People tend these days to describe any odd time signature or atonal melodies as "Art Rock". It is just a label and labels are psychologically limiting. This is a nice song and fits the Prog motif.
People tend these days to describe any odd time signature or atonal melodies as "Prog". It is just a label and labels are psychologically limiting. This is a nice song and fits the Art Rock motif.
This is some really good stuff. I don't normally like Progressive Rock (I appreciate it, but I don't listen to stuff link Pink Floyd, Yes, Genesis, Rush, etc, on a regular or frequent basis) but this is really excellent.
Man, some people don't understand the 21st century. Does today's prog sound like 70s prog? No. Does today's pop sound like 70s pop? No. Come on, people. As much I'd like it to be, this isn't 1973. Music has evolved since then. Sure, this isn't experimental or complex; but it's a more delicate and simple side of prog. At the very least just think of it as a song in itself.
It's just as progressive in nature as "Us and Them" by Pink Floyd. It certainly is at the mellow end of the prog scale. I guess it could also be considered "melodic rock", like Moody Blues. Melodic and prog overlap at points.
Magenta never are. I don't even get why they are considered prog at all. They have minor prog elements in their arrangements (obviously not here), but that's pretty much it.
Good vocal:) yeah u go on keeping your thang girl! Soooo pure and beautiful! Love it soooo much man! I loooove prog rock sooo muchhhhhh!!! Yaaayayayayayayayayayayay :D
There is now a new version, available on the "Singles" album and free for download from their website, which has a much more rocky solo on the end, it's awesome!
You are so right i know Tina and the band very well,Chris Fry is an amazing guitarist and his brother Dan now plays bass in the band. The Brains is Rob Reed musician and producer extrodinaire a real talent.
If you have the Gathering DVD i am in the special features talking pissed as a newt LOL.
It seems you are mistaken. Or a little confused. I can't see why you would say 'cookie cutter', and it certainly is prog, seeing as how the song goes through stages, never repeating itself. Isn't that the definition of progressive?
Not really. It's cookie cutter in that when I listened to it the first time, I predicted every single progression. The song doesn't really go through stages, it changes itself based upon already established chord progressions. I have no right to say what is prog and what isn't, but as far as I'm concerned, I would file this under maybe avante-pop.
i think the spirit of progessive is clear: an evolution from an acoustic sweet song to a lush instrumental section. there are strings and a beautiful electric guitar solo near the end. great song.
I can understand those who talks about "old prog" it's true that Magenta isn't breaking any rules with it's old fashioned prog' but... Christina's so... gorgeous and her voice is so cute ;-)
I think this is archetypal progressive rock. Would have fit right in with early Genesis. OK, it's not in 13/8 time and may not sound like an Altairian mating chant played on electric kazoos, but neither did King Crimson's "I Talk to the Wind." I enjoyed it for what it is.
OMG! I WAS AT THAT CONCERT WITH MY DAD :D that was so funny xD they were having technical difficulties and so Chris starting playing jingle bells... AMAZING BAD!
So you appear in the dvd Live at the Point
rushfacu 3 months ago
Kind of like a Kate Bush, though maybe not quite as pretty...or weird..
DCussen 9 months ago
@DCussen Or talented, or original, or interesting or...you know, good.
teaflax 5 months ago
Damn! Christina is so beautiful...even her feet are perfect....yummy!
SANTORIOBUSTANUT 1 year ago
Sounds like an updated version of the band Curved Air, that did stuff like this 35-40 years ago. Nice to hear something current in this genre.
morleygrey 1 year ago
Does anyone got tabs for this? i couldnt find it
Alblackk 1 year ago
oh what a great performance, yumyum
Sawa137 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
People tend these days to describe any odd time signature or atonal melodies as "Art Rock". It is just a label and labels are psychologically limiting. This is a nice song and fits the Prog motif.
lol lol lol
richardwhl 2 years ago
People tend these days to describe any odd time signature or atonal melodies as "Prog". It is just a label and labels are psychologically limiting. This is a nice song and fits the Art Rock motif.
Beadbud5000 2 years ago
This is some really good stuff. I don't normally like Progressive Rock (I appreciate it, but I don't listen to stuff link Pink Floyd, Yes, Genesis, Rush, etc, on a regular or frequent basis) but this is really excellent.
Send em to America for us?
MontySmith88 2 years ago 4
Was hat das mit ihren Beinen zu tun. Solche blöden Kommentare braucht die Welt.
Ich habe dieses Duo heute zum ersten Mal (bewusst) gehört und ich finde sie klasse!
Danke fürs Einstellen, TravelChampion. (Thank you!)
Lujacos 2 years ago
Man, some people don't understand the 21st century. Does today's prog sound like 70s prog? No. Does today's pop sound like 70s pop? No. Come on, people. As much I'd like it to be, this isn't 1973. Music has evolved since then. Sure, this isn't experimental or complex; but it's a more delicate and simple side of prog. At the very least just think of it as a song in itself.
BinkyTheRabbit 2 years ago
Ok I see but where is the progression in this song? :)
melakseek 2 years ago 2
Exactly! Where is the thing that gives Prog Rock its name?
