maybe correct you. all those who "willingly" sided with him. remember alot of those who followed him were forced into it because of threats on their lives or their families
Shadetree what the hell is your problem? I know you're probably spitting this shit out to get a rise out of everyone but why don't you just put your foot in your fucking mouth and choke on it. I have 3/4 German blood in me and I hate every drop of it because of what they did during WWII. The Jewish population and those that helped them during the Holocaust will stand in history as the greatest examples of humanity.
no ifyou look at hitlers life his dad(or mother)was jewish and died at the hands of a docter that was jewish aswell so he had been very mad for a long time, same as his dad(i think)
wat you said is right, hitler went to jail because he was trying to cause a rebolt. in jail he wrote a book where he talk about the jews being the cause of the depression, and loosing the war. very good baseball
I think what a lot a of people don't understand is that anti-semitism goes back a really long way. It wasn't just Hitler that felt this way about the Jews, most people hated the Jews for many reasons. Jews had/have been a scape goat for the worlds problems for hundreds of years before WWII.
I wrote a prize-winning book about people who survived (or tried to survive) in Warsaw. I ran into around 300 people who had actually been through it, and found evidence of 28,000 more. Check out secretcitybook dot com. Has just come out in Polish too.
the way people are talking about stalin is as if they are trying to make excuses for hitlers actions. they were both evil in equal measure, its just that hitler never had the same period of time to kill jews as stalin had with the kulaks etc.
I must agree that this is a wonderful movie, however, Hitler was not the worst person who lived, Stalin killed 20 million of his own people in just as horrible ways. It's just something to think about.
However, Stalin's killings were over a longer period of time-Hitler's were a large amount in a short time. Also Hitler's killings were thought out and targetting specific groups of people not to mention he truly believed they were an inferior race-Stalin was just trying to eliminate the opposition
Stalin was not even the grand champion, Mao killed more. However, it's not a competition or a numbers game. Hitler's distinctiveness comes from his attempt to eliminate whole biological groups, for ever and ever. That was real genocide - the attempt to eliminate an entire "genos" or genetic group. Stalin killed "class enemies", but guess what, his "class enemies" re-emerged and are thriving today. The East European Jews on the other hand, with their unique culture, are gone forever.
skriv stfu every nazi isnt bad. the ss and the people who killed the jews were but not the ones who fought because they got drafted nshit. they had to do wat they had to do.
It's a common misperception to associate National Socialism with racist anti-Semitism. Just because someone believes in an alternative political system it doesn't necessarily mean they condone genocide.
Too many people here make ridiculous comments on subjects that they don't have the most elementary of knowledge on.
Really? When 16 out of 20 points in the party program were anti-Jewish in one way or another, and Hitler made a speech in 1939 "predicting" the "annihilation of the Jewish Race in Europe"? Their "alternative political system" was a system without Jews, and their moral system viewed mass killing as part of the Darwinian struggle for survival. 2+2=4: you couldn't believe all that and not condone genocide.
everything in this film is based on the things that the director saw in real life, im sorry but those of you who have nothing better to do than take the critisise this should try living through what millions of innocent jews did, it disgusts me that this really happened.
Well, not quite. Polanski did survive in hiding as a child, but in Krakow, not Warsaw. The movie is based on the memoirs of Wladyslaw Szpilman, and it's not quite true to Szpilman's story. It has been tampered with to make a better movie.
The titles are wrong. More is known about Hosenfeld than that died in a Soviet camp - his family had his diary and letters. He was an anti-Nazi soldier who helped others besides Szpilman - Poles as well as Jews.
Depends on how you define Nazi. Someone who believes in Nazi ideology? Then you're right. Someone who joined the Nazi party? Then there were a lot of apolitical types who did it to advance their careers - Oscar Schindler, for example - and a few who infiltrated the party to see if they could sabotage it - like Kurt Gerstein, who tried to pass word about the camps to the Swedes. Who then sat on it, so as not to compromise their neutrality.
Why? Because that's how it happened. Szpilman is a real person and this is his story, in the form of a film. And people help him which shows compassion on an individual level, and is a fascinating story about how the holocaust affected families and individuals - something discarded in textbooks when people consider a raw figure of the number killed. And believe it or not, not every Nazi was inherently evil, as much as a product of circumstance.
i watched this movie in history over the past 4 lessons, its so moving, it really made us well up. How they threw that guy out of the window when he couldnt walk! and shot that women in the head just because she asked where they were going!
