@sitakishida - Thank you. They only pit one woman against another just to bring on the negative comments about one or the other. Black women need to realize when one of us shines, it lifts all of us. If nothing else, it lifts my spirits to see these black women doing their hustle, perfecting their craft, taking chances, following their dreams. Jen and Beyonce carry themselves v well. How can u not cheer for both of them. THEY ARE BOTH GREAT.
ugh ok ur turn you need too stop trying to tear others down your very sensitive my comment was directed towards someone else not you u need to learn to read cuz i said i like jenni and i really didnt say anything bad about her loosin weight is good and gainin wait can be to if u get offended by every lil comment that someone says youtube is not going to be any fun for you or anybody its a comment get over it move on and enjoy youtube ma'am/sir dang
Didn't she fire mathew knowles 2 be honest everybody knows heaverier set ppl get loud jenni is loud I like her but beyonce is better at singing....lmao trust b ain't have no damn surgery jenni on the otha hand lost hella weight and no has a big head wit a lil body idnt think she even sings anymore
@abeno18 - What is your problem with Jennifer? She dis, she dat...lost weight/big head/lil' body. You act like you made a pass at her in the mall and she said, "no thanks". Get over it! She's an amazing singer and actress and Beyonce's an exceptional entertainer too. Good for both of them!
@abeno18 - This is my wish for you: For the next year starting today everybody that comes in contact with you tells you EXACTLY how they feel about your looks, personality, and critique you without regard to your feelings. Everytime some one tells you 'like it is' about YOU, think about my wish for you and see how you feel about their bluntness. You'll be just fine, I'm sure 'cause you'll think back to how you were just keeping it real about Jennifer and just smile at your critics.
@abeno18 - This is my wish for you: For the next year starting today everybody that comes in contact with you tells you EXACTLY how they feel about your looks, personality, and critique you without regard to your feelings. Everytime some one tells you 'like it is' about YOU, think about my wish for you and see how you feel about their bluntness. You'll be just fine, I'm sure 'cause you'll think back to how you were just keeping it real about Jennifer and just smile at your critics.
@abeno18 - This is my wish for you: For the next year starting today everybody that comes in contact with you tells you EXACTLY how they feel about your looks, personality, and critique you without regard to your feelings. Everytime some one tells you 'like it is' about YOU, think about my wish for you and see how you feel about their bluntness. You'll be just fine, I'm sure 'cause you'll think back to how you were just keeping it real about Jennifer and just smile at your critics.
@RomDiddi lol well my wish to you is that you find happiness and you live a prosperous life because you need lol lol u dnt know me i dnt know you lol there are so many different ways to handle situations than to wish bad or someone I like jenni bigger anyway but have a good day sir/ma'am
@abeno18 - Thank you for wishing me happiness. I'm wishing you happiness too in the midst of your critics. Why would you think I'm wishing you bad? I'm just wishing you the same level of scrutiny that you so easily bestow upon Jennifer with the stroke of your keyboard. I know you weren't wishing "bad" on Jennifer Hudson. Like you said, "it is what it is". And I'm sure you'll understand that the next time somebody decides to complete an inspection report on YOU. LOL!
@RomDiddi well atleat we got that striaghtened out glad you i wasnt saying anything horrible just my opinion thank you glad i met u and u are right quote "it is what it is" lol
@abeno18 - Let me be your first critic for today --- 'you're a negative person that should be rooting for Jennifer (someone who has not done anything to you) instead of trying to tear her down'. I mean I'm just 'keeping it real' and o'yeah, 'It is what it is...' LOL! Enjoy your weekend but if you leave the house today you betta have every hair in place, no chipped fingernail polish, a slammin' outfit, and a smile on your face 'cause critics are waiting......
@RomDiddi ugh ok ur turn you need too stop trying to tear others down your very sensitive my comment was directed towards someone else not you u need to learn to read cuz i said i like jenni and i really didnt say anything bad about her loosin weight is good and gainin wait can be to if u get offended by every lil comment that someone says youtube is not going to be any fun for you or anybody its a comment get over it move on and enjoy youtube ma'am/sir dang
@RomDiddi And there are alot of comments abou jennit that are worser than mine why pick me out the bunch im confused on that lol acting like u a fortune cookie get out of here im done so go head get your last comment in cuz wen i get notified this time im not readin it and im not responding back if i I said anything that hit a nerve about jenni i apopogize by how u acting you could be her like i sad learn from this stop gettin offendin and have fun dueces
@abeno18 - I doubt Jen has time to even view YTube much less respond to ppl who make neg comments about her anatomy. U think 'cause you're behind a computer u can display ur mean-spirited twin. Funny bet u wouldn't make blunt comments to her face - like I wish others will do for u just for a year. U appear v. young which means u have time to grow and wisen up. U need to learn from this - if u don't have something positive to say, keep ur mouth closed or in this case, toss ur keyboard.
@abeno18 -I know enuf about you to know you probably come across as a 'nice person' around other people but have a mean-spirited twin that Y'Tube gives you a chance to unleash behind closed door. In other words, phony/cowardly. Of course I DO NOT wish people are unkind and blunt to you I just wanted you to get that uncomfortable feeling that you did when put in a negative spotlight. Jennifer lost 3 important members of her family and i bet ya thought your neg comments were appropriate.
wow, they both have amazing voices but they defiantly shouldn't be singing together! Sounds like they're just trying to out due each other cause they both have strong vocals buy I love them both :). & I hate how Jennifer lost so much weight compared to this video ugh :( she was so curvy and sexy!
Beyonce yessssss! her voice is just so perfect! Jennifer can sing but she over does it to.me by trying to put to much power into it! Just because she is louder then Beyonce dosent mean she sings better! a bear can roar but that dosent mean the roar sounds pleasent
I believe that Jenny and Bee both are talented. The difference is that Jenny sings from the heart. Most of the time I can tell it is just part of a show for Bee. I remember her from the beginning when she was only 15 starting out with Destiny's Child; she's had vocal coaching to fine tune her voice. The singer in her group was Kelly Rowland; Beyonce was not much of a singer, but a performer. Jenny however was born to sing;each sound coming out of her has power of the heart making her better.
