Ngay xua Hoang Thi

[caodon]

Bài hat thật hay, người hat, người đệm đều hay làm tôi nhớ lại thửa xưa tuổi học trò.Tôi gặp ngọ trong đại học, ngày ngày theo ngọ, tóc ngọ dài, theo ngọ về qua 4 cái câù (cầu chữ Y, cầu mật, cầu Hiệp Ân và Nhị Thiên Đường, sau đó lộn ngược lại 2 cái để về nhà, 4 năm như vậy, tôi thay biết bao nhiêu cái vỏ xe đạp, cuối cùng ngọ cũng theo tôi về.Giờ ngọ sinh cho tôi được một pony 8 tuổi, sống ở Mỹ hơn 20 năm.Nghe bài này làm tôi nhớ lại rõ mồn một khung cảnh ngày xưa ở Sài Gòn. Cám ơn người post

[bonghongvang9999]

Đúng là Đoan Trang hát bài này quá đỉnh!! Ko ngờ hát đúng mình tưởng tượng..Trước h nghe hoài qua các clip của các ca sĩ nổi tiếng trước và sau 75 nhưng mình thấy quả là ĐT hát bài này vô đối!!

[callboyHN]

Những tác phẩm sống mãi được với thời gian là những tác phẩm mà người nghe ( hoặc người đọc, người xem) cảm thấy có mình trong đó.

Bài này là một trong những tác phẩm như vậy.

Mỗi chúng ta ai chẳng có một thời "xưa tan trường về" ! Phải không?

[dangkhoi1504]

1 bài hát đc đưa vào lòng mỗi người bằng giọng ca tha thướt của Đoan Trang.. làm gợi lại biết bao nhiêu kỷ niệm thời High School.

[levincent62]

goose bump

[kimloanlecres1]

Lúc đầu nghe với Piano đệm theo rất hay dịu đàng, từ từ đi hơi ennuyeux...

[lenguyen53]

Vo Truong Toan 1960-1972

[phanlean]

tuyet voi

[MrDongTruong]

Qua tuyet voi.

Cam on da post .len mang.

[truongchivyamor]

phan hoa am nghe nhe nhang that

[htnetcenter007]

tuyệt vời

[ottolinh]

trong sach, hay



[lenguyen53]

Doan Trang dua minh ve voi nhung ky niem thoi 20 tuoi, cam on Doan Trang

[cnnguyen2784]

@lenguyen53

Trước bạn học ở đâu ?

1964 -65 tôi ở Chu Van An

[doichanvang]

Với mình thì mình thích nghe bài này do ca sĩ ĐOAN TRANG thể hiện hơn là cô THÁI THANH

[johnlca]

Đoàn Trang hát bài này hay tuyệt vời và arrangement cũng rất là hay. She really sing with her heart.

[cuongcuc]

Doan Trang hat bai nay qua tuyet voi!!! hat mot lan nhung se song mai voi thoi gian!!! de doi!!! 40 nam truoc kia Cu co Thai Thanh hat cung khong the sanh bang!!! chang co ai sanh bang!!! cam on da post cho nghe!!! va xem... ca mot gian nhac to lon!!!

[dankaren95]

This is one of a few songs from Pham Duy that I can understand. The others are just too deep. His and Trinh Cong Son's songs are for advanced VNMese speakers, I guess.

[SweptAway5]

I'm totally not following what people are saying about VC's here.. 1- Because most people don't have a sound argument... 2 - What does it have to do with anything? Doan Trang performed so well vocally on this song! :)

[SweptAway5]

Ahhh I read some previous comments and now I understand what what you guys are arguing about here.. hehe but the thing is.. :) She's singing a song.. hehehe and she sings well... so why are we having a VC discussion? Did I miss something? :-)

[cuongcuc]

hoan ho Doan Trang!!! Doan Trang hat hay hon cac cu co TT va TL nhieu lam, nghe thuat trinh dien rat la! truyen cam,va co hon !!!