It was sick and I can't believe they actually did that!
By the way, the story of the guy being thrown out of the window was one of the liberties Polansky took with the story. In Szpilman's memoir, that incident happens outside the ghetto and the guy thrown out the window was Polish, not Jewish.
pimp
tavbf 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
DEATH TO ROMAN POLANSKI
WalmartXXX 2 years ago
This is one of my favorite movie. I cried at the end.
expat36 2 years ago 11
This has been flagged as spam show
NO Zionists allowed Breathing for that matter ....
HAHAHA Seig Hail new revolution Demolish the illegal STATE of Israel !!!!
ediramaa 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
defined irony: a fucking child abuser makes film abut moral
Ilovekoreayea 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
What a pity. He also won the director's oscar, too. :(
hackensac 2 years ago
seems like a lot of koreans are pretty messed up.
too much pride?
BboydnL 2 years ago
One of the most memorable scenes of the film... I absolutely loved Wladec's interactions with Dorota.
It would have been a crime had Adrien Brody not won the Oscar for this performance.
CityofDreadfulDelite 2 years ago 7
alguien sabe que cancion es la que toca cuando esta en el restaurante?
dulcedecalabaza1 3 years ago
that guy sounds a bit like john lennon when he speaks
rjmyy 3 years ago 2
I love this scene
dizzymabuk 3 years ago
I wish Hitler was still alive so
I could make him suffer over...and over...
lavenderblossom 3 years ago 11
whilst i am pacifist i am inclined to agree with you - whilst we're at it, all those who sided with him..
acorntechnique 3 years ago 3
maybe correct you. all those who "willingly" sided with him. remember alot of those who followed him were forced into it because of threats on their lives or their families
punksnotdead15 3 years ago 4
May I join you?:)
EnchantingNature 3 years ago
The more the merrier!
lavenderblossom 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
fuck this part
valivalivaligv 3 years ago
Shadetree what the hell is your problem? I know you're probably spitting this shit out to get a rise out of everyone but why don't you just put your foot in your fucking mouth and choke on it. I have 3/4 German blood in me and I hate every drop of it because of what they did during WWII. The Jewish population and those that helped them during the Holocaust will stand in history as the greatest examples of humanity.
EnglishRose719 3 years ago 3
thats a bloody thing to say, why would you hate Germans and yourself being German because they did this?? not all germans were nazis remember??
luvyaalex 3 years ago
I salute you man..! you are a good person and that's what metters now...
JewBoy117 2 years ago
i love this scene :)
kolorypostaci 3 years ago 5
I LOVE this part, just the way he speaks :D
Ibpoisonivy 3 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
I can't believe how Hollywood makes these degenerates out to be such innocent victims! Fuck the Jews!
shadetree6981 3 years ago
fuck you you ignorant white mother fucker!
ClevelandBrowns44 3 years ago 8
Number one Certainly My number one too..
ALKANAT999 3 years ago
Who has uploaded this movie, Please please please let me know.
sonofmanchu 3 years ago
Youtube decree, no copyright movies to be posted!
hnksnw 3 years ago
trovo molto bello il film e molto affascinante l attore! una bella accoppiata no?
vallellob 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
did she get rape?
thebbeast2012 3 years ago
dude!!what the hell are you thinking!!!
Merider 3 years ago 2
communism
hotelcostes345 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the hell?
what was the point?
mirlin235 3 years ago
I dont get it!
Why on earth did hitler do anything like that!?
God damn! I get so angry when i think about it!
morty9111 3 years ago 3
because he blamed the jews for germany losing the war in ww1 and he blamed the jews for the depression and because of anit simitism
baseball180 3 years ago
no ifyou look at hitlers life his dad(or mother)was jewish and died at the hands of a docter that was jewish aswell so he had been very mad for a long time, same as his dad(i think)
mirlin235 3 years ago
There is no reason to kill millions of people..Polish, Jews, ....