@nw31705 wow u delusional B was always the SINGER and Front leader there are even videos on youtube where she is coaching the girls Vocaly so dont do it and kelly said even once My voice is like: lalalaaa (smal9 and B was always like LAAAAAAAALWLWALALALWAAW !
B had a great tone and amazing naturel vibrato
B was bron to sing to Jennifer is doing churc h belting screamig B uses proer technique and can do melisma etc sing songs Jenn couldnt even dream about
@nw31705 Thank you--Someone expressing the facts about Beyonce's voice. She is OVERRATED as a singer. Even with all the vocal lessons Beyonce' has had she still sings flat and off key a bit; especially when covering other people's hit songs. Jennifer Hudson's voice has more flexibilty & POWER. Beyonce' "sells sex," had plastic surgery' & uses vocal tricks including lip syching to enhance her voice & her appeal to the public--including heavy promotion from her father, Matthew Knowles & Jay-Z.
enjoys both vocals here and they each have their own style and grace! JHud is the best! Bey handles her business, both young gifted and talented women who have so much to live for! Always a blessing!
regardless of what anyone says... jennifer is a strong singer but Bey wasnt drowned out by her at all.. which shows Beyonce can hold her own...some other singers wouldnt have been able to sing next to jenn
@Love10177 Cute voice and she can sing LISTEN etc and outsing Screamiffer when she cam out and overpowerd her with that F5 and she was sick and she doesnt need to show of pluheees
I remember this performance, and I remember thinking they did not have chemistry together. It seemed like they were sort of competing with each other. At least that was my perception.
@slayer3to10 see where i come from "screamin" means killin, banged, murdered.. in that nature.. to put it in your terms she did better than jennifer in my opinion.
PRESS CHANNEL TO GET EXCLUSIVE FOR WHITNEY HOUSTON TO TONI AND TAMAR BRAXTON... GET INFO ON BEYOUNCE AND WHY SHE HOLD S THE TITLE OF DIVA....WHAT ABOUT JENNIFER ...? PRESS CHANNEL TO GET A CLUE..
@leilani1977 Exactlyyyyy thank you! I hate how everyone is like "Jen showed her up/stole the show!!1" etc. In the actual musical it was the role of Effie which got the most acclaim and is supposed to be the most emotionally stirring role, period. I think a lot of people just want to be able to say that Beyonce was shown up, just 'cuz.
Yes Jennifer can sing, but her voice isnt ALL THAT!!! Its just loud, and she can hit high notes! But her phrasing, runs, riffs, and vibrato isnt up to par! Beyonce's voice is sooo damn versatile, she can sing anything and make it sound beautiful, Jen cant! But I loved this performance!
beyonce is a great singer but people say Jennifer is better not to be hatin on b but cuz Jennifer actually does have a higher power her vocie is stronger then b's but b is a high alto border line soprano but power wise she does not have it. in dreamgirls when i forget his name said something about her voice that's true in real life dont get me wrong beyonce has power to her voice but not Jennifer Hudson power
irather listen to beyonce more then jenn , i feel like jen voice is too high & like madd soul while beys voice is more soothing & calm to listen too . jen has more of a church voice tht is hard to be toned down when Bey has a voice that could go to a high range & a low one, but dont get me wrong . anyone would be BLESSED to have a voice like either of theres . theyre both awesome
I think Hudson power is easy and natural but Beyonce got to strain to get the power that Jennifer got natural....Beyonce got to strain, Jennifer is natural...so that just my thought....besides Huson is 5 Octives
@brownstone65 And Maria Callas had 3 octaves, and between the three,who do you think sings with the most powerful voice?? Vocal range isn't everything. In here, Beyoncé sings with more resonance and a lot more power.
@hrick92 I am sorry I disagree, Jennifer has power she do not strain to use its natural, beyonce always strain in order to keep up with Jennifer even in the movie dream girls when beyonce was singing to Jamie Fox, "Listen" you can look and see her vains popping out her neck she was straining so hard to out do Jeniffer.
@brownstone65 I'm sorry, but these is your arguments? You said 5 times the same thing. What you disagree?
Ok,maybe "I get it":when Jennifer is natural in screaming, Beyoncé "strains" to sing. And the result: just listen. It's clearly Beyoncé hit that note with more technique, resonance...
@brownstone65 Clearly Jennifer sings effortlessly while Beyonce' has to strain and do convulsions, and "vocal gymnastics" in order to produce power in her voice and she still does not have the range and pure sound of Jennifer Hudson.
I just recently discovered SELENA / I would rather look at and listen to SELENA anyday ! All these fake and untalented ass new females who want to be called "DIVAS" so bad can't touch SELENA WITH A 10 ft pole I'm a proud African American Black Man AND I LOVE SELENA !! She was more naturally talented / more naturally sexy / and more naturally BEAUTIFUL inside and out as a woman and a person / and that goes for J LO TOO! / you may have imitated her in a film / BUT YOU CAN'T TOUCH " THE REAL DEAL
Chill. I mean that's what she said in the interview before this performance she said something to the effect of "I'm not feeling well I have some sort of cold, but I didn't wanna give this up so I'ma just hope I don't mess up!" It just so happens I watch the Oscars and Grammys every year... and do you mean "fan"? It wasn't an excuse for her, it was a reason AGAINST her, I said it's possible she only wasn't oversinging because she was sick. As in, if she were well, she would've been annoying.
I would love for black artist to stop trying to out sing each other. Thats my thing, personally to me beyonce is always trying to out sing someone. It annoys me. Not that she can out sing Jennifer, but its still annoying. Just work together and have fun damn
@rosarah9 Black artists? Have you HEARD Christina Aguilera try to sing with other people? They always have to turn her mic down because she insists upon snarling at the top of her lungs to drown out anyone else.
