@nekosama yea, totally agree, that sounds wicked but that's about it, the Tony Kakko version seems way better to me, still this song will ALWAYS rule. My fav forever ;)
by the way tarja is not reading lyrics. You should read the lyrics first and have a look at this that in those part she sings something like that : "...Your trembling paw IN MY HAND
Dreaming of that northern land..."
You really think that Tarja write the lyrics at hand?:) THINK , than write.
2:43 - 2:49 OMG !!!!! Its sounds heavenly incredibly, Marco had changed this part of vocals at highest and its sounds amazing!!!!!!!! Heaven on earth!!!
Of course you don't see Anette in this video! Anette couldn't hit those notes on a bet! At any rate, I love all three singers deeply (Marco, Tarja, Anette).
I'd rather not, this song was designed around tarja's voice, and probbly wouldn't be as great when Anette sings it. Just how for example "Amaranth" wouldn't fit with Tarja's voice.
I love watching Marco sing live, he has absolutely no emotion on his face at all. And I'm not saying that as a negative since I love his voice. Its just a funny quirk.
Maybe when singing semi-calmly but when singing songs where he really puts the power into his fantastic voice, he really looks angry and possessed: very intense, red face, wide eyes.
Great song. Was one of my first nightwish songs I ever heard. I loved from the begining. Awesome lyrics and great playing overall. I like the one with Tonny Kako from Sonata Artica better though
tarja got fired by all the member's of the band of NIGHTWISH and she's not coming back ,she got her own band and she's very happy with her success ,we wish her well and all the good luck.
*takes a deep breath* how can you confuse anette with tarja? they're absolutely nothing alike. ok, maybe you don't know how they look, but the voices couldn't be more different. no, it doesn't have anette, it has tarja, the original singer. maybe you should listen to the older albums. and then listen to dark passion play again, you obviously didn't listen to it well if you didn't realise that this couldn't possibly be anete.
... You think _I_ can't separate them from each other?! That was why I was puzzled, I was thinking that what the fuck are you going on about, the video has TARJA, not Anette, and it's screamingly OBVIOUS.
Then, just now, I read comments before yours and understood. My bad.
she probably could, it's within her range but some parts mght not be, she wouldnt be able to pull off the end or not as well anyway. good though anette is.
I wish they'd made an actual remake of 'Beauty and the Beast' with Marco and Tarja and included it on one of their CDs. But at least we have the original, which is one of the best Nightwish songs in my opinion :)
I think nightwish was power! I mean = music + voice! That was perfect, and I think that anette's voice doesn't had that kind of power that I'm talking about (and she's had I great voice, but not for nightwish), she's too "pop", and for me that is not nightwish =( ... the new songs with anette are good songs, but it doesn't have all the scent of nightwish!
Wow, that was beautiful. I wish you Tarja fanboys would shut up though. I admit, Tarja was great with Nightwish, but that era is over - get over it. It's Anette as lead vocalist now and if you don't like it, you can follow Tarja's solo career AND ONLY HERS. I'm personally a fan of both, so it's not like I'm being biast in saying this.
... I love this song but here... the guys are so... hmmm I don't how to describe it... they seem like tired and sad... even the music sounds different, I know that's the idea of this particular song... but... there's something that I don't like here
Marco is God! ...... MetalGod :))
TheFoufoutos7 2 months ago 3
I love Marco's interpretation, he keeps his notes way more longer than Tony or Tuomas and I love listening to that song with him because of that!
Rayaelle 2 months ago
Under his beard Marco doesn't have a chin. He has another bass!
sandamn85 5 months ago 2
Marcos beard looks so...unorganized.
HeadmasterPrime5 5 months ago
02:44 ok, my dear friend, if you say it that way... I´ll definitely love you before the last petal falls...
LadyVaipraFallent 5 months ago
Tony can't come close to Marco :)
AlexisGolnas 8 months ago 2
:O Marcoooo:Ame la Parte de Love me before the last petal falls xD
NwDevotion 9 months ago
mmm.... not bad, but i prefer the version made by tony :D
pulcippo 11 months ago
@nekosama yea, totally agree, that sounds wicked but that's about it, the Tony Kakko version seems way better to me, still this song will ALWAYS rule. My fav forever ;)
hyperdesignro 11 months ago 4
I love this, Anette just doesn't have tne vocal power to duet with Marco
Labm0m 1 year ago 3
that's hot!
laal67 1 year ago
BOOOOO! This is Tuomas' song Marco!
nothingtolookat 1 year ago
Marco's "love me before the last petal falls" is absolutely orgasmic.
