Obama Amnesty Debate Robert Rector Vs Ali Noorani - Lou Dobbs

[madamatv]

Amnesty is the way :)

[onstageagain]

Amnesty ? I can't believe the Senate Dems R pushing amnesty! Unbelievable. The world is on FIRE, the country going down the tubes, Americans in dire staits & the Dems make amnesty for illegals a priority!?! Best for the country? LOL, it is about what's best for the Dem Party. Amnesty means illegal votes, whooppee!

These politicians R  tone deaf to what Americans want. So FED UP with this nonsense. Time to organize.To teach.To learn.To vote, before it is too late.

A Fed UP American

[biggniggalol]

that 60 percent of illegals that r drop out r poor because in other countries u have to pay to got to skewl! who is to say that illegals even want welfair!? just cuz americans who aint workin r on it doesnt mean they r gunna get it! remember they r the 1's who came to this country to work not lounge around on welfair! jobs have no1's name on them! and what bankrupt the country already is dumbass people lik u push broom is government spending and stupid republicans!

[biggniggalol]

what this old ass here is saying ppl is that it is ok for illegals to build ur homes, roofs, and do other jobs better than legals but not live in this country! agreeing to come to this country legally is right but has any1 ever seen how hard it is to be legalized!? especially Mexicans?! sence the bored has been getting more attention, legalization is being denied to ALL! what is wrong with bringing your family from a bad country to a good country?!

[biggniggalol]

question for the old fart with the push broom mustache, how can you hire 8 million illegals into 3 million new jobs OTHER THAN CONSTRUCTION AND OTHER SMALL BUSINESSES AND RESTAURANTS with out papers!?! becuz the new jobs ur taking about r governemtn jobs! every dumb ass thats says they can find a job blames it on illegals r yall even lookin for jobs! or u just dont want to see another race prevail?

[onstageagain]

@biggniggalol This video on, " YOU TUBE" "  IMMIGRATION GUMBALLS "

should be the Center Piece when discussing immigration. If you have not seen this... please , it only takes 5 min of your time ... You have never seen any other like it!

Immigration Gumballs

[biggniggalol]

21 million people who r looking fro jobs that just lounge around anyways lol they r jokes! they r i see american construction workers all the time not doin anything! i also see immigrant works workin none stop! they never take breaks they never complain they never wine! what it has to do with 12 million illegals is that they find work cuz they work for less and lik i said dont complain and get the job done and quick! the better man whens legal or not!

[TheKChick]

"No man is above the law and no man is below it: nor do we ask any man's permission when we ask him to obey it."

- Theodore Roosevelt

[biggniggalol]

how is no man above the law that is writin by man? only obey the laws made by God. i aint seen his name on any bills ever have u?

[biggniggalol]

how is no man above the law that is writin by man? only obey the laws made by God. i aint seen his name on any bills ever have u?

[NeedAJobUSA]

Homeland Security & I.C.E. employs 1,000's of American Citizens. Every dollar those agencies receive is worth it. ALL Funding should be diverted from medicaid/welfare/food stamps & ALL ESL education costs - to pay for Homeland Security & ICE. If illegals are granted citizenship - they will lose their jobs to illegals. Employers need to be fined $5,000 PER employee first time, the second time around closed permanently.

[deesilvestre]

please push this law

[danny4evr]

F*** Lou DoOUCHE, and the other 4 eyed racist mother F****er. how u gonna kick ppl out of a country your not even native too....ass hole....first of all immigration is the reason the economy is so bad, y? because immigrants are willing to take jobs that regular americans wouldnt do. how many americans actually work as janitors, or at drive thrus....but these pplp work hard for thier money, and they spend that money in the us. if they were documented then they would be able to pay taxes!!!!!

[b0219u]

I like how this clown Ali Noorani brings up the white worker, and black worker, but not the legal or illegal worker. Yet again, pro-illegal immigrant lobbyists play the race card.

The labor market is not level because illegal aliens low-ball the pay for citizens. They can get an illegal to work for $5/hr while a citizen does it for $20/hr. Enforce the laws, and that levels out the labor market.

The '86 amnesty failed miserably, we don't need another.

[SyriusBelsferg]

It's sad to see that newscasters lack journalistic integrity. It's all about coloring and spinning the news in order to gather attention. Neutral, unbiased reporting is a thing of the past.

Now it's all about "Look at this thing! They are going to let such and such do such thing and such, and get this and that, while you have to do this and that! It's outrageous!"

It doesn't matter if it's race, money, work, taxes, anything. All in the name of ratings and pleasing their sponsors.

[aznjokeryou]

HAHAA, you know...what an argument used years ago in the Depression was "women should not work, then we'd have jobs for men! No unemployment!". I know there are flaws in this analogy, but it's still funny =)

[StLukey7]

another dumb video by atheist lou dobbs the Jesus hater!

[salvy4u]

Simple as this.. for each illegal immigrant to get legalized.. the USA is going to atleast get $3,000.00 out of each one. Now times that by 12,000,000. That comes out to a whopping $36000000000!

