H Nisar: Pakistan & Muslim Societies -1/4

[debdina]

The person talks the same as Rabindranath Tagore wrote in SAMDROYATRA(SEA TRAVELL 1920) when he was travelling in an

english ship from india to england.He wrote we indians didnot invent these machines and didnot discover these sea-routes. I (Tagore) feel ashamed to buy the service as our countrymen didnot contribute anything in any of these but buying it giving money and feel happy to do that. (during the ship journey from india to england)

[Jamshaidzubairee]

at 7:30 he throws a bomb.......

[nayiabhishek]

5:43 "hamari contribution he ki hum cell phone ke dhamakey kar dete he"

[nayiabhishek]

In some Videos Pakistanis say Hassan nassir is Indian Agnet and here they say Zaid Hamid is Indian paid agent. Sale, tum sab bike hue ho kya.

[zaidfarooqi]

You are the most hated person in the world

[rehan376]

Muslims contributed nothin in this 21st century for the mankind... Frm roadways to vehicles... Frm submarine to space ships ..Frm radio to satellite ...Frm medicine to major vaccine Frm Telephone to Internet...Frm typewriter to Computer...This is all the great innovation of West ... Whome these Mulvi and Jahil curse.. And shamefully use all their product for basic need.. Pathetic

[TheSolitaryRex]

Ye aik lafz nikalay meray Nabi (S.A.W.) ke khilaaf, mai iska katal khud karunga, insha'Allah. Baaqi iski bakwas se mujhe koi interest nahi.

[McChirkeen]

@TheSolitaryRex - tum say bara badbakht ees dunya mai nahi hoga. Tum kiya kisse ko qatal karo gai, tum tau khood aik zaleel qisam kai mardood ho jis ko pagal kuttay ho jis kai paas kuch nahi hai. Tum sai zyada pathetic insaan koi nahi hai. Tum kiya nabi kaa naam lay rahay ho, tum tau khood muselman kahlanay kai laiq nahi ho. Aaj western mumalik tum jaisay zaleel insano ko khatam kar rahay hain aur kartay rahain gai. Ja kah mar jao, mardood zaleel insaan.

[maximgrg]

@TheSolitaryRex u r a total terrorist :) .. isko jab marne jaye toh bomb lagake jaiyo...iske saath saath khud ko bhi maarle

[suleman666]

Respect for Nisar...He is great philosopher of pakistan...

[rehan376]

These mullahs paralyzed whole Muslim world through their illiteracy and so called fatwa sayin shit against west and America but they shamelessly use all modern technology which r the innovation of west .. We Muslim didn't do shit for the mankind except talkin... Bla bla bla

[rehan376]

@khan1561... Get little more education before u question Mr Hassan Nisar ...ur IQ is too low right now..In Afghanistan if they want they can destroy whatever left... in one day. They hv invented so advanced weapon but they scare of mss civilian casualty ...they r still better than Taliban

[KHAN1561]

MR HASSAN NISAR SOME OF YR POINT I AM NOT AGREE W PL ANSWER ONE QUESTION HOW MANY FORIGEN TROOPS ( VERY ADVANCE) R IN AFGHANISTAN AND HOW LONG THEY R THERE AND WHAT ACHIVMENT THEY GOT? KHAN VA USA

[sabkt]

responding to bosnia issue , who said muslims did nothing, they were praying and having dua in jamias ... but if they catch one abusing prophet(PBUH) they kill him..bosnians were not abusing prophet(PBUH) you should know that ......

[TheHarmanism]

well Hasan asks that what is the contribution of Muslim civilization compared to west but, I heard Imran khan and Zaid hamid saying that there were a lot of Muslims scientists with a lot of inventions in the past and medieval period,so is he right in making those comments about contribution of Muslims in science.

[sabkt]

@TheHarmanism living in denial

[irshaad86]

@TheHarmanism Muslims during 7th century to 11th century had several scientists among dem but later on muslims did not hav ny major contributions in science n technology n Mr Nissar was speaking about dat.... he jus wants 2 say dat muslims 2day r living on da glory of past n not doin something worthy...

[DharmRakshak2]

@irshaad86 The only thing muslims ever invented was coffe. And they didnt even realy invent it, they just discovered that it can be made into a drink and that is is refreshing.

[TheHarmanism]

Hi Kashif Bhai,I suggest you to make some URDU videos with subtitles so that ,English Speaking people can also understand.

