যে লোকটা সারা জীবন যৌবনের, নুতনের, সবুজের খোঁজ করে মরল, তার এটা খারাপ লাগত, এটা মানতে পারছি না...যদি নতুন করে আবিষ্কার নাই করতে পারি, তাহলে আর পুরনোটাকে এতো ঠাকুরঠাকুর করা কেন?
.r jara 30-40 doshoker gaaner dhoron niye pore achhe tara sobai ottonto uchchu maner sangeet boddha?...RNT-r gaan ke chhoriye deoar jonno ei rokom application dorkar...atleast na hole ei gaan gulo kotota kaalojoyee ta promaan kora jabe na!
actually,this is not a remix.it is a experimental job.so.we sud encourage it..however it is...and being a music director and composer...i sud say..that in music all sorts of experiments are allowed..and we can even see that even tagore had implemented some of the western tunes in some of his songs...now , in those days the western songs were like that..and nowadays,the songs have become more modified.thats all.many experiments are done to invent and discover new things.so its a great job..;-)
i am a singer and have been singing Kabiguru's songs al my life. I have also studeid English Literature all my life. So, in retrospect, personally i dont think one of the greatest minds/hearts of all times would mind his song being ADAPTED to the times. Long live Tagore, long live the dynamics of the changing times.
plsss rabindranath ke rabindranather moto thakte din.... tini jodi POP/Rock e akhhom hoye thaken bole mone hoy tahole tar akhhomota tuku sporsho kora to dure thak khuje pawar khomota tao apnader ba amader hoyni.......'
@ritadrik well.. i dont quite agree with you.. we all grew up listening to Tagore songs.. but today's kids have no idea about these beautiful Tagore creations.. u tell them to listen to one n they'll try n shrug it off.. i think it's a great idea to make it hummable for this generation too.. at least they'll listen n probably love it .. and these "re-mixes" aren't that bad to totally banish them.. i m sure Tagore wont mind if he comes across these adaptations.. so relax !!
i guess this is a beautiful remix version... musically very good... and in philosophical way the song's interpretation has changed in a more contemporary way! there should not be any problem with that! if you really have to keep rabindrasangeet alive we have to do this kind of effect more... with changing generation the traditional way might not suit for the coming generation...
@sumanlondon excuse me, but wouldnt you call that the beauty of TAGORE songs. They transcend time and make sense not just to a select few (like me who has been with Kabiguru and Literature all my life) but to all!
the guy commented below me is an idiot. A little learning is always a dangerous thing.What you know about sin or virtue? what you know about creator? How dare you judge Rabhindranath !
Well robindranath wish not be in the heaven as he has done all the dirty and sinful things. As he was underqualified person and you can see many of his works related to sinful ideas, against the creator and religious perfection. So he must be in the hell and must enjoy these.
certified shanti niketanites n tanpua harmonium ne shikha rabhindra sangeet pp,l would like to tell u that u r not having the only rights over gurujii's song those r for us too who like to give it modern sound..
n yes for all ur knowledge wud like to tell u that d songs gurujii has recorded in his own voice were of latin irish tune. so he made them all western during his time only n by himself. so just grab it
certified shanti niketanites n tanpua harmonium ne shikha rabhindra sangeet pp,l would like to tell u that u r not having the only rights over gurujii's song those r for us too who like to give it modern sound..
n yes for all ur knowledge wud like to tell u that d songs gurujii has recorded in his own voice were of latin irish tune. so he made them all western during his time only n by himself. so just grab it
ya ... rabindra sangeet k niye western dhaache notun vabe record obossoi kora jai ... bt somehow lyrics er sathe eta jaina for this song ... its a sweet song ... not hard rock ... shreya is awesome in this song ... bt some extra added things are irritating .. its not that i dont like western ... or m a fond of classical rabindra sangeet ... if u wanna hear what some one can do which is soothing for ears listen to the songs of the film "mon amour" .... just to check how to mix or "remix" ...
As a Bangladeshi musician I have to say that movies like these don't do justice to Bangalis of Bangladesh really. I mean, to start with, the very name "bong" for Bangla is derogatory since a ganja-smoking pipe is also known as "bong". Bangladesh is just not a country of floating debauched vagabonds that this movie aims at showing. This type of cinematic discrimination should be scrutinised carefully before they are allowed to find a place in our markets here.
I happen to see the movie on Zcafe yesterday night-cum morning from 3 to 5 am.........too Bengali morning ....but the movie was a subtle reflection on the change of mindsets of NRI and the hypocrisy that still prevails among them...........as a character of Rita a brat turned good at end but was sad to know about the character like Rakesh Ganguly......a second class american......well people like them are every where but to the same free birds are ready to break out........a good work
বেচারা রবীন্দ্রনাথ। এটা না কোরে অন্য একটা ভাল গান তো লিখে তাতে সুর দেওয়া যেতে পারত। this is a sacrilege of something divinely beautiful । এরকম নির্লজ্যতা অচিন্ত্যনিয়।
@IAZADC :রবীন্দ্রনাথ এর কিছু হাছে কিনা জানি না তবে আপনি অসুস্থ হবেন এইটা সুইনে যে আসল গান এর দর্শক মাত্র ২৫০০০ আর এই movie তার গান এর দর্শক ৪২৫০০০, তাই বলি old is gold হতে পারে তাই বলে নতুন গান হীরা হতে পারে না কেন ?
@IAZADC hahahahha! it would be massive rather than a major one. Nachiketakey sroddha kori....darun ekta album korecchey o Ustad Rashid khan-er songey(called Yatra)...ar ekhaney eto keno khepe gelo ei ganta gawar jonno ta bhogai jane. besh kichu taka peyecchey nischoi. Rabithakurer copyright uthey geccheto. Nachi, i still respect u....and don't want to lose it.
