Added: 3 years ago
From: Lilith89ibz
Views: 31,568
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (35)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • she has amazing control over her instrument and a great technique that allows her to sing with great precision...a pity there is on video footage of this.

  • Highly dramatically alert performance. Bravo!

  • next march Lucia will be HD broadcast. . . i just wish it was Diana and not Dessay in the role(not that i don't like her, but i really really wanna see Damrau :S)

  • Diana Damrau is great as Lucia, either her dramatic passages or the coloratura ones are very good. I don't like to compare sopranos but something is telling me that they should have recorded and released the DVD with Damrau instead of Netrebko. Diana is Dynamite!

  • What a privilege it would have been to have  heard Damrau in person on that occasion...

  • I don't know if anyone can ever top Joan Sutherland for me, but this is beautiful.

  • @musikphantom1881 I agree! No one can top Sutherland, but that's not what we want right? We want as many good sopranos as possible to keep on doing Lucias for a long long time!

  • @lipera hi, i know you wrote this 5 months ago and probably already forgot it but i agree with you about ". . . We want as many good sopranos as possible to keep on doing Lucias for a long long time!"

    i would like you to listen Rachele Gilmore doing Lucia, if you already did it, you'll agree with me that she has a bright future ahead her(she is only 28 years old) if you hadn't it will be a really good surprise

  • I agree with

    Marroiamaxu: Netrebko is wonderful, but she does not have voice for this...

  • It is lovely to hear a soprano who is able to make musical choices that are not based on what she can get away with in this music! I hope she has a very long career indeed.

  • Damrau is a true coloratura, whereas Netrebko sings in the false repertoire. That's the difference.

  • perfetta e meravigliosa...

  • Finally a secure, stronger and healthier Lucia. Different from the no-capable-to-do-coloratura sopranos or the flute-like-sound coloratura sopranos...

  • I am a Netrebko fan but Ms. Damrau is so wonderful in this role. Hard to imagine a contemporary who is better!

  • Mariella Devia is also a lovely Lucia. Although she recently retired the role.

  • Is that an armonica instead of a flute? haunting and beautiful

  • Yes, that's right :)

  • Yes its a "glass harmonica" :)

  • @TrebleB4Mi glassharmonica, to be exact: the original partiture indeed was not for flute (sigh, I play flute!)

  • @TrebleB4Mi

    That is a water armonica, an instrument already much forgoten by the time the opera was written but used by Donizetti by the eery quality of the sound, perfect for this scene. This is the original music composed by Donizetti.

  • I <3 her!

  • Beautiful version Diana!! So touching...!! Impressing!! I really prefer Diana than Netrebko... :) Bravo Diana!!

    She is the new Gruberova!! :D

  • Well, Diana has the right voice for this, Netrebko DOES NOT!

  • I saw this last Wednesday - she's AMAZING! Love the glass harmonica - soooo creepy I'm getting chills right now listening.

  • Is this the entire aria? It's missing something, I think.

  • No, it's not. The entire aria is too long for a single video. Check the 'Ardon gli incensi' and the 'Spargi d'amaro pianto' for the whole madness scene :)

  • Thanks for posting this, by the way. I got to see it last weekend and she was amazing and it's nice to get to re-live it a little.

  • Amazing performance! Her voice sounds so close. I would like to know what was the distance between you and the stage when you taped this, Lillith89ibz.

    Thanks for all the posts, by the way :)

  • Oh, I did not tape it! It was an online recording :)

    You are welcome ^^

  • Damrau is a GODDESS! Period.

  • Gracias por dedicarme el video, pro habria preferido sea otro video, k no puedo soportar ver a esa producción de lucia con otras cantantes k Natalie!!!

  • Jajajaja!

    A mí me pasa lo mismo, asocio demasiado las producciones a los cantantes y esta vez, a Natalie... como otra a Stefania Bonfadelli, etc etc...

    Me gustó Diana en el rol :)!

    una Lucia con mucha fuerza!

  • Yes a healthier and stronger Lucia! LOL

  • Merci pour avoir posté ceci. Damrau est une des meilleures Lucia actuelles. Bravo à elle pour cette prise de rôle. Dommage que ce soit avec Netrebko que le DVD sera enregistré. Ses variations sont très intéressantes. J'aime beaucoup Damrau et c'est une des meilleures sopranos cooratures actuelles. Elle surclasse Dessay et Massis dans ce rôle pour citer les Lucia actuelles.

  • C'est degoutant que Netrebko sera enregistré. Je suis très triste que la prise de Damrau sera perdue pour toujours :[

  • Si beau.

  • Hm...el Regnava me gusta más...la escena de la locura, prefiero la de Dessay (su interpretación del personaje en esta parte, para mi es mejor XDDDDDDD)

  • Alix mi spiace, ma mi sa che è meglio dela Dessay....

    O, almeno è brava come la tua Natalie...

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more