goldfish male or female?

[fcuk0828]

I think fish #2 is a male and #3 is a female and the first one was hard to tail since cam was up to close

[4dEgrEE]

1.)Males GF would have pointy pelvic fins.

2.) Its caudal tail is longer (imagine a peacock with its pretty "fan"

3.) Males are longer, skinny, short (smaller), but this is not always the case.

Source: my experience with breeding gf.

just let me know if you've finally grasped the wonderful aspect of being able to identify goldfish genders. It just takes practice and you'll be like an expert!

[4dEgrEE]

How to distinguish bwt fe/males:

1.) Females GF would have round pelvic fins.

2.) Its caudal tail would be shorter than the males

3.) Check out the body size; females are usually rounder and fatter ,but this is not always the case if it's your first time distinguishing bwt goldfish genders.

[4dEgrEE]

Your camera is just too UPCLOSE and personal with the fish. BTW, your fish are cute! Fish number 3 is female. Look at its short tail versus the first two goldfish with long tails and pointy pelvic fin (look up these words and you'll know what I mean).

It's just so hard to tell wether the first two are males because your camera is so close that I'm not only trying to look at the tails,but also its pelvic.

[Franke123100]

THERE BOTH FAT SO THEY ARE FEMALES

NO OFFENSE THIS IS AQUALY REAL THATS HOW U CAN IDENTIFY FEMALES

THANKS IN ADVANCE

:)

:)

:)

:)

:)

[galvinlim11]

Fish 1&2 is female fish3 is male

[1000chetos]

the #1=femal #2=male  #3=male check my videos are in spanish but is it easy macho is male hembra es female

[fdelvalle11]

Females have the thing on the back near the tail fin on the bottom

[wasabiphobia]

fish 1 female fish 2 female 3 male

[Amy24x7Official]

#1 and #2 are females, females usually are fatter than males due to eggs inside them.

[krazy4warriors]

@Amy24x7Official

I know my fish are different genders-- i know it-- but my female dont have eggs, or a big belly.

[ComeFlyWivMe]

HI all!, hope you all had a great Christmas and a happy new year! just would like to say, that this is 1Filmproducer, im jsut making a comment to say, that this channel comeflywivme is my new channel , cause as some of you might already know, i love flying as another hobby i do, so please subscribe to it!, much appriciated,

CFWM ( or 1FP)

[mesud18]

i need help if a goldfish spits its food out it mouth does it mean he dont like that food or he dont wanna eat??

[ComeFlyWivMe]

@mesud18 thats normal for goldfish!, goldfish do not have teeth, so there way of chewing, is to suck food in and blow it back out, then keep doin it, sometimes they do it once, then later they will eat it, its normal, my goldfish that are in the video did do it, there fine, but if you wanna upload a video response to this, then i'll take a look for you :D

[ComeFlyWivMe]

@mesud18 oh and btw, this is 1filmproducer, its just my other channel, this is my video, jsut commenting on my own video through another channel of mine aha

[ApertureScience21]

youi have got beautiful goldfish :-)

[1Filmproducer]

@ApertureScience21 thank you very much!

[SpanishhKidTV]

1 female 2,3 male

[adamwilkes123]

male: white spots on gills and on the pectoral fins on the edge. Their pectoral fins are thicker too. also males anus seems to concave (go inwards slightly)

female: no white dots, pectoral fins thinner and anus convex's (sticks out slightly)

[EldeMarjo]

@adamwilkes123 tnx for the info men. like like cheers

[akeames]

And it I remember correctly, the vent of the female is more rounded and pronounced the the males...

[usher4513]

fish 2 male



[usher4513]

number 1 male

[Erkerkerk123]

1&3- females

2 - male. I just know it k?