Plus, I'm not saying always, but in this particular performance Anika and Jennifer were the ones oversinging, Beyonce was kinda just chillin (but she was sick so she mighta been scared to mess up).
@VocalPowa Yes i said BLACK ARTIST, Im sure there are other artist who do the same thing, but in this situation im only focused on my own race. And YES...that is my issue with her and other black artist who do it, I don't like her anyhow but that is annoying. And she was SICK? You must be a stan who tries to make excuses for her. Because you talked to her and she told you she was sick right?
@rosarah9 bey was looking over smiling at her , saying you singg it girl in the background trying to give her support. to me they both had team work . of course theyre gonna put some soul into their singing , its not trying to outsing one another .
Why is everyone so obsessed with who's "Better"? If you like it, great, if you don't, click on something else. Why everyone feels they must be Simon Cowell now is beyond me.
When does powerful or louder equate to better? I like the chord Beyonce set up at the chorus. She actually made that chord darker and fuller or how most people say "soulful". Just saying louder ain't always better, musicality is more than a powerhouse voice. These singers have very different voices and it's sad we can think less of a voice that is not the most stereotypical "black".
• • ENOUGH IS ENOUGH..PEOPLE PLEASE; I JUST DONT UNDERSTAND WHY WE HAVE TO BAIT EVERY SINGLE BLACK ARTISTS AGAINST ONE ANOTHER..WE DONT NEED TO DO THAT, WHITE PEOPLE R ALREADY DOING THAT SHIT BY CLOSING DOORS ON THEIR FACES & IGNORING THEIR MUSIC..WAT THEY NEED IS OUR SUPPORT, BUT PEOPLE KEEP REFUSING THEM THAT.WE ALL WILL WATCH SOON AS ARTIST'S LIKE CIARA, KERI HIL, KELLY ROW,JEN HUD, TIEARR M, & OTHER TALENTED BLACK ARTISTS MUSIC CAREER DIES A SLOW DEATH...IT’S ALREADY HAPPININ NOW..
b voice is wayy more pleasent than jenns they both can sing their asses off but b has the better voice in my opinion she owned jen in listen and her entrance on love yu i do and was flawless in listen liked her singing it much better!
@AJtheamazing1 i totally agree i could not help myself i laugh my ass off @ your comment Jennifer has a way more POWERFUL voice than B, Jen voice is ABSOLUTELY with out a doubt a POWERHOUSE she was totally drowning out B and thats the i see it I LOVE YOUR COMMENT ......AJtheamazing1...
@ATLNice Yep jennifer's voice is powerful and very souful. But in the end technique wins as when beyonce came out and sang that F5 with jen, hers was more resonant and powerul, drainig out jenn's. But good performance from both. have a nice night:)
I love them both, but Beyonce has more power than Jennifer. Beyonce is much more resonant than Jen. Proof is at 1:33 where Bey beasted Jen on that F5. Competely drowned Jen out.
@SlowY00 she not full of herself she just singing the song like it was suppose 2 b sang like n the movie n jennifer hudson's voice its just naturally louder when she sings nyway she cant help it
Beyonce got boo boo'd on this performance Jennifer should have taken over listen because beyonce didn't do the song justice once Jennifer started singing it, and Jen didn't need help on her song
They both have powerful voices, both are vocal powerhouse.It's just that Beyonce is far more accomplished as vocalist, with the around vocal abilities(sufficient in all vocal elements). Jhud on the other is still very much a 1 dimensional singer, who still attacks every song and screams out every note, lacking the essential vocal element(vocal control) and still hasn't learned how to build a song.
@unbreakablekat smh all that shyt is so aggravatin its called soulful singin...u know singin from the heart not everybody wants all that vocal control bs i mean its nice n pretty but jennifer hudson sings from the heart beyonce is more trained either one is good so quit tryna compare so its not just screamin like u close minded people think
Beyonce notes actually overpowered (had more resonance) than Jennifer's several notes -- when they sang at the same time. Beyonce has a lot more power than people give credit for, just saying.
Loder is better...Jenn is NOTE A BETTEr VOCALIST Beyonce has a much helthier and a AMAZing technique she was sick that day she held back Jennifer is louder and her voice is heavier but she cant do the build in listen like beyonce vocaly ! and a lots more,,j hudson overdos it sometimes
See now det jennefer lost her weight, all she has to do is start dancin like beyonce n shell be her surperior cuz jennifer can blow, all she has to do is get sum gud choreography n she'll dominate beyonce
Beyonce was being respectful and allowing Jennifer to sing her song. I think Jennifer is a better vocalist than Beyonce, but Beyonce has better stage presence and is a better performer. Hands down both ladies are hella talented
beyonce.. she's showing modernity !
jadetanchannel 22 hours ago
Love you I do.
TheJayDiem 2 days ago
Comment removed
gorantrevise 1 week ago
Jennifer Hudson is better
ritamoii1 1 week ago
it's soooooooooooooo gooood but it's n-o-t listen..lol
sho123am 1 week ago
The video and audio are not correctly synced...
user190295 2 weeks ago
i just skipped straight to beyonce <3
Sammy30581 2 weeks ago 2
@Sammy30581 lol I did the same thing!
marlove86422 1 week ago
we automatically expect women to compete but two men can perform and this petty shit wouldn't happen. THEY ARE BOTH GREAT.
sitakishida 2 weeks ago 3
@sitakishida - Thank you. They only pit one woman against another just to bring on the negative comments about one or the other. Black women need to realize when one of us shines, it lifts all of us. If nothing else, it lifts my spirits to see these black women doing their hustle, perfecting their craft, taking chances, following their dreams. Jen and Beyonce carry themselves v well. How can u not cheer for both of them. THEY ARE BOTH GREAT.
