Added: 4 years ago
From: cgc1992
Views: 195,285
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (307)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • ชอบมากๆๆๆๆเลยอ่ะ

  • This? is much better than that horrid 8 minute one.get this album from downloadmusic.im

  • @ginuwinejay

    i do agree that jessica does a good version

    but its no way near better then robbies

    people can do covers of originals al the time. im not against it at all

    but the originals are more real. robbie wrote that song

    he obviously didnt about his life and singers who write a song are gonna sing it better. its their words. no one elses.

    she does a good job

    but robbies means more

  • wow i m very impressed i didnt know that she has such a strong voice....

  • I love it.... great voice and nice cover of this beautiful song

  • Hermosa y una bellisima voz encantadora, realmente para cantar esta cancion hay que ser magicos...

  • i love jessica simpson she is so good at this song and so is robbie williams well done both of you :D

  • es demasiado bell esta cancion.. la tome como favorita.. mis saludos

  • she has done a good cover i like it

  • i am sining this for the talent show

  • This song is beautiful and emotional I love it

  • why all the videos the sound so muffled o.o

  • hey RuthGehrigDiMaggio, Gene Pitney did the original, but Williams does a passable job...the instrumental background sounds identical

  • i love jessica

  • i love this song. but i no effence jessica simpsons shouts alot... and i mean ALOT

  • I think she did very well on this song. I always loved her voice.

  • She's a Pop star, but in this song she's trying to singin' like a rock star!!

  • No one sings this like the original, Robbie Williams.

  • I just heard Robbie's original version and in my opinion Jessica's is 10 times better. She ads LIFE to this song!

    I mean

    -HEARTFELT EMOTION

    -SOARINZG VOCALS

    -A TOUCH of (ROCK INSPIRED) GOSPEL

    It's an INSTANT CLASSIC!

  • Why do i have a funny feeling that Miley Cyrus is gonna try to take on this song next?

  • Hahaha I think the same.

  • There's to many version of this song.

  • Shame really, I think she has ruined this classic song. Robbie Williams had a much more emotionally gripping version.

  • i soo agree with you

    and eveyone in britain knows that robbie and gay chambers wrote this song and its been number one british best song for 25 years

  • awful

  • she was ok..but she shouts a lot

  • She did a wonderful job on this.  Her voice is very powerful. And this is coming from someone that doesn't like pop artists lol.

  • beautiful *tear*tear*

  • This is going to be my funeral song when i die its soo good

  • Diana Reyes' version is better

  • i like jessicas version better

  • i wanna make a remix of this song..i like robbie when he sings the rest of the song but i think simpson has a slightly better chorus...but thats it.

    i dunno..my opinion :]

  • I prefer Robbie....She's not so good

  • she used to be my girlfriend

  • She fucking killed it!!!!! Never sing again!!!

  • It's okay but I prefer Robbies and All Angels version

  • Such a beautiful song.

  • smut

  • Great song... tho, i prefer child star Declan Galbraith's version, it sounds 100 times better!

  • love this song my fav

  • And through it all, he offers me protection

    I love this song :)

  • Amazing! That's just unbelievable how she ruined it! I couldn't have done that any better :)

  • Oh dear she's killed robbie williams song!

  • her best before she turns slutty

  • Best versions of this are Ruth Lorenzo and Robbie Williams

  • luv her!! way better than the origional.

  • I love this song :)

    its beautiful

    especially the way she sings it.

  • ditto

  • this might just be one of my favorite songs... and videos.

  • she is amazing

    love it

    amazing hiiiiigh strong voice

  • this is song..amazing =)

  • she is like barbie

  • thats a really beatiful song Jessica you really outdid yourself

  • Robbie williams is the top but this version is not so bad

  • Damn I can't stand to watch her sing.

    she looks like she's about to fall out. She hot but I can't stand to watch her and christina Ag(cakeface) perform.

  • Wow this is pretty sad after watching David A's... her voice is too 'breathy.' It sounds as if she doesn't have enough air so she has to keep taking breaths

  • actually, i kinda prefer this one over davids just a little bit. only because she brings the high notes. and to me, thats real music. :D my opinion.