[theindivish]

Indian here.... Pak citizens if you wanna succeed follow this guy....

[kthgeodesy]

cheater and lier manipulating the history, playing with the sentiments of people who can not understand these kind of evils.

[chfaaz]

That man too much great.

[suaveprudent]

Its not right that Muslims haven't participated in Science and Technology most of Muslims and even non-Muslims admired the work which was done by Muslims in medical science and astronomy and other fields as well. there are some names

Ibn Hasim . Bu ali sina. and many more

[ihatemonday111]

Hassan nisar is great man , i am really impress, thanks for upload this video

Hope kay hum sab kuch seekhain aur baqi rahe ye gadhay jo ye keh rahy hain kay he is sick.... Ye wo loog hain jinahin akal ko hath marna cahye baki hum wo loog hain jo apnay moo miya mithoo banay huay hain kay we are the best

Wake up pakistan

[xrathore]

Hassan Nisar is sick by mind, always a pasamistic mind, if you have that much hate about pakistan and love for west , get lost from this country ..............

[TheTayyab1]

dude....he is not sick.....corrupt and criminal ppl hate him bec he speak truth.........compare west from paki and think what did paki made so far............nothing........­.everything is coming from west.......even your food, and all physiologial need r coming from west.........where the F***k u thinking..............don't just blame anyone.....i know u is someone who is one of the those ppl he is taking about that why get F***k..............

[margff]

One thing we Pakistani's must consider not to make our habbit to put blame on our personalities like paid by Indians, Jew, or any other power, as with out proof we must not say a word against any one wether Muslim or any other human being. We must correct our selves and try to contribute any thing good to our socities if we have some capability. This is the most difficult thing, to contribute good. Blaming others is very easy.

[TheTayyab1]

dude....he is not sick.....corrupt and criminal ppl hate him bec he speak truth.........compare west from paki and think what did paki made so far............nothing........­.everything is coming from west.......even your food, and all physiologial need r coming from west.........where the F***k u thinking..............don't just blame anyone.....i know u is someone who is one of the those ppl he is taking about that why get F***k..............

[berchaali]

I don't have words to Explain about Great Husan Nisar.he is the one of best Journalist.

[mushmax]

Great Moralist.

[aniketranade]

Wow!...What a gut wrenching argument!....Nice to see a true patriot getting this sort of platform.

[nirmaljot]

his mind is totally open and living in real world .....salute you nisar saab

[TheHussainn]

kher me es ke es bat se eteffaq nhe kerta k pakistanio ko bare fikar he allam e islam ke wu unhe ghass bhe nhe dalte........jab wu koe bura kam kerte he tu kya hum bhe esa he kryn................muhammad (p b u h) ka farman he tamam musalman apas me bhae bhae he........jab aik musalman ko taklef hute he tu dusre uske taklef mahsus kerne chahye..........wu shakhs musalman he nhe jo allah ke deen ko mazeed na phelaye...........

[attractivue]

Naveed your an absolute idiot. Apart from very few significant contributions Muslims have achieved nothing!

All the major Arab scientists lived over 600 years ago anyway!!

[bizojan]

I 100% agreed with HASAN NISAR

[shahidbspmk08]

molvi jahal hainnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn

[naveed418]

Indians dont love this man for nothing. Obviously he is talking their words, and not only Indians, he is spewing his venom over the whole Islamic world and every muslim who has ever lived and thats the language of enemies of Islam and Muslims.

Nsar plz do some research before u open ur mouth. Muslims have had a termendous contribution towards science, yes they didnt invent an airplane in 17th century, but did Europeans or Americans knew about airplane in 17th or 18th even in 19th century??

[kunalsarkar1984]

He not only question Pakistan he is asking the state which was combined Ind and Pak that we fought , we divided our land , still we are fighting and the west is selling weapons to us to fight each other and still we fight over religion , he is above religion for a second cause he is telling truth !!!! hats off come to India and tell us our weakness also we will like people like you in India also !!!

[pzb786]

This asshole is an indian agent. He does not even know that flights from almost all major airports get delayed. So Pakistan should not look for minerals since Arabs are wasting their money. What a fucking stupid.

