere the pure European race. Shame on you, if you don't fo anything, Europe as we know it will disappear!
@AlchemistPure Yes thank you Hitler . Look if we were to unite the USA would stand no chance and furthermore what do you have against Islam the religion . The fact is that we Europeans are extremely racist , not like America who frowns on any meaning of the word . That comes from the fact that we have come to accept this since we are much older countries . Oh and please don't ever say that again because it backfires . America isn't united , it's just under one flag .
I absolutely love the ominous music when the Germanics make an entrance :) But you forgot to add Belgium to the list of German-speakers, we have a small German-speaking minority in the east of Wallonia called the German Cantons. German is also one of the 3 official languages of Belgium, along with Dutch ("Flemish") & French.
@MegaMae021 I won't argue with you on the fact that we are Slavs , but we once wanted to be Greek . You had no problem with it when we we're in Yugoslavia and our name was still Macedonia . I'm not trying to be rude and i would like to hear your opinion . And please understand , it's common bias . Macedonians would withhold for Macedonia and Greeks for Greece . Would really like to hear from you .
Macedonians are greeks like spartans cypriots athenians trojans and e.t.c not slavics. İf u mean the FYROM thats another story. And your video is based on theories they had never proove this. pls make a research about fyrom thank you
@KsanaPaixtou Yeah, Original Balkanic people have nothing to do with Slavs. but I was NOT talking about Macedonian people, I just talked about macedonian language which belong to the slavic family. Iberians were not Latins either until the Roman invasion , but nowadays we speak a Latin language or at least most of us (With the exception of the Basques).
@yotuve87 i repeat pls make a research about it. Macedonian language was greek and nothing greek is belong to slavic family and remove the flag of greek macedonians which belonged to King Philip II and it represents the 12 gods of olympus land sea fire and air and you r representing it as a flag for slavs.
@mistertamarro obviously i can't assure it but what historians say is that before "Hispania" the languages of the Iberian peninsula were Iberian,Celtiberian,Tartessian, Lusitanian (Portugal)... and, of course, Basque (Aquitanian) which probably is the unique survivor of the ancient Iberian language... the same happened in Italy and Etruscan language for example.
The most Swiss(who speak Swiss) would laugh at you if you would say them,our language is a dialect of German. I speak Swiss! It's very very offending to see that you write ''Switzerland'' under this stupid German flag! It's even unpossibel for a German to hoist their German flags here in Switzerland, because the Swiss often destroy them.
@yotuve87 We don't talk German. A lot of Germans say that Swiss-German sounds as a foreign language for them. Swiss-German is a foreign language! ca. 70'000 words we use aren't words of the High standart German. So PLEASE CORRECT this mistake. The big majority of the Swiss say that Swiss-German Is a own language! Pleeeaasse!
@doutdesful11 You are wrong however, Swiss German is just a regional dialect of German. The fact that German language area is so large, has made its dialects very different, and not only when compared to Switzerland, this is the case for Germany itself. As I have studied the state language of Germany as a foreign language, I have yet to find a place in Germany where people don't think I'm from some other part of the country..
We don't speak GERMAN in Switzerland! We speak SWISS-GERMAN that isn't the same. When we talk SWISS-GERMAN the Germans can't understand us. SO YOUR VIDEO IS VERY OFFENDED FOR US! We don't say ''Guten Tag'' you idiot! We say Grüezi or salü or hallo. BUT WE DON'T say ''Guten Tag''. So pleeaaasse correct these huge failure!
@doutdesful11 (Idiot??? I'll ignore it). I know you don't say "Guten tag" there, and?? i'm talking about Laguages, not dialects!! so I have nothing to correct in this case, because Like it or not you speak GERMAN! and doesn't matter if Germans can't understand your DIALECT... you don't even understand other Cantons' dialects within Switzerland.
@yotuve87 swiss-german is a language at its own and quite different from german like dutch is also different from german or even flemish, dutch used german writing only100years ago-still its considered a language.
Having lots of valleys different dialects were created in Switzerland, still the swiss understand their dialects-I am speaking 3swiss german dialects plus french,english,italian and high german---you as latin speaker could be also considered speaking just an italian dialect
@yotuve87 missing in your potpourri of languages is the friulan language, a rhaeto-romance language with 800thousand speakers-its related to the ladin spoken in the Swiss Engadin valley and stretches quite far almost to Venezia.
--if you mention la langue d'Oc you should also mention the friulan--plus don't forget the Plattdeutsch language--which mixed with 40% french became english which considered its the bastardization of french and german and is only borderline a germanic language
@Skyifictionable WHAT R U TALKIN ABOUT? UGRIC INVATION COMES LATE IN NINTH OR TENTH CENTURY,
AND YEAH WELL THE HUNS CAME BEFORE THAT BUT ONLY IN FOURTH CENTURY. BUT ANYWAYS EVEN IF FINO-UGRIOO WAS THERE EUROPE IS ONLY EUROPE WITH US WHITE, ARYAN CALL IT WAHT U WANT PEOPLE. AND WE GAVE THIS CONTINENT ITS NAME. EUROPE IS KNOWN AS A CONTINENT OF INDO-GERMANIC PEOPLE THROUGH ALL ITS HISTORY MAN.
@TRANFUCKER First, take your caps of, it makes you look stupid and arrogant.
Second, INDO-European. Indo short for Indian. Aryan people aren't native to Europe either they originated somewhere in Central Asia. No one is truly native to Europe.
The first people to get to Europe where the Uralic/Finno-Ugric peoples. It is fact, you cannot dispute this
The Ugric people are white; Caucasian that is. Look at a Finnish person.