Kela89 3 years ago 6
yes very true
mirlin235 3 years ago
there was one for hitler.
dizzymabuk 3 years ago
wat you said is right, hitler went to jail because he was trying to cause a rebolt. in jail he wrote a book where he talk about the jews being the cause of the depression, and loosing the war. very good baseball
luchin89 3 years ago
I think what a lot a of people don't understand is that anti-semitism goes back a really long way. It wasn't just Hitler that felt this way about the Jews, most people hated the Jews for many reasons. Jews had/have been a scape goat for the worlds problems for hundreds of years before WWII.
soup87 2 years ago 24
This has been flagged as spam show
hopefully Palestinians are better treated now
tom123ek 2 years ago
Jo,dieses Kommentar war so dumm wie DU, dU scheiss deutsche Ratte!
bogbron 3 years ago
Deeply moving film
aleXandra28000 4 years ago
Hitler was such a disgrace
sweetaznpride 4 years ago 16
some people like them , no , some love them
-.-
jeroenno19920404 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
My grandfather died in a concentration camp.
No one really knows how he fell out of that guard tower.
DerPanzerKommander 4 years ago
kk daap
thijsos512 4 years ago
Whats your fucking problem?
thijsos512 4 years ago
Live through all that what Spileman did.And Comment then.
konzolmester 4 years ago 2
amazing story...just wish you could find alot more people who have actually been through it.
X
perfectNblonde 4 years ago
I wrote a prize-winning book about people who survived (or tried to survive) in Warsaw. I ran into around 300 people who had actually been through it, and found evidence of 28,000 more. Check out secretcitybook dot com. Has just come out in Polish too.
gspaulsson 4 years ago
LOOOO)OOOOOOOOOOO)oooooooooooooooooo00000000000000o00ººººººººl
Fraps hahaha
fanOTHL 4 years ago
it's very sad.
a horrible story of one man,that survived in the holocaust.
there are alot of horrible stories,but many of them,we dont know: now,and never,:(
shaninu1 4 years ago 4
it's a real story.
the real szpillman die in 2000 on age 88
shaninu16 4 years ago 2
the way people are talking about stalin is as if they are trying to make excuses for hitlers actions. they were both evil in equal measure, its just that hitler never had the same period of time to kill jews as stalin had with the kulaks etc.
iainc 4 years ago 4
good movie I have the rare 3 disc collectors edition on dvd :)
tunerboi369 4 years ago
I must agree that this is a wonderful movie, however, Hitler was not the worst person who lived, Stalin killed 20 million of his own people in just as horrible ways. It's just something to think about.
soup87 4 years ago
However, Stalin's killings were over a longer period of time-Hitler's were a large amount in a short time. Also Hitler's killings were thought out and targetting specific groups of people not to mention he truly believed they were an inferior race-Stalin was just trying to eliminate the opposition
Ghst343 4 years ago
Stalin was not even the grand champion, Mao killed more. However, it's not a competition or a numbers game. Hitler's distinctiveness comes from his attempt to eliminate whole biological groups, for ever and ever. That was real genocide - the attempt to eliminate an entire "genos" or genetic group. Stalin killed "class enemies", but guess what, his "class enemies" re-emerged and are thriving today. The East European Jews on the other hand, with their unique culture, are gone forever.
gspaulsson 4 years ago 2
what do you think have taken most lives?
1. Comunism
2. Facicsm
3. Nazism
4.Racism
morty9111 3 years ago 3
How many lives has laissez faire capitalism taken?
Grimgerde 3 years ago 3
Enough to be on that list.
xNeverthought 3 years ago
I love this movie... ! it's one of the better movies that i have seen in my live!
arse16 4 years ago
fuck all of you
rakugorakuen 5 years ago
skriv stfu every nazi isnt bad. the ss and the people who killed the jews were but not the ones who fought because they got drafted nshit. they had to do wat they had to do.
gackinator 5 years ago
It's a common misperception to associate National Socialism with racist anti-Semitism. Just because someone believes in an alternative political system it doesn't necessarily mean they condone genocide.