nekosama 1 year ago 13
My favourite version is Tuomas's one <33
Agapoulinaki 1 year ago 6
@Agapoulinaki
I tottaly agree with you. he isn't maybe the best singer in the world but his version is special. i like it most
ausgox 1 year ago 3
Tarja & Marco - true Beauty and the Beast :)
Gergorable 1 year ago 14
curiousli, I prefeered this version than Tony's
hadessama93 1 year ago
this version is shorter than the original version they edit some of the song at the solo at 5:30 .
bignade00 1 year ago
Comment removed
Khimothy 1 year ago
MARCO IS AWESOME. I adore Tuomas, but dear God, please don't sing again, love :)
Khimothy 1 year ago
marco i love
SuperSwanHeart 1 year ago
Is there are recorded version with Marco?
desiccant 1 year ago
i prefer marco anyways... and as well in this one :)
midanelcancio 1 year ago
com è Tarja, nn t regge la voce oggi? oppure nelle registrazioni ti sistemano gli acuti?.. bà
SaraMetalSinger 1 year ago
this version of the song is different from the original ,they skiped the last part of the song .
bignade00 1 year ago
Marco is the Best !!!
thedarktimesofterion 1 year ago 6
tuoma sings the original from angels fall first teh song is original singing from tuomas
1880Chris 2 years ago 2
yeah no actually Tuomas sings the original from angels fall first
shroudwalker 2 years ago
i want a baby with you marco.
Forunth 2 years ago 3
Many people confuse it. On Angels Fall First album aka the original with Beauty, it is Tuomas, you can him live on montreal 2000.
HailDissection 2 years ago
tony kakko is singing in "from wishes from eternity". on the album (which is in fact the original version) it's tuomas.
BlackDizzy 2 years ago
i love marco, but tuomas does it better!! =)
Winterhe4rt 2 years ago 5
@Winterhe4rt come on!!... XD
I know you're a tuomas fan... but he can't sing XDXD
he admit it XD
sopotito 2 years ago 2
well i seriously like the tuomas and studio version better!
music is not about playing/ singing good, but about waht u feel while u do so.
and tuomas does that way better IMO.
just an oppinion, man. ^^
btw: why giving someone thumps down for that shit? LOL
Winterhe4rt 2 years ago
MAARRRRRRRRRRCOOOOOOOOOOO
XodusOnan 2 years ago 2
OMG MARCO U R AWESOMEEEEE!!!!
thelordofdarkness99 2 years ago 6
marco is better than tuomas singing this song...love it
oooooooooouuuuuuuu 2 years ago 4
thats because tuomas isnt singing that osng u fool
therens13 2 years ago
uhm...yeah he is. in the original version it's tuomas. might wanna refrain from calling other people fools when you're the foolish one.
BlackDizzy 2 years ago 5
Na parte 2:22 parece q a Tarja boto uma colinha na mão pra conseguir lembrar a letra xDD
tbm num eh pra menos... segunda musik do primeiro album xD
Tarja Rulez
NW Rulez
jean36554519 2 years ago
by the way tarja is not reading lyrics. You should read the lyrics first and have a look at this that in those part she sings something like that : "...Your trembling paw IN MY HAND
Dreaming of that northern land..."
You really think that Tarja write the lyrics at hand?:) THINK , than write.
ViolenceOfWind 2 years ago 6
Unfortunately there is only so much we can ask of certain people.
PiperBloodheart 2 years ago
Oh *__*
I really wanted to hear Marco sing this song! *__*
Rowina18 2 years ago 2
2:43 - 2:49 OMG !!!!! Its sounds heavenly incredibly, Marco had changed this part of vocals at highest and its sounds amazing!!!!!!!! Heaven on earth!!!
ViolenceOfWind 2 years ago 6
totally agree
XodusOnan 2 years ago
Tarja is reading the lyrics in her hand!!! lol!
rafarads 2 years ago
This is a really cool version. Sounds like it's been transposed down as well.
Summers4545 2 years ago
OMG! What a great song! Marco sang this really awesome!
MontanaPB 2 years ago 6
Tony better on this I think
but I still love you Marco <3
MyHandInTheCookieJar 2 years ago 47
@MyHandInTheCookieJar
I agree with you on this one!
ely010101 1 year ago
@MyHandInTheCookieJar Who the fuck is Tony? :P
Khimothy 1 year ago
@Khimothy Tony was the male singer for this song on the "over the hills and far away" album
yyhkingsburg 1 year ago
@yyhkingsburg No, he was the male singer for 'Astral Romance' on the 'Over the Hills and Far Away' album
JaketheSnakeESP 1 year ago
@MyHandInTheCookieJar toumas origonaly sang. in the album that is, so i think toumas is way better
evilass334 1 year ago
@MyHandInTheCookieJar lets see Tony sing it AND be thumping away on the bass ;)
MrDeylen07 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
anette sucks:P
Tarja rulezz!! /,,/
TheVanaheim 2 years ago
Hm, I don't happen to see Anette in this video, do you? Get over it, Tarja's gone, so shut up about it.
