Added: 4 years ago
From: floydfanbr
Views: 834,904
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,049)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • great solo..

  • Pink Floyd are the original Rock Gods blowing ppls minds since 1965 and thier psychedelic songs mixed with their philosophical lyrics........well just listen you know what i mean!

    They say not to judge a book by its cover but you take one look at any Pink Floyd album cover and it judges itself.....!

  • great job i would say ...

  • This sounds like the PF working out a demo version before discovering the perfect arrangement we've all come to know & love. Imperfect, but delightful. And I certainly was in the right.

  • I don't know I was very drunk at the time.

  • And on the seventh day God ended his work which he had made; and he rested on the seventh day from all his work which he had made.

    002:003 And God blessed the seventh day, and sanctified it: because that in it he had rested from all his work which God created and made Pink Floyd on the End of the Seventh Day

    Then he rolled up a big fat doobie and chilled to music of The Floyd

  • Wow i've never heard this version....cool!

  • @lalala6751 indeed.

  • jesus christ this was excellent

  • @fishinsumbeach

    Did you? Or was it too hard to take the gun out of your ass?

  • I've got a version where they sing even more monotone and morbid. Fucking love it!

  • @bryanswagerty do share it with us

  • I think it is a cover version of PINK FLOYD. It sounds funny and different.

  • can never get enough of Pink Floyd!

  • you don't need drugs to enjoy pink floyd, you need pink floyd to enjoy drugs.

  • Man, this version is better than the one released on the album.

  • where was this played? or how can i get this recording (what set or cd?)

  • @samiam112 its a bootleg recording so its a little hard to find. what you need to search for is live at the rainbow theater 1972 or In Celebration of the Comet - The Coming of Kahoutek

  • pretty cool how pink floyd usually experimented and made new songs and played them live before releasing them on album. perfect way to tweak the songs too.

  • Time is our camouflage.The present eternal moment is where that secret lies.. They knew this when they wrote the song...Very haunting melodies.

  • Buenísimo!

  • O M G.

  • One day, I'll be an artist too. There can never be another Pink Floyd, but I'll do something impressive all my own.

  • This recording sounds way better than any "song" made today. 

  • The recording is reaaly bad, but this is a masterpiece!

  • I'VE SAID IT BEFORE, I'LL SAY IT AGAIN...

    EVERYONE WHO HITS THE DISLIKE BUTTON,

    JUST NEEDS TO GET THE FUCK ON OUTTA HERE,

    THEN...

  • One of the greatest written songs EVER!

  • Again, I really enjoyed the comparatively low-tech early concerts. On "Careful With That Ax," it was just a spotlight shining on Waters' face in the darkness as he screeched the screech. Very affective!!! Still the most intense concert I've ever been to. $8.50 ticket

  • I saw what surely was a dress rehearsal for the great guitar solo here at a concert of Pink Floyd at the Winterland in San Francisco in 1972 ( Feb. if I remember correctly, still have the ticket stubs somewhere) somewhere in a mix of "Set the Controls," "Careful With That Ax" and "Nile Song." It was just inserted in there without fanfare- only a spotlight shining and reflecting off Gilmore's guitar in the hazy darkness while he WAILED.

  • he never plays the same solo, though they all sound great everytime. 

  • For those who say they fell asleep, ever wonder where experimentation with DDL and echo came from? Here/

  • essa gravação está uma bosta, onde foi que fizeram isso?

  • das solo ist nicht sehr am original dran, ich habe auf 440 hertz gestimmt u. das klingt verstimmt es macht nichts denn dave spielt alles jeden tag anders im gegensatz zu mir ich halte mich in meiner band an das original, ich muss das weil die leute das so hören wollen.

  • @fishinsumbeach

    Kindly go ahead.

  • @fishinsumbeach so you liked it..didn't you?cause you wouldn't have heard the whole song if you didn't.. ;) no one can dislike Pink Floyd so do you..

  • booya Jimbo this is better than stocks !

  • Only the best solo, dont forget the Echoes and Shine on my creazy diamon.

  • The FLoyd and, Gilmours solos, with the structure can mess you up.

  • this song comes from the soul, that's why it's eternal... I love pink floyds

  • I want this song on my funeral.