Indo-Germanic? Never heard of it. I'm not Germanic, I'm Celtic
@Skyifictionable WELL THE CAPS ON IS CUZ I LIKE IT. IF IT MAKES U THINK I'M STUPID THT'S YOUR OWN CRITERIA. INDO-EUROPEAN, IS BECAUSE THAT FAMILY OF LANGUAGES R EXTENDED FROM THE RIVER INDUS VALLEY NORTH OF INDIA TO THE MOST WESTERN BORDER OF EUROPE. DAT THE FIRST PEOPLE TO GET TO EUROPE WERE FINNO-UGRIC, IS NEW TO ME N I MUST GO AND MAKE A SEARCH I GUESS, I'M IN THIS SHIT FOR YEARS AND NEVER HEARD OF THIS IT IS NEW. AND THE UGRIC PEOLPE IS NOT WHITE UNLESS U CONSIDER WHITE ONLY A FKN SKN COLOR
@Skyifictionable MAN OF COURSE WE ARYANS OR INDO-EUROPEANS U KNOW WHAT I'M TALKING ABOUT, ARE NOT NATIVE TO EUROPE I NEVER SAID WE WERE, I ONLY SAID THAT IT IS US ARYANS WHO REPRESENT THAT COUNTRY NO MATTER WHAT OTHER GROUP HAVE EVER BEEN BEFORE, AS FAR AS I'M CONCERNED NEANDERTHALS LIVED IN EUROPE. LATER WE CAME, BUT NEANDERTHALS ARE LONG GONE IT IS US AND OUR HISTORY THAT EUROPE IS KNOWN FOR, AND U HAVEN'T GET ME WELL, I AM NOT DENYIN FINNO-UGRIC PEOPLE WERE IN EUROPE BEFORE US...
@TRANFUCKER I understand where you are coming from but you said the Finno-Ugric people were an invading force. I was just stating that infact they were not and arrived in Europe before Indo-Europeans.
19th century? You are aware this is the 21st century? Modern times = modern terms.
In other words, Indo-European, not Indo-Germanic as Indo-Germanic excludes the peoples of Southern, Eastern and Celtic Europe.
And I was saying you look incompetent because you use caps.
@Skyifictionable EXCUSE ME I THOUGHT I WROTE CONTINENT I WROTE COUNTRY HAHA, WELL ...AS I WAS TELLING U I AM NOT DENYING FINNO UGRIC PEOPLE WERE BEFORE US, AS U SAY, I'M JUST SAYIN' THAT IT IS THE FIRST TIME I HEARD OF IT AND I NEED TO CHECK ON THAT SUBJECT TO CORROBORATE IT, I DON'T HAVE YOUR 100% CERTAINTY. AND CALLING INDO-EUROPEANS INDO-GERMANIC IF WRONG, I AM NOT TO BLAME FOR THAT MAN, NINETEENTH CENTURY ANTHROPOLOGISTS AND LINGUISTS USED BOTH TERMS INDISTINCTLY WHEN REFERRING TO WHAT IS..
@Skyifictionable ...VULGARLY KNOWN AS WHITE PEOPLE. IT'S NOT SOMETHIN' OF MY INVENTION TO USE THE TERM INDO-GERMANIC. SO DON'T SAY THIS LOOKS ME INCOMPETENT I DON'T THINK SO MAN.
@Skyifictionable AND BRO THAT U SAY I SAID U CALLED FINNO-UGRIC PEOPLE ARYAN IS WRONG. I SAID THAT FINNO-UGRIC PEOPLE ARE NOT WHITE BECAUSE U STATED ABOVE THAT THE UGRIC PEOPLE ARE WHITE HERE'S YOUR QUOTE: "The Ugric people are white; Caucasian that is. Look at a Finnish person." AND I SAY IT AGAIN THEY R NOT "WHITE" ARYAN OF COURSE THEY'VE INTERBREEDED A LOT WITH ARYANS, SO THEY HAVE A LOT OF THAT AND SURE THERE IN FINNO-UGRIC COUNTRIES LIVE POPULATION THAT IS 100% ARYAN BUT THIS DON'T...
@Skyifictionable MAKE FINNIC-UGRYANS ARYAN AS I SAID THEY R A MIX OF ARYAN SEMITE, AND MONGOL RACES. AT LEAST THAT IS WHAT ANHROPOLOGISTS GENETISTS AND PHENOLOGYSTS HAVE STATED FOR LONG.
@TRANFUCKER True that, but this still doesn't prove that all of our ancestors were Mongoloid. Many Finno-Ugrics are also Mongoloid because of Mongol invasions in the previous centuries.
@eksiarvamus TO BE FINNO-UGRIC MEANS THAT. THAT PERSON RACIALLY IS A MIX OF ARYAN MONGOLOID AND I AM NOT SURE WHAT ELSE IF THERE'S SOMTHING ELSE. TURKS RACIALLY ARE SEMITE MONGOLOID AND ARYAN. PERHAPS IT'S ABOUT PERCENTAGES FINNO-UGRIC HAVE MORE FROM ARYAN.
@TRANFUCKER Don't you know that the Aryan people themselves (a branch of the Indo-European group) in India look quite dark? Definitely darker than the average Estonian ;)
And the Indo-European ancestors have been mixing with their predecessors and even with Finno-Ugrics aswell. There is no "clean" white race, it's all just a mix of different genes, that make us what we are today. If you are white from the Netherlands, you won't differ much from me, a person from Estonia. That's that
@Skyifictionable BUT WE R TALKIN ABOUT A RACE THAT FOR TO KNOIW WHAT WEE REFFER TO WE USE TO CALL IT ARYAN, IT'S JUST A NAME, WRONGLY USED OR NOT, IS ONLY FOR TO KNOW WHAT WE R REFERRIN TO AND NO FINNO UGRIC PERSON IS ARYAN, THEY R A MIX OF ARYAN SEMITE AND MONGOLOID RACES. AND INDO-GERMANIC IS ANOTHER TERM TO CALL THE PEOPLE THAT MADE THE MAJORITY OF EUROPE THROUGH HISTORY AND THAT SPEAK EVERY INDO-GERMANIC LANGUAGE CELTIC INCLUDED, UNDERSTOOD BY THIS THE ARYAN PEOPLE
@TRANFUCKER Lol, Indo-Europeans are invaders aswell, only that they came later than some of the Finno-Ugrics. The time of arrival should be 1) Baltic-Finns 2) Indo-Europeans 3) Hungarians.
Everyone knows that the Indo-Europeans are the majority and most parts (!) of Europe do belong to Indo-Europeans, but some parts also belong to the Finno-Ugrics, so... get over it.
Actually, there is a mix of 70% Basque and 30% Romani, Spanish and French called Erromintxela, and there are also dead languages of the Vasconic languages, such as Aquitanian and Iberian. There's another alleged very ancient family called Dené-Caucasian, that would link Basque to Chinese dialects, Abkhaz, Cree and Ojibwe.
why the devastating terror music rolling in when Germanic languages come up? We Germanic people are the creators of all of Europe's best classical music.
