Added: 2 years ago
From: bravenewfilms
Views: 88,342
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,071)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • well it seems like the truth always gets bashed n islam is the truth and the message has come to you so don't blame any muslims in the day of judgement.

  • dick cheney is a WAR-CRIMINAL!! period

  • You’re a waste of a human being, and your opinions come from absolutely experience or other solid foundation. You probably are one of those people that think the world is out to get you, and your hobbies include basket weaving or some form art. Your defiantly about to be blocked so don’t bother replying, just use this as food for thought and try to grow with it.

  • This subject is more intricate in detail then you realize. It is not a one step process that makes them mindless tools. It is a long and patient process that grooms people (commonly referred to as brainwashing). Besides that point, recruiting anyone to work with them is beneficial for their cause, even if they don’t blow themselves up. They need supply guys and MTI’s just like USA does. You have no knowledge of this subject.

  • @raavan06

    lol i love how you think that you are providing information that is unknown or clever. this is not new to anyone. stop being a dumb wanker.

    its kinda sad that you have to do that to make yourself feel clever.

    and it is impossible to truly knw what people are thinking, you can make reasonable assumptions but you will never knw for sure.

  • @Crazylalalalala Don’t be angry that you are an idiot. The statistics he is talking about don’t come from only the dead. Additionally be advised if you think it is a “reasonable” also meaning logical, “assumption” also meaning statement, why are you even wasting your time and multiplying yourself into an illogical uneducated(or not a very good education) clown? You are bad at making your point.

  • @raavan06

    its funny that you call other people idiots yet you cant even form a counter to my argument. and then go off in a personal attack. its sad that you have to do that to make ur self feel significant.

  • most of the violance in iraq is not even directed at US troops. The iraqi civilians are baring the brunt of it. So to say that these foreign fighters join because they care so much about their fellow muslims seems a bit strange.

    I doubt they were like "OMG look what the US is doing to them... " then they go off and blow themselfs up in a market full of muslims with no US troops around. just doesnt make sense.

    they shouldnt be turturing people but its not the core of the issue.

  • @Crazylalalalala In addition to that, remember that torture and abuse is counterproductive, and it is an extremely useful recruiting tool for terrorist organizations. We established a relationship with Iraqi people, and basically promised them a better lifestyle. Terrorist’s blow-up markets full of people because they are an easy target, additionally it shows that America is not doing well at bringing the peace we want to. Since we cannot do a good job people seek safety elsewhere.

  • @raavan06

    im not supporting torture as a practice. but it doesnt make sense for foreign fighter to join a cause because they brothers where being abused/tortued by the US when that cause kills far more of their brothers then the US. it makes even less sense to pin in on torture or abuse.

    the strategy of the terrorist is pretty obvious as you stated. but stating that people join in to that strategy to protect their fallow muslims makes no sense.

  • hmm, how did they come up with the figure that 90% of the suicide bombers did it because of this torture? didnt realize that US intelligence services can get information from the after life.

  • @Crazylalalalala Long after your dead, people will still be able to find out you are an idiot because of the stupid thing you said on YouTube.

    Your choices always have a reason, and that reason is likely compromised when you express it to others. For Example, your favorite color, or the reason you applied for, or worked somewhere was compromised and possibly even documented, when your employer asked why you wish to be hired.

  • @raavan06

    said the idiot who made a comment that has nothing to do with what i said.

  • I advise you to slow down, read your comment. Then read my comment, finally ask yourself how my response gives a legitimate reason that intelligence can get information “from the afterlife”. I hope the other posts steer you in the right direction, even though I think if you couldn’t analyze the first comment, you will experience an epic failure at comprehending the others.

  • @raavan06

    it is impossible to knw the true reason of why someone did what he did. He could have tolled someone something but there is no way of knwing if that was infact the reason.

  • @Crazylalalalala You’re dumb as a rock, and I’m done talking with you. That safety elsewhere I was referring to are terrorist organizations that lie and preach to these people a secure lifestyle. It’s a 3rd world country and many of them don’t have the freedom to see what you do. When they do get news, it’s usually from these bad people, and the majority of it is lies that degrade westerners. It is not impossible to find out why people do things.

  • Why just Cheney? What about the Obama administration? Torture advocacy is hardly only a GOP method in waging planetary war. Mr. Obama has escalated everything, openly and covertly.

  • I guess we should throw flowers instead of grenades, shoot pixie dust instead of guns. War isn't neat and nice so people need to wake up and realize we are at war and we need to use every resource we can to take out our enemy.

  • Comment removed

  • @loccysmif How am I the enemy? And if you read my last statement, chances are you wouldn't find an unruly garden hose let alone muslim terrorists or me.

  • Comment removed

  • This is a good presentation, but the interrogator should detail his experience: where he drew the line between right and wrong, how he held it, and if-and-how his line changed over those 1000 interrogations.

    Cheney, Rumsfeld, Bush, Yoo, and others should all be jailed for war crimes, but there still must be some criminal torturers on the bottom to be prosecuted.