  • This is a great song but she over sings it. Something she does a lot. She has a beautiful voice but I hate what she does with it.

  • I think she over plays the raspyness when she sings...I am a fan of hers but like her much better when she JUST SINGS. And...how do you not LOVE this song? It's gorgeous!

  • the clip is not good but the song is beautiful :)

  • I love this song is so very beautiful

  • yuridia the best

  • How could she dare it?

  • Agree with you Lilybelle.

    Nobody can sing this song as good as RW does!

    Kieghacat, this song is the opposite of a "peacful" song. It's full af pain, sadness and may be hope too.

    And Archuleta's perform is a bad joke!!

  • True NOBODY can sing it like Robbie Williams.

    I had to come on to hear it as I've had peeps say it's so bad.

    So IMO , Jessica has murdered this song

  • i like her singing this sone

    but no one will ever be able to beat robbie at his version his was the most beautiful song anyone has ever heard

    xx

  • david archuleta version is by far the best

  • perfect

  • I like Jessica but I don't like this version at all. Nothing can beats such an amazing song as the original one. What Robbie did is master piece!

  • This is a beautiful music video. I love the style which Jessica sings it with. but i think, that this song being quite a 'peaceful' song if u know what I mean, she should probably have toned down the verses just a little. I think she put way too put energy into them. but the end was amazing

  • Jessica Fucked up this song so bad. Declan Galbraith at 13 years old sang it much better , even better than Robbie.Jessica stick to what you know and when you find out what that is let us know. You can't sing or act

  • I think she sings this nicely. I like it. It's definitely been made different with her own style, but it still works.

  • This is alright but Robbie Willams is way better.

  • they are both good. but i think robbie williams sings it too fast.. well in some parts. I like how Jessica slows it down

  • Im not saying shes bad im just saying its to soon for a song like that to be remade.

  • ah k

    but wasn't it a song even b4 Robbie Williams sang it? maybe they both had the idea to re-do it?... meh I dunno...

  • i love this song,and 4 all u people who say she cant sing make me laugh,if u had her voice ud be out there makeing money frm it so diss her,

  • Are you kidding me...she just shrieks and hollers at the end and tries to pass it off as singing...they even said that her and her father hoped she get nominated for a Grammy for this performance...YEAH RIGHT

  • She does 'scream' sing, I agree. but in my opinion, she is one of the few singers who can do that and actually make it sound amazing!

  • hmm, i agree with u! :)

  • Is better Robbie Wiliam Version!!!

  • Get your head out of the gutter, stop being so critical and just enjoy the music video! there are people here who love this and don't think that

  • OMG she just can't sing. David Archuleta's version live is INCREDIBLE! She needs some singing lessons!

  • David Archuleta has the greatest version of this hands down!!!!

    Jessica should take lessons from Archie!! lol

  • No, DA has made the worst version i've ever ear!!

    Jessica is much better.

    But the better version is RW's one.

    Nobody can sing this song as good as he does!!

  • No David Archuleta has the best version & saying Jessica Simpson sings it better means you are deaf!!!!!

  • Definitely, you haven't understand what Angels is!!

    It's a very sad and strong song. The sream of an unjuried man.

    Certainly not this insipid lullaby for teenager like DA does.

  • beautiful song and lirycs

  • Her voice is so affected, she sounds like she's trying way too hard and it isn't very nice to listen to in my opinion. She has talent, but she needs to just relax and let it happen.

    Still prefer the Robbie version.

  • Hey evryone there... I love mych better Robbie Williams version.

    There is a Mexican Singer, "YURIDIA" and I invite you to listen this song but it is in Spanish. I swear You'll love it, her voice, interptretation and everything she projects. If you don't beleave me, search here in youtube :" Yuridia angel en la academia ultima generacion "

    Sorry about my english... !!!

    Manuel (mexico)

  • i know both versions - by her and by robbie and although i like robbie very much, i still think jessie did a great job on this one. her voice is something unbelieveable.

  • I heard this in the supermarket today and just had to find out who was responsible for this atrocity. This literally hurts my ears! Truly terrible! What a way to wreck an otherwise beautiful song.

