...this is good, but a few things.... mark's mom is jewish... and wearing a christmas vest. my high school is putting this on as well, and honestly a lot of the singing in this is more screaming to a tune in parts/ talking.... not real broadway voices. it is good, mark and roger sound good, but it is not the bets version in the world.
im not saying they don't have talent, i was just pointing out the christmas vest thing, because it's one of those little things that might irk some (like me, im jewish loll) i didn't mean to sound so judgemental i swear! x) im in high school theater and we did this, i was just kinda mentioning some stuff. believe me, we had our faults too lol.
@bens2good i didn't see it, our quality showed up bad on video as well, im sure it was a good show though here! wish i had seen it, i've only been in our version and seen the broadway on youtube. i hate when the sounds get messed up.
@manoflamancha99 You have to be there to be blown away, because you obviously haven't seen our plays yourself. We send shock waves of suprise through every bay area school every year because of how our plays go so well. >:D
While I can appreciate the director's audacity in doing this show, it just loses most of its muster when done in an edited format. Also, I agree that it is a bit lackluster. Other than that, solid work.
And one more thing, Mark isn't really supposed to have a rock voice. He's a geeky AV club nerd, he's not gonna be joining any Guns and Roses tribute bands. I think that he did a really good job with his part.
I dont want to get in the middle of this death match here, but I saw this and felt that I had to speak up.
This is a high school production of a Broadway show, and you have to take that into account. The people who played these parts on Broadway are actors and rockers in their late 20's early 30's, so of course it isn't going to be as good. But if it not being as good as a Broadway performance doesn't convey the message to your liking then I would suggest you not see anymore school productions
It's not me you're really offending. It's the cast of the show. You know the guy who said that you should be Mark instead? Yeah...he was Mark in this vid. Matthew Strasser, great singer, great guy. I don't think, I KNOW that this show was amazing. I was there.
I am very sorry for offending the actors. That wqas not cool of me, but saying things like "go fuck yourself" doesn't make you any better. Its disappointing when productions of Rent aren't conveying the message tp people who are seeing Rent for the first time. Its supposed to be a life changing show so I have very high standerds for people who put on this show.
I'm really sorry if I offended you. You are very talented, I'm just very particular about who performs in Rent since its such an amazing show and I'm so used to hearing the Broaday people I got carried away. Its not that am not happy with the actors, its that Rent has been given to high schools who won't do the same job as the professionals at conveying the message. I am very sorry for insulting you. You are very talented.
This made me feel so uncomfortable. People can't act and it sounds like 90% of what's sung isn't in the people's ranges! I always thought it was wierd for a high school to do Rent anyway, but this reinforces it... And you have such a huge cast!! You could do so many other good shows.
So do I... Devan Johnston is a good friend of mine, and she was in this!! I can't believe I missed it!! And plus Matthew is a good friend of my boyfriend.. =\ I should have been there to support them!!
I'm not a student at EHS, but I do partake in their productions (Not this one, obviously.). This is a special "School edition" of RENT, which edits out the some of the heavier cussing and sex scenes. It was phenomenal, though.
Lol, that's weird. St. Mary's College Prep High School (A catholic school I applied to but didn't get into.) is doing Grease. I went to Catholic Elementary and Middle school and I hated it. Public School is hella better. Plus, it's cooler.
...this is good, but a few things.... mark's mom is jewish... and wearing a christmas vest. my high school is putting this on as well, and honestly a lot of the singing in this is more screaming to a tune in parts/ talking.... not real broadway voices. it is good, mark and roger sound good, but it is not the bets version in the world.
xodreamchicxo101 1 year ago
@xodreamchicxo101 yeah its a shame this high school wasn't able to put on the best version in the world..... quit being such a critic
bens2good 8 months ago
@bens2good
im not saying they don't have talent, i was just pointing out the christmas vest thing, because it's one of those little things that might irk some (like me, im jewish loll) i didn't mean to sound so judgemental i swear! x) im in high school theater and we did this, i was just kinda mentioning some stuff. believe me, we had our faults too lol.
xodreamchicxo101 8 months ago
@bens2good i didn't see it, our quality showed up bad on video as well, im sure it was a good show though here! wish i had seen it, i've only been in our version and seen the broadway on youtube. i hate when the sounds get messed up.
xodreamchicxo101 8 months ago
OMGOMG HOLY THAT WAS AMAAAZZINNGGG OMGOMOGMOGMOGMOM MARK GEEEEZZZZ I WISH I COULDA BEEN THRE T_T
aznmelodiii 1 year ago
lol... benny! noo... Great! crap...
igkad 1 year ago
okay i kinda thought so becuase there is absolutely no way you could have gotten away with the real version lol
dorkgirl94 1 year ago
u guys did the actualy version? not the school version? thats impressive and controversial wow
dorkgirl94 1 year ago
@dorkgirl94 No this was the school version, I just didn't put that in the title lol.
mikokat 1 year ago
Mark=Amazing. Rest of cast=Good.
However, Benny made me want to hurt things.
jewbowl225 2 years ago
good job "mark"!
defyinggravity0705 2 years ago
im sorry but this is really not very good. tons of off pitch moments and just kind of awkward much of the time.
manoflamancha99 2 years ago
@manoflamancha99 You have to be there to be blown away, because you obviously haven't seen our plays yourself. We send shock waves of suprise through every bay area school every year because of how our plays go so well. >:D
RaineyX949 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
When Roger sings, "Well the notes are sour, where is the power, we once had to ignight the air" ... he takes like 3 breaths. It should be only one...
greendaybryce 2 years ago
There is such thing as doing songs a little different. Its called bringing your own take to it. Its acceptable in theatre.