Very very nice creation ... Please pardon me if it seems rude. Ami abangali meye kintu bangali bou. I accept Robindra Songit is eternal. But for people like me its monotonous and some times it gets boring as well, as most of the songs are slow. But this is a very nice way to make Rabindra Songit spread. Let both kind of songs reach public. Now its our choice what we want to listen. This way at least we get a chance to know Rabindra Songit.
Rabindranath went to England in 1878 at the age of 17. After his return from England he composed a music drama "Balmikiprotiva". After grand success of this he composed another musical drama "Kalmrigoya" in few years. Both of these contain songs were based on western music.
Phoole Phoole dholey dholey bohey ki ba........ is an adaptation from the irish song named "Ye Banks and The Braes of Bonnie Doon".(You can check it out in youtube if you wish to) Call it a copy, a remix, a makeover or an inspiration; the great poet himself was surely not against it.
So people who claim that Kobiguru would be unconscious after hearing this version are surely mistaken.
As traditional that I am, and I would never belive that I would ever say this.. but I kinda like it... I think that credit needs to be given for the attempt... For those of us, who absolutely love Tagore and his work, will find this offensive, but for the newer generation, who is not interested in Tagore at all.. and doesn't care about Tagore's work, for them, this is a great introduction to the wealth of art in Tagore.
Why are we destroying our heritage for commercial exploitation!!! this is absolutely unacceptable... Bikram you are one educated Chap, and trained and in classical, I admire you how ever how can you be a part of such crap. Can you ever dream of writing a lyrics like this !!!! STOP EXPERIMENTING WITH TAGORE!!!!
KHUKU 41----Experiments r always welcome. Film tar prosongeh ei gaan hoyto thhik aachhe. D male singer ki Nachiketa ? Na, typical 'Bong sentiment' noy----but moneh
serokom daag kaatlona- sorry ! Anyways, a good try .
We can enjoy this song a a song but as a Tagore song, may be many views. Whatever those, this song has to be evaluated as a part of that film "The Bong Connection". The bengali boy who returned from US trying to touch his roots from US background. So, its a fine attempt. But regarding video one can say " it could have been adjusted with the lyrics of song (rainy Day with strong turbulent wind). If you can reach west and new generation with Tagore, where is the Problem?
@Tupunsayan : Jar hoy, tar hoy, aamader hoy na :) (excerpt from Shesher Kobita).. It is very much vital for the new generation to see Tagore's work from their viewpoint, and this is an example... if I hear this version of the song playing in a car full of youngster... it will make me happy, I rather hear this than loose this great culture
This is a new attempt...Some would like and some won't...I like both the versions...I think we bongs love to live in the past...We had only 1 Rabindranath, 1 Satyajit Ray, 1 Sourav Ganguly..and we keep chewing the cud rather than producing something as good as them...I think we should move ahead and be open to new things....
Sick of this stupidity. U lal la = U lal la asinine. The composition is on baul did the idiot recomposer has any sense? Who is the braying man singing? Must be the recomposer.
Priyaranjan da i didnt get what was so stupid abt this video, the song is abt free sprit and if u consider free sprit as stupidity then may be u fall in the group most commonly known as intelectual aatel !!!!
I think the song is good...Music changes with generation ..we shudnt compare with original...however I felt that the video is not at all modern ..its very cheap but the song is good!!
Hey sorry to have caught up with this a lil late.... frankly i love this score. I think its aesthetically done and can be played even on your car audio... cant imagine playing rabindra sangeet otherwise while driving, no matter how close we all are to these songs because we have grown up listening to them.
@sandatta1963...do u think dere is any chance of creating another rabi thakur?...no way...i am focsing on dis particular song and its music...apni probably sristi r srastar moddhe gulie felchen..hve u seen dis movie?..thats perfect match wid d scenario..rabi thakur k nie samalochonar sahos bodhhai amar & apnar karor e nei..chalte chaltei natun path pao jai bose thakle noi..seta nahok chena path thekei suru holo....wht do u think?
rabi thakur to durer katha ekta sachin dev athaba salil chowdhury o habena. yes I have seen the movie. if u scroll down u will see. Yes it is a good match for the scenario. But tar mane ei noi je the song attained any class when played outside the context of the movie. As a bengali I have certain expectation when u touch rabithakur.... it is about the song not the movie. if u want to cont. this pls reply on my msg otherwise it doesn't come to my mailbox and I don't come back here to check msg.
what i can tell....unless and until u try to do something different.........u cant survive in dis competitive world.....bt changes shld be in +ve way....r serom bichar korle rabi thakurer to oneeek sur western music theke copy kara ba inspired....amra to proudly accpt korechi sei sob gan even vry popular o.....eventually i can see everything has its own way,,,,u cant say anything bad vry quickly....dont 4get law off relativity...ultimate add 1 more dimension that is TIME.. sandatta
rabithakurer gaan khubi kam sankhyay influenced by western music, most of them came naturally during his in Britain and his love of Scottish folk music. He incorporated it absolutely in Indian way like he did with baul, kirtan, tappa,carnatic not for popularizing his music but for enriching it. Creative people are passionate and get influenced and create new things completely original. not by putting few nonsensical word before a song and trying to sound 'cool'. that is called selling.
and couldn't add in my last comment due to limitation of size. I appreciate your civil tone and not trying to judge me and instead of focusing on the subject here. Rabindranath is a brand name and survived 100 years in this competitive world unlike most of our latest creation. If we are still creative lets try to create another brand like him instead of piggy backing on him. That is in my view not courage, it is cowardice and ineptitude.
i dont understand why people dont wnt change.....for a change it is excellent..r .....legally eta r biswabharatir ekar sampatti noi.......even it is a good move to make rabindrasangeet more popular.........but i love 2 listen sagar sen, debabrata biswas too
There are few things in life I would appreciate if left untouched (at least this way). I happen to see this movie a very stereotypical portrayal of Bengal and Bengalis in US. Just putting a funky tune to a Tagore song is not experiment. It is shows your lack of sensitivity and understanding. As someone says you killed the original song now what you do with the bones and ashes no one cares.
yes I can decide what I like or not. That is what I wrote. Please read carefully. And to answer your question if you don't like something which people have adored in its form for 100 years why not create something original which will may survive for 100 years. Instead of doing the easy thing 'experimenting' on the Tagore? Yes sir I know I can't change your view in 500 words but nevertheless I want to document it that I absolutely detest it. any problem with that?
ppl liked "it" becoz they did not have the taste of alternate genre's of music, becoz they did not have the guts to accept anything different, becoz they never dared, and thats why every bengali outside bengal is scorned upon, who
hide behind the wall of intellectual snobbishness.
also i'd like to add that i'm very proud of being a bengali, a independent bengali of today
that's fine with me. you have your view and I have mine. let me express my view loud and clear. It is sad to see that people need to mix coco cola to taste nectar. That's all I have to say.