  • i agree 100% with what that guy just said.. fuck torture it doesnt do anything but promote hate like we need anymore of that?

  • This is very interesting. I am a retired Army Intelligence Interrogator (MOS: 96C which became 97E). I retired in Sep 1998. I am interested, since up until my retirement--well within your 14 year career--there were no Air Force interrogators; at least not for hostile intelligence Interrogation. There could have been SP's that practiced law enforcement interrogation, but nothing in the intelligence field.

  • Comment removed

  • @loccysmif I am not sure exactly what you are trying to say, other than expressing your personal moral evauation. I don't think anyone would argue that 'torture' is immoral. The logical flaw here is that no one has defined exactly what they mean when they use the word 'torture'. (This is the same flaw to be found in most discussions--as well as both national and international treaties and law--about 'terrorism'.)

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @loccysmif Actually, I was not trying to lure you into a sematic debate. I just didn't realize that there was a character limit until I went way over it. If you don't recognize that some things need to be objectively defined, then we are wasting our time. For instance, what does 'brutal' mean? It can range from perm physical damage to hurt feelings. Seeing as how some people think that forcing someone to listen to loud music a night is torture, isn't important we define it, first?

  • Comment removed

  • @loccysmif Absolutely! It would be a walk in the park compared to what they normally do. You forget, that I have had done to me all the things that are described as 'torture'. But as your mind is made up that you know all about it, this conversation is over. I try not to waste my time on fools.

  • Comment removed

  • @loccysmif, There is a huge difference between average American citizens and government. The US government tortured, the people didn't. Many Americans are disgusted at the way their government is doing things and the danger they are putting it's citizens in. They are beyond out of control and there is basically nothing we can do about it.

  • @freedomsadvocate Not to mention, how does someone on RESERVES get into Interrogation or intelligence?

  • Matthew knows what he is talking about unlike idiot dick head Cheney .

  • He is 100% rite

  • If Dick Cheney does not burn in hell for all eternity, the Bible is a lie.

  • I get all of my news events from a Russian channel, a couple of ours earlier too. All sweet and unbiased, you guys should try that, get out of the box we're all in every once in a while... Also to experience how the world sees us

  • @shadowprism

    Which channel? I'm always looking for new news sources, and I'd be interested to check it out.

  • Russian television, I think channel 274 if u have comcast, usually placed next to the Al-Jazeera channel. Good stuff

  • Lesson learnt here is never to be captured alive

  • 1st. Why is it OK to prosecute Sadam and Molosovich for human rights abuse and war crimes and not Bush and Co?

    2nd. US did not have world support because the world loved and cared about US citizens, it was the upolding of an ideal that gave the US its power. In engaging in torture, it shartered those ideals in the most incidous ways and lost its power base.

    3rd. In future, how can any Western POW's ever feel safe. By engaging in it, the US has condoned it on a world wide basis.

  • If only more americans could think rationally like this man and not have their judgement clouded by hatred and racism

  • Cheney is yet ANOTHER example of the profoundly bad judgement that is the hallmark of the republican party. That is if you buy into the idea that any conservative terrorist activity's are "mistakes" at all. Republican Cons are cold hardened murdering criminals who must be held accountable if we care at all about the "future generations" everyone claims to care so much about in their self interests.

  • fox news is the greatest channel on TV.

  • @jda1961

    who owns that channel? i think if you look deeper you will find that FOX is just another proponent of the left/right paradigm used to divide you and conquer you. it is just as evil as the other channels

  • WHEN WILL BUSH AND GANG HANG?

  • @agent1up How about when you step up and be a hangman.

  • Let's be honest and get down to the truth that no one seems to want to talk about. If Adolf Hitler were running for President of the United State and he picked Stalin as his running mate and he ran as a Republican, the Republicans would vote for him. They don't care about Right or Wrong, Good or Bad and they honestly don't care about America. They hate this President on two Major fronts. He's a Democrat and a Black man. Obama could create the cure for Cancer they would find a way to hate on it.

  • @jds51500 actually I heard that Obamas urine does cure cancer at the pray to Obama meeting I went to.

  • I like the humor, the exaggeration, and there is some truth behind your comments. Bottom line, Repunklicans are in a death grip within the wanning days of WASP control of the US. And therefore will do anything and support anybody that may further thier hegemony just a few more years.

  • Sadly you are correct. I don't even think Obama is doing much better than Bush but I find myself defending him against the ignorance of the Fox news worshipers.

  • i completely agree with you

  • I just came from abc's news web page and i cant believe Americans are defending torture! An eye for an eye makes the whole world go blind. This is definitely a dark time for humanity. Pray for all souls!

  • this clip contradicts the notion that Al-Queda and Iraq were not linked, wont you say?

  • Not really. Al-Queda didn't exist in Iraq until after we invaded. Al-Queda used that and the abuse as recruiting tools to get a hold in Iraq.

