I agree on one thing. George Lucas is a TERRIBLE director and filmmaker.
Perhaps George has a good imagination for creating story-boards. But he knows nothing of dialog, chemistry and just about anything else. Perhaps because he is a petty and small person in real life. Thats WHY he could not fix his films.
All this crap from him about "Oh, I had a vision" and "I wrote a backstory". He is just so pathetic he cannot admit he made errors (Vader was not Luke's father in IV inconsistency).
@SeerTravisTruman If for the prequels Lucas had written a 3 page story, handed it to a professional writer, and then directed JUST the action scenes then it would have been good movies. Your very right in saying he knows nothing of dialogue. He should never be let near a 'talking/emotional' scene ever again, cos without help it is beyond him.
im actually surprised it took this long for a full on point by point indictment of just how bad the prequels are, they should be studied in film schools, reviewed at every level... they could take up an entire semester.
lots of angry people out there, like me. i hope lucas watches the "red letter" review. so he knows just how badly he betrayed us.
@Oanlitz2 Lol exactly. I mean, it is Youtube. The point being to post videos. I believe recording a video response shows more appreciation than writing one.
George Lucas must of seen this video 11 times...
gtz1975 2 weeks ago
It could have just been an accurate, well put-together review, but he went the extra mile of making it FUNNY. I agree completely.
thatsamoanguy 5 months ago
You SUCK!
sexybutts7 7 months ago
I'd like to request a song.
TheRegulator81 7 months ago
I agree on one thing. George Lucas is a TERRIBLE director and filmmaker.
Perhaps George has a good imagination for creating story-boards. But he knows nothing of dialog, chemistry and just about anything else. Perhaps because he is a petty and small person in real life. Thats WHY he could not fix his films.
All this crap from him about "Oh, I had a vision" and "I wrote a backstory". He is just so pathetic he cannot admit he made errors (Vader was not Luke's father in IV inconsistency).
SeerTravisTruman 1 year ago
@SeerTravisTruman If for the prequels Lucas had written a 3 page story, handed it to a professional writer, and then directed JUST the action scenes then it would have been good movies. Your very right in saying he knows nothing of dialogue. He should never be let near a 'talking/emotional' scene ever again, cos without help it is beyond him.
Pentdad 10 months ago
@SeerTravisTruman "Vader was not Luke's father in IV inconsistency" What's this about?
john42t 6 months ago
im actually surprised it took this long for a full on point by point indictment of just how bad the prequels are, they should be studied in film schools, reviewed at every level... they could take up an entire semester.
lots of angry people out there, like me. i hope lucas watches the "red letter" review. so he knows just how badly he betrayed us.
MpowerdAPE 1 year ago
did this have to be a video? what's the point?
Jacklesworth 1 year ago
@Jacklesworth for him to get a video with a lot of views
Oanlitz2 1 year ago
@Oanlitz2 Lol exactly. I mean, it is Youtube. The point being to post videos. I believe recording a video response shows more appreciation than writing one.
jakedizzle 1 year ago
@Oanlitz2: 3,300 or so views is not a lot. My wedding proposal video had more than that until I put it on private.
HPLoveshaft 1 year ago
Clone wars - the cartoons, Lucas should shove up his ass
f00kumofo123 2 years ago
Right on!!
fractaldog 2 years ago
I Agree great review. Fuck that movie
jamesedwardclard 2 years ago 3
completely agreed
scrykidsscringme 2 years ago 8
Preach on!
MickTaylor 2 years ago 2