Just Fata Fati.....Rabindranath ke venge chure natun vabe gora......Fresh Blood in a Fresh Body.....Full of Youthness.....Jai Hooooo.........!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
why didn't I die before listening to this horrible experiment with Rabindrasangeet? There are few experiemnt on tagore songs that are good but at least they tried to keep the soul of the song.
Grow up. People started listening to Robindrosongeet after this. The next generation needs to know what is in there. If we don't change ourselves, its our loss...its our society's loss.
@LBiolSci you should die like a taliban commander and stay in hell after death. This is an experiment with Tagore's music... and people are liking it.. "brishtir nesha bharaa sondha bela kon baloraam-er ami chyalaa... aha!!!" Nachiketa's voice is superb here with this new words added into the golden song.
The kids are so international looking. Like my son and my daughter. I regularly exchange music with people on the Internet and you are with this and other songs part of my pride. I love passing this tune to my English and American Friends all of whom love it. Keep it up kids! People don't criticize to this degree unless they have a hate agenda. There is nothing wrong in repackaging the classics to keep them alive. The oooll llla oola la hey -it works. Good looking people making great sounds.
I read some of the comments on here with horror! How petty minded and small for these pyjama-wallas to belittle an amazing cheerful and colourful presentation. I am 57 and I was tapping my feet and swinging with the tune.
টিটু দত্ত,গত এক বছর ধরে যা প্রতিক্রিয়া এখানে জমা হয়েছে তাতে দেখা যাচ্ছে দুটু ধারা।এদের সবাইকে নিয়েই কিন্তু "বাংলা"।সময়-এর স্রোতেই সঠীকতা বিচার হবে! আর হ্যা,আমার বয়স ৪১।
I think the soul of that song just died in this remix. Use of new instrumental technics + mordernizing of the rythm is ok. But sometime you should not play with the origin/root to make it more beautiful. Root is just root. For an example, you can not go beyond the Big bang of the Universe, its beyond human imagination. You can just look it through Habol telescope.. If you realy want to feel the soul of Rabindra Shangeet, then go back to origin. Just my 2 cents..
Tagore tomader prophet naki heeee? lol!
Japan, U.K, U.S beeeeesh pucheeeee Tagore ke! lol
nadeemstine 1 month ago in playlist Bong Connection
যে লোকটা সারা জীবন যৌবনের, নুতনের, সবুজের খোঁজ করে মরল, তার এটা খারাপ লাগত, এটা মানতে পারছি না...যদি নতুন করে আবিষ্কার নাই করতে পারি, তাহলে আর পুরনোটাকে এতো ঠাকুরঠাকুর করা কেন?
MrDhruba88 1 month ago
.r jara 30-40 doshoker gaaner dhoron niye pore achhe tara sobai ottonto uchchu maner sangeet boddha?...RNT-r gaan ke chhoriye deoar jonno ei rokom application dorkar...atleast na hole ei gaan gulo kotota kaalojoyee ta promaan kora jabe na!
subhammukherjeersgis 2 months ago
atleast amra jara Europe-e thaki tader khub kachakachhi pouchote perechhe ei version-ta...ekhane to surer kono golmal ghoteni...sudhu matro kichhu notun beats added hoyechhe....rabindrasangeeter songe indian classical mesalei jodi khub bhalo hoye (eg. Yatra)...tahole western Funks mesale setar jaat jabe keno?....west-e ki nimnoruchir manush thake?...
subhammukherjeersgis 2 months ago
jini nijeke khola hawa-ye bhasiye dite cheyechhilen, take atkano to tar-e asroddha,...RNT nijer gan-e Pankaj Mallik-er sur sun-e setakei rakhte bolechhilen (diner seshe)...ei gaan-ta-e Pagla hawar asol unmadonata khuje pawa jachchhe....
subhammukherjeersgis 2 months ago
mast hai
mishtirupu1990 3 months ago
Heart sherey gachhe, Guru bhaalo achhe; bolechhe aamake chhariye de shapto shurer paraag bhore; Guru-ke niye khel-lei Guru-r proti sreshtho shroddhha janano hoy.
dranandamay 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Heart sherey gachhe, Guru bhaalo achhe; bolechhe aamake chhariye de shapto shurer paraag bhore; Gure-ke niye khel-lei Guru-r proti sreshtho shroddhha janano hoy.
dranandamay 4 months ago
Heart sherey gachhe, Guru bhaalo achhe; bolechhe aamake chariye de shapto shurer paraag bhore; Gure-ke niye khel-lei Guru-r proti sreshtho shroddhha janano hoy.
dranandamay 4 months ago
actually,this is not a remix.it is a experimental job.so.we sud encourage it..however it is...and being a music director and composer...i sud say..that in music all sorts of experiments are allowed..and we can even see that even tagore had implemented some of the western tunes in some of his songs...now , in those days the western songs were like that..and nowadays,the songs have become more modified.thats all.many experiments are done to invent and discover new things.so its a great job..;-)
Apan750 4 months ago
i am a singer and have been singing Kabiguru's songs al my life. I have also studeid English Literature all my life. So, in retrospect, personally i dont think one of the greatest minds/hearts of all times would mind his song being ADAPTED to the times. Long live Tagore, long live the dynamics of the changing times.
