Carrie. Not only does she have beautiful powerful vocals but she can play piano and guitar. She CO writes some of her music. She stays classy while doing it.
@lizzyvance FAIL!! Carrie Can ONLY sing Country, Christina Can Sing Pop, Jazz, Rythem & Blues(Something Carrie could NEVER do) & Can Sing in TWO Languages & She Co Writes Her Music as Well... Im Not saying Carrie Cant Sing Beautifuly But Come On Seriously saying Carrie Sings Better then Christina is EXACTLY like saying Demi Lavato can sing better then Jennifer Hudson!! So yah Again u FAIL!!!
Christina's voice is not versatile, she sings with the same range and same timbre and same styling’s She is not capable of mutating her timbre and style to match the music. If she truly is the best singer why does she sound so strained all the time? Why does she crack or goes flat on simple middle voice notes? Why does she go off key so much singing live? Why are her low notes unsupported? Why are her registers so disconnected with huge gaps between them? Please explain.
@lizzyvance W/e Ur jus Desperate, U Obviously Haven't heard Christina Enough to Know what she Can do, I've Heard Christina Hit the EXACT SAME HINGH NOTE'S Mariah is Known fotr Can Carrie Hit those Notes to.... EXACTLY!! And r u Deaf or jus Ignorant to Real Vocal Talent Look at the C5 Range There's NO WAY Carrie Even came close to Matching wit Xtina in that Category Or Most of them 4 that Matter & Wow Ur Gonna Cal Xtina Out for strainging CARRIE STRAINS JUS AS MUCH ITS EVEN OBVIOUS IN THIS VIDEO!
You’re the desperate one that responded to me first because I did not pick Christina. She has no support,forces her notes terribly. Carrie's is strong and full. You have not heard Carrie enough to know what she can do. She can hit C5 better than Christina. She has horrible technique. Does pointless mellismatic and runs. She also loses power and cracks. Mariah is much better singer than Christina. Christina tries but does not come close to Mariah.
@lizzyvance Bitch I NEVER Said Carrie Didn't have a Beautiful Voice Im NOT denying That Cus UNLIKE U im at least giving Credit where its Do, Christina has a Beatiful Voice & u know it ur jus Not admitting it Cus u either H8 her OR ur jus a Huge Carrie Fan, & u OBVIOUSLY Didn't WATCH the Video where they Did C5 cus Christina Obviouls killed Carrie in it!! And ur Comment bout Christina Cracking & Losing Power R getting So OLD ALL Great Vovcalist Crack once in a while, Mariah, Whitney, & CARRIE TOO
@lizzyvance Alos I NEVER Said Christina was Better then Mariah, I Said I've heard Christina Hit Those SAME EXACT HIGH NOTE MARIAH HITS, so Read My Comment Next time B4 u comment!! & if Christina has No power then Why Would Legends like Etta James & Pattie Labell whos say they HATE when other Artist try remaking there songs say 'CHRISTINA IS THE ONLY EXCEPTION CUS SHE OUT DOES EVERONE IN HER GENERATION(that includes Carrie)"!!
Christina has good voice but I think she is overrated. Just because they don’t praise someone does not make them any less of vocalist than someone they don t praise. There are a lot of people who sing better than Christina to me. Christina does it a lot not just once in a while. I don’t need someone telling me what to think. Not everyone is going to like Christina better. You’re just going to have to get over it.
Just because someone does not think Christina is great singer does not mean they hate her. Calm down. I’m not being bias. I’m sure there are other non Christina haters who agree. Let’s stop discussing because I can see you’re just going to get mad because I don’t think Christina is great.
@lizzyvance Ok ok fine I call troops its jus honestly I guess I find it kinda sad that we All try to find flaws in artist vocals not jus Carrie & Christina But Jennifer Hudson, Leona Lewis, Kelly Clarckson, Amy Lee...ect That can Actually SING But yet somehow its rair when u hear some1 critisize a singers vocals who's autotuned or average But oh well i guess thats jus the game, lol :/
@maiosmusiclover@soaprivera then u fail at judging music.. my bro made a good point... How long has Christina been around??? a LONG time.. and how many big hits does she have? 1.... Carrie's been around for 6 years... has like 20 HUGE hits
@KnowYourEnemys No I didn't fail, her vocal range is incredible, there's no comparison with carrie, xtina is considered one of the best vocalists ever, and the best one now. Carrie can't sing as well as xtina, I mean r u death? Carrie is good, but xtina is marvellous!
@KnowYourEnemys IDIOT You Cant jus make up Shit, Christina is the 2nd Highest selling single Artist of the 2000's behind Madonna, Christina's sold Over 50million Albums Carrie's Only sold over 12million! Christina's Voice has been Recognized by other Legendary Vocal artist like Aretha, Whitney, Celine, Patti, Etta; how many legendary artist have recognized Carries Vocals?? Carrie's Good BUT Christina Over Powers her Any Day She's the Voice of her Generation No Other Female her age comes Close!!
Everyone on Here who's saying Carrie OBVIOUSLY KNOWS NOTHING ABOUT ACTUAL VOCAL TALENT!!! Sayin Carrie is better then Christina is like sayin Leona Lewis sings better then Whitney Houston! Christina Vocals have been compared to the greats, and her voice has been praised by other Vocal legends such as Whitney Houston, Celine Dion, Aretha Franklin, & Etta James and NO one on here can say the same bout Carrie, cus she may be good but she cant even be copared to the Voice of her Generatin Christina!
If all you have is that Christina is better singer than Carrie becuase she was compared to greats is weak. lol Carrie could be known 10 years from now. Your just crazy Christina stan. I like both but Carrie is better.
@CMUfanenglishfreak Ur an idoiot Christina may have messed up the words but she sung it great, waaaay better then Carrie did last year so suck it bitch!!!
