Added: 5 years ago
From: kLafied
Views: 60,949
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (348)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • You have an incredible voice, but I REALLY want to hear it with the capo lower on the fret board, so it harmonizes with your voice!!!! The octave is so high all you hear is the twang instead of the deep warm notes. It really takes away i think. :/

    BUT AMAZING VOICE!!!! :D

  • I just want you to know this is my favorite cover on YouTube. You have a truly amazing voice and you look very beautiful. I share this with people all the time. Keep up the amazing work.

    -Andrew

  • can't believe all the negative comments.. i, too, have been listening to this version for around 4 years and i still absolutely love it. just as good as the original, and just as moving. i adore your voice kaila (and i used to fantasise about what your face looked like because of this video lol)

  • @simonx49 I don't reply to too many comments, but that last line really made me laugh haha! Thanks so much for listening :)

  • Comment removed

  • You've got a really beautiful voice.

  • It is better than the original. I've been listen to this version for 4 years and it never gets old. I'd like to see you re-record better quality

  • I seriously think this is better than the original...

  • Good job! Love this song!

  • love the song and you

  • Sorry, but don´t like the way how you slow it down..

  • i didnt think alot of people knew about sufjan stevens i think its awesome that u do you're a good singer to keep it

  • do you own a black guitar?

  • There will always be critics but it's because of envy! you know-opinions are like .....

  • great!

  • incredible, sounds like a blast to play. Going to pick up the tab now!

  • u are sooooo fuckinggg good !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    if u and sufjan were singing this song together at a concert i would pay big bucks!

  • This might just be better than the original. HOLY SHIT

  • You know I really wish you would redo this song. I first saw this 3 years ago and I am sure you could do it better.......... it still makes me cry, thanks

  • Beautiful. Best Casimir cover I've ever heard.

  • amazing, such a beautiful voice, and such a good song you covered

  • Absolutely fantastic. You are ridiculously talented, and it is such a joy to listen to your covers.

  • your singing is all awesome !!

  • you should do "boy with a coin" by iron & wine!

  • I like it. =)

  • major hottie!!!!

  • You have a strong voice but you killed the melody of the song by showing it off. I don't think it works.

  • I don't love this cover, but keep in mind this is a pretty hard song to sing with the original melody if you're a girl and want to stay in your chest voice. I've seen female covers of this song where the person made changes to the melody that, in my opinion, sounded better than the changes she made--but you pretty much have to make some changes.

  • yess this is a very good cover.

  • Is that a Zolof the Rock and Roll Destroyer shirt?

    And nice cover too!

  • oh shnaps!!!

    tight :)

  • This is amazing. I love your voice. Best cover of this song I have heard.

  • Great cover, awesome voice.

  • agh

  • this is absolutely beautiful.

    i'd like to say i have a good voice, but i aspire to be a singer like you someday.

    never stop singing.

  • this is great!

  • Really good coverr

    great voice...x

  • really really good!!!

    I agree with lawrughh

  • amazing...you sing it well! 5 stars

  • I seriously listen to this cover whenever I am sad. It is so beautiful. This is one of my favorite songs. Honestly, this is so amazing, you should be proud.

  • wow

    jhoijodaijbgda

    (:

    this is really lovely

    (tune your guitar?)

    haha

    x

  • I love this song, and this cover is just so amazing. Your voice is strong and powerful so effortlessly and without being forceful.

    God, I would KILL for your voice.

    :D

  • different than the original, mainly because your capo is so high up on the neck, but it sounds good.

  • im pretty sure i have commented on this video b4, but it is just beautiful and i just keep comin back to watch more!

  • seriously.

    amazing!

    you have a GREAT voice!

  • you are so absolutely amazing. I love the song, and your rendition of it is absolutely breath taking.

  • Wow.....really cool. the best version i´ve ever seen. congratulations for that. i hope to see sth. new of you.

  • really good vocals

  • you are perfect.

    this is beautiful.

  • dooode!!

    xD i love this song! and ur vocals just made me luvv it more!

    woow!!!!

    mel ♥

  • You're amazing.

  • impressive!

  • I like it...it's different from Sufjan's version, but I guess the whole point of a cover is to make it your own, and you certainly did a good job with that! :-D

  • Really good cover, your voice is perfect. This song sounds really nice with the capo up at 6.

  • wow. nice singing, your voice is really pure. nice work.

  • i don't care what everyone else says.

    it's a COVER guys, take a song and play it with you're own heart.

    Personally i think you do a wonderful job playing this song. I generally play it on 3rd or 5th fret. I change capos on most of my covers as well, it's not a crime people.

    But kudos, lovely job your voice fits the song very very well!

  • The capo is on the 3rd fret, trust me.

  • Are you sure it isn't capo'd on 3?

  • There are ways of telling people they are wrong without coming across like a total bitch. How's that for an opinion?

  • did you find your voice too high for capo on 1?

  • Do you have a band or solo carrear?

  • I play solo

  • myspace?

  • yea i go to pulaski school!!in chitown!!

  • yay great! i really like it!

  • you have an amazing voice

  • yeah ,hes got a great Mic ,

  • pretty guitar.

    and your voice is impressive.

    well done.

