And to be honest, he was right in all his theories. According to his theories he shouldn't choose the wine in front of him or the wine in front of the other guy. So he should have come to the conclusion that no wine was safe.
@DramaMC It might have worked if he Wesley had offered him the opportunity to switch the glasses round himself afterwards so only the Sicilian would know if they'd changed position (he'd turn his back). Otherwise it doesn't make much sense. If u knew where the poison was and ur opponent chose the non-poison, you would be effectively committing suicide. He should of known Wesley was a man of honour, so would not not drink the poisoned cup if he had to. I guess he got sidetracked by Australia :)
@Martintheauthor I'm assuming the given pretence as presented by the Man in Black. He knew both cups were poisoned (as do we), but he would need to offer Vizzini the chance to switch cups to retain the illusion (assuming Vizzini was half as smart as he thought he was, because of the points of logic I outlined earlier). The rest of the conversation could then follow along largely similar lines, and Vizzini could reveal whether the cups had been switched after they had both drunk.
@Martintheauthor Vizzini should have realised the poison was in both cups, for Westley's remaining in honour commands it. Had the Man in Black allowed Vizzini the chance to switch the cups while his back was turned so that only Vizzini would know which was which (so the Man in Black would not be compelled to drink from a poisoned cup), the battle of wits makes some sense. Without that, Vizzini proves that he is a great fool. And you could have worked it out without being told, same as Vizzini.
What he should have thought was that no man takes around a poison to create a wager like that unless there's a catch in their advantage. "Never take what the enemy gives you" he should have never taken the wager.
I am not a great fool, so I can clearly not choose the wine in front of you. But you must have known I was not a great fool, you would have counted on it, so I can clearly not choose the wine in front of me.
All songs composed by Mark Knopfler unless otherwise noted. "Once upon a Time...Storybook Love" 4:00 "I Will Never Love Again" 3:04 "Florin Dance" 1:32 "Morning Ride" 1:36 "The Friends' Song" 3:02 "The Cliffs of Insanity" 3:18 "The Swordfight" 2:43 "Guide My Sword" 5:11 "The Fire Swamp and the Rodents of Unusual Size" 4:47 "Revenge" 3:51 "A Happy Ending" 1:52 "Storybook Love" (composed and performed by Willy DeVille) 4:24
never get involved in a land war in asia!
springbok86 1 year ago
And to be honest, he was right in all his theories. According to his theories he shouldn't choose the wine in front of him or the wine in front of the other guy. So he should have come to the conclusion that no wine was safe.
DramaMC 1 year ago 2
@DramaMC It might have worked if he Wesley had offered him the opportunity to switch the glasses round himself afterwards so only the Sicilian would know if they'd changed position (he'd turn his back). Otherwise it doesn't make much sense. If u knew where the poison was and ur opponent chose the non-poison, you would be effectively committing suicide. He should of known Wesley was a man of honour, so would not not drink the poisoned cup if he had to. I guess he got sidetracked by Australia :)
thespacialone 1 year ago
@thespacialone Actually the poison was in BOTH glasses, Wesley spent the last several years building an immunity.
Martintheauthor 1 year ago
@Martintheauthor I'm assuming the given pretence as presented by the Man in Black. He knew both cups were poisoned (as do we), but he would need to offer Vizzini the chance to switch cups to retain the illusion (assuming Vizzini was half as smart as he thought he was, because of the points of logic I outlined earlier). The rest of the conversation could then follow along largely similar lines, and Vizzini could reveal whether the cups had been switched after they had both drunk.
thespacialone 1 year ago
@thespacialone But we DON'T know that both cups are poisoned until after Vizzini is dead and Wesley states that fact to Buttercup.
Martintheauthor 1 year ago
@Martintheauthor Vizzini should have realised the poison was in both cups, for Westley's remaining in honour commands it. Had the Man in Black allowed Vizzini the chance to switch the cups while his back was turned so that only Vizzini would know which was which (so the Man in Black would not be compelled to drink from a poisoned cup), the battle of wits makes some sense. Without that, Vizzini proves that he is a great fool. And you could have worked it out without being told, same as Vizzini.
thespacialone 1 year ago
What he should have thought was that no man takes around a poison to create a wager like that unless there's a catch in their advantage. "Never take what the enemy gives you" he should have never taken the wager.