@soaprivera You're soo way off,sweetie. Yes, I am biased towards Carrie, there's a reason why my name is CAREBEAR4VA....But, even if CARRIE performed as awfully as Christina did this year, I wouldn't defend her. Her performance last year was stunning, she didn't miss a single note (the second last one was strained, but certainly not hard on the ears). Xtina on the other hand was GOD-AWFUL this year. She sounded terrible, her riffs were an EPIC FAIL. That she messed up the words was just a bonus.
Xtina fans, you guys can keep whining about how Carrie "yells" and is "so painful to listen to" and so on....Face it, Carrie pwns any day. The most obvious reason why is simply because she has the ability to stand in front of a microphone, take a breath and belt her rear off. Christna simply cannot do that. She either needs to be minimally dressed, or else has to be more dramatic than a Broadway actor, what with the way she screws up her face and pants. Carrie can sing just as well EFFORTLESSLY.
Stop trying to compare them!! They're both amazing. So why bother comparing them? We all know they have AMAZING vocal ranges so stop acting like 6 years olds and saying one is better than another.
@Xtina4evahLegend Christina is just as white as Mariah which is only half she's biracial why do u think her last name is Aguilera thats spanish so yah she's not a full white girl jus fyi
Any one who says Carrie over Christina obviously doesn't know shit! Christina has been compared to other Vocal Legends out there like Whitney Houston, Celine Dion, and Barbra Streisand, how many of ya'll can say the same about Carrie! Carrie's very good im not denying that but when it comes to who's more succsesful and who Has more Vocal ability, Its CHRISTINA ALL THE WAY!!! and if anyone says different it's only cus they hate Christina or like Carrie more!!!
@Jussayindonthate what are you talking about Christina has not only way more album sales but way more number ones! Christina is waaaaay more succesful then Carrie in the music industry so idk why ur sayin that, u obviously need to do ur research, haha poor thing!
@soaprivera Ummmm. Maybe you should look at your research... She is a complete fail. Her last album bombed, she hasn't done a tour in years, and her performance at the Super Bowl last night just proves my point!!! Poor you, so mistaken in your way of thinking.
@Jussayindonthate Umm yah ur a fuckin idiot, so her last album wasn't that successful EVERY ARTIST has an album that doesn't do well in there career, Mariah had Memoirs, Britney had Blackout, P!nk had Try This, and eventually Carrie WILL have one to!! And her performance at the superbowl yah she may have messed up a line but other then that it was beautiful WAY better then Carrie! Christina's been Praised by vocal legends like Whitney, Celine, Aretha, & Etta James & Carrie had..... oh Yah NONE!!
@soaprivera The only fuckin idiot here is obviously you. Christina is over. She shouldn't have gotten such a big head thinkin she's so great no matter what she does, maybe she would still be where she used to be. Now, she over sings everything and screws it up while she's at it. Carrie is and always will be better at everything! Dont make up facts, it just makes you look dumber than you clearly are. Also why dont you look up a good ear doctor, because clearly you need your hearing checked.
@Jussayindonthate I'm NOT making up facts u Dumbfuck you can look it up "Christina Aguilera admiered by Many Artists" and on there you'll find legends praising Christina not only on her work but on her vocal ability and Whitney Celine & Etta James are on there like I said including other legends like Cher & Patti LaBell who said only Christina could pull off remaking her songs! Face it Carrie's Very Good BUT her Vocal ability will never be remembered 10 yrs from now like Christina's will!!
@soaprivera I wouldn't waste my time. If what you say is true, I'm sure they've all taken it back by now, judging from her performances lately. Carrie will be remembered in 10 years for everything she has done and everything she will be doing, not who she used to be. Carrie is AMAZING! But, you're right, Christina will be remembered... For how she went from a young star with a bright future to a bombed album, bombed movie, bombed Superbowl performance, messed up personal life, and jail time.
@Jussayindonthate OMG jus GO THE FUCK AWAY ur an idiot, jus face it Christina is more of a vocal icon then Carrie, NONE of them would take it back and Aretha Franklin even defended her super bowl performance along with many others! And many Great artist have had break downs in there career b4, Look at Mariah & Britney they went through shit and had unsuccecful albums BUT they came back stronger then ever & so will Xtina, she's MORE succesful then Carrie especialy when it comes to vocal talent!
haha, dude, I looked at the title, and I'm like, wtf? Are you serious, Carrie beats the crap out of Christina!!!!! Haha, jk, Christina is my fav, Carrie is crushed by Christinas voice. Like, seriously no joke.
@gallaril000 agreed kelly can sing and be able to control her voice better then xtina. and carrie well she just always sounds the same no matter what shes good at country and that is all
srry but at the first video of christina laughing like hehe and then screaming like that.. that was so annoying XD but they r both good, no comparing is needed but whatever.
@Xtina4evahLegend not really...obviously u haven't listened to country in a while because most country singers today have a limited vocal range compared to Carrie...
christina aguilera,carrie underwood,leona lewis...son grandes artistas...entre muchos mas,creo que no se trata de ribalizarlas entre ellas,hay veces que les sale mejor que otras,creo que es normal.I love garbage...
Carrie is Damn Good but she doesn't stand a chance in hell against Christina, She's the voice of her generation No Diva can take her on not Carrie, Beyonce, Mariah, Kelly Clarkson, or Amy Lee!!!!!
@soaprivera Hi, sorry, but I have to disagree with you about Mariah, not being as good as Christina. I do agree, however, that Christina, is the only one who could come close to mariah. I really don't care for Beyonce and Kelly Clarkson is good, bu, NOT as good as Mariah or Christina.
