A HORRIFYING OVERSIGHT!!!!

[BlazingLightSword]

Sorry Hank, I'm for Team John ;) Happy very belated birthday though!

[SheIsStarStuff]

You simply can't pick one of the vlogbrothers.

John is the literature nerd, and he makes you think about your life and the way that you live it, while simultaneously being awkward and making you laugh.

Hank, on the other hand, is more of a science/computer nerd, and he makes you laugh, say WTF and makes you remember not to take life too seriously,

(Of course there are exceptions to each of these.)

It's hard to choose a specific one, because each of them do different things for you.

[cupcakegurrrrl77]

I enjoyed John's singing...

[editornia]

Happy Birthday Hank!!

[lookingformybluebox]

Henry the made of awesome baby is my favourite vlogbrother

[theEumenides]

You think this hotel is fancy. Just wait, John. In the future, you will stay at a hotel that is bigger than your house and has an authentic Picasso sketch.

[abbigatorchomp]

The Yeti is my favorite

[Catbrodcasting]

Noo!! John is my favourite brother shhhhh dont tell hank

[CharKorbit]

You know, you're not actually that bad of a singer.

[RodaSmash]

#TeamWilly.

[eggansmile]

I love both brothers equally!!! Though, admittedly, The Katherine is my favourite. XD

[26Staples]

you sang!!! YOU PROMISED YOU WOULDNT SING

[HermioneNerdfighterW]

HAPPY BIRTHDAY 3 years late

[mamemimoma]

I love both brothers too much. Happy very late bday Hank!

[plushalligator]

i think he is tone deaf in the way that he cant hear that he dosent suck

[Greaseball01]

I just travelled back in time...

[pbjellybeanful]

I love both brothers an insane amount, but i unfortunately have to say i like John more. I feel bad choosing, but i just find his videos more entertaining, even though both him and Hank are 100% awesome.

[pbjellybeanful]

I seriously thought he was going to say "SHIT" at the beginning.

[KiraraLuver]

JOHN WILL ALWAYS BE MY FAVORITE BROTHER

[sciencenerd111]

hank forgot the #1 rule... DFTBA!!!!!

[goldensnitch14]

OMG!OMG!OMG! Ok uh, ok don't panik me um, Happy Birthday Hank no no no that's not e-Nuff uh........ I'll get back to y-...... Oh HBHDFTBA ( which iz like impossible 4 Hank AND John

[andyanderson100]

Happy Birthday Hank! DFTBA!

[gilliemillie]

katherine is my favorite vlogbrother

[Theintern55]

@Gvf77x I'd like your comment, but it has 123 likes and I don't wanna mess that up:)

[starlove0043]

haha i love both, but John is probably my favorite<3 sorry hank!<333

[Miranzira]

I forgot that this happened and it is still a little hilarious.

[lollymarbles]

My birthdays May 4 :)

[JeimuzuShige]

dungeons and dragons add next to the video? coincidence I think not!

[AdmiralJef]

What's a sidebar?

[FlargTheKitty]

@AdmiralJef A long, long, long, time ago, the dooblydoo below the video used to be on the side, thus it was called a sidebar. :D

[MarkLatimerRussell]

Btw you're not tone deaf

[filmfan41]

Happy Way Belated Bday (Bidet?) Or as I like to think of it, Hank Green Day (although it is other people's days, too). The birthday is the one day of the year set aside to celebrate the individual. I forget them, too. Best Wishes, Hank!

[ChelsieOliviaa]

Whoa.

I live in Grandville.

Like, a millimeter from Grand Rapids.

THAT'S SO COOL.

[DyingPickle]

We are like 3 years late x) kinda wish I had discovered vlogbrothers 4 years ago -.-"

[islandboy4445]

Happy very belated birthday...from 2011. ;)

[LuneFromage]

It's fairly late, but you should dance around a may pole.

[BethTheBubblyGirl]

HAPPY SUPER LATE BIRTHDAY HANK

[kittendancer]

he looks alot like hank in this video. I mean more than usual.

[ajswanson91]

How can someone pick between Hank and John? I like each of them for different reasons, but I like them both equally!

[Bluebird11235]

I can't choose! I think John is more INTERESTING to watch, while Hank is FUNNIER to watch. So, that begs the question would I rather put facts in my head or stuff on my head? Both of which are very important things to do.

[bwink239]

To ask which vlogbrother I like better is a question wrongly phrased. I like Hank for his music, his creativity, and his passionate discussions on the importance of green technology (among others) . I like John for his books, his puff, and his political and current events expertise (among others). I love the vlogbrothers channel because it is a place where I am a part of a community that is awesome.