  • Comment removed

  • There is no doubt that Cheny and Bushshould be prosecuted for war crimes and the murder of thousands of innocent lives, to include the murder of our troops for putting them in this situation. I've never seen a more uneducated and arrogant man as cheney.

  • im doing a paper on torture from a sociological perspective, little did i know how complicatied and controversial this issue is

    anyways torrture is internationally illegal and those lawyers, whose jobs are to enforce and protect the law, abused their power to make waterboarding look legal, they should be on trial, and cheney too because he was the one who asked those lawyers to make the law flexible...

  • Maybe you would like to lay out the errors that Yoo and Bybee made in their legal analysis? I'm sure that now that you have done a paper on the issue you are more qualified than these respected attorneys to evaluate this legal issue.

  • torture is unconstitutional...then again the bush administration raped the constitution

  • I hate it when people say that we should torture because they torture our own people. You know what? We're supposed to be ABOVE that. We're supposed to REFUSE to stoop to their level.

    We can't call ourselves the good guys and do bad guy things. Yes, Cheney should be put on trial for war crimes.

    Not only is torture immoral and inefficient (a true interrogator will tell you that only a poor interrogator uses torture as a first resort), it is against the 3rd and 4th Geneva Conventions.

  • what a total GREEDY idiot, liar, cheat, piece of garbage this man cheney is. I hope he sees pain in his own life befitting the pain he has inflicted on others.

  • Obama should try, convict, and execute Bush, Chenny and others on pay per view t.v.. That should generate enough cash to pay for the illegal iraq war!

  • This guy is the real deal. Dick Cheney is a draft dodging chickenhawk who ordered people tortured to get them to falsely confess to nonexistent Al Qaida connections with Iraq. Cheney should be tried for war crimes.

  • Nobody on this planet has the right to decide who to torture and who not to, who deserves to die and who deserves to live....

  • Evolution is a word, not a belief.

    Toggling between a word and whatever wad of political theology they are attempting to proselytize at the moment is the signature trait of socialists.

    A few other such words are gay, liberal, conservative, progressive, welfare, environment, global-warming, and green.

    Word sophistry is one of their most prolific marketing tools.For example, it's how they absolve the Democrat party of its rich history of slavery, racism, and domestic terrorism.

  • This little socialite needs to leave the USA and go live wherever you submissive dipshits will be happy singing kumbya together holding hands

  • Bush and Cheney were using torture to get other people to confess to crimes they committed. Until Bush and Cheney are in jail we are no longer a country of law. WE HAVE TO PROSECUTE THEM!!!

  • Al-Quaeda has a right to fight the US for torturing and slaughtering so many citizens. Since we won't convict the highest levels of our government of warcrimes, as they have commited, our entire country has commited warcrimes and should be forced to make repairations, even through war. Every American citizen who refuses to fight to put Bush away is, in a sense, being stood in for by an Al-Quaeda freedom fighter. Al-Quaeda is bad, but the US is worse. You people suck.

  • Who is "WE"? "our war crimes" ? You arent an American who the fuck are you talking about?

    limpkin here is the result of a mass braiwashing gone so horribly right that he literally wants to die. Why dont you just get the fuck out of America?

  • We is Americans. I am partly an American. If you don't take any action against your leaders, you are responsible for their actions. Ergo, Americans share the burden of warcrimes with the Bush administration.

    I'm no limpkin, you really need to learn how to read. How could brainwashing go wrong in the first place, you fucking idiot? If you think I'm wrong, then wouldn't the brainwashing be going smoothly? I don't want to die, and I'm a minor. I'm saying they have a right to fight our military.

  • LIMPKIN- Hey dipshit... YOU cant read.

    I said it went "horribly right" moron.

    You are just a spoiled little brat who thinks he knows what is going on in the world but you really dont realize that you are a pawn in some old Jewish Socialists scheme to enslave us.

    You are discusting.

    LIMPKIN

  • LMFAO!

  • And I'm the one who is brainwashed? Go have a smoke with your nazi friends and ignore us commies. And by commies, I mean the whole damn world. America is spending millions on Israel - why don't YOU get the fuck out of America?

  • Yeah the whole damn world? Oh. Youre so smart little Limpkin. Do me a favor and come on back and talk to KingDingaLing once you have hair on your balls.

    Little Limpkin.

    I dont have time to engage in debates with children. Run along... LAAAAAaate.

  • "And by commies, I mean the whole damn world." That's called sarcasm. Well, it wouldn't be in your crazy eyes, of course, but it was to me. And dude, with a name like KingofDickLicking, children are the only people you can keep up with in an argument. Go stare at your porn collection/oh-so-hairy balls while you fervently try to get an erection.

    What the fuck is late supposed to mean?

  • I know what sarcasm is and that wasnt sarcasm. It was an overstatement maybe but not sarcasm. Little Limpkin.

    You just got carried away with your adolecent balls. By adolecent balls I mean they havent dropped yet and no hair on them. Little Limpkin.

    You are a child involved in a discussion that you dont have the education to handle and you are in WAY over your head.