  • BEST SOLO EVER

  • @gremby what about the drums, Nick Mason's the man with Rogers funky bass lines, this IS Floyd!!!

  • I love you guys!!

  • On my deathbed play this, put the headphones on me....

    shoot me up with the mescaline.....let me just fly away

  • @econoroller If I had to choose I'd say I'd rather die to Wots...Uh the deal?

  • @dylanfx67 With or without the shot of mescaline??? ha ha ha ha! :)

  • @econoroller I'll do it with out! But Time would be a very nice choice of death music!

  • Not audible for me though I turn all the buttons at their peak level...... But I try to 2extrapolate" these tiny decibels for my ears to imagine what the audience received and the real power of this track...

    : (  for the criminal way the track has been cut...

  • Those were the days of venyl records/LP´s. We meditate to the amazing sound of Pink Floyd and the music was our best friend.

    Music was my first love and it will be my last oVo

  • 70's ruled! i wish i was born earlier. (prefer th album version tho)

  • incredible version, so deep, raw and mindf****ing. but sadly missing the last seconds here... also missing the piano sneaking in oh-so-gently to start the great gig and finish the A Side. What a fabulous concept grew out of this, a milestone of music history for those who understand.

    thx floydfanbr!

  • @Zappelminna Your comment deserves my thumb ;)

  • es un demo de la canción ? 

  • Please someone build a time machine so I can hang out with these guys in 1973.

  • @Greenheads35 1972 I was 12, my parents bought me a cassette player, I had no idea what music to buy... went in the record shop and saw the cover of 'Relics' with the four eyed mask and said I will have that one. I feel like it is still 1973 when I listen to that album... do yourself a favour and get it, listen in a peaceful room with curtains closed and incense burning. Layers of smoke, shafts of light through the smoke drifting in slow motion.....mmmmmm...... peace.

  • by the way, the mask is a metal bottle opener, I actually just bought one on ebay after never knowing what it was since '72. So now you know.

  • @philblah you talkin about Relix ? The mag that covered so much Grateful Dead, New Riders, Hot Tuna, etc. I loved that mag!

  • @1tag2 No, there is a brilliant Floyd compilation album from early 70's called 'Relics', it has Julie Dream, Careful with that axe Eugene, Nile song etc oh and Cirrus Minor... put it on and meditate while you listen it is an amazing album. The label says ' a bizarre collection or antiques and curios'. There are 2 covers, one with the four eyed mask is the one I got.

  • how is this rare??

  • @mavop2000 thi is a "raw" version of time. meaning a muddy studio mix

  • I want this recording of Dark Side.. Where can I get it?

  • this whole album is good...search for pink floyd bootleg torrents... i have the whole album of this it's so amazing

  • @kirkh34 This is from the Rainbow Theater show on February 17,1972?

  • @kirkh34 Yes.

  • @cwtae diocane

  • No More Rare!

  • who's that old-ass dude at 6:50 ??

  • @Anaben11 you kidding or what? thats Gilmour

  • ele tinham cheirado mt gatinhos 

  • My life changed the first time I heard this song. I could not get enough of it. The Floyd are timeless.

  • @fultonfroth you stole words from my mouth

    absolutely best music ever

  • @fultonfroth Best comm. ever

  • @fultonfroth Dude, I was the same way. I can't believe it took me until my first year of college to finally hear this album! The studio version of the solo is constantly playing through my head day to day. I've always felt that Waters' lyrics don't fit this song very well. The music means so much more to me. Gilmour and Wright... what an awesome combination.

  • Comment removed

  • @lughlongarm76 Love Wright, a very underappreciated pillar to this band's sound. Gilmour, the master of channeling emotion and melody through the guitar. Waters is great too, but this is Pink Floyd, 4 pillars combined. If you like Dark Side, check out Obscured by Clouds, one of my faves.

  • @fultonfroth I love Obscured By Clouds. "Stay" is one of my top favorite Floyd tracks. Wright wrote the music for that.

  • @lughlongarm76 great tune...I like that one too. "Childhood's end" is bears much resemblance to Time, with the intro and also lyrically i would say.I have always felt Obscured was the older brother of Dark Side...great era in the band. Have you heard "Summer of 68" by Rick Wright, another good one.

