Added: 3 years ago
From: newscientistvideo
Views: 187,918
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,211)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This is Bullshit

  • I will put a V8 engine sound in my smart fortwo.

  • it need a better sound

  • lol now sounds like the thing at the toilet

  • have a mic on the electric engine and connect that to speakers so the woosh or wine is amplified like AFX cars.. those cars sound cool and are electric.

  • Comment removed

  • this is exactly like the fake horses head on horseless carriages to stop horses from being spooked.

  • lol they should use an engine running sound instead of this fucked up shit it sounds like "the grudge!!!" LOL

  • In the future, when silent cars become the norm not the exception. The noise should come from some "sentinel" robot at the intersections.

  • This is ridiculous because unless under hard acceleration, almost all modern cars with factory exhaust are quieter than the noise the tires make when contacting the road. Next time your walking and a new car is coming toward you at lets say 35mph, listen and pay attention to what you hear. You hear the tires, not the exhaust.

  • @sniper1334 This is true at higher speeds. However, the concern is not with cars traveling at 30 MPH or faster. Rather, it is with cars at slower speeds that you would get at urban intersections, turning corners, or in parking lots. The safety studies by NHTSA have shown that the increase in pedestrian crashes for hybrids is only at lower speeds. Go out sometime to a street corner with a blind person and see how well they can detect hybrids versus other cars at 25 MPH and slower.

  • We (my husband and I) own a Prius for economy (saves gas) and the environment and love it; we also cycle for our health and happiness!

    It would be nice to hear the Prius coming when we are on the bike and I respect the scientists who are trying to help the blind - despite the juvenile and snarky comments here!

  • @humanbeing524 just a few questions not trying to be rude but my dad has now owned 2 Prius's 2nd and now 3rd generation and have you really calculated how much you save? Figure out that you paid close to 10-15 thousand dollars more than i dunno say a Yaris which uses little gas. now calculate how much money you saved remembering that you have to spend gas in the other car too so on every 20$ of gas you're only getting an extra 5 dollars worth it takes years to get back that "saved" money

  • better idea, fuck electric cars and just go to HHO combustible engines instead (burns water). that way it still makes:

    1. Makes Sound.

    2. More engine power.

    3. Does not take 'world damaging' Nuclear Power to charge.

    4. True 'Zero emissions'.

    5. Aid in taking back our world from the greedy Oil Companies and Bank-sters.

  • tron will laugh at this

  • yes lets put speakers in the two places on the car that cop the most stones and dirt!! way to go!!

  • lol

    

  • wow, make it sound like a shitty chainsaw. gg

  • Or simpler solution to this is put clickity clackers on the wheels and make it sound like a bicycle with a card hitting against the spokes! That's what the cool kids do!

  • Great, more noise pollution. Most cars are nearly inaudible at low speed now. When I walk down the street , cars are constantly coming up from behind and I do not hear them until they are going past. Why is this not a problem now?

  • i would have to ask sombody whats wrong with thier prius if they pulled up and it was makeing that sound. people buy the damn things because their quiet and have good MPG. wall with this it takes away one of them.

  • Sounds fucked!

  • Sounds like shit. Make I agree just make it sound like a regular car. I4 V6 V8 V-10 V-12 who cares. Just not like this crap. Sounds like the wheel bearings are grinding.

  • why not just make it sound like a regular car? this is just dumb as shiet

  • It Sounds likes like shit . The first thing that runs through my mind is something within the inner fender well is scraping . Master tech /Collage student

  • How about we just drive with little courtsey. One of the primary reasons for have an electric car is to reduce sound pollution. Yes sound pollution is a big problem in modern world. If they put these in new electric cars i am will be first one to figure out a way to replace speakers with some leds or just something that can waste this energy without making a stupid sound

  • Doesnt even sound like an engine.

  • That´s what´s happening when engineers, os student engineers, are developing a sound... crap shit!!!

    Leave sound creation to the experts like people from the movie or music industry!

    Or contact me... I´ve worked in the entertainment industry for more than a decade as a music producer and now I´m into automotive industry... i know why... they need my skills... :-)

  • how bout getting boise speakers and blast that shit

  • silent prius scare me when I ride my bicycle.

  • It sounds like an empty stomach ...

  • there's an invention called a car horn.

  • jay, my coffee is ready

  • Horse shit !

  • just have a v8 idling

  • i like how its projected so the driver cant really hear it,just makes electric car owners look even more like a bunch of twats

  • How about we just use our eyes

  • Schwachsinn

  • If people are too stupid to not look, then let them die.

    Lets uphold Darwinism!

  • @terrorfalc The video was actually talking about the dangers for >blind< people...

  • @SZDarkhack

    Ah but that fits in perfectly with the Darwinism theory!

  • Then you can make your 2012 Toyota Aygo sound like a V 5,7 L Covette Stingray!

