Towering, overwhelmingly powerfull, with fervour yet warm expression, long sheer endless lines and notes sung in forte -seemingly effortless, excellent italian idiom, unmatched in commanding force. Martti Talvela.
I disagree with those who dislike Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau's Giovanni: I think he's superb in this role, and the blend of his and Flagello's voices is also excellent: each distinct and reconizable, butnever in conflict or competition.
@SoulNotes1 Yes - many lions out of a big forest! And yet I just read that when he was going to sing this at the Salzburg Festival in 1968 with Herbert von Karajan conducting, HvK wanted him to use a microphone... Martti was Not Pleased!! He 'thundered, "Karajan's arranging for me to sing with a microphone! He wants a metallic voice. He thinks I haven't got the volume. Brings me a microphone! God's sake!"' (roughly translated from Pekka Hako's biography) XD!!
I have heard this scene in this specific recording probably hundred times-one of my favourite opera scenes in the opera of operas(E.T.A. Hofmann) so admirably described by Hesse in Steppenwolf and so outstanding a performance by the definitiv Commendatore Martti Talvela. Fervour, intnesity, beauty, drama... I am so glad I know this recording since my teenage years. Phantastic.
amazing scene. too bad dieskau is the d.g. with those awesome voices that are flagello's and talvelas. such virility, then dieskau's ever so tenoral voice... just doesn't fit in.
is this Ferenc Fricsay ?
operalover67 2 months ago
@operalover67 - Karl Bohm conducted this performance.
DeclanVB84 2 months ago in playlist Favorite Opera Excerpts
Kurt Moll and Samuel Ramey just can't be beat.
watch?v=dK1_vm0FMAU
MrMicMan12 10 months ago
Towering, overwhelmingly powerfull, with fervour yet warm expression, long sheer endless lines and notes sung in forte -seemingly effortless, excellent italian idiom, unmatched in commanding force. Martti Talvela.
reviewsvoiceontube 10 months ago 4
..die Stimme Talvela´s formt die Botschaft dieser Szene auf einer einizartigen Weise.
johan52312 10 months ago 2
@johan52312 ...auf eine unvergleichlich eindringliche Weise-mit einer angemessenen Dominanz und in jenseitiger Gewissheit ruhenden Kraft.
reviewsvoiceontube 9 months ago 2
Aw Talvela didn't showboat the low D
zegermans750 10 months ago
I disagree with those who dislike Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau's Giovanni: I think he's superb in this role, and the blend of his and Flagello's voices is also excellent: each distinct and reconizable, butnever in conflict or competition.
tones3d 11 months ago
FINALLY! I've been wanting to find a recording of Talvela as Il Commendatore, but never could. Thank you!
BorisGodunov 1 year ago
Talvela is magnificent. Dieskau is of the most refined singers of his generation, but Don Giovanni is not his role.
LordoftheTrapdoors 1 year ago
What a magnificent volume Martti had for a bass! Just sheet magnificence... he could roar a few lions out of a forest!
SoulNotes1 1 year ago
@SoulNotes1 Yes - many lions out of a big forest! And yet I just read that when he was going to sing this at the Salzburg Festival in 1968 with Herbert von Karajan conducting, HvK wanted him to use a microphone... Martti was Not Pleased!! He 'thundered, "Karajan's arranging for me to sing with a microphone! He wants a metallic voice. He thinks I haven't got the volume. Brings me a microphone! God's sake!"' (roughly translated from Pekka Hako's biography) XD!!
tahileki 1 year ago
Don Giovanni sounds scared although he doesn't want to admit he is... I LOVE it!
nnmakowska 1 year ago 2
I have heard this scene in this specific recording probably hundred times-one of my favourite opera scenes in the opera of operas(E.T.A. Hofmann) so admirably described by Hesse in Steppenwolf and so outstanding a performance by the definitiv Commendatore Martti Talvela. Fervour, intnesity, beauty, drama... I am so glad I know this recording since my teenage years. Phantastic.
reviewsvoiceontube 1 year ago 5
OMG Martti is so handsome ... and That Voice, oh wow ... I go weak at the knees even when he's being scary!!!
tahileki 1 year ago
amazing scene. too bad dieskau is the d.g. with those awesome voices that are flagello's and talvelas. such virility, then dieskau's ever so tenoral voice... just doesn't fit in.
marcellny 1 year ago
@marcellny Dieskau is certainly no Giovanni....
brodsky96 1 year ago
man Talvela is a beast....
keithtwa 1 year ago
Talvela! Nielsen is also wonderful in the performance!
TheWisemonkey8 1 year ago