DramaMC 1 year ago
Inconcievable!
mark3smle 1 year ago
I heart Wallace Shawn
gaoutlaw 1 year ago
Ah....its rex from toy story!
dragchute86 1 year ago
I love this movie. It's funny, fun, and just cool.
NephilimFree 1 year ago
he has my name lol
bballshawn24wallace 1 year ago
He dosent sound anything like rex
go34cjx 1 year ago
@Davey647 only a great fool would have guessed it was in one or the other, for no one bets their life on a game they dont know the outcome to
donovan3955 1 year ago
Australia has been discovered in the 1200's?
.... wut?
LionTroy 1 year ago
@LionTroy australia is where the english put there criminals
billywiz21 1 year ago
@billywiz21 ....
You fail history forever.
Australia wasn't discovered till 1770s, This was at maximum the 1300s. We're talking a good half a millennium of difference.
LionTroy 1 year ago
@LionTroy gayest sentence ever goes to "you fail at history forever"
billywiz21 1 year ago
It's Grand Nuges Zek from Deep Space Nine!
Freddie1980 1 year ago
the battle of wits. I love the end (close to the end)
funtownmandy 1 year ago
Comment removed
peacepipe4 1 year ago
"You ever heard of Plato? Aristotle? Socrates?"
"Morons!"
Capercaillie100 1 year ago
Never go in against a Sicilian when death is on the line!!!
Theburn77 2 years ago
the ending is hilarious "Ahaaaahhaaa! Ahaaaahaaaha!" PLOP!
BlackHallow55 2 years ago
From one of the best family movies of all time!!
A timeless classic.
MasterOtogi 2 years ago
AHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAH AHAHAHAHAHAHAAH HAHAHA...Thud
imthatweirdgyatw0rk 2 years ago
LMAO Ima see the guy who plays Mr. "Smart Guy" here next month xD
Cherrums 2 years ago
THE CLIFFS OF INSANITY!
666brandon666 2 years ago 4
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHA AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA AHAHAHAHAHAHAHA thump
free2Bme31 2 years ago
That great line, "The most famous is 'Never get involved in a land war is Asia!'" is right out of the book. :D
rakshasa7 2 years ago
and I love it - it's also a tip in Civ IV
KGrumbles 2 years ago
you're trying to kidnap what I've rightfully stolen
MegaDoug 2 years ago
as you wish...
aperfectfailyour 2 years ago
one of the best movies ever!
TheHonestTheist 2 years ago
Thanks for this, 5 STARS.This is easily my favorite scene of the entire movie.
[[You're that smart?]]
>>Let me put it this way, have you heard of Plato, Aristotle, Socrates? [[Yes.]]
>>Morons.
I laugh at that every time!!! Pure comedy.
uoldphuk 2 years ago
I am not a great fool, so I can clearly not choose the wine in front of you. But you must have known I was not a great fool, you would have counted on it, so I can clearly not choose the wine in front of me.
TeamJazzWhitlockHale 2 years ago 4
@TeamJazzWhitlockHale and then the head exploding scene from scanners plays.
evilmidget 1 year ago
I Love This Movie!!!
madarchon 2 years ago
This movie is amazing... Now i'm gonna go watch it. Thank You
SHEEHAKR 2 years ago
All songs composed by Mark Knopfler unless otherwise noted. "Once upon a Time...Storybook Love" 4:00 "I Will Never Love Again" 3:04 "Florin Dance" 1:32 "Morning Ride" 1:36 "The Friends' Song" 3:02 "The Cliffs of Insanity" 3:18 "The Swordfight" 2:43 "Guide My Sword" 5:11 "The Fire Swamp and the Rodents of Unusual Size" 4:47 "Revenge" 3:51 "A Happy Ending" 1:52 "Storybook Love" (composed and performed by Willy DeVille) 4:24
haskel420 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
please, for any lover of this movie : what was the title of (Mark Knopfler)'s song at the movie's closing credits ???
wrtwertwr 3 years ago