Added: 4 years ago
From: trip2boulet
Views: 91,648
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,769)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Nightwish have won!

    The main reason is because except Amy Lee in band, all other in Evancescene sucks!!!!

  • vcs estao tentando comprar a doçe amy lee com esse travecão da tarja vai toma no cu

  • Nightwish with Tarja was imho the best band of all time in any genre.

  • the two *-*

  • amy lee muito melhor

  • Don't speak about Amy and the band as if they couldn't give a fuck about the music or the fans and that they only care about money! Evanescence are true artists! Amy Lee is a classically trained pianist and harpist and has an amazing voice live and recorded! Evanescence will wait years to create an album that is worth listening to! That being said I don't like metal so. and Tarja isn't in Nightwish any more so how can you compare something to something that doesn't exist ? Evanescence forever <3

  • @Rarkphoenix thank you very much :)

  • Favourite band? Evanescence. Tarja vs Amy? I'd have to go with Amy purely for being such an inspirational songwriter.Tarja's probably the more talented singer though. Both fantastic singer/songwriters in my opinion.

  • what nightwish song is this??

  • @mariaPorcelain Passion And The Opera (from the album Oceanborn) (:

  • @Rarkphoenix This is one a the few songs i still need. Also his is what drew me into Nightwish, her epic beautiful voice sends chills down my spine. Though the music is what has keeped me with then and songs like Meadows Of Heaven

  • nigthwish 

  • How can you Compare the Alternative style of Evanescence with the Symphonic Metal of Nightwish ??.

  • Evanescence better ;D

  • I LOVE THEM BOTH!!! <33 

  • evanescence

  • Nightwish = Epic Symphonic metal

    Evanescence = Overrated commercial Nu/Alternative "metal"

  • Evanescence is good,but, sorry nobody compares with Holopainen miracle, bow to the god of metal children.

  • Amy Lee is better <3 but just a little bit :D

  • AMY LYNN LEE HARTZLER WINS!!!!! :) :) :)

  • @FALLENdarkANGELfreak fuck you trying to be clever

  • Definately Evanescence. No contest.

  • no hay comparacion!!! tarja la mejor!!

  • a amy lee é linda de mais '----'

  • i love both but...in term of vocals

    Tarja vs Amy = i can't choose because sometimes amy voice give me more emotion, but tarja is epic

    Annette VS Amy = i prefer Amy because idk why i can enjoy annette voice just for a period and after listen again and again i got annoyed may be her voice is too squeeze and not as strong as Tarja and Amy.

    sorry for my english

  • Nightwish had Tarja.

    It's like playing with GOD mode activated.

    Evanescence is not even worthy of playing as a support band for Nightwish.

  • Evanescence is an average band with a few good songs, a lot of promotion and lots of money invested in postprocessing. Live they are zero, both voice and instrumental.

    Nightwish has an exceptional composer, HAD the best female voice in the business, has virtuoso instrumentalists.

    Fans and critics agree that the first 4 NW albums were one of the best made in all metal history.

    Moreover, NW was great live.

  • @rsimion3 Few good songs?! What have you been listening to?! Evanescence's songs are all great, and live, they are AMAZING!!!! They blew me away!!! Nightwish, in my opinion they're not that good..her voice is actually kind of annoying!

  • @Sherley881

    Nightwish current singer is pretty weak, I was talking about Tarja Turunen.

    Regarding tastes, they are indeed subjective but even these days when NW is very commercial, they are years ahead Evanescence from a musical POV.

    I could tell you - objectively - the difference between good and bad music, between creative/quality music and commercial garbage, but don't have that much time.

    It will eventually come to you, with experience.. or not.

  • Evanescence has always been kind of crappy, Nightwish by far, especially with latest Imaginaerum album is an absolute epic masterpiece!

  • Nightwish !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!

  • NW IS MUCH BAND BEST SONGS AND NOT COMMERCIAL BAND LIKE EVANESCENCE

  • I GO FOR NIGHTWISH...THEIR MUSIC IS QUALITATIVE...

  • TATJA TURUNEN

  • @funkyfranx

    I won't start trashing you (although I have an urge) - but your opinion and taste regarding voice quality is one at several millions.

