A lot of the tonality of a piece depends on the range of the voices. However, keys have a personality. This piece would not sound the same in G as in G-flat. I don't understand it, but it's true....
Reasonable question. It may depend on the range for the seperate voices (SATB). Try to forget the number of flats & sharps while singing. It all turns out to be do-re-mi (if in major) in principal. Personally I would write all christmas carols in E flat or A flat major, 'cause these key signatures reflect the dark of night and the cold of winter during Christmas. If you raise f.i. E flat by one semitone (thus E) you'll experience a different feeling.........
This is one of our standard pieces during the 9-lessons-and-carols event in the runup to Christmas. I wonder why G-flat was chosen rather than, say, F or G? I'd have thought they'd have been easier keys to play in, but maybe it doesn't matter - mostly black keys instead of white ones, what the heck ha. Perhaps E-flat or A-flat are trickier. Can anybody more knowledgeable advise?
well when you're on the same level as this choir, ochestral trickyness of E flats isn't really something to worry about;)
by the way, who is this choir acctually, they don't have a very british sound, but clearly they're not american. sounds european though... or am i completely of?
If ever there where a composer that influences earthly choirs to sing like heavenly ones.....John must be that person! Sitting here with tears in my eyes. Happy christmas to all.
Thank you for this beautiful carol of Rutter that's very English in spirit. Given the very fine choral tradition there the glorious singing here is not unexpected. It brings peace, goodwill and so much light in these benighted times. Merry Christmas everyone! sd goh (malaysia)
Thanks for posting this. Of all the compositions ever created for the holidays, this by far shines the brightest. I someday hope to meet Mr. Rutter, shake his hand and thank him.
For me, this Christmas will, frankly, suck. I'm not sure that I'll look forward to the holiday ever again in my life. But hearing this reminds that things were once different, and perhaps the season is a happy one for someone, somewhere.
Amaizing
MrFilwin 2 years ago
GOD what a beautiful song. :,)
crimsondoor513 2 years ago 6
so sweet it's bad for the teeth
dvanroijen 2 years ago 37
muy bonita obra, com la mayoria de John Rutter
nefta235 2 years ago 4
we are playing this for band <3
lexaTrexa 2 years ago
We're playing this for our Christmas Concert in band. I think we play it every year. I love it [:
onyxfireball 2 years ago
this song is great!
kingplayer14 2 years ago 3
we sing it :)
I love it :)
but I love everything if it is english :P
Lihanee 2 years ago
it beatiful! i has sing it with my choir :D
i love it!
CounterNic 2 years ago 25
A lot of the tonality of a piece depends on the range of the voices. However, keys have a personality. This piece would not sound the same in G as in G-flat. I don't understand it, but it's true....
Kierran0000 2 years ago
Hi,
Reasonable question. It may depend on the range for the seperate voices (SATB). Try to forget the number of flats & sharps while singing. It all turns out to be do-re-mi (if in major) in principal. Personally I would write all christmas carols in E flat or A flat major, 'cause these key signatures reflect the dark of night and the cold of winter during Christmas. If you raise f.i. E flat by one semitone (thus E) you'll experience a different feeling.........
Best regards
Nico
Netherlands
nico1096 2 years ago 7
Thank you Nico!
magpie4321 2 years ago 4
Yes. I see your point. Thank you, Nico. :)
Carlos516ese 2 years ago
This is one of our standard pieces during the 9-lessons-and-carols event in the runup to Christmas. I wonder why G-flat was chosen rather than, say, F or G? I'd have thought they'd have been easier keys to play in, but maybe it doesn't matter - mostly black keys instead of white ones, what the heck ha. Perhaps E-flat or A-flat are trickier. Can anybody more knowledgeable advise?
kapariz44 2 years ago
well when you're on the same level as this choir, ochestral trickyness of E flats isn't really something to worry about;)
by the way, who is this choir acctually, they don't have a very british sound, but clearly they're not american. sounds european though... or am i completely of?
MMKursch 2 years ago
omg this song is truly ahmazing,
i sing this for the choir i was in,
and it sounded ahmazing,
i was an alto one :)
neveelicious 3 years ago 2
This song is simply fantastic. Ive loved it since watching it being performed by Vons Steubens wonderful band and choir back in the late 80s.
DJ100674 3 years ago
Sounds so similar to Angel's Carol
skyeyez101 3 years ago
seriously, im getting shivers all the time.. THIS near to cry.. good job :')
Gorith89 3 years ago 4
If ever there where a composer that influences earthly choirs to sing like heavenly ones.....John must be that person! Sitting here with tears in my eyes. Happy christmas to all.
fiddleup 3 years ago 8
Thank you for this beautiful carol of Rutter that's very English in spirit. Given the very fine choral tradition there the glorious singing here is not unexpected. It brings peace, goodwill and so much light in these benighted times. Merry Christmas everyone! sd goh (malaysia)
301250 3 years ago 12
Thank you and Merry Xmas as well.
Nico
The Netherlands (Holland)
nico1096 3 years ago 2
I love this song and the singing is so beautiful!
cmars861 3 years ago 2
We have to play this song in band.I like it, It's pretty cool:]
JameeDaBaller 3 years ago 2
Yes, you can!
Just send this contrib to all your choir members AND the pianoplayer, to listen to it a 100 times!
Success!
nico1096 3 years ago 8
breath-taking...! :')
titaniclives23 3 years ago
Thanks for posting this. Of all the compositions ever created for the holidays, this by far shines the brightest. I someday hope to meet Mr. Rutter, shake his hand and thank him.
For me, this Christmas will, frankly, suck. I'm not sure that I'll look forward to the holiday ever again in my life. But hearing this reminds that things were once different, and perhaps the season is a happy one for someone, somewhere.
moproducer 3 years ago 2