@loveloving10 What do a few people living in the modern era of Jewish religion have to do with the source of European languages? There is no relationship between Afro-Asiastic languages and Indo-European, you are mistaken and obviously confused about archaeology, linguistics and history. I am Japanese and I clearly know more about Europe and her languages than what I can assume you do from these odd comments. Just research some of your theory you will see that it is faulty.
@loveloving10 What does your theory about middlerners supposedly becoming Europeans have to do with European languages? You obviously have an agenda, and it is clear that you do not favour dispassionate research. European languages have many sources and there are only minimal relations with Afro-Asiastic languages. You seem intent on conflating ethnicity and language. We are indeed all related in some sense but to say that Semitic language spawned European language is false.
@loveloving10 Again you clearly have shown yourself here to have some odd racial agenda about Jewish people which are not a race at all but a religion. That would be akin to saying that these people were not products of Italian and German culture, they were a part of it not some racially based island of productivity. Some strange Japanese people believe similar theories about us and they are completely false. Plus this is about language not Jewish people or operas!
@loveloving10 I am not confused about semites and jews, although you clearly seem to think that they have been the source of all humans and their languages. This discussion is reaching epic ridiculousness when you start claiming that even Japanese culture and language flows from this source by your supposed connection of the word Samurai to Israel. You have a strange theory and it is not factual, not for European languages or Japanese people, stop trolling and study dispassionately
I am not claiming that Japanese people relate to Israelites.
I am just repeating what some researchers are claiming.
I am personally not interested much in the Japanese history. However,the migration of the Semitic speaking Middle-Eastern Neolithic farmers to Europe after the Last Glacial Maximum is an established fact.
People came to Europe from the Middle-East and not from another planet.
@Sociolog26 what songs would fit better with all Slavic Countries? @NorthPro40 is Latgalian a language or a dialect of Latvian? ... after reading something about it , i'm not 100% sure. thanks
This video is not correct because the very name "Indo-European" is wrong.
The roots of the modern European languages: Slavic and Germanic, are in the Semitic Middle-East. All modern European languages were derived from Proto-Semitic language
which was spoken by the Semitic Neolithic Middle-Eastern farmers who repopulated Europe after the Last Glacial Maximum.
@loveloving10 Excuse me love loving but I have no love for your theory, it is wrong. European languages have as much in common with Semitic languages as they do with Hindi or Urdu, which is not much at all. That would be like claiming Japanese is just a form of Chinese which is also foolish and wrong. Go to University and try claiming such nonsense.
The fact that the Middle-eastern Neolithic farmers repopulated depopulated by the last Glacial Maximum Europe is supported by Archeology, Genetics and Linguistics.
In Semitic languages Eretz or Aretz means "land"
From Semitic erets or aretz came arietz or aryan (land dweller)
In English it's "earth" in German "erde"
In Semitic 'hai" means life from which came Germanic "hail"
From Semitic "Shalom' came Germanic 'hallo", English 'hello", Spanish 'hola".
@loveloving10 I am not following your explanation here it does not stand up to research of any kind. There are words in European languages from many different sources, why you are so stuck on the scant relationships with semitic languages is beyond me. The fact remains that European languages are from the Proto-Indo-European languages and that places their earliest sources in the bronze age migrations of people and their languages from the Caucasus and Central Asian Steppe.
@Sociolog26 Oh, if you mean this reason, right you are! )) Really, it is unfairly to use only russian or any other's nation music style... To tell the truth, I believe, all Slavs have to unite alltogether... Politically, at least...
@Sociolog26 Why the author have to change music of Slavic language? Anyway, Russian is the most widespread language in the Slavic world, and the only Slavic language in such organization like UN, for example. ))) So, Russians one of the most recognisable people in the European world from the cultural point of view... So, Why not to change music for German languages, for example?
@Sociolog26 Why the author have to change music of Slavic language? Anyway, Russian is the most widespread language in the Slavic world, and the only Slavic language in such organization like UN, for example. ))) So, Russians one of the most recognisable people in the European world from the cultural point of view...
@xowicked ok, you're partially right it's not an european language but as far as i know, Western Turks are europeans, (i guess more than Rotterdam's mayor). so this fact make their language a language from Europe. . P.S: I didn't classify Georgian as Indo-european language but as Kartvelian (or south Caucasian).
@aitormartin696 "La lingüística y el nacionalismo lingüístico españo"l (por Juan Carlos Moreno Cabrera, catedrático de la Universidad Autónoma de Madrid): youtube. com /watch?v = McnU2uyWfB8
@gabidios0078 jajaja lo he escrito así porque era la única forma de que me entrara el texto entero. pero cómo esta el país!!, es solo mencionar la palabra "Cataluña" y la gente se vuelve loca, efectivamente, los "países catalanes" no existen como unidad política.... pero si cultural... y tanto el valenciano como el mallorquín son el mismo idioma, catalán. así que creo que, al menos lingüísticamente, está bien eso de "Catalan countries".
@yotuve87 hombre, xra q la gente q lo vea y lo ubique sta bien!! (aunq lo mismo a los valencianos y mallorquines no les hace muxa gracia ke les digan ke su lengua es catalán ;)
Some of these languages i never heard before, like Frisian its pretty intresting
RZworld1 2 hours ago
Turkish is NOT European. The differences are immense, how embarrassing of you, an European!
AlchemistPure 1 week ago
@AlchemistPure Technically it is and it isn't more accurate say Eurasia.
hannah60000 6 days ago
@AlchemistPure 3% is in europe though.. but culturally not
MsGera1994 5 days ago
Europe is the shit. I wish we were just one and same country :)
Detektor 1 week ago 3
@Detektor then you'll kill each other.. Irish people with engish, germans with greeks, russians with balts.. u'll destroy each other... better no
MsGera1994 5 days ago
@MsGera1994 Yeah, thats true, I guess. But still, we are Europeans. Almost the same race. Dont you think? :) Anyway, it would be wonderful if we were together, thats my opinion. Because I like every country in Europe. People, nature, and the cities. Just beautiful! And food for fuck sake!!! :D
Detektor 4 days ago
@MsGera1994 we dislike germans (merkel at least) but not people that much. we prefer to kill turks (asia)
panosmel97 2 days ago
@panosmel97 heyyy)) i'm persona of turkiC nation (kazakh).. what we did to you??