    By over your head I mean you are drowning in a sea of propaganda and everything you think and say is bullshit.

  • You think the world is ruled by socialists/communists and coneiving jews, and I'M the one without education? Like I said, the only people you can hold your head above water with in an argument are minors, and you reaffirm this by repeating little limpkin, because you think this is going to win an argument with a child (or at least distract them from your insanity.) Seriously, does any mainsteam media spout your ideas? Hell no. So how is my bullshit any different than the common US citizen's?

  • Little Limpkin- You dont have the slightest clue who or what I'm talking about. So I'll give you a name, George Soros.

    Go look him up. The reason you are so sure of yourself is because Socialists control the media.

    Seriously Little Limpkin. You are a rat and you say, think and do exactly what they want. YOU ARE SEVERELY BRAINWASHED.

    BTW I'm 27 Little Limpkin, I know I seem like an old man to children though.

  • So fox news, who was for a time if not now #1, is socialist? The channel whose main attack against Obama was that he was socialist?

    Being brainwashed is being in a state where, through extensive torture, you will give up important information without any concious thought about it. The media has taken this term and run with it, and labeled people who will not listen to reason as being brainwashed. I am not brainwashed.

  • Who the fuck asked you? I guess this is little Limpkin? Oh ok. Yeah Fox news is the ONLY other media network that isnt completely socialist and they have mostly stooges working for them like Shep Smith and Bill O'reily. Hanity is conservative but he is a puppet too. Brainwashed has nothing to do with torture unless you are talking about shock therapy where a person is litteraly programed. But dont take it from me, just look at the ultimate example, the Nazi Joeseph Goerbbels... to be continued

  • part 2 little Limpkin. Joseph Geobbels said all you have to do is tell a lie enough times and it becomes the truth.

    For example you think we are just as evil as terrorists because you were programed to think they have done nothing wrong and we killed their people. However you are probably unaware that we found 550 tons of Uranium and biological weapons of mass destruction and Sadam Huessien was a mass murderer who was responsible for the death of over a million of his people.

  • People may very well be influencing my thoughts and I may very well be thinking as they want, but I am in complete control and responsible for my actions. We all have the choice to believe what we want, and even you agree, as you do not pity me as some mind slave of an evil society, you hate me for my own opinions and ideas, whether they happen to agree with the majority or not.

    Your youtube page proclaims that you are 64. I didn't say it without reason.

  • It's obviously not the same 'bullshit' as the common citizens, but it's all bullshit to you, isn't it?

    After you answer me this, I'm done toying with an old man like you. But you can dream about how you won it all with your brilliant talking points. (grow some hair on your balls! everything you and everyone else says is wrong! socialist jews are enslaving us!)

  • Torture is the process of verifying what the torturer already believes to be true, otherwise, how would the torturer know when to end the "interrogation"?

    Historically, torture has been used to terrorize the enemy and gain false confessions.

    How can anyone trust a government that would use a technique for "information gathering" if the same technique can be used for false confessions?

  • spot on man

  • This guy is full of shit...Torture works..and should be used..The enemy does it because it works...How stupid are you?...Everyone tries to make a name for themselves by selling out those they worked for when their popularity wanes...We need to stop buying the bull shit that almost got the traitor John Kerry elected..Cant wait until this self admitted torturer runs for office on a hypocritical platform...Imbecile.

  • Mr. Alexander states it correctly. We had the same result in Viet Nam, the more we tortured, killed the innocent , the quicker we lost the "heart" of the Viet Namese People. We left a legacy of SHAME, but it is the New World Order

    Bankgangsters that get control of Key positions of our Government. NEVER let members of CFR, Tri-lateralists, Skul & Bones club into positions of influence... which they hold 99% of today... and we are in a mess , they helped create via both

    Dem, & GOP.

  • This guy shuts cheney down! Wait and see everyone! This issue is far from over. We will be paying the price for the bush administration for years if not decades. One good thing I think will come out of this is that when it is time to vote for the President, remember just how the GOP handles emergencies. They can not see past the nose on their faces and can not see the long term damage that they do. Fuck'um!

  • peaceispatriotic- you are obviously dumb as fuck so um fuck off k. bye bye then.

  • Aaahhh! Are you a poor loser and can't pull a half decent arguement out of your ass? Dial 1-800-whaaaaa!

  • Lol. Yeah RIGHT. Go read my other comments if you want an argument. Im tired of communicating with sheople.

    Retards dont understand words.

  • Good God, even a child could read Cheney's body language: he doesn't believe a word he's saying. He's lying, he knows he's lying and he thinks we don't know he's lying. Pathetic. And criminal.

  • the first thing is that from looking at the world history you have no clue what you are talking about KingDingaLing090. All you are doing is insulting the others on this page. Calling them socialist when you have no idea of their personal views. Then even if a person was socialist that doesn't mean they are cruel or bad people. They only have a diffrent look on the world which you should respect. Also the Islamic faith does not teach people to hate only people who bend it for their own gain do.