  • @fultonfroth You're right! I never noticed how similar the intros are. And they have the same basic structure, and even a similar melody. But nothing will ever beat the solo on the studio version of Time... I recently learned to play it. It's actually quite simple, but I can't play it as fast as Gilmour yet.

  • Hello, just out of curiosity, not that it matters - the album came out in 1973, right? So is this some pre-recording? Do we know? thanks

  • Comment removed

  • @zfiser It says in the title that it was Live in 1972. It sounds live. xxxxxxx

  • @zfiser It took them years to make Dark Side, so they most likely already had this song finished. They went back and mixed and re-recorded over and over. That's why it's such a masterpiece :) Lots of bands play songs live from records they haven't released yet. It's a good way to gauge audience response.

  • when i finish my time machine, im going here!

  • Pink Floyd will still be listened to and treasured long after we are all gone, and that is the true mark of genius!

  • wow thats crispy. awesome intro, great solo. floyd. thx for sharing

  • 47 people missed the starting gun

  • @themindminder why is the dislike button even on here?

  • Oh... 47 people don't know Pink Floyd. Just it.

  • Found this on limewire or somewhere as a live set from London. has a better sounding tone than the studio!

  • shame they never did a sanctioned live version of DSOTM in the early 70s...

  • Gilmour was definately under appreciated & underrated as a guitarist!

  • When I grow up i want to become this song

  • jaie fais les pink floyd a paris en tant que securite je les cotoyer et vue de tres pres quelle bonheur un grand merci a mon pote remi qui va se reconnaitre ...... numa27

  • @saraaah743 speak english

  • speak english

  • Gilmours solo. The Sustain, the toying with Volume, Makes him a god in my ear.

    LtCurry.

  • @ltcurry Guess you're really in to music :P :O

  • I second one of the most powerfull in o.d. and power dervivied solos. One of his best.

  • This was intended to be like their classic albums, pre-Dark Side, with a more mellow, psychedelic tone. In the actual album you will note that the lyrics are harder and in which this was the transition to the post-Dark Side era of Pink Floyd.

  • Quem ama Pink Floyd só teria uma coisa a dizer: Maravilhoso !!!

  • "The moon was luminous, or was it illuminated by the sun? What lights the sun? Its own fire, The sun burns time, man burns everything else. Montag knew he had to stop burning or all would be burned" ---Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury. goes very well with pink floyd

  • 46 People ran out of time! WTH? LOL

  • this album will be played at my funeral as ima creamated celebrating life and all its ups and downs twists and turns and knowing you had great music friends and family on ur journey to the great gig in the sky. plus this is actually a recording b4 the actual album was released a working progress jus to show u were they came from to their final release. jus amazing.

  • Lindo

  • OMG, my spine freeze when the solo begins, but, time is a 1973's song lol

  • @jacksalazara this was performed b4 darkside of the moon was released hence why its 1972, and completly different!

  • @Si1301

    enlightened :)

  • OMG, my spine freeze when the solo begins

  • perfection parfaitement profonde...

    ...Pink...

    pour toujours!!!

  • Everything changes as the time passes by. We all get old and, eventually, will be out of time.

    Everything and everything passes by except this kind of music. It lives forever and defies the Time.

  • Wow!!!! I love this version of time! Much better than the studio version!!!

  • 43 dont have the time

  • Division Bell..............what about the coming back to life intro......David is the best guitarist and take a gander at his collaboration effort's credits. Just my take.........

  • i like this versions guitar solo and keys better...but the drums are all over the place.

  • animals is my fav pink release....

  • Don't mean to pick a fight with the Gilmour fans, I'm one too. I had commented before that back in the 70's and 80's, I was pissed he never got on those best guitarist list. Not only is he great, he has a distinct sound. A lot of those that always made those list, although great, didn't have a distinct sound. Just my opinion, but Division Bell and Momentary Lapse just lacked that oomph!! I will shut up on this matter and agree to disagree...LOL. I think we all agree on 1 thing. PF rocks!

  • @byron2521 Hell Gilmour is a hell of a guitarist , but I guess no one does the writing like Syd or Roger x) . PF ROCKS!

  • lets all eat a Hoffman!