  • I'm going to record my neighbor's Honda when it's bouncing off the rev limiter.

    Then I can drive along in my electric car in total silence while everyone else hears "VRRAH BIM BIM BIM BIM BIM BIM BIM"

  • Ok so it sounds like your dragging your bumper, horrible idea, that sound is second to only nails being grated across a chalk board, and Jim Carrey's most anoying sound in the world.. "HEY WANNA HEAR THE MOST ANNOYING SOUND IN THE WORLD?!aaAAEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE­EEEEEEEEEH!"

  • Comment removed

  • I want mine to sound like the Jetsons. Let's agree to it with the condition that it's customizable. 

  • wow 201 people drive a toyota or some other toy car that dosent use gas therefore it is not a real car

  • man... why don't just let the cars be on fuel?

    p.s. global warming has no sence. just like hybrid cars.

  • @Lightwader3338 Why should they be on fuel forever ? there won't be fuel forever ... .

  • @TheKaos90 Don't believe these people...

  • WOW What a shitty noise! Can you customize it? Can you use the slap bass seinfeld theme?

  • That has the potential for so many pranks.

  • the 200 people who liked this all drive shitty cars

  • HAHAHHAHAHAHAHAA FAILBLOG PLEASE PICK THIS UP!!

  • Yep this was always going to have to happen for electric cars

  • This would work great in winter.. when it gets covered by snow turds lol. Its an awful noice still. WHy not just put it in the grill so it only points forward, and one at the rear plate for use when backing up.

  • I would set mine to play Cannibal Corpse "Hammer Smashed Face" when I turn left and "I Cum Blood" when I turn right, because you know, there's blind people to be saved.

  • It sounds like I'm missing like half of my tires.

  • What a nightmare.

    Do not overrun people and animals, and do not make noise.

  • Need to use the Guile theme from street fighter instead of the "dragging bumper" like krais3r said lol

  • Hes got the skills to make a box

  • Stick a 6.2 litre V12 in the back with straight pipes just incase the peds don't hear you

  • That car sounds like dump

  • Switch it out for an MP3 of a school buss!

  • Horrible. Not a solution; this is a bandaid. Cars moving more than 10 or 20 km/h generate more noise from the wheels than the ICE anyway. At speeds slower than that, the driver has enough time to hit the brakes...

  • why dont u get a vroom box... o.o

  • look at the good part, now even my grandma's car can sound like a mean mustang

  • i want my gas car back. no thanks

  • Why do pedestrians have to be so aware of the cars? I mean seriously as a driver would you not see a pedestrian in front of you and stop? And if you are a ped you are only supposed to cross at crosswalks. While the drivers have to make sure to stop at crosswalks if there is a ped.

  • blind people are going to think its a skater gang coming at them

  • oh my god that is fucking stupid. You can forget about getting women to jump in your car with that noise. Sounds like he got a flat with a soda bottle stuck in the wheels.

  • The great Hitler would have had the blind executed.

  • Remember. The many must be happy. Im tired of the many having to suffer because of the few. When was the last time you ever met a blind person> Fuck this!

  • Fuck this crap. If the blind get hit, then its called natural selection. They get hit because they were blind and did not have the tooks necessary to survive. Being blind sucks. Being dead is better. First it was polution, then it was gas millage. They came out with hybrids, and the blind are bitching. Jesus fucking chris. Kill all of humanity. Thats the answer.

  • The hybrid/electric vehicle to operate quietly until a pedestrian needs to hear it. The automotive companies spend millions of dollars to keep the cars QUIET, PASS only allows noise when it's necessary this is why it should be on demand, FYI Leader Dogs for the Blind in Rochester Hills, Michigan has 2 system that they have been using for 2 years for training. but I am the inventor of PASS SYSTEMS so I am Bias, go to my you tube and see it

  • This has to rank as the biggest excercise in stupidity I have ever witnessed because the simplest solution would be to plant small acoustic transducers on the armature of the electric motor. The moment the electric motor starts spinning the transducers would create an appropriate noise at a reasonable level.

  • ..personally i do not like this "idea" at all.. but this is just my personal opinion.

    The this is that it is TERRIBLY EXECUTED! ..this is what a 5 year old would think to do if asked!!

    Just think about the MOT guy.. going through his list..

    ...

    - seat belts.. checked

    - external speakers.. checked

    ...

    ..wont take long until someone connects his mp3 player to them.. making star wars sound and it will be legal as well!!

  • people in the future will laugh at us for this

  • @viclope just like the fake horse heads on cars to prevent spooking

  • wanna be heard? get a system!

  • I have a better solution: Look both ways before crossing the street. Something we all should have learned at the LATEST by age 5.

    Pro: Inexpensive, asserts the right of vehicles to be on the road

    Con: None

  • those speakers would last 3-4 minutes on a salt covered winter road...

