Added: 4 years ago
From: PetroleumHead
Views: 221,878
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (156)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • How sad was it for Toshi to sing this during the last live, as he was really gonna sing without them (esp. Yoshiki) after that.....

  • Great song.

  • I like his voice.This music is so sad.

  • i like it

  • I'm X ....

  • oh no ... i'm cryinggggg

  • I just LOVE this song <3 My favorite part of the 3:38 to 4:02 <3

  • I juss started listening to x japan so I thought listen to this one first,,, damn I was :O soooo nice n beautiful I like this song, well too listen to the rest ^.^

  • I'M  X....

  • i had the best eargasm ever

  • HidE xJApaN . . mY idOL . .

  • ur in my heart forever X JAPAN:-*

  • it makes my heart melt:(...awwwwwwwwww

  • Comment removed

  • im ur FOREVER FAN,,,i love u X JAPAN!!!!!!!!!

  • So brilliant

  • I LOVE THIS SONG!!!

  • Toshi's voice is epicccc!!!!!!!!!

  • Can't sing without hide! :(

  • WE ARE X!! FROM SINGAPORE!! X Japan forever! :)

  • @LaMusiqueEstAmour too bad they never come here to perform...they go thailand...damn

  • This is epic, this is so damn epic!

  • SING WITHOUT YOU...I SING WITHOUT YOU!!!

    :'(

  • Normally i don't leave comment. But just to make it clear that a X's fan's still watching these clip over and over. Love you and your emotional songs.

  • ....

    

  • WE ARE X!!!!

  • REST IN PEACE HIDETO MATSUMOTO

  • PERO QUE HERMOSO *0* XOXO

  • we r we r x

  • Im falling for you X JAPAN!!

  • Que cancion tan hermosa...saludos desde Mexico!!!

  • awesome.....

  • song toremember

  • trust me, u wont find another guy that can sing x's song better than Toshi

  • @phodem12pm try go listen hk rock band beyond 《海阔天空》 is also awesome ^^

  • @matthiewzheng lol im a big fan of Beyond too, im not Chinese or Japanese but i just love their songs.

  • @phodem12pm than What do you race?

  • @matthiewzheng Viet

  • without you hide!!! RIP... missing you....

  • without you hide!!!

  • Damn!! good song!! :)

  • One of my fav X songs, ToshI's voice was so touching~

  • Hong Kong has Beyond. Tokyo has X-Japan

  • the best band ever..xjapan..

  • omg..touching

  • I can't imagine X Japan without Toshi either. X Japan wouldn't be X Japan without his voice. His voice suits the X Japan songs and emotion, I think Yoshiki knew that when he refused to find his replacement. Toshi and Yoshiki are irreplaceable in X Japan because they're the heart of X Japan.

  • @bsb95 i'm agree with you!! no one can replace them.

  • @bsb95 You know, after this live, yoshiki decided to reforme X with hide on vocals, without toshi... But, hide died...

  • ..*cries hard* oh gosh..T_T totally moved.. T_T

  • IMAGINE KYO'S VOICE (VOCALIST FROM DIR EN GREY) WITH YOSHIKI IN THE PIANO AND SUGIKO PLAYING THE VIOLIN........

    I THINK THAT WOULD BE THE BEST BAND EVER MADE.....

    I LOVE X JAPAN,BUT THIS VOCALIST ISNT AS GOOD AS HE SHOULD BE TO BE IN THIS BAND.... I THINK YOSHIKI IS IN A HIGHER LEVEL....

    JUST MY OPINION..

  • @userantifa Toshi makes the band.

  • @userantifa Whatever

  • @userantifa Kyo's voice is totally a different style which won't go along with the songs of X at all. I'm sure this isn't just my own opinion, and I assume Yoshiki would be offended if he read your comment. He wrote all his songs according to the characteristics of Toshi's voice, and he believes only Toshi can express his aesthetics. After Toshi dropped off X in 1997, Yoshiki refused to recruit a new vocalist and thus disbanded X. I can't imagine X without Toshi either.

  • @userantifa X-japan is what it is. If they didnt have the members they have now.. including Hide! X-japan wouldnt be here.

  • @userantifa Bull. Crap.

  • @userantifa Toshi is one of the greatest vocalist you'll find. There's no X Japan without Toshi.

  • They made my cry! :( What a song! <3

  • I went to their concert 2 days ago :] In Toronto at Massey Hall.

  • Yoshiki had mistake in piano 3:03... ^_^ ehe but its beautiful

  • what's togireta?

