@anilkumarshinu This is not to agree or disagree whether rd copied or not. I really do not think copying should be thought about something bad. sitting today with internet all over and around we speak about copying from other songs. but i think more that copying gave us to listen to a music which we might not have got a chance to hear at all..
copying the right music and making a melody out of it in a different language is a big skill similar to our copying in the exams and getting high scores
@anilkumarshinu Dear Sir, I wouldn't use the word, "copying". Perhaps the word, "editing", or "enhancing" or "blending" or even "transforming" would be better words. R. D. blended western music with eastern in a manner that would only suit a genious. His speciality was the way he would use rhythm. If you don't have training in music, you can never catch his rhythm. His music may be described as "fantastic".
@dgarindam1983 Thanks for the upload, just love the song. It has slight hints of the song "Ruk jana nahi kahi haar kay" and a bit feel of David Gilmore guitar (shine on you crazy diamond), the introduction is just so haunting
and yes today's era is more of item songs with cheap lyrics and out of sync singers
gone are the days of rafi, lata, kishore, asha, udit, sanu, abhijeet, alka, anuradha, kavita...last of the league left is sonu nigam but he too complains on the non-availablity of gud songs.
@rajeev10able...I think you should watch your foul mouth your retard...you give people of Indian extraction a terrible name..if you do not start behaving I will have your account shut down on youtube..keep in mind abusive language on the web is a prosecutable offense...you might have to hide in India for the rest of your pathetic life
r d made this song both in bengali and hindi...in bengali r.d. himself sang this song and hindi he composed but s.p. balasubramaniam sang it... i think r.d.burman much sang better than s.p.balasubramaniam.
@rajeev10able dai who r u to say this "r d" sir is better than ..... "SPB" sir......u not even a dust before those guys keep ur suggestion in ur bleedy mind.........mind it
@sureshbalaji50 hey u idiot..u didn't understand what i said. this song composed by r.d bengali and hindi and r.d. himself sand in bengali and s.p. sang in hindi. r d. sang better sure in this particular song. that doesn't mean one is better than other..listen u stupid dumb ass, too much of idly makes u dumb ass. try some protein like meat or fish. its sharpen brain. protein develops brain cells. so too much of idly dhosa, vegetables making u ppl dumb and thats why u didn't understand.
the bengali version " tumi koto je dure" sung by the maestro himself is one of the best bengali compositions ever made. A tragic song can be such beautiful if it has only been touched by the midas himself (read RDB).
I stand corrected on his origins. I know of SPB from listening to his Tamil songs mostly.
I am really interested only in appreciating music not someone's place of birth.
Your comments are rude and uncalled for. Your comments shout out the following." Poor schooling and and an unread person"
It will be a cold day in hell before you can deign to teach me English. You must be every lonely to spend time trawling the net for people to rub the wrong way,
Dude, your comment reflects you. I was just correcting you. If you really feel so offended if someone corrects you, then you should be mindful of about what your writing in the first place.
I was minding my own business before you poked your snout into where it does not belong. Using words like dude or chill does not make you cool or absolve you of being an uninvited boor. Why don't you take your own advice and chill ?
Hey I see your comments have been flagged. Is it because you ran out of words you poor loser you.?..and had to resort to profanity?.by the way do you have anything worthwhile to do or you just trawl the net?. It looks like you are an A**hole and a loser! What a combination! Sad... all over an RD song... He must turning in his grave
Thanks for the advice. Maybe you should be the one to see a doctor,,you know the kind that treats deranged minds who takes to the net to gets his kicks
@sujaydani12 Dear just try to look for semantics. Urdu was developed in India (Primarily in Lucknow and without the local dilect the language development wouldn't have been possible. )
r.d burman is a great musician, but he has copied a lot of songs from english to make his projects.
anilkumarshinu 1 month ago
@anilkumarshinu This is not to agree or disagree whether rd copied or not. I really do not think copying should be thought about something bad. sitting today with internet all over and around we speak about copying from other songs. but i think more that copying gave us to listen to a music which we might not have got a chance to hear at all..
copying the right music and making a melody out of it in a different language is a big skill similar to our copying in the exams and getting high scores
dgarindam1983 1 month ago in playlist Uploaded videos
@dgarindam1983 I can show one example. The song "Mehabooba" is direct lift from Demis Roussoss’s Say You Love Me.
anilkumarshinu 1 month ago
@anilkumarshinu Dear Sir, I wouldn't use the word, "copying". Perhaps the word, "editing", or "enhancing" or "blending" or even "transforming" would be better words. R. D. blended western music with eastern in a manner that would only suit a genious. His speciality was the way he would use rhythm. If you don't have training in music, you can never catch his rhythm. His music may be described as "fantastic".
bkc7577 2 weeks ago
@anilkumarshinu
so what
panchamsfanclub 1 week ago
disagreeing to the above statement.......not two genius ,but one thats RD and not SPB
Indraneel1Chatterjee 2 months ago
no one come even near to rd's composition, greatest ever.