Too many people here make ridiculous comments on subjects that they don't have the most elementary of knowledge on.
st0rmjunkie 5 years ago
Really? When 16 out of 20 points in the party program were anti-Jewish in one way or another, and Hitler made a speech in 1939 "predicting" the "annihilation of the Jewish Race in Europe"? Their "alternative political system" was a system without Jews, and their moral system viewed mass killing as part of the Darwinian struggle for survival. 2+2=4: you couldn't believe all that and not condone genocide.
gspaulsson 4 years ago
hey sexxychikka i wanna watch d whole movie i once watch this in cable but i wannat watch it again and again and again...
hey anyone knows the "ENEMY at The Gates" its also a cool true to life story
victorrose 5 years ago
everything in this film is based on the things that the director saw in real life, im sorry but those of you who have nothing better to do than take the critisise this should try living through what millions of innocent jews did, it disgusts me that this really happened.
pinkbubbles99 5 years ago
Well, not quite. Polanski did survive in hiding as a child, but in Krakow, not Warsaw. The movie is based on the memoirs of Wladyslaw Szpilman, and it's not quite true to Szpilman's story. It has been tampered with to make a better movie.
gspaulsson 4 years ago
cheap jews cant you buy the movie? penny pinchers
aryan6969 5 years ago
It's a true story and it's not stupid. If it was fiction then it would be far fetched but it isent.
FunBoy15 5 years ago
i hate to say it but adrien has something gorgeous about him
pantoinette 5 years ago
that one nazi guy that helped him is cool
thegestopo 5 years ago
he is not a nazi. Dumbass!
SSUstufRudel 5 years ago
The guy that helps Brody's character in the movie WAS a nazi...so I'm afraid you're the dumbass.
Weillfanatic 4 years ago
yes, but he was also a german soldier fighting for his country and not as a nazi
phemyda94 4 years ago 2
The titles are wrong. More is known about Hosenfeld than that died in a Soviet camp - his family had his diary and letters. He was an anti-Nazi soldier who helped others besides Szpilman - Poles as well as Jews.
gspaulsson 4 years ago
hey you guys..if you wanna watch the whole movie just go on my channel and watch it :)
sexxychika 5 years ago
Err... st0r,junkie... Every nazi is evil. Why else would he/she be a nazi?
I love that movie, it's my favorite.
It's a sad story, with a happy ending - and for real. I really like it. I read the book before I watched the movie. Very good job! 5/5 from me.
skrivbok 5 years ago
Depends on how you define Nazi. Someone who believes in Nazi ideology? Then you're right. Someone who joined the Nazi party? Then there were a lot of apolitical types who did it to advance their careers - Oscar Schindler, for example - and a few who infiltrated the party to see if they could sabotage it - like Kurt Gerstein, who tried to pass word about the camps to the Swedes. Who then sat on it, so as not to compromise their neutrality.
gspaulsson 4 years ago 6
the holocaust is the worst...killing 6 millions Jews wat u expect when hitler hates the jews so much??
ichigo42 5 years ago
Nightelfo needs an brain but great movie btw :D
xteam1234 5 years ago
Stupid movie if you ask me. Why does everyone help Wladek? Even some nazi does in the end of the movie.
Nightelfo 5 years ago
Why? Because that's how it happened. Szpilman is a real person and this is his story, in the form of a film. And people help him which shows compassion on an individual level, and is a fascinating story about how the holocaust affected families and individuals - something discarded in textbooks when people consider a raw figure of the number killed. And believe it or not, not every Nazi was inherently evil, as much as a product of circumstance.
st0rmjunkie 5 years ago
it's a real story, not every nazi is a sadist, some of them even betrayed hitler for that reason
cantputanynamehere 5 years ago
umm...how is this a dumb movie? okay the movie shows us that their were good germans and bad jews
indianlover1987 4 years ago
Because they're probably were
elixirguitarist 4 years ago
thnaks!! can u post more clips from this movie?
heyitzTiff 5 years ago
i watched this movie in history over the past 4 lessons, its so moving, it really made us well up. How they threw that guy out of the window when he couldnt walk! and shot that women in the head just because she asked where they were going!
It was sick and I can't believe they actually did that!
amiethecheesemeister 5 years ago
Well they are only fictional events, mostly overdramatised and untrue. Bad things happened but bad things happen in all wars.
Lewis1985 5 years ago
this is biographically told by Szpilman. Why would he make up such horrible things?
oooda 5 years ago
By the way, the story of the guy being thrown out of the window was one of the liberties Polansky took with the story. In Szpilman's memoir, that incident happens outside the ghetto and the guy thrown out the window was Polish, not Jewish.
gspaulsson 4 years ago
Wat a SAD MOVIE...
tahugoreng2 5 years ago