  • Oh really? If someone supports Obama they are Socialists or they are too stupid to understand his politics. I dont have to respect anything, I hate socialism and I have good reason to hate it. The Islamic faith has to be twisted in order for it to be peaceful. The classical Islamic faith is hateful and violent. The only reason you think it is not hateful is because someone lied to you. I have read the Quran, have you? Do want me to quote chapter and verse?

    Just let me know. Kacah5

  • if you hate socialism so much, then i guess that means you'll never dial 911 if you're in trouble, right? you'd rather call a privatized police and fire department? how about tolls on every single highway you drive on?

    Canada is a socialist country, and the financial crisis had one of the smallest impacts on our economy of all the western countries! :P

    And btw, ALL THREE big religions promote violence and irrational behaviour.

  • I hate cops I think they make WAY too much money for what their education level their pensions are unsustainable. I have never gotten the help I needed from them. If it was my choice I would make them accountable to the people who pay them. Like ME. If they had some form of competition and I could take my business elsewhere that would be AWESOME! duuuuude.

    That's a good idea seanrz. High five : )

    Tell me about Christianity and Judaism promoting violence. Seanrz. Im listening.

  • Deuteronomy 3:1-7 Psalms 136:17-21 Deuteronomy 7:1-6;20:16-17 Joshua 6:20-21 Joshua 8:1-2 Joshua 11:14 Numbers 31:7-12 Numbers 31:14-18 Numbers 31:25-47 I Samuel 15:1-3 Isaiah 13:13-20 Ezekiel 9:1-7 II Chronicles 36:16-17 Jeremiah 48:10 Revelation 6:3-4
  • Wow you taught yourself to google. I AM not impressed. wa, wa, waaaah.

  • You're just a retarded Bill O'Reilly fanboy. You don't even have a clue. Quit ripping off other people's opinions and trying to pass them off as your own. That's artificial intelligence.

  • I HATE Bill O'Rielly. You are wrong AGAIN dipshit.

    Lol!! Now you think I am just ripping off other people's opinions? Hmmm. Like my opinion that Islam is a religion of hate and war? That is an awful lot of opinions Im ripping off then huh? Like, my proffessors in college, and the authors of books I have read? Hmmm... "The Quran, and the Book of Sacred Islamic law?

    You probably never even studied it yourself huh iM0st3r?? So what do you base your opinion on? Hypocrit. Lol!

  • It's not just Islam, it's Christianity, Judaism, and Mormonism. All you have to do is read them and use common sense. You can't find God in any book.Knowing that why would I study it? I've seen enough passages to know it's not worth the time. Lol, hypocrite? It's not whether one of us is a hypocrite or not. We all are.

  • None of the others you listed have Preists, Pastors or Rabbi's that preach the old testamate litterally. They dont tell followers to carry out ANY violence WHATSOEVER.

    ISLAM DOES they teach that it is commanded by Allah to kill. .

  • Are you serious dude? Islam is a religion of hate and war? The Catholic religion has more blood on their hands than any other religion. Fuck-N-A, get off YouTube and open a book! Jesus!

  • Even when you're proven wrong by your own methods, you still can't even admit you're wrong just reply with petty insults. What a colossal dipshit. Stop post comments and just stick to masturbating to FOX news.

  • You mind telling me what you proved me wrong about?

    BTW I NEVER watch Fox news. I skin it.

    You didnt do shit and you havent even said what you are trying to prove. What is your point? Please tell me or just SHUT THE FUCK UP.

  • .................

    If you think they make too much money then that right there says something about YOUR education level and quality. Do your parents know you're on the computer?

  • Dude shut the fuck up. They start out at 75 to 80 thoudsand a year with no college expirience and retire at like 50. They dont do SHIT. And fuck you anyways.

  • Chainey and his administration needs to be sent to prison. End of discussion.

  • so what's the answer? get out of the loop! don't believe the hype. i don't let irishness be my identity. patriotism is about power and violence. i'm a person. so are you. so is everyone. i live through others. so do we all. us v them is the problem. so is talk talk talk. enjoy enjoy be happy be positive be emotionally intelligent. don't speak of individuals as muslim or american. that's maintaining a false consciousness. run for the hills! ha ha ha

  • american leaders and strategists, obama states in his 'audacity of hope' have perenially favoured subversive strategies such as supporting revolutions[and ethnic cleansing], genocide and assassination to exercise political control, rather then overt imperialism. there's nothing new here. i'm not saying america is worse than other states... it's just not better than any. it thrives on keeping strong through controlling the world's resources. it's about power and egotism, not people and altruism.

  • Insofar as torture working against our front-line forces and our objectives, I find his commentary consistent with other reports, thus credible:

    "Anyone who served in Iraq, and veterans on both sides of the aisle have made this argument, knows that the foreign fighters did not come to Iraq en masse until after the revelations of torture and abuse at Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo Bay. I heard this from captured foreign fighters day in and day out when I was supervising interrogations in Iraq."