What asia have to do with europe? r u racist? hmm? )
MsGera1994 2 days ago
@panosmel97 Seriously! Don't be racist! Hated will destroy yourself! I'm sorry for u! I see you have national problems, you're also racist! Racism will turn your life into Hell! Judge people by it's PERSONAL characters, if someone kills a man, another man of his nationality is Saving a life!
Remmember, there are lots of innocent Children in every race, nation whom u hurt saying that..
Peace, from an asian whom u wanted kill!
MsGera1994 2 days ago
@MsGera1994 lolololol i was just kidding.i dont want to kill anyone (Not a nation at least just some ppl i know :P) anyways i was kidding. btw i was not referring to tatarsw but to the nation called turkey,there were many wars bewteen us and we were under occupation for nearly 350 years.then when we got our freedom not even half of the totall greeks were there,they were in ottoman occupied lands.so we went in the 1st war which we lost.then 1912 bulgary,serbia,montenergo and greece went in war
panosmel97 2 days ago
@MsGera1994 2) with the ottoman empire whic greece won.later during the end of ww1 greece joined the allies and attacked ottoman empire again occupying smyrna (izmir) the world war ended but turks didnt stop it.they lost the war but didnt want to give up so they performed a genocide killing MILLIONS of armenians and greeks, burning down smyrna.i bet you gonna say 'thats in the past bro' in 1974 they attacked cyprus forcing greeks of the northen part to go the south one or die.
panosmel97 2 days ago
@panosmel97 by the word Tuk"S" u mean all turkic nations, nation who live in turkey is Turk"ISH" people.
it's sad to Greece, i'm sorry!. and i think today's people aren't responsible for what their evil Ancesstors made.
Actually, i'm always in the side of justice.. and i'm sorry for our brother nation's ancesstors
MsGera1994 2 days ago
@MsGera1994 well i dont say i hate all turk-ish but forgetting history is not easy.everyone from mother's side has roots in asia minor (where the genocide took place) but i cant say im gonna kill turk-ish people.by the way i thought you were called tattars.and ways if you ever hear a greek talking about turks he is talking about turkey most likely.also we dont even refer to turk-ish people as tattars or turks,we say they came from mongolian lands (central asia) is this where tattars were?
panosmel97 2 days ago
@panosmel97 yes, all turkS came from North Alatai mountains :)
MsGera1994 2 days ago
@panosmel97 also, from Syberia
MsGera1994 2 days ago
@MsGera1994 thanks.you see greeks or 'hellenes' as we call ourshelfes are not a mix we are descendants of the anicent hellinic tribes (dorian,ionian,achaians) and some other hellinized groups.the magor 3 i mentiones forwars built state-cities (athens sparta) are the most famous.and thats all.so i get confused with multi cultural nations...
panosmel97 2 days ago
@panosmel97 Multi cultural nations live funny & joyfully XD
MsGera1994 1 day ago
@MsGera1994 still weird.like whats different bewteen russia and ukraine?or why isnt austria a part of germany or how can italy be a nation when the northen ones are mostly francs and german like while south ones are greek and 'real' italians
panosmel97 1 day ago
@Detektor NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
panosmel97 2 days ago
Russian has way more than 100 million speakers.
Antaraxenox 1 week ago
@Antaraxenox right...100 million are the Native speakers in Europe : 6:43 you can see the number of native speakers Worldwide.
yotuve87 1 week ago
You dumbass Europeans fight with each other instead of making an united empire to protect from ISLAMISTS attacing from everywhere the pure European race. Shame on you, if you don't fo anything, Europe as we know it will disappear!
AlchemistPure 1 week ago
@AlchemistPure Yes thank you Hitler . Look if we were to unite the USA would stand no chance and furthermore what do you have against Islam the religion . The fact is that we Europeans are extremely racist , not like America who frowns on any meaning of the word . That comes from the fact that we have come to accept this since we are much older countries . Oh and please don't ever say that again because it backfires . America isn't united , it's just under one flag .
MegaNekojsi 1 week ago
I absolutely love the ominous music when the Germanics make an entrance :) But you forgot to add Belgium to the list of German-speakers, we have a small German-speaking minority in the east of Wallonia called the German Cantons. German is also one of the 3 official languages of Belgium, along with Dutch ("Flemish") & French.
Synthiotics 1 week ago
beautiful flags :)
MoriAryka 2 weeks ago
Macedonians are Slavs wanting to be Greek
MegaMae021 2 weeks ago
@MegaMae021 macedonians = serbia = Russian people, all slavs people are same
MergimMafia 1 week ago
@MegaMae021 I won't argue with you on the fact that we are Slavs , but we once wanted to be Greek . You had no problem with it when we we're in Yugoslavia and our name was still Macedonia . I'm not trying to be rude and i would like to hear your opinion . And please understand , it's common bias . Macedonians would withhold for Macedonia and Greeks for Greece . Would really like to hear from you .
MegaNekojsi 1 week ago
So much ignorance in the comment section, I don't know where to begin.
Cryptoguy 2 weeks ago
IT IS NOT MACEDONIAN YOU BASTARD GIRL IT IS SLAVIC VARDAC
MACEDONIANSM LANGUAGE WAS AND IS GREEK
GreekArmy57 2 weeks ago
GREEK IS GREEK NOT INDO EUROPIAN!!!
GreekArmy57 2 weeks ago
Macedonians are greeks like spartans cypriots athenians trojans and e.t.c not slavics. İf u mean the FYROM thats another story. And your video is based on theories they had never proove this. pls make a research about fyrom thank you
KsanaPaixtou 2 weeks ago
@KsanaPaixtou Yeah, Original Balkanic people have nothing to do with Slavs. but I was NOT talking about Macedonian people, I just talked about macedonian language which belong to the slavic family. Iberians were not Latins either until the Roman invasion , but nowadays we speak a Latin language or at least most of us (With the exception of the Basques).
yotuve87 2 weeks ago
@yotuve87 i repeat pls make a research about it. Macedonian language was greek and nothing greek is belong to slavic family and remove the flag of greek macedonians which belonged to King Philip II and it represents the 12 gods of olympus land sea fire and air and you r representing it as a flag for slavs.
KsanaPaixtou 2 weeks ago
@yotuve87 and what language he spoke first, "the Roman invasion?
mistertamarro 1 day ago
@mistertamarro obviously i can't assure it but what historians say is that before "Hispania" the languages of the Iberian peninsula were Iberian,Celtiberian,Tartessian, Lusitanian (Portugal)... and, of course, Basque (Aquitanian) which probably is the unique survivor of the ancient Iberian language... the same happened in Italy and Etruscan language for example.
yotuve87 7 hours ago
@KsanaPaixtou
Macedonians are not "Makedons" ! They are mixed by; slavs and cummans and other* ! Makedonia was in Macedonian lands !