@m5e8n9h Well I do admit Mariah is very good and I love her Just as much as I Love Christina and I'd Love to hear those two do a duet that would be amazing!! :)
@soaprivera I totally agree! I also meant to say that, I think Carrie, is one of the best country singers today. I honestly think she would have been ok, in the pop music department also. Her voice is proof, that regardless, of her winning on American Idol, she would have had a contract anyway.
@soaprivera Christina is just full of antics that don't add to her voice. Christina is good but Carrie is the better singer. Carrie knows how to sing while Christina performs. Also Christina is loosing her voice and over emoting to compensate. The over emoting by Christina is tiring.
@robinannhunt I totally agree about christina's voice. Carrie will stand the test of time and in my opinion the best singer we have today in any genra
@robinannhunt You obviously don't know what vocal talent is if u think Carrie beats out Christina. Saying Carrie is a better sing then Christina is jus like saying Leona Lewis sings better then Whitney Houston. Christina"s vocals have been praised by vocal legends like Whitney and Celine Dion what other artist known for there vocals have said the same about Carrie, oh wait NONE! Carrie maybe good but her succes and voice dont even come near to being compared to Christina so don't even!
@soaprivera Still in your little la la world. Christina ruined the NA at the superbowl by doing those riffs to cover her aging voice and missed words. That must have been embarrasing for you and Christina. I wish Christina would just sing a song. Maybe she is still pretty good. And leona probably is better than Whitnew these days. I don't really follow leona.
@soaprivera Carrie sings much better than Christina and you can actually understand what she is singing and you don't need constant runs to disuise the lack of other areas
@carrie1fan123 You obviously don't know what vocal talent is if u think Carrie beats out Christina. Saying Carrie is a better sing then Christina is jus like saying Leona Lewis sings better then Whitney Houston. Christina"s vocals have been praised by vocal legends like Whitney and Celine Dion what other artist known for there vocals have said the same about Carrie, oh wait NONE! Carrie maybe good but her succes and voice dont even come near to being compared to Christina so don't even!
Carrie Underwood!!!! She is so amazing!! I saw her Live and her voice is perfect! She sang ''I know you won't'' with those great notes and it was crazy!!! I really thing she is better then Christina!
P.S. I hate when Christina aguilera do '' ya ya ya ya ya ya ........! '' when she do a high note.. it looks really weird!!!
Year year Carrie is better - IN YOUR SWEETEST DREAMS KIDS!!! Christina has better voice than W.Houston and M.Carey and you compare her to such NO TALENTS like Carrie Underwood? There is something wrong with this world.
sorry bitch. bt i think the most succesful till now is KELLY CLARKSON.. actually she got at least a hit.. well some.. but christina is on other level..
@luisitolima um...ur stupid...stop talking because if u check record sales carrie has sold more albums in a shorter career than kelly has in her career which is at least 3 years longer.
Christina is a pathetic excuse of a singer. her voice is almost as irritating as Taylor Swift's voice. Carrie is a way better singer than most singers out there. Christina just screams..
Carrie has a great voice and I love her, but Chritina has the most incredible voice of the world, and she shows it in every song in every time she sings
Carrie Underwood, Christina has a great voice but I think I prefer Carrie overall. Sometimes Christina tries too hard and ends up failing to hit those long notes whereas Carrie hits them effortlessly no matter what the occasion or the song for that matter. Plus Christina has had crappy songs lately...CARRIE - has the ability to belt and still bring tears to your eyes!
I love both but Carrie. She can just belt and sound amazing. Christina does to many runs and she ends up sounding like she is trying too hard. Love them both.
i like both of them, but theres just something about carrie that i like a little better. idk wat it is. theres something about christina that just seems show-offy.
theres only one way to really compare them other than have clips of each have them perform together. but regardless with the clips x-tinas better hits higher notes than carrie and has a more powerful voice. watch?v=4cwAtkSLGy4&NR=1. shes also versatile which carrie isn't, christinas already christina, carrie is who? again.? Boring no comparison
I like Christina and Carrie but I think Carrie is better. She just sounds so natural when she does her notes like she is not even trying. Carries voice amazes me to. Dont get me wrong xtina has a great voice when she is not doing those riffs. Carrie for some reason is one of the few artists who voices do amaze me.
I like Christina and Carrie but I think Carrie is better. She just sounds so natural when she does her notes like she is not even trying. Carries voice amazes me to. Dont get me wrong xtina has a great voice when she is not doing those riffs. Carrie for some reason is one of the few artists who voices do amaze me.
I agree with what one another poster said..the clips are honestly of substantially different levels of quality, but people will still have their opinions and that's good. At the end of the day though it's not about winning or losing but what kind of person you are and they both seem great and they both bring high amounts of energy and flair to every song they sing!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
christina aguilera does notes that i'v never heard before and she is one of the most successful singers of all time. shes such an inspiration. although she does oversing at times she is still my #1 singer and i think she is the best at singing
lol nice job using carrie's worst notes and christina's best. but carrie still makes belting high notes sound twice as christina does. and she can go higher in chest voice.
I love Carrie and her voice is just amazing, but Christina has a fricken fabulous voice its just incrediable the notes she can hit. Christina is the shit over Briney or Jessica and I have always thought that.
are you guys serious? christina aguilera has a much louder and way more powerfull voice than carrie underwood! i cant believe people are trying to compare them c'mon!
CHristina all the way
SheLovesXtinAguilera 2 months ago
christina, she's so much better her voice is unique and just the best :) everybody should hear that who has ears that work
MsLittleradio 4 months ago 5
The Brazil loves Carrie - The Brazil loves Carrie - The Brazil loves Carrie - The Brazil loves Carrie - The Brazil loves Carrie... ♥
paulbritney 5 months ago
Carrie. Not only does she have beautiful powerful vocals but she can play piano and guitar. She CO writes some of her music. She stays classy while doing it.