  • what do I think??

    .. Prosecute Cheney and everyone else who ordered the torture, and hope that those operatives who followed illegal orders will be granted some form of amnesty.

  • Oh yeah sure we'll start with Nancy Pelosi. Then we'll move on to congress.... Hell, we could lock up every politician and CIA agent in the country.

    Then you idiots can see what toture really is.

  • Matthew Alexander gives no proof for his assertion that "Torture does not save lives". His assertion that torture helps Islamists make "new recruits", is a joke!

    Islamists use ANYTHING for recruitment.

    A crushing defeat or an outrage and they vow "vengeance". These dipshits engage in murderous riots about cartoon drawings - months after the drawings are published. Folks who believe shills like Alexander, are outside rational discussion, as many have proven here.

  • > Matthew Alexander gives no proof ...

    His statement is expert testimony. He has more than ample qualifications to be regarded as an expert witness on this topic in a court of law. He is offering his judgment based on a background that makes him highly qualified.

    > murderous riots about cartoon drawings

    Good point. There are serious problems that go well beyond any relationship to torture. But Alexander isn't claiming our torture is the source of all the ills of Islamic fundamentalism.

  • Windblowpee- He isnt an expert in anything, he just conductded interrogations.

    They say they fight because of torture because they are making excuses for their actions. They are recruited systematically in the name of Allah. Look no further than the rest of terrorist acts around the world. The religion is not peaceful, they blow themselves up to be in paradice with 73 virgins not for revenge. Their leaders manipulate them to establish Dar Al Islam. World submission to Allah

    Windthrowpee

  • > Windblowpee ... Windthrowpee

    One can only hope you're a tween or younger. You sure act like it.

    > They say they fight because of torture because they

    > are making excuses for their actions. They are recruited

    > systematically in the name of Allah. ...

    There's more to it, relating to our conduct in the middle east, but still I agree with what you say there. The torture has little to do with our enemies' desire to come after us in the first place. [cont'd...]

  • ... The major strategic problem is that torture profoundly damages out moral standing with everyone ELSE. This is a big, complex, dangerous world. It takes a lot more than a kick-ass military to be safe. You need ALLIES. You need people in other countries to LIKE AND RESPECT US.

    And people world-wide HATE US AND ARE DISGUSTED BY US for having become a country that tortures captives. GWB/Cheny have sunk us to the level of the most barbaric countries on Earth.

  • It's essentially a separate issue, but yes, you're right, Islamic extremism is a serious problem. It's one major source for the conflict and constitutes an indecent threat to safety and civilized society. I don't disagree there.

  • "people world wide HATE US AND ARE DISGUSTED BY US."

    Really? Not as much as they hate Muslims.

    You seem to think it's torture but it is not. People hate us and are disgusted by us? Yeah, people like you? The reason Muslims hate America is because of people like you in Europe. Liberal Socialists who bash america on a regular basis (like you) and justify their hatred for us with revisionist history and anti-capitalism. Fuck you. YOU validate their hatred. Bitch.

  • People in Europe love America especially its ideals, the people in the Muslim world also love America (they drink Coca Cola, drive American SUV's and listen to Hip Hop), what EVERYONE hates is when American policy does not live up to American Ideals, e.g. America "claims" to champion democracy & freedom, yet is more then happy to support oppressive dictators especially in MidEast, attacks Irans nuclear ambitions while helping Pakistans Nuclear Program.

    American Hypocrisy should be condemned.

  • It looks like hypocracy because youre mind is playing checkers and WE (Americans) are playing chess. We supported Sadam against Iran and Osama against USSR because that's how the game is played. Duuude. BTW Muslims dont hate, Islam teaches them to hate, and using our capitalist goods is not proof otherwise. You just seem very naive and you dont understand the political arena or the Muslim world.

  • So if your going to play "games" using people as pawns then the hate you will receive is justifiable.

    But playing such games is against the principles laid out by the founders and history has shown the blowback from such activities is more harmful in the long term.

    I prefer Ron Paul's foreign policies, friendship & trade with all with no interference in the matters of others.

  • When you lose the argument you resort to insults, its childish but did i expect any better? No

  • Just because I insult you doesnt mean I lost anything. That's just a cop out for loser's like you who fucked with someone who knows WAAAAAAAAY more about the shit than you.

    Do you know what the Cold WAR was? Hmmmmm.... Go google that shit you goof ball, you need to learn some shit.

  • Don't act like you know more than other people because you read, or heard another set of information somewhere else. You don't have any first hand experience or knowledge on this subject. So really, just shut the fuck up. Regurgitating information proves you know nothing. Fuck, I could teach an elementary school kid to google.

  • Oh, you mean you cant even challenge the shit that I said? You can only say that I know more because I read and hear information?

    HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAAAA!!!!!

    Go teach yourself to google nigger.

  • His "expertise" was gained long after most of the shooting was over in Iraq, and YEARS after al qaeda could have developed any major "projects". Nowadays, al qaeda is barely hanging on, whipping women and children in the mountains of afghanistan and pakistan, and getting their ragged heads stomped in Iraq by coalition and locals.