  • I love your voice! Such a beautiful version.

  • i dunno how anyone can say anything bad about ur voice. It's so beautiful, and it adds an extra element to the song. I love it. Anyhow if u get a chance check out my version!

  • I like...Vocals aren't bad

  • of course the voice and guitar could use some...tweaking. But I really liked it. It makes me happy. You definitely put your own 'twist' on it.

  • woah. Your voice is kind of strange but it's interesting. I kind of like it.

  • yea this would be 10x better if your guitar was in tune but i enjoyed listening to it and your singing style is different, good

  • dang, i can't keep the guitar and vocals in rythem. goot job

  • Hey, I really enjoyed it, nice voice, and I loved how you personalisez this great song. keep on posting your music!

  • Wow, I really love your voice, I love this song so much and you did it justice, considering you had to change the key., Great job! :)

  • Singing the last line of each verse higher is the best idea idea ever. This song is so hard to sing if you're a girl; I sing it in my head voice but it sounds weird.

    To be honest I don't love your Eisley covers, I think because you make up the chords, but this is really, really good and beautiful.

  • Of course comments like this make me feel a little blue, but I can't help but agree with you. This video is more than a year old and I think my voice has matured greatly in that year. I look back at this video from time to time and wonder how people can stand listening to it. I'm completely nasaly and my guitar WAS completely out of tune.

  • @kLafied Don't let this comment get you down I think your voice is awesome. Just remember to let your breath carry your tone, not the other way around. Relax your throat and let the breath hold the tone up. Also, try putting the capo on 3 and actually sing it a full octave above how he does it. This might help but I'm not sure how your voice would do up there. I absolutely love the way you say 'touched your blouse' your voice is pure beauty there

  • @kLafied

    I love it when someone ruthlessly criticizes an artist's performance, then you click on their channel... and they have no uploads of their own. This destructive criticism is peppered over EVERY youtube video, regardless whether it's The Beatles or a girl doing beautiful cover of a beautiful song. These comments pedantic and crass and you shouldn't pay them any mind. You sound lovely. Fuck the haters.

  • @ballsdeepbaby I think that's only partly her fault, but mostly it's the fact that all Sufjan Stevens songs are boring as hell and drag on.

  • @ballsdeepbaby Your comment makes me question whether or not you actually play/sing or understand the idea of artistic interpretation

  • I prefer the original, but you did a really good job! How smart just not to do that low bit, i always struggle with that myself, but singing that last part of the sentence higher is a very good solution!

  • Thank you! I wish more people would realize that the only reason I sang it this way was because it was too low in the original...I prefer the original way it was sung 100% more..I just couldn't do it, so I made up something else.

  • man if i could get an mp3 of this, it'd be on my ipod. i like it so much moar than the original.

  • its so nice to hear a girl do a decent sufjan cover! word.

  • awesome voice =] loved it.

  • wow i think you actually improved the song

  • i love your variations more than i love the original song.

  • This is amazing, you might even do it better than the original band. keep it up, do you do any other songs?

  • i think that was amazing.

  • Powerful Voice.

  • I honestly don't like this too much. The guitar isn't tuned and I think she puts too much emphasis on the end of each phrase.

    But hey, that's just me.

    Cheers

    David

  • Nice interpretation! Good work ^^/

  • Great cover! Love that song.

  • The best cover of this song i have heard so far. keep up the good works!

  • i really love this so much :)

  • i love this.

    better than the original.

  • my fave Sufjan tune...thanks

  • your voice is so unique!

    definitely the best cover i've seen so far.

    :]

  • wow, this has always been my favorite Sufjan song, and this is an amazing cover. You have a gorgeous voice, and the way you changed the melody a tiny bit fits your voice perfectly

  • yeah, i saw this a while ago, but now seeing it again, your voice is too sweet and smooth for me, but the way you do it great. not crazy about the sixth fret either

  • this is great. love your voice. it's really clear and open. and I think the capo sounds great on the sixth fret. I think I might try to play it that way. :)

  • Freakin incredible i like what you have done with it and you have an amazing voice

  • I love how sometimes you go for the harmony when it gets a bit low, and other times you just switch to the higher octave. Very well done. Towards the very end, during the "ooh's" I found myself singing the harmony aloud with you. I must say - we friggin blend.

    wish you were in Vegas.

    heh

  • sounds awesome. you have a great voice.

  • wow, that sounds amazing. youve truly done a wonderful job covering this song. ones like these really produce a majestic and beautiful tone

    awesome =-)

  • gorgeous person, singing a very awesome song.

  • everyone else has already said it--- you're amazing.

  • amazing omg...your a star.

  • wow really good job, awesome job.

  • marry me omg

  • Well done

  • I WANT TO CONTACT YOU TO MAKE A REMIX WITH MY STUDIO my email : info (at) hyb2o (dot) info

  • i love your cover of this song. best sufjan cover on youtube. but a bit of advice for your singing, just raise the roof of your mouth (palette) so your voice doesnt sound nasally. you have a crystal clear tone and your pitch is practically perfect, just focus on the quality of your voice.

