Added: 5 years ago
From: Marburgnils
Views: 157,699
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (120)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Truely heart warming! A well done performance by three of the best musicians of our time.

    Soothing and unforgettable and to the bone!

    Geneblncht

  • Great version...

    

  • BRIAN GENIUS EVER GOD BLESS

  • Boy can that Carly Simon sing or what? Not to many performers could pull off singing a classic Brian Wilson/Beach Boys tune and sound almost as good. Well she's done it again! I'd like to see her take on the "Ultimate" female singer test, Mrs. Patsy Cline. It would be great to hear!

  • I could never get tired of the sounds of The Beach Boys.

  • Is this concert available on cd? I want this version with my girl, Carly!

  • "He was never your friend. Keaton didn't have any friends!"

  • I have one word for to describe David, Carly, and Jimmy.....LEGENDS!

  • Just don't know how Crosby does it...

  • lovin this cover nice!!

  • WoW! Truly these are some good vibrations!

  • great vid pity about the stretched wide format

  • Awesome cover Brian should be proud

  • Takes me back to High School , Cool !

  • what's an autist?

  • How much does he look like Albert Einstein?

  • fantastic song and sung beautifully

  • By singing "In my room" she's ripping off the Bangles and may be sued!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Didn't do it for me. I really like David Crosby, and love some of Carly Simon's songs (I'll confess I don't know anything about the other guy, though he's probably a genius). The harmonies were good and sweet, and I'm sure the artists were sincere, but, for me, the performance had no magic. Still, waaay better than Ricky Martin's take earlier in the concert. For me the highlight was Paul Simon's take on Surfer Girl, and I really liked Mann and Penn's "I Just Wasn't Made for These Times"

  • @therealdmt 'The other guy," Jimmy Webb' wrote "MacArthur Park," "Galveston," "Wichita Lineman," "Highwayman," "By the Time I Get to Phoenix," "Up Up and Away," "All I Know," "Didn't We?," "The Worst That Could Happen," and "The Moon's a Harsh Mistress," among many, many others. He IS a genius!

  • @christoddur love this version.....

  • Scharfe Körpersprache#! HE

  • when was this recording done?

  • @walterbrob Dude, How old are you? Carly Simon Has Been Great Since WAAY before Miley, or even BillyRae Cyrus You need too know that . She is one of the BEST songwriters ever !!

  • @walterbrob

    WHAT PLANET ARE YOU FROM? miley and billy ray are nothing but ameture white trash compared to

    Carly Simon.

    Carly is one of the all time greats and you put her in the same category as the white trash singers of today?

    Not Likely !

  • even they know this song is a masterpiece

  • Enjoy this performance of "In My Room" and remember you always have your room to go to when you need it.

  • What a trip, I never would have thought that those three artists could get together and do a cover of "In My Room" that I wouldn't turn off after the first 2 bars. I gotta go now, I think I'll watch this video again.

  • Just OK... I would have rather seen Carole King rather than Carly

  • 0ne word : Beautiful<3

  • Now, this is talent!! So beautiful. Really, really beautiful. I love this song dearly. I love the Beach Boys and normally don't like covers, but this is exceptional!

  • David Crosby....so talented.

  • Wow---incredible!! What year was this. One an incredible performance by such incredible people

  • I love Carly's blouse!!!!!!!

  • Cool to see Jimmy Greaves on vocals too...where's Ian St.John tho?? :)

  • Who's Jimmy Greaves ? Do you mean jimmy webb ?

  • A wonderful tribute.......amazing voices.....straight to my favs.......thanks for the share redbaron !!!!!

  • sounds good

  • Great.....thanks for posting M...../.

  • Beautiful!! Thanks for posting Marburgnils!

    Thank you for this great share dear Georgina!

  • A Very Beautiful Song!

    Thanks you for this share tomasemma:)

  • How wonderful to see three serious artists offering so much care to presenting this glorious song. Not the usual personality display, just that rare thing: sincere tribute. Thank you!

  • Brian Wilson was such a great songwriter!

  • John 9944, just down below, is right. Carly Simon is a National Treasure, still going strong since the 70's, maybe even late 60's. An all around ARTist. One of the very Best!

  • Here is a note for all you naysayers on this performance. First off, Jimmy Webb is known for hos songwriting, not his singing. Second, have YOU ever tried to sing this song? If you have, you will know it is a VERY difficult song to perform. They are paying tribute to the genius that is Brian Wilson. Be happy about that and shut up. I perform this song with my band and people are touched when they hear it because they realize that it is one of the most beautiful songs in pop music history. Chill!

  • WOW. Anybody that doesn't like this song is too picky. Hey, it's live. Carly is still the queen. I see her occasionally on the Vineyard and she always has a nice word and a smile. She is a national treasure.

  • Ha.... I am new to Utube..and am a very old fan of Carly. I came all the way from California .. a long time dream of about 30 years... just to see the Vinyard and hope to catch Carly and say hello.. What a beautul place... I met lots of people who run into Carly all the time.. ah... lucky souls.. she is the best.. and for sure.. Nobody does it Better ;-)

  • You'll usually see her walking in Vineyard Haven (Which is where the ferry from Woods Hole comes in.) She lives in Tisbury. Also a place you'll see all the island celebs is the movie theater in Oak Bluffs. You will also see her at the Friends of the Library benefit. One year (1994-5?) she auctioned off an in home concert. When the bidding stalled at 50K she sang a verse of Nobody Does it Better and said that she would reveal the inspiration for You"re So Vain. The final bid was $85K.

