Bakshi is an excellent artist. There's disputing that. But it's all this detail and rotoscoping put into this movie that just makes it far too hard to watch and enjoy. The body-language and sudden shift of expression makes the characters far too human for an animation,which isn't a bad thing. I think the over-all problem with the movie is the script and directing. Like in the end, Gandalf circling and waving his arms like a mad-man. It's a little over the top.
Its remarkable how close some of the background a feel of this film is to Jackson's version. Although the whole thing does have a really trippy feel about it!
EH? Did 17 years actually pass? I haven't had the chance to read the book, but in the new version they made it look like only a couple days passed, if that.
@Achmeron This animated film used the rotoscoping technique which traces real actors movements and whatnot. Disney also employed this technique in many of their films like Snow White.
To the people that say this is better than the Peter Jackson version, you need to get your heads looked at !!
the voice acting in general is awful (but in some parts surprisingly good).
the layout of the dialog and scenes is messy (again there are some part which are surprisingly good).
how ever i really enjoyed the film none the less. the scenery and how everything looked (mostly) was beautiful and pretty accurate to my image of Middle earth!
When I was a tiny girl, I had an abnormal phobia of rotoscope animation & shadow puppets. The part at the Prancing Pony nearly had me shitting bricks, but the opening part has that "so bad it's hilarious" quality to it. Imagine if they did this for Harry Potter.
Damn, I wouldn't want to be Smeagol's boyfriend. XD
Both animated movies depict Gandalf as like the ultimate badass creepy old man.
DONT READ THIS CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS.YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE.TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE.HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT TO AT LEAST 2 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS.NOW YOUVE STARTED READING THIS DONT STOP.THIS IS SO SCARY PUT THIS ON AT LEAST 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN YOURE DONE PRESS F6 AND YOURE LOVERS NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS.THIS IS SO SCARY CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS!
I cant decide if I like the Bakshi art better or the Rankin/Bass. Just watched Return Of The King. Preeeetty rad, but I think this wins. Wish they'd finished it.
this film portrays the book accurately, unlike the Peter Jackson's version.. Though I admit I enjoy the 2000 films much more. The book will always be the best though. If you only read one book in your lifetime, make it LOTR, and don't be in a rush to finish it.
Why do people say that? I loved this, but it certainly isn't more accurate then Jackson's. About on the same level.
People have to take into account that certain events in the book just weren't cinematic. Great to read, and fans would loved to see those scenes, but they wouldn't have worked. I do think all the adaptions, including the Rankin/Bass, are good adaptions.
@sunnybrand Both versions have inaccuracies.This version's scene of the black riders chasing Frodo is more accurate than Jackson's version. I agree, certain parts of the trilogy are long with too much dialog, example, Tom bombadil's speech.
@Ovningskora Are you serious, not only does this film mispronounce half the words and screw up a bunch of dialogue, it also changes about every scene and makes all the characters look gay
Bakashi did a great job on this film. Is areal shame people still criticize it even though its a really underrated version compared to Jackson's films. If he completed the film it might not have gotten so much stick.
Its such a great show! make sure that you upload the rest. Thanks for uploading it:) I have subscribed to your channel and rated this video. It's so good! come and se my channel, and watch a few of my videos, you'll be the first.
8:24 Does Gandolf not know that it is terribly rude to point one's hand at others?
Triakis2011 1 month ago in playlist Films
This has been flagged as spam show
re-edited version of this film:
/watch?v=13kcUUkTyKg
includes switched endings, the Saruman/Aruman issue fixed and the Part One in the title screen. please enjoy it.
aquelescaraaaaaaaaaa 1 month ago
Thats 1 epic ring there too bad it isn't real
Mubu5Reborn 1 month ago
Elvish kings' shadows luke just fabulouuus. ;]
vanderToki 1 month ago
HAHAHAHAHAHA
BMSiren 2 months ago
I didn't even know there was a LOTR movie before the Jackson's till now........I feel so ashamed -______-
MultiHollywoodYoutub 2 months ago
At the last part of this clip Gandalf hugs himself because he's so ALOOOOOONE!!!