This sob does not know muslim history. Who invented Aljebra that all these fucking indians do programming with? Whose medical books were taught in the west for a century? Europeans were not even allowed to take shower when muslim civilization was at the top. Obviousy indians love him

[comsel100]

@pzb786

Algebra was invented by Hindus in India, as were all the numerals, decimal system and many more. They were carried over to the West by the Arabs. They were just translators and carriers of the already existing knowledge in India. Learn to study the true history, not the one doctored by your system.

[KtnClan]

@comsel100

actually sir, you should probably do your research. It was the Muslim Persian mathematician Al-Khwarizmi that founded Algebra - and after that, many civilizations and thinkers advanced Algebra to greater heights. there's no shame in admitting the truth. all people contribute to humanity.

[killintymm]

@KtnClan who told you these lies ?

[paki010491]

@pzb786 I am so sorry to say that your name contain 786 and your language is not a muslim's language. I think you can also talk without swearing. What hassan is saying that when Muslims were on the top, they used it to impose their world order but now others are more powerful so they are imposing their world order. However why you are trying to proove that you are the one who has invented"Gallian"

[KtnClan]

@pzb786

clearly you lack the understanding to realize that he is talking about contemporary Muslims.

[eddieparbhakar]

yeh video zaid hamid ke chamcho ko dikhao koi yaar

[eddieparbhakar]

hahahahaaaa... hamari badi contribution hai.... hum us cell phone me dhamake kar dete hai..... lol..... kya hazir jawaabi hai yaar....

[TheAamirmirza]

hassan sahab i love you sooooooooo true

[bundukhan100]

Hassan Nisar is my hero

[liono777]

im agree...look at arabs....when u overseas arab look at paki indian as filth nation...all paki indian known in arabs as "curry muncher" they ll say islam our relgion u paki suppose to b Hindu or christian....

[shankyxyz]

hahaha, hamari badi contribution hai,"hum us cellphone pe dhamake karte hain". lol. too good.

[chanu07888]

I wanna see Nisar vs zaid hamid debate .

[alps112001]

what a great man.....

[oldlahore1857]

zabardast Hassan sahib.... you are absolutely right!!

[ismaeel522]

Kalla angraiz ....make no sense

[scottmorrinson]

great comments sir. Please continue the good work.

[khanibrahim]

He is such a amazing person he have given me the reality check. Such a great writer.

[supercalifragable]

Hasan Nisar should come to India. We need people like him here.

[gatesrocks]

Zaid Hamid for President. He will do ghazwa-e-hind on hasan nisar and install radio pakistan on his head

[neilqayoom]

he talks fact,we generally act like ostrich,wow, what treat to listen his analysis

[INARA72]

well its not liking or disliking , Hassan Nisar should do some research , It was Islam and Prophet Mohammad PBUH who told about which food are good and which are bad , also It was again Islam and KulFa Rashdeen era which gave us a Concept of Welfare States , Justice , respect and protection of Minorities , and much more , Hassan Nisar is too negative person , and he lacks vision about glory of Islam , what about Europe Dark ages

what about millions and millions who had died in the last

[str8desi]

protection of minorities hahaha. What about the minorities in Egypt, Iran, and Pakistan?? HIndus in pakistan are treated like shit. THe bahaiis were kicked out of Iran and persecuted in Egypt. Islam and Protection of minorities may be true in the Koran, but muslims have failed to follow through with this teaching

[mjben0407]

we need a leader like him.. very wise man

[hamsaleem]

Hasan nisar sahab please do the positive thinking and guide the people of pakistan with ir Positive thinking, dont spread negativity, there is already too much hatred and neativity in our country

[smodass]

@hamsaleem I think he is asking Pakistanis to look at their weaknesses first and then improve them. This is better than being falsely positive.

[ISB2KHI]

Hats off to Hassan Nisar. you are great

[lokegeet]

we should learn from his guftugo

[farrukhj]

I like Hasan Nisar as well. He has great depth in weeding out the issues in our society, however Leadership will be improved if we at individual level would improve. We deserve President like Zardari because we are so weak individually. We have to first fix ourselves in our daily lives first proper hygine, dealing with others with respect etc.

[kkamalx]

The problem with people who dont like Hassan Nisar speaking the truth is because its hard to view your dirty image in the mirror. You dont have to agree with everything he says, also dont like what he is saying then present a competing argument. You think he is not factual then present the facts refuting him. This name calling is very inhuman and un-islamic. Shows your low character and IQ.