Good point man.
rodrigitotube 2 years ago
It's just as progressive in nature as "Us and Them" by Pink Floyd. It certainly is at the mellow end of the prog scale. I guess it could also be considered "melodic rock", like Moody Blues. Melodic and prog overlap at points.
gareebee 2 years ago 2
where is the rock?!!!
loris760 2 years ago
not so progressive
ucutumia 2 years ago
Magenta never are. I don't even get why they are considered prog at all. They have minor prog elements in their arrangements (obviously not here), but that's pretty much it.
teaflax 2 years ago
awesome
rtother666 2 years ago 2
waste of time
JimHarmatz 2 years ago
Comment removed
dnsrees 2 years ago
Great sound.
Reminds me of Camel.
The group, not the animal.
Rikkadir 2 years ago
would you , repeat !^^ please ! are you sure ? ! ; )
well i don t really agree , or few seconds
adnaruto25 2 years ago
Love this band actually. ^^
Freddie25 2 years ago
prog rock??
is it a dragqueen???
GandhiLama 3 years ago
Good vocal:) yeah u go on keeping your thang girl! Soooo pure and beautiful! Love it soooo much man! I loooove prog rock sooo muchhhhhh!!! Yaaayayayayayayayayayayay :D
doutzen177cm 3 years ago
wow, this is probably the best original song video for me on Youtube. Wish that distortion was a little more climactic during the solo though.
dude111111111110 3 years ago
There is now a new version, available on the "Singles" album and free for download from their website, which has a much more rocky solo on the end, it's awesome!
musicman1692 2 years ago 3
Wow she's drop dead gorgeous and has a great voice :)
philipgregorymusic 3 years ago
You are so right i know Tina and the band very well,Chris Fry is an amazing guitarist and his brother Dan now plays bass in the band. The Brains is Rob Reed musician and producer extrodinaire a real talent.
If you have the Gathering DVD i am in the special features talking pissed as a newt LOL.
Ry42Back 3 years ago
cool... ncie sound...
IronWorkz 3 years ago
buuuuuhhh!!!!
aburrido!!!!!
kamezzx 3 years ago
Yea So
good band
its not as if igot to say that =D
XxtootsyxX 3 years ago
Cookie cutter rockpop. Although near the halfway mark, it started to catch my interest. But as what it is. And it's definitely not prog.
jackandmeg2001 3 years ago
It seems you are mistaken. Or a little confused. I can't see why you would say 'cookie cutter', and it certainly is prog, seeing as how the song goes through stages, never repeating itself. Isn't that the definition of progressive?
poboproductions 3 years ago
Not really. It's cookie cutter in that when I listened to it the first time, I predicted every single progression. The song doesn't really go through stages, it changes itself based upon already established chord progressions. I have no right to say what is prog and what isn't, but as far as I'm concerned, I would file this under maybe avante-pop.
jackandmeg2001 2 years ago
Well then it's predictable prog. Regardless of the genre, I think that it's pretty cool.
poboproductions 2 years ago
i think the spirit of progessive is clear: an evolution from an acoustic sweet song to a lush instrumental section. there are strings and a beautiful electric guitar solo near the end. great song.
frankibio 3 years ago
what a great band, nice finding with this band. i am very happy of have found them.. what a voice good job.!!
bugsex2012 3 years ago
what a beautiful voice
LizzieSpark 3 years ago
That's my guitar teacher up there (Y)!
Rogue1011 3 years ago
That's my uncle up there (Y)!
XxtootsyxX 3 years ago
I can understand those who talks about "old prog" it's true that Magenta isn't breaking any rules with it's old fashioned prog' but... Christina's so... gorgeous and her voice is so cute ;-)
renaudoo 3 years ago
You are great Christina!
comalies77 3 years ago
Boring. I must confess that I was fooled by the "Progressive rock" label. This has NOTHING to do with prog rock.
liam5150 3 years ago
I think this is archetypal progressive rock. Would have fit right in with early Genesis. OK, it's not in 13/8 time and may not sound like an Altairian mating chant played on electric kazoos, but neither did King Crimson's "I Talk to the Wind." I enjoyed it for what it is.
wardka 3 years ago
it was very good. i enjoyed it. wasn't prog tho. beautiful, but not prog.
brianhasredhair2 3 years ago
You got a pretty narrow definition of "Progressive Rock" then. I thought it was quite good.
herbie2001tdi 3 years ago
jordan bool behave your self on youtube
EVILLORD987 3 years ago
HAHA dumb ass not technical difficatlys
let me tell you something drumma dude alan ran off got into his car and drove home!
he came back =]
thats why he is quit dah
im robs neice i love getting the lovly gossip on magenta
im at every point consert working behind the magenta stuff table.
XxtootsyxX 3 years ago
Hey >:( i only just found out!
Not nice to call me a dumbass, how was i ment to know? -.-
karagain 3 years ago
Well its mr Chris fry
Jordanbool2112 4 years ago
I was also standing behind the guy who recorded this :) CHRIS IS HOT XD
karagain 4 years ago
OMG! I WAS AT THAT CONCERT WITH MY DAD :D that was so funny xD they were having technical difficulties and so Chris starting playing jingle bells... AMAZING BAD!
karagain 4 years ago
This is my favourite Magenta song, and i had the pleasure of meeting the band, and seeing them at The Robin - Bilston in November.
The Buffet was fantastic.
gooner194 4 years ago
And I was stood the other side of him - superb gig !
niggly69 4 years ago
and i wish i had been there, too.
so hot! the girl performs barefoot.
Pectiniculus 4 years ago
They were awesome as usual. Can't wait for the dvd. (I was standing next to Travelchampion as he recorded this).
dabaynton 4 years ago