    Alexander is an answer to a question nobody who counts has asked.

  • > Alexander is an answer to a question nobody who counts has asked.

    MANY are asking "is torture worth the cost?" In fact, the right is asking that even more than those on the left. The left tends to argue that it doesn't even matter whether torture helps or not, because it's immoral and contrary to our values and thus shouldn't be used regardless.

    It's an exceedingly important issue on which Alexander is providing his perspective. Whether you find him credible or not is your prerogative.

  • Evolution is a word behind which socialists proselytize a wad of notions as holy writ to the scientifically illiterate. Through such fake science, they've propped up their racist policies like eugenics and the Final Solution.

    The bailout is a massive government spending program. That's the polar opposite of a market-based solution.Conservatives are NOT for it. It's just Fannie Mayhem redux, first spawned by fascist FDR, and then furthered by federally mandating suicidal lending practices.

  • This schmuck keeps refering to waterboarding as torture. Its pathetic to watch a member of our military sympathize with the enemy. He should slap himself.

    The interrogation techniques we used saved American citizens from another attack pure and simple. This man is just a coward, it's written all over his face.

    Fuck him. Does he think we should just roll over and die? I wonder how many lives were lost because he sympathizes with the enemy.

  • why do you think these people are attacking you in the firstplace fucktard?

    why do you think they fight with such a vision of their own righteousness?

    they wronged america with 9/11, that cost 5000 lives... america.. has cost them HUNDREDS of THOUSANDS of lives!! and it wasn't just impersonal attacks either.. so you cannot BEGIN to imagine their rage!

    get it?

    from the start, by your government abandoning it's own values it MAKES them your enemy!

  • They fight with their own vision of righteousness because their GOD TELLS THEM TO. First of all, you fucking idiot. They declared war on us not vice versa so dont try to twist it up. You are just ANOTHER coward who sympathizes with our enemy and if it were up to you we wouldnt have a country so fuck you. You dont know SHIT. You think those people blow themselves apart because we waterboarded members of Al Queda? You need to go back to school little man.

  • umm remember how George Bush gained popular support from the American populace for removing Saddam Hussein in the FIRSTPLACE??!?! he used the mistreatment of Iraqi citizens by their own government as justification for invading..

    (though i don't see him doing anything in Zimbabwe or Serbia)

    their god doesn't tell them shit. violent islamics pervade a warped version of their religeon similar to the christian crusaders.. dealing death in the name of god.. which is bullshit

  • UMMM. Shut the fuck up.

    It's ISLAMISTS. No "Islamics". ISLAMISTS.

    Violent ISLAMISTS pervade a CLASSICAL version of Islam, completely in line with Muhammad (who cut the heads of 100's of Jews personaly)

    They practice JIHAD. Which is commanded BY THEIR GOD over and over and over in the Quran.

    Have you ever read the Quran and SEEN what it tells them??? Obviously not two by four. Your a mental midget with a computer. By the way it's RELIGION. Dipshit. no "religeon".

  • yes.. how could anybody POSSIBLY disagree with anything you.. have PERFECT SPELLING (ZOMG!)

    oh AND lots of swear words.. well i'm not sure about the others on here but I'm convinced.

    =/

    a Jihad is a holy war. as far as they are concerned the United States government HAS committed crimes against humanity.. the extremist nutjobs might have started it all, but many of the actions of your government are just adding to their cause. Don't try to deny it.

  • Of course they dont like the US! We woop their fucking asses all day long everyday.

    They shouldnt have declared war on us. That THEIR fucking problem Two by Four.

    BTW, idiot. The extremist nutjobs are Imams who preach the same shit in Mosques all over the world.

    The more religious they are the more "extreme" they are. So I guess what you are really saying is religious Muslims started it all huh?

  • > The interrogation techniques we used saved American citizens

    > from another attack pure and simple.

    Actually, not so. turned out Cheney was lying yet AGAIN.

    tinyurl(.)com [slash] lco2n2

    "Sen. Carl Levin, chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee, says former Vice President Dick Cheney's claims -- that classified CIA memos show enhanced interrogation techniques like waterboarding worked -- are wrong. ... the two CIA documents that Cheney wants released [cont'd...]

  • ...

    'say nothing about numbers of lives saved, nor do the documents connect acquisition of valuable intelligence to the use of abusive techniques.'"

  • Um actually yes you stupid bitch. Winthropej. You stopped trolling the Obama Birth Certificate channel huh? How long did you spend on that channel trying to convince everyone that Obama wasnt lying about his birth certificate?

    Ohh how many times did you post STUPID FUCKING BULLSHIT websites that supposedly proves your point?

    We all know this is a lying sack of shit administration. Look no further than Nancy Pelosi.

  • Apparently, you can't read, QueenDing. I wonder who's typing for you.