Just imagine what the government can do with that money! Create a ton of new jobs! What about the taxes after that? The purchase of cars, houses and other things that no illegal has been able to purchase?? People don't be stupid, now!

[JimyRoss]

ok for your sake i will minimize the actual numbera(so you might understand). lets say there were only 5 million illegal immigrants living in the united states, and say only half of them sent $100 a week back to their families living outside the united states. thats $250,000,000 leaving the united states economy EACH WEEK never to return. do you like our country in recession? fuck you too. die in a fire

[JimyRoss]

legalize that, and we will kill you

[zhao4long2]

fix the regulation, legalize illegal immigrant, this is the country of immigrant anyway, and use them to benefit this country!! they came to this country because this is a great country, we still got hugeeee land to build. let them pay fine whatever, so they are legal and buy cars and houses

[jijigod]

The only reason why illegals take jobs is Becouse Illegals Mexicans are Wage_Slaves! You see us black fought for our civil rights, so we would not have to work like slaves anymore!

The only reason you Wet Backs take jobs is becouse Illegals,work for pennys!

4$ And 5$ dollers a hour

Yall call that Mexican pride? I call that slavery! Ya fruit picking punks! I bet yall would pick cotton if they ask illegals to pick cotton! Illegals do construction jobs for 5$ a hour yall the new nigger slaves!

[salvy4u]

You've gotta be kidding me, eyes and a smile! Immigrants certainly work for money. Unlike your kind! Back then when niggers, like you, were slaves.. it was because it was slave times, dumb fuck! Unlike now.. all your fucking nigger heads brainwash your stinky dark asses, making you think that everyone's a bad guy! You niggers ARE racist! You have a black pride thing.. but if any other race has any sort of pride.. they're bad and racist (according to "yall") So nigger... please....

[salvy4u]

Oh yeah.. about the eyes and a smile. Yo mothafucking great great grandmother.. the fucking slave was so dark her nickname was motherfucking eyes and a smile! Bitch!

[jijigod]

Wow! You must realy be a illegal, thats about to be deported!

Your mad as hell! Huh burritoe breath!?

[Crackalafagus]

jijgod is a solami pirate, with aa crooked eye, wheres your birth certificate kunta!?

[serenanocturna]

So is Ali a Pakistani prayer rug muncher who learned how to speak English like an American or a Black American who sold out to the religion of peace because he hates this country, changed his name to bin-Ali & broke his mama's heart?

[knightoneday]

Ali Nooran is selling out the black community. See youtube videos by black community leader Ted Hayes on the subject of illegals immigration.

Additionally, ther are NOT 12 million illegals in the U.S. Hell, there are probably that many in California alone. To downplay the problem, our government always deliberately grossly understates the number of illegals aliens.

But the actual figure now is almost 40 million.

See this web address: theamericanresistanceDOTcom/re­f/illegal_alien_numbers.

html

[tncdel]

To GET RID OF THE ILLEGALS:

Just round up a few thousand, as an example to the rest. Then FINE and FORCE-work them [on chaingangs, road crews, etc.] to pay off the fines before deporting them.

When the rest see what's happening, they will leave too.

Also, make the employers of illegals pay all deportation costs, NOT taxpayers. That will also serve as an example to other employers of illegals, who will quickly lay off those working for them.

And then our own people can have more jobs.

[POdPatriot]

"Protect the borders at all cost."

Thomas Jefferson

[POdPatriot]

242467 Says

"If Amnesty passes STOP PAYING TAXES GET ON THE STREET, ORGANIZE, REVOLT!!!"

I say, "Why wait until it passes?" "Let's REVOLT now!!!" "Let's take this country back and run ALL the illegals out NOW!!!!"

[robertoct]

you are funny

[salvy4u]

lol- just like your kind made it's original inhabitants (the indians) move to the side. Because I mean hey, the whites said, "I think we'll massacre these Indians and take all this land.. after all we're white trash, thieves and we don't give a fuck, because we're cold hearted"! Ironic how Indians are the only real people with the moral authority to try and kick illegals out.. and little pansys like you talk and talk with no motherfucking right!

[madfiman]

Robert Rector, is stupid. Just think all the money that the USA will make off of illegals with Amnesty. It cost about $3000.00 dollars for residence papers x that by 13 million.

[242467]

If Amnesty passes STOP PAYING TAXES GET ON THE STREET, ORGANIZE, REVOLT!!!

[stevenrdivver]

Immigration Reform is corrupt and for lobbyist.

[caverron]

Illegal means illegal, NO matter how these liberal "let's be nice to everyone idiots " feel. Enforce the DAMN LAW!!!!

[bllardw]

Rector is a moron, Ali is a genius, Lou is a dumbass.

[JimyRoss]

so instead of giving the work to americans they should just keep them unimployed and give the jobs to people who came to this country illegally? you are the dumbass moron if you think that is the best answer. please kill yourself

[salvy4u]

As for you.. give me a fucking break! The president knows what he's talking about! This will fix the economy.. there are so many things illegals can't buy without being legal. They'll be able to buy cars, insurance will go down.. yes even for your stinky white ass, they'll buy houses and hey.. they could travel within the United States now and give all airlines more business... and maybe even save their asses from bankruptcy! So don't just speak of your imagination.. think about it for a second!