RomDiddi 2 weeks ago
@RomDiddi Amen to that
KayCma 5 days ago
ugh ok ur turn you need too stop trying to tear others down your very sensitive my comment was directed towards someone else not you u need to learn to read cuz i said i like jenni and i really didnt say anything bad about her loosin weight is good and gainin wait can be to if u get offended by every lil comment that someone says youtube is not going to be any fun for you or anybody its a comment get over it move on and enjoy youtube ma'am/sir dang
abeno18 2 weeks ago
beyonce is a commercial artist jennifer hudson is much more reality
ciaralilbrojayj 3 weeks ago
@ciaralilbrojayj u a ciara stan u don know nothing go sit
beyonceboy100 1 week ago
beyonce can't do nothing with jennifer
ciaralilbrojayj 3 weeks ago
Burr
pprgtv 3 weeks ago
Beyonce can't do a thing with Jen! Go Jen!
MsTahray2001 3 weeks ago
Didn't she fire mathew knowles 2 be honest everybody knows heaverier set ppl get loud jenni is loud I like her but beyonce is better at singing....lmao trust b ain't have no damn surgery jenni on the otha hand lost hella weight and no has a big head wit a lil body idnt think she even sings anymore
abeno18 3 weeks ago
@abeno18 Mathew knowles stole money from her. that's why she fired him
slayer3to10 3 weeks ago
@slayer3to10 Awww see i learn something new everyday smh
abeno18 2 weeks ago
@abeno18 - What is your problem with Jennifer? She dis, she dat...lost weight/big head/lil' body. You act like you made a pass at her in the mall and she said, "no thanks". Get over it! She's an amazing singer and actress and Beyonce's an exceptional entertainer too. Good for both of them!
RomDiddi 2 weeks ago
@RomDiddi I mean did u get offended or sumtin???? All i said is what i felt eerybody knows jenni good but it is what it is
abeno18 2 weeks ago
@abeno18 - This is my wish for you: For the next year starting today everybody that comes in contact with you tells you EXACTLY how they feel about your looks, personality, and critique you without regard to your feelings. Everytime some one tells you 'like it is' about YOU, think about my wish for you and see how you feel about their bluntness. You'll be just fine, I'm sure 'cause you'll think back to how you were just keeping it real about Jennifer and just smile at your critics.
RomDiddi 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@abeno18 - This is my wish for you: For the next year starting today everybody that comes in contact with you tells you EXACTLY how they feel about your looks, personality, and critique you without regard to your feelings. Everytime some one tells you 'like it is' about YOU, think about my wish for you and see how you feel about their bluntness. You'll be just fine, I'm sure 'cause you'll think back to how you were just keeping it real about Jennifer and just smile at your critics.
RomDiddi 2 weeks ago
@abeno18 - This is my wish for you: For the next year starting today everybody that comes in contact with you tells you EXACTLY how they feel about your looks, personality, and critique you without regard to your feelings. Everytime some one tells you 'like it is' about YOU, think about my wish for you and see how you feel about their bluntness. You'll be just fine, I'm sure 'cause you'll think back to how you were just keeping it real about Jennifer and just smile at your critics.
RomDiddi 2 weeks ago
@RomDiddi lol well my wish to you is that you find happiness and you live a prosperous life because you need lol lol u dnt know me i dnt know you lol there are so many different ways to handle situations than to wish bad or someone I like jenni bigger anyway but have a good day sir/ma'am
abeno18 2 weeks ago
@abeno18 - Thank you for wishing me happiness. I'm wishing you happiness too in the midst of your critics. Why would you think I'm wishing you bad? I'm just wishing you the same level of scrutiny that you so easily bestow upon Jennifer with the stroke of your keyboard. I know you weren't wishing "bad" on Jennifer Hudson. Like you said, "it is what it is". And I'm sure you'll understand that the next time somebody decides to complete an inspection report on YOU. LOL!
RomDiddi 2 weeks ago
@RomDiddi well atleat we got that striaghtened out glad you i wasnt saying anything horrible just my opinion thank you glad i met u and u are right quote "it is what it is" lol
abeno18 2 weeks ago
@abeno18 - Let me be your first critic for today --- 'you're a negative person that should be rooting for Jennifer (someone who has not done anything to you) instead of trying to tear her down'. I mean I'm just 'keeping it real' and o'yeah, 'It is what it is...' LOL! Enjoy your weekend but if you leave the house today you betta have every hair in place, no chipped fingernail polish, a slammin' outfit, and a smile on your face 'cause critics are waiting......
RomDiddi 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@RomDiddi ugh ok ur turn you need too stop trying to tear others down your very sensitive my comment was directed towards someone else not you u need to learn to read cuz i said i like jenni and i really didnt say anything bad about her loosin weight is good and gainin wait can be to if u get offended by every lil comment that someone says youtube is not going to be any fun for you or anybody its a comment get over it move on and enjoy youtube ma'am/sir dang
abeno18 2 weeks ago
@RomDiddi And there are alot of comments abou jennit that are worser than mine why pick me out the bunch im confused on that lol acting like u a fortune cookie get out of here im done so go head get your last comment in cuz wen i get notified this time im not readin it and im not responding back if i I said anything that hit a nerve about jenni i apopogize by how u acting you could be her like i sad learn from this stop gettin offendin and have fun dueces
abeno18 2 weeks ago
@abeno18 - I doubt Jen has time to even view YTube much less respond to ppl who make neg comments about her anatomy. U think 'cause you're behind a computer u can display ur mean-spirited twin. Funny bet u wouldn't make blunt comments to her face - like I wish others will do for u just for a year. U appear v. young which means u have time to grow and wisen up. U need to learn from this - if u don't have something positive to say, keep ur mouth closed or in this case, toss ur keyboard.
RomDiddi 2 weeks ago
@RomDiddi Take yo own advice you dont know me and i dint know you if your way older than me act like it stop tryna be my fortune cookie
abeno18 2 weeks ago
@abeno18 -I know enuf about you to know you probably come across as a 'nice person' around other people but have a mean-spirited twin that Y'Tube gives you a chance to unleash behind closed door. In other words, phony/cowardly. Of course I DO NOT wish people are unkind and blunt to you I just wanted you to get that uncomfortable feeling that you did when put in a negative spotlight. Jennifer lost 3 important members of her family and i bet ya thought your neg comments were appropriate.