Christina strains and has bad technique.
lizzyvance 6 months ago
@lizzyvance FAIL!! Carrie Can ONLY sing Country, Christina Can Sing Pop, Jazz, Rythem & Blues(Something Carrie could NEVER do) & Can Sing in TWO Languages & She Co Writes Her Music as Well... Im Not saying Carrie Cant Sing Beautifuly But Come On Seriously saying Carrie Sings Better then Christina is EXACTLY like saying Demi Lavato can sing better then Jennifer Hudson!! So yah Again u FAIL!!!
soaprivera 6 months ago
@soaprivera
Christina's voice is not versatile, she sings with the same range and same timbre and same styling’s She is not capable of mutating her timbre and style to match the music. If she truly is the best singer why does she sound so strained all the time? Why does she crack or goes flat on simple middle voice notes? Why does she go off key so much singing live? Why are her low notes unsupported? Why are her registers so disconnected with huge gaps between them? Please explain.
lizzyvance 6 months ago
@lizzyvance W/e Ur jus Desperate, U Obviously Haven't heard Christina Enough to Know what she Can do, I've Heard Christina Hit the EXACT SAME HINGH NOTE'S Mariah is Known fotr Can Carrie Hit those Notes to.... EXACTLY!! And r u Deaf or jus Ignorant to Real Vocal Talent Look at the C5 Range There's NO WAY Carrie Even came close to Matching wit Xtina in that Category Or Most of them 4 that Matter & Wow Ur Gonna Cal Xtina Out for strainging CARRIE STRAINS JUS AS MUCH ITS EVEN OBVIOUS IN THIS VIDEO!
soaprivera 6 months ago
@soaprivera
You’re the desperate one that responded to me first because I did not pick Christina. She has no support,forces her notes terribly. Carrie's is strong and full. You have not heard Carrie enough to know what she can do. She can hit C5 better than Christina. She has horrible technique. Does pointless mellismatic and runs. She also loses power and cracks. Mariah is much better singer than Christina. Christina tries but does not come close to Mariah.
lizzyvance 6 months ago
@lizzyvance Bitch I NEVER Said Carrie Didn't have a Beautiful Voice Im NOT denying That Cus UNLIKE U im at least giving Credit where its Do, Christina has a Beatiful Voice & u know it ur jus Not admitting it Cus u either H8 her OR ur jus a Huge Carrie Fan, & u OBVIOUSLY Didn't WATCH the Video where they Did C5 cus Christina Obviouls killed Carrie in it!! And ur Comment bout Christina Cracking & Losing Power R getting So OLD ALL Great Vovcalist Crack once in a while, Mariah, Whitney, & CARRIE TOO
soaprivera 6 months ago
@lizzyvance Alos I NEVER Said Christina was Better then Mariah, I Said I've heard Christina Hit Those SAME EXACT HIGH NOTE MARIAH HITS, so Read My Comment Next time B4 u comment!! & if Christina has No power then Why Would Legends like Etta James & Pattie Labell whos say they HATE when other Artist try remaking there songs say 'CHRISTINA IS THE ONLY EXCEPTION CUS SHE OUT DOES EVERONE IN HER GENERATION(that includes Carrie)"!!
soaprivera 6 months ago
@soaprivera
Christina has good voice but I think she is overrated. Just because they don’t praise someone does not make them any less of vocalist than someone they don t praise. There are a lot of people who sing better than Christina to me. Christina does it a lot not just once in a while. I don’t need someone telling me what to think. Not everyone is going to like Christina better. You’re just going to have to get over it.
lizzyvance 6 months ago
@soaprivera
Just because someone does not think Christina is great singer does not mean they hate her. Calm down. I’m not being bias. I’m sure there are other non Christina haters who agree. Let’s stop discussing because I can see you’re just going to get mad because I don’t think Christina is great.
lizzyvance 6 months ago
@lizzyvance Ok ok fine I call troops its jus honestly I guess I find it kinda sad that we All try to find flaws in artist vocals not jus Carrie & Christina But Jennifer Hudson, Leona Lewis, Kelly Clarckson, Amy Lee...ect That can Actually SING But yet somehow its rair when u hear some1 critisize a singers vocals who's autotuned or average But oh well i guess thats jus the game, lol :/
soaprivera 6 months ago
@soaprivera
Shakira can sing in more languages than Christina so does that mean Shakira is better?
lizzyvance 6 months ago
@soaprivera
Writing a good song yourself takes talent not CO writing. Carrie CO writes some of her songs.
lizzyvance 6 months ago
Carrie's Good But She DOESNT STAND A CHANCE IN HELL against Christina!!
Christna's sold over 50million albums, Carrie's sold over 12 million albums
Christina's sold 46 million singles Carris sold over 18 million singles
Both have a high Octave Range BUT Christina Can Dance while using hers
Christina has a Star on the Hollywood walk of Fame, Can Sing in TWO Languages Has been Praised By Vocal Legends Whitney, Celine, Aretha, & Patti
& has been Dubbed as The Voice of her Generation! BEAT THAT
soaprivera 7 months ago
XTINA DESTROYS HER, I'M SORRY
maiosmusiclover 8 months ago
@maiosmusiclover@soaprivera then u fail at judging music.. my bro made a good point... How long has Christina been around??? a LONG time.. and how many big hits does she have? 1.... Carrie's been around for 6 years... has like 20 HUGE hits
KnowYourEnemys 8 months ago
@KnowYourEnemys No I didn't fail, her vocal range is incredible, there's no comparison with carrie, xtina is considered one of the best vocalists ever, and the best one now. Carrie can't sing as well as xtina, I mean r u death? Carrie is good, but xtina is marvellous!