[JimyRoss]

ok well as for me im not racist that is the last think this country needs. the first thing it doesnt need is ignorant rasist morons like you trying to spread your ignorant racism. im not white, am i clear you racist prick?

[salvy4u]

Thank you! That's what I'm saying!

[reg4321]

I'll bet the bottom dollar that Noorani is a Democrat supporter. He knows that if these people are given amnesty and legalized naturalization, they will vote Democrat in future elections.

[reg4321]

Noorani is trying to pull the wool over the eyes of the American people. How about the remittances sent out of the country by illegal aliens? Dobbs and Rector are right on. Why should amnesty be given to illegal aliens who have committed social security fraud and identity theft.

[eHitcher]

nothing wrong in sending money "home" - it's upto this country to define where their "home"is. Got it?

[johnneo007]

This Rector is a pure retarded he doesn't know a nary about immigration law system and process nor he doesn't when it comes to cost and effects on the same possible legalization of these undocumented workers. No fundamental argument to keep it up.

[AmericanTaino]

Heritage guy was overmatched. Ali argues for fixing the immigration system, while Rector throws up all sorts by racially tinged scare scenarios. Not much of an argument.

But anyone who's ever studied history knows that nations go into decline the moment they wall themselves off. Ronald Reagan understood this.

Nations also take a hit when they enact policies that scapegoat, harrass and abuse their most vulnerable workers.

[revansatoda]

Yes, Rector is making the perfect the enemy of the good. Amnesty clearly won't solve all the problems but he offers nothing better than e-verify. Even if e-verify were to actually work, un-documented workers would still find employers to hire them thereby be denied workers' rights.

[nextdrink45]

It's funny that both of these guys agreed on the fact that in order to have immigration reform, we NEED enforcment!!!! So finish the fence, beef up border security, get more border patrol, continue with the ICE raids.........then in 5 years, we'll look it immigration reform!!!!!

[SoFlaPatriot]

When they raided that motor repair company in Oregon(?) they took out 28 illegals...200 showed up to apply for those jobs. So take your, they do work Americans won't, garbage and shove it!

[utahaztec]

too bad the employers care more about exploiting workers than the law, huh?

[SoFlaPatriot]

No they aren't exploiting the workers they are exploiting the behavior of our feckless state and federal governments. The illegals don't feel exploited, they're happy. They only workers harmed are legitimate Americans and legal visa holding foreigners who have been betrayed by the employers and our shitty elected officials who prevent the laws from being enforced. I would just deport the ilegals but I would throw the employers in jail.

[utahaztec]

"No they aren't exploiting the workers ...They only workers harmed are legitimate Americans" Are they not workers? Are they not exploited? Maybe the other workers are "happy" but they are also exploited for their cheap labor which hurts all legal workers.

[Rthbr1]

This is the last time they will ever try to push for amnesty, the American people are fed up with the blatant pandering to special interest groups and this proposal will be stopped once and for all. It is time all illegals packed their bags before someone else does it for them.

[sagharbormo]

The first immigrant advocacy group to seriously take on Dobbs will move to center stage. Boycotts are very difficult, but they can be successfully waged as we saw in the example of the UFW.

I say no amnesty for Dobbs, no forgiveness, no mercy, no quarter, no public stage to spew his hate..

Amnesty for all those who work hard. That will ,make USA stronger, better, more productive. . --mo

[seriouslysad]

Amnesty doing the same thing over again and expecting different results. Having laws that work if enforced, but not enforcing them and calling them broken is stupidity! illegal immigration undermines all our laws!

[eHitcher]

if a law was not enforced for 20 years I THINK it can be considered that perhaps it is "UNENFORCEABLE" therefore broken - what do you think

[omarverdozagonzalez]

shut the pile hole we pay freakin taxes n u know that crap give us rites or we will bring u down is that simple together we stand or separate we fail your choice

[siclos]

Illegal immigration is invasion by asymmetic warfare. Some traitors say legalizing the invaders would work, but then they'd have to be paid more. Then the companies would just illegally hire the recently legalized workers. We need enforcement first, declaring criminals to be legal workers doesn't prevent them from just breaking what new laws are put in place. Stop invasion, stop terrorists, stop drugs coming in, stop money going out. Enforcement, enforcement, enforcement... or prepare for war.

[pedroz84]

stop drug users, stop corupting other countries with the money n power of the usa, stop stilling resources frm other counties so half of the planet can stop hating usa, stop ur corrupted enforcement. stop the ignorance in people like u. all the problems that r here in usa right now its because the usa has create them. ur just stupid by thinking in another war who do u even wan to go in war with half of the planet. u like lou n glen doesnt know shit about anything. we dont need ur opinion sir.

[siclos]

"stop drug users, ... stop ur corrupted enforcement"

Well, we agree on these two things at least.

[Tunedup81]

as more Hispanics are moving into the USA Americans are moving to Mexico lol eh.. why not seems everythings ass backwards these days. republicans spending trillions, Democrats sending troops into battle.. eh seems like hell on earth haha