NinjaPuma9408 2 years ago
Yeah, there is such a thing as bringing your own take to it, but taking breaths in different places is an insult to the composer.
greendaybryce 2 years ago
vocals are really good...especially Mark!
pianochick93 2 years ago
Yeah, Matthew Strasser is an amazing singer! He has some other cool stuff on his YouTube channel, just search MatthewStrasser.
mikokat 2 years ago
While I can appreciate the director's audacity in doing this show, it just loses most of its muster when done in an edited format. Also, I agree that it is a bit lackluster. Other than that, solid work.
kalebfutch 2 years ago
I wish our school could do Rent.
unfabulous386 2 years ago
marks microphone needed to be turned down when eveyone sang
TaylorswiftWannabe 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this sucks, im doing rent right now and this really sucks
iamchuck16 2 years ago
I disagree.
mikokat 2 years ago
We did RENT too, check out the clips on my page.
italiano1346 2 years ago
Wow, you guys did a great job!
mikokat 2 years ago
lots of talent here. Great job to the entire cast!
musicrules91 2 years ago 8
I agree 100%.
mikokat 2 years ago
There is no passion here... no spark.
madonnashomeboy 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
eh....
9stinky9 2 years ago
And one more thing, Mark isn't really supposed to have a rock voice. He's a geeky AV club nerd, he's not gonna be joining any Guns and Roses tribute bands. I think that he did a really good job with his part.
MuchoBoho 2 years ago 4
Thank you, kind sir.
mikokat 2 years ago
I dont want to get in the middle of this death match here, but I saw this and felt that I had to speak up.
This is a high school production of a Broadway show, and you have to take that into account. The people who played these parts on Broadway are actors and rockers in their late 20's early 30's, so of course it isn't going to be as good. But if it not being as good as a Broadway performance doesn't convey the message to your liking then I would suggest you not see anymore school productions
MuchoBoho 2 years ago
It's not me you're really offending. It's the cast of the show. You know the guy who said that you should be Mark instead? Yeah...he was Mark in this vid. Matthew Strasser, great singer, great guy. I don't think, I KNOW that this show was amazing. I was there.
mikokat 2 years ago
I am very sorry for offending the actors. That wqas not cool of me, but saying things like "go fuck yourself" doesn't make you any better. Its disappointing when productions of Rent aren't conveying the message tp people who are seeing Rent for the first time. Its supposed to be a life changing show so I have very high standerds for people who put on this show.
bwaybaby333 2 years ago
I was there, and it conveyed the message quite well to me.
mikokat 2 years ago
bwaybaby333, i think ur right, i think you should have done it instead
matthewstrasser 2 years ago
I'm really sorry if I offended you. You are very talented, I'm just very particular about who performs in Rent since its such an amazing show and I'm so used to hearing the Broaday people I got carried away. Its not that am not happy with the actors, its that Rent has been given to high schools who won't do the same job as the professionals at conveying the message. I am very sorry for insulting you. You are very talented.
bwaybaby333 2 years ago
i think so too
bwaybaby333 2 years ago
the Mark's singing is not rock enough for rent. he sounded constipated. the ms.cohen was just terrible. Collins can sing amazing, but can't act.
bwaybaby333 2 years ago
EXACTLY!
greendaybryce 2 years ago
This made me feel so uncomfortable. People can't act and it sounds like 90% of what's sung isn't in the people's ranges! I always thought it was wierd for a high school to do Rent anyway, but this reinforces it... And you have such a huge cast!! You could do so many other good shows.
dramanrc 2 years ago
WTF? Are you high? Encinal did a fucking GREAT JOB with this show. You only saw a small clip of the show, I saw the full show, and it was AMAZING.
mikokat 2 years ago
well, i watched your acting too... and you don't know much either.
dramanrc 2 years ago
Well, I'm still a student and I'm learning.
mikokat 2 years ago
Already posted! Check my channel!
mikokat 2 years ago
Wow, Strasser kicked ass in this. He did a great job. ^ ^ I wish I had money to go to Rent. =/
TheXemnas 2 years ago
So do I... Devan Johnston is a good friend of mine, and she was in this!! I can't believe I missed it!! And plus Matthew is a good friend of my boyfriend.. =\ I should have been there to support them!!
iTracyNL 2 years ago
that was a very loud beep WHAT ?!?!?! i never heard a beep
jesusfreak34988 2 years ago
Maybe the beep was loud to get because she was on the phone, but we can't hear it?
mikokat 2 years ago
I wish my school would do this! :(
TheQuestionBoy4 3 years ago
this gave me goosebumps =)
I miss you all!
curtainfevaaa 3 years ago
ah I'm so jealous!
my school would never let us do RENT =[
You guys are pretty awesome
katiewasherexoo 3 years ago 4
I'm not a student at EHS, but I do partake in their productions (Not this one, obviously.). This is a special "School edition" of RENT, which edits out the some of the heavier cussing and sex scenes. It was phenomenal, though.
mikokat 3 years ago
oh yeah, I've heard about that, but I go to a catholic school and apparently Grease is too sexual for us lol
katiewasherexoo 3 years ago
Lol, that's weird. St. Mary's College Prep High School (A catholic school I applied to but didn't get into.) is doing Grease. I went to Catholic Elementary and Middle school and I hated it. Public School is hella better. Plus, it's cooler.
mikokat 3 years ago
nice vid miko
morri908 3 years ago