I think you did a great job and I appreaciate it but I think it´s ridicilous that so many people say they learned the songs by "ear" but every single note is like on the sheet or just a few changes--if you are that good why are you not making your own songs and get world-famous----but anyway good job!!
@Godiiiiiiiiii You obviously have never played an instrument for any long period of time; after an indefinite period most PROFICIENT musicians can tell the scale and notes a song is played in. If a person really liked a song, who is to say that they didn't take time to write the song down after learning it by ear.
@MrPoopyhatt well im playing piano since 8 years....im not saying that is a very very long time but still enough to judge somethinkg at that level...and most people who really play by ear put their own different notes in there so it sounds better for them and btw i never said that he didnt play it by ear..i said "many people" and if really can play meldoies like that by your ear you really can write your own GREAT songs as well but like i said still awesome played....
cuz if you say you've got no sheets and played by ear you'll get no pm with that sentence: "can i have the sheets please? would u send it to me?" hehe :P
The best playing of this song I have ever heard is by you, really. people who voted against envy you, stupid people. U are very talented, and I would like play as good as you:)
Bajando las escaleras rodantes de, un subt, en movimiento parece ser esa cancion.Y Cuando llegas al cerca del metro suena la bozina se cierran las puertas y tenes que esperar el proximo metro.Abren las puertas y logras entrar y te vas al fin al puerto deseado.
@LoongChicken if only that song. 300-450 hours if u never have played a piano. 100-200 hours if u have been practicing in a year but nothing serious, like 20 min each week. 24-48 hours if u are playing seriously much every day after been practicing over a year and played in 1 and a halv,
Hey great video, perfect playing, I just wish there was more resonance in the room for the chord part, but it's really great. You say that that last part was not composed by Dave Thomas? Could you tell me which Yann Tiersen recording you based this on because it's on none that I can find so I figure that Dave Thomas made it up. I'd appreciate it thanks
reinoudoor, until I see you post your own fantastic performance online, please be gentle with other people's playing. Not everyone is perfect. I did my best, and soon, I'll repost a new version with imrpovement suggestions from all other people's better comments. :)
dont think about the comment of reinoudoor.......he is a ass......your playing was PERFECT!!!!!! AWSOME!!!!!! WONDERFULL!!!!!! ; ) .........i like this kind of people like you^^......you and other Piano players here are for me Fucking talented peoples!!!! i like you all and i respect you all.....(sorry for my english)
Wow, looks like heaps of people like my playing, Yipeee! :D By the way, the final part is NOT composed by Dave Thomas, it is present in the Yann Tiersen's recording of Rue des Cascades that I based this piece on ( The part is rather difficult to make out unless you've got good hearing) All in all, its all Yann Tiersen's Composition.
@sydnickmusik Love the performance, I'm always really impressed by people being able to play anything by ear, let alone a complex piece like this.
I'm learning this piece, got the sheet music, but like you say the last part isn't in the Dave Thomas original. I love the last bit, but I can't play by ear to save my life. Is there anywhere I can get hold of a transcript of it, or even anyone who can post what the notes are?
@EvilGenius01 That's not at all what he said. He said the Dave Thomas did not COMPOSE the last part. It was, however, present in Dave Thomas' video because that is something Yann Tiersen composed.
@gordon9821 Yeah, you're right. I realised that after I posted, when I actually went and watched Dave Thomas' video and found out who he was. I was a bit confused, since it sounds like a Yann Tiersen piece. Do your research first, I guess.
Where did you get the sheets from of the part that begins at 2:26? I can't find this version (with the part that begins at 2:26), played by Yann Tiersen of 'Rue des cascades' anywhere, does this version even exist? If so what's it called?
where do you have the last part from ? beginning at 2:26, i can only find the notes without that part.
Sleepwalker360 1 week ago
Why by ear?
Go on internet, print a sheet and you won at least 2 days of your life wasting your time trying to find it by ear :D
IWolfGod 1 month ago
wooow !!! :ooo♥
caroko1997 1 month ago
This was amazing for not Yann Tiersen)))Like
TIMA92F 1 month ago
3 min de plaisir. =) Merci !
Zodiack92 2 months ago
I think you did a great job and I appreaciate it but I think it´s ridicilous that so many people say they learned the songs by "ear" but every single note is like on the sheet or just a few changes--if you are that good why are you not making your own songs and get world-famous----but anyway good job!!