RomDiddi 2 weeks ago
wow, they both have amazing voices but they defiantly shouldn't be singing together! Sounds like they're just trying to out due each other cause they both have strong vocals buy I love them both :). & I hate how Jennifer lost so much weight compared to this video ugh :( she was so curvy and sexy!
kimeBaksh 3 weeks ago 2
Jennifer AALLLLL THE WAY. even beyonce herself knows that.
NoRegretsNot1 3 weeks ago
jeni trashed beyonce
sabrinalight 4 weeks ago
what is funny, is that jennifer's runs ins't in pitch, and she can't reach a e5 without straining.
just saying
drigao16 4 weeks ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
HI EVERYONE, PLEASE WATCH MY COVER OF ONE NIGHT ONLY ITS MY FIRST YOUTUBE VIDEO, IM JUS STARTING OUT - LET ME KNOW WHAT YOU THINK :) THANK YOU X
mialouise87 4 weeks ago
Do you hear the smoothness and control in beyonce voice......
MrDane1911 1 month ago
fuck,thhis is no listen
S9719526I 1 month ago
Jennifer beats Beyonce in this one!
mamz123 1 month ago
love beyonce...great voice
sijunynetto 1 month ago 2
Beyonce yessssss! her voice is just so perfect! Jennifer can sing but she over does it to.me by trying to put to much power into it! Just because she is louder then Beyonce dosent mean she sings better! a bear can roar but that dosent mean the roar sounds pleasent
hueyhughley 1 month ago
wow
creatingyourfate 1 month ago
I believe that Jenny and Bee both are talented. The difference is that Jenny sings from the heart. Most of the time I can tell it is just part of a show for Bee. I remember her from the beginning when she was only 15 starting out with Destiny's Child; she's had vocal coaching to fine tune her voice. The singer in her group was Kelly Rowland; Beyonce was not much of a singer, but a performer. Jenny however was born to sing;each sound coming out of her has power of the heart making her better.
nw31705 1 month ago
@nw31705 wow u delusional B was always the SINGER and Front leader there are even videos on youtube where she is coaching the girls Vocaly so dont do it and kelly said even once My voice is like: lalalaaa (smal9 and B was always like LAAAAAAAALWLWALALALWAAW !
B had a great tone and amazing naturel vibrato
B was bron to sing to Jennifer is doing churc h belting screamig B uses proer technique and can do melisma etc sing songs Jenn couldnt even dream about
beyonceboy100 1 month ago
@nw31705 Thank you--Someone expressing the facts about Beyonce's voice. She is OVERRATED as a singer. Even with all the vocal lessons Beyonce' has had she still sings flat and off key a bit; especially when covering other people's hit songs. Jennifer Hudson's voice has more flexibilty & POWER. Beyonce' "sells sex," had plastic surgery' & uses vocal tricks including lip syching to enhance her voice & her appeal to the public--including heavy promotion from her father, Matthew Knowles & Jay-Z.
FunLoveGirl123 4 weeks ago
@FunLoveGirl123 You sound angry.
slayer3to10 3 weeks ago
enjoys both vocals here and they each have their own style and grace! JHud is the best! Bey handles her business, both young gifted and talented women who have so much to live for! Always a blessing!
Choclongleggz 1 month ago 2
Jennifer has a stronger voice, but Beyonce has the more versatile voice.
Kingdom4Real 1 month ago 3
@Kingdom4Real Stronger in noooo way and Bs voice has grown she got much more heavier now, stroger isnt SCREMING FLAT HIGH NOTES to overpower ;)
beyonceboy100 1 month ago
regardless of what anyone says... jennifer is a strong singer but Bey wasnt drowned out by her at all.. which shows Beyonce can hold her own...some other singers wouldnt have been able to sing next to jenn
MrPrinceBadazz 2 months ago
Jennifer Hudson was so much sexier back then oooooohhhhhhh!
rizzel7 2 months ago 4
Jennifer has the bigger voice but beyonce's is prettier and she knows more tricks and has a better ear.
bemaniac2 2 months ago
I thought Jennifer was a little off key in the beginning, check it out the proof is there and Beyonce always flawless.
NubianQueenNEFERTITI 2 months ago 2
@NubianQueenNEFERTITI hahahaha
guiantony 2 months ago
beyonce has a cute little voice but jennifer damm
Love10177 2 months ago
@Love10177 Cute voice and she can sing LISTEN etc and outsing Screamiffer when she cam out and overpowerd her with that F5 and she was sick and she doesnt need to show of pluheees
beyonceboy100 1 month ago
What a concert ??
paemippo 2 months ago
@paemippo Oscars 2007 or 2008 i believe
javarie19 2 months ago
@javarie19 thank you very much.
paemippo 2 months ago
I remember this performance, and I remember thinking they did not have chemistry together. It seemed like they were sort of competing with each other. At least that was my perception.
wifey231 2 months ago
beyonce just screamed on her ass lol but they both did a awesome job! love it
bingbean07 2 months ago
@bingbean07 if anyone was screaming it wasn't bey...
slayer3to10 2 months ago
@slayer3to10 see where i come from "screamin" means killin, banged, murdered.. in that nature.. to put it in your terms she did better than jennifer in my opinion.
bingbean07 2 months ago
... guys. They're both goddesses. Doesn't matter which one's more divine.
Kibetha 3 months ago 59
jhudson seems like she's trying too hard.
annjili 3 months ago
@annjili Stooooop IIiiiiit Thats The Way She Always Sinqs.
mrzlaudet11 2 months ago
PRESS CHANNEL TO GET EXCLUSIVE FOR WHITNEY HOUSTON TO TONI AND TAMAR BRAXTON... GET INFO ON BEYOUNCE AND WHY SHE HOLD S THE TITLE OF DIVA....WHAT ABOUT JENNIFER ...? PRESS CHANNEL TO GET A CLUE..