I don't know who sounds better on this song, Marco, or Tony. I love them both, and they both sound great..
Daikiirai 2 years ago 3
Of course you don't see Anette in this video! Anette couldn't hit those notes on a bet! At any rate, I love all three singers deeply (Marco, Tarja, Anette).
-Lochness
ShaeAogiri 2 years ago
Ugh. That is so annoying that I don't even know what to say to that.
Daikiirai 2 years ago
@Daikiirai Who is Tony?
Khimothy 1 year ago
@Khimothy Tony Kakko. He sang live on this song on one of their DVDs. He's also the singer of Sonata Artica.
Daikiirai 1 year ago
I wish I could hear Tuomas sing this :( The only video I can find is such bad quality I can hardly hear him!
hiddenxleafxninja 2 years ago 2
On the album Angels Fall First, I think it was recorded with Tuomas singing.
innosmarto 2 years ago 6
if you type in beauty and the beast in youtube the first video thatt comes up should be a amv of beauty and the beast - that's got toumas singing
Theangelofdeathwolf 2 years ago
Tarja have awesome voice...the most beautiful women voice i ever heared..:)
TheVanaheim 2 years ago 34
yea...
:)
but anette voice isn't bad also..
marco quite cool..
The44Xavierz 2 years ago 6
@TheVanaheim are you kidding me lol
darkstarsergio 4 months ago
Ha, look how short Tuomas' hair is here!
StarkMessanger 2 years ago 2
They were very young in the first pic, Tarja looks really beautiful
MarbleThrower 2 years ago
I prefer Tony Kakko (on "From wish to eternity" DVD)
thorus974 2 years ago 2
I would love to hear this with Anette. I love this song.
Nightowljrm 2 years ago
I'd rather not, this song was designed around tarja's voice, and probbly wouldn't be as great when Anette sings it. Just how for example "Amaranth" wouldn't fit with Tarja's voice.
Vitaire 2 years ago 3
yuk!
dcow123 2 years ago
I agree... Tuomas singing this song added a more special touch. (I say more, because every Nightwish song is special in some way. ^^)
Nightowljrm 2 years ago
Tuomas' voice on this song def. did sound better than in the other songs, imo.
wonderfoam 2 years ago
Marco have his own style, and i like it :P
Ljuba95 2 years ago 4
lol i love how Tuomas is trying to play while the others aren't ready.
dontreadmyusername0 2 years ago 3
Marco is the freaking BEAST.
XodusOnan 2 years ago 2
Marco and Tarja, one fucking perfect combination
TompsonBG 2 years ago 7
I love watching Marco sing live, he has absolutely no emotion on his face at all. And I'm not saying that as a negative since I love his voice. Its just a funny quirk.
MetalCore84 2 years ago
Maybe when singing semi-calmly but when singing songs where he really puts the power into his fantastic voice, he really looks angry and possessed: very intense, red face, wide eyes.
JamminJimmyClark 2 years ago 2
me gusta como suena con marco!
tarjascabbia 2 years ago
Marco rooooockkkks!!!
fairyxcorpse 2 years ago 5
What year was this?
StarkMessanger 2 years ago
2002
f2szilard666 2 years ago
MARCO!!!!!!!!!!! I LOVE YOU!!!!!!!!
THESHKY 2 years ago 3
Great song. Was one of my first nightwish songs I ever heard. I loved from the begining. Awesome lyrics and great playing overall. I like the one with Tonny Kako from Sonata Artica better though
ric2401 3 years ago
tarja forgot the lyrics at 2:22 !!! OMG
haha just kidding..but looks like she forgot that part and wrote it on her hand xD XD jajaja
R2ROrancid 3 years ago 3
Haha she's cute =)
cath2204 2 years ago
Lol, Tuomas actually forgot the lyrics when he sand 'em in 2000 at Montreal. =P
Nightowljrm 2 years ago
really? at which second? that's on that video around here that tarja aproaches him with the mic right?
