Jessica Simpson vs. Carrie Underwood

[robinsonjamie04]

carrie underwood duh

[BlueBear26]

carrie of course

her high notes dont sound strained like jessica's

[1bounce234]

Jessica

[powmia21]

JESSICA

[SexiVirgoGirl]

Wow...before watching this vid, I probably would have said Carrie but now I saw Jessica hands down. But it's like ppl don't want to listen to Jessica anymore. I don't know why...I still like her music.

[danielmendezdrummer]

jessica is the best !!!

[lankapk]

Carrie b/c she's classier

[maggggggggic]

Jessica simpson all the way

[WildAtHeart100]

Carrie Underwood. When she sings long notes they seem to come more natural and Jessica's seem forced.

[lizzyvance]

I like both. Carrie is my pick.

[fruitx4yay]

I think Carrie's voice is more powerful.

[vocalskills]

Don't know who Jessica is but she shits all over Carrie a hundred times lol...

[Carlos91091]

jessica better voice

[taffycool]

Jess, of curse l ;)

[pescatkd]

Jessica Simpson por supuesto, una diosa!!!!

[FullofAwesomeness101]

They're awesome!!!! :)

I dnt even kno on this one.

Man, Jessica was the best wen she was younger. She kinda struggles to get some of those notes nowadayz.

[withyouiam18]

Carrie. Jessica trys to hard.

[thebestofY0UTUBE]

Carrie Underwood

[johnnynwendie]

By Far JESSICA SIMPSON!!!!!! She is soooo beautiful!!!

[njl32091]

Well, lets look at the ratings....

hmmm.......

Carrie hands down

[CarrieLegendary]

Carrie is better

[robinsonjamie04]

Carrie...duh

[cool3465]

carrie underwood is my girl i love her so much she has inspired me to sing i am a pretty good singer i'am a average singer i am good though. i try my best thats how you win

[qtpie92484]

Carrie underwood by far!!!!

[b3astm0d3r]

carrie

[joshrexrode08]

they are both amazing but sometimes jess sounds amazing and other times her voice sounds freaky it is so weird, but i like country and carrie always sounds great so ill go with carrie

[saveskii]

Jess!

[sexxypariss]

JESSICA!

(love carrie too though)

[NastyKreap]

jessica wins by far in everything!!!

[muscle25ftl]

Awesome clip! Are those the names of the notes they are singing? I like them both, but Jessica is the best singer there hands down.

[ablesoftball]

carrie all the way

[LingLingRox]

when did jessica simpson song with patti labelle?

[maggggggic]

Jessica

[jackson4socks]

Jessica

[derriknoack]

Jessica Simpson.

[71A08]

i have to say Carrie. I like Jessica but theres something about her voice thats irritating. .. But she has a great voice aswell.

[keonawashere]

jessica.

her voice sounds so much better ad is much more pleasant to my ears.

[maggggggic]

jessica

[punkprincess660]

jess tony romo baby

[singerprissy]

Jessica

[brokeeeeeeeeeeee]

both girls are awesome¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡

[miluska1988]

jessica all the way!!

[CasZjEE]

Jessica Duhh =D

[icebra]

Jess.

[suicas]

jess

[barksalotvergara]

jess wins hands down

[deadworms]

jessica

[jackson4socks]

Jessica has a very good voice, but she's fucking retarded half the time. she's completely short-bus when she sings, spazing out...awful!

However, her voice is great! she's a belter, like Carrie is, except Jess is a better belter while Carrie has an unfortunate tendancy to be pitchy quite often. Jess is the better singer, while Carrie is considerably less challenged. :-)

[derriknoack]

Jess>carrie

Goooo Jessica!

[13junior15]

I just Like Belting

[musiclover872008]

wow same here i didnt know jessica could belt like that but damn,she just owned carrie,seriously

[Sam7svu]

Agreed! :D

[teamsimpson1]

jess can blow omg!

[pobee88]

OMG I never realized how awesome Jessica Simpson's voice is! i knew it was good, but not this great..

[KellyFan4Lyfe08]

I'm obviously a huge kelly clarkson fan but out of these 2 i'd have to go with jessica,she killed that G5 her range is higher then carries,carrie cant hit a G5 shes just hit a F#5/G5,JESSICA ALL THE WAY