INTERESTING AND EYE OPENING...!
Victoryisoursindeed 3 months ago
beeeyonceeeee
grobinson20 3 months ago
That's definately not listen.
slayer3to10 3 months ago 77
Actually Dreamgirls was more about Effie not Deena people get i twisted as far as the story is concerned.
leilani1977 3 months ago 2
@leilani1977 Exactlyyyyy thank you! I hate how everyone is like "Jen showed her up/stole the show!!1" etc. In the actual musical it was the role of Effie which got the most acclaim and is supposed to be the most emotionally stirring role, period. I think a lot of people just want to be able to say that Beyonce was shown up, just 'cuz.
IRunLA69 3 months ago
you cannot compaire beyonce with jen helllow its beyonce the legend and beyonce singing is much better then jen every pro knows that
goodiesboy75 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Jennifer Hudson showed Beyonce up in the movie Dream Girls, in fact stole the show.
stretch4859 3 months ago
Jennifer Hudson showed Beyonce up in themovie Dream Girls, in fact stole the show.
stretch4859 3 months ago
@stretch4859 hell yeah and that's why she won the oscar!!
ACPmoka 3 months ago
love them both they are the bomb!!
prettya238 3 months ago 2
Yes Jennifer can sing, but her voice isnt ALL THAT!!! Its just loud, and she can hit high notes! But her phrasing, runs, riffs, and vibrato isnt up to par! Beyonce's voice is sooo damn versatile, she can sing anything and make it sound beautiful, Jen cant! But I loved this performance!
liljayfludd 3 months ago
@liljayfludd Jhud only got the church loudness has nothing to do with vocaly speciels
beyonceboy100 3 months ago
@beyonceboy100 Exactly!
liljayfludd 3 months ago
Is it wrong for me to think that Hudson looks better as a thicker woman?
3912James 3 months ago
beyonce is a great singer but people say Jennifer is better not to be hatin on b but cuz Jennifer actually does have a higher power her vocie is stronger then b's but b is a high alto border line soprano but power wise she does not have it. in dreamgirls when i forget his name said something about her voice that's true in real life dont get me wrong beyonce has power to her voice but not Jennifer Hudson power
Chipmunk2007 3 months ago
@Chipmunk2007 Just like what Jamie says in the movie.. Jennifer has power, but Beyonce has quality ;)
revanslc 3 months ago
@revanslc yea imma call him just jamie lol cuz i cant remember his name in then movie but it's true
Chipmunk2007 3 months ago
irather listen to beyonce more then jenn , i feel like jen voice is too high & like madd soul while beys voice is more soothing & calm to listen too . jen has more of a church voice tht is hard to be toned down when Bey has a voice that could go to a high range & a low one, but dont get me wrong . anyone would be BLESSED to have a voice like either of theres . theyre both awesome
PurdyTeeTee 3 months ago
Comment removed
complexdimplex89 3 months ago
BEYONCE IS ONE PERFECTLY BEAUTIFUL WOMAN! WITH A FLAWLESS CLEAN AND CRISP VOICE!
gracie4music 4 months ago
I think Hudson power is easy and natural but Beyonce got to strain to get the power that Jennifer got natural....Beyonce got to strain, Jennifer is natural...so that just my thought....besides Huson is 5 Octives
brownstone65 4 months ago
@brownstone65 And Maria Callas had 3 octaves, and between the three,who do you think sings with the most powerful voice?? Vocal range isn't everything. In here, Beyoncé sings with more resonance and a lot more power.
hrick92 4 months ago
@hrick92 I am sorry I disagree, Jennifer has power she do not strain to use its natural, beyonce always strain in order to keep up with Jennifer even in the movie dream girls when beyonce was singing to Jamie Fox, "Listen" you can look and see her vains popping out her neck she was straining so hard to out do Jeniffer.
brownstone65 4 months ago
@brownstone65 LOL ha ha ha ha veins popping
raymondcharles12002 4 months ago
@brownstone65 I'm sorry, but these is your arguments? You said 5 times the same thing. What you disagree?
Ok,maybe "I get it":when Jennifer is natural in screaming, Beyoncé "strains" to sing. And the result: just listen. It's clearly Beyoncé hit that note with more technique, resonance...
hrick92 4 months ago
@brownstone65 And I didn't see anything special in Beyoncé's neck.
hrick92 4 months ago
@brownstone65
agreed
Love10177 2 months ago
@brownstone65 Clearly Jennifer sings effortlessly while Beyonce' has to strain and do convulsions, and "vocal gymnastics" in order to produce power in her voice and she still does not have the range and pure sound of Jennifer Hudson.
FunLoveGirl123 4 weeks ago
@1:33 enough said; Beyoncé slayy!
ldslight 4 months ago
great voices both ladies!!
teeka153 4 months ago
I can't believe how much weight Jennifer's lost. She's transformed and she looks amazing, but she's always been a beautiful woman!
JimiJegede 4 months ago
elas sao d+ vcs merecem euloveyou
FERNANDHO2 4 months ago
They both got amazing voices but Jennifer got it hands down
nrdixon10 4 months ago
that was powerful.. much respect to both ladies but Beyonce has a very sharp pitch !!
kennylondon123 4 months ago
gosh Beyonce's hair is so damn beautiful
shenmue2yakuza 4 months ago
I just recently discovered SELENA / I would rather look at and listen to SELENA anyday ! All these fake and untalented ass new females who want to be called "DIVAS" so bad can't touch SELENA WITH A 10 ft pole I'm a proud African American Black Man AND I LOVE SELENA !! She was more naturally talented / more naturally sexy / and more naturally BEAUTIFUL inside and out as a woman and a person / and that goes for J LO TOO! / you may have imitated her in a film / BUT YOU CAN'T TOUCH " THE REAL DEAL
druhbe1996 4 months ago
@druhbe1996 y r u trolling
JBxPuppyxLover 4 months ago
Jennifer got that one :-)
thetoughtruth 4 months ago
what is the name of this single ladies remix????