tamalray 3 months ago
Comment removed
soninapasar 3 months ago
Slight influence from Pink Floyd but what a genius of RDB touch. This is easily one the top compositions in Bollywood.
samincal4u 3 months ago
beautiful song!!!!!
myp232 3 months ago
pl sonmebody give the name opf the tamil version
VALANIFS 3 months ago
hallmark of the man's genius , as usual... the one and only panchamda...
venkeeful 3 months ago
beautyfull song,B U T FUL Composition
ak65454 4 months ago
Shine on You Crazy Burman.....
maithuster 4 months ago
we people are lucky.......this types of voice only in heaven
rajivtalapalli1 5 months ago
Everytime I hear this song I just go into a trance... This happens when two Greatest Genius meet RD & SPB
dgarindam1983 5 months ago
@dgarindam1983 Thanks for the upload, just love the song. It has slight hints of the song "Ruk jana nahi kahi haar kay" and a bit feel of David Gilmore guitar (shine on you crazy diamond), the introduction is just so haunting
palnilesh 4 days ago
heart touching music composition
aaswinjain 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
SP really sang it very well and with great attitude.....hats off to RD Burman for composing such a beautiful romantic song..........
pakierr0r 6 months ago
Comment removed
pakierr0r 6 months ago
realllyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy grt song
pakierr0r 6 months ago
my fav song.. <3 it..
nb4u1983 6 months ago
RD..RD.RD....nothing further...a gem of a song....!
johnmoosa 6 months ago
Wah Wah Great Song
junaidonlinenow 6 months ago
beautiful,what a voice......
vimi1ify 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
HAPPY BIRTHDAY R.D BURMAN TUM JIYO HAZARO SAL
avijitchatterjee59 7 months ago
HAPPY BIRTHDAY R.D BURMAN TUM JIYO HAZARO SAL
avijitchatterjee59 7 months ago
nice song
singhangad300 7 months ago
every1 loves romantic songs...but nowadays where is dat romance??
every1 is busy in flirting...
avradeep999 7 months ago
@avradeep999
wow u said so correctly
and yes today's era is more of item songs with cheap lyrics and out of sync singers
gone are the days of rafi, lata, kishore, asha, udit, sanu, abhijeet, alka, anuradha, kavita...last of the league left is sonu nigam but he too complains on the non-availablity of gud songs.
antuneeleshranjan 7 months ago
@antuneeleshranjan
hi u r right n i m total agree with u ir
singhangad300 7 months ago
Jaane tu hai kana, so apt, so poignant, so meaningful after losing you!
antaeusvh 7 months ago
fantabulous song frm the magician rd burman da
antuneeleshranjan 8 months ago
.asadharannn.
TheFallingStare 8 months ago
great composition .. both music director and singer are gods of music... long live balu sir..
ankhatri 8 months ago
RD was God.. He cant die... He is stil living with us...
vipulmvithlani 9 months ago
what a composition..
just kono kotha hobe na...asadharannn.....
meetarpita 11 months ago
@rajeev10able...I think you should watch your foul mouth your retard...you give people of Indian extraction a terrible name..if you do not start behaving I will have your account shut down on youtube..keep in mind abusive language on the web is a prosecutable offense...you might have to hide in India for the rest of your pathetic life
PrasadShastri 11 months ago
Awsome!!!!!!!!!
anne12345ful 11 months ago
the greatst song
hiromul 1 year ago
r d made this song both in bengali and hindi...in bengali r.d. himself sang this song and hindi he composed but s.p. balasubramaniam sang it... i think r.d.burman much sang better than s.p.balasubramaniam.
rajeev10able 1 year ago
@rajeev10able dai who r u to say this "r d" sir is better than ..... "SPB" sir......u not even a dust before those guys keep ur suggestion in ur bleedy mind.........mind it
sureshbalaji50 11 months ago
@sureshbalaji50 hey u idiot..u didn't understand what i said. this song composed by r.d bengali and hindi and r.d. himself sand in bengali and s.p. sang in hindi. r d. sang better sure in this particular song. that doesn't mean one is better than other..listen u stupid dumb ass, too much of idly makes u dumb ass. try some protein like meat or fish. its sharpen brain. protein develops brain cells. so too much of idly dhosa, vegetables making u ppl dumb and thats why u didn't understand.
rajeev10able 11 months ago
heart touching, one of the classics of all time
casanova0333 1 year ago
no body could have sung this song better than ballu bhaiya...luv this song..thanx for sharing dgarindam1983 boss
gautamkaku 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
no body could have sung this song better than ballu bhiya...luv this song..thanx for sharing dgarindam1983 boss
gautamkaku 1 year ago
No body could have sung this song better than ballu bhaiya....luv this song..thanx dgarindam1983 boss
gautamkaku 1 year ago
one of the best conpositon
rahul4458 1 year ago
we miss you R.D
sanjayvacharya 1 year ago
Seriously you are the BOSS...