[lappinlover]

i love both brothers! and happy super late birthday :D

[FunnyGirlz221]

is it wrong that blenderizing a birthday cake sounds kind of delicious?

[MegaRandompeoplez]

@FunnyGirlz221 no beacause a resturaunt actually blenderizes birthday cake and sells it

[FunnyGirlz221]

@MegaRandompeoplez that sounds awesome. where?

[harrySTINKINpotter]

@CestLaLouise I feel the same way. The other day my friend said she liked John better, but then she came up with an argument for Hank, and that just proves that you cant pick a favorite vlogbrother, just like you cant pick a favorite child.

[CestLaLouise]

I really dislike anyone who tries to compare the two. I really hate people saying, "I like John better." or "I like Hank better"

[DiminutiveFlower]

I cannot believe I missed you both being in GR, Michigan. :( To my credit, I did not have high speed internet, much less watch youtube until and beginning in April of 2008.

[musicalxsilence]

"Awesome is immortal"- John Green. DFTBA. So tweeting this, right now.

[BeelzaneffCATDOLL]

ah! okay so this may not intrest you in the least but it freaked me out! okay so i clicked on this vid and when it started my computer went black but you could still hear the audio and RIGHT as the screen went blank I heard John say "oh~ SHOOT!" thats what i was gonna say!! 0.0

[rhylin26]

LOL Link in the sidebar. :)

[invictagirl2007]

well, I cant choose my favourite. I love both of you equally xx for your own merits :D

[StarKidGleekSarah]

John, you're my favorite brother. However, I'm kind of an English nerd so it makes sense.

[WafflesandFruitloops]

true point John... he's what, 32 now? my mom and all of my firends put him at about 19

[crazycookie76]

HHHAAAPPPYYY BBBIIIRRRTTTHHHDDDAAAYYY HHHAAANNNKKK!!! A very merry birthday, tooooooooooooooooooo youuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu!!!

[raphysantana]

As a science nerd and a insufferable bookworm, I LIKE YOU BOTH EQUALLY.

[robaphone20]

I like both equally, its really close

[11xxLilyxx11]

Dude... I think I've been in that hotel.

[oforth]

if it's any consolation, while i certainly didn't know about this particular birthday, (28th right?) at the time, youtube totally suggested this channel to me prior to the 5th of this May...so i should have been able to wish Hank a happy 31st(?)

[oforth]

@oforth and it just occured to me...if 'nerdfighter' is hard for people to understand, nerdfighting is really bad.  sure, you know that it must, by extension mean 'fighting against Decepticons and their worldsuck in a nerdy way' but it's really really bad for general usage.

[Spontenaity]

Aww, John. If it makes you feel any better, I'd stop watching if either one of you left.

(I lied. I enjoy your rants too much. I wouldn't stop...although I would miss the puff.)

[sockostealshearts]

i love you both but john is my favorite :D

hey at least im straight up about it.

[leftheadphone]

VLOGBROTHERS WITHOUT HANK? THATS...THATS... THATS LIKE PB AND J WITHOUT THE 'J'!

and then its just PB, and thats just weird...

[ircuteskitty]

@leftheadphone my brother eats it with just the PB.....

[leftheadphone]

@ircuteskitty ...i think your brother is broken

[ircuteskitty]

@leftheadphone :/ hes not broken hes just crazy!

[cloudsmymind]

I know this is an old vid, but notice the poof get bigger and bigger as the video went on? XP I love you John and Hank!

[NinoKazuSuki]

I thought John promised not to sing anymore......

[classicpink7]

Actually I like John better. I mean, Hank is great, but John is amazing.

[xtiredxemox]

i like you equally. because john writes and gives me good quotes and teaches me things and hank makes me laugh all the time. so you're both equally awesome.

[emvln92]

john can sing pretty good for saying he's totally tone-deaf! he needs to give himself more credit!

[iamthewalrus080391]

Everyone likes Hank better, even you like hank better

[Curriay]

I like Hank a bit  more actually.

[Anna28Twilight]

I think that Willy is the best!

[topcat3768]

Hmm...well, Hank does more of the "acting funny", but I usually crack up more at things John deadpans.

I LOVE YOU BOTH!! :D

[Gvf77x]

How can you like one brother over the other?!

Hank is funnier, John is more insightful.

They're both awesome in different ways and saying one is better is madness! Madness I tell you!

[thephilipfn]

@Gvf77x Madness?

THIS. IS. yeah I'm not gonna make that reference.

[TheFashionVavilon]

@Gvf77x Because in my opinion John is funnier, smarter, more insightful, sexier, so on

[DisBeKalea]

Both brothers are equal to me <3

Mostly because I'm a writer.