  • I have a better idea! Instead of that annoying sound, how about we blast Never Gonna Give You Up! ... This way you can drive down the road while Rick Rolling everyone!

  • Good idea but terrible execution.

  • It needs to sound exactly like "The Jetsens" cars!

  • fucking gay

  • The only reason the blind would need to know about a car in the road is if they are crossing it, which should be at a designated crossing ... so unless they are concerned about the blind 'jay walking' and getting hit ... im not quite following the use of this.

    It sounds like crap and surely imitating the noise or a pertrol car defies one of the benifits of an electric.

  • Blind people should just learn how to adapt to the natural sound of an electric vehicle. The rest of us should not have to be inconvenienced, because of their blindness. Supposedly, heir hearing is more acute, because of their blindness. Maybe they should just listen better.

  • Sounds like me slurping the last drops of my soda with a straw.

  • LOL i can make the intro music wirh my 3 years old Motorola handy!

  • don't worry, the gas industries will find another excuse to ban it

  • just take the noise from a video game

    take like a F1 car or a ferrari

  • Make it sound like a Lambo...

  • I don't think they have ever heard of the radio in their cars...

  • just drive a real man car fuck hybrids and fuck the blind

  • @diesel5355 YEAH AND FUCK A YOU DOLPHIN AND A FUCK A YOU WHALE

  • @ufoforestgump yeaaaaaaa!

  • makes me think "Coffe's ready!" but 24/7 that's not a good thing.

  • ugh thats gonna be annoying when all the prius owners are forced to have this installed.... all the fake engine sounds. i want to put a V8 in a prius, and convert to RWD.

  • Obviously it makes them safer. Someone i know was run over by an electric car cause he didn't hear it coming.

  • sounds like a skateboard.... 

  • Sounds like shit, who would want that? One of the best factors of electric cars is the removal of vast amounts of noise pollution, pointless, fuck the blind, what are they, 1 in 1000 of the population, if that? Do we have to put speakers on push bikes? NO. Another example of pathetic neo-liberals trying to make the world bubble wrapped.

  • Totally nonsense.......

    Even "How to fake a six pack" related video have much more sense than this "invention"

  • fuck the blind community 

  • Wtf, this is stupid... So you buy better for nature, nicer thing to drive, and then make it shittier because someone does't do their job. It is government responsibility to make it that blind people are safe. It is each individuals problem to make sure they are safe. + that is why cars got honk for. Except it is soooo misused these days. They are used to make frustration and stress in traffic but not to warn others...

  • @onenutmonkey234.... There is an actual engine in it smart guy lol, read a book.

  • That's ridiculous!!!! It's makes the car sound more like a coffee maker rather than an actual car, lol. What will these scientists think of next??! Lol

  • Why use a warning device that will draw power off the main batteries?

    Wouldn't it be much simpler, not to mention a lot more efficient, to use a strategically placed pinwheel clicker or whistle? (Similar to the gizmos used for deer, except audible to humans)

    No offense, this makes no sense to me... pedestrians typically look both ways before crossing and otherwise don't play in the highway around these parts.

  • sound more annoying than with no speakers.. in either way makes people frustrated... i am not big fan of electric cars

  • if they standardize that i'm sure people would disable them considering people don't like added noise pollution and enjoy the whirr of the motor. how about making another horn, a kind of a tap on the shoulder horn to let pedestrians know you are coming. that seems a little more practical than adding artificial noise to cars that developers work so hard on making quiet.

  • You know theres this magical thing called a horn? and get this, it has a purpose :O

  • WTF? It's electric car! It shod be quiet! That's why we want it!

  • ok this is stupid, like c'mon play some loud music or something, the chevy volt has a better solution, its chirps

  • that sounds like my bong

  • I gess the popcorn is ready....XD

  • sound like my ass scraping against a cheese grader...

  • if you have the sound mind as well put an actual engine in it...

  • that fuckin prius was already rubbish but.. with this sound.. it sounds even more rubbish

  • Show me proof of widespread accidents with deaf/blind people and electric cars. We already have enough noise pollution, we don't need cars that make more noise than before. Plus, if I get a car with any "fake engine sound" you can bet your ass I'll be disabling that the first day I get the car.

  • lol they sound like a skateboard on a crappy road not a car

  • Sheez, that's what they make boom box for :D

  • Christ, what next will the Blind want !! ability to See !! , no I get it, make the rest of the World Blind ,, Poke OWe !!!!

  • That's ridiculous! The driver is not blind!

  • Electric car is bullshit. Just buy 2-Store Honda NSR 500 and fuck up everyone asd

  • that sounds like a coffee maker not an engine.

  • That's awful... we should be moving in the way of QUIETER vehicles, causing less fossil fuel pollution AND less noise pollution.