Kurucfy1 1 week ago
But anyway you are an Spaniard, so at this way I'm not surprised why your video is so wrong.
doutdesful11 4 weeks ago
@doutdesful11 Sorry, if I was 14 years old I would play with you, but not at my age, it's nothing personal.
yotuve87 4 weeks ago 6
@yotuve87
Bisch en hurä lööli welä vo nüütem ä ahnig hett!
You are a ''Gwagglichopf''!
doutdesful11 4 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The most Swiss(who speak Swiss) would laugh at you if you would say them,our language is a dialect of German. I speak Swiss! It's very very offending to see that you write ''Switzerland'' under this stupid German flag! It's even unpossibel for a German to hoist their German flags here in Switzerland, because the Swiss often destroy them.
doutdesful11 4 weeks ago
Comment removed
doutdesful11 4 weeks ago
look for txikibosti at google if you want to learn basque!!!
txikiportu 4 weeks ago
DUTCH is also spoken in Surinam (South-America) and in South-Africa Afrikaans is spoken wich in my opinion is old Dutch mixed wich exotic words.
jetzers 1 month ago
Nice video but the only disappointment was that you completely overlooked the
1) Indo-Aryan languages of Europe. I was expecting Romani and other dialects spoken by the Gypsies
2) Yiddish, a Germanic language spoken by the Ashkenazim
& 3) The Sami languages of the tribes of northern Scandinavia
But otherwise it is a very good video :) Liked it
SuperSangfroid 1 month ago
@SuperSangfroid ROMANI BASTARDIZED, YIDDISH BASTARDIZED, AND SAMI FINNO-UGRIC NOT INDO EUROPEAN OR INDO-ARYAN
TRANFUCKER 1 month ago
puta perra hija de puta cabrón
doutdesful11 1 month ago
We talk Swiss and not German!
doutdesful11 1 month ago
@yotuve87 We don't talk German. A lot of Germans say that Swiss-German sounds as a foreign language for them. Swiss-German is a foreign language! ca. 70'000 words we use aren't words of the High standart German. So PLEASE CORRECT this mistake. The big majority of the Swiss say that Swiss-German Is a own language! Pleeeaasse!
doutdesful11 1 month ago
@doutdesful11 You are wrong however, Swiss German is just a regional dialect of German. The fact that German language area is so large, has made its dialects very different, and not only when compared to Switzerland, this is the case for Germany itself. As I have studied the state language of Germany as a foreign language, I have yet to find a place in Germany where people don't think I'm from some other part of the country..
eksiarvamus 1 month ago
@doutdesful11 SWISS-GERMAN, SO U ADMIT ITS GERMAN.
TRANFUCKER 1 month ago
@doutdesful11
As a native German I have less trouble to understand "Luxemburgic" (declared as an own language) than Swiss-German.
HesseJamez 4 weeks ago
@MattRodrig
That is correct. We say hoi to friends or family members or any other person who you know well. You don't say ''hoi'' to persons who you don't know.
doutdesful11 1 month ago
The Scandinavians and the Dutch speak English so well that you could have listed those countries in the English flag :P Just joking
MattRodrig 1 month ago
We don't speak GERMAN in Switzerland! We speak SWISS-GERMAN that isn't the same. When we talk SWISS-GERMAN the Germans can't understand us. SO YOUR VIDEO IS VERY OFFENDED FOR US! We don't say ''Guten Tag'' you idiot! We say Grüezi or salü or hallo. BUT WE DON'T say ''Guten Tag''. So pleeaaasse correct these huge failure!
doutdesful11 1 month ago
@doutdesful11 (Idiot??? I'll ignore it). I know you don't say "Guten tag" there, and?? i'm talking about Laguages, not dialects!! so I have nothing to correct in this case, because Like it or not you speak GERMAN! and doesn't matter if Germans can't understand your DIALECT... you don't even understand other Cantons' dialects within Switzerland.
yotuve87 1 month ago 13
@yotuve87 emmm .. there is big difference between dialect, language and languages group.
Sweden - Indoeuropean, Germanic language group, Swedish language.
Bezdievis 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@yotuve87 swiss-german is a language at its own and quite different from german like dutch is also different from german or even flemish, dutch used german writing only100years ago-still its considered a language.
Having lots of valleys different dialects were created in Switzerland, still the swiss understand their dialects-I am speaking 3swiss german dialects plus french,english,italian and high german---you as latin speaker could be also considered speaking just an italian dialect
hyurgy123 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@yotuve87 missing in your potpourri of languages is the friulan language, a rhaeto-romance language with 800thousand speakers-its related to the ladin spoken in the Swiss Engadin valley and stretches quite far almost to Venezia.
--if you mention la langue d'Oc you should also mention the friulan--plus don't forget the Plattdeutsch language--which mixed with 40% french became english which considered its the bastardization of french and german and is only borderline a germanic language
hyurgy123 1 week ago
@doutdesful11 you forgot the "hoi", my swiss friend says it haha but it's not as formal as Grüezi he told me
MattRodrig 1 month ago
@doutdesful11
WTF!!!
hb11bh 3 weeks ago
good job,i can speak polish,english and russian.and thinking to start to learn french.
cezaryjerseybean 1 month ago
The half of the english vocabulary comes from french so....
MrAnaon 1 month ago
Comment removed
vercens 1 month ago
whats the song being played for the Fino-Ugric lanuguages?
silvermoons92 2 months ago
@silvermoons92 Levan Polkka by Loituma. It's a finnish group.
yotuve87 1 month ago
FINO-UGRIC IS NOT EUROPEASN IT IS AN INVADER FAMILY LANGUAGE OF THE URAL-ALTHAI GROUP
TRANFUCKER 2 months ago
@TRANFUCKER It was in Europe BEFORE the Indo-European languages even existed. :L
Skyifictionable 1 month ago
@Skyifictionable WHAT R U TALKIN ABOUT? UGRIC INVATION COMES LATE IN NINTH OR TENTH CENTURY,
AND YEAH WELL THE HUNS CAME BEFORE THAT BUT ONLY IN FOURTH CENTURY. BUT ANYWAYS EVEN IF FINO-UGRIOO WAS THERE EUROPE IS ONLY EUROPE WITH US WHITE, ARYAN CALL IT WAHT U WANT PEOPLE. AND WE GAVE THIS CONTINENT ITS NAME. EUROPE IS KNOWN AS A CONTINENT OF INDO-GERMANIC PEOPLE THROUGH ALL ITS HISTORY MAN.