    

  • @indonutswetrust togireta means broke ,lost pause.end off etc...

    like this "there was a pause in the conversation '

  • Hide-chan, you look so sad here,,, WIsh I could have done something to help you, Dooshite??????? Mina-san morainaki

  • I may regret saying this, but X Japan is the one band that I want to listen to forever

  • Comment removed

  • I LOVE YOU FOREVER~

  • I'm not even Japanese, in fact, I'm Korean, but I know that this is a group of amazing musicians and I absolutely LOVE X Japan. They're talent is immeasurable and the amount of love that they have for other group members shows so clearly in their concerts. Hide... dear talented musician, you will forever be with us. LOVE X!!!

  • 99.269 views ,,,,, come on~ X Japan deserves much more than lady gaga n others for example.

    this is music! X!!!!!!

  • This song is so sweet......everytime I listen this song it make me thinking of my girlfriend..... TT^TT

  • Beautiful. 

  • Beautiful... X-Japan was and is the greatest band ever to have played.

  • i was moved by this song~ :'(

  • OMFG!! It's almost killed me to watch them like this!!! That old saying you hurt the ones you love - in this case so true! At least they made peace when they got to Forever Love....

  • Yoshiki was practically crying... it really hurts to see them like that... this is the best song ever and X Japan forever!!!

  • this song is call " Longing "

  • touching voice... touching performance....

  • x japan no utta 4 ever!!!

  • an epic song!

  • im sing without youuuu...ouhhh...

    very sad song...

    well done x-japan...

    arigato gozaimaz from me...

    x-gaban malaysia

  • hi, neighbour!!! ;D

  • como no llorar con esta cancion mis respetos algun dia podre tocar canciones de X japan gracias por subirlo

  • X Japan is in the top 5 of the world's best Jrock bands...and I am not even half surprised.

  • Oh, How are another? Can U tell me?

    I'm not too. X-Japan are the legend J-rock

  • @AetherEthereal

    i am..... yup im surprised...... surprised that x japan isnt in the top 5 greatest bands of all time... their definitly there ha ha

  • i love this,,, my heart is very sick

  • I cry every time I see/hear Longing.... its so... sweet and... awesome and I love the Lyrics! no wonder X Japan is my fave J-Rock/V-Kei forever...!

    LONG LIVE HIDE!!!

  • first time i listen this song..i'm started fell in love with x japan

  • @haida1809 me too !!..they're all genius !!

  • cry..cry

  • lo amoo... amo esta cancion.. es una de las mejores canciones que e oidoo!

  • I still cry listening to this song. It was the song played on the news report of Hide's death. And yes, the song X Japan played in Tsukiji Hongwanji is FOREVER LOVE... I still make the pilgrimage to Tsukiji everytime I go to Japan and leave a note and flowers on his memorial, and when I can, drop flowers and cigs into the water at Santa Monica Pier for hide...

  • I did the same thing at the pier for hide. Catch me in a PM ok???

  • this song WAS and IS call "Longing~togireta melody ". "Without you" is another song written by yoshiki after hide's death, for him. and hide's funeral is NOT set inside a church, but a temple instead. (the song was also not without you, but forever love instead..)

    and also, (my opinion) we were not walking away without hide, he is with us all the time, looking apond us, and smiling to us in the sky....so we're not alone...

    but i must agreed with you: "we love you "X"....forever....."

  • @mformelody If it was written after hide's death, then why hide's hologram is playing along? If you see his fingers, you will notice he is really playing the song. I'm confused...

  • @jukus you're making me confuse as well == well, all i can say is "do your homework" then you'll know. ask any other fans they'll give you the same answer. btw, "without you" is an orchestral piece as well as a piano+vocal piece...where did the guitar part come from ==?? have you mixed up "longing" and "without you" ?????

  • X Japan diz bem mais do que sou para ninguem

  • this song is called longing or without you?

  • longing. Without You was written later.

  • @derek91249409 this song is called Longing =]

  • They are back together now so I stopped crying..........

  • they do?I don't think so..without hide...no

  • who's playin' the drums? :O

  • Have you ever seen a Live from X Japan?

  • yes i have : ) i was wondering if it was a another person drumming or if it was a playback. i have now found out that it was a playback : P

  • noone is :P

  • 'cause still i love you

    can you feel mu pain?

    HIDE,do you know I love you?

  • so touch.....this song in last live...........hope x japan can come again to hong kong la.........i saw many concert...linkin park, korn, avril lavigne...........but the x japan live in hong kong 17/1 is really touching and exceting live..........and i think that is the best live in the world ...........ha ha

  • Comment removed

  • LOVE LOVE LOVE

  • X Japan is MAGIC

  • How one song can make me feel like this? There is so much some kind of magic in X Japan. I`m so glad that I founded this band and started to listening their music. WE ARE X!

    ♥

  • Yoshiki is way too cool; definitely not from this planet

  • he was sent from above to entertain mankind

  • like elvis, but azn. x japan rocks!