  • Robbies Version = WHEY BETTER.

    credit to the guy, love himm x

  • Shes WONDERful!!!

  • that one really sucks

  • it's not that bad..

  • not that bad . . . but i like the original version

  • you guys are some tough critics lol

  • She makes this song bad

    Stop that please!

    Robbie sings that thousand times better!

  • not bad but she stole it from robbie williams

  • people call such yhings cavers, you know...

  • The best version of this song is without a doubt Robbie Williams, he knows the meaning behind the song Jessica and all cover artists dont-it should have been left well alone but the fact that so many pepole have covered it jsut goes to shpw what a talent Robbie Williams has (and lotsa credit to mr chambers et al as well of course)

  • this is horrible!!! makes me appreciate David Archuleta's version even more;)

  • lol woah seirously?

  • Eww, her voice is SERIOUSLY over-rated. She's trying WAY too hard.

  • talentless whore

  • i heard first the version from robbie williams (years befor i heard now this versions) i dont like jessica and robbie but robbies version is 10000 times better

    his voice is much better for this song....

  • oh my god

    so wrong

  • i love this song!!!!

  • same here i believe this is one of her best songs from her album the other one is Sweetest Sin and then there 2 other great ones.

  • i want this for my funeral maybe ????

    or the song with you it reminds me of me and my sister and mom diriving to arkansal to go see my grandma but then my grandma moved over to are house.....ya i liked the song better when she was in arkansal

  • I really don't think she did this song any justice. On some of those high notes she's pushing way too hard, almost sounds constipated...especially aroun 3:17 to 3:22. Girl's got a voice, but this ain't her song, she shouldn't have gone there

  • I completely agree. The high notes sound un natural and too forced.

  • Robbie affcourse ...

    She is Sex bomb , that would be enought ...

    About sing low 3 ...

  • so who's "right" version?

    robbie or jessica

  • i agree with you tigerclose she lips sing thou the whole song.... i dont think she is all that great my 8 yr old is better than her

  • You don't sing live in videos. You record it in a studio then they use the play back in the music video. This allows the artist to do dances and other physical actions without getting winded or out of breath.

  • no duh stupid its recorded cuz its a music video

  • what has she done to this beautiful song!!! as much as i like her some songs should just be left alone!!!!

  • come rovinare una canzone splendida...però apprezzo lo sforzo...

  • This version is really good, but I just got to thinking. Wouldn't it be amazing if Emmy Rossum did this song? I love her :)

  • Robbie Williams= better

    :D

    but this is still amazing

  • what can i say , she is AMAZING!!

  • Gosh! This is amazing!

  • robbie williams version is amazin but this is good

  • she can sing but i dont know wat happened with this song.she cud have done better

  • beautiful girl

    You are my angel

  • Also look for my brother (Chadrick Honore') in the new movie "Patriots" with bow wow, taraji henson, isaiah washington, robbie jones, eric hill, lil wayne, irma hall, jared einsohn, j.b. smooven, and Chyna McClain. My brother plays Bow Wow friend in the movie. Also, be lookin out for I (myself) in "Obsessed" starring Beyonce'.

  • My big brother is in this video. Check him out in 4:02. He is all the way in the back(left side), he's playing a trumpet. His shirt kinda looks blue but anyways WORLD be looking out for him ok! His name is Chadrick Honore'. Type his name in on google and you'll see!

  • I LOVE THIS SONG

  • ridiculooous

  • stfu ppl she can sing better than all of u ppl she may b a brat at times but not 27 thank u very much

  • well, i dont care what all you people say, its a beautiful song and jessica did a good job. i dare anyone of you to record yourself singing this song and post it on here and sound this good.

  • She's not a bad singer, she's just conceited. No one dares to give her constructive critisism be bacuse she tends to turn brattish when she's looked down upon. Daddy's little princess.

  • I'm asking myself "what the heck is this" i did not know she sang this song... but she butchered this wonderful Robbie Williams song... at certain places it sounds like she is talking.. some places she is screaming.. and her voice is soo rough... Archuleta is sooo much better.. he has a more clear voice w/ emotion.. and he is singing not like jessica... sorry.