19dimitri92 4 months ago
Argggh Beyonce should play a bigger part in this song.
Dleef100 4 months ago
Chill. I mean that's what she said in the interview before this performance she said something to the effect of "I'm not feeling well I have some sort of cold, but I didn't wanna give this up so I'ma just hope I don't mess up!" It just so happens I watch the Oscars and Grammys every year... and do you mean "fan"? It wasn't an excuse for her, it was a reason AGAINST her, I said it's possible she only wasn't oversinging because she was sick. As in, if she were well, she would've been annoying.
VocalPowa 4 months ago
Both ladies did well!
trw1501 4 months ago
I would love for black artist to stop trying to out sing each other. Thats my thing, personally to me beyonce is always trying to out sing someone. It annoys me. Not that she can out sing Jennifer, but its still annoying. Just work together and have fun damn
rosarah9 5 months ago
@rosarah9 Black artists? Have you HEARD Christina Aguilera try to sing with other people? They always have to turn her mic down because she insists upon snarling at the top of her lungs to drown out anyone else.
Plus, I'm not saying always, but in this particular performance Anika and Jennifer were the ones oversinging, Beyonce was kinda just chillin (but she was sick so she mighta been scared to mess up).
VocalPowa 4 months ago
@VocalPowa Yes i said BLACK ARTIST, Im sure there are other artist who do the same thing, but in this situation im only focused on my own race. And YES...that is my issue with her and other black artist who do it, I don't like her anyhow but that is annoying. And she was SICK? You must be a stan who tries to make excuses for her. Because you talked to her and she told you she was sick right?
rosarah9 4 months ago
@rosarah9 bey was looking over smiling at her , saying you singg it girl in the background trying to give her support. to me they both had team work . of course theyre gonna put some soul into their singing , its not trying to outsing one another .
PurdyTeeTee 3 months ago
i FIND A LOT OF JENNIFER HATING HERE. GIVE THE LADIES WHAT IS HERE,,GOOD SINGERS...BEATIFUL GIRLS...GIVE ME A BREAK!!! JENNIFER HAS VOICE
gloryglory316 5 months ago
beyonce OWNS jennifer hudson in listen, they did two songs that night one from beyonce one from hudson!! watch?v=i5TLNrVRDVU&feature=related
itsMUSICY 5 months ago
Why is everyone so obsessed with who's "Better"? If you like it, great, if you don't, click on something else. Why everyone feels they must be Simon Cowell now is beyond me.
Great performance from both.
jla9180 5 months ago
When does powerful or louder equate to better? I like the chord Beyonce set up at the chorus. She actually made that chord darker and fuller or how most people say "soulful". Just saying louder ain't always better, musicality is more than a powerhouse voice. These singers have very different voices and it's sad we can think less of a voice that is not the most stereotypical "black".
saxman29212 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
• • ENOUGH IS ENOUGH..PEOPLE PLEASE; I JUST DONT UNDERSTAND WHY WE HAVE TO BAIT EVERY SINGLE BLACK ARTISTS AGAINST ONE ANOTHER..WE DONT NEED TO DO THAT, WHITE PEOPLE R ALREADY DOING THAT SHIT BY CLOSING DOORS ON THEIR FACES & IGNORING THEIR MUSIC..WAT THEY NEED IS OUR SUPPORT, BUT PEOPLE KEEP REFUSING THEM THAT.WE ALL WILL WATCH SOON AS ARTIST'S LIKE CIARA, KERI HIL, KELLY ROW,JEN HUD, TIEARR M, & OTHER TALENTED BLACK ARTISTS MUSIC CAREER DIES A SLOW DEATH...IT’S ALREADY HAPPININ NOW..
celestina742 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
b voice is wayy more pleasent than jenns they both can sing their asses off but b has the better voice in my opinion she owned jen in listen and her entrance on love yu i do and was flawless in listen liked her singing it much better!
Avatargeek23 1 minute ago
Avatargeek23 5 months ago
Does anyone know the brand of Beyonces dress ?
Blondzable 5 months ago
who are the dancers?
Csani 5 months ago
I don't care I love Jennifer Hudson better. Her voice is more soulful and passionate. Beyonce's is manufactured and generic.
AJtheamazing1 5 months ago 2
@AJtheamazing1 i totally agree i could not help myself i laugh my ass off @ your comment Jennifer has a way more POWERFUL voice than B, Jen voice is ABSOLUTELY with out a doubt a POWERHOUSE she was totally drowning out B and thats the i see it I LOVE YOUR COMMENT ......AJtheamazing1...
ATLNice 5 months ago
@ATLNice Yep jennifer's voice is powerful and very souful. But in the end technique wins as when beyonce came out and sang that F5 with jen, hers was more resonant and powerul, drainig out jenn's. But good performance from both. have a nice night:)
MrButler124 5 months ago
both of they voices sound good 2gether
MKLuciouSTV 5 months ago
love b's dress!!
MissCommo 5 months ago
I love them both, but Beyonce has more power than Jennifer. Beyonce is much more resonant than Jen. Proof is at 1:33 where Bey beasted Jen on that F5. Competely drowned Jen out.
stardusth2o 5 months ago
@stardusth2o Beyonce has way more training, Jennifer just sings because she loves to.
yourlove1992 5 months ago
Fuck off you all. It's not a VOCAL BATTLE. It's a DUET. Do I need to draw this up to make you understand?
RenanLikey 5 months ago
Is it me or is Jennifer full of her self here? Its like she is trying to take over too much and Beyonce is so nice to her while she is singing.