TRANFUCKER 1 month ago
@TRANFUCKER First, take your caps of, it makes you look stupid and arrogant.
Second, INDO-European. Indo short for Indian. Aryan people aren't native to Europe either they originated somewhere in Central Asia. No one is truly native to Europe.
The first people to get to Europe where the Uralic/Finno-Ugric peoples. It is fact, you cannot dispute this
The Ugric people are white; Caucasian that is. Look at a Finnish person.
Indo-Germanic? Never heard of it. I'm not Germanic, I'm Celtic
Skyifictionable 1 month ago 2
@Skyifictionable WELL THE CAPS ON IS CUZ I LIKE IT. IF IT MAKES U THINK I'M STUPID THT'S YOUR OWN CRITERIA. INDO-EUROPEAN, IS BECAUSE THAT FAMILY OF LANGUAGES R EXTENDED FROM THE RIVER INDUS VALLEY NORTH OF INDIA TO THE MOST WESTERN BORDER OF EUROPE. DAT THE FIRST PEOPLE TO GET TO EUROPE WERE FINNO-UGRIC, IS NEW TO ME N I MUST GO AND MAKE A SEARCH I GUESS, I'M IN THIS SHIT FOR YEARS AND NEVER HEARD OF THIS IT IS NEW. AND THE UGRIC PEOLPE IS NOT WHITE UNLESS U CONSIDER WHITE ONLY A FKN SKN COLOR
TRANFUCKER 1 month ago
@TRANFUCKER Seriously, it makes you look incompetent.
Yes, Indus Valley Indian/Pakistan, hence Indo. The point I was making is that they are not native to Europe
It is fact that Finno-Ugric peoples aka Uralic peoples were in Europe before Indo-Europeans. You can't dispute this, I am 100% certain.
I never said Finno-Ugric's were Aryan. Not sure where you pulled that out of.
Calling "Indo-European" "Indo-Germanic" is wrong. Only about 10 countries out of the 50 in Europe are Germanic
Skyifictionable 1 month ago
@Skyifictionable MAN OF COURSE WE ARYANS OR INDO-EUROPEANS U KNOW WHAT I'M TALKING ABOUT, ARE NOT NATIVE TO EUROPE I NEVER SAID WE WERE, I ONLY SAID THAT IT IS US ARYANS WHO REPRESENT THAT COUNTRY NO MATTER WHAT OTHER GROUP HAVE EVER BEEN BEFORE, AS FAR AS I'M CONCERNED NEANDERTHALS LIVED IN EUROPE. LATER WE CAME, BUT NEANDERTHALS ARE LONG GONE IT IS US AND OUR HISTORY THAT EUROPE IS KNOWN FOR, AND U HAVEN'T GET ME WELL, I AM NOT DENYIN FINNO-UGRIC PEOPLE WERE IN EUROPE BEFORE US...
TRANFUCKER 1 month ago
@TRANFUCKER I understand where you are coming from but you said the Finno-Ugric people were an invading force. I was just stating that infact they were not and arrived in Europe before Indo-Europeans.
19th century? You are aware this is the 21st century? Modern times = modern terms.
In other words, Indo-European, not Indo-Germanic as Indo-Germanic excludes the peoples of Southern, Eastern and Celtic Europe.
And I was saying you look incompetent because you use caps.
Skyifictionable 1 month ago
@Skyifictionable EXCUSE ME I THOUGHT I WROTE CONTINENT I WROTE COUNTRY HAHA, WELL ...AS I WAS TELLING U I AM NOT DENYING FINNO UGRIC PEOPLE WERE BEFORE US, AS U SAY, I'M JUST SAYIN' THAT IT IS THE FIRST TIME I HEARD OF IT AND I NEED TO CHECK ON THAT SUBJECT TO CORROBORATE IT, I DON'T HAVE YOUR 100% CERTAINTY. AND CALLING INDO-EUROPEANS INDO-GERMANIC IF WRONG, I AM NOT TO BLAME FOR THAT MAN, NINETEENTH CENTURY ANTHROPOLOGISTS AND LINGUISTS USED BOTH TERMS INDISTINCTLY WHEN REFERRING TO WHAT IS..
TRANFUCKER 1 month ago
@Skyifictionable ...VULGARLY KNOWN AS WHITE PEOPLE. IT'S NOT SOMETHIN' OF MY INVENTION TO USE THE TERM INDO-GERMANIC. SO DON'T SAY THIS LOOKS ME INCOMPETENT I DON'T THINK SO MAN.
TRANFUCKER 1 month ago
@Skyifictionable AND BRO THAT U SAY I SAID U CALLED FINNO-UGRIC PEOPLE ARYAN IS WRONG. I SAID THAT FINNO-UGRIC PEOPLE ARE NOT WHITE BECAUSE U STATED ABOVE THAT THE UGRIC PEOPLE ARE WHITE HERE'S YOUR QUOTE: "The Ugric people are white; Caucasian that is. Look at a Finnish person." AND I SAY IT AGAIN THEY R NOT "WHITE" ARYAN OF COURSE THEY'VE INTERBREEDED A LOT WITH ARYANS, SO THEY HAVE A LOT OF THAT AND SURE THERE IN FINNO-UGRIC COUNTRIES LIVE POPULATION THAT IS 100% ARYAN BUT THIS DON'T...
TRANFUCKER 1 month ago
@Skyifictionable MAKE FINNIC-UGRYANS ARYAN AS I SAID THEY R A MIX OF ARYAN SEMITE, AND MONGOL RACES. AT LEAST THAT IS WHAT ANHROPOLOGISTS GENETISTS AND PHENOLOGYSTS HAVE STATED FOR LONG.
TRANFUCKER 1 month ago
@TRANFUCKER I don't know, go and look the Hungarians (Ugrics) or Finns and Estonians (Baltic Finns), they look quite European ;)
eksiarvamus 1 month ago
@eksiarvamus WELL SOME ARE INDO-EUROPEAN BECAUSE OF MIGRATION, OR MIXING.