  • i actually like your version WAY more than sufjan's. very nice job

  • Atta girl! loved it!

  • your voice is so sweet.

  • i recognise everything.. sad..

  • wow. well done:) sounds good on a girl too i guess. I like how you moved it up a bit. good job.

  • amazing amazing amazing!! ive wached this a cuzzilion timmes!!

  • :( This was great. My ex was taken away(from Canada to New Zealand) by her father because she developed leukaemia(and had to get treatment) and this song just kills me, but somehow Im addicted to it, and your version is gorgeous. Thanks for putting this up.

  • Wow ..

  • Awesome. Awesome. Awesome. Awesome. Awesome.

    Thank You.

  • i like this sooo much

    i just did a cover of chicago by sufjan.

    check it out!!!

  • I like this more than the original.

  • diggin the vocals

  • Gosh ...shivers..

  • this is amazing. i think i must of listened to it about 30 times over! can you put it somewhere so i can download it or something!!!! singing ace and guitar too!!

  • Wow, great voice. I really like your cover... Maybe make the hammer ons slightly more pronounced though? Good job.

  • your voice is awesome.

  • Love the voice.. good stab at taking the song and making it your own.

  • That's really beautiful, I love your voice =)

  • normally i don't like girls singing. the high pitch drives me crazy. but this is very impressive. very well done.

  • your voice is excellent. the guitar could be a bit better but thats a tough song to get right. the hammer-ons are tricky.

  • J'aime beaucoup le son de ta voix. Elle est vraiment magnifique. Si seulement en France on pouvait avoir une si jolie voix, on s'endormirait peut être mieux les soirs.

    Cette video me fais un peu pensée à Peyton dans One Tree Hill, je ne sais pas pourquoi. Tu me fais beaucoup pensée à son personnage.

    En tout cas bravo pour cette chanson qui est vraiment très belle.

    ps: j'espère que tu arriveras à me traduire.

  • Wow.

    I was hoping I could find a girl singing this song and I'm so glad I did.

    You sing this song so beautifully. Thanks :)

  • doesn't approach sufjan but it's pretty good as far as youtube covers go.

  • You did an amazing job on an amazing song. Madddd props homegirlll =]

  • Very nicly done. i love this song so much.

  • you definitely don't suck.

  • I listened to the actual song, and think you sound much better. Might just be bad video coverage of them, but you still sound great.

  • your wearing a zolof shirt, thats awesome! you should definitely cover one of thier tunes. great job on this by the way

  • i got sufjan's demo of this yesterday and it just made me want to play your version again lol

  • I think it sounds best capoed on fret 3.

  • Well, I just had to put it where I sang the best.

  • You should probably have stuck the capo on the first fret, but otherwise, I love it! I keep coming back to this video because it sounds so nice...

  • this is absolutely brilliant.

    you have an amazing voice. keep up the good work.

  • beautifully done.

  • I love this cover, i think you do a beautiful job and you have a great voice! Keep it up!

  • love your voice, envious

  • nice voice. i think the song sounds a bit better capo1 though... the chords are D C Am G for the inquisitive

  • wow i love this song adn i hate covers but your really good you did a good job

  • finally, someone with a really solid voice! come to new jersey / massachussetts and we'll jam together woo

  • That was beautiful. And I to love Sufjan, especially come on feel the illinoise. I live in Illinois and I get Casimir Pulaski day off school. Its my favorite holiday. Your voice makes me happy.

  • I see C, G, and Am... what's the other chord please? (and you're playing the same ones for Romulus, correct?)

    Nice work!!

  • The other chord is a D, I believe. And yeah, I'm pretty sure its the same chords for Romulus. Thanks!

  • that was so pretty.

  • Very nice, sounds neat with the capo up higher. Good job changing the vocals to a more powerful feeling with it. Hopefully I will get to see Mr. Stevens some day. Maybe at bonnaroo this summer.

  • Wow, you're amazing, keep it up.

  • I never get to see him anymore though.. but hes making other people happy too so i guess its ok.

  • I'm sorry :( That must be annoying. He seems like a really nice guy though.

    Thanks for watching the video. I was going up to all my friends afterwards and saying "I think Sufjan Stevens neice commented my video!" haha.

  • Where can I find an audio file my iPod? Hurry the hell up and make an album. Screw covers, when you got talent... you got talent. Keep it up.

    oh... and thanks for the Casimir Pulaski cover, its beautiful

  • you sound spectacular, the only I'd suggest is maybe add more dynamic contrast to both your playing and singing.

  • out of all the covers floating around on youtube of this song, this one is by far the best (hands down, like woah)

    <3yerawesome.

  • thank you.

  • to hell with the critics. this is BEAUTIFUL, and it doesn't have to fit anyone else's tastes, preferences or version of what "perfect" is. if music were about perfection, then it truly WOULD be robotic. like unknownation, this brought tears to my eyes, which is rare - and that's enough for me to think it wonderful. so keep doin yo thang, and thanks for sharing a bit of beauty.

  • Good job. I really enjoy this and your voice. It encouraged me to learn this song, albeit a little simple to play ;)