Blargwhatsittoya 3 months ago
Bakshi is an excellent artist. There's disputing that. But it's all this detail and rotoscoping put into this movie that just makes it far too hard to watch and enjoy. The body-language and sudden shift of expression makes the characters far too human for an animation,which isn't a bad thing. I think the over-all problem with the movie is the script and directing. Like in the end, Gandalf circling and waving his arms like a mad-man. It's a little over the top.
runedragon1985 3 months ago
8:20
Now that's just scary lolll
Jonassoe 3 months ago
0:34
Timothy Gandalf?
SwedishmanPsycho 3 months ago
8:16 = mindfucked
mastercrowly 4 months ago 2
i like that little tango they had at the end.
mastercrowly 4 months ago
right at 1.39 haha like a play performed by 5 year olds
mastercrowly 4 months ago
lol the beginning of this is so fucking gay
mastercrowly 4 months ago
If sir Ian McKellen had that long bear...wonder how he would look like?
TheStarcraftJACKAL 4 months ago
there are so many similar parts of this version and Peter Jackson's. Makes me wonder...
SpiderBatwoman 6 months ago in playlist LOTR 1978
Ralph Bakshi
ParanormalStories 6 months ago
Oh my god I haven't seen this in years. But I'm all excited for the Hobbit and wanted to rewatch :D
I remember really liking Aragorn in these.
TheEmpress666 7 months ago
animation style looks similiar to Filmation or Hanna-Barbera
nobodysperfect06 8 months ago
@nobodysperfect06 you cant really judge the animation style right on the beggining because it sure gets better.
it's rotoscoping, the actors move with realism
aquelescaraaaaaaaaaa 5 months ago
I always thought Frodo was extremely cute in this one! ^^)
MagicalKirbyGal 8 months ago
do u have the hobbit?
minimaximus1 8 months ago
@minimaximus1 /watch?v=vcllH6Kslw8
brasz101 8 months ago 3
I like Gandalf's interpretive dance.
Shatallion 8 months ago
Its remarkable how close some of the background a feel of this film is to Jackson's version. Although the whole thing does have a really trippy feel about it!
TomandJerry09 8 months ago
EH? Did 17 years actually pass? I haven't had the chance to read the book, but in the new version they made it look like only a couple days passed, if that.
Necrodragn 9 months ago
Comment removed
luisa53boteroc 8 months ago
gandalf scared me a lot
Laloestaburrido 9 months ago
smeagol sounds so gay.
rodneytheincontinent 9 months ago
frodo sounds like angry kid
Frankiti99 9 months ago
Very goog animators, those clothes seems very realistics...
Achmeron 10 months ago
@Achmeron This animated film used the rotoscoping technique which traces real actors movements and whatnot. Disney also employed this technique in many of their films like Snow White.
edwin11373 6 months ago
To the people that say this is better than the Peter Jackson version, you need to get your heads looked at !!
the voice acting in general is awful (but in some parts surprisingly good).
the layout of the dialog and scenes is messy (again there are some part which are surprisingly good).
how ever i really enjoyed the film none the less. the scenery and how everything looked (mostly) was beautiful and pretty accurate to my image of Middle earth!
SoundsoftheWave 10 months ago
lol @ the silhouette fight scene in the beginning. We did more realistic silhouette fights in high school theatre.
CrawdaddyJoe 10 months ago
7:02 AWWW how cute is that
daffodil977 11 months ago
wow.... i am so high right now:P
bosto23 11 months ago
Don't freeze at 6:59
Ermundos 1 year ago
8:26 Gandalf Wants You! To Destroy the One Ring.
zecraw 1 year ago
When I was a tiny girl, I had an abnormal phobia of rotoscope animation & shadow puppets. The part at the Prancing Pony nearly had me shitting bricks, but the opening part has that "so bad it's hilarious" quality to it. Imagine if they did this for Harry Potter.
Damn, I wouldn't want to be Smeagol's boyfriend. XD
Both animated movies depict Gandalf as like the ultimate badass creepy old man.
LikaLaruku 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
DONT READ THIS CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS.YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE.TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE.HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT TO AT LEAST 2 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS.NOW YOUVE STARTED READING THIS DONT STOP.THIS IS SO SCARY PUT THIS ON AT LEAST 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN YOURE DONE PRESS F6 AND YOURE LOVERS NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS.THIS IS SO SCARY CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS!
MrMG43 1 year ago
I like Peter Jackson's version more, but this one is still good. I love the dark atmosphere and the backgrounds of the forests
94animationkid 1 year ago
I must say this film is much more engaging than Jackson's watered down version.