  • @funkyfranx

    Btw: the "something about Aphrodite" is called "Passion and the opera" where that "horrid singer" performs several staccato passages reminiscent of Mozard's "Magic Flute".

    The few singers capable of such feat you can count on the fingers of one hand.

  • @funkyfranx Finally someone I can agree with! You said it all!!! :)

  • both suck

  • @mihantas

    Make that "all three", I heard your mother joined the party.

  • @rsimion3 your ears are broken; ebanescence and nightwish still suck;)

  • @mihantas

    Unlike you, who are all woman ;)

  • @EvHateisForbidden for now nightwish is better, evanescence is fu*ked up... the new albums sucks also ... the old evanescence music is good but getting too old and not anymore so good to me ...

  • Nightwish...!!!

  • Nightwish win!!

  • It's a real hard decision, I love both of them :x But still, I think the Old Nightwish wins over Evanescence...Nothing can beat the voice of Tarja :o

  • lol easily nightwish

  • its like comparing chocolate and lobster both have great taste but are very different from each other .So this video is pointless....

  • Old Nightwish win over Evannescence

    Evannescence win over new Nightwish

    Old(real) Nightwish > Evannessence > New Nightwish

  • Nightwish is alot better LIVE!! and the new evanescence album sucks for real, so long waited for it and was very very disappointed, and the style isn't same as the old good evanescence music... SO i go for NIGHTWISH

  • @Salkkarit2012 you got wrong when you said that nightwish has better live, nowadays evanescence has amazing live, just watch 2011 Rock in rio and you'll see

  • you are idiot if u compare that two band! ofc nightwish!

  • Easy answer. Who is better at concerts?

  • Epica wins

  • @FourStringBassKing There is a written Nightwish and Evanescence .. Not Epica

  • Dammm, even withouth Tarja, NW is way far from evanescence...

  • How can you compare these two? Tarja is professional opera singer and Amy is hardly has a half of Tarja vocal power. No offence Amy fans, but in some songs I can hear that Amy can't go any further with her voice. Tarja instead, can easily give 100% of her voice power without any issues.

  • Honest opinion, I love both bands. They are both amazingly talented, and there really isn't any comparing them because they are nothing alike. Tarja and Amy Lee have two completely different vocal styles, and the bands produce completely different sounds. There is no comparison here. Stop trying to make one.

  • Nightwish ^^

  • Here's my response:

    Therion, Haggard and Nightwish (now Epica is surfacing) are the best of the best. And they MURDER Evanescence and their "gothic" stupidity.

  • TBH, I don't really listen to Nightwish, for me, it's too dramatic and OTT, kinda trying to hard, you know?? I love EV cos they have the balance between gothic drama and real... but Tarja has a gorgeous voice, can't understans why they fired her :S

  • in musicality we cant arguy about tastes , but in voice tarja win very easily...and iam not afan boy , of this style, i am more prog metal and rock like Dream theater; Opeth Tool SYOD Ping floyd Rush and so one. u guys got the point.

  • nightwish so easily. 

  • evanescence

  • ugh, evanescence just stinks, mainstream garbage, nightwish all the way

  • You cant compare night-wish with EV. night-wish will never be the same without Tarja. At the moment its EV for me cause there is no Tarja in nightwish

  • I don't compare them, and i love both, nuff said!

  • i can`t decide... Evanescence is completly different of Nightwish. I love this two bands... and maybe Amy`s voice is so much more like Simmone Simons of Epica

  • Nightwish working with Evanesence would be incredible :D

  • definitely Nightwish...but I think it has no sense to compare these two bands..

  • NIGHTWISH FOR EVER \m/_ NOT EXIST BETTER THAN THEM IN EVERY GOTHIC METAL

  • which song is on the start?? pls answer ://

  • thumbb up for evanescence ... !!

  • NIGHTWISH <3 Whisper, for example, can't compare to songs like The Pharaoh sails to Orion. Your Star, even if it's a great tune, can't compare to Ghost Love Score. Bring me to Life can't even begin to compare with The Poet and The Pendulum or Stargazers. Nightwish forever, just ignore my username.

  • They are both great singers...and they should make a song together!