SlowY00 5 months ago
@SlowY00 she not full of herself she just singing the song like it was suppose 2 b sang like n the movie n jennifer hudson's voice its just naturally louder when she sings nyway she cant help it
MKLuciouSTV 5 months ago
beyone came out with ease and killed it.. jennifer slayed too.. they were both great
nativecryptblood 5 months ago
Daaammmmm she was fine as fuc' on here...delicious thick...now she'z Whitney skinny...not cool!!
1datniggaarealstud1 5 months ago
@1datniggaarealstud1 Hahahahahaha ''delicious thick'' lmao.
RenanLikey 5 months ago
Beyonce got boo boo'd on this performance Jennifer should have taken over listen because beyonce didn't do the song justice once Jennifer started singing it, and Jen didn't need help on her song
medstudent42 5 months ago
They both have powerful voices, both are vocal powerhouse.It's just that Beyonce is far more accomplished as vocalist, with the around vocal abilities(sufficient in all vocal elements). Jhud on the other is still very much a 1 dimensional singer, who still attacks every song and screams out every note, lacking the essential vocal element(vocal control) and still hasn't learned how to build a song.
unbreakablekat 5 months ago
@unbreakablekat tHANKS
beyonceboy100 5 months ago
@unbreakablekat smh all that shyt is so aggravatin its called soulful singin...u know singin from the heart not everybody wants all that vocal control bs i mean its nice n pretty but jennifer hudson sings from the heart beyonce is more trained either one is good so quit tryna compare so its not just screamin like u close minded people think
MKLuciouSTV 5 months ago
J Hud is making Beyonce sing
mstreds 5 months ago
both have a perfect voCal...love yeah
MsDjKimi 5 months ago
Beyonce notes actually overpowered (had more resonance) than Jennifer's several notes -- when they sang at the same time. Beyonce has a lot more power than people give credit for, just saying.
jwaggerz 5 months ago 46
@jwaggerz I do agree with you that Beyonce's notes are purer and more resonant, but by God has Jennifer got soul :)
StrawberryJungle 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@jwaggerz I do agree with you that Beyonce's notes are purer and more resonant, but by God has Jennifer got soul :)
StrawberryJungle 4 months ago
@jwaggerz doesnt matter cuz Jen hudson is sexy
ZodiacBryan 4 months ago
@jwaggerz THANK YOU and she was sick that day and She grew vocALY ALOt HeAVIer NOW while Jhud stayed same BACK THEN B would slay her if she wanted...
Jhud gave 955 vocaly
The other 3 girl of dreamgirsl GAVE 100% SHE TRIED
B gave 60%
beyonceboy100 3 months ago
Loder is better...Jenn is NOTE A BETTEr VOCALIST Beyonce has a much helthier and a AMAZing technique she was sick that day she held back Jennifer is louder and her voice is heavier but she cant do the build in listen like beyonce vocaly ! and a lots more,,j hudson overdos it sometimes
beyonceboy100 5 months ago
I adore both of them when singing this song from Dreamgirls also it represent that Afro American female actors has come a long ways.
missmochashake 6 months ago
Jenn Killed it..such power...
TheJahem 6 months ago 6
backround is just fine for beyonce. go jennifer
lichtlein88 6 months ago 2
@lichtlein88 Hello
medstudent42 5 months ago
@medstudent42 come on, jennifer is the best.
lichtlein88 5 months ago
@lichtlein88 no baby I agreed with you beyonce should have been in the background
medstudent42 5 months ago
@medstudent42 well then, you`re right :-)
lichtlein88 5 months ago
i love jenny but BEYONCE SLAYED.......she walked up on that stage like "Bitch Fall Back"
MakeLoveNoBabiez 6 months ago
@MakeLoveNoBabiez no beyonce got slayed
medstudent42 5 months ago
guess what?????? Beyoncé just schooled her in her own song, just sayyin
KnowlesfanBeyonce 6 months ago
Was this the Oscars?
JasperKenneth06 6 months ago
Beyonce came out like 'bitch stand back" !
terralwalker5 6 months ago
Beyonce slayed Jenifer sorry :)
terralwalker5 6 months ago
@terralwalker5 NO! jenny is wy better ,vocally
SuperTm13 6 months ago
My gurl aint evan TRYING AND SLAYING YAS
beyonceboy100 6 months ago
yes Beyonce can sing but not like Jennifer Hudson she is a real singer in my book hands down gives me chills ever time i hear her sing :P
ChiyoINFINITY3000 6 months ago
Jennifer yelling..If you know wat real singing is you know beyonce is the real good singer buht jennifer cool..
cripG09 6 months ago
@cripG09 jenny is singing okay, shes vocally way better! beynce is a okay of a singer
SuperTm13 6 months ago
See now det jennefer lost her weight, all she has to do is start dancin like beyonce n shell be her surperior cuz jennifer can blow, all she has to do is get sum gud choreography n she'll dominate beyonce
MrFuturekappakelly 6 months ago
@MrFuturekappakelly Why is it you can spell "choreography" but you can't spell the simpler words?
kamwrites 6 months ago
Beyonce was being respectful and allowing Jennifer to sing her song. I think Jennifer is a better vocalist than Beyonce, but Beyonce has better stage presence and is a better performer. Hands down both ladies are hella talented
1BadBamaBelle 6 months ago 2
jennifer hudson sounds better singing the song she is more powerful and she don't have to sound seductive. She is gorgeous and so is beyonce.
Littlereny1 6 months ago
Jennifer is freaking powerhouse and Beyonce got that sweet seductive voice. No choice but to love them!!!
MrBokLee 6 months ago 9
Voices of angels.. ii love them...
sexiiCp3 6 months ago
stop comparaison jennifer and beyonce are phenomenal
tarmoul1 7 months ago 2
@tarmoul1 i got chills when they both were singing it was like boom
ERIC933G 7 months ago
Beyonce is such shit lol
TristanSpears06 7 months ago
@TristanSpears06 U MAD???
jgutter34 6 months ago
Ey...You know this song isn't "Listen," right? It's "Love You I Do." Same show, wrong title.
JazziA8 7 months ago