Godiiiiiiiiii 2 months ago 14
@Godiiiiiiiiii agree.
kerimau5 2 months ago 4
@Godiiiiiiiiii You obviously have never played an instrument for any long period of time; after an indefinite period most PROFICIENT musicians can tell the scale and notes a song is played in. If a person really liked a song, who is to say that they didn't take time to write the song down after learning it by ear.
MrPoopyhatt 3 weeks ago
@MrPoopyhatt well im playing piano since 8 years....im not saying that is a very very long time but still enough to judge somethinkg at that level...and most people who really play by ear put their own different notes in there so it sounds better for them and btw i never said that he didnt play it by ear..i said "many people" and if really can play meldoies like that by your ear you really can write your own GREAT songs as well but like i said still awesome played....
Godiiiiiiiiii 3 weeks ago
@Godiiiiiiiiii
cuz if you say you've got no sheets and played by ear you'll get no pm with that sentence: "can i have the sheets please? would u send it to me?" hehe :P
mavjmusic 1 week ago
you really did way better then the last video i watched lol
great job! :)
wthlolrofllmao1234 3 months ago
masterpiece <3
LittleCuteBow 3 months ago in playlist Liked
W O W ! ! !
dozenbeer 3 months ago
well ... ive learned it also by ear o_O
Destructor02 4 months ago
is good but ur just playing the song and ur not adding passion
felix95vs 4 months ago
I play the piano myself...
But i can't immagine somewone learning this peace by ear!!!
great!!!!!!
TOMREEP97 4 months ago
I LOVE THIS SONG.... excelent sydnickmusik..... (from Guatemala)
21onlyone 5 months ago
i would push button like million times!
KsettyAutre 6 months ago
The best playing of this song I have ever heard is by you, really. people who voted against envy you, stupid people. U are very talented, and I would like play as good as you:)
KsettyAutre 6 months ago
On dirait que tes mains volent <3
coPoisson 6 months ago
you.are.amazing.
enough said
vatomuraki 6 months ago
maybe a little bit to fast, but amazing!
MegaMusicloverrr 6 months ago
i love ur piano <3
mrswolgangamozart 7 months ago
I posted your video on my facebook... best Rue de Cascades cover so far... and I've seen many... =) get it up!
dodanvieira 7 months ago
Bajando las escaleras rodantes de, un subt, en movimiento parece ser esa cancion.Y Cuando llegas al cerca del metro suena la bozina se cierran las puertas y tenes que esperar el proximo metro.Abren las puertas y logras entrar y te vas al fin al puerto deseado.
SuperVyJ 8 months ago
awesome, very well done!!! And might I add: you have very handsome hands (no pun intended ;))
YayyyyyyEnglish 8 months ago
Is it possible that u tell me the notes for improvisation towards the end beginning at 2:25? If you can I would greatly appreciate it. Thanks :)
verizonownage 8 months ago
great playing :)
verizonownage 8 months ago
u did this by ear? :O
my attempt:
left: DUM dum dum dum DUM dum dum dum DUM dim dam dum
right:
kliklakluklämklambimkumkammimmmmkam
SijujiS 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@SijujiS its not DUM dum dum dum DUM dum dum dum DUM dim dam dum its DUM dum dum DUM dum dum...
TheSuperlativeOne 8 months ago
amazing!
ShamaniTza 9 months ago
I would like to know the last notes! :) would u make a tutorial :O ???? Please
LUISTHEBETTER 9 months ago
I really wish I could play like that!!!!!!!!
TheFeDeRiCo1195 9 months ago
yeah, i have to play this song for my test ^^
AkoyaP6618 9 months ago
i could hear this song 1000 times and still wanted t hear it once more
DaBigOne80 10 months ago
God bless your hands, oh and you! :D
TheDinoist 10 months ago
personally,the best version heard on the web.
BRILLIANT.
danaaaful 10 months ago
Molto Bene!
darestium 10 months ago
Great! Fantastic! I love it :) Wish I could play like that^^
Omskanielar 10 months ago
Fantastic! Absolutely Brilliant!
mrdindurden89 10 months ago
J'aimerais jouer comme ça. C'est magnifique. Bravo !!!!!
claudinegue 11 months ago
Nice playing. I´m just learning the song too^^ btw I like your piano
GasGas175 11 months ago
Your hands are made of gold!
TheDinoist 1 year ago
you are very talented, your version of this song is my favorite. It is amazing you play it by ear.
undoo22 1 year ago
Comment removed
undoo22 1 year ago
woaw, it's great! (:
Nadinepiano123 1 year ago
my goodness. not many people on youtube are as good as you playing this song.
