Hilary Duff and Joel Madden Fan Video

[AshKatalyst]

Hey, can i know which awards were the both of them at. 0:35-0:38. Please tell me somebody.

[angeltibgal13]

I m not sure which award show it is..its probably...mtv video music awards..or american music awards...and the yr is 2005

[20yarenny20]

hey cool vid.0:47 is so sweet.

[angeltibgal13]

thanks

[bubblewrap77a]

Hilary is soooo pretty

[angeltibgal13]

thanks

[foxymusic95]

i hate him so much cuz he had to go get Nicole Richie pregnant right after he went out with hil. So screw him!

[emochick956]

ehh i thougt this was pretty.. made me wanna cry for some reason lol guess 'cause i was thinking about me and my ex together haha thought that would last a long time but thin again nothin lasts forever even when you want the moments to say forever

[Larish77]

is the most beautiful video I ever seen

[angeltibgal13]

aww.thank you

[9sujata]

hey i found this on google check it out is it outdated or just not real i wish it was;According to sources, the 25-year-old socialite and Good Charlotte singer Madden, 28, have gone their separate ways. According to the source, the couple split after the MTV Video Awards in Australia. Madden is said to have dumped Nicole because she was "too clingy."

[tenziyouden]

omg..he dumped nicole??? but she is pregnant with his child!!!! he cant jus leave her!! he'll have to work things out...anyway thanks for sharing the info

[9sujata]

they do belong 2gether.........who broke up first?..thnx 4 the video really cool!

[angeltibgal13]

i think hilary broke up first! i m not sure..thanks for commenting and calling my video cool.

[gilmore117]

0:37- What appearance was that at?

BTW I love this video. Jilary rocks =] So sad they broke up =[ =[

[angeltibgal13]

I think 0:37 was 2005 mtv music awards but i m not that sure. anyway thanks for luving my video lol!

[agg91dog]

there so  cute together

[cwitz]

lurve hil n joel picture in 00:53 seconds... so cute n sweet!!!!

[cwitz]

totally agree... pity hilary.. joel is so stupid cuz he doesnt noe how 2 appreciate hilary's lurve... =( i cry when i view this video.. im such a baby but hilary is much better for joel than nicole...

[georgiamadden]

they were so cute together always when i look to hilary i remember of joel!!!and when i look to joel i remember of hilary!i'm sorry because they broke up!

[angeltibgal13]

thanks for ur comment..

[emopunkgerl]

maybe they are not meant to be 2gether..their age gap is so big..if their parents dun mind..but i like them 2 be together couples..

[angeltibgal13]

yea true abt the age gap...and thanks

[emopunkgerl]

u mean dat u dun know dat they break up??

[angeltibgal13]

yea i know they broke up...i made this video when they were together ok? thats all bye for now ttyl

[emopunkgerl]

pity hilary..joel has found a new love just after they break..does joel think of hilary's feeling??guys sometimes sux..

[Asianchica93]

Yep,they broke up.read in a mag.I felt so sad.They we're purfct 2gether :(

[princess739]

why did they?

[lifeissucks]

because they are different!!

hes rock star and she is a pinky girl and the age shes 19 and hes 27 see a different

[ahimsaw]

they broke up!

[tenziyouden]

yea i know...

[animeanimeanimeanime]

Wow....Awesome pic! Thanks for sharing it with us! Cute couples! ^^

[angeltibgal13]

thanks!!

[journytothend]

did they break-up ?

[angeltibgal13]

no!! lol why? well i m not tht sure

[HilarySuperGirlFan]

yes,they break up.

):

[angeltibgal13]

really?? are u so sure?? can u show me any proof? sry i m acting like lawyer or detective but i cant believe it!!! do reply

[Truematch]

awsome vid... love it<3

[angeltibgal13]

thank u!!!