R2ROrancid 2 years ago
Yeah, if you re-watch it and pay attention, he throws his head back when he forgets. You can see Tarja mouthing the words. =P
Nightowljrm 2 years ago
yeah i noticed xd moments ago i was watching the video : P cool haha i thought that he was concetrated on playing or smth..has happened to me too :)
R2ROrancid 2 years ago
Ouch didnt knew that Marco play with pick :S
zigmaister 3 years ago
Ofcourse he does :)
f2szilard666 3 years ago
That's so not cool..Fingers rox ^^
zigmaister 3 years ago 2
Wonderful with Marco! And Tarja with the wordless notes at the end sounded so beautiful. Thanks for posting this!
Estelindis 3 years ago 5
And they all look SO tired
Ladydarkshadow 3 years ago
OOHHH I LOVE IT WITH MARCO!!!!
Ladydarkshadow 3 years ago 3
tarja got fired by all the member's of the band of NIGHTWISH and she's not coming back ,she got her own band and she's very happy with her success ,we wish her well and all the good luck.
bignade00 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
marco sang great but it was slower..i didn't loved it! just liked it :P
R2ROrancid 3 years ago
Is it just me or Tarja seems really bored/annoyed while singing this song at this video?
DaviSonata 3 years ago
looks tired, probably one of last tracks in show
Shellewell 3 years ago
goooooood!! she is stuuupid.. soo stupid..
but she's got such a great voice...
fortal12 3 years ago
It's funny how only Tarja gets dressed up fancily and Marco and the rest just wear clothes as if they're going out for the day.
TheDarkmage 3 years ago 3
Marco Hietala. WHAT A WINNER! This is awesome!
ZombieMarshmallow23 3 years ago 4
Marcos voice and Tajas voice combined in a duet! great! amazing!
Ale22992 3 years ago 3
awesome version!
thanks for sharing!
ian3000gt 3 years ago
I'm so glad to see that this isn't filled with Annette flamers, so much as I loved Tarja :3
ENDiTunes 3 years ago 7
wich concert is this?
I want to download it
neofrio 3 years ago
end of innocence Dvd
kernelcoem 3 years ago
Thanks.!!
neofrio 3 years ago
Tracklist stated on their site. So it is The Beauty and the Beast.
1. Elvenpath
2. Beauty And The Beast
3. The Carpenter
4. Astral Romance
5. Angels Fall First
6. Tutankhamen
7. Nymphomaniac Fantasia
8. Know Why The Nightingale Sings
9. Lappi (Lapland)
HailDissection 3 years ago
Marco showing Tuomas how its done...LOL
XodusOnan 3 years ago
MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMhhhhhh....I say for Marco.....The Beauty of the beast (it´s cute!! jaja)
cesulins 3 years ago
ah! sorry hehehe :p
kernelcoem 3 years ago
It´s Beauty OOOFFFFF the Beast.
cesulins 3 years ago
sorry homie this is beauty ANDDDDDD the beast.
If you wanna hear beuty OFFFFOFFFFOFOFOF the beast, check the song in Century Child album, the last track. ;)
anyway thanks for the views and comments!
kernelcoem 3 years ago
sorry, but this isn't beauty of the beast.
OneMoreNightToLive 3 years ago
very good!!! :)
Lolkita 3 years ago
aguante la version con tony kakko.. igual marko es un personaje.. q onda q le pone el tipo..
cooperwishmaster 3 years ago
they should start playing this live with anette:)
systemoscar 3 years ago 13
uh, I'm not sure if this would be a good idea ...
Yavanna77 3 years ago
No. Anette could not handle the operatic parts.
OceanbornAngel 3 years ago 2
She has taken her own style to the operatic parts in songs like the Siren. so she could do it
nightwishfan60 3 years ago 7
Fully agreed. Anette/Marco-version would rock.
TheHopesWereHigh 3 years ago 6
i bet she can't do the high ahs at the end of the song. and since this is one of best parts of the songs, i think i'll skip.
BlackDizzy 3 years ago
For one, the whole song is quite.. Well. I think they have it nailed. ^^' Just watch the ending!
TwicePea 3 years ago
i meant anette wouldn't be able to do it.
BlackDizzy 3 years ago 3
It... doesn't have Anette? *puzzled*
TwicePea 3 years ago
*takes a deep breath* how can you confuse anette with tarja? they're absolutely nothing alike. ok, maybe you don't know how they look, but the voices couldn't be more different. no, it doesn't have anette, it has tarja, the original singer. maybe you should listen to the older albums. and then listen to dark passion play again, you obviously didn't listen to it well if you didn't realise that this couldn't possibly be anete.
