Added: 4 years ago
From: rudugudu
Views: 147,371
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (63)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • She doesn't seem to have much respect for what she's doing. The expressions are more of a cover-up to her sloppiness in the dance form. Dance isn't doing something just because you can whether required or not!!! If anyone does have a good performance of hers can you please share? I've been searching for one.

  • It would so wonderful to see Shobana live.

    She's amazing & so is Bharatanatyam.

    You don't need to be Indian to appreciate the beauty of this classical art.

    I'm Australian & love it, I really want to learn this beautiful dance

  • she never danced in proper armandi.........the stardom help her as a bharathanatyam dancer.

  • she is beautiful but somebodys head is getting in the way !

  • what is the music?

  • what bharatha natyum style is Shobana's dance?

  • nice dance

  • While I am fairly uneducated in the ways of traditional dance (I grew up learning Western dance styles), it seems like something is missing here, as if her heart wasn't in it. I know she's incredibly talented, but I'm not seeing it here.

  • i think she's just a bit tired during this performance.

  • I too expected more from her. Here she is very superficial and her karanas and mudras are very lethargic, lacking the definition of hard years of practice and even a spiritual understanding behind the margi karanas. As for the araimandis, good observations have been made about its absence. I remember seeing Vaijanti Mala performing live, many years ago, and her most perfect araimandis.

  • ok firstly there is no aramandi secondly it dosen't look like she is enjoying what she is doing it very mechanical and she is getting very puffed out... she could do better than that!!!!

  • I see the video is of very bad quality... maybe the fact is that , the video is of such low definition and frame rate that we are unable to notice the rapidity of her movements and they are seeming mechanical

  • Comment removed

  • I don't see her sitting in "bharata natyam" position except for one time while doing one step. How can you do bharata natyam and your first position is wrong. I've seen her dances and I really like her but this is a basic factor of this style.

  • The 'sitting position' or Adha Mandi is the first position to be lost if one isn't being watched by a good teacher. Fact!

    Nick

  • @tripmonk0 TRUE!

    not to be rude or anything, but i don't see Shobana sitting in ara mandhi..

    is it a different style of bharatha natyum or...?

    so confused...

  • @giggles1987 nvm. i figured it out..

    she learned the Vazhuvoor style of Bharata Natyum...

    it has more grace and stuff

  • @tripmonk0 true but she was in the beginning. it doesnt have 2 be teachers, it can be any1 who learned bharatanatyam.

  • no,Didi,no need,thank u.I think i can handle by myself.U were very nice and helpful to me,thanks again.:)

  • sorry,i didnt mean to offend anybody and anything...someone has just given me links of better bharatanatyam than this... Shobana herself has better dances than what she is performing here in this video. Well,i dont have much knowledge,but i like mallavika sarrukai most.

  • is she making film bharatanatyam here?...

  • She needs to keep her hands a little more stiff. they are way too rubbery.

  • I agree with you, her posture and arms are very poor for a bharatanatyam dancer. She has a nice face, but this is not a good example of bharatanatyam at all.

  • wat the hell is dis.... seems t b like filmy natyam..

  • What you would say yenchant if any tell that you slept with ur own mom. Its the same to talk abt others guru. Dont do it. A real bastard i came across

  • maybe people dont look for the truth here... It's enough to have a beautiful surface only...

  • It is a unbroken heritage of India passed on from several hundred years .... one need to have kaladristi to appreciate this art .. there is a saying that how does a lay man know the beauty of Grammer ....

  • well said kamakotisankara.

  • An art form can live on for ages because unlike stars which live for millions of years, we only have about 60 to 80 years to absorb all the worlds kinetic art forms. you obviously don't like any art form that requires discipline. Such an attitude shows how imature you are. I'm pretty sure you're almost alcoholic and frequent strip clubs for artistic experience, which is shit.

  • U R right, haruny21. We should not look into the personal issues of dancers. So what if they sleep with their students father or mother? As long as they communicate the feelings of Radha or Meera, who cares if they rot in their lifes.

    But in a way, I do agree with erimp1 that these dancers should be brought to light. I have seen in my own circles that the teacher was sleeping with the student's father.

  • alot of todays modern western dances originate form these classical dances today....try an appreciate it and not make such immature comments. intimate sex talk and vocab has nothing to do here...there are so many other videos and sites dedicated to that kind of interest go there to explore your interest and make comments....this is not the place nor the video!!!please have some self respect!

  • it is sad that people come on here unnessarrily commenting and being rude and crude...what for???this a type of classical dance it takes years of hard work, dedicaton and it is a form of sport even....standing streched like this with bent knees and firm calf muscles if so hard alot of people have no idea....neverthelss it is a south indian/asian form of dance...a part of world culture...

  • Hinduyodha - didn't realize you went to class with her. Look at her where she is and look at you, learnt the bad language probably you meant her private part when you mentioned venCunt.

  • So what if you know her? Is that means Bharathanatyam is good? Who is Chitra or Saroji? It is fake dance with no morals. Most dancers think they can sleep with anyone, but why portray Krishna or Rama in their dances, why not portray Hilton, Madona or Lindsay Lohan...

  • shut the f..up venCUNT.. btw this is abt shobhana.. i know her and she is my fellow student from Chitra Visweswaran who is also my guruji.

  • Look at your language!!! Sure, you are from a good Indian culture. You want me to show "Brahmin" bharathanatyam teacher sleeping with student's father in USA and India?

    But you right, it happens less in Asian culture, but comparison is not the argument here. Some Bharathanatyam teacher sleep with student's father. I have seen that too.

  • can a Bharathanatyam teacher (married to someone else) sleep with her own student's father? Some people say it happens all the time, is it so?

  • it is the actress shobana.

  • she looks like the actress shobana

  • that IS the actress shobana - she sings, dances, and acts

  • really? what movie was she in?

  • if you search shobana on imdb you will find her - she acted in mitr, my friend and a lot of south indian movies.

  • is she a mallu actor

  • mallu actress

  • so yes she was in Manichitratazhu

  • YUP

  • people say she is not so nice in real life. i know a few friends of mine who where taking dance classes whith a teacher and Shobhana was asisting that teacher. So what happened was that shobhana was realy mean to everyone. they were in ny

  • well the steps are bharatnatyam style....i can see why people think its somewhat filmy-but what is it exactly?? ( i just cant pick it out)

  • Is it Bharata Natyam !! or Filmy Natyam set to Modern Choreographers!

  • her moves were too slow for the fast paced rhythm

  • can any1 upload the whole Video?

  • i wish i could see what her feet were doing

  • anywayyyy she is da besttt wow her dancing is excellent

  • What is that weird sound around 1:10? Its really distracting.

  • Its a part of the soundtrack. That was Goddess Kali laughing when she catches a glimpse of Shiva.

  • @rudugudu Awesome!! Can I get the entire video of this show...?!? Please!!!

  • Her dance style is pretty filmy but nevertheless, very enjoyable! She communicates a lot of joy in her movements.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more