蔡健雅-红色高跟鞋MV

[northodin]

自己聽過之後旋律有幾個地方挺像的，但是Tnaya這首又不同.­...

現在音樂是越做越同調了~ 難道也要說是抄襲喔?

Take It From Me有點像是當初的蛋白質女孩的那種簡單

兩個不太同吧，哪裡抄襲?

[newmanwong]

就算是抄来的， 蔡健雅的嗓音也是非常棒的。 超喜爱的一首歌

[mungnic]

除了伴奏，告訴我還有什麽是像的？

[prosaici]

大概是英雄所見略同

所以吉他合絃有些類似

有學吉他的人也知道很多歌曲其實和絃常常會重複到

但歌曲本身旋律部分就比較難了

蔡健雅所唱的旋律比是被影射的歌曲所沒有的

所以請支持台灣的音樂人呀!!



[fixedouble]

我也是覺得除了前奏的吉他和絃雷同之外，找不到其他說的上是抄襲­的地方

[chensochen58]

我最討厭找碴的聽眾朋友們

掃興就算了

自以為很高尚

如果你的耳朵有那麼"專業"

就去當選秀比賽的評審阿

還閒在這做啥

對這社會多點貢獻好嗎!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­

[chensochen58]

以她滿山的創作歌曲

說她抄襲實在不合邏輯呀

[lisaqwe2003]

聽起來只是編曲方式相似 旋律根本不一樣= =

說抄襲真的太牽強

[N7Tiga6233]

嗚哇,幾乎一模一樣嘛

[last4sec]

真。 。 。

[86110365]

很棒!



[86110365]

很棒!



[t8102000]

奇怪咧！「曲」這種東西不就是幾個音符跑來跑去嗎？幹麼要說誰抄­誰？！Tanya作的歌大家有目共睹，我相信Tanya！

[azole2009]

前奏好像　ＮＡＮＡ－ＬＯＮＥＬＹ



[qz13wx46ec]

一聽像是翻唱,又耳熟

但認真聽又不是 又說不出是翻哪一首歌



[IANCHENGG]

除了前奏以外，到底有哪裡像？

[john19921126]

編曲是真的滿像的

[yjo4cl3x84]

超好笑的！

如果說你覺得The Weepies - Take It From Me跟蔡健雅-红色高跟鞋

是抄襲的話，那你可能分不出很多首歌的差別囉?

個何況這不叫做抄襲，

這頂多只能稱做參考，

以Take it from me這首為靈感在做創作，

難道創作一定要100%全部自己出手不能參考其他人的作品嗎？

[mrsanrice]

倒底哪裡抄了啊，這樣就說抄，寫歌維生的歌手都去吃土好了，

音樂聽多了卻不知道音樂是怎麼來的，和弦和弦會撞到很正常，

不要人云亦云的說抄襲，哪裡抄怎麼抄請音符一個一個說出來好嗎？

抄？！是你們吵什麼吵吧？！

好好欣賞聽一首歌很難嗎？

[yang78122]

吉他和弦一樣的歌多的是

[SinSyoung]

哪有像阿.......吉他和絃有時候就會讓你聽起來很像...­...

[wintershingshing]

红色高跟鞋和Take It From Me

remix 起來很好聽呀!!

[ivysoftTube]

@che5277 It is your opinion. Tell me.... are you a music writer? 不像. That is my opinion.

I am sure anybody can find some similarity on some songs but this is a nice new song. Cute movie.

[ivysoftTube]

@che5277 It is your opinion. 不像.

I am sure anybody can find some similarity on any song but this is a nice new song. Cute movie.

[s7a9m8m1y]

是我耳朵不好嗎?? 我怎麼覺得不像~~

[jpy3030]

不是只有前面那裡節奏一點點像而已嗎～

我聽了聽我覺得還OK啦



[sunyindi]

忽略電影，只愛這主題曲

[jackcarpentersax]

There are English translations for

Tanya Chua jia xiang di (Imaginary enemy)

S.H.E and Jolin Tsai

on my channel.

[fatboonbo]

I'd say it's a nice ripoff, but ripping off of someone else's work is just ... desperate ... pitty.

[onepieceslash]

阿錄音貝斯手就一樣 編曲上當然會很像 旋律也會有影響 一直講抄襲 歌是你們寫的喔

[jibikao]

Part A is very very similar but I think the chorus part is quite different. "Take it from me"'s chorus' is in fact, quite boring.

Not sure if Tanya copied it. The MV says song/lyric were written by her. It is indeed too similar.

[yuxiao13119]

I like this more than "take it from me"!

Tanya rocks!

[happy002]

This song is really nice and i don't see the problem with you guys. There are many many songs out there that have been 'translated' into different languages using the same tune etc.. what's the big deal? Just enjoy a great song.

[a83911123]

翻唱要付版費

你不說 我不說 誰知道是不是抄的

你說是不是 ha

[angelzing2008]

sweet song...

[niche102]

this is awesome!

[Apt192]

林嘉欣,好甜！

[icer5]

The song is just too similiar, especially the front part, the guitar arrangement etc.  Singing is slightly different that's all.

[faithstory]

為什麼不好好的欣賞就好?

這個世界真的已經夠亂了。

聽個歌也要爭吵？會不會太累。

[StarlnTheDark]

说的真好

[Fridgeasaur]

I love the Weepies when they do this... a cover of it was NOT a good idea... especially a one as bad as this...

[vin326]

很失望，竟然是抄袭the weepies，要不就说翻唱，第一次听就耳熟。 现在看tanya自己说没抄都不知道怎么评论了。 一直都喜欢她的作品，华语女歌手里难得的好声音，这次真的不应该­。

[darpay]

It's obviously a rip off of The weepies.

[jeffrey21735]

我只能說我相信蔡健雅的人格 她做了那麼多好歌有必要去抄別人嗎 我相信她沒這麼笨 但是其他製作團隊我就不敢保證了 不知道樓下說的台灣人是指? 因為蔡健雅是新加坡人 而且指控抄襲的人有證據嗎 有證據的話就去提告啊 旋律像的歌多的是 喔反正網友最自由了 公眾人物就倒楣 人云亦云跟著亂罵的人我覺得最可悲

[che5277]

@jeffrey21735 講得真好阿 不過抄還是抄阿

[babycaca13579]

@jeffrey21735

好一句我相信蔡健雅的人格!!!!!!!!

以tanya的才華及過往作品的水準

相信不用靠抄襲才造出好作品~~

在網上以一句話否定別人非常容易

用心欣賞然後中肯判斷才是學問=]

[tpeswimmer]

還以為是翻唱咧

哈哈

[tienweihuang]

抄太大了....= =+

[JohnCallender]

Do we know if the Weepies were compensated for the use of the song? Or is this just a blatant ripoff?

[mussiemail]

The Weepies's song... and the original is 100000000000000000000000000000­000000000000000000000000 times better...

[sachisachi]

This song is such a big rip off of The Weepies, Take it from Me! Wtf Japan? Really? You're like the most creative country out there, can't you come up with something original? Or just use The Weepies song???

[gnomopocho]

Not Japan. It's either China or Taiwan.

[bieduoluo]

Singapore actually.

[jptlove1]

這首歌跟The Weepies的《Take It From Me》根本就一樣

大家可以自己去聽聽看

蔡健雅真是讓人失望

[dedomvUser]

聽 蔡健雅 单曲 - 红色高跟鞋 完整專輯 在 dedomv 滴兜 MV 音樂網 ! : bit . ly / 1IBTi1

[jardish123]

好聽的音樂喔