surodeep82 5 months ago
plsss rabindranath ke rabindranather moto thakte din.... tini jodi POP/Rock e akhhom hoye thaken bole mone hoy tahole tar akhhomota tuku sporsho kora to dure thak khuje pawar khomota tao apnader ba amader hoyni.......'
ritadrik 5 months ago
@ritadrik chup...
arinch1 5 months ago
@ritadrik well.. i dont quite agree with you.. we all grew up listening to Tagore songs.. but today's kids have no idea about these beautiful Tagore creations.. u tell them to listen to one n they'll try n shrug it off.. i think it's a great idea to make it hummable for this generation too.. at least they'll listen n probably love it .. and these "re-mixes" aren't that bad to totally banish them.. i m sure Tagore wont mind if he comes across these adaptations.. so relax !!
factsays 4 months ago
Creativity, in all forms, should be encouraged
TruFrndisg28 5 months ago
I am glad that those restricting undemocratic 50 years are over now .... Finally art is free ....
sumittechkgp 6 months ago
@netnew ...u r a kid who stays in home does not go out and reads all bullshit..right..thought so . gofukurself u dumbfuk
rajatmig29 7 months ago
i guess this is a beautiful remix version... musically very good... and in philosophical way the song's interpretation has changed in a more contemporary way! there should not be any problem with that! if you really have to keep rabindrasangeet alive we have to do this kind of effect more... with changing generation the traditional way might not suit for the coming generation...
ronydrocker 7 months ago
এই প্রথম রবিন্দ্র শুনে ভাল লাগল । সব রবিন্দ্র সঙ্গিত REMIX করতে বল না কেন তাকে ? তাহলে তো আমরাও শুনতে পারি ।
kaloakhy 7 months ago
nice one
69sujoy 7 months ago
Why Tagore songs? Why?? don't you got whole lot of shits in the world to fit in the rubbish movies???
sumanlondon 8 months ago
@sumanlondon excuse me, but wouldnt you call that the beauty of TAGORE songs. They transcend time and make sense not just to a select few (like me who has been with Kabiguru and Literature all my life) but to all!
surodeep82 5 months ago
Luv This song!! Rabindre Sangeet wth a western touch! Beautifully sung by Shreya Ghoshal!!
IAMPRESILLA 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
oooooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiaaaaaaaaaaaaaaiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii
yyeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
guess...............
this is the felicitation for the creator
psarit2 8 months ago
oooooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiaaaaaaaaaaaaaaiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii
yyeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
guess...............
this is the felicitation for the creator
psarit2 8 months ago
the guy commented below me is an idiot. A little learning is always a dangerous thing.What you know about sin or virtue? what you know about creator? How dare you judge Rabhindranath !
jasso28 8 months ago
Well robindranath wish not be in the heaven as he has done all the dirty and sinful things. As he was underqualified person and you can see many of his works related to sinful ideas, against the creator and religious perfection. So he must be in the hell and must enjoy these.
netnew 8 months ago
certified shanti niketanites n tanpua harmonium ne shikha rabhindra sangeet pp,l would like to tell u that u r not having the only rights over gurujii's song those r for us too who like to give it modern sound..
n yes for all ur knowledge wud like to tell u that d songs gurujii has recorded in his own voice were of latin irish tune. so he made them all western during his time only n by himself. so just grab it
tiapakhii 8 months ago
certified shanti niketanites n tanpua harmonium ne shikha rabhindra sangeet pp,l would like to tell u that u r not having the only rights over gurujii's song those r for us too who like to give it modern sound..
n yes for all ur knowledge wud like to tell u that d songs gurujii has recorded in his own voice were of latin irish tune. so he made them all western during his time only n by himself. so just grab it
tiapakhii 8 months ago
What Rubbish .What a insult to our Guriji. Please stop this madness,whoever dared to do this
F.h
ferdousehannan 8 months ago
What Rubbish .What a insult to our guriji. Please stop this madness,whoever dared to do this
F.h
ferdousehannan 8 months ago
Ulla lla Ulla lla....Ulllaa Laa....
This music director is fit for B-graded bengali films...
"Times have change and keep on changing"
@abagchi77
Baba tao buro hoye geche .. get one from the market...Rascals..
bapan1977 8 months ago
times have changed and keeps on changing.....
we should accept the change, graciously
abagchi77 9 months ago
Ooo la la
Ooo la la
Oooo la la Heeeeyyy
Ooo la la
Ooo la la Heeeeey! that guy is majorly hot. Like Keanu Reeves, but with more than one facial expression.
pezkills 9 months ago
Ooo la la
Ooo la la
Oooo la la Heeeeyyy
Ooo la la
Ooo la la Heeeeey!
pezkills 9 months ago
ya ... rabindra sangeet k niye western dhaache notun vabe record obossoi kora jai ... bt somehow lyrics er sathe eta jaina for this song ... its a sweet song ... not hard rock ... shreya is awesome in this song ... bt some extra added things are irritating .. its not that i dont like western ... or m a fond of classical rabindra sangeet ... if u wanna hear what some one can do which is soothing for ears listen to the songs of the film "mon amour" .... just to check how to mix or "remix" ...
liknahibaj 9 months ago
As a Bangladeshi musician I have to say that movies like these don't do justice to Bangalis of Bangladesh really. I mean, to start with, the very name "bong" for Bangla is derogatory since a ganja-smoking pipe is also known as "bong". Bangladesh is just not a country of floating debauched vagabonds that this movie aims at showing. This type of cinematic discrimination should be scrutinised carefully before they are allowed to find a place in our markets here.
ritubahar 9 months ago
I happen to see the movie on Zcafe yesterday night-cum morning from 3 to 5 am.........too Bengali morning ....but the movie was a subtle reflection on the change of mindsets of NRI and the hypocrisy that still prevails among them...........as a character of Rita a brat turned good at end but was sad to know about the character like Rakesh Ganguly......a second class american......well people like them are every where but to the same free birds are ready to break out........a good work
mecheaven 10 months ago
I love this song !
khaleda66 11 months ago
বেচারা রবীন্দ্রনাথ। এটা না কোরে অন্য একটা ভাল গান তো লিখে তাতে সুর দেওয়া যেতে পারত। this is a sacrilege of something divinely beautiful । এরকম নির্লজ্যতা অচিন্ত্যনিয়।
SeiPakhi 11 months ago 3
agree with that
prinsa666 9 months ago
very good mordern rimix of rabindra sangeet.
bulbulghosh 11 months ago
BREAKING NEWS >>>> Tagor just had a major heart attack in the Heaven..................... Please help him to get well by STOP listening this song.