BlackDizzy 3 years ago
... You think _I_ can't separate them from each other?! That was why I was puzzled, I was thinking that what the fuck are you going on about, the video has TARJA, not Anette, and it's screamingly OBVIOUS.
Then, just now, I read comments before yours and understood. My bad.
TwicePea 3 years ago
oh, now i understand. sorry for being harsh on you for nothing :)
BlackDizzy 3 years ago
That's alright. n__n'
TwicePea 3 years ago
yyou mean marco will do the beauty part and anette beast part :P?
just kiddin' but i think tarja's voice and looks are the kind of beauty that tuomas wrote about..
kotopoulo13 3 years ago 4
Haha. :P No, he actually wrote it about, you know... the film. It's a great one, you should see it if you haven't.
TheHopesWereHigh 3 years ago
i don't mean that hge wrote it for her i mean that tarja fits more than anette in the belle role.. :/
kotopoulo13 3 years ago
but she would do it horribly wrong
Allard88 3 years ago
No she would do it in her own style
nightwishfan60 3 years ago 3
she probably could, it's within her range but some parts mght not be, she wouldnt be able to pull off the end or not as well anyway. good though anette is.
Shellewell 3 years ago
I wish they'd made an actual remake of 'Beauty and the Beast' with Marco and Tarja and included it on one of their CDs. But at least we have the original, which is one of the best Nightwish songs in my opinion :)
Momothelemur100 3 years ago 8
I think nightwish was power! I mean = music + voice! That was perfect, and I think that anette's voice doesn't had that kind of power that I'm talking about (and she's had I great voice, but not for nightwish), she's too "pop", and for me that is not nightwish =( ... the new songs with anette are good songs, but it doesn't have all the scent of nightwish!
Tarja COME BACK!!! =(
ps: sorry for my english.
Gohiko 3 years ago
it's not a question of Tarja coming back, she got fired. everyone always comments as if she left by her own choice
Shellewell 3 years ago 3
wow!! I've never seen this version! with marco singing
great!
sopotito 3 years ago 5
Wow, that was beautiful. I wish you Tarja fanboys would shut up though. I admit, Tarja was great with Nightwish, but that era is over - get over it. It's Anette as lead vocalist now and if you don't like it, you can follow Tarja's solo career AND ONLY HERS. I'm personally a fan of both, so it's not like I'm being biast in saying this.
Nightowljrm 3 years ago 6
I agree with you 100%.
sipulirinkeli 3 years ago
i wanna hear tarja and marco singing together again...
meretrixmala 3 years ago 3
me too... but maybe in 10 years :S XD
sopotito 3 years ago
I love the Marco´s voice...perfect...
Isanan 3 years ago 5
... I love this song but here... the guys are so... hmmm I don't how to describe it... they seem like tired and sad... even the music sounds different, I know that's the idea of this particular song... but... there's something that I don't like here
fercychan 3 years ago 3
This version sounds better than original song in the Angels Falls First Album. I miss you, Nightwish, I mean Tarja, Tuomas, Marco, Emppu and Jukka.
alejonightwish 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
muy buen video.. ojala esos tiempos regresaran.. amo a tarja y odio con todas mis fuerzas a anette!!!!!
tefomontecalvo 3 years ago
Jaja..Ya somos Dos amigo!!..La Banda Le queda Grande a Anette!!..Tarja es La Mejor!!..
gabriela3j 3 years ago
Emppus solo!!! =D
I loves it!!!
MoNzTeR969 3 years ago 4
marco hietala and tarja turunrn are thr best!
FanAHF 3 years ago 3
Tarja and Marco rules!!
BlackDahlia333 3 years ago 13
canta bien marco
morgoth969 3 years ago 6
Argentina Te Ama Tarja :)
bufiexperimento 3 years ago 3
You should def change (correct) the info.
You know it's Tarja..
Anette & Tarja each deserve more respect then to have someone purposely misrepresent their performances.
HahnsMom 3 years ago 9
Who's in the picture with Tarja?
Akantyss 3 years ago
Yes, and the T and H in "Nightwish" are wrong. (A)
kSp3kSp3 4 years ago 3
stradiviper is correct. that's Tarja Turunen.
zirateb 4 years ago 3
yeah i know, but it wrote ANETTE because of i wanted to more people watch my video, and anette is being popular at the moment ;)
kernelcoem 4 years ago
very very good
kSp3kSp3 4 years ago 7
muy muy bueno el video, seguro ke os argentino (?)
nunka lo dejast en la pc para ke yo lo suba!!!
subilo esta noche y akordate del favor
juanmadraco 4 years ago
awesome :D thnx
konczeizs 4 years ago 4