C'est vraiment de la merde, les Français ne sont pas doués pour les dessins animés, les personnages sont vraiment moches et mal faits, arrêtons le massacre ! Laissons aux Japonais avec leurs mangas, le monopole de la création artistique dans ce domaine...
Je suis Français...mais au vu de ce désastre et de cette nulité je n'ai pas pu m'empêcher de critiquer.
AMAZING!!!!! I LOVED IT!!! Wish there were more people doing classic animation it can be so beautiful! Amazing job!! The style and and the colors the mood, everything worked so well, i wish there were more films like this!!!! Bravo!!!
why is there not a european "Pixar" already? There's more than enough talent, which is proven each semester with these short films, to make beautiful feature length animated films.
What an amazing short, for those that says they dont get it, it is about the self destructive masochism that comes about from Isolation, Andre obviously can't make friends with anyone else because of his language barrier issues as observed from the cafeteria scene. Seeing his only friend leaving prompts a lot of negative psyche in him and the wolf with the hovering knife is a visual metaphor for self destruction. I havent seen an animated short with this much depth since "Ryan"
@jinnaboy Hm, it seems I cant find this "Ryan" short you mention, could you link me or give me some info of it's author or something? it seems after Ryan Woodard's brilliant "Thought of You" you cant find anything else related to "ryan" and "animation short". Have you seen "more" or as it's also known "happy product"? it's also very deep.
@jinnaboy Thank you, I think having the author's name did the trick =). Dont worry about the link thing, youtube does that so people dont spam random penis enlargement websites. next time you can just send a private message to the person or post it replacing the dots for the word dot, as in site dot com.
@reddo619 I'm thinking the same thing! I looked them up in cartoonbrew and there's a lot more shorts made there that I loved I didnt know they were from students of that school
Man, I can't count how many times I've watched this, this film is ridiculously good, great pacing, incredible restraint. Congrats guys. Truly awesome.
@Conceptualgamer1 It's a school in France where they teach animation. It's one of the best in the world. Once a year they show all the projects their students ahve finished. Subscribe to the channel and you'll be happily surprised in a year or so.
la premiere fois que j'ai vu la video j'ai eu peur !!
mahin25320 3 weeks ago
Chut... Tais-toi et agis au lieu denigrer.
NASHtux 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
C'est vraiment de la merde, les Français ne sont pas doués pour les dessins animés, les personnages sont vraiment moches et mal faits, arrêtons le massacre ! Laissons aux Japonais avec leurs mangas, le monopole de la création artistique dans ce domaine...
Je suis Français...mais au vu de ce désastre et de cette nulité je n'ai pas pu m'empêcher de critiquer.
erakingofsea 2 months ago
Comment removed
erakingofsea 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
This is an excellent animation. That closing shot alone was so poignant.
Oecobius33 2 months ago
Alcohol causes hallucination
jeanclaudejunior 3 months ago
French is a language that can make hardened oil-rig workers seem like sophisticated romantics.
peeeesh 5 months ago 13
Sachant que les dialogues sont intégralement en français ça aurait été de bon ton de sous-titrer AUSSI les dialogues en anglais non ? -__-
dragondor712 7 months ago
@dragondor712 y a quoi, 2 phrases en anglais ? et de niveau 6ième...
blqckdeqth 6 months ago
c'est pas souvent qu'on en voit avec des dialogues et franchement ça marche super bien.
Fatfrontflip 7 months ago 4
I started clapping when it was finished, even though I'm alone behind my copmuter. wow, wgat great story telling!