    Amy+Tarja= EARGASM

  • u can't compared them. Different styles.  NW has great live shows. Evanescense not so great.

  • Nightwish una gran banda

  • Can`t decide... :)

  • como se llama la canción de tarja, alguien me puede decir por favor :)

    y para mi las dos bandas son geniales.

  • Comment removed

  • For me Nightwish. Evanescense haven't listen so much, can't say nothing bad or good.

  • Can't believe people STILL compare them! 10 years comparing what both of them have proved is totally different!!!!!!

    OVERCOME THIS AND GROW UP, GUYS!

  • Nightwish!!!!

  • evanescence for teen,

    NIGHTWWISH -TARJA ............IMMORTAL

  • what is the evanescence song

  • Why was Tarja fired? Were they smoking crack at the time? If anyone knows drop me a line.

  • @dondi2261 She Believed being the lead singer she should get more money than the others in the band.

  • Nightwish is amazing and beautiful. but EVANESCENCE has my bigger love x)

  • They're BOTH great. Nightwish was and still is a power metal, symphonic metal/rock, opera rock/metal band. I love them SOOOOO much. Tarja & Anette are both great :) But Evanescence wins - hands down. Because they mix genres. Rock, pop, metal, r&b, symphonic pop, alternative dance even a little bit of r&b. But i love both. Ev mix genres and I always have a suprise when they bring out a new song. :)

  • Comment removed

  • The both very diffrent then other. they both great <3

  • It's a hard decision but I go for nightwish...because they have good CDs albums and their music may transmit you a lot of motions and it never fades their metal style! About Evanescense I like it too but in this comparison i choose nw

  • Oh dear... is ths even to compare??? Nightwish aaaaalllll the way!!!!

  • come si possono mettere a confronto una band che ha anni alle spalle e una band che invece dopo un album non si sente più da anni??

    solo e semplicemente nightwish :)

  • this is the worst comparing that i have ever seen.

  • There is no other voice like Amy's..........

  • Evanescence and NW are bands, so why only use vocalist pictures? It especially fails with Nightwish, considering Tarja was fired in 2005

  • I refuse to choose between Tarja and Amy. I love them both, each have their own style and I do not expect Amy to hit the operatic style of Tarja and I do not expect Tarja to do Evanescence stuff. They are different and both deserve my admiration.

  • Tarja sucked if i wanted to here that i would go to an opera EVANESCENCE all day

  • Comment removed

  • NW RLZ!!! \m/

  • EVANESCENCE

  • TARJA!!!!

  • Nightwish! <3

  • Tarja has a great voice but it's too operatic for me. Amy however is beautiful and I love her voice

  • Nightwish..Tarjaaa!!!!

    Amy canta bien...pero me gusta mas Tarja...

    eso si... si hablamos de NW de ahora..gana Ev...pero si hablamos de NW con Tarja gana NW por lejos!

  • NIGHTWISH:x:x::x

    I CHOOSE TARJA:x

  • Nightwish is better. But Evanescence isn't very bad.

  • Finland vs Usa, the winner is Tarja Turunen by Finland

  • Amy lee maybe hotter looking for sure, but lacks the classical training and range of Tarja, Amy lee is back by talentless hacks, Nightwish doesnt need tarja to be incredible musicians. Amy lee and Tarja are nothing compaired to Floor Jansen.

  • Both are good, but Amy has more range, IMHO.

  • @dondi2261

    what planet do you live on? Tarja's operatic style goes VOLUMES beyond Amy's range... Amy just has a little more "RAWNESS" which is beautiful, in it's own right, a rawness which probably got voice trained out of tarja.

    anyway, "imho", you haven't listened to much nightwish (based on your favoritism of amy's range), and I think you should listen to some OLD nightwish. but beyond that, your opinion wasn't humble in the first place... like -you- can sing any better than either of them!

  • both, of course! o.O

    this is stupid question!

  • esta super vergon el video!!!

  • I would say Nightwish.. All songs of Evanscence is too sad :(

    I'm cryin when listen Amy's voice and lookin videos of Evanscence...

  • tarja pateaba culooos, anette tambien tiene lo suyo pero amy lee no le llega ni a los talones a esas dos e_e

  • Otro ridiculo que compara dos bandas totalmente diferentes. 