TRANFUCKER 1 month ago
@TRANFUCKER True that, but this still doesn't prove that all of our ancestors were Mongoloid. Many Finno-Ugrics are also Mongoloid because of Mongol invasions in the previous centuries.
eksiarvamus 1 month ago
@eksiarvamus TO BE FINNO-UGRIC MEANS THAT. THAT PERSON RACIALLY IS A MIX OF ARYAN MONGOLOID AND I AM NOT SURE WHAT ELSE IF THERE'S SOMTHING ELSE. TURKS RACIALLY ARE SEMITE MONGOLOID AND ARYAN. PERHAPS IT'S ABOUT PERCENTAGES FINNO-UGRIC HAVE MORE FROM ARYAN.
TRANFUCKER 1 month ago
@TRANFUCKER Don't you know that the Aryan people themselves (a branch of the Indo-European group) in India look quite dark? Definitely darker than the average Estonian ;)
And the Indo-European ancestors have been mixing with their predecessors and even with Finno-Ugrics aswell. There is no "clean" white race, it's all just a mix of different genes, that make us what we are today. If you are white from the Netherlands, you won't differ much from me, a person from Estonia. That's that
eksiarvamus 1 month ago
@Skyifictionable BUT WE R TALKIN ABOUT A RACE THAT FOR TO KNOIW WHAT WEE REFFER TO WE USE TO CALL IT ARYAN, IT'S JUST A NAME, WRONGLY USED OR NOT, IS ONLY FOR TO KNOW WHAT WE R REFERRIN TO AND NO FINNO UGRIC PERSON IS ARYAN, THEY R A MIX OF ARYAN SEMITE AND MONGOLOID RACES. AND INDO-GERMANIC IS ANOTHER TERM TO CALL THE PEOPLE THAT MADE THE MAJORITY OF EUROPE THROUGH HISTORY AND THAT SPEAK EVERY INDO-GERMANIC LANGUAGE CELTIC INCLUDED, UNDERSTOOD BY THIS THE ARYAN PEOPLE
TRANFUCKER 1 month ago
@TRANFUCKER Lol, Indo-Europeans are invaders aswell, only that they came later than some of the Finno-Ugrics. The time of arrival should be 1) Baltic-Finns 2) Indo-Europeans 3) Hungarians.
eksiarvamus 1 month ago
@eksiarvamus PERHAPS BUT THE CONTINENT THE WHOLE OF IT IS OURS INDO-EUROPEAN PEOPLEWE'VE ALWAYS BEEN THE MAJORITY, AND THE MAKERS OF ITS HISTORY
TRANFUCKER 1 month ago
@TRANFUCKER Seriously, how old are you?
Everyone knows that the Indo-Europeans are the majority and most parts (!) of Europe do belong to Indo-Europeans, but some parts also belong to the Finno-Ugrics, so... get over it.
And please, why the capital letters?
eksiarvamus 1 month ago
Armenian is dealed as a non-indo-europian language even though it IS a indo-european language.
finjpnKyabia 2 months ago
@finjpnKyabia NO, you are wrong. Armenian is dealed as "Other Languages"
yotuve87 2 months ago
@yotuve87 Armenian is indo-european language as well,look it up on wikipedia.
Fivaprold 1 month ago
@Fivaprold oh yeah? thanks but look it up at 6:25, "FAMILY:" look it up before speaking!!
yotuve87 1 month ago
@yotuve87 sorry 6:21
yotuve87 1 month ago
Actually, there is a mix of 70% Basque and 30% Romani, Spanish and French called Erromintxela, and there are also dead languages of the Vasconic languages, such as Aquitanian and Iberian. There's another alleged very ancient family called Dené-Caucasian, that would link Basque to Chinese dialects, Abkhaz, Cree and Ojibwe.
Raphacom123 2 months ago
why the devastating terror music rolling in when Germanic languages come up? We Germanic people are the creators of all of Europe's best classical music.
konnichiwa53 2 months ago
@konnichiwa53
I used to think that it's Italians who have created opera and the best classic music.
Although Giuseppe Verdi was an Italian Jew.
Jacques Offenbach was a Prussian Jew.
And there were many others and Germans were among them but not the only.
loveloving10 2 months ago
@loveloving10 What do a few people living in the modern era of Jewish religion have to do with the source of European languages? There is no relationship between Afro-Asiastic languages and Indo-European, you are mistaken and obviously confused about archaeology, linguistics and history. I am Japanese and I clearly know more about Europe and her languages than what I can assume you do from these odd comments. Just research some of your theory you will see that it is faulty.
konnichiwa53 2 months ago
@konnichiwa53
European people came from the Middle-East, they did not fall from the sky.
Is not it obvious.
loveloving10 2 months ago
@loveloving10 What does your theory about middlerners supposedly becoming Europeans have to do with European languages? You obviously have an agenda, and it is clear that you do not favour dispassionate research. European languages have many sources and there are only minimal relations with Afro-Asiastic languages. You seem intent on conflating ethnicity and language. We are indeed all related in some sense but to say that Semitic language spawned European language is false.
konnichiwa53 2 months ago
@loveloving10 Again you clearly have shown yourself here to have some odd racial agenda about Jewish people which are not a race at all but a religion. That would be akin to saying that these people were not products of Italian and German culture, they were a part of it not some racially based island of productivity. Some strange Japanese people believe similar theories about us and they are completely false. Plus this is about language not Jewish people or operas!
konnichiwa53 2 months ago
@konnichiwa53
You are confused about Semites and Jews.
To be a Semite does not mean to be a Jew, although, to be a Jew does mean to be a Semite, a descendant of Sem, the eldest son of Noah.
Jews constitutes only one of the many existed Semitic tribes.
The Semitic speaking Middle-Eastern Neolithic farmers moved to Europe long before Jews came into existence.
Speaking about Japan.
Some connect Japanese people with Israelites.
Like the name samurai with Samaria, the city in Israel.
loveloving10 2 months ago
@loveloving10 I am not confused about semites and jews, although you clearly seem to think that they have been the source of all humans and their languages. This discussion is reaching epic ridiculousness when you start claiming that even Japanese culture and language flows from this source by your supposed connection of the word Samurai to Israel. You have a strange theory and it is not factual, not for European languages or Japanese people, stop trolling and study dispassionately
konnichiwa53 2 months ago
@konnichiwa53
I am not claiming that Japanese people relate to Israelites.