[cnnguyen2784]

@cuongcuc

Đoan Trang hát Ngày Xưa Hoàng Thị khác hẳn với Thái Thanh, Thanh Lan , Hiếu Thuận.

Mỗi nghệ si` có cách trình riêng, hay khác nhau .

[cnnguyen2784]

Theo y kiến cuả tôi. Có lẽ bản nhạc này là bản nhạc để đời của Đoan Trang .

Đoan Trang hát Ngày Xưa Hoàng Thị khác hẳn với Thái Thanh, Thanh Lan , Hiếu Thuận.

Mỗi nghệ si` có cách trình riêng, hay khác nhau .

[cnnguyen2784]

Thanks so much for posting!

Ngay xua Hoang Thi by Doan Trang is one of the very good version (Thai Thanh or Thanh Lan or Thuan Hien versions are excellent too!)

it is different way to express the song. They should not be compared.

Its good to know young artists return to the old timeless songs

[levincent62]

qua hay

[Free4Voice]

FYI, Voice4Free has been resurrected to Free4Voice. Perhaps my account was disabled because I had too many of Thuy Nga's videos on there.

[dankaren95]

By the way, Voice4Free's account has been disabled. For you VC's out there, that's good news for you.

[toolovesomeone]

Khong ngo Doan Trang lai hat hay den vay. Best version.

[dzulangtu]

Bạn Dan.. nói không có gì sai lắm. Anyone here had read Animal Farm novel? In the last chapter, pigs tried to learn human culture and the other animals could not consider between those pigs and men? What a joke!!!

[dankaren95]

What a joke! VC doing show business is like animals learning to talk. Art is deserved for the rich and well fed, not for animal smiths who can barely survive. Arts produced by these people would only satisfy the imbeciles. Stick with your bribery skills dude!

[alexalexoe]

sucker like you can understand what art is, funny =)) ...

[Voice4Free]

It's quite obvious you're an imbecile for calling this art and for claiming I don't know what art is. Perhaps that's why you're in VN and I am here in the US, a place where everyone wants to come, including you but couldn't. Ha....Ha.....Ha.....Ha....! Go eat some bugs, rats, and dogs!

[dinh]

Art is like beauty, in the eye of the beholder. To me, this is art in its purest form. Vocal backed up by basic musical orchestra. Quit it with the hate and politics.

[TrueDamnation]

i'm living in us, and there are not so many animals like you who eats shit and never brush teeth

[dankaren95]

Việt Cong mà làm nghệ thuật thì dóng như thú vật mà học nói chuyện. Nói về nghệ thuật thì chỉ có những nước dào sang mới có người đưa nghệ thuật đến lẩn vực tối cao mà thôi. Còn mấy thàng chân bò ở VN mà làm nghệ thuật thì chỉ cho mấy người mù hoặc dốt coi thôi. Ăn hôỉ lộ đi mấy cha ơi.

[grisnuages]

Từ khi Alexandre de Rhodes dùng ký tự alphabet để ký âm tiếng việt ở VN,qua bao chế độ,nhà Nguyễn,Pháp,Mỹ,và việt cộng,chưa ai sai chính tả tệ vậy! "giàu sang"->"dào sang", "giống như"->"dóng như"....

Người tự cho đang giàu sang,làm ơn tự tu bổ văn hoá trước khi comment ở nơi public,uốn lưỡi 7 lần trước khi nói!

đã đủ giàu và quay lưng với văn hoá việt trong nước và hải ngoại,chớ dính líu tới những sản phẩm nghệ thuật việt nữa!

và đừng lôi chính trị việt cộng gì vào comment cho nghệ thuật!

[dankaren95]

My "chinh ta" is bad because I left VN when I was 6 you dumb fuck. Give me credit for trying to write in Vietnamese. As long as you get the point, why bother with my "chinh ta?" My purpose of writing in Vietnamese was so that people like you would understand my comments. Find something better to criticize you imbecile!