  • I don't understand why people make this comparison. I don't see very much in common between Nightwish and Evanescence. I had never even heard of Nightwish until a few months ago, and I've listened to their entire catalog now, and not once was I reminded of Evanescence, a band I've heard for years.

  • Fuck evanescence when i say Metal:)

  • amoooooooooooooooo a tarjaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa ni que comparar ni que nada

  • How can you compare those totally different bands? Lol! Nightwish is symphonic and Evanescence is gothic, but it comes a lil bit closer by pop-rock! These bands can't be compared because of their different style! You're so childish!

  • Evanescence of course...amy lee has stronger and better voice than Tarja..

  • @MsStranger57 Really, because I bet you haven't heard Tarja live. Her vocals go way beyond what Amy can do.

  • Symphonic Metal/Power Metal vs. Alternative Metal/Gothic Rock. OMGGG. *fainted* Before I fall to the floor, Nightwish owns. Evanescence is not that bad, they're good otherwise.

  • NIGHTWISHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH­HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHNIGHTWIS­HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH­HHHHHHHHHHHHHHNIGHTWISHHHHHHHH­HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH­HHHHHHNIGHTWISHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH­HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHNI­GHTWISHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH­HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHNIGHTWISHH­HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH­HHHHHHHHHHHHNIGHTWISHHHHHHHHHH­HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH­HHHHNIGHTWISHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH­HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHNIGH­TWISHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH­HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHNIGHTWISHHHH­HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

  • BOTH!!!!

  • c'mon its like compare jonas gay brothers with ozzy osbourne !!!

    tarja its the best!! singer ever

  • Nightwish. To me, Evanescence just sound like any other cookie cutter goth metal band. Leaving aside Tarja's epic voice, Nightwish is (was) something special and beautiful (go listen to Ghost Love Score- seriously). With NW it's about the whole band and not just the lead singer. Emppu, Marco, Tuomas, Tarja and Jukka; the whole lot of them rock(ed) it live. Does anyone even know the names of the other members of Evanescence?

  • EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE!!!!!!!!!

  • Nightwish forever!!!

  • they don't have the same song, Ev is more Rock and Metal and Nightwish is more Classical and Metal. Soooo what? we can't compare.

  • evanescence is rock and nightwish is more emo if ur saying that evanescence sings all emo song than ur wrong cause good enough is not emo

  • @Eduardo131451 lol did you just said that Nightwish is emo?

  • @vezok716 well they sound emo

  • @Eduardo131451 kid, none of these two bands are emo. Espesially nightwish, i can assure you that they sure as hell are not emo. Evanescence sound emo, however they aren't. But hell, if nightwish is emo then EV is 10 times more emo than nightwish

  • EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE EVANESCENCE AMY <3

  • @Thexpumazoxrock You're kidding right? Amy Lee is an awesome singer, but the rest of her band is average at best.

  • Evanescence!!

  • Evanescence is an American rock band, Nightwish is a Finnish symphonic metal band

  • Evanescence is best forever !!

  • guys Evanescence is American style metal music and Nightwish is typical Scandinavian symphonic metal! don't compare! it's just different!

  • Comment removed

  • AMY LEE INFINITAS VEZES MELHOR QUE TARJA!!!!

  • @MyLayze SO SE FOR DENTRO DO SEU CU SEU CORNO

    NEN EM SONHO QUE AMY LEE E MELHOR QUE TARJA

    PAU NO CU

  • @100strey Acho que vivemos num país livre. Eu tenho todo direito de achar amy melhor sem ser agredida verbalmente. Mas como além de ignorante você não tem noção de moral, devo lhe dizer que ainda assim, com todas as suas palavras torpes, AMY LEE É MELHOR QUE TARJA!!!!

  • @MyLayze primeiramente:

    tarja faz bem mais sucesso que amy lee

    segundo:

    tarja e uma das poucas que ovocal dela possui symphony of destruction

    amy lee so tem gothic symphony e grave

    ve o agudo de amy lee

    ve o video phanton of opera live end of era

    e ve se alguem supera a tarja

    resposta par aburro desinformado e de graça

  • @100strey Será que devo ficar feliz porque pelo menos o caps você desativou? será que devo aplaudir porque diminuiu as ofensas?