HateMyClass 1 year ago
@HateMyClass dave thomas is
wartree 1 year ago
@wartree I agree
HateMyClass 1 year ago
it took me 2 days... depends how good u are....
mutar5 1 year ago
ohh. and btw, nice! Not all correct. but thats not the important thing, u can play it and u have a really good ear!
XiskogenX 1 year ago
fabulous! by ear? incredible, really
Chibadwaow 1 year ago 9
wooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooow. Thank you for sharing!!!
ilovemusicandrythm 1 year ago
nicely done man!
thanks I want to be better.
penguinfoot 1 year ago
really nice...does anybody know how long you have to practice to be able to play this song?
LoongChicken 1 year ago
@LoongChicken if only that song. 300-450 hours if u never have played a piano. 100-200 hours if u have been practicing in a year but nothing serious, like 20 min each week. 24-48 hours if u are playing seriously much every day after been practicing over a year and played in 1 and a halv,
XiskogenX 1 year ago
@LoongChicken it depends on yourself.
HateMyClass 1 year ago
go! go! GOO!
ceciapecia 1 year ago
I found other versions of this too fast to keep the beauty of this piece, but you caught it perfectly! :)
NovaTheli 1 year ago
Thanks so much!
sarahdu71 1 year ago
tutorial pease!!!!!!!!!!!!!!,:)
nodamegumichan 1 year ago
@nodamegumichan
or you could just find sheet music... iits really not that hard.
MacahroniProductions 1 year ago
Magnifique !!!
Bravo, aucune faute, et une technique parfaite !!!
TheTelleMusic 1 year ago
All done by ear`? Haha... sure, you play exactly the original notes... sry
hierlesen 1 year ago
Amazing!!!!!
Camendozad 1 year ago
So amazing interpetation !!!! Congratulations!!!
Camendozad 1 year ago
great playing. maybe there could be more passion in the chord part. still, was an awesome cover of an awesome piece XD
tamz0123 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey mate, awesome performance... can you send to me the sheet music of this song? I would be really gracefull for your help.
Thanks.
PS. my email is menendea@hotmail.com
menendea 1 year ago
Hey great video, perfect playing, I just wish there was more resonance in the room for the chord part, but it's really great. You say that that last part was not composed by Dave Thomas? Could you tell me which Yann Tiersen recording you based this on because it's on none that I can find so I figure that Dave Thomas made it up. I'd appreciate it thanks
lenglain 1 year ago
Simply amazing. 5* ;)
ImprovedPiano 1 year ago
oha :O
sehr geil :)
HelliAnnikaHannes 1 year ago
omg...you play it sooooooooo good....i'ts briliant!!!
MultiVaske 1 year ago
awesome
Alexander2010ization 1 year ago
like it very much
classicalGass17 1 year ago
DUUUUUUDE! awesome!
CincoCeroSiete 1 year ago
wooooow...that was AMAZING, fantastic!!
Congratulations man...
eloisatulio 1 year ago
Your interpretation is the best I've seen, because, unlike other people, you have found the good rythm, and that's why I prefer your version
Korosujin 1 year ago
great!! realy good ;)
radol777 2 years ago 4
esta bien, pero te apuras mucho en unas partes, pero igual 5 estrellas =)
nonxioro 2 years ago
Comment removed
Ratta71 2 years ago
Remarquable !!
Ratta71 2 years ago
By ear, fuck me; thats insane
WeldonDean 2 years ago
W0000W ! *__*
cravinq 2 years ago
Wow, fantastic job!
Obyschick 2 years ago 2
This very ,very good !!!!
Remarquable
saadamiens 2 years ago
Wow....
ColorfulTofu 2 years ago
I think reinoudoor don't understands music ;l You play it Fantastic!!!!!
I like your performance ;)
gaby33174 2 years ago
reinoudoor, until I see you post your own fantastic performance online, please be gentle with other people's playing. Not everyone is perfect. I did my best, and soon, I'll repost a new version with imrpovement suggestions from all other people's better comments. :)
sydnickmusik 2 years ago 18
dont think about the comment of reinoudoor.......he is a ass......your playing was PERFECT!!!!!! AWSOME!!!!!! WONDERFULL!!!!!! ; ) .........i like this kind of people like you^^......you and other Piano players here are for me Fucking talented peoples!!!! i like you all and i respect you all.....(sorry for my english)
hammerK983 2 years ago 12
man you are good you do it by soul
Redspot1973 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
no feeling or whatsoever. I cant believe people think he is god :S:S. Check out dave thomas his version, that is the best one
reinoudoor 2 years ago
I noticed that you didnt use scores...