IAZADC 1 year ago 32
@IAZADC :রবীন্দ্রনাথ এর কিছু হাছে কিনা জানি না তবে আপনি অসুস্থ হবেন এইটা সুইনে যে আসল গান এর দর্শক মাত্র ২৫০০০ আর এই movie তার গান এর দর্শক ৪২৫০০০, তাই বলি old is gold হতে পারে তাই বলে নতুন গান হীরা হতে পারে না কেন ?
smart78085 1 year ago
@IAZADC dada acholayatan porechen? Rabindranather lekha
MegaIdntcare 5 months ago
@IAZADC hahahahha! it would be massive rather than a major one. Nachiketakey sroddha kori....darun ekta album korecchey o Ustad Rashid khan-er songey(called Yatra)...ar ekhaney eto keno khepe gelo ei ganta gawar jonno ta bhogai jane. besh kichu taka peyecchey nischoi. Rabithakurer copyright uthey geccheto. Nachi, i still respect u....and don't want to lose it.
Arupkant 5 months ago
Very very nice creation ... Please pardon me if it seems rude. Ami abangali meye kintu bangali bou. I accept Robindra Songit is eternal. But for people like me its monotonous and some times it gets boring as well, as most of the songs are slow. But this is a very nice way to make Rabindra Songit spread. Let both kind of songs reach public. Now its our choice what we want to listen. This way at least we get a chance to know Rabindra Songit.
Shwetsdubey 1 year ago
Rabindra nath Tagore r Kishor Kumar jodi aaj beche thakten tahole khub dukhho peten aie gaanta shunle.
rohanb007 1 year ago 2
@rohanb007 correct
liknahibaj 9 months ago
cholbe dada! bangla rabindra sangeet is reali good 2 listen.
bidyutsarkar3 1 year ago
Loved the song and the changes in it.
@CRITICS:
Rabindranath went to England in 1878 at the age of 17. After his return from England he composed a music drama "Balmikiprotiva". After grand success of this he composed another musical drama "Kalmrigoya" in few years. Both of these contain songs were based on western music.
tapabrataful 1 year ago
Phoole Phoole dholey dholey bohey ki ba........ is an adaptation from the irish song named "Ye Banks and The Braes of Bonnie Doon".(You can check it out in youtube if you wish to) Call it a copy, a remix, a makeover or an inspiration; the great poet himself was surely not against it.
So people who claim that Kobiguru would be unconscious after hearing this version are surely mistaken.
tapabrataful 1 year ago
Thanks for uploading this video. Loved this film from the first time I saw it New York in '07.
barunghosh 1 year ago
Hats off to Anjanda.Keep up the good work:)
HOTMALEDEEP 1 year ago
Great job in bringing a new dimension to Rabindra Sangeet. Change is always good. Thanks for trying out something different.
nickybasu123 1 year ago
--- last night --I saw RABI THAKUR --collapsed --- hearing this song --
farid,
tx,
usa.
farid1948 1 year ago
@farid1948 Whats with you bhoka bangali everything is Robiondro Vivekanand And Joyti basu Dirt
43Madhuri 1 year ago
@43Madhuri In fact the 'dirt' is in your mind...
sarthakaju 1 year ago
also its nice song
ontoo14 1 year ago
mind blowing song
rockinghosh 1 year ago
I actually like it....
prateekroy 1 year ago
Rabi dadu opor theke ese keliye rekhe jabe
Ritoban1 1 year ago
Naa jabe na. Khushi hobe. Robi thakur eto sonkeerno mona chhilen na. He would have loved it to see that people are doing lots of research on him.
rays100 1 year ago
@rays100 true
ritwik1234 1 year ago
E gaan shunle Rabindra Nath Shotti Kalir Dwat Fele Hoto Kupokaat...
Shame...we don't need to change the roots...
rafiovi 1 year ago
fuck off !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
indrani20 1 year ago
Comment removed
charhagaru 1 year ago
@indrani20 To whom?
charhagaru 1 year ago
Kbiguru'r mone je eto chanchalyata chhilo....ei video ta dekhle seta bojha jaay :-) !
realy like it !!!
Maddhyam 1 year ago
a case of dogheads takin d plung where angels (of music world) fear. both rendition & d improvisation r utterly gutterly.
mohdjuddin 1 year ago
harsh_nishad@yahoo.co.in
manoj20103 1 year ago
As traditional that I am, and I would never belive that I would ever say this.. but I kinda like it... I think that credit needs to be given for the attempt... For those of us, who absolutely love Tagore and his work, will find this offensive, but for the newer generation, who is not interested in Tagore at all.. and doesn't care about Tagore's work, for them, this is a great introduction to the wealth of art in Tagore.
I will give kudos to the creator
ChefSuman1 1 year ago
Worst kind of rabindra sangeet remix ever. Who the F commisioned this movie? :X
my7thsense 1 year ago
Comment removed
rizzodex1 1 year ago
@rizzodex1
Navarun1 1 year ago
rabindra sangeet ke ei bhave remix kora uchit hoini
sandipnandy12 1 year ago 2
@sandipnandy12 aar robindronath nijei boleche je tar gaan kono rokom change ba ei remix kora jabe na
MultiBadboy420 1 year ago
i can't digest it.one of bad video i have ever seen in my life.
saswatilogin1 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ruined the beautiful song.
