X Factor UK 2011 - Judges Houses - Decision of the Girls

[Thepianofreak17]

It should have been Jade and not Sophie.

[chrisiyyatv]

sophie should of gone home and jade should of made it thru but i just hope jade returns love her

[abacuslukey]

im glad jade didnt get through sophie misha janet and amelia were better i think lol soz

[IljaEnot]

На каком основании делается подобный выбор?! Я был уверен на все сто, что Джейд пройдёт дальше. Разочарование полнейшее! ((((

[lameecefiliz]

the only reason i dislike this video is because JADE didn't make it through! hope these damn judges see this. the problem is the 4 who got through are all great, but I would rather have Jade instead of misha. that would be the perfectttt choice. JADE, janet, sophie and amelia.

[pichkatimaterina]

I think it doesn't matter that Jade is not thru, she is going to be a BIG STAR.

[XLolliies]

I think that Ameilia, Misha & Janet deserved to go through to the live shows but I'm not so sure about sophia... I mean if you Sophia and Jade together, who would you chooose and who has the stringer and better voice? :LL I would choose Jade, Kelly made a mistake not choosing jade, she is amazing and beautiful :)

[MajaWalter]

The only reason why Jade didn't go thru,is her weight...maybe kelly thinks the other girls are so beautiful to see..she sad that to Janet.. I am so sad there is no-one to see the live shows for....

[demichientarichie08]

@MajaWalter I don't think so. Yeah! Kelly really made a mistake, BIG MISTAKE (I was hope see Jade on the LIVE SHOW) but the weight issues is not the reason for Kelly don't choose Jade. Maybe some others reason. But please don't say Kelly didn't pick JADE just because JADE ARE FAT. That not true.......

[MajaWalter]

@demichientarichie08 How do you know this ?

[demichientarichie08]

@MajaWalter I don't know how....... But Kelly really have an experience in music industry. She's talented too. I am pretty sure she didn't do it(About Jade). She's professional..

You know what, I'm so disappointed too when she kick Jade. Jade deserve to go to live show. But that the fact. Jade didn't make it.....

(I really have no idea why Kelly didn't pick Jade. Wonder why. Because she the one that really like Jade's audition)

But I'm sure Kelly have others reason but not weight.

[ekin108]

kelly... not taking jade is ur biggest mistake!!!!!!!

[baowdang]

we love Jade Richards

[123456789sergito]

I think that the fact that Jade didn´t make it is a positive thing cause now she could make an album before the rest so we could enjoy her great voice! I LOVE JADE!!

[samboy1983]

we want jade

[michelledoherty1967]

So Happy for Janet. She really is a true star in so many levels. What a voice she has and Heaven on earth. xxx

[oke00306]

i prefer jade than misha or amelia

[kellybriannefan26]

jade should have gone through. shes so good. and so is janet. but this was a tough decision. all these were so fricking good. its nothing like the boys or the groups. one of these girls should win x factor

[Chimpza]

i agree with Kelly!!!

Jade should be Unique more++++

Love Amelia, Cheer you up!!!

[speedyreidy81]

i really cant believe it...BIg big mistake !!!

[IsidroJoe]

I think that right now Jade is too much like adele and its not fair for her to be constantly compared to someone like that, I think Kelly made the right choice...

[jojomaya7]

Jade was like the best! Bad bad bad decision =(

[DavidArchuletaArg]

I can't believe it, seriously.. I just.. can't believe it.

[elistagirl]

it saddens me that Jade did not make it thru, I think she is the next Adele...but then again, I'm so happy that Janet make it and I still have a reason to watch the show...Janet break a leg and you can do it girl!!!!

[jabeau23]

Unbelievable, Jade is amazing and not to put her through is a huge mistake. I believe if any of the other judges had her in their category it would have been a no brainer as she impressed everyone with her talent. I hope this doesn't stop her from pursuing a musical career and that she comes back next year and tries again if she doesn't find success in the meantime. I'm devastated for her. :-((((

[raimundoray111]

jade was one of the best ones in the competition. BIG MISTAKE

[smitten14]

I know she can only pick 4, but not putting through Jade doesn't made sense!!! She is amazing!!!

[roadragebunny]

I don't understand, why not bring the big guns? the best of the best and you don't choose them???? no jade???

[ksasaad911]

why the choice must be between janet and jade!!

this is not fair

can't imagine the live show with out jade.

[PaginGirl1]

I would buy an album by Jade right now...... IMHO, BIG MISTAKE not taking her thru. What a voice!

[nicko3880]

i can not believe jade did not make it