UsTheInvincible 7 months ago in playlist Films de fin d'études 2011 5
This is incredible!
style5animation 7 months ago
AMAZING!!!!! I LOVED IT!!! Wish there were more people doing classic animation it can be so beautiful! Amazing job!! The style and and the colors the mood, everything worked so well, i wish there were more films like this!!!! Bravo!!!
siliconneedle 7 months ago
why is there not a european "Pixar" already? There's more than enough talent, which is proven each semester with these short films, to make beautiful feature length animated films.
its2009 7 months ago 4
What an amazing short, for those that says they dont get it, it is about the self destructive masochism that comes about from Isolation, Andre obviously can't make friends with anyone else because of his language barrier issues as observed from the cafeteria scene. Seeing his only friend leaving prompts a lot of negative psyche in him and the wolf with the hovering knife is a visual metaphor for self destruction. I havent seen an animated short with this much depth since "Ryan"
jinnaboy 7 months ago 6
@jinnaboy Hm, it seems I cant find this "Ryan" short you mention, could you link me or give me some info of it's author or something? it seems after Ryan Woodard's brilliant "Thought of You" you cant find anything else related to "ryan" and "animation short". Have you seen "more" or as it's also known "happy product"? it's also very deep.
conceitarturo 7 months ago
@conceitarturo Ryan, an animated documentary by Chris Landreth. i dunno why but youtube is not letting me post the link here
jinnaboy 7 months ago
@jinnaboy Thank you, I think having the author's name did the trick =). Dont worry about the link thing, youtube does that so people dont spam random penis enlargement websites. next time you can just send a private message to the person or post it replacing the dots for the word dot, as in site dot com.
conceitarturo 7 months ago
Greatest Gobelins film I've seen yet, I think.
Saturnome 7 months ago
it gets better every year
BigDaddy7O 8 months ago
The second it started I was gripped by the animation.
Then the story was really interesting. Though I'm confused...it was still very deeply affecting.
YoshidoriAnimation 8 months ago
I need to enrole in this school, great animation
reddo619 8 months ago 2
@reddo619 I'm thinking the same thing! I looked them up in cartoonbrew and there's a lot more shorts made there that I loved I didnt know they were from students of that school
conceitarturo 7 months ago
@conceitarturo unfortunately iam half way around the world and broke LOL
reddo619 7 months ago
magnifique, poignant
honee17honee 8 months ago
Man, I can't count how many times I've watched this, this film is ridiculously good, great pacing, incredible restraint. Congrats guys. Truly awesome.
Wes
TheLibrabear 8 months ago
Amazing!
Z3uS2 8 months ago
C'est tellement beau que ça m'énerve...
gaetanlehobbit 8 months ago
Woah, that was surprisingly dark for a gobelins short. Absolutely incredible though!
Oppurtunafish 8 months ago
Vraiment trés beau, j'ai adoré.
Baloo51 8 months ago
Interesting symbol of a wolf.
Tagraff 8 months ago
This is haunting. My name is also Andre.
bloteshame 8 months ago
Bravo les gars, ambitieux et de bonne tenue!
croumic 8 months ago
damocles
CMichaelEH 8 months ago
beautiful style!
CMichaelEH 8 months ago
Thanks for the replies.
I subscribed ages ago. its a really cool channel.
Conceptualgamer1 8 months ago
J'ai beaucoup aimé le tout. La ligne graphique et les cadrages sont délicieux.
padder2 8 months ago
amazing
amatsu1614 8 months ago
Andre was half a friend, he only thought about him self, he didn't wish best for his friend, he wasn't happy for him...
DrAlexandrius 8 months ago
Absolutely beautiful
themo8pie 8 months ago
That was Great!!!!!!!!!!!!! The best to come out of the school in a while! It's like a moving comic! Congrats to the team
messytimbo 8 months ago
Really good! Loved it.
thatsoundsdelicious 8 months ago
are these animated films all by the same studio? Ive tried looking up gobelins but I cant find anything at all.
Conceptualgamer1 8 months ago
@Conceptualgamer1 It's a French art school. These films are made by its students. :)
Phroshy 8 months ago
@Conceptualgamer1 It's a school in France where they teach animation. It's one of the best in the world. Once a year they show all the projects their students ahve finished. Subscribe to the channel and you'll be happily surprised in a year or so.
Slug99 8 months ago 33
This has been flagged as spam show
Best so far, amazing!
Sulicius 8 months ago
Awesome
GargantuanHunter 8 months ago
Comme dirait mon ami philosophe Scott Bakula : Oh Bravo.
gcassuto 8 months ago
Bogossitude maximal
pilpoilanim 8 months ago
cool copain!
Khelian 8 months ago