[mallang007]

hassan nissar ka sab se barra almiya ye hai k us ne america may payda hona tha lakin wo payda ho gaya pakistan may. is waja se usko barra ghussa hai.

[myjaanpakistan]

Hassan Nisar is right

[desisher16]

Hasan Nasir sahab - excellent job.

Please continue to educate your gumrah janta...

keep up the good job!

[PersonOfBook]

You can Mind your own business! Leave Pakistan and Muslims on their own!

[davidshaz20000]

This harami qadiani doesnot know about the history of Islam

[poolinpool]

davishaz bro hasan sahib is true pakistani nd he always show u reality.. dnt call him qadiyani etc.. dont be a firqa prast... may ALLAH give u some spitual teachings

[PersonOfBook]

Somebody shut up this traitor! Pakistan is the lone Muslim Nuclear Power and Pakistan is blessed with all sorts of Mineral resources and Gold. Why doesn't he leave Pakistan and go to U.S?

[tcua8]

@PersonOfBook

If pakistan have so much then why does it is dependent on foreign aid?

Now don't start blaming others for this.

Think my friend think....

[zeb120]

I dont know about the fact of CALIPHS and his sources

this is total bs

the four caliphs always encouraged social jusitice and women had the best quality of life under their rules

even till the the end of abbasyd and ottoman calipahte

[auh786]

I get a feeling Nisar still cannot fully express what he feels, due to our so-called 'Mashriqui iqdaar'

[burraak1]

hassan nisar is a fan of west becaaaaaaaaaaaause her mother was gang raped by western dogs and he came into life after that incident.

[MrCoper123]

100% RIGHT none of the muslim contries cares for us,even they hate us but still we always beat their drums.

[mubashir56]

Yeah! We specialize in suicide jackets!

Shame on us!

[ashutoshmikku]

hamari bari contribution hai. ham us cell phone se dhamake karate hain. lol :)

[cheegum]

I agree with a alot of things Mr. Hasan Nisar has to say and i am glad that atleast someone has the courage to come out openly and admit our faults as a muslim ummah. It is true we have not contributed anything to the modern world in the past few centuries. I only wish he would give credit to us for our contribution to the sciences, even if it was 1000 years ago. Before europeans could bring about the industrial revolution they had to first acquire all that knowledge from the muslims of spain.

[muhammads123]

democrasy doesn't suit the muslims , we should get our khilafat because from 1400 years we had khilafat .

[zeropro0]

We have Khilfat you just need to open your eyes and look at Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamat.

[cheegum]

Democracy is a car thats fueled by education. Without a 100% literacy rate there is no democracy. Educate the masses and watch democracy spring into action. Unfortunately our ruling elite will always make sure the masses do not get an education.

[muhammads123]

im not agree with his thought and his ideas he doesn't know the history if u see history muslims scintist who created modern education and technology and diffrent modern medicines and other kind of all modern education when christin defeated muslims and they took all there knowledge their educaton and technoly because of this education euorope invented more technologies and and then they came super power of educations.

[mubashir56]

Nisar should start teaching in the University. We need more like him!!

[afk3279]

well said nisar

[mister786]

Salute to Hasan Nisar & Mubashar Luqman.

Keep up the good work.

[shaukat155]

very sensible talk

[wahabnawaz3]

Nissar is a real man, there are few others in our country with same views such as sibte hasan, but they have been banned and sentenced to death by mullas and army dictators.They want equal rights to all humans around the world. Now Its upto paki people to select the best.

[wahabnawaz3]

Nissar is a real man, there are few others in our country still and back in history as well such as Sibte hasan, but they have been criticized and banned by mullas, corrupt politicians and army dictators. They ask for equal rights of all humans around the world. Now its upto people of pakistan to decide what is the best for them.

[007avner]

At least i found one intellectual in Pakistan. hat's off to you Nisar saab.

[shankyxyz]

hahaha, hamari badi contribution hai, ham cell phone pe dhamake karte hain... quote gold.

[Hinduismglance]

video is great

[alogis]

Well done kashif .. I have seen first time a pakistani scholar speaking truth for improvement of pakistan .. i m Indian . but appreciate his facts .. Similar is Pervez hoodbhoy .. he is a amazing scholar too... not radical at all..