And I'm a song writer.

And a singer.

So...

c:

[pokemonmanic400]

have a private jet named ''nerdfighter'' to pull (random number) 27 sown- together vlogbrothers shirts all facing the same direction and on the back it says HAPPY BIRTHDAY HANK! DFTBA! for all the world to see.

[pendragonmalasia]

Hank used to be my favorite brother, then it was you (because of your books) and then you two were equal.

[kiajacobbella]

Hey! It's almost another of your birthdays!!

[FredIsMyName22]

I LOVE BOTH BROTHERS EQUALLY.

[tifftat2008]

I like John more. :P

[katnisspeeta12]

You know what, John seems more loved, but Hank is awesome. Like seriously.

[tonnieannelewis]

HAPPY BIRTHDAY

[Fluteplayinghuru285]

Come baaaaaaaack did not know you were coming because I was like eleven!!!

And happy three years late birthday Hank!!!

[uglyfudge]

John's actually my favorite brother, because he wrote the best book ever.

[nillie1234]

Awww please go to grand rapids mi again I didnt know about u then :(

[ked147971]

Happy Birthday Hank! Even though this video was made in 2008 and it's now 2011

[HyperEmmie]

HAPPY BIRTHDAY

[OddballEndorser]

I love Hank, but I don't know why he's the most popular brother. I love you the best :D

[JamieMin0r]

You said you'd never sing again on Vlogbrothers. You lied, but I'm glad you lied.

[OhSomethinClever]

NERD GLASSES ARE BACK!

[aquadrop25]

He SANG! In 2008 John Green sang a song and posted it on YouTube! I is very happy now.

[blondylicios]

happy very very i mean like a kazillion years late burfday!!!!!!!

[writergirlchic]

HAPPY VERY LATE BDAY HANK!! I LOVE YOU XD

[CharmyGirl5]

HAPPY LATE BIRTHDAY

[tallrunner1600]

You know, John always complains about how he can't sing, but that birthday song was actually pretty good.

[HarryPotterTrio91]

Happy VERY belated birthday lol.

:D

[nobelmorningstar]

"..because everyone knows awesome is immortal." HAHA GREAT.

[kelseyhm]

HANK? more popular? Pffttttt You're both awesome. :)

[TheWarnerSister]

Forget the time passed... HAPPY BIRTHDAY, HANK. <3

It's gotta be his birthday SOMETIME.

[survivalgun]

happy birthday hank

[SirTeeGeeEss]

Cognitive surplus should be in the dictionary.

[EthantheAbsol]

oh my god you were in atlanta!!!!

Happy Birthday Hank!!

Write a book about two brothers going all over the place but they never see eachother, and they talk over the.... internet, or letters, but still make it fun!

[SSdetectiveagency]

to be honest....I like Willy the best :P

[superghostc]

john ismy favourit :)

[bakerybabe29]

I like you better, John!

[greengirllover]

I like youuu best :)

[pinatafication]

hey, I thought John wasn't gonna sing after the end of brotherhood 2.0

[foolersqueen]

John... You always have been and always will be my favorite.

ALWAYS.

[wolfganggangwolfe]

I'm 137373 viewer, cool

[calichic98]

john you will always be my favorite vlog brother!

[cibomatto47]

John! What happened to these nerdtastically awesome glasses?!

And by the way, though you guys are equally awesome, I'm a book nerd in the most extreme way--so, you're definitely my nerd-brother!

[CodyAndJemima]

you should have gotten santa christ and introduce them. unless!! HE HAS ALREADY MET SANTA CHRIST.!!!!! in that case you should have... you should have introduced him to jesus claus

[RenegadeJuggler]

Monday May 5th is my birthday!

[Belula4]

what. you were in michigan???

why couldnt you have gone in 2010 when i wasnt kinda living in china :[

[CheeseGenius]

Oh shit, I left a comment about the time, but I misheard him, so I Have to find and delete it!

[CheeseGenius]

Oh, I thought you were worrying about friday the 5th being one week away from friday 13th. Also even though hank is more popular. He isn't more popular on twitter lol!

[hattieeatsthings]

Cool, Hank's birthday is the day before mine :)

[oldspicemanloverrr]

no. hank is NOT the more popular brother!

you are forever THE BEST!

[benleahful]

Happy b-day hank (even though you don't know me). John for forgetting his b-day you should get him at least one shark with a laser attached to it's head.

[gigi6598]

you're my favorite!

[RavensAndRitter]

Puff level rising visibly XD

Personally, I always thought Hank needed more love, John gets more fawned over ^^

[supercrazypurplegurl]

I thought everyone knew John was the more popular brother...

