Aramary VS Revo VS kuribayashi Minami エルの楽園［→ side:E →］

[dante7167]

minami kuribayashi is the best!!!!!

[desrow66666]

音痴とか言うんじゃないぞ！絶対だぞ！

[MyNANA1010]

あらまり・・・さん？？

え・・？？？

[2525HANA0110]

あらまりさんが居た頃のSHがあるから今のSHがあるんだし、素­晴らしいことに変わりはないんだから、どっちかが良いとかって争­わなくて良いと思う。

両方、評価してこそ国民だと思ってる！

[melo9030]

あらまり嬢を否定したいわけではないんだけど

一番音程が悪いよねライブでは

歌唱力や音程を重視するとやっぱミラコンＶｅｒが

一番いいと僕は思う

あくまで僕の意見です。

[kaitokita]

Like Revo's surprisingly.

[nekomata6924]

低評価した人はきっと押し間違えたんだよね！

だって低評価する理由がないもん。

[TaiBarajou]

i think that Minami-san makes a good job with this song but we can't lost sight that te inversion of the 3rd song is more than aramary's version...

but i agree... thath aramary forgot the feelings in the live version...

about REVO... I do not want to say anything ...

[Velystor]

There's a word in Japanese that nicely describes Amamary's performance: 音痴.  I can't understand why people vote for her. Being worn out or sick doesn't make a performer sing off-key. It was painful to listen to her. And her mask is SUPER creepy.

My vote goes for Moira.

[Velystor]

There's a word in Japanese that nicely describes Amamary's performance: 音痴. I can't understand why people vote for her. Being worn out or sick doesn't make a performer sing off-key. It was painful to listen to her. And her mask is SUPER creepy.

My vote goes for Moira.

[AliceEnma]

hmmm...I think it's a little unfair since Aramary-san wasn't well during the concert @.@

omg Revo-sama tripped at the end >.<

careful!

[sherryc0519]

Definitely Aramary's!!

REVO...I love his music, but he's better in writing than singing lol

I think the singers sang really well in Moira, their live performance is really stable and good. But their tone seems too strong in this song. I would feel scared if they are singing to me, it's just like shouting at me><

[HazyDreamerNeko]

@HisokaKurone just saying...arent SH all about the changes? like it or not, its kinda what makes it nice and special...i personally enjoy all 3 versions >< or im just bais to all SH songs :/

[HisokaKurone]

>:I Why did they change the lyrics in the Moria ver? I personally don't like it that way. It killed the song. Plus there were too many people for that song. It really should be only one person singing. Aramary pwns them all. But I really like Revo's voice! >w<

[MyuNekoi]

T--that freaking mask. Why? No, really... WHY? Aside from being horrible, it doesn't let me see Aramary's expressive eyes at all.

[niinana119]

あらまりを否定はしません。

一期メンバーのおかげで、完成度の高い二期メンバーが出来たと思­う。

あらまりはCDで聞くと最高だし、二期メンバーはライブが最高！­

[sydwert]

This isn't fair, Aramary's voice was worn out from singing the whole concert.

[darklight123123]

can anyone tell me what this song is about ?

[sakuya8011]

ARAMARI様

これで不調だったとわ、、、

信じられない、、

[Furudephii]

Sincerely, I don't think there's a better version in "feelings" term (even though Revo's version is kind of... cute XD) Aramary puts feeling, yes, but I think Minami also put. And... Even though it's the same song, I think the "feeling" here is different. In Aramary version, is a daughter asking the father; In the Moira version, is a sister asking the brother. And I don't think there's no one better than Minami to make Misia. So, yeah, probably I like more Moira version in terms of only "music".

[vanchunyin]

Aramary's one was out of tune often while she was sick, but she performed well, you can feel El from her =)

While it's not quite fair to Revo as the song is meant to be sung by girl, which has extremely high notes... same goes to Jimang's version of Ark in 3rd Territorial Expansion. He tried his best though =)

When it comes to technique, Moira one wins definitely.

[AiliaThirske]

Overall, Revo wins, hands down XD That "NEE PAPA" gets me every time.

Vocally, definately the Moira version. The Harmonia make harmonic (no pun intended, I swear) and Minami is a very capable singer. Aramary's makes my ears bleed, and her mask creeps me out, but she IS El, so I've forgiven her terrible singing.