  • @pauljosemvargas 250 ug. or more ;) (i once had 800 ug. dose of LSD... wauw) "Lucy please share one of your sunbeams with me, and we shall fly together on kites of the mind and velvet grass like clouds made of vivid lilac tigers will be our flying carpet in the sky " ohh how i loove LSD...

  • 43 People are totally deaf. Get a life trolls

  • To the atheists, I believe every letter of the new Catholic Catechism, but I love Pink Floyd. They are my heroes underneath the Catholic saints

  • @sp588 - I hope you continue your study of the catholic catchism and one day come to the knowledge of the truth.

  • real music never dies.. it only get better with time.

  • real music never dies..

  • Pink Floyd was and still is one of the best bands ever! ROCK ON !!

  • this is AWESOME!

  • LONG LIVE.....TRUE MUSIC....MOODIES, PARSONS, FLOYD..... ~~~ DID ....ALREADY....PLEASE.... the garbage out there today !

  • Most want to attribute most of the singing on this as well as the songs to Roger Waters, but the only time Roger Waters sang on this album was for 'Lunatic'. The rest is DAVID GILMOUR.

    As for music today: The majority of (probably like 85%) is not MUSIC! Notice every time I look up a piece of 'real music'....the stuff....GAGA...is posted in the top corner. Don't buy/listen/recommend!! What they are 'airing' today is not music. They have to rely on SEX to sell the crap !

  • @Tabstarbelle True... Gilmore did most of the vocals on Dark Side and is one of the greatest guitarist ever. I use to get pissed 25 years ago when he never made any of the top guitarist's list. He gets a lot more credit now, finally. Everyone seems to be on the Roger Waters bashing band wagon now. True, he is an arrogant ass, but so was John Lennon. However, all of Pink Floyds hit songs were written by Waters. That is why the last 2 albums just never quite lived up to the old standards.

  • @byron2521 Sorry to disagree with you. While The Wall was a decent album, it was too focused on a story and less on music. I loved Momentary Lapse of Reason and Division Bell. If you were to ask me to choose my LEAST favorite from 1970 forward ...I'd pick 'THE WALL'. Primarily because the songs can't be enjoyed as individual pieces of music. I think Gilmour is one of the GREAT GUITARISTS & never got recognition he should have. I have his solo albums...but not a single one Water's !

  • @Tabstarbelle Actually, I agree with you on this one. Althought I have the Wall, I think it is more for nostalgic reasons. I never listen to it. Although there are a couple of songs that I think can stand on their own, you make a valid point. I actually hated the song Wall part 2, too much of a pop song for me. However, despite what some PF fans think, the Wall was not the only thing Waters wrote. M.L. & D.V., in my opinion, are the weakest of all PF albums but I respect others that like them.

  • @byron2521 Lennon&Waters while further out in left field were the more varied and creative, and McCartney&Gilmore were the more centered and stable . L&W needed M&G to keep from going to far out there and M&G needed L&W to keep them fluid and freethinking. I love all 4 of them but none of their solo works come close to what they accomplished as a team. L&W's stuff was eccentric M's work was pop and G's work was redundant.

  • @anydamnname EXACTLY! This is totally my point as well. I don't mean to give the impression that I am a Roger Water disciple or something. I just don't understand this trend, not just on here, to suddenly try and act like Pink Floyd was all 100% David Gilmour. Gilmour was the stability and Water brought the psychedelic edge. And who gets no credit at all was Wright, who actually helped pulled it all together into something coherent. M.L. & D.B. don't even compare to Dark S., Wish & Animals.

  • @byron2521 Funny you should mention Lennon. When discussing Floyd and the breakup ive always said the the Gilmore Waters partnership , was like the Lennon McCartney partnership. All talented on their own , but when combined with their partner was much more than 1+1, they exploded on a logrithmic scale much more than twice as good as their solo work. I think each of them needed their respective partners to act as a sounding board.

  • @anydamnname Even right down to their personalities (only on the surface), are similar: Lennon-Water; arrongant, outspoken, cutting edge. Gilmour-McCartney; more subdued, stable, technically flawless. Even Wright and Mason can be compared to Harrison and Ringo. Especially Harrison and Wright, both under appriciated talents. The other 3 members of Pink Floyd once refered to Richard Wright as the musician of the band. The whole is better than the sume of its parts. That's why they call it a band.