[thefirethief101]

HAPPY BIRTHDAY HANK

[WateverWatever04]

HAPPPPPY BIRTHDAY! We could just punish you for forgetting and also do said punishment ourselves! lol 

[littlemisspoppiepie]

37 people dislike this :O, obviously not nerdfighters, :'( very unawesome

[sdagirl626]

Ya i kinda like John better, even though Hanks pretty great too

[beeguyification]

you are a nerdfighter you're made of awesome and you don't have an idea

[artvandelay13]

WHY THE FRICK WON'T IT LET ME WATCH THIS VIDEO??????????????

[STFUxSARAH]

You are soooo freakin' cute!

[raeg]

whenever you say that you're less popular than hank it makes me feel like i should go round to your house and give you affirmation

you are both equally awesome

[BRAAAAAAAT]

Happy Birthday ;)

[TheMusicKing713]

OMG CINCO DE MAYO! LOL

CAPS!!!

[tomatoe1111]

happy birthhday!!!

[krissygirl12385]

John, forever and always, you are my favorite brother

[OutcastAngelV]

@krissygirl12385 awee dont play favourites! they are both equally awesome!

[BurninSonoma]

Hm...I actually like John better than Hank by a teeny tiny bit.

But that's because I'm a writer too...

[LebnulKirec]

Eh, I'd say Fireball is the most popular vlog... puppy? vlogpuppy??

[4ndiland]

haha LOL party blowers! not legally allowed to answer that!

[lilclou69]

happy birthday Hank

[emilyyloveeyouu]

hank? the most popular? to me sure.. but not according to twitter :P

[eragonlover1]

COME TO RALEIGH. grrrr.

Nah, I love you guys anyways. But come anyway.

[chs2011xx]

p.s. your my favorite vbrother... js js

[lamarnza]

I miss this entry...

[SuperCursed13]

Merry Birthday Hank! (super belated)

[naethyCee]

happy birthday! dont mind the fact that this video was made 2 years ago. :)

[ginnyisdacoolest]

Hank has the same birthday as my real mum!

[diaverde09]

May 5 is also cinco de mayo. Yay! Viva

[naginnahehtmiolleh1]

Happy birthday

[chinareds54]

Woah, it's weird NOT hearing john refer to it as the dooblydoo now.

[trapjohnson]

ridiculously belated birthday hank, from a blue haired guy who might be able to outpuff your bro.

[hermeeown]

^ super awesome hair

[babylorne]

Happy birthday, Hank!!!

[MissheardMagic]

HAPPY BIRTHDAY HANK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

Even tho that was 1/2 years ago =P

-Disco31

DFTBA

[tropicola100]

HAPPY BIRTHDAY HANK! (although by now that was a half a year ago)

and u guys are equaly awesome

[chinareds54]

@tropicola100 or a year and half ago...

MERRY UNBIRTHDAY Hank!

[tropicola100]

@chinareds54

Gasp! it's my unbirthday too!!

[DarthLizzy]

Who voted and made Hank the favorite brother? I mean, I like him and all but you're my favorite. :)

[Nerdfighterfreak]

you rock hank!!!!! *inserts Nerdfighters symbol*

[LoveShiaGDSN]

I'm a bi-brother fan. ('tis a term I borrowed from the Supernatural fandom, which I am part of. It simply means that I love both brothers equally.)

[Nani101]

You look a little like Bill Nye in this video O.O

[RitchyWolf]

John--even though you think you're tone deaf, I think you sing pretty well

[Nicky7868]

Lol, Hank has the same birthday as one of my favorite anime characters! (Deidara)

Wow... I need a life, I know an anime character's birthday! xP

[beagle4864]

Happy Birthday Hank! (I'm really really sorry, I didn't know who you were when it was your birthday, and I'm really late!)

[theamazingcherie]

John, you've always been my favorite brother. :)

[SmellyJelly99]

John you're totally my favourite brother.

[VampireNya]

Me too. Don't tell anyone. >>

[kuroshokora]

I'm not surpised by the fame of Hank, but I personally adore them both in equal proportion.

[enmantra]

happy b day 1 year late XD

[mylovelydame21]

Happy Birthday, Hank! (I know I'm late, and I apologize profusely)

[BestFriendzOnline]

Happy Birthday, Hank. ;) late...

[ishirticapslock]

This is kind of...random and it doesn't matter, but is that a Four Seasons hotel? I stay at a Four Seasons hotel every year, and that look pretty identical to one of the rooms there.

[Xxelyssax007xX]

i think john is the more popular brother to me! woohoo!