arunava385 1 year ago
this is the best composition sung by balsubramanyam
rahul4458 1 year ago
the bengali version " tumi koto je dure" sung by the maestro himself is one of the best bengali compositions ever made. A tragic song can be such beautiful if it has only been touched by the midas himself (read RDB).
sambuddha7777 1 year ago
Really...Can't get enough of it...what a beautiful composition.....Kudos
subhajitdebroy 1 year ago
rediscovering the music of Sagar... n its kinda beautiful ...
shachipandey1 1 year ago
Ultimate SP Balasubramniam ur simply great singer
ankursrivastava16 1 year ago
SP at his best.
sandeepdsunny 1 year ago
I was looking for this song for quite some time now imagine if Kishore Kumar sung this song, having said this even SP has done a great job
waiter09 1 year ago
The beats and the guitar sound a lot like the intro bit in "Ammayi muddu ivvande" from "Kshana kshanam."
Keeravani might have been 'inspired' by this song.
Extraordinary song by Pancham da. Kudos.
mindryin 1 year ago
The prelude tune of this was also used in the movie Saagar, when Rishi Kapoor sees Dimple for the first time taking bath in the sea
subrajits 1 year ago
what combination!!!!! rd and sp, dream team and a dream song, like floating on silk on cloud nine
sevanagar 1 year ago
very refreshing song, was done in 80's but sounds very modern, superb
jaggernat 1 year ago
S.P.Balasubramaniam singing for Pancham Da.. can't get any better than this.. one of the most romantic songs in the history of Hindi cinema!!
rajeshshroff 1 year ago
sung by SP Balasubramaniam..the living legend
ssssdd123 1 year ago
evergreen!! the most romantic ever!!!
blackbox085 2 years ago
this is not just a song...............
the soul-song of nature
singing through mesmerizing RDBurman!!!!!!!!
balochiiii 2 years ago
@balochiiii RD Burman sang this?
ankithvyas 2 years ago
SP Bala from Tamil
sithikatt4 1 year ago
@sithikatt4 telugu dude....
vinnyloid 1 year ago
@sithikatt4
two things,
first correct your english,
secong SP Balasubramaniam is not tamilian and he is from Andhra Pradesh
mdprasad123 1 year ago
@mdprasad123
I stand corrected on his origins. I know of SPB from listening to his Tamil songs mostly.
I am really interested only in appreciating music not someone's place of birth.
Your comments are rude and uncalled for. Your comments shout out the following." Poor schooling and and an unread person"
It will be a cold day in hell before you can deign to teach me English. You must be every lonely to spend time trawling the net for people to rub the wrong way,
what a moron and imbecile.!
sithikatt4 1 year ago
@sithikatt4
Dude, your comment reflects you. I was just correcting you. If you really feel so offended if someone corrects you, then you should be mindful of about what your writing in the first place.
Just chill dude
mdprasad123 1 year ago
@mdprasad123
I was minding my own business before you poked your snout into where it does not belong. Using words like dude or chill does not make you cool or absolve you of being an uninvited boor. Why don't you take your own advice and chill ?
sithikatt4 1 year ago
Comment removed
mdprasad123 1 year ago
Comment removed
mdprasad123 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@sithikatt4
thanks for ur advice ANGRY man....... just what the doctor advised
mdprasad123 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@mdprasad123
Hey I see your comments have been flagged. Is it because you ran out of words you poor loser you.?..and had to resort to profanity?.by the way do you have anything worthwhile to do or you just trawl the net?. It looks like you are an A**hole and a loser! What a combination! Sad... all over an RD song... He must turning in his grave
sithikatt4 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@sithikatt4
thanks for ur advice ANGRY man....... just what the doctor advised
mdprasad123 1 year ago
@mdprasad123
Thanks for the advice. Maybe you should be the one to see a doctor,,you know the kind that treats deranged minds who takes to the net to gets his kicks
sithikatt4 1 year ago
@mdprasad123
true but he will die as a tamilan :)
erropop 11 months ago
one off the best Hindi songs,
preferred as #1
rajeev02118 2 years ago 8
@rajeev02118 Aray Hindi Nahi Urdu Song Hai,
Hindi to Namashkar, Ashirwad, Waghaira Alfaz Wali Hoti Hai... Ye To URDU Hai
asifoct 10 months ago
@asifoct Urdu Hindi ke bina yateem hai. Hindi Urdu ki maa hai. Janam dene wali maa kehlati
johnangelo2000 8 months ago
@johnangelo2000
hindi song ++ aap hame aadesh kare to hum prem ka shri ganesh kare...this hindi song,
sujaydani12 7 months ago
@sujaydani12 Dear just try to look for semantics. Urdu was developed in India (Primarily in Lucknow and without the local dilect the language development wouldn't have been possible. )
johnangelo2000 7 months ago
excellence of r.d. burman.
nayaghoda 2 years ago 9