Although I must say that I hope that, that guy isn't usually the singer, You were off key throughout the whole song almost. The band did a pretty excellent job with the music though, let me know if you need vocals.
You're right dude...we tried to do this song even knowing that our vocals weren't sufficient to do it. Sometimes passion speaks louder...hope you forgive us about the imperfection. And yes, we always need vocals...tell me how can we make something together :)
I definitely see the passion in what you're doing. It's nice to see a group of people really enjoying Elliott's music and playing it quite well, might I add.
Naw man you guys pretty much had it dead on. It was very well done, No one can match vocals perfectly. Elliott had a wide scale of vocals and the way he spoke is hard to match. Maybe I'll get to see you guys do another song!
If they would have covered the song the way you said, I and many other people would have been pissed. You shall never try to alter any of Smith's music. If they would have played this song and changed it a bunch it would have been terrible and unrecognizable.
Man i just came across your groups videos...this is really good. where are you guys based? i love playing ES covers! Shoot me a PM if you would like to share tabs/chords or jam sometime! I play drums and guitar
Elliott recorded both guitar parts separately, not the same time. Don't knock these guys. The fact that they listen to Elliott's music makes em great let alone attempting his songs. Good work, theesproject. Peace amongst all Elliott Smith fans please!
Thanks for the criticism bro...in fact our bass player is missing a lot of rehearsals lately...he's basically playing just the main notes, learning them in the moment we met at the studio...lol we're giving him a hard time already...:P
I like this!
dreamsleeper 2 years ago
Great stuff. You guys do the song justice. Keep it up.
trumpeteerTralala 2 years ago
It might not be perfect but the fact that you cover Elliott Smith really kicks ass and makes it awesome.
AnastasiaExpert 2 years ago
thank you...:) That's really the spirit of this tribute...
theesproject 2 years ago
Although I must say that I hope that, that guy isn't usually the singer, You were off key throughout the whole song almost. The band did a pretty excellent job with the music though, let me know if you need vocals.
Clifurd 2 years ago
You're right dude...we tried to do this song even knowing that our vocals weren't sufficient to do it. Sometimes passion speaks louder...hope you forgive us about the imperfection. And yes, we always need vocals...tell me how can we make something together :)
theesproject 2 years ago
I definitely see the passion in what you're doing. It's nice to see a group of people really enjoying Elliott's music and playing it quite well, might I add.
LLawliet133 2 years ago
Naw man you guys pretty much had it dead on. It was very well done, No one can match vocals perfectly. Elliott had a wide scale of vocals and the way he spoke is hard to match. Maybe I'll get to see you guys do another song!
Clifurd 2 years ago
It's rather uninteresting when you copy the song instead of covering it with your own style.
seeknshangrila 2 years ago
dont be jealous.
kaytizzzl3 2 years ago
dont be offended.
seeknshangrila 2 years ago
If they would have covered the song the way you said, I and many other people would have been pissed. You shall never try to alter any of Smith's music. If they would have played this song and changed it a bunch it would have been terrible and unrecognizable.
Clifurd 2 years ago
This was a cover band...a tribute band to say better. :P
theesproject 2 years ago
this is a really good cover. I dont know why dude was bashing on the vocals, because they sound great.
rafael1188 3 years ago
Thanks man...:) For us what's more important is to integrate Elliott's fans and remember again the great work of this true genious of out time :P
theesproject 2 years ago
Awesome.
LLawliet133 3 years ago
You're welcome!!
theesproject 2 years ago
that was pretty alright
anything is better than nothing!
amycrielaard 3 years ago
We think in the same way...thanks!!
theesproject 2 years ago
Man i just came across your groups videos...this is really good. where are you guys based? i love playing ES covers! Shoot me a PM if you would like to share tabs/chords or jam sometime! I play drums and guitar
Rennfahrer555 3 years ago
mad props to the tre guitar...elliott did it with one! one guitar! you're not elliott!
wah wah wah!
xteasty 3 years ago
Thanks for reminding us we're not Elliott... we would never know if it wasn't for you dude!!! :P
theesproject 3 years ago
Elliott recorded both guitar parts separately, not the same time. Don't knock these guys. The fact that they listen to Elliott's music makes em great let alone attempting his songs. Good work, theesproject. Peace amongst all Elliott Smith fans please!
Flipperdoodles 3 years ago 3
That's the spirit man...:) thanks for your words of peace!!
theesproject 3 years ago
:) thanks
theesproject 2 years ago
i don't like covers that are just the same song played by other people... elliott already did it... make your own version of it
fcool 4 years ago
This is our version of it :P
theesproject 3 years ago
nah, it's still elliott's version played by you... dare to change something, take a risk
fcool 3 years ago
come on... be serious if they did you'd be shouting "blasphemy!", why don't you take you own advice?
yousuperpussy 3 years ago
seems like you would ever know me
2 of the many songs i like a lot´:
madelein peyroux's cover for btw the bars and beck's cover for ballad of big nothing.
i'm serious about it
fcool 3 years ago
I agree...those are great versions that does justice to the original work :P
theesproject 2 years ago
do you guys play it wrong on purpose or is it just cause you're in standard?
itsjose 4 years ago
I think a little of the two possibilities...you can interpret as you wish :)
theesproject 3 years ago
Nice cover.
sk8tolive123 4 years ago
sweet practice area
the cover is cool too
m1xolyd1an 4 years ago
You've certainly got Elliott's poor singing down pat, but none of his charm.
BalmainBoy 4 years ago
Hey don't hold back, say what you think.
Beasty12 4 years ago
hey that was really good guys everything sounded pretty awesome.
some constructive criticism: show yer bassist what yer playing he gets off pretty often.
deafkarma1 4 years ago
Thanks for the criticism bro...in fact our bass player is missing a lot of rehearsals lately...he's basically playing just the main notes, learning them in the moment we met at the studio...lol we're giving him a hard time already...:P
theesproject 4 years ago