  • I was born and bred listening to Pink Floyd. Some evil pop music tried to brainwash me in my teens but it didn't have the desired effect - I was taken to see them on the Pulse tour when I was 15 years old and am now 33, never been to a better gig since. I will always love this band - their music lives on. RIP Syd, RIP Rick.

  • @dreamlish2007 I never saw them live but I'm 30 and feel the same way!

  • 41 people were too stoned and hit the wrong button

  • at 3:59 when the distortion starts fizzin' and popin' like a chainsaw i get goosebumps...

  • @koricory BEST EVER.

  • OUT OF THIS WORLD FOR SURE....

    THIS SOLO IS SO EMOTIONAL..

    DAMN I LOVE PINK FLOYD TOO MUCH!!!!!!!!!!

  • Prefer the original. 

  • this is excellent my friend fantastic ****** 555555

  • GoodStuff.

    =

    TLC

  • oh shit, my face is like all over the floor!!^^

  • I'm with you jeffrey2you........... 3 times live for me too. Travelling back from Manchester City football stadium listening to my 8track of Dark Side, ears still ringing. In fact They still do. (Tinitus)

    IF you get a chance, DO go to see Brit Floyd. It will stir you and I bet you cry at one point. aaaaaah what memories.

  • Jimmy, its Occupied Ireland, not Northern Ireland. 

  • Pink Floyd.....'Nuff said!!!

  • Thank you for the chance at hearing the work in progress for one of the best songs by the BEST band the world has ever known. To these assholes who have nothing better to do than bitch; bite me.

  • Thank you for the chance at hearing the work in progress for one of the best songs by the BEST band the world has ever known. To these assholes who have nothing better to do than bitch; bite me.

  • the best song of all time.. a timeless masterpiece

  • JIMMY YOU REALLY NEED TO JUSTFY YOUR EXISTENCE ON THIS EARTH, GO AND PLAY WITH REALITY SPUD!!!

  • STILL A LOAD OF UNDULATED MENTAL DERANGED CRAP........LITTLE WONDER GLOVER, WATERS, MASON AND ESPECIALLY THAT NUTCASE BARRET ARE ALL MENTAL DEFECTIVES PLAYING RUBBISH LIKE THIS.............GOD SAVE US ALL FROM THE LIKES OF THESE NUTTERS............James G Brown Ballymena Co Antrim N Ireland

  • @jimmygb64 how can you say that this is rubbish??i want to discuss with you cause i want to understand why you think that this is rubbish..

  • Sorry mate, you should have left this recording where it was as the sound quality is the worst I've ever heard on Youtube.

  • @AustraliaFare09 Look, don't think this is bad, this is before they formulated it into a song, it's 1972. The Dark Side of the Moon was released in 1973

  • At least that I know, Roger and David are atheists. Isn't it Ironic that the religious minds find a mystic experience in PF music? Well, Floyd is simply that great. Who knows, in 300 hundred years, the branches of monotheism could be very well supplanted by a new Floydian cult. I have certainly been a Davidist Floydian , then a Rogerist Floydian devotee. Now I simply joined the schism and became a united Pink Floydian. I am atheist, but Floyd is the closest thing to a religion I have.

  • @gozaderadrfunk What are you on acid? Jerkoff!

  • @gozaderadrfunk shit man!!!you're right!!!

  • Golden silence at 4:59 - 5:01.

    "music is the silence between the notes."

    I agree with poster, this is his best solo. I've been listening to this bootleg for 25 years. Thanks for posting.

  • THE BEATLES WERE THE "BACH" OF THE ROCK GROUP, BUT PINK FLOYD WERE THE "MOZART & BEETHOVEN" TOGETHER. WHAT CAN YOU SAY....

  • @dkalokeri King Crimson were definitely the Beethoven of that trio. ;)

  • why is this rare?

  • @saprando Its not. this has been available since 1972.

  • @saprando It's because not that many people have heard it.

  • PINK FLOYD PERU!!!!!!

  • they skip part.sloppy but good .

  • @farro1224 its cuz its pre realese they probly werent complete w/ the song yet