maiosmusiclover 8 months ago
@KnowYourEnemys IDIOT You Cant jus make up Shit, Christina is the 2nd Highest selling single Artist of the 2000's behind Madonna, Christina's sold Over 50million Albums Carrie's Only sold over 12million! Christina's Voice has been Recognized by other Legendary Vocal artist like Aretha, Whitney, Celine, Patti, Etta; how many legendary artist have recognized Carries Vocals?? Carrie's Good BUT Christina Over Powers her Any Day She's the Voice of her Generation No Other Female her age comes Close!!
soaprivera 7 months ago
Carrie is way better
Kyserboy321 9 months ago
Carrie s2
paulbritney 10 months ago
Everyone on Here who's saying Carrie OBVIOUSLY KNOWS NOTHING ABOUT ACTUAL VOCAL TALENT!!! Sayin Carrie is better then Christina is like sayin Leona Lewis sings better then Whitney Houston! Christina Vocals have been compared to the greats, and her voice has been praised by other Vocal legends such as Whitney Houston, Celine Dion, Aretha Franklin, & Etta James and NO one on here can say the same bout Carrie, cus she may be good but she cant even be copared to the Voice of her Generatin Christina!
soaprivera 1 year ago
@soaprivera
If all you have is that Christina is better singer than Carrie becuase she was compared to greats is weak. lol Carrie could be known 10 years from now. Your just crazy Christina stan. I like both but Carrie is better.
lizzyvance 11 months ago
Oh and another reason why Carrie rocks : she can remember the words to her anthem. Not to mention sing it better :P
Face it : Carrie Underwood FOREVER!
CMUfanenglishfreak 1 year ago
@CMUfanenglishfreak Ur an idoiot Christina may have messed up the words but she sung it great, waaaay better then Carrie did last year so suck it bitch!!!
soaprivera 1 year ago
@soaprivera Nice comment.
robinannhunt 1 year ago
@soaprivera You're soo way off,sweetie. Yes, I am biased towards Carrie, there's a reason why my name is CAREBEAR4VA....But, even if CARRIE performed as awfully as Christina did this year, I wouldn't defend her. Her performance last year was stunning, she didn't miss a single note (the second last one was strained, but certainly not hard on the ears). Xtina on the other hand was GOD-AWFUL this year. She sounded terrible, her riffs were an EPIC FAIL. That she messed up the words was just a bonus.
CMUfanenglishfreak 1 year ago
Xtina fans, you guys can keep whining about how Carrie "yells" and is "so painful to listen to" and so on....Face it, Carrie pwns any day. The most obvious reason why is simply because she has the ability to stand in front of a microphone, take a breath and belt her rear off. Christna simply cannot do that. She either needs to be minimally dressed, or else has to be more dramatic than a Broadway actor, what with the way she screws up her face and pants. Carrie can sing just as well EFFORTLESSLY.
CMUfanenglishfreak 1 year ago
Stop trying to compare them!! They're both amazing. So why bother comparing them? We all know they have AMAZING vocal ranges so stop acting like 6 years olds and saying one is better than another.
xxxTeamUnderwoodxxx 1 year ago
@Xtina4evahLegend Christina is just as white as Mariah which is only half she's biracial why do u think her last name is Aguilera thats spanish so yah she's not a full white girl jus fyi
soaprivera 1 year ago
Any one who says Carrie over Christina obviously doesn't know shit! Christina has been compared to other Vocal Legends out there like Whitney Houston, Celine Dion, and Barbra Streisand, how many of ya'll can say the same about Carrie! Carrie's very good im not denying that but when it comes to who's more succsesful and who Has more Vocal ability, Its CHRISTINA ALL THE WAY!!! and if anyone says different it's only cus they hate Christina or like Carrie more!!!
soaprivera 1 year ago
I take Carrie's voice over Christina's ANY DAY! She is an awesome singer, but too much nonsense when she sings....if you have the voice, just sing!
Brie26 1 year ago
carrie all the way. voice of an angel for me :)
pinoydream 1 year ago 3
Carrie, by a mile! Chrisytina is decent in her own right, but doesn't some close to Ms. Underwood
CMUfanenglishfreak 1 year ago 3
chrsitinaa!
deverdad1000 1 year ago
CARRIE! Always has and always will! Just look at the album sales. Proves it right there.
Jussayindonthate 1 year ago 10
@Jussayindonthate what are you talking about Christina has not only way more album sales but way more number ones! Christina is waaaaay more succesful then Carrie in the music industry so idk why ur sayin that, u obviously need to do ur research, haha poor thing!
soaprivera 1 year ago
@soaprivera Ummmm. Maybe you should look at your research... She is a complete fail. Her last album bombed, she hasn't done a tour in years, and her performance at the Super Bowl last night just proves my point!!! Poor you, so mistaken in your way of thinking.
Jussayindonthate 1 year ago
@Jussayindonthate Well said!! Carrie Underwood forever!!!
CMUfanenglishfreak 1 year ago
@CMUfanenglishfreak CARRIE FOREVER!!! There's nothing she can't do!!
Jussayindonthate 1 year ago
@Jussayindonthate So true!! CARRRIIIEEEEEEE
CMUfanenglishfreak 1 year ago
@Jussayindonthate Umm yah ur a fuckin idiot, so her last album wasn't that successful EVERY ARTIST has an album that doesn't do well in there career, Mariah had Memoirs, Britney had Blackout, P!nk had Try This, and eventually Carrie WILL have one to!! And her performance at the superbowl yah she may have messed up a line but other then that it was beautiful WAY better then Carrie! Christina's been Praised by vocal legends like Whitney, Celine, Aretha, & Etta James & Carrie had..... oh Yah NONE!!
soaprivera 1 year ago
@soaprivera The only fuckin idiot here is obviously you. Christina is over. She shouldn't have gotten such a big head thinkin she's so great no matter what she does, maybe she would still be where she used to be. Now, she over sings everything and screws it up while she's at it. Carrie is and always will be better at everything! Dont make up facts, it just makes you look dumber than you clearly are. Also why dont you look up a good ear doctor, because clearly you need your hearing checked.