[micozito]

i love the ''nee papa'' from revo and the end when he was about to fall

[kaitokita]

i think revo's was the best. no one get upset with me over Aramary, she couldn't help that she was sick, Revo's will always be my favorite

[PapyMandarine]

So difficult to judge... Aramary was sick and sang the whole live herself, Revo's version is too short in this vid', and the third live here is in a very low quality (I put the volume to the max in order to listen very carefully, but you do notice that the higher notes don't sound good). So I'm not convinced by any version here xD

[berrybeautyberry]

Aramary. Cause she performed solo and honestly, I think Elysion is her album and no one could replace that. The songs sang in Moira and the TTE were nice but I kept on thinking: 'Ah, I wish Aramary was singing this.'

Revo's guitar most definitely improved, but I can't say much about it cause I don't play any musical instrument and they sound almost the same to me. X3

Stage performance... Aramary's.

[tkaniam]

Where can i find just Revo singing?

[vicky37a]

i don't like the third one...

[juliahime]

The Moira concert version is my favorite. And I've been a fan since before Aramary left the band so no bias or anything. This song really isn't difficult to sing though.

[MillaTalonHand]

As wonderful as Aramary was on record, and with all that anergy to create that atmosphere, I have to say her voice was trembling a lot and her intonation was very off. Even if she's sick and did the whole concert on her own, there's a limit to how off one can be while performing.

So yeah... I like the Moira one more, based purely on performance and accuracy. I couldn't really hear Revo's one clearly so I can't judge.

[DelinArt]

I didn't mind Aramary's singing in the live concerts. Lafrenze and Eru no Tenbin etc weren't that bad, I mean she had to move so much, AND she did the whole concert herself. I just wish they could do a concert like this again, hopefully when Aramary wasn't sick. The vocals in the Moira one were better, but I just didn't like it. I also think they could have done with less people.

[DemanteQuattro]

What song that Aramary sang firstly?

[YoukoEleena]

I have to agree that Aramary's is the best, simply for the overall "feel" of the song. Aramary is just awesome in general really... it still ceases to amaze me that she basically did that entire Elysion concert herself. In Moira they have a full cast... but with Elysion the only singers were Aramary and Jimang. It must have been very difficult.

That being said, when Revo yelled "NEE PAPA!" at the end of his version I giggled. XD So cute Revo~

[Azuberu]

アラマリさんしか考えられない。

皆いいんだけどね・・・

[thetarachel]

Moira one is the best~!!!

For Aramary one, she did good in CD version, but really bad in concert.

[TerrixTheTerror]

Sometimes I really hope aramary puts that amount of feelings to the tracks in the cds. I can really "feel" el in the live concert.

everyone forgot about revo lol.

do take note of how much revo improved his guitar skills over the 3 clips.

[yrmh0718]

Minami seems like she's just shouting....I just watched the video again....TskTsk

[tootalz]

Aramary puts so much feeling into the songs.

[zaku33]

It is not about who is singing better. You can't compare. It is the right mood and right singer.

[tootalz]

Okay.. honestly, it's not even about 'who's better'.. the song itself is supposed to be a story, a little girl sings to her father.

Sure the second version has a dozen vocalist backups and sounds somewhat more superior, but the song's original meaning is lost.

Furthermore, everyone sings their own line in the second version.. anyone would have enough stamina to sing it properly.

I think Aramary did a better job conveying the song despite the less extravagant live.

[angelalgorithm]

I do think they change the lyrics slightly to make it fit Moira better though.

[PaladineSkyBlade]

I like the one Aramary did more.

Felt more like a play(more elements present) rather than merely a performance. It's a pity that she didn't have much backup singers unlike how Kuribayashi Minami did.

It seemed that she was mostly out of breath most of the time due to non-stop singing whilst projecting her voice.

It's a pity I won't be able to see such a performance played out anymore I guess.

[PaladineSkyBlade]

Btw I heard that Aramary was sick during her concert. Does anyone know more about this? Enough to confirm or deny it?

[x101807x]

Apparently she had a fever, or a cold, or something like that.

[ribbon821]

なんだかんだでやっぱ

みな実ちゃんが1番安定してる

[yrmh0718]

Ok, to put it simple, although I am just a crazy real crazy maniac of Aramry-sama, but I must admit she is a type who can't do live.

[karasuqqq]

これで体調悪いんかよ、Aramary様...!!

[pockystik]

aramary is the best

[Maddery]

The best version would be the one featured in Elysion album, but as for the live version, it is Moira.

[soichirokun]

The original album version is the best, of course, but in LIVE, the best one is the Moira one.

[KKazee]

Anime Mask = Win

[pluubooruu]

I prefer the moira version best, but Revo did it very well as well.

As for Aramary... her voice sounded very shakey...

[trumilashkat]

@pluubooruu Well... she was sick... orz