[dankaren95]

correction:

Dào = giàu

Dóng = gióng

Anymore grsnuages?

[damraumuong]

Grisnuages da sua lai nhung loi nhu ban dang chep lai...."giàu sang"->"dào sang", giống như"->"dóng như"....what else Dan!!Co le toi nham lan chang?!

[hvutrong]

I prefer you to contribute more before complaining. I know the bad things and good things more than you do since I was in Vietnam until 18 and now studying abroad. I just shut up most of the time, do the best I can so that my voice in the future matters to people.

If you stay in the U.S and talk shit from your hatred mind, nobody cares.

[Voice4Free]

Did you bribe them to let you study aboard? Anything is possible in VN. There are many cases of people like you coming over just to do NAILS. You claimed to have live in VN for 18 years. Perhaps you should spend just one day teaching yourself what the VC did & have been doing since they took over the country. What can you possible contribute to VN for you to sound like a martyr? The Japanese & the Europeans had contributed billions to VN, but only a fraction of it went to the people. Go figure!

[hvutrong]

Many things you said were left in the past and no longer exists. There are just few other things that you mentioned are correct.

You simply copy the same thing that everyone can hear or can read from the websites, newspapers, or whatever from your American Vietnamese community. Nothing special! Honestly, I'm not an experienced person. So, what I do is to go out and find the best way to deal with these things.

[dankaren95]

I am not in anyway associated with the Vietnamese American community because I don't like what they represent. I only speak of what I know about the VC and never copy anyone's words. Whether it's past or present, what the VC did and does are correct. You don't like to hear it because you have been more or less brain-washed by them. You are either an imbecile or a VC for defending them. You cannot change the fact, hvutrong!

[hvutrong]

people will change this corrupted government, but not by swearing. If you want to change the country, the first thing you do is to put all the bitter thoughts aside, think of what you can do and work on it now. At a point, there will be a strong force enough to make a huge innovation. We are not at that point yet.

[dankaren95]

I don't think there's anything anyone can do to change Vietnam, unless the change is from within the communist party. For them to do so, they must first change their ideology. They must put the people in top priority and put an end to corruption, their government-led bribery and extortion scheme. Finally, to be democratic they must share or minimize their power. As a result of these changes, many Vietnamese scholars from different parts of the free world will return to help them.

[lollyviet]

I can tell you're a very knowledgeable person. I guess you must be ole, but your English is extremely good so I don't know. I hope someday VN will be a free country like US and many other Western countries. Our people deserve so much better. But like you've stated, VC are sick to the bone. They'll never give up their power for the sake of their people unless there are tremendous forces against them. Poor Vietnamese in Vietnam.

[dankaren95]

Well thank you lollyviet. At first, I tried to write in Vietnamese so people in VN could understand but was criticized for my "chinh ta." I have written many comments against the VC, more harsh ones than those written here. Free4Voice, Voice4Free were mine, but they were canceled by Youtube due to copy right reasons.

[dankaren95]

Unfortunately, the VC are sick to the bone. They are incurable. Therefore, such a dream would never happen simply because they would never relinquish their power, an entity they have been using to enrich themselves ever since they took over. Money & Power are the two greatest greed in human history. It's virtually impossible to forfeit them, especially by the VC. I sense your optimism, but I personally think it is an impossibility unless there's a miracle that causes the VC to suddenly change.

[lollyviet]

I totally agree with wat you say about VC. The damages they'd caused and cause right now are are soooo obvious! Only people are either stupid or being brainwashed think the damages caused by VC were in the past! Wake up people and look what VC do to our people currently. I can ignore the past, but not the present and yet, I'm only in my 20s.

[tyvn2304]

what do you know about VC and Vietnamese when you can't even speak vietnamese? do you want to distort vietnam's images in front of foreigners when you posted these comments in English?