Jussayindonthate 1 year ago
@Jussayindonthate I'm NOT making up facts u Dumbfuck you can look it up "Christina Aguilera admiered by Many Artists" and on there you'll find legends praising Christina not only on her work but on her vocal ability and Whitney Celine & Etta James are on there like I said including other legends like Cher & Patti LaBell who said only Christina could pull off remaking her songs! Face it Carrie's Very Good BUT her Vocal ability will never be remembered 10 yrs from now like Christina's will!!
soaprivera 1 year ago
@soaprivera I wouldn't waste my time. If what you say is true, I'm sure they've all taken it back by now, judging from her performances lately. Carrie will be remembered in 10 years for everything she has done and everything she will be doing, not who she used to be. Carrie is AMAZING! But, you're right, Christina will be remembered... For how she went from a young star with a bright future to a bombed album, bombed movie, bombed Superbowl performance, messed up personal life, and jail time.
Jussayindonthate 1 year ago
@Jussayindonthate OMG jus GO THE FUCK AWAY ur an idiot, jus face it Christina is more of a vocal icon then Carrie, NONE of them would take it back and Aretha Franklin even defended her super bowl performance along with many others! And many Great artist have had break downs in there career b4, Look at Mariah & Britney they went through shit and had unsuccecful albums BUT they came back stronger then ever & so will Xtina, she's MORE succesful then Carrie especialy when it comes to vocal talent!
soaprivera 1 year ago
Carrie KICKS CHRISTINA'S ASS!!!!
CMUfanenglishfreak 1 year ago 3
I PREFER CARRIE!
iamaveryuglyboy 1 year ago 3
CARRIE UNDERWOOD BY FAR IS THE BEST DUH!!!
thesandylove11 1 year ago 3
haha, dude, I looked at the title, and I'm like, wtf? Are you serious, Carrie beats the crap out of Christina!!!!! Haha, jk, Christina is my fav, Carrie is crushed by Christinas voice. Like, seriously no joke.
penguinsrox87 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
No offense people but Christina looks like crap.
monkeygirl333sm 1 year ago
No offense peopel but Christina looks like a piece of... crap.
monkeygirl333sm 1 year ago
both are very good... carrie has more "good days" than christina, but christina on a good day will crush everyone...
mariotl 1 year ago 2
CHRISTINA of course !!! she is a divaaa !!!
but both are great singers :)
martinianipobo 1 year ago 2
Carrie because she doesn't overdo it like Christina does. It's like, "Christina, just sing the @#$%*NG SONG!"
XmightbiteyouX 1 year ago
@Xtina4evahLegend kelly can sing as powerfull as christina...if not more powerful. Carrie has the best voice in country though, gotta say.
gallaril000 1 year ago
@gallaril000 agreed kelly can sing and be able to control her voice better then xtina. and carrie well she just always sounds the same no matter what shes good at country and that is all
KCfan008 1 year ago
Christina is fucking amazing !!!
TheDanny2a 1 year ago 2
srry but at the first video of christina laughing like hehe and then screaming like that.. that was so annoying XD but they r both good, no comparing is needed but whatever.
TheAlienAndTheTree 1 year ago
xtina
bvega06 1 year ago
@Xtina4evahLegend not really...obviously u haven't listened to country in a while because most country singers today have a limited vocal range compared to Carrie...
ejhmed 1 year ago
christina aguilera,carrie underwood,leona lewis...son grandes artistas...entre muchos mas,creo que no se trata de ribalizarlas entre ellas,hay veces que les sale mejor que otras,creo que es normal.I love garbage...
carlos197604 1 year ago
I'm sorry, but Xtina cannot carry a note...she has to have "runs" so that it seems as though she can. Like nails on a chalk board! Ugh!
Fyreflyy 1 year ago
õ/ Carrie.! ♥
bjooonomeeliigaa.! ;p
bia857 1 year ago
Christina Aguilera.
atrayu90602 1 year ago
i love carie and christina..but i think i love christina's voice more
jeny163natali 1 year ago
Carrie underwood ♥ COME TO BRAZIL
besseslo 1 year ago 19
Carrie is hotter and her voice is more smooth and velvet, but Christina has a stronger and larger range voice
ExdeathXInfinity 1 year ago
@ExdeathXInfinity
bia857 1 year ago
CHRISTINA THE BEST
steinbeck19 1 year ago
Carrie underwood
besseslo 1 year ago 3
Carrie! <3
HannahPlyler 1 year ago
Christina's Eb5 is an E5 :)
yahiie 1 year ago
None of them hold a candle to my girl, Kelly C.
EvFan1985 1 year ago
Carrie is Damn Good but she doesn't stand a chance in hell against Christina, She's the voice of her generation No Diva can take her on not Carrie, Beyonce, Mariah, Kelly Clarkson, or Amy Lee!!!!!
soaprivera 1 year ago 2
@soaprivera Hi, sorry, but I have to disagree with you about Mariah, not being as good as Christina. I do agree, however, that Christina, is the only one who could come close to mariah. I really don't care for Beyonce and Kelly Clarkson is good, bu, NOT as good as Mariah or Christina.
m5e8n9h 1 year ago
@m5e8n9h Well I do admit Mariah is very good and I love her Just as much as I Love Christina and I'd Love to hear those two do a duet that would be amazing!! :)
soaprivera 1 year ago
Comment removed
m5e8n9h 1 year ago
@soaprivera I totally agree! I also meant to say that, I think Carrie, is one of the best country singers today. I honestly think she would have been ok, in the pop music department also. Her voice is proof, that regardless, of her winning on American Idol, she would have had a contract anyway.