Titanic1954utube 1 year ago
Awesome song. I just can't stop listening. Good Job...
We should experiment. I hard to find good clean bengali song like this.
Thanks
CoolRikde 1 year ago
Absolutely shit
0425836991 1 year ago
that slut raima sen dancing to a rabindra sangeet song... what trash......
aryanremedios 1 year ago
and is that shayan munshi
aryanremedios 1 year ago
its shot in santiniketan
ayanendu1 1 year ago
Why are we destroying our heritage for commercial exploitation!!! this is absolutely unacceptable... Bikram you are one educated Chap, and trained and in classical, I admire you how ever how can you be a part of such crap. Can you ever dream of writing a lyrics like this !!!! STOP EXPERIMENTING WITH TAGORE!!!!
TheKingshukbanerjee 1 year ago
non sense
rafiq3406 1 year ago
Fucking stupid
rafiq3406 1 year ago
crap...lost the beauty of the song...
ishtyakk 1 year ago
KHUKU 41----Experiments r always welcome. Film tar prosongeh ei gaan hoyto thhik aachhe. D male singer ki Nachiketa ? Na, typical 'Bong sentiment' noy----but moneh
serokom daag kaatlona- sorry ! Anyways, a good try .
@tupunsayan----Ur comment is most appropriate.
Khuku41 1 year ago
I like the fact that they're experimenting, but really, the "ooh la la" was completely unnecessary. :/
ambarinsultana10 1 year ago
Its all for my cuty friends
olay2658 1 year ago
this is a nice remix
well done
MrDharamsala 1 year ago
@ mmadbd...
completely agree wid u......it's a superb attempt...specifically in context of the movie.
suman4c 1 year ago
We can enjoy this song a a song but as a Tagore song, may be many views. Whatever those, this song has to be evaluated as a part of that film "The Bong Connection". The bengali boy who returned from US trying to touch his roots from US background. So, its a fine attempt. But regarding video one can say " it could have been adjusted with the lyrics of song (rainy Day with strong turbulent wind). If you can reach west and new generation with Tagore, where is the Problem?
mmadbd 1 year ago
I can see some typical bengali sentiments!! :-)
golpata 1 year ago
Rabindra Nath k chere dile hoy na??
Tupunsayan 1 year ago
@Tupunsayan : Jar hoy, tar hoy, aamader hoy na :) (excerpt from Shesher Kobita).. It is very much vital for the new generation to see Tagore's work from their viewpoint, and this is an example... if I hear this version of the song playing in a car full of youngster... it will make me happy, I rather hear this than loose this great culture
ChefSuman1 1 year ago
This is a new attempt...Some would like and some won't...I like both the versions...I think we bongs love to live in the past...We had only 1 Rabindranath, 1 Satyajit Ray, 1 Sourav Ganguly..and we keep chewing the cud rather than producing something as good as them...I think we should move ahead and be open to new things....
souravcal81 1 year ago
it's a great fusion of the original song. i loved it. all the western classics have numerous versions, why make a big fuss about it?
also this is part of a movie and the version is more in tune with the film. cheers.
sohojsorol 1 year ago 20
absolutely worst!!!! Tagore would die after listening this trashy songs.
dnbarman 1 year ago
how can Anjan Dutt make this ??? this is bullshit...omg...i just can't believe this shit....
balarkahajra 1 year ago
daru pranjal o prashongik. rabindranath ki achalayatan pachhanda korten?
am9932580070 1 year ago
nobody maybe imagined this kind of shit will happend with even Kobiguru ,should not we cry..........
debashishbiswas 1 year ago
purono gaan ta bhalo, notun e kharab ki??
v shuld evolve out of our nostalgic mindset n accept change which is different n innovative, coz in innovation lies the root of prosperity.
aporajito
neal0009 1 year ago 4
Eto nice 1ta ganke ki korlo era?
tanvir9804086 1 year ago
Certain thing shouldn't change with time. Such as this song. The original is so much better. Jottoshob....!
rayehan30 1 year ago
Sick of this stupidity. U lal la = U lal la asinine. The composition is on baul did the idiot recomposer has any sense? Who is the braying man singing? Must be the recomposer.
SuruchiSangeet 1 year ago
Comment removed
sujoyray9434 1 year ago
Comment removed
sujoyray9434 1 year ago
totally rubbish!!
beevatsyu 1 year ago
A Baul Rabindrasangeet and Arabic tune match only in a asinine mind. This the sick to the nth degree. Shame on the weirdo.
SuruchiSangeet 1 year ago 2
Only listen to Shreya and till Shreya sings and close your eyes while you do so and then stop when shreya stops singing....video is such stupidity...
priyaranjan45678 1 year ago
Priyaranjan da i didnt get what was so stupid abt this video, the song is abt free sprit and if u consider free sprit as stupidity then may be u fall in the group most commonly known as intelectual aatel !!!!
supriyo1985 1 year ago 2
I think the song is good...Music changes with generation ..we shudnt compare with original...however I felt that the video is not at all modern ..its very cheap but the song is good!!
priyaranjan45678 1 year ago
Hey sorry to have caught up with this a lil late.... frankly i love this score. I think its aesthetically done and can be played even on your car audio... cant imagine playing rabindra sangeet otherwise while driving, no matter how close we all are to these songs because we have grown up listening to them.
abaneeta 2 years ago
its too boring
sujoyray9434 2 years ago
@sandatta1963...do u think dere is any chance of creating another rabi thakur?...no way...i am focsing on dis particular song and its music...apni probably sristi r srastar moddhe gulie felchen..hve u seen dis movie?..thats perfect match wid d scenario..rabi thakur k nie samalochonar sahos bodhhai amar & apnar karor e nei..chalte chaltei natun path pao jai bose thakle noi..seta nahok chena path thekei suru holo....wht do u think?