  • Thanks for putting this up- really is magic.

    Leroy

  • It's nice, but what happened to the vocal harmonies in the Bridge? Not enough rehearsal time?

  • Ms Teeth is Carly Simon to you. I still love her, her voice is still gorgeous and I'll never stop being a fan ever.

  • Legends singing nicely together but the blend of their voices certainly doesn't create any magic.

  • Fat too slow for Carly. She can do much better than this.

  • Great performance - thanks for posting it.

  • Try searching for Carly and James Taylor ;-)

  • I love Ms Teeth as you call her. I don't think its her singing, I think the arrangement is too slow and boring. She also doesn't need to sing a three part harmony. Just let her sing it alone and with a more up tempo beat. Listen to her sing "Coming Around Again" and you will know she is one of our greatest singer-songwriters.

  • saab900se (Nice car) I assume you didn't know that Saab build fighter aircraft? I guess you can't sing either. Carly Simon has more soul than your poor ...............

    I was about to get very insulting. But i simply cannot be bothered.

  • I do know that Saab build aircraft although they're powered by a Volvo license built General-Electric engine and no I can't sing either. But I can still pass an honest opinion which is that Miss teeth has a voice which is not pleasing to my ear.

    P.S.

    I think I love you.

    XX

  • when i hear this song it goes to show what dennis really went through to writea song like this grat job

  • Denny may have gone through similar experiences as Brian when they were young but it was Brian who wrote this song and NOTHING compares to hearing him sing this. Try and hear Brian and his band sing this then you'll see.

  • Sorry, this is not even close, might I even say, a terrible version. Brian Wilson's voice will never be duplicated... Check out the original. Thanks for the music, Bri.

  • Hey Hi....who did the original of this??? anyone??

  • Beach Boys?

  • carly eats that song..

  • Lovely video. Beautiful voices.

  • And one of the best dvd's

  • and which one would that be??? TITLE/Date PLEASE!

  • Beautiful performance---I think that you guys have listened to the original Beach Boys as a comparison. No comparison, mon freres.

    Love ya anyways.

  • "take my cap off?" - hey, there's Bruce Babyman Baum again - what's the freak flag boy singing now?

  • WOW...Jerry springer can sure sing.

  • LOL

  • Wow. Great tribute. Thanks David, Jimmy and Carly. Carly. Sigh.

  • Oh, my Lord have mercy; what a blend! This is so sweet, and Carly is timeless...

  • i've always loved this song.

    i've always loved carly simon.

    the last recording tammy wynette made was this song as a duet with brian wilson himself.

  • Outstanding!

  • A very nice rendition - thanks!

  • Carly's got the pipes! I also liked the side cut out top she was sporting too! Great vid!

  • The beautiful thing about this video is that you can mute out the first 31 seconds.

    The singing is really great.

  • How?

  • Who is that yankee asshole, anyway?

  • Can anyone find that song called "Jesse", by Carly Simon? I've been lookin' but can't find it anywhere. I LOVE that song!

  • david crosbys is a legend,,,carly owns this

  • If you can't say anything constructive, please keep quiet.

  • If you can't say anything constructive, please keep quiet.

  • Anyone know where i can find the song "in two stright lines" Carly sang?

  • one of the best collaborations and covers ever made!

  • Thank you!

  • Great harmony! As for the comment on the "boob shot" - it was distasteful...BUT...if I was a breast cancer survivor and actually had breasts remaining after the cancer was removed, I would show them off a little, too...and would be flattered someone noticed them! :-)

  • Great comeback WALKER2ROY. Well said.

  • Great, gentle harmonies.

  • So beautiful- thanks for posting!

  • Carly rocks!

  • carly is great so is david the both could have killed it on their own

  • AWESOME!! BEAUTIFULL TRIO..PEACE

  • Sweet!!

  • Not sure how Carly would react to the "boob shot" comment after surviving breast cancer....

  • shed react with class and talent,jud like she has for years

  • Comment removed

  • Crosby should have sang this on his own

  • The are a bunch, Olivia, Robert Lamm, Peter Cetera, Neil Diamond, Glen Campbell and Carly Simon among others who are in their early sixties and still look timeless.

  • Lord, her voice hasn't changed at all. Thanks for uploading that.

  • I am truly amazed by this....I had never heard of it, and it's the best thing I've seen this year..thanks so much for putting this out in youtube

  • Get down on your hands and knees and PRAY that you look and sound as GREAT as Carly does at 60!

    va-va-varoom!!!!!!!!

    thanks for uploading this gem!

  • Carly kool!!!!!

  • I think Carly's the standout in this song!! Smashing outfit and performance!!

  • i totaly agree

  • Ditto. She carries the song just like she did in No Nukes on "Power".

  • Awesome!! Fu&(ing AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more