    Continuo batendo na mesma tecla. O Brasil é um país livre, assim como tem gente que gosta de lixos musicais como pagode e etc, há quem goste de amy lee, que por sinal estará no Rock in Rio... Faz o seguinte: você gosta da tarja e eu da Amy... e ponto final.

  • AQUI IGUAL EVANESCENCE NO ES NI LA SOMBRA DE NIGHTWISH NI MUCHO MENOS DE TARJA

  • You didn't even compare similar songs. -.-

  • To me Nightwish is (or was) beautiful and totally unique, and that's not even factoring in Tarja's amazing voice. Ghost Love Score is a work of genius. Evanescence is just another generic female fronted metal band. I understand why people would disagree though, sometimes people find it hard to get into Tarja's voice.

  • Dont compare Symphonic Power Metal to Alternative Metal. They're too different from each other BUT both of them are great in their own way.

  • Theres no correct answer to which band is better. It all comes down to preference and taste.. I personally prefer Evanescence over Nightwish anyday

  • Neither because they are both great on many levels. Nightwish is superior musically, but Evanescence has themes that are relateable to almost anyone.

    Within Temptation takes the cake though for both though. All of them are great.

  • Amy lee and Evanescence!

  • Wait, so remind me why we are comparing a metal band with a not even hard rock band? And is there really any question as to who is the better technical singer of the two?

    Just in case you can't hear, that would be Tarja.

  • I would like to see Terry Balsamo go up against Samantha Escarbe in a guitar battle so I could just see her humiliate him easily.

  • As far as record sales they do not equate talent by that logic any Top 40 artist won more grammies and sold more albums than Evanescence so they are automatically more talented.

  • Nightwish slaughters Evanescence even with Annete on vocals.

  • Nightwish and Tarja make a powerful sound

  • Tarja's voice is stronger butt Amy is softly

    I like Tarja

  • Cuando una vocalista se viste de negro ya piensan que hacen el mismo estilo de musica?? No se puede comparar, una banda totalmente diferente de la otra. Pero yo prefiero nw, tiene arreglos con la musica clasica, barroca etc. La otra banda es mucho mas sencilla, solo aparecio en mtv y se pusieron de moda. Y obviamente desde ahi muchos piensan que es una de las mejores bandas , lo cual no es cierto; si la ams famosa ,pero no la mejor!

  • BOTHH!!!!! Amy Lee is my godess and Tarja is my Queen ^-^

  • @GomezPatel

    Song: Passion and the Opera

    Album: Oceanborn (1998) :)

  • 1)Nightwish

    2)Evanescence

    But now...

    1)Evanescense

    1235243623462) Nightwish

    Anette sucks! :(

  • Tarja sucks !! Evanescence 4ever!

  • my fave bands r

    1)Within Temptation

    2) Nightwish

    3) Evanescence

  • Difficult.....just difficult to compare these two, but i personally feel that Nightwish is the better cuz they have a more metallic touch and secondly their vocalist Tarja is incomparable....Amy is great and has a great voice but she can't simply compete the voice of Tarja, so IF TARJA WOULD HAVE BEEN STILL IN NIGHTWISH THEN:

    1) NIGHTWISH

    2) EVANESCENCE

    ...BUT....CONSIDERING ANETTE IN NIGHTWISH AND THEN COMPARING IT WITH EVANESCENCE, THEN...

    1) EVANESCENCE

    2) NIGHTWISH

    ...Simple as that

  • amy is deffintly the best of theese two vocals. but Tarja is also good.

    but they are so enormesly different from eachother. Tarja is either doing a new style, or very bad opera style vocals. but sounds good when mixed with nightwish.

    oh oh oh, and then amy is just toooooo damn cute.. Raaaauwww

  • @Andzull Hahahaha. Amy definitely the better vocalist? Hahahaha. Amy is horrible. Tarja isn't.

  • Nightwish, of course!

  • Mil Veces Nightwish!!! como comparan a esta maravillosa banda..con la porqueria comercial de evanescence ??? pffff

  • Uhh to me its a no brainer Evanescence I love her =)

  • evanescence