  • to X-Japan fans: u're so lucky been loving this band so long. I miss so much nice stuff. I think watching them live must be unforgettable. hope not too late to say:we are X

  • Buy it.

  • good point!

  • Damn, is always the same, Hear The song and start to cry T.T i love this song and reminds me the great Hide

  • Favorite song from this band.

  • I fall in love with yoshiki after the death of hide...

  • This song really amazimg , I love this tone

    It's really sing to my heart

  • OMg this song makes me think of hide!

    It makes me want to cry!

  • this song makes me burst into tears everytime Q___Q

  • 4.13 yoshiki crying....

  • I luv the lyrics, so touching and beautiful. Best ballad of X japan.

  • Yeah... I sing without you....!!!!!!!

  • when was this??

    is it still in present?????

    never heard of this band,BUT!!

    but I've found this song,at last!!!

    I've been searching for it for like 6 years,shit!!!

    btw,this song made me cry coz I've lost someone I think,is very special to me,for 4 years I've been thinking about her,still...

    hoping that she'll comeback again....

    damn,this song fits my emotions now....

  • This last live took place in 1997, after it they broke up, hense it being called the last live, but they reformed last year with two new songs I.V & Without You, and have done lives a few months ago in march, the drummer/pianist Yoshiki injured his back doing the concerts because he worked too hard beforehand and during the concerts, they're having their next live this month in paris, the start of their world tour, but there's a possibility they're disbanding again after the tour is over.

  • well,I hope they won't disband again...

    at what year did they start???

    first time I heard this song,it's on a channel having an AMV of ffx,since then I've been anticipating the AMV on that channel every night

  • They weren't famous until 1989, but they officially started in 1982, with only Yoshiki (drummer/pianist) & Toshi (vocalist) as the original members, they had other members for a few years, but then the ones you see in this video replaced them in 1987, also in 1987-89 they were one of the famous amongst bands that were not well known and not featured on tv much.

  • Btw I'll tell you this now, the lead guitarist Hide, the one with the red jacket and pink hair in this vid died a few months later after this live. In the reunion lives they used guest guitarists & holograms of Hide.

    The new song they made when they reunited called "without you" was written for Hide, they played the song live, it was in the making for ten years, Yoshiki was in a serious depression after he died and started the song immediatly, but it didn't have Toshi's vocals until now.

  • that's just sad....

    I'm starting to know them a little bit,but when I knew that someone died in one of their group,I feel so sad....

    so,they officially started in 1989????

    I was 1 year old that time

  • No they started in 1982 but weren't famous until 1989, they're pretty much the Led Zeppelin of Japan.

    Continue to research more about them, like why they decided to break up, the band members pasts before the band formed, what they did after 1997 ect.

    We don't know wether Hide commited suicide or not, some say he didn't because he had plans and his solo career was going well, but some have researched his past and have found lots of info that would indicate he killed hinmself.

  • hey, what did they find that possibly indicated that he killed himself??

  • At some point watch the videos on Hide's funeral, very sad, and its the last time the x-japan members came together, after that they didn't see eachother for ten years, you'll find out why if you research into it.

  • Hi, I love hide (no disrespect but that's how he prefers it written) and have been following him for 5 years (that was when I found out about him and his music). Do you know where I can find the latest info and news about him? Just to keep me updated, eg: closing of museum, hide memorial summit, etc.

    Thanks a lot! :)

  • great!!!

  • i can't waiT for their concert in taiwan!!!!!

  • this is what i call music.

  • adoro questa canzone. sei grande x japan yoshiki!!!! kiss.

  • こんなに激しくて切ないメロディを奏でるバンド

    他にはいないと思う。。

    X JAPAN Forever!!

  • wOw! wAt a grEat sOng!!!!!!!!!... ds sOng s onE of my favorite sOng of tha X-JApan bAnd..

  • I could see the pianist wipe his tears. How moved! I love this song although I don't know who they are.

  • pianist is also the drummer and his name is yoshiki =)

  • @JulianDang I love Yoshiki <3 He is so emotional and honest about his feelings. And he is an amazing drummer, songwriter and pianist!

  • @eggiroth When i first saw this, I didn't even know who they are. But the strange thing is, unlike other songs that i have listened to, I can comprehend the feeling. I shed tear the second time listen to this (perhaps, it represent my feeling at the moment).

  • @JulianDang Aaw, I am so moved by your words, Julian. I feel the exact same way. I've cried many times listening to Yoshiki, especially to his symphonic version of Amethyst, but to all his compositions really. There is just something about this band that instantly touched me, and now I love them so much. How wonderful to talk to another X-Japan fan, among my friends I'm the only one lol. Take good care!

  • i love this song!

  • very intesnse.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more