supriyajana 2 years ago
rabi thakur to durer katha ekta sachin dev athaba salil chowdhury o habena. yes I have seen the movie. if u scroll down u will see. Yes it is a good match for the scenario. But tar mane ei noi je the song attained any class when played outside the context of the movie. As a bengali I have certain expectation when u touch rabithakur.... it is about the song not the movie. if u want to cont. this pls reply on my msg otherwise it doesn't come to my mailbox and I don't come back here to check msg.
sandatta1963 2 years ago
what i can tell....unless and until u try to do something different.........u cant survive in dis competitive world.....bt changes shld be in +ve way....r serom bichar korle rabi thakurer to oneeek sur western music theke copy kara ba inspired....amra to proudly accpt korechi sei sob gan even vry popular o.....eventually i can see everything has its own way,,,,u cant say anything bad vry quickly....dont 4get law off relativity...ultimate add 1 more dimension that is TIME.. sandatta
supriyajana 2 years ago
rabithakurer gaan khubi kam sankhyay influenced by western music, most of them came naturally during his in Britain and his love of Scottish folk music. He incorporated it absolutely in Indian way like he did with baul, kirtan, tappa,carnatic not for popularizing his music but for enriching it. Creative people are passionate and get influenced and create new things completely original. not by putting few nonsensical word before a song and trying to sound 'cool'. that is called selling.
sandatta1963 2 years ago
and couldn't add in my last comment due to limitation of size. I appreciate your civil tone and not trying to judge me and instead of focusing on the subject here. Rabindranath is a brand name and survived 100 years in this competitive world unlike most of our latest creation. If we are still creative lets try to create another brand like him instead of piggy backing on him. That is in my view not courage, it is cowardice and ineptitude.
sandatta1963 2 years ago
i dont understand what the fuss is all abt
if u do not want to listen to this then go and listen to whatever u like
plz do not critisize ppl and show ur shallownwss
arpanmajumder 2 years ago
i dont understand why people dont wnt change.....for a change it is excellent..r .....legally eta r biswabharatir ekar sampatti noi.......even it is a good move to make rabindrasangeet more popular.........but i love 2 listen sagar sen, debabrata biswas too
supriyajana 2 years ago
@supriyajana thnx atleast some people are not afraid to welcome some positive changes
arpanmajumder 2 years ago
amra change chai, tobe ta holo apnar moto faltu lok er change.
njsalma 1 year ago
fool!
beevatsyu 1 year ago
Gaale chor diye music ber kora laagbe na.
Gaale chor diye daat gulo fele dewa dorkar :)
potheekaami 2 years ago
Eta ki? Rabi Thakur-er matha chibiey khawa?
Arupkant 2 years ago
ufffff.....
sabuzhimu 2 years ago
taamasha...
gcomment 2 years ago
Eta ki?
Arupkant 2 years ago
There are few things in life I would appreciate if left untouched (at least this way). I happen to see this movie a very stereotypical portrayal of Bengal and Bengalis in US. Just putting a funky tune to a Tagore song is not experiment. It is shows your lack of sensitivity and understanding. As someone says you killed the original song now what you do with the bones and ashes no one cares.
sandatta1963 2 years ago
@sandatta1963 just want to say that u cannot decide what to do and what not to do
coz there are many like me who like change becoz it requires courage to break the stereotype for better
arpanmajumder 2 years ago
yes I can decide what I like or not. That is what I wrote. Please read carefully. And to answer your question if you don't like something which people have adored in its form for 100 years why not create something original which will may survive for 100 years. Instead of doing the easy thing 'experimenting' on the Tagore? Yes sir I know I can't change your view in 500 words but nevertheless I want to document it that I absolutely detest it. any problem with that?
sandatta1963 2 years ago
ppl liked "it" becoz they did not have the taste of alternate genre's of music, becoz they did not have the guts to accept anything different, becoz they never dared, and thats why every bengali outside bengal is scorned upon, who
hide behind the wall of intellectual snobbishness.
also i'd like to add that i'm very proud of being a bengali, a independent bengali of today
arpanmajumder 2 years ago
that's fine with me. you have your view and I have mine. let me express my view loud and clear. It is sad to see that people need to mix coco cola to taste nectar. That's all I have to say.
sandatta1963 2 years ago
nice song sweet no fret who wrote
Ribosome100 2 years ago
Just Fata Fati.....Rabindranath ke venge chure natun vabe gora......Fresh Blood in a Fresh Body.....Full of Youthness.....Jai Hooooo.........!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
sutapautpal 2 years ago 2
Eto baje picturization manush korte pare.
Prithibir sob cheye baje video gulor modhye competetion hole eta firs prize pabe.
Tito Dutta.
trulytito 2 years ago
Such an insult to RabindraSongit.Get a life!!
ronyca 2 years ago 2
Ami etai to eto din dhore bolchi.
Tito Dutta.
trulytito 2 years ago
Liked Nockiketa's part: "Bristi Bheja Bhora Shondha Tara, Kon Boloramer ami Cheyla"
Added life to the song...........
tcborty2008 2 years ago
why didn't I die before listening to this horrible experiment with Rabindrasangeet? There are few experiemnt on tagore songs that are good but at least they tried to keep the soul of the song.
smitomalvino 2 years ago 2
Absolute trash!
dodulhuq 2 years ago 2
Absolute trash!
dodulhuq 2 years ago 4
@dodulhuq : you are right...nonsense
balarkahajra 1 year ago
@dodulhuq
Grow up. People started listening to Robindrosongeet after this. The next generation needs to know what is in there. If we don't change ourselves, its our loss...its our society's loss.
rays100 1 year ago
boring rubbish
and that's being kind
gerundino98 2 years ago 3
@LBiolSci you should die like a taliban commander and stay in hell after death. This is an experiment with Tagore's music... and people are liking it.. "brishtir nesha bharaa sondha bela kon baloraam-er ami chyalaa... aha!!!" Nachiketa's voice is superb here with this new words added into the golden song.
getmaxmode 2 years ago
somebody please get a gun and sgoot me. so thats how they sodomized a tagore's lyrics. arrghhhhh.....