CJCody2006 1 year ago
wow this is trippy lol.
andysim232 1 year ago
@andysim232 you should see the yellow sumbarine movie
countryandpivot 1 year ago
wow so many layouts, angles and ideas went straight to the new films
Astrales 1 year ago
lol the eyes are proper trippy its like there all on pills
monkeyshoes69 1 year ago
Gandalf is a bit over-dramatic in this...lol.
intheTea04 1 year ago
the 70s a simpler time
benisawesome11 1 year ago
Brilliant! I was born in 1978, and never seen this before.
maksphoto78 1 year ago
Wow, uh.. pretty brief final convo between Gandalf and Bilbo, wouldn't you agree?
AMNlinkinparkfan115 1 year ago
It's good, but i prefer Jacksons version alot more.
archangel385 1 year ago
I cant decide if I like the Bakshi art better or the Rankin/Bass. Just watched Return Of The King. Preeeetty rad, but I think this wins. Wish they'd finished it.
sunnybrand 1 year ago
A much more accurate portrayal of Frodo than the annoying sacrificial lamb portrayal of the Jackson films.
tightlypackedcoil 1 year ago
I didn't know that someone made an animation movie of the L of the R =\
lara1891 1 year ago
God! That intro music is like ear-rape to me!
AMNlinkinparkfan115 1 year ago
this film portrays the book accurately, unlike the Peter Jackson's version.. Though I admit I enjoy the 2000 films much more. The book will always be the best though. If you only read one book in your lifetime, make it LOTR, and don't be in a rush to finish it.
Ovningskora 1 year ago 2
@Ovningskora
@Ovningskora
Why do people say that? I loved this, but it certainly isn't more accurate then Jackson's. About on the same level.
People have to take into account that certain events in the book just weren't cinematic. Great to read, and fans would loved to see those scenes, but they wouldn't have worked. I do think all the adaptions, including the Rankin/Bass, are good adaptions.
sunnybrand 1 year ago 3
@sunnybrand
Well, just by watching this first part you can see that Jackson left out a huge detail that Ralph kept in.
Ovningskora 1 year ago
@Ovningskora
It's tit for tat.
sunnybrand 1 year ago
@sunnybrand Both versions have inaccuracies.This version's scene of the black riders chasing Frodo is more accurate than Jackson's version. I agree, certain parts of the trilogy are long with too much dialog, example, Tom bombadil's speech.
chroniclerofthe70s 1 year ago
@Ovningskora Are you serious, not only does this film mispronounce half the words and screw up a bunch of dialogue, it also changes about every scene and makes all the characters look gay
VaatiPownsNoobs 6 months ago
7:51 he's like WTF DUDE!?!?!?!
spikeharusame 1 year ago 28
Why are Bilbo and Frodo the only normal looking Hobbits. :/
UACmarine2O8 1 year ago
@UACmarine2O8 Yeah right
cessnaid 1 year ago
If anyone sees this, watch the RANKIN and BASS version! it;s my chidhood watch. i'm just trying this versaion now!
dirosaga 1 year ago
oh fuck. whats that?
DreamchildToni 2 years ago
nice upload.
jthansen7 2 years ago
I found it to be beautiful.................and quite true to the original***
am1966ath 2 years ago 2
Bakashi did a great job on this film. Is areal shame people still criticize it even though its a really underrated version compared to Jackson's films. If he completed the film it might not have gotten so much stick.
nukem11 2 years ago 33
@nukem11 Jackson's film owes a lot to this one for both plotting (what to keep in and what to cut out) and even individual shots....good stuff.
tarnopol 1 year ago
@nukem11 IT was only after I watched this that i remembered how much balls this movie sucks
VaatiPownsNoobs 6 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Its like the LOTR for retards.... 8/
Cecatron 2 years ago
i remember watching this as a kid
daishalinton 2 years ago
the beggining is so fuckin WEIRD
quote55 2 years ago
Yeah it really is! The animation in this movie really takes getting use to!
Ashleypalmer1991 2 years ago 2
its all fucking wierd
teebon3117 2 years ago
LOL!
coleminor375 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
That's great. Look forward to seeing it, subscribe to me so we can keep in touch.
449944991 2 years ago
Its such a great show! make sure that you upload the rest. Thanks for uploading it:) I have subscribed to your channel and rated this video. It's so good! come and se my channel, and watch a few of my videos, you'll be the first.
449944991 2 years ago 2