[zeeshank16]

At least in Pakistan we listen to views from both side of the spectrum,tell me which of your anti-Pakistan channel shows a Indian analyst pointing out Indian short falls,I love to listen to Nisar,but his views are debatable

[SYLFan2008]

"of your anti-Pakistan channel....Indian short falls"

Maybe if you pulled your head out of the sand, you'd know that in the last month issues on gay rights, educational reforms, racism, the budget, safety in schools, Lierberhan report, etc. have taken center stage in India and have been heavily debated upon. You do know that in a DEBATE, one hears BOTH sides of an argument, right...or are you one of those dense individuals I often run into?

Visit tubaah(.)com and see for yourself.

[asatsi]

Its surprising to know such views do exist in Pakistan, especially after the bombardment of the ch*@#$ Zaid Hamid's videos. Keep up the good thinking!

[agentsback]

Finally an intelligent pakistani!!! But i like zaid hamid more, cuz he keeps pakistanis in dark, tells them we are not responsible for wat we are... India, US and israel are!

Sometimes i think india pays zaid hamid for creating an illusion for paksitanis.

[fizzboh]

India does not need to pay the likes of Zaid Hamid to preach intolerance, emotional analysis and imaginary conspiracy theories. Its been the official pak army policy all these years - in fact there are many who feel that ZH is a pak army spokesperson.. It makes sense for the army to maintain their vice hold on all the nations' wealth and aid and let the public wallow with empty sentimentality and imaginary enemies. The policy worked brilliantly till now: 1. Billions in aid 2. No accountability

[KashifHKhan]

PART VI:

I must admit that I also completely agree with Nisar that: (a) Pakistanis are "not a nation, but a population", and (b) a good leader should be a combination of a father and a teacher. In order for a people to constitute a nation, there has to be a strong sense of common good and shared sacrifice. Similarly, it is the job of leadership to take tough - but necessary - decisions and actions for the good of the general public and the country (without regard to populists feelings).

-Kashif

[manishwantit]

@KashifHKhan: Very true, Mr. Nisar is a real wellwisher of Pakistan. He looks and analyze deep and advises which best for pakistan and its people. I salute to such thoughts.

[KashifHKhan]

PART V:

In order to have even a remote chance of improving their lot, Pakistanis (and Muslims) - a per Nisar - must look at themselves objectively and critically. An understanding of one's weaknesses is the critical first step to potential improvement at a later date. As cases in point: (a) why demonize the West when modernity itself is a direct consequence of Western inventions?, and (b) why project Pak as a "power" due to nuclear weapons when the technology is well over 60 years old?

-Kashif

[KashifHKhan]

PART IV:

I agree with Nisar that Pak leadership's selfishness and contempt for the country is patently manifest, as in: (a) use of national army as an "occupation army" (to control the people), (b) focus on acquisition of increasing amount of wealth (via appropriation of national resources or foreign aid), (c) prevention of rise of representative democracy (to maintain grip on power), and (d) use of Jihad to rally the masses while avoiding inscription of their children in Jihadi causes.

-Kashif

[KashifHKhan]

PART III:

Pak leadership deserves huge blame for the state of the country. As Nisar beautifully points out, leadership "consists of people who have neither property nor children in the country". That is, Pak leadership's wealth is stashed abroad while their children also study abroad and stay abroad. (Remember Zardari's corruption cases in Swiss courts or that Musharraf's son lives in the US?) With no personal stake in the country, no wonder Pak leadership feels free to exploit it.

-Kashif

[KashifHKhan]

PART II:

The culture that fosters these traits is equally damning: (a) religious intolerance (towards non-Islamic faiths and even Islamic sub-sects), (b) lack of dialogue (with each other as well as with foreigners), (c) absence of intellectual openness (towards different points of views or novel ideas), and (d) disenfranchisement of women (50% of potential workforce). Under such a highly restrictive culture - as Nisar correctly points out - how can society ever produce "a great man".

-Kashif

[KashifHKhan]

PART I:

I consider Hasan Nisar to be a brilliant analyst of Pakistani and Muslim societies. In this interview, he dwells at length on Pakistani (and Muslim) character, culture, and leadership. Character traits include: (a) passion for pan-Islamic causes, (b) widespread corruption at every level of society, (c) intellectual dishonesty (even among peers), (d) total disregard of fellow citizens rights, (e) utter contempt for punctuality or legal due process, and (f) poor personal hygiene.

-Kashif

[hmammoth]

Mr. Hasan Nisar is a rare level head in a sea of intolerance, ignorance, insanity, extremism, and dogmatism.