LBiolSci 2 years ago 3
trulytito
eisab bangladeser concern moulobadi tadi.......
debdina 2 years ago
@debdina
MOULABADI'S do not hear RABINDRA------SSSSSSSSSSSSSS
farid1948 1 year ago
Lovely !! Rabindranath is always great and this picturisation is good.
SurjyaKar 2 years ago
So nice....
dba26y 2 years ago
excellent song remix...........
a lil bit over use of music
debdina 2 years ago
BULL SH*T !
9uru9ulabkhatri 2 years ago
Very good.
Keep it up.
Make some more music.
3772barishal 2 years ago
i dont think a simply remix can ever kill the essence of a grt song like "pagla hawa".
It only proves how versatile our Rabi Guru is.
even many shakepeare plays are still "modified" till this day...but it dusnt make him any less "shakespeare."
grt writers like Rabindronath and Shakespeare will be always cherished. their art will nvr grow old.
shihab1975 2 years ago
i dont think a simply remix can ever kill the essence of a grt song like "pagla hawa".
It only proves how versatile our Rabi Guru is.
even many shakepeare plays are still "modified" till this day...but it dusnt make him any less "shakespeare."
grt writers like Rabindronath and Shakespeare will be always cherished. their art will nvr grow old.
shihab1975 2 years ago
The kids are so international looking. Like my son and my daughter. I regularly exchange music with people on the Internet and you are with this and other songs part of my pride. I love passing this tune to my English and American Friends all of whom love it. Keep it up kids! People don't criticize to this degree unless they have a hate agenda. There is nothing wrong in repackaging the classics to keep them alive. The oooll llla oola la hey -it works. Good looking people making great sounds.
gonedoolali 2 years ago
I read some of the comments on here with horror! How petty minded and small for these pyjama-wallas to belittle an amazing cheerful and colourful presentation. I am 57 and I was tapping my feet and swinging with the tune.
gonedoolali 2 years ago
i luv u india
adhi721 2 years ago
death of a Great Song!
khanolid 2 years ago
@khanolid,
Or semi death, yes I too feel same.
Tito Dutta
trulytito 2 years ago
Balo laglo...
lottolive 2 years ago
sadhu proyas.thanks.ei jodi na hoy to notun projonmo robindro sunbe kibhabe?
harounrashid68 2 years ago
@harounrashid68,
mante parlam na apnar kotha, sorry, amar boyosh 21 years 10 months. Aar amar ei gaan bhalo lage ni. Aar sadhu proyash o mone hoy ni.
Dukhito.
Tito Dutta.
trulytito 2 years ago
টিটু দত্ত,গত এক বছর ধরে যা প্রতিক্রিয়া এখানে জমা হয়েছে তাতে দেখা যাচ্ছে দুটু ধারা।এদের সবাইকে নিয়েই কিন্তু "বাংলা"।সময়-এর স্রোতেই সঠীকতা বিচার হবে! আর হ্যা,আমার বয়স ৪১।
harounrashid68 2 years ago
Comment removed
trulytito 2 years ago
@haronrashid68,
part 2/2
(contd...)
Aar ei muluke emon obostha, kotha boli ek bhashay, aar jibon chalanor jonyo sikhte hoy aar ek bhasha. Nijer bhumi te poro bashi hoye achi.
Bujhlen? Jodi bujhten to ei sob gaan ta ke sadhu proyash bolten na.
Suvo Dipabali.
Regards.
Tito Dutta.
trulytito 2 years ago
টিটুদত্ত,আমার অবস্থা তোমার চেয়ে খারাপ!জীবিকার তাগিতে দেশ ছেড়ে থাকি সাউদী আরব।তোমার অবস্থা ঠিক বুঝতে না পারলেও বলব মৌলবাদী হইও না।তোমার profile,chennel contents-এ তুমি সারা দুনিয়ার নাগরিক।ভাল থেক।
harounrashid68 2 years ago
@ harounrashid68,
Eta abar kemon reply holo? Ei rokom uttor asha kori ni. Moulobadi hote jabo keno? Boye gache!
1952 er 21 february er andolan ke o ki apni 'moulobaad' bolben?
..... ..... .....
Regards.
Tito Dutta.
PS, apni bodh hoy, Bengali software kimba GoogleTransliteration Lab e Bangla e likhe Ekhane copy koren. Tobe Bangla e likhle lekha gulo khib choto hoye jaay, porte osubidha hoy.
trulytito 2 years ago
[Correction.]
In part 2 of my previous answer please read the name 'harounrashid68' instead of 'haronrashid68'.
Apologize.
:(
Regards.
Tito Dutta.
trulytito 2 years ago
@harounrashid68,
part 1/2
Ebaro mante parlam na apnar kotha.
Jodio apnar montobyo r jonyo dhonyobad.
Achcha apni ki Bangladeshi?
Hole to bhaloi.
Bangladesh emon ek desh jekhankar matri bhasha Bangla. Ghore ghore matri bhashar koto ador!
(contd....)
trulytito 2 years ago
I love it, it's good...
lalti11 2 years ago
I love it, it's good...
lalti11 2 years ago
I think the soul of that song just died in this remix. Use of new instrumental technics + mordernizing of the rythm is ok. But sometime you should not play with the origin/root to make it more beautiful. Root is just root. For an example, you can not go beyond the Big bang of the Universe, its beyond human imagination. You can just look it through Habol telescope.. If you realy want to feel the soul of Rabindra Shangeet, then go back to origin. Just my 2 cents..
shimvidtube 2 years ago
well done itz a great remix !!
hotdoggandu 2 years ago