You play the first accords in wrong order...
i noticed that in other videos too. if you would play it in the order yann tiersen wrote the piece down it would be very much better.
greez from germany
n1co2pr0 2 years ago
Thanks for the comments guys! :D
sydnickmusik 2 years ago 7
I LOVE YOU ;D
Kiwibajs 2 years ago
can't agree more! you're totally awesome.
iFaisalTube 2 years ago
Genial !! Una gran interpretación!!
AlisSs89 2 years ago
nice ear! slow down and enjoy more while playing, that would make u sound so much better!
Argeenospleeno 2 years ago
Najlepsza wersja jaką słyszałem na YouTubie .;] Płynności może ci telewizja pozazdrościć. ;P
kyuubidg 2 years ago
Your Fingers seems like flying over the Piano, i love your playing...
You do it so damn nice... really really nice.
Its the best played Interpretation i've seen here on Youtube so far.
KristallFire 2 years ago
great job, your timing just needs to be right, but otherwise its excellent, better than other versions.
ThePianosKeys 2 years ago
Comment removed
c838972 2 years ago
very good job, really enjoyed it. all ur playing for that matter. keep em coming
skeeleraar 2 years ago
very good. especially playing by ear! just a note, you might want to look at the piano score just to get your timing right
some of your notes were a tad too fast....but otherwise ...indeed, a marvelous job, i so wanna play that!
Katwhiskers12 2 years ago 2
Wow, looks like heaps of people like my playing, Yipeee! :D By the way, the final part is NOT composed by Dave Thomas, it is present in the Yann Tiersen's recording of Rue des Cascades that I based this piece on ( The part is rather difficult to make out unless you've got good hearing) All in all, its all Yann Tiersen's Composition.
Thanks for all the comments! :D
sydnickmusik 2 years ago 5
@sydnickmusik Love the performance, I'm always really impressed by people being able to play anything by ear, let alone a complex piece like this.
I'm learning this piece, got the sheet music, but like you say the last part isn't in the Dave Thomas original. I love the last bit, but I can't play by ear to save my life. Is there anywhere I can get hold of a transcript of it, or even anyone who can post what the notes are?
EvilGenius01 10 months ago
@EvilGenius01 That's not at all what he said. He said the Dave Thomas did not COMPOSE the last part. It was, however, present in Dave Thomas' video because that is something Yann Tiersen composed.
gordon9821 10 months ago
@gordon9821 Yeah, you're right. I realised that after I posted, when I actually went and watched Dave Thomas' video and found out who he was. I was a bit confused, since it sounds like a Yann Tiersen piece. Do your research first, I guess.
EvilGenius01 10 months ago
Wonderful job. The best version on YouTube I've seen besides the original. Thank you for playing this song so beautifully!! Keep it up!
pagemayo 2 years ago
so amazing i have to learn this one too
Roxas240 2 years ago
really nice !
kara0303 2 years ago
amazing :)
mimuxa666 3 years ago
awesome!!
thanks for posting :)
0oLittleMeo0 3 years ago
absolutly breathtaking.. excellent play!
exedeus 3 years ago
PERFECT !
mariiCORE 3 years ago
Woow, so beatiful!
Where did you get the sheets from of the part that begins at 2:26? I can't find this version (with the part that begins at 2:26), played by Yann Tiersen of 'Rue des cascades' anywhere, does this version even exist? If so what's it called?
Sariie15 3 years ago
Dave thomas is the composer of the final part
lenoircoeur 3 years ago
Comment removed
lenoircoeur 3 years ago
it's the live version : (2006) Yann Tiersen - On Tour
jfbb75 2 years ago
that's whats up
DatingMyPiano 3 years ago
wow. the last like 30-40 seconds of the vid just take my breath away! Amazing work!
bandgeekbaby 3 years ago
wow, this is just fantastic. You made my day
brandonvids64 3 years ago
i played that song too., ! you played super good you R great,Good Job.!
poyllitoconpapas 4 years ago
especially the ending is great !!
paranoic7 4 years ago
best one ive heard so far, other than dave thomas's <(-,-<)
punchbeesinface 4 years ago
Just one word... BEAUTIFUL!
olive1294 4 years ago
Excellent! Thanks for posting
nitinjamdar 4 years ago
Good job!really sounds nice!
congratulations !
JesseGuitar07 4 years ago