    There must be other ways for blind people to avoid cars crashing into them - oh wait, how about the drivers pay attention when driving a car! Or how about they wait for a pedestrian crossing to tell them when they can cross. Whether it's a fossil fuel car or an electric car you'll still get run down if the drivers ignore the lights in any case.

    This is dumb.

  • @jkaplonek The engine noise is to reassure a blind person that the vehicle has come to a complete stop. People like you or me that can see would be able to see if a car has stopped whether is makes noise or not. I'm not saying is an ingenious idea, but it's a safety thing. Maybe making the vehicle only make the sound when it's at a complete stop seems more reasonable rather than putting them at risk completely, and possibly have it sound more like a real engine, rather than this gay crap...lol

  • Speakers.

    Made in China.

  • This is retarded...

  • Of all possible sounds they chose this shit?!

  • It sounds like a damn diesel train.

  • I'd like a quiet car. :)

  • Omg cant they hear that it sounds aweful ???!! Seriously it cant be that difficult to actually make it sound like an engine.

  • Why not do something SMART! Why not raise people to be aware of their suroundings? Not like the retarded people in the city, thinking "I don't need to lok for my self. I'll let this random person infront of me do it. Then i'll just follow him!" I'm quite sick of how stupid most people are, well, the increse that occoured about LAST GENORATION!

  • why don't they just make the car make lion noises so the stupid deers could avoid us when we are driving our cars ? and maybe we can turn out cars into mr. frosty ice cream on wheels? make some side money selling ice cream so we can attract ice cream clients and then at night run some music and it can turn the car into a mobile disco!! charge the cops half price for admission! hahaha

  • They should play some music instead of these idiotic sounding fake things.

  • awesome. no one cares about noise pollution. that sounds like the car has a upset stomach all the time. attractive.

  • How little perception one must have to have never noticed that the noise they hear from passing cars is from the tyres and wind resistance, even at the slowest speeds. Absolute FAIL for all that haven't noticed that.

  • This is da shit, i prefer the hemi v8 like sound ;)

  • Great now it can sound like im dragging my bumper everywhere i go

  • and what about the people who cant hear????

  • That sound is totally gay, they should use a good sound atleast. Not like popping popcorn in a trascan!

  • Jetsons car sound anybody?

  • make its sound like a V8 or v12 then, its only worth having a look at :)

  • thats a hemi

  • I would make it so when you turned the wheel,it made sounds like people screaming,explosions,packs of dogs growling.Have fun with it

  • so this is when the disables are disabling society to progress

  • better of using a Vroombox

  • ahahahahaha lol doesnt sound like a car much

  • sounds like a farting machine

  • Sounds like a skateboard on sidewalk.

  • Should make it sound like a V8. Or at least like one of those fart cans teenagers put on Japanese cars. Or how about the sound of George Jetsons car. There should be a button to customize it. make it take MP3's on USB stick.

  • lol thats great

  • use the car sounds in gattaca

  • stupid idea

  • Oh, I don't know... they could mave made it sound like a normal car engine?

  • I would so customize it to make it sound like an arcade UFO.

  • I prefer to drive with loud music and open windows bro.

  • it'd be better if they made the sames sounds as the hovercrafts from the jetsons.

  • that sounds like crap.

  • @mannybz yeah

  • the speakers might be getting packed with dirt, mud and moisture after time.

  • I think this would make more blind people or anyone in general tell the car owner that their exhaust is scraping on the floor. -_-

  • yep , sorry but i'd be ripping that out pretty quick, how about a nice whirring electric motor sound, something like you hear in those slightly older sci-fi movies, the sound of brushes on the stator or something at least interesting. just hearing this video made my brain itchy <.<

  • @curtis133 Got my Exhaust from KwikFit...Can hear me coming half mile away now.

  • sounds like they're dragging a chair

  • Instead of a fake car sound, have it play a speech by Al Franken. That'll get people out of the way.

  • that doesnt sound like a fucking car.

    Wtf.

    Atleast make it go Vroom not CRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR­RRRRRRRRRRRRR

  • dude that would piss me off if my car sounded like that.

    sounds like a skateboard going down a street.

  • Cool! You can make Melex sound like a racecar, tank or hovercraft!

  • can i make mine sound like the ice cream truck (mr. softy) music.

  • I would want mine to sound like a Harley!

  • what if they make it sound like a way over-blown 4banger with a cherry bomb, complete with backfires and everything?

  • Comment removed

  • Kako gluhi inače prelaze cestu!? /

    How deaf people cross the road otherwise!? ;)

  • i lol'd at 1:26. "i got da skiallzz" lol

  • A classic case of OverThink. Any 16-year old could come up with a cheaper solution. Make the wheels click. Done.

  • Comment removed

  • this is one of the stupidest ideas

  • they cud just install sound system and play some good music