m5e8n9h 1 year ago
@soaprivera Christina is just full of antics that don't add to her voice. Christina is good but Carrie is the better singer. Carrie knows how to sing while Christina performs. Also Christina is loosing her voice and over emoting to compensate. The over emoting by Christina is tiring.
robinannhunt 1 year ago 3
@robinannhunt I totally agree about christina's voice. Carrie will stand the test of time and in my opinion the best singer we have today in any genra
carrie1fan123 1 year ago 2
@robinannhunt You obviously don't know what vocal talent is if u think Carrie beats out Christina. Saying Carrie is a better sing then Christina is jus like saying Leona Lewis sings better then Whitney Houston. Christina"s vocals have been praised by vocal legends like Whitney and Celine Dion what other artist known for there vocals have said the same about Carrie, oh wait NONE! Carrie maybe good but her succes and voice dont even come near to being compared to Christina so don't even!
soaprivera 1 year ago
@soaprivera Still in your little la la world. Christina ruined the NA at the superbowl by doing those riffs to cover her aging voice and missed words. That must have been embarrasing for you and Christina. I wish Christina would just sing a song. Maybe she is still pretty good. And leona probably is better than Whitnew these days. I don't really follow leona.
robinannhunt 1 year ago
@soaprivera Carrie sings much better than Christina and you can actually understand what she is singing and you don't need constant runs to disuise the lack of other areas
carrie1fan123 1 year ago
@carrie1fan123 You obviously don't know what vocal talent is if u think Carrie beats out Christina. Saying Carrie is a better sing then Christina is jus like saying Leona Lewis sings better then Whitney Houston. Christina"s vocals have been praised by vocal legends like Whitney and Celine Dion what other artist known for there vocals have said the same about Carrie, oh wait NONE! Carrie maybe good but her succes and voice dont even come near to being compared to Christina so don't even!
soaprivera 1 year ago
Who the heck do you think is better? It's obvious it's Christina Aguilera!
EpicFailPersin 1 year ago
Carrie is better! she improved much from idol.Xtina is overrated
num1carrieufan 1 year ago
Carrie Underwood!!!! She is so amazing!! I saw her Live and her voice is perfect! She sang ''I know you won't'' with those great notes and it was crazy!!! I really thing she is better then Christina!
P.S. I hate when Christina aguilera do '' ya ya ya ya ya ya ........! '' when she do a high note.. it looks really weird!!!
misscote8088 1 year ago 3
These are like two of my favourite female vocalists but, is it wise to compare them?
h0neycrisp 1 year ago 2
CHRISTINA!! Because she has those deep tones!
unchato 1 year ago
CArrie's voice sounds more natural .
They have a wayy difeerent type of music.
I personnally like Carrie better <3<3 =D
myriam205426 1 year ago 2
I can RUUUUN to...!!! Xtina's F5 is AMAZING, I love it. She's better than Carrie.
Paburo14 1 year ago
Year year Carrie is better - IN YOUR SWEETEST DREAMS KIDS!!! Christina has better voice than W.Houston and M.Carey and you compare her to such NO TALENTS like Carrie Underwood? There is something wrong with this world.
ViolaXZ 1 year ago
@ViolaXZ
Whitney Houston and Mariah Carey suck.
lizzyvance 1 year ago
@ViolaXZ cuz im sure u have more talent then her at singing...
ejhmed 1 year ago
I think that Carrie Underwood's vocals sound much smoother!
avataranime101 1 year ago
christina is the best who is the other bitch
luisitolima 1 year ago
haha, bitch? wow you're ignorant. she's only the most successful American idol to date.
2012chriswill 1 year ago
sorry bitch. bt i think the most succesful till now is KELLY CLARKSON.. actually she got at least a hit.. well some.. but christina is on other level..
no one knows carie what?
luisitolima 1 year ago
@luisitolima um...ur stupid...stop talking because if u check record sales carrie has sold more albums in a shorter career than kelly has in her career which is at least 3 years longer.
ejhmed 1 year ago 2
Carrie most definately. She sounds like a natural powerhouse with that voice of hers
QuassDebonair 1 year ago 2
Christina is a pathetic excuse of a singer. her voice is almost as irritating as Taylor Swift's voice. Carrie is a way better singer than most singers out there. Christina just screams..
MrJrball91 2 years ago
yup she starts using whistle something carrie cant do
XtinaCUMSLindaPerry 2 years ago
no, she starts screaming, even in this video xtinas E5 sounds like she's been hit by a bullet
samgt500 2 years ago 2
Carrie has a great voice and I love her, but Chritina has the most incredible voice of the world, and she shows it in every song in every time she sings
Both rock
Maryland765 2 years ago
why didn't you add the F#5 from both singers? like carrie with "alone" and xtina's squeaks from lady marmalade?
agators212 2 years ago 2
Carrie Underwood, Christina has a great voice but I think I prefer Carrie overall. Sometimes Christina tries too hard and ends up failing to hit those long notes whereas Carrie hits them effortlessly no matter what the occasion or the song for that matter. Plus Christina has had crappy songs lately...CARRIE - has the ability to belt and still bring tears to your eyes!
Myra1991JR 2 years ago
christina is such a screamer it's so irritating.. carrie underwood has a much better voice.. christina tries too hard..
Katie19711 2 years ago
I love both but Carrie. She can just belt and sound amazing. Christina does to many runs and she ends up sounding like she is trying too hard. Love them both.
lizzyvance 2 years ago
Carrie all the way
4793Jesus61406 2 years ago
carrie!
jesusfreak321123 2 years ago
Christina Aguilera cuz she hold them lond=ger than carrie ut love them both
bertin24ruiz 2 years ago
carrie has a much better voice. christina using the same bumpy voice thruout all her songs, its rather annoying
Jessieab1 2 years ago
ok with them... i would have to go with christina.... their both awsome but christinas voice is just more unique...