Sorry, you DO NOT have the right to say ANYTHING about Vietnam because:

1. You never suffered from the pain of losing parents, siblings or relatives in the war. You cannot feel that hurt so you think that we were wrong when we fought to gain independence

[tyvn2304]

2. you received money from the vietnam america to tell people about incorrect things about vietnam. We are building our Vietnam. Although there are a lot difficulties a head, we are still ourselves and it's undeniable that we have accomplished a lot of goals.

3. This is a musical site. Pls don't make use of this site to spread your campaign. Anyone who come here just wants to enjoy the music. Pls let us develop and enjoy our music.

If you're the loser, be a good loser!!!

[lollyviet]

I don't think what I and others view of the VC are from our hatred minds. You must be so closed-minded to not see how horrible VC are to our people. What we see of them are solely based on facts.

[SweptAway5]

Hmmmm... :) What does this have to do with Doan Trang singing this song? :) Though I am against the communist regime, this post is not a political post, and was not meant to stir any kind of political debates. If you enjoy political debates, you should not search for music videos like this to post your comments. Much is needed to make the world a better place, and props to you for being determined and passionate, but in my personal opinion, we need to be careful, productive, and effective

[SweptAway5]

in how we tackle and present our ideas in order to gain respect and keep things classy. I don't know... :) just little me.. having a little thought.... after being inspired by you. :)

[dankaren95]

SweptAway5, if you read my prior comments, you'll find I also praised the singer, both her look & singing. I didnt just use my ears, but my eyes tool. Had you done the same, you would have noticed all the flaws in everything else besides the singing, as criticized in my previous comments. As for politics, it can be discussed when ever it is present. In this video, I see a bunch of people who were trained by animal-smiths to create art, the same very idiots who are only good at war & corruption.

[SweptAway5]

Oh wow.. I guess didn't use my eyes. Goodness me. :) You are so awesome, Dankaren95.

[xiaoaovn]

nhạc hay lời hay mà ca sĩ hát dở quá đúng là chỏi

[lollyviet]

I think she sounds realllllly good and she was singing live too! Time for hearing check!

[ltvuong]

Beautiful voice.. just like Anh Tuyet .

[ouinonyes]

awwful sing stop trying to be Thai Thanh

[superdragon07]

Wonderfull.

Thks 4 posting this

[DuMaHCM]

Thai Thanh is much better. But good for new kids under VCs to know this beautiful song (of course written by Southern artists as ususal -- the North ones were busy to write about uncle dick! LOL)

[nigz123]

hahahahaha uncle dick LOLOLOL

DuMaHCM <--- CLASSIC!!!!!! my hat comes off to you!!!!

[lolakim73]

awsome

[nondo44]

Minh thay ca si Duc Tuan hat bai nay cung hay lam do! Nhung minh kiem tren net ko co, nen ko the cho cac ban nghe thu de so sanh duoc. Theo ban than minh cam nhan thi ca si Duc Tuan hat bai nay la hay nhat!

[HTNKY]

Toi cung thich Thai Thanh ca bai nay

[dzulangtu]

Thai Thanh ha't bai nay mo'i hay, va khong ai ha't hay ho*n duoc

[willyumgrampa]

Khi nao Co Thai Thanh moi ve que huong day???????!!!!

[ToanSaigon]

Oh Gosh! How lovely this song is. Nice voice and great performance also after Thai Thanh.

[daouu]

I love this song the most. I think the best song for memory of student life in VN. Pham Thien Thu gave us this precious piece of poem/song.

[vutien1942]

Doan Trang da hat rat thiet tha voi nhung loi ca vo cung de thuong cua ban nhac. Cam on thi si, nhac si, va ca si.

[rainvn]

Oh great, i like this song so much!!!

[ngxthang]

didn't think doan trang could sound like that

[chery1234]

Beautiful voices! Great performance!

[onceuponatimeinasia]

yep, way better than old faggot Thai Thanh

[cafeviahe]

Doan Trang is great singer

[vaodoi2000]

wow... great song... great performance