    The story I'm quoting made every remotely credible news outlet. Like it or not, Cheney's assertion that CIA documents proved torture (or call it "enhanced interrogation" if you prefer) saved lives turned out to be false.

    I see you're quick with the profanity and insults. Apparently, rational argumentation is too stressful for you. Sure sign of a weak mind.

  • Here. Clearly not a "bs website":

    tinyurl(.)com[slash]l7g4x4

  • What insults? You are a stupid bitch.

    You know what a sign of a week mind is? When you let CNN brainwash you. You are the most brainwashed of any I've seen. Ive seen you for a long time I know how you think. You are happily blind and more than willing to overlook ANYTHING and EVERYTHING that doesnt fit the Left wing agenda (CNN,MSNBC, CBS) basically the puppet masters for your life.

    You know who has more credibility than Carl Levin? Dick Cheney. so quit with your bullshit STOOGE.

  • > What insults?

    "You stupid bitch" isn't an insult? You're even more mentally debilitated than I imagined. (If insulted, yes, I insult back.)

    > You know who has more credibility than Carl Levin?

    > Dick Cheney.

    So Iraq WAS involved in 9-11? Iraq DID have WMDs? The original detainees at Gitmo WERE the "hardcore" element? At what point do you realize Cheney is as credible as Ronald McDonald?

    Believe whatever you wish. All evidence available indicates our torturing did not save lives.

  • Bloody,

    Your post is the No-I'm-Not-But-You-Are defense. Well done, for a tween!

    Evolution is a word, not an issue. Fannie Mayhem isn't due to free-market anything. And complaining about the most effective contract soldiers just makes you sound like a Code Stink tween.

  • All we have to do is look at the history of these torture techniques. During the Cold War, the SERE's training manual was created to prepare U.S. soldiers to resist the specific torture techniques used in totalitarian regimes to obtain FALSE confessions against the state. They were NEVER designed to obtain actionable information. Using the SERE manual in reverse could only result in the kind of false confession we obtained from Ibn al-Shaykh al-Libi who admitted to an al Queda & Iraq link.

  • All we have to do is look at the history of these torture techniques. During the Cold War, the SERE's training manual was created to prepare U.S. soldiers to resist the specific torture techniques used in totalitarian regimes to obtain FALSE confessions against the state. They were NEVER designed to obtain actionable information. Using the SERE manual in reverse could only result in the kind of false confession we obtained from Ibn al-Shaykh al-Libi who admitted a link between al Queda & Iraq.

  • Whatever one wants to say about Cheney, he is not stupid. It is difficult to believe that he would not have foreseen the negative effect of this practice. On the other hand, the result of torture could be beneficial to someone with investments in industries profiting from wars. And he more than anyone knows this. Halliburton should ring a bell.

  • Now that Obama has wisely stopped the torture, war criminals like Cheney need to be brought to trial.

  • What the interrogator had to say, makes sense to me.

    It sounds to me like this house of cards is beginning to crumble (as Bush & Cheney run for the exit)

  • well it seems to me that it would be hard to argue that this fellow is naive, when he was an interrogator!!

  • if i tortured your mom and raped your sister, would you feel more or less love for me ?

  • 45axelh - excellent rebuttal to the pro-torturers. If we witnessed Al Queda or some other supposed enemy torturing American servicemen or civillians, we would be enraged enough to mount an all out attack against the perpetrators, and THAT is why torture NEVER works. Plus, the information obtained through torture is rarely reliable. People will confess to anything when being tortured if they think it will make the torture stop.

  • They were recruiting before, but not in the same numbers, and not from the same crowds. There were relatively few suicide bombings towards our troops during the first few years of this war, and now it is almost daily.

    I agree that it isn't the ONLY thing, but that it is still major. Don't forget the taboo of stripping anyone naked in Muslim culture, and how blatantly we violated that.

    Torture was extremely counterproductive for our troops safety, and pushed "radicals" farther away from us.

  • MrStoner, many of the politicians that you probably support have hated America for decades as well. Do you support torturing them?

  • I see no difference between the logic of Dick Cheney and Hermann Gehring, or any other Nazi war criminals. He should be tried as they were at Nurenberg. This clip by Matthew Alexander is the best response I have seen to the evil, mendacious argument Cheney makes. I hope it gets widely distributed.

  • Cheney can't even look anyone in the eye...

  • "Torture and abuse, really, is a failure of leadership." (2:46)

  • at the international military tribunal of the far east,after ww2, some Japanese soldiers were hanged  for "water torture"(waterboarding) U.S. p.o.w's in violation of the International torture laws.

    change the wording to *enhanced interrogation* & Cheney claims its not torture.

    w.t.f. happened here?

  • It's telling that Mr Cheney has become the least credible voice amongst many.

  • Amazing related comment from GENERAL PETRAEUS:

    watch?v=RaYkOuaEsUA

    Petraeus rebuffs Gitmo and torture: "I think it is important to live our values"

  • 2006?  I thought the torture stopped in 2004 when the Abu Ghirab photos hit the news.