SeskiBaby09 2 years ago
i like both of them, but theres just something about carrie that i like a little better. idk wat it is. theres something about christina that just seems show-offy.
BrickByBoringBrick7 2 years ago 2
Christina.
atrayu90602 2 years ago
Carrie's got it, but I think Christina has a little more power in her voice.
RaulQuintanilla 2 years ago
theres only one way to really compare them other than have clips of each have them perform together. but regardless with the clips x-tinas better hits higher notes than carrie and has a more powerful voice. watch?v=4cwAtkSLGy4&NR=1. shes also versatile which carrie isn't, christinas already christina, carrie is who? again.? Boring no comparison
1model4life 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I like Christina and Carrie but I think Carrie is better. She just sounds so natural when she does her notes like she is not even trying. Carries voice amazes me to. Dont get me wrong xtina has a great voice when she is not doing those riffs. Carrie for some reason is one of the few artists who voices do amaze me.
lizzyvance 2 years ago
I like Christina and Carrie but I think Carrie is better. She just sounds so natural when she does her notes like she is not even trying. Carries voice amazes me to. Dont get me wrong xtina has a great voice when she is not doing those riffs. Carrie for some reason is one of the few artists who voices do amaze me.
lizzyvance 2 years ago
slutty christina does the same voice over again tho when she goes high and carrie does different high volcals when she sings.
Jessieab1 2 years ago
Well, Carrie always. Christina got her boobs done and is just slutty. Carrie is real!
Jessieab1 2 years ago
i didn't know boobs had anything to do with how good you sound
kanaeri 2 years ago
they do. if you want to sing and show boobs, just be a stripper and not a singer
Jessieab1 2 years ago
tell that to hmm well almost all the lady singers out there
kanaeri 2 years ago
They'll learn for themselves one day.
Jessieab1 2 years ago
Carrie ;)
Ingridth 2 years ago 2
I love both Christian and Carrie, but i'm gonna have to go with Carrie.
TheAbbyandMaddyshow 2 years ago 2
Christina. period.
evagabor2005 2 years ago 2
Carrie by far.
MichaelWard555 2 years ago
LOL, they used Carrie's worst clips here, but she still wins because Christina sounds SO strained on notes above E5.
mellynumerounoo 2 years ago 2
I agree with what one another poster said..the clips are honestly of substantially different levels of quality, but people will still have their opinions and that's good. At the end of the day though it's not about winning or losing but what kind of person you are and they both seem great and they both bring high amounts of energy and flair to every song they sing!
twostep2009 2 years ago
Christina WINS
SandyShooter 2 years ago
christina wins
litebluu 2 years ago
CHRISTINA OFCOURSE!
melanieee078 2 years ago
SORRY BUT CHRISTINA WINS!!!
steinbeck19 2 years ago
Sorry, but no.
mellynumerounoo 2 years ago
Christina has always been a favorite of mine. Carrie has a good voice but Christina is the best IMO.
Sam7svu 2 years ago
i love them both, too different and two different generes, i think christina could over do it some times though
nikkidabest812 2 years ago
carrie is the best cuz half the time christina is lipping !
48412J 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
christina aguilera does notes that i'v never heard before and she is one of the most successful singers of all time. shes such an inspiration. although she does oversing at times she is still my #1 singer and i think she is the best at singing
dawin41215 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Carrie went flat on some it was wrong.
latinheat801 2 years ago
I love both. If I have to pick one im going with Carrie. .
lizzyvance 2 years ago 2
Carrie hands down
CarrieUnderwoodful 2 years ago 2
why is this voted down 7 times? its just proving how talented xtina is.
XTINA FOREVER
Jessikia527 2 years ago
Xtina fans are voting my down. That really proves nothing.
lizzyvance 2 years ago
lol nice job using carrie's worst notes and christina's best. but carrie still makes belting high notes sound twice as christina does. and she can go higher in chest voice.
calixlatino 2 years ago 2
Christina for sure!
taffycool 2 years ago
ist unfair to compare Christina to anyone!!! she is the best hands down. Carrie is also a great singer however in a diff. style.
delreynian 2 years ago
There's no comparison.
ThatsWhereItIs 2 years ago
lmao. bitch u are stupid. Christina has to shit a brick to belt an E5, Carrie belts to G5 and not those head voice G5s christina does
NoseyFreak 2 years ago 2
xtina her E5 and above are crap lmao
damskooo 2 years ago
Loving all the Christina stans here! lol
mattmoll6690 2 years ago
christina her E5 are horrible and strained lmao
damskooo 2 years ago 2
Carrie Underwood
thebestofY0UTUBE 2 years ago
carrie, only because i like her music better
fruitx4yay 2 years ago
I love Carrie and her voice is just amazing, but Christina has a fricken fabulous voice its just incrediable the notes she can hit. Christina is the shit over Briney or Jessica and I have always thought that.
gfo69 2 years ago 2
At first christina sounds better but after a while the way she sings annoys a lot.Carrie is never annoying
albr0330 2 years ago 2
Christina
carolinagirl009 2 years ago 2
carrrrrrrrrrrrrrie !!
VelmaX3 2 years ago
Carrie Underwood!!! :D
cardude527 2 years ago
carries good but christinas better
christinaaaax3 2 years ago
They're both great but Christina puts a smile or something like that in my face when i watch her hit high notes
So, I go for Christina
Daegon3000 2 years ago 2
xtina
lovegxx 2 years ago
Carrie!!!
CodePink85 2 years ago
CHRISTINA AGUILERA!!!!
candy1806 2 years ago
They both suck shitty ass,
but I prefure Carrie. But they're both shit
fhfuhifr 2 years ago 2
are you guys serious? christina aguilera has a much louder and way more powerfull voice than carrie underwood! i cant believe people are trying to compare them c'mon!
mary3434alv 2 years ago