  • ok well all know that jessicas voice isnt that strong at points. i agree at times she does this little annoying thing with her voice that throws the song off.BUT she must be doing soemthing right that ppl love or she wouldnt ahve millions. i beleive she can sing high pitch notes as good as any other singer just her voice is different. if u like her u do if u dont u dont. me i like her

  • omg, this is awful

  • i dont know why she sings so akward now. it doesn't right anymore....she needs a vocal coach ASAP, if she plans on having a music career in the future

  • Jessica Simpson is rubbish!

    Can't Sing. Can Scream Though

    ROBBIE WILLIAMS IS WAY WAY WAY BETTER. (ORIGINAL)

  • What a shit.

  • i dont understand why people are being so mean about her and her singing! i would like to see if any of the people saying this crap can do any better. i love jessica simpson she is amazing!!!!!!

  • david archuleta from AI sings this better than jessica and robbie put together

  • robbie's version is waaaayyy better....especially when he sings it live...anytime...anywhere...

  • davids is better:)

  • I dont go much on Jessica Simpson but she does an excellent job of this song.

  • I'm not American I'm Scottish

    but oh my god, this only goes to some of you it is a song but the words nd language some of you people come away with get a life! it is a song and SOME of you are acting like it is some thret of something it is a beautifull some so calm down with the language and if you are going to leave comments then leave nice one's for goodness sake!

    LOVE THIS SONG YOU ARE GREAT JESSICA !! KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK AND SAME TO ROBBIE WILLIAMS XX

  • wat the hell are u talkin about lol!

  • I think that both of the singers versions are good and i love the song no matter who sings it and i agree with ellenorspendlove if you other people don't have any thing nice to say then dont even bother saying anythig at all !! I LOVE JESSICA SIMPSON SHE IS A GREAT SINGER AND SO IS ROBBIE WILLIAMS THE TWO SINGERS MADE THE SONG SOUND PHANOMANAL!! I THINK THEY SHOULD DO A SONG TOGETHER BECAUSE IT WOULD SOUND ABSALUTLY BRILLIAN!

    love,love,love this song soooo much !!!

  • this is afucking war crime.If this idot didnt have a pussy it would be useless

  • she needs to stop breating so hard thats correct. she have a good voice but thats it.

    robbie versie is match better

  • I love this song, but she needs to stop breathing so hard and moaning over her words, otherwise, I love it! =)

    P.S.- Robbie's is wayy better though. ;)

  • AMEN!

  • Well I was told that if you don't have anything nice to say then say nothing so...

  • ppl how many ppl do u know of that can do 3:07-3:20...i mean cmon

  • ur right about that!

  • umm...i hate to sound like a bragger but i can.

  • Well sorry but this song belong's to Robbie Williams.

  • my god this is AMAZING. doubt any of you people could sing like her. she sings her heart you every single time she performs.

  • she does breathe really heavy

    and sounds like she's singing through her nose

    the only song i like by her is with you

    and that is how it will remain

  • I hate her, fucking bitch! How can she do such a thing as trying to make a song better than robbie! she's stupid, that's what she is. I think she looks like a moose when she sings, and she sounds like a half-dead dolphin.

  • Man! Why do you guys have to get so violent!!! It's not that serious! I think that Jessica is beautiful and she sings this song beautifully! What has she done to make you hate her so much? I'm getting more and more convinced everyday that America has some serious issues. I'm an American myself but you people really need help!

  • why does she have to breathe loudly during all of her lyrics? She is an overrated, undertalented hack

  • She should do a duet with David! That would be hot.

  • Hey Jessica nailed this song.

    She is a great singer. Not alot of people can belt it out like she can.

  • This song is nowhere near a good benchmark of her vocal potential. Check out "I Wanna Love You Forever"...NO one out there today could belt those notes like her in FULL voice.

  • Still bad!

  • david achuleta just sang this on americon idol

    he did amazing <3

  • heyy, TheLeeFamili, i agree with you, but the guitar solo in robbies song was shit!!!

  • shes absolutly amazing  lovers her =)

  • love it