I am just repeating what some researchers are claiming.
I am personally not interested much in the Japanese history. However,the migration of the Semitic speaking Middle-Eastern Neolithic farmers to Europe after the Last Glacial Maximum is an established fact.
People came to Europe from the Middle-East and not from another planet.
loveloving10 2 months ago
@Sociolog26 what songs would fit better with all Slavic Countries? @NorthPro40 is Latgalian a language or a dialect of Latvian? ... after reading something about it , i'm not 100% sure. thanks
yotuve87 2 months ago
what's the name of the song played for the Romance Languages???
TheJsamayoa 2 months ago
@TheJsamayoa it's "Now We Are Free" by Lisa Gerrard. very popular song, in fact it's Gladiator film's main theme.
yotuve87 2 months ago
This video is not correct because the very name "Indo-European" is wrong.
The roots of the modern European languages: Slavic and Germanic, are in the Semitic Middle-East. All modern European languages were derived from Proto-Semitic language
which was spoken by the Semitic Neolithic Middle-Eastern farmers who repopulated Europe after the Last Glacial Maximum.
loveloving10 2 months ago
@loveloving10 but in modern times Indo-European languages are spoken mainly in Europe and India.
dtrez09 2 months ago
@loveloving10 No, European languages are not related to Arabic or Hebrew, sorry, but no
RapperWar 2 months ago
@loveloving10 Excuse me love loving but I have no love for your theory, it is wrong. European languages have as much in common with Semitic languages as they do with Hindi or Urdu, which is not much at all. That would be like claiming Japanese is just a form of Chinese which is also foolish and wrong. Go to University and try claiming such nonsense.
konnichiwa53 2 months ago
@konnichiwa53
The fact that the Middle-eastern Neolithic farmers repopulated depopulated by the last Glacial Maximum Europe is supported by Archeology, Genetics and Linguistics.
In Semitic languages Eretz or Aretz means "land"
From Semitic erets or aretz came arietz or aryan (land dweller)
In English it's "earth" in German "erde"
In Semitic 'hai" means life from which came Germanic "hail"
From Semitic "Shalom' came Germanic 'hallo", English 'hello", Spanish 'hola".
And so on...
loveloving10 2 months ago
@loveloving10 I am not following your explanation here it does not stand up to research of any kind. There are words in European languages from many different sources, why you are so stuck on the scant relationships with semitic languages is beyond me. The fact remains that European languages are from the Proto-Indo-European languages and that places their earliest sources in the bronze age migrations of people and their languages from the Caucasus and Central Asian Steppe.
konnichiwa53 2 months ago
@Sociolog26 Oh, if you mean this reason, right you are! )) Really, it is unfairly to use only russian or any other's nation music style... To tell the truth, I believe, all Slavs have to unite alltogether... Politically, at least...
Svarustar 2 months ago
@Sociolog26 Why the author have to change music of Slavic language? Anyway, Russian is the most widespread language in the Slavic world, and the only Slavic language in such organization like UN, for example. ))) So, Russians one of the most recognisable people in the European world from the cultural point of view... So, Why not to change music for German languages, for example?
Svarustar 2 months ago
@Sociolog26 Why the author have to change music of Slavic language? Anyway, Russian is the most widespread language in the Slavic world, and the only Slavic language in such organization like UN, for example. ))) So, Russians one of the most recognisable people in the European world from the cultural point of view...
Svarustar 2 months ago
You only mentioned 2 Baltic languages. What about Latgalian?
NorthPro40 3 months ago
@NorthPro40 I agree with you!
Svarustar 2 months ago
Love the music on the Germanic languages.
MYN4M3IS4M3 3 months ago
good video but you should put georgian music on georgian description :(
TSsharaba 3 months ago
@TSsharaba sorry, you know what happens with bordering countries, anyway for me Georgia will always be Europe.
yotuve87 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Free Girona! Catalan fascist oppressors out of our earth!
GIRONA IS NOT CATALONIA!!
Gerona libre!! opresores fascistas catalanistas fuera de nuestra tierra!!
GERONA NO ES CATALUÑA!!
Girona lliure! opressors feixistes catalanistes fora de la nostra terra!!
GIRONA NO ÉS CATALUNYA!!
MrGironalliure 4 months ago
Turkish is not european language. Why would you even mention this scum.
Btw, georgian belongs to the caucasian language group not indoeuropean.
xowicked 5 months ago
@xowicked ok, you're partially right it's not an european language but as far as i know, Western Turks are europeans, (i guess more than Rotterdam's mayor). so this fact make their language a language from Europe. . P.S: I didn't classify Georgian as Indo-european language but as Kartvelian (or south Caucasian).
yotuve87 5 months ago 2
aki el úniko fascista eres Tú Prouderac1!!
aitormartin696 6 months ago
@aitormartin696 "La lingüística y el nacionalismo lingüístico españo"l (por Juan Carlos Moreno Cabrera, catedrático de la Universidad Autónoma de Madrid): youtube. com /watch?v = McnU2uyWfB8
prouderac1 6 months ago
@prouderac1 txakuuuurraaaa!!! vete a kagaarlaaa!!
aitormartin696 6 months ago
esta bien el video, pero los países catalanes no existen!! existe cataluña y no es un país,,
gabidios0078 6 months ago 2
@gabidios0078 Qué obsesión tenéis los fachillas racistas contra los catalanes, por dios...
prouderac1 6 months ago
Comment removed
gabidios0078 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@prouderac1 fachilla racista lo será tu madre!! TU ADEMÁS DE FASCISTA ERES UN IGNORANTE!!
gabidios0078 6 months ago
@gabidios0078 la verdad, marcada como Spam!!
aitormartin696 6 months ago
@gabidios0078 jajaja lo he escrito así porque era la única forma de que me entrara el texto entero. pero cómo esta el país!!, es solo mencionar la palabra "Cataluña" y la gente se vuelve loca, efectivamente, los "países catalanes" no existen como unidad política.... pero si cultural... y tanto el valenciano como el mallorquín son el mismo idioma, catalán. así que creo que, al menos lingüísticamente, está bien eso de "Catalan countries".
yotuve87 5 months ago
@yotuve87 hombre, xra q la gente q lo vea y lo ubique sta bien!! (aunq lo mismo a los valencianos y mallorquines no les hace muxa gracia ke les digan ke su lengua es catalán ;)
gabidios0078 5 months ago