[Jillianwebkinzrule09]

its a male theyre all males

[Megi1616]

1 male , 2 male , 3 female

[TheLoveJazmine]

all females boys are skinny  girls are fat

[LakeOwen2011]

fatty gorilla

[sreevenkadesh13]

if gold fish have white dots in their gills its male and the distance between the tail and stomach have long distance.but female doesn't have the white dots on the gills and the distance wil be less between stomach and the tail,and big belly which shows it as female.

[1Filmproducer]

@sreevenkadesh13 correct mate!, thanks

[bulmer24]

@sreevenkadesh13 goldfish do not have stomach

[1Filmproducer]

@bulmer24 correction, yes they do mate, there stomach is the same size as there eye aprox, it works the same as us, :) ty for the comment, made me think for a sec

[gottaluvbirds]

@bulmer24 you must be the most retarded waste of oxegen ever born.

[lol73984]

@sreevenkadesh13 they r all females dar



[EldeMarjo]

@sreevenkadesh13 tnx men know i know what is male or Female, c'z i wanna Breed my Gold Fish.

[TheMartindance]

fish one: male

fish two: female

fish tree: female

[chuy1682]

Fish #1 is male

fish #2 male

fish#3 male

All male

[hamstergamer1]

how do u tell if there male or female?

[1Filmproducer]

@hamstergamer1 Hi, you can tell by looking at there gills in mating time, if they have white spots on them then it generly means there male, this is the best way i think, also femals will tend to be a bit bigger than the males, but not by much.

Hope this helped

Mike

[Pop12646Okami]

How about looking it up? There are many informative websites that will tell you how to identify if they are male or female. Then, you'll know what they are in the future when you get more. :)

[1Filmproducer]

@Pop12646Okami hi, yep looked it up a little while back thanks. Thank yuo anyways for the suggestion :)

Mike

[Pop12646Okami]

@1Filmproducer You're welcome :)

[deepz93]

all r male

[1Filmproducer]

@deepz93 thank you :)

[Ctm1008]

1=female

2=male

3=femAle

[1Filmproducer]

@Ctm1008 thanks mate :), always good to hear the answers you all have to give me :)

[27mehmood]

hey we have to seprate the fish from the breeding box

[1Filmproducer]

@27mehmood yep, seperate them else they'll get eaten :)

[Daymian20]

2.male



[Daymian20]

i think its probably a male

[27mehmood]

hey wat to do wen my gold fish is pregnent

[1Filmproducer]

@27mehmood Hi, the first thing you need to do is make sure its pregnant, as in it may have a bladder deases, if it is then lets get started!. First you need to have lots of plant cover and feed her well. If you wish for the babys to survive then you need to have a breeding box, you can get them really cheap from your pets shop. then once she starts to lay on the bottom or cvircle plants and you feel shes ready then place her into the breeding box, once shhes done it then put her in the tank

1FP

[1Filmproducer]

Respond to this video...  then rerite to me :) goodluck

[1Filmproducer]

@27mehmood Respond to this video... then rerite to me :) goodluck

[spiritgirl2796]

I need some Help finding my fish gender also If anyone can help :) Just posted it on my channel, Thanks :D

[1Filmproducer]

@spiritgirl2796 thanks

[amvaca]

if you had a flea then its probably a fleamale

[1Filmproducer]

@amvaca oh dear, ahah nice one :)

[XtremeRCTV]

Again this is an emotional video :( Please check out 1FP Time lapse, it is erotic :)

[1Filmproducer]

@XtremeRCTV you confuse me miserably aha :P

[XtremeRCTV]

@1Filmproducer :P

[pluizen]

1st fish is a female and 2nd fish is a male simple bescause a male has white things on their belly and female fishes doesn,t have white things on thier bellfollow me on facebook my name is mohammed hussain on facebook

[1Filmproducer]

@pluizen thanks and will do

[pluizen]

1st fish is a female and 2nd fish is a male simple bescause a male has white things on their belly and female fishes doesn,t have white things on thier belly

[ruckaisawesome]

rip...

[1Filmproducer]

@ruckaisawesome lol

[XtremeRCTV]

@1Filmproducer How dare you lol :( i got attached to them to :( LOL

[1Filmproducer]

@XtremeRCTV lol yeah, i was meaning lol thanks ahah

[1Filmproducer]

@ruckaisawesome btw when i said lol, i meant thank you as in aha thanks, i loved them dearly as i had them since they were babys, tiny little beggers they were!, :'( thanks and im filming tutorials as i write this aha, will post them soon!!, thnk you again

1FP

[XtremeRCTV]

@1Filmproducer Beggers? why didn't you feed them more then? You have know idea Mike, no idea LOL :P

[1Filmproducer]

@XtremeRCTV the reason why i dont feed them cos there dead dumbass!! lol brother, god you just dont know what ive just done for my fish aha, it was exspensive ( not as in how much cause i got a lot for my money and a great dicount) just alot of money to spend on fish but was totally worth it 100% new video up btw people

[harleyquinn1152]

@1Filmproducer sorry fish dont have female or male its true and i dont know how they have eggs



[1Filmproducer]

Hi everyone

Wuz due to put up a time lapse but got right to the end and was about to upload and it sayed error and deleted the whole thing!!!! really annoyed, try and redo it for tommorow,

Mike

[gomezgiovanni1]

there all female

[Henrybailey1]

fish 1 girl fish 2 boy fish 3 girl

[Henrybailey1]

fish 1 girl

[mrrizween]

female



[1Filmproducer]

@mrrizween thank you

[dragonslayer124120]

i have oranda too!

[1Filmproducer]

@dragonslayer124120 nice! there great fish

[dragonslayer124120]

@1Filmproducer i have 3 and they are babies and let me pet them! :D

[1Filmproducer]

@dragonslayer124120 wow nice mate im thinking of buying a 80gallon tank and having a giant gourami so i can pet him. I'll hopefully make videos if I buy it as well. This will all start in 4 weeks!!

[dragonslayer124120]

@1Filmproducer my fish taank is in direct sunlight cause we had no where else to put it

but i clean more often as well

[1Filmproducer]

@dragonslayer124120 lol nice, im just a tad confused on how we got from our other conversational to this but having aquariums in direct sunlight in'st always a problem. The algae will grow rapidly meaning you'll need to clean more frequently but other than that it should be fine. My tropical tank is and the algae grows really fast but other than that its all good. Thank you for commenting

1FP

[dragonslayer124120]

@1Filmproducer ps . girl , boy , girl you can tell by there mouths ps. orandas lay 1000s of eggs!

[1Filmproducer]

@dragonslayer124120 Thank you, i found that out when i cleaned and found hundreds of them scattered all of my back wall of the tank lo

Thnxs

1FP

[1Filmproducer]

@dragonslayer124120 ps i subscribed to you, if you couldnt be so kind a return the favour i would really appreciate that!

Thanks

1FP

[dragonslayer124120]

@1Filmproducer ty i be ure too

[1Filmproducer]

@dragonslayer124120 thank you

[SuperPianowizard]

Whoever disliked this clearly doesn't know whether they are Male or Female

[cloudyohten]

#1 girl #2 boy #3 girl

[Alien11Boy]

2 girls 1 boy

[beats900]

1#girl 2#girl 3#girl

[1Filmproducer]

@beats900 thank you

[sweetluckydog12]

1 boy 2 boy 3 boy

[1Filmproducer]

@sweetluckydog12 thank you

[drizdmm]

interesting

[1Filmproducer]

@drizdmm Thanks :) make sure to check the videos out at the start! thank you

[Bilvysaur]

1#.boy

2#.boy

3#.girl

[1Filmproducer]

@Bilvysaur Thanks!!

[davidd1928]

fish #1 is a female

[1Filmproducer]

Hey Youtubers! as my brother pointed out to me that i never told you that when i cleaned my aqurium out after the tragic death of my fish, i found goldfish eggs attached to the back of the tank!, just thought id share that with you!, please thumbs up this so everyone can see it!

Thanks again everyone for your support and remember to subscribe and feel free to ask any questions!



[Incie100]

@1Filmproducer The eggs are probably unfertilized, meaning no male was there to put a baby inside the eggs. If the fish was still alive, she would simply eat the eggs. Im sorry. :( Maybe go to a fish store, and try again,

[1Filmproducer]

@Incie100 I was thinking that. Ive got a tropical tank which im hopfully gunna make videos of but thts not a bad idea,

1FP

[CyBr94]

its april check if the are white spots around the gills because it means that it is male.... i think.....

[1Filmproducer]

@CyBr94 thanks

[alheiser]

Idk but fish #2 is really pretty

[1Filmproducer]

@alheiser thank you very much, i thought that aswell, i miss them dearly :(

[SuperPianowizard]

@1Filmproducer Yer i know how you feel! I only had them in ma room for 2 weeks and i already got attached to them :'( and yer the 2nd was well fit and all!!! Btw did you tell ya views that we found eggs? :L

[1Filmproducer]

@SuperPianowizard no i didnt!

[SuperPianowizard]

@1Filmproducer :L don't you think it would be a good idea to tell them then??

[MrHazman2000]

Fish 1 is a Male, 2&3 are Females x

[1Filmproducer]

@MrHazman2000 thank you everyone!!

[smileyflyz]

@MrHazman2000 how do you know, im putting a video on soon of them can you tell me if " diddy the fishy" is boy or girl

[cameronwilliamson121]

i have a goldfish and i dont know if its male or female?

[booty612mpls]

@cameronwilliamson121 the males has white little pimples around the two front fins and around the gails.

[talkinggina1]

1 - female and the rest male

[1Filmproducer]

@talkinggina1 thanks mate

[Henrybailey1]

u carnt tell the difrence in myn

[rajaputh]

I think the first 2 gold fish are Females and the third one is a male but not old enough to mate.

Now it is the best season to buy new gold fish and spring is coming, may be you can see them mating and get frys all around

[1Filmproducer]

Hello Everyone!! Thanks for all the comments and view that ive been getting,

But sadly last sunday due to a sudden increase in bacteria all three goldfish sadly passed away very quickly! :(

But please keep the comments coming cause id still love to know wat you think!

Thanks

1Filmproducer

btw check out my new vid, Tropical tank

[SuperPianowizard]

@1Filmproducer Sorry to hear of your loss. I just lost 3 goldfish aswell on the same day aswell! I know how your feeling but try not crimiting suicide!!! LOL bro!

[1Filmproducer]

@SuperPianowizard not funny brother!

[SuperPianowizard]

@1Filmproducer Dont worry man,cause ever little ding is gunna be alrite dont worry man :L Soz for ya lose bro :L

[SuperPianowizard]

Tht one person is a he/she

[broli85]

I think all are female. Not too clear though. If you want to breed just add a spawning mob and increase the temperature by a couple of degrees. if you have a couple they will definetly spawn.

[Coolboyert123]

they all are females

[TehTofoMon]

hey filmproducer the male is the one wtih white gill plates

[m111254]

fish one is female because it not pratty as fish two i thing so

[123codfan]

the first one

[1Filmproducer]

@123codfan

Thanks

[123codfan]

ITS A MALE IT HAS DIMPLES NO JOKE I KEEP EM MYSELF

[1Filmproducer]

@123codfan which one is a male

[FunnyAccent1]

If you would let them talk I could tell you from the sound of their voice who's male or female :)

[1Filmproducer]

@FunnyAccent1 haha very funny ..but i really need sensible comments

thanks anyway :)

[seeyou414]

They all look like females to me expect #2 Could be a male but looks more like a female. With fancy goldfish look at their vent area that is where the poop comes out males will have a small dent like someone punch a hole and females will have a white like